Stuff that is hopelessly inadequate (i.e. it does not approach the standards used for medicine) has been ripped to shreds. That does not tell you what would happen if you presented something that met the standards used for medicine, though....
....Why assume otherwise when all we have ever demonstrated here is the application of the same standards to homeopathy as are applied to medicine?
Okay, let us see what would happen. Let's test my assumptions.
Thirty-seven percent were alive and disease free at a mean follow-up of 20
years. Untreated, only 3.7 percent are alive and disease free at 10 years
The above study on breast cancer in women was given as an example of "incontrovertible proof of effectiveness in the cure of a non-self-limiting condition." Let me hypothetically present the
exact same study, except substitute homeopathic remedies for lumpectomy, mastectomy, and irradiation. (I also substituted "breast imaging" for 2 references to surgical specimens.) The research design, methodology, and findings would all remain
exactly the same. By my understanding, if this hypothetical study were real, you would be congratulating me on meeting the challenge. So let's test this out.
ABSTRACT
Background
In 1976, we initiated a randomized trial to determine whether Belladonna 200C with or without Sulphur 200C was as effective as Belladonna 1M for the treatment of invasive breast cancer.
Methods
A total of 1851 women for whom follow-up data were available and nodal status was known underwent randomly assigned treatment consisting of Belladonna 1M, Belladonna 200C alone, or Belladonna 200C and Sulphur 200C. Kaplan-Meier and cumulative-incidence estimates of the outcome were obtained.
Results
The cumulative incidence of recurrent tumor in the ipsilateral breast was 14.3 percent in the women who used Belladonna 200C and Sulphur 200C, as compared with 39.2 percent in the women who used Belladonna 200C without use of Sulphur 200C (P<0.001). No significant differences were observed among the three groups of women with respect to disease-free survival, distant-disease-free survival, or overall survival. The hazard ratio for death among the women who used Belladonna 200C alone, as compared with those who used Belladonna 1M, was 1.05 (95 percent confidence interval,
0.90 to 1.23; P=0.51). The hazard ratio for death among the women who used Belladonna 200C followed by use of Sulphur 200C, as compared with those who used Belladonna 1M, was 0.97 (95 percent confidence interval, 0.83 to 1.14; P=0.74). Among the Belladonna 200C-treated women whose breast imaging showed tumor-free margins, the hazard ratio for death among the women who used
Sulphur 200C after Belladonna 200C, as compared with those who did not, was 0.91 (95 percent confidence interval, 0.77 to 1.06; P=0.23). Sulphur therapy was associated with a marginally significant decrease in deaths due to breast cancer. This decrease was partially offset by an increase in deaths from other causes.
Conclusions
Belladonna 200C followed by Sulphur 200C continues to be appropriate therapy for women with breast cancer, provided that the margins of breast images are free of tumor and an acceptable cosmetic result can be obtained.
Whoa! What do you know, the flaws in methodology and design are now glaring. If I were to present this study, this is the "ripping to shreds" I foresee happening.. (Now my imagination may be wrong, so you tell me.)
1. There was no untreated control group. There was no placebo control group. Without either, how do we know these women wouldn't have had the same results even without treatment? No control group = no information, only guesses = no scientific rigor. It doesn't matter if you have a good reason for not having a control group. Having a good reason does not mean you get to upgrade your assumptions to substitute for cold, hard proof. Having a good reason doesn't mean you get to extrapolate from data that is not related to the sample in this study.
2. The statistic offered for untreated women was apparently taken from a group of women who had already decompensated and were diagnosed too late for surgery to make a difference. Surely you can't tell me that a comparison of mortality rates between healthier women to severely ill women is valid. If you divided the existing study population by severity of illness and prognosis, you might find a significant difference between the two. This disingenuous comparison cannot possibly come near compensating for the absence of baseline information.
3. The authors of the untreated group statistic state: "Historical data of untreated breast cancer patients reveal a potential for long survival in some cases. The spectrum of clinical aggressiveness of breast cancer varies between virulence and chronic disease. " Without an untreated control group, how do we know the samples in this breast cancer treatment study aren't simply skewed towards women who have the potential for long survival and breast cancer as chronic disease? You can guess, but at the end of the day, there still isn't any proof. (I recall a similar complaint about autism, since some make improvements on their own.)
4. "No significant differences were observed among the three groups of women with respect to disease-free survival, distant-disease-free survival, or overall survival. " The hazard ratio for death is the same for all three groups. What is this supposed to prove? That no matter what remedy you take, you have the same chance of dying? That 3 different homeopathic interventions didn't do squat in improving life expectancy? And this is proof of effectiveness, how?
5. "The cumulative incidence of recurrent tumor in the ipsilateral breast was 14.3 percent in the women who used Belladonna 200C and Sulphur 200C, as compared with 39.2 percent in the women who used Belladonna 200C without use of Sulphur 200C (P<0.001)." Ah, the gold nugget of the study. So women who used Sulphur in addition to Belladonna had a lower relapse rate than women who only took Belladonna. First, all this tells us is that taking these two remedies is better than taking one. It doesn't tell us if taking these two remedies is better than any other treatment or doing nothing at all. Second, how do we know that the lower relapse rate wasn't a result of an enhanced placebo effect of taking two remedies instead of one? Yeah, we don't know. That is why placebo control groups are standard.
6. But hell, for the sake of argument, let us suspend scientific rigor for a moment, and take this lower relapse rate at face value. Did these women who didn't relapse live longer? No, because they all had the same survival rates, remember?
"Sulphur therapy was associated with a marginally significant decrease in deaths due to breast cancer. This decrease was partially offset by an increase in deaths from other causes." So yeah, if you suspend scientific reasoning, they can "cure" breast cancer in some women, but the treatment causes some other fatal condition so that you're just as likely to die within 20 years. Now, how about showing me proof of a cure that isn't also fatal?
How about showing some proof that doesn't require the suspension of scientific rigor?
(This is just the ripping of the abstract. I could go on with the text of the study. But you get the idea.)
----End of ripping to shreds----------
Now, if I am wrong, and you all would not rip this study to shreds as I have imagined, then I will assume these sorts of flaws are acceptable to you. I will begin my search for a study with similar flaws to present for the challenge.
If this does not meet the standards of "evidence," then this is what I meant by a double-standard. Please then find me another citation that has the standards you would accept. (And it isn't just this study, but I can imagine your "ripping" all the medical studies that have been cited as acceptable examples, once the treatments have been substituted. So I would recommend doing this little exercise of substituting the treatment to ferret out that bias. I have my own biases and routinely do these exercises when I read, so I am not saying this in judgment.)
I have thought about submitting both medical and homeopathic studies with the treatments blinded. See which ones you would accept as "incontrovertible" proof of efficacy, and then reveal what kind of treatments were really studied. On second thought though, I don't have time to do that much work. You guys could try it out for yourself, if you were curious about how much of a double standard you may have. You just need a buddy who's willing to blind it for you.
If you're really brave, try blinding the results of the study, and not just the treatments. I found out all sorts of things about just how objective I was when I did that. Whoa!
Anyway, back to the challenge at hand. If you acknowledge that yeah, this was a bad study and would like to find another one to set a higher standard, please let me know. If not, I think I can find a homeopathic study that is just as bad.
After immersing myself in the homeopathic literature and discovering for myself how mind-numbingly vacuous their "evidence" is,...
I had the same feeling. (The truth be told, that is why I sought out this board. I was looking for people who knew what science was for a change. ) But the funny thing is, I have the same feeling when I read JAMA, NEJM, Lancet, BMJ, etc.
I hope this little example helps you understand what I mean when I say I don't know what your standards are for proving efficacy. Because they all look the same to me (both medical and homeopathic): mind-numbingly vacuous (good description!).