Even More Fun with Homeopath Dana Ullman, MPH(!)

Take patients from a flu outbreak. With their consent of course, randomly assign them to either a doctor and a homeopath. Within each group, randomly assign them to a placebo or real treatment. A doctor would most likely prescribe the same medication to all his patients. A homeopath would most likely prescribe different remedies for all his clients--even though they all have the same symptoms and conditions--because they all have different individual pictures.


Sshh...don't tell Boiron

But really, I'm afraid all the above just shows how little you have thought this through.

It really doesn't matter that homeopathy claims to be able to work in a different manner compared with real medicine. Homeopaths claim cures, therefore homeopaths can define cures therefore the success-rate of 'curing' can be measured. This is not difficult stuff. Don't pretend that homeopaths don't have the time or the desire to do trials. What they don't seem to want to do is good trials.

In any case, trials of clinical disease are one thing, but provings are the cornerstone of homeopathy. If homeopathic remedies are no different from placebo in a proving then the whole scam is busted. This has been done. It has been done by homeopaths. Time for you to pack up your toys and find something useful to do.

Unless of course you are holding out on us with the answer to this question: Can you not find one single instance of a homeopath curing AIDS?

That doesn't require any complex methodologies. Just one happy former AIDS patient waving their previous medical records in one hand and their new blood test certificate showing that they are now HIV-ve in the other. Surely even a homeopath can manage an n=1 trial.

Your stubbornness and evasiveness on this issue is becoming more stark.
 
She doesn't talk about getting the diagnosis, either in the article or in the book. From her description, her son's symptoms meet criteria in the DSM-IV for a diagnosis of Autistic Disorder. But you're right. Thank you for alerting me to the possibility that she might not have ever gotten an official dx and therefore would not qualify for the challenge. However, other "cure stories" on her website might have, and some of them might have been officially diagnosed. Dx is a relatively minor point, if autism qualifies as a "non-self-limiting condition" for the purposes of the challenge.

The diagnosis is a major point. The DSM-IV is not intended to be used by laypeople for good reason. The criteria are not meant to for a description of the disease so that somebody who is unfamiliar with it can tell what it looks like. They are meant to standardize communication among people who are already familiar with what it looks like. It's the difference between asking someone who already knows what the "Mona Lisa" looks like to pick it out from among a dozen similar portraits of women, and asking someone who doesn't know what it looks like to pick it out based on a brief description.

The point is that without a diagnosis from someone who knows what they are doing, there's no good reason to think that her son had autism, or that his development wasn't exactly what would be expected in the absence of any specific effect from the magic pills.

Homeopathy works very differently from medicine. In medicine, treatments fit symptoms and diagnoses. In homeopathy, remedies fit the picture of the whole person, including personality, preferences, and other characteristics that seemingly have no relationship to the symptoms themselves. It is thought that symptoms that aren't specifically "treated" by the remedy would go away anyway when the whole person is healthy.

One reason homeopathy doesn't do well in RCT's is this very problem. The research designs are borrowed from a medical model and don't fit homeopathy well. It is no surprise that the remedies don't work well; they aren't supposed to work that way.

Matching a correct remedy to the whole person picture requires a tremendous amount of skill. When remedies don't work, most in the homeopathic community question not the remedies, but the skill of the prescribing homeopath. There are very few skilled homeopaths around; many get their training piecemeal and hang out a shingle.

There is nothing in what you've said that would prevent an RCT from providing a good test of homeopathy. RCT's don't care how you choose a particular therapy or even whether you choose difference therapies for different people. They also don't care what it is that you use to decide when someone is better, how long it takes, or how many changes you make along the way.

Here is a design that would better approximate how homeopathy is supposed to work. Not that it is perfect, but it is more consistent with homeopathic philosphy.

Take patients from a flu outbreak. With their consent of course, randomly assign them to either a doctor and a homeopath. Within each group, randomly assign them to a placebo or real treatment. A doctor would most likely prescribe the same medication to all his patients. A homeopath would most likely prescribe different remedies for all his clients--even though they all have the same symptoms and conditions--because they all have different individual pictures. Then compare documented symptom alleviation in all 4 groups. Then replicate this design with other conditions and with other homeopaths. Now this still doesn't constitute proof of anything, but it can offer a glimpse at how effective homeopathy might be, when it is used the way it is supposed to.

See? That wasn't hard at all. Those are the kinds of studies that have been done already.

Indeed, that is a problem for the purposes of this challenge. While doctors are trained to keep good records (for legal as well as medical reasons), people who treat themselves very rarely do. Homeopaths they consult can keep records of what symptoms are self-reported, and what remedies are recommended. But there is rarely any objective assessment such as lab analysis or imaging results. There is simply no incentive for them to seek such procedure unless they are trying to prove something--and most people who are "cured" aren't trying to make a point. They just wanted to be well.

Your excuse is irrelevant. Patients may not keep adequate records, but homeopaths claim to do so. And if their recording-keeping and follow-up is so inadequate that they cannot demonstrate to anyone else that they have actually accomplished anything, that means that they cannot demonstrate it to themselves either.

Also homeopathy works differently from medicine in that dosing is subjective. How "strong" and how often one takes the remedy depends on the presentation of symptoms. If there is no change in symptoms, homeopathy consumers take it again or make the remedy stronger. If they see an improvement in symptoms, they wait until the improvement stops and the symptoms come back before taking another dose. If they see an aggravation of symptoms, they either make the remedy weaker or change remedies altogether. Dosing completely depends on how one's symptoms "react" to the remedy, and this doesn't just vary from individual to individual, but also across time in the same individual.

So what? None of that prevents you taking the same steps with a (unbeknownst to you) placebo substitute.

Well, she did write a book. ;)

All I can say is I have observed a different culture in the homeopathic community than in the medical one. They value anecdotal and clinical details more so than objective appraisal.

Well, duh. :) If they didn't they'd have to close up shop and go home.

They don't feel like they have to prove that something works, so it is sufficient to gather enough clinical information to pass on to others. In contrast, "proof" of effectiveness dominates the medical mindset, so naturally, papers are the first thing a doctor would write. It is hard to bridge this cultural gap, to prove something in a world where no one cares about proof, to an audience that cares only about proof.

They are the ones that chose to bridge that gap by making the sorts of claims that would be dangerous if untrue, by taking my money (through public funding), and by causing harm to people it is our responsibility to protect. Once they made that choice, all this hand-waving designed to hide the fact that it matters whether things are true or false when it comes to lives and health, starts to become overtly dishonest.

Linda
 
The double-blind placebo-controlled trial isn't really the gold standard in medical research.....What it's good at is deciding whether a small, perhaps doubtful, effect is actually there or not. It's just not necessary for the majority of things....


Two things:

The DBRCT is the gold standard, isn't it, for any new medication coming onto the market (or any existing medication which has managed to escape such a process). It must be double-blind and with random allocation of patients between the new medication and the existing standard treatment (or placebo if there is no existing standard treatment).

And, if we're talking about new treatments, we really don't know whether the effect is going to be large or small. In fact, the beneficial effects of some new treatments are occasionally so large that it becomes unethical to continue treating the control group with the standard treatment.
 
HelenSan. Write this down and post it where it will remind you: "Some cases of autism resolve spontaneously."

Therefore, in the case of Lansky, lack of professional diagnosis, documentation, and the use of confounding treatments are not only damning they are irrelevant.

As for the difficulty of research, it does not absolve proponents from the need for it. In fact, they publish lots of "research" in their fanzines (e.g., Homeopathy) and it is invariably of the most naive sort. Occasionally, they attempt a high-quality study and get it published in a good journal.

However, such publications are not engraved in granite, they are the first step in analysis and acceptance or rejection. There was a recent paper that passed peer-review and found its way into Chest. More critical examination (than the peer-review) finds that the data do not support the conclusion that homeo preps were effective:
http://scienceblogs.com/insolence/2007/07/homeopathy_in_thecringeicu_1.php

To date, homeos have offered a lot of "research;" it mostly does not meet the requirements of a high-school science-fair project. The problem is not the difficulty, it is the incompetence of proponents.

Here is a basic problem- you think homeos have barriers to research (they do not, they only whine about that), so why do you accept their unsupported claims? Are you one of those people who will invest in a scheme that assures 50% return per month with no documentation of performance?

ETA, I started this and then had to dig out my car and lay in stores for the next snowstorm (tomorrow). I note that people made many of my points while I was gone.
 
Last edited:
"Might" and "might." It's a poor foundation upon which to build a medicine.
Umm...I'd say it's a critical point.

I don't think I made myself clear. I wasn't building a medicine. I was talking about building a case for the challenge. I could conceivably find someone who DID get an official diagnosis. I meant that finding someone who officially got diagnosed is a minor point, if the condition itself is acceptable to you guys for the purposes of the challenge.

1. "Like cures like" is a central tenet to homeopathy (each variation of it). That in the Lansky case the prescribed cure was for a set of symptoms not associated with the named illness should be very troubling.
But that is not how it is always practiced. In most of the "successful" cases, that is not how the right remedy is picked. Just telling you, the practice differs somewhat from the books, especially for chronic conditions. They move away from simply the symptom picture to a whole person picture.

2. You are saying that all the over-the-counter homeopathic medicines are worthless. Have your treatments been individually prescribed or have you bought them OTC?
Yes, most classical homeopaths will tell you the same. All mine are individually prescribed. Just the other week, 4 of 5 members in my family got the flu. We all got prescribed different remedies. Again, this is not offered as evidence of anything other than how homeopathy is practiced.


As an aside, I just typed a lengthy response to Linda's questions. I mean lengthy. I spent 3 hours on it. When I went to post, it said I couldn't have any url's. When I hit the back button, the post was deleted! :eek: I have to do that all over again. But not now. I have to mourn 3 hours of my time.
 
HelenSan. Write this down and post it where it will remind you: "Some cases of autism resolve spontaneously."

Does this mean autism is not acceptable as a "non-self-limiting condition"?

Please remember, I am not claiming proof of efficacy. I just want to submit something that would meet the terms of this challenge.
 
The diagnosis is a major point.
I meant finding someone with a diagnosis is a minor point, for the purposes of the challenge.

There is nothing in what you've said that would prevent an RCT from providing a good test of homeopathy.
Agreed. I meant the problem with RCTs that have already been done have not used homeopathy as it should be used.

See? That wasn't hard at all. Those are the kinds of studies that have been done already.

Really? I would love to see a reference if you happen to have it handy.

Your excuse is irrelevant. Patients may not keep adequate records, but homeopaths claim to do so. And if their recording-keeping and follow-up is so inadequate that they cannot demonstrate to anyone else that they have actually accomplished anything, that means that they cannot demonstrate it to themselves either.

Good grief. It isn't an excuse. It is an explanation on why it is hard to find documentation. And yeah, they can't demonstrate it to themselves, but they don't need to. They feel better, they're happy. They aren't on this board, and they don't care about "demonstrations."


So what? None of that prevents you taking the same steps with a (unbeknownst to you) placebo substitute.

I posted all that in response to Garrette, who was wondering why Lansky's remedy was not picked on autistic symptoms. It was not a comment on why there are no good RCTs on homeopathy.
 
Does this mean autism is not acceptable as a "non-self-limiting condition"?

Please remember, I am not claiming proof of efficacy. I just want to submit something that would meet the terms of this challenge.
YES.
 
The diagnosis is a major point.
I meant finding someone with a diagnosis is a minor point, for the purposes of the challenge.


The diagnosis is a major point for the purposes of the challange.

(If you don't know what you are treating, how can you be sure that your treatment worked?)


Hint: If you write a long post, always save it in Notepad, before pressing any buttons.
I had a similar experience a long time ago.
 
HelenSan,

You make the point that homoeopathy uses subjective measures while conventional medicine uses objective measures of success.

Setting aside the fact that many homoeopaths do, in fact, attempt to use objective measures to prove homoeopathy works, do you really think both are equally good at measuring success?

The following are reasons why subjective measures can make it seem as if a treatment is working:
- placebo effect.
- regression to the mean.
- wishful thinking.

Objective measures seek to eliminate these sources of errors in order to see if the treatment really does work.

Do you not agree with this?


BillyJoe
 
Last edited:
As an aside, I just typed a lengthy response to Linda's questions. I mean lengthy. I spent 3 hours on it. When I went to post, it said I couldn't have any url's. When I hit the back button, the post was deleted! :eek: I have to do that all over again. But not now. I have to mourn 3 hours of my time.


That is a royal pain. (My forte is typing Ctrl-R instead of Shift-R when I start my name at the end, and losing the lot!) As well as the advice to save a copy of any lengthy post, even if only on the clipboard, I've more advice for that particular one.

Don't hit the back button!

If the forum rejects a post for some reason, you will probably find it is still there and can be modified to be acceptable, but if you hit the back button you'll lose it. Look at the page you've got and seek any other option - there may be a continue option, or something. Just avoid the knee-jerk temptation to hit that <- above all else.

Rolfe.
 
HelenSan. Write this down and post it where it will remind you: "Some cases of autism resolve spontaneously."


This might be a bit of an overstatement. :cool:
See here:

http://www.medicinenet.com/autism/page4.htm

It is important to remember, despite some recent denials, that autism is virtually a lifelong condition.


Apparently, there are various conditions which resolve spontaneously that produce symptoms of autism, but the diagnosis of Autism specifically excludes underlying conditions such as these.

The article gives an example of such a self-limiting condition called Landau-Kleffner Syndrome. In this condition the autistic symptoms are caused by epilepsy (sometimes not clinically manifested and only picked up on EEG) in which the epilepsy and the autistic features spontaneously resolve at around age 4.

Maybe you have this condition in mind. :D
 
Last edited:
...even if only on the clipboard.


This is not foolproof.
In my haste, I have sometimes failed to press either the "ctrl" or the "insert" button with the result that the information has not been saved.
In Notepad, you have visual proof.
 
HelenSan. Write this down and post it where it will remind you: "Some cases of autism resolve spontaneously."

....

You forgot to put "Especially when not verified by a professional diagnosis".

Lansky never did seek an official diagnosis. There are many reasons for a child to have speech and language delays. I have had two sons with speech and language issues, neither of them were autism.

One child still has several learning disorders, the other is an honor student (who actually freaked out the neurologist by solving a wood puzzle so quickly as a three year old).

So without a professional assessment, everything Lansky wrote is worthless.
 
I don't think I made myself clear. I wasn't building a medicine. I was talking about building a case for the challenge.

What???

You have millions of homeopaths. Many millions of patients. You have all of homeopathy's historical track-record.

All you have to do is come up with one case. Just one. Only one.

In real medicine this can be done every day of any week. Look: here is the mammary adenocarcinoma that has been removed. See here is the patient tumour-free for any period you care to define post-operatively.

Obviously a single case is not absolute proof of anything, but find one then another and we'll be seriously impressed.

All I am seeing is the usual prevarication and delay...oh, and pointless reanalysis of a fourth-hand description of something that may or may no have been autism that may or may not have resolved. Puh-leeze!

It is a very familiar pattern. I strongly suspect that it reflects a deep desire to avoid commitment to any definitive position for which you might be called to acccount. Keep things vague, don't think too hard about the details and you don't have to face any awkward truths. Your objections are not real objections. They are just temporising tactics.

No, just go and find that cured AIDS patient, or Parkinson's patient or Type 1 diabetic.

Will you have the honesty to draw the necessary conclusions when you cannot find a single instance?
 
I meant finding someone with a diagnosis is a minor point, for the purposes of the challenge.

You may be surprised to discover, as you proceed on your quest, that finding someone with a confirmed diagnosis turns out to be a major sticking point.

Agreed. I meant the problem with RCTs that have already been done have not used homeopathy as it should be used.

Do you really know whether that's the case, or are you re-iterating the excuses that homeopaths give for their failure? Most of the time, is the homeopaths who set up these trials, after all.

Really? I would love to see a reference if you happen to have it handy.

This is an example of an RCT using individualized treatment.

http://thorax.bmj.com/cgi/content/abstract/58/4/317

Good grief. It isn't an excuse. It is an explanation on why it is hard to find documentation. And yeah, they can't demonstrate it to themselves, but they don't need to. They feel better, they're happy. They aren't on this board, and they don't care about "demonstrations."

I think you misunderstood. Documentation is available from homeopaths just like it is available from MD's. If their (the homeopaths) documentation fails to show that homeopathy accomplishes anything useful, and clinical trials show that it doesn't accomplish anything useful, then where is the idea that they are doing anything useful coming from? Considering that the ideas on which homeopathy is based have already been tested and have been shown to be false (the idea of similars is not necessary, sufficient or reliable as a way to categorize which chemicals have which physiologic/pharmacological effect; all of biochemistry and physiology shows us that physical presence is necessary for a physical effect), anyone who is considering providing homeopathy should be asking themselves, "how do I know that I am doing anything useful by providing this therapy?" If they have information that answers that question for themselves, then it should be easy for them to pass on the information to anyone else who asks. That they are unable to find anything like this to pass on to us, tells us that they don't have it. And if they don't have it, then they have not answered their own question.

All that has ever been passed on to us is information that we already know to be unreliable - e.g. observations in the absence of blinding and controls, subjective perceptions unmatched to any objective or physical effects. We already know that depending upon that kind of information has led us to form false conclusions many, many, many more times than it has led us to form conclusions that are true. Unless homeopaths have a way to discover, for themselves, which of the things they have tried are false, how can they possibly know it's not all false?

And that's what I mean by dishonesty. If they are going to go to all the trouble of making claims that would be harmful if false, of taking my money, and of taking advantage of vulnerable people, and if they are willing to do all this without knowing whether or not what they are saying is false, then their willful ignorance is bordering upon criminal.

I posted all that in response to Garrette, who was wondering why Lansky's remedy was not picked on autistic symptoms. It was not a comment on why there are no good RCTs on homeopathy.

Okay.

Linda
 
No, just go and find that cured AIDS patient, or Parkinson's patient or Type 1 diabetic.

Will you have the honesty to draw the necessary conclusions when you cannot find a single instance?
We have plenty of "instances." The problem is that every time an "instance" is presented, you guys say it is completely worthless.

Okay... so now I am trying to find out exactly what would an "instance" not worthless. So when I search for an "instance," I can sort through those that you would no doubt reject and not waste my time presenting them.

Take Lansky's case. Her kid wasn't diagnosed--no good as proof. That is fine. But her child DID have chronic symptoms. We don't know what the diagnosis would have been, but there would have been a diagnosis of something. Those symptoms DID disappear. He was cured of whatever he did have. Now we don't know what cured him: speech therapy, placebo, homeopathy, reiki, or any combination. So again, it's no good as proof. (Correctly so.)

But the fact remains, something cured this boy of a condition that is very similar to autism. That itself should be intriguing. Let's find out what that might be. Even if it is a combo of speech therapy and placebo, it would be the first time! Yet the whole "instance" is dismissed as completely worthless.

And then someone tells me autism shouldn't even be admissible for the challenge because it is not "non-self-limiting." So now I can't even present a different autism case where there was a diagnosis.

I just want to know what your standards are.

BTW, there has been a study in India on homeopathy and HIV with positive findings. But I haven't read it yet, so I can't comment.
 
But the fact remains, something cured this boy of a condition that is very similar to autism. That itself should be intriguing. Let's find out what that might be. Even if it is a combo of speech therapy and placebo, it would be the first time! Yet the whole "instance" is dismissed as completely worthless.

It is not worthless in the sense that if information could be gleaned from this case, it could tell us something potentially useful. It is worthless in the sense that it is presented in such a way that no information can be gleaned from the case.

I just want to know what your standards are.

What part of this do you need clarification on?

"Typically what we would look for is documentation of the diagnosis, treatment, note of other possible contributing factors and documentation of how cure is determined. For your example, it would be notes written by a doctor or other expert (with some indication of what makes this person capable of making the diagnosis of autism) listing the results of observation and testing, a list of all treatments/therapies used, additional examination and testing by an expert to document "cure", and an indication of the range of outcomes that could reasonably be expected in the absence of any specific effect from homeopathic pills."

BTW, there has been a study in India on homeopathy and HIV with positive findings. But I haven't read it yet, so I can't comment.

There's lots of homeopathy studies with 'positive' findings. What they fail to reveal is why on earth anyone should assume that the results had anything to do with magic pills.

Linda
 
But the fact remains, something cured this boy of a condition that is very similar to autism.

See? You're doing it again. Why did anything need to "cure" that boy?

I really don't want to get drawn into a discussion of this because it is wholly irrelevant to the problem you have been set and are utterly failing to respond to however, just read this and please draw that as a line under this diversion.

You should be embarrassed that you even tried using such a nebulous diagnosis as your first pitch.

BTW, there has been a study in India on homeopathy and HIV with positive findings. But I haven't read it yet, so I can't comment.

As fls has said there are many studies. Overall those studies show that homeopathy is literally useless.

You have been asked (repeatedly) for a single impressive case of a non-self-limiting disease. At least I know know that you have read the list of specific suggestions that included AIDS as an example. Now, please try and find a single "cured" case.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom