Badly Shaved Monkey
Anti-homeopathy illuminati member
- Joined
- Feb 5, 2004
- Messages
- 5,363
Take patients from a flu outbreak. With their consent of course, randomly assign them to either a doctor and a homeopath. Within each group, randomly assign them to a placebo or real treatment. A doctor would most likely prescribe the same medication to all his patients. A homeopath would most likely prescribe different remedies for all his clients--even though they all have the same symptoms and conditions--because they all have different individual pictures.
Sshh...don't tell Boiron
But really, I'm afraid all the above just shows how little you have thought this through.
It really doesn't matter that homeopathy claims to be able to work in a different manner compared with real medicine. Homeopaths claim cures, therefore homeopaths can define cures therefore the success-rate of 'curing' can be measured. This is not difficult stuff. Don't pretend that homeopaths don't have the time or the desire to do trials. What they don't seem to want to do is good trials.
In any case, trials of clinical disease are one thing, but provings are the cornerstone of homeopathy. If homeopathic remedies are no different from placebo in a proving then the whole scam is busted. This has been done. It has been done by homeopaths. Time for you to pack up your toys and find something useful to do.
Unless of course you are holding out on us with the answer to this question: Can you not find one single instance of a homeopath curing AIDS?
That doesn't require any complex methodologies. Just one happy former AIDS patient waving their previous medical records in one hand and their new blood test certificate showing that they are now HIV-ve in the other. Surely even a homeopath can manage an n=1 trial.
Your stubbornness and evasiveness on this issue is becoming more stark.