Even More Fun with Homeopath Dana Ullman, MPH(!)

Keeping adequate records of my patients is essential for me. Unfortunately I didn't keep any records on my past expenses. If I did I wouldn't have lost 48,000 EUR last night in a casino (and this was also a record loss for me).

What kind of adequate records could homeopaths provide? I immagine extremely diluted records. Have any of you ever seen an anonymised case study of an homeopath?
 
Unfortunately I didn't keep any records on my past expenses. If I did I wouldn't have lost 48,000 EUR last night in a casino (and this was also a record loss for me).


How would keeping records of expenses have prevented you losing money in a casino?

And if you don't keep records, how do you know it was a record loss?
 
Keeping records of casino (and other unnecessary expenses), over the past 30 years, would have probably made me more rational, i.e. I would probably stopped going there.

I don't remember how many times I went to casinos and I have no idea of how much I lost over all these years but I remember very well the past record losses and even the few jackpots I made. I'm also sure that only the year 2000 was positive when I didn't lose money whereas 2006 was a disaster. Homeopaths suggest taking Ignatia to give up gambling. I tried it but it didn't work: maybe I didn't take the right potency because nobody explained me the different effects of Ignatia on the 5CH, 7CH, 9CH, 12CH, 15CH and so on.
 
When you gave your reasons for giving homeopathy a try, the sole evidence you alluded to was anecdotal. [/I]
I have never made any claims about homeopathy on this list, nor did I ever made the suggestion to give "homeopathy a try." You must have misinterpreted reasons that I presented for why *I* use homeopathy.

I just want to clarify my position and my purpose for being on this board. I have no desire to convince anyone that homeopathy is efficacious. I have no desire to convince anyone to give hom homeopathy a try.

I do not believe there is scientfic evidence to date that homeopathy (in general) is effective. I do not believe there is any scientific evidence to date that homeopathy (in general) is ineffective either. Using the same standards, I do not believe that there is scientific evidence to date that medicine (in general) is effective or ineffective. This is because human experimentation in studying disease processes and treatment is largely unethical. Doing "science" with huge ethical constraints results in a sort of "cargo cult science," where you have the trappings of an experiment, but none of the scientific rigor. What these studies provide is data and information that could be useful for clinicians in making treatment choices. But none of it should be construed to be scientific. (And yes, data can be useful even if it is not scientific). I believe there are studies on homeopathy that are comparable to studies in medicine, with similar flaws and limitations.

My purpose on this board is to assess if the terms of the "Give one incontrovertible example" challenge can be defined and if meeting the terms of this challenge would result in any change in opinion.

No more, no less.

(Well, ok, I do have some curiosity on why people here don't find the placebo effect of value, but that is for another thread, if I have time after this one.)
 
My purpose on this board is to assess if the terms of the "Give one incontrovertible example" challenge can be defined and if meeting the terms of this challenge would result in any change in opinion.

You have been given several examples of conditions that would satisfy: AIDS, Type 1 Diabetes, Cancer, Rabies, Addison's disease. Things that are, you know, not self-limiting, hence the question.

Just to be clear, it is of no relevance whatsoever that conventional medicine cannot cure all of these diseases. We are talking about homeopathy, which is allegedly a "complete system of medicine" unlike the pale feeble imitation of such a system which poor conventional physicians must use. We stand in awe of the claims made for homeopathy. Please go some way to substantiating them by producing just one impressive case, with the sole proviso that it must be properly documented that the diagnosis was correct.

Maybe you are yet another homeopath who only tiptoes on the margins of medicine fiddling about with the usual trivia. Perhaps you believe that homeopathy is limited in what it can treat, in which case please define those limits- I'll bet they carefully exclude anything that is serious.
 
I have never made any claims about homeopathy on this list, nor did I ever made the suggestion to give "homeopathy a try." You must have misinterpreted reasons that I presented for why *I* use homeopathy.

I just want to clarify my position and my purpose for being on this board. I have no desire to convince anyone that homeopathy is efficacious. I have no desire to convince anyone to give hom homeopathy a try.

I do not believe there is scientfic evidence to date that homeopathy (in general) is effective. I do not believe there is any scientific evidence to date that homeopathy (in general) is ineffective either. Using the same standards, I do not believe that there is scientific evidence to date that medicine (in general) is effective or ineffective. This is because human experimentation in studying disease processes and treatment is largely unethical. Doing "science" with huge ethical constraints results in a sort of "cargo cult science," where you have the trappings of an experiment, but none of the scientific rigor. What these studies provide is data and information that could be useful for clinicians in making treatment choices. But none of it should be construed to be scientific. (And yes, data can be useful even if it is not scientific). I believe there are studies on homeopathy that are comparable to studies in medicine, with similar flaws and limitations.

With all due respect, that you can say that with a straight face indicates that you don't really have the foggiest idea about what constitutes science and scientific rigour. Your own education and understanding is your choice, but please do not assume that you can judge conclusions arrived at through knowledge and experience by comparing them to those arrived at through ignorance.

My purpose on this board is to assess if the terms of the "Give one incontrovertible example" challenge can be defined and if meeting the terms of this challenge would result in any change in opinion.

After immersing myself in the homeopathic literature and discovering for myself how mind-numbingly vacuous their "evidence" is, if a single example could be given demonstrating that even a single homeopath understands what it means to provide reasonable documentation, it would go a long way toward reversing my impression that their dependence upon ignorance is bordering upon criminal. These are strong words, which should be some indication of just how bad it is, considering that I am willing to treat any idea seriously and have taken the time to analyze each piece of information Mr. Ullman has presented.

No more, no less.

(Well, ok, I do have some curiosity on why people here don't find the placebo effect of value, but that is for another thread, if I have time after this one.)

Of course the placebo effect is of "value". However, objective changes happen regardless of whether or not magic pills are involved, and having a cup of tea with your mom is probably an equivalent substitute for any minor subjective changes. No need for the whole waste of resources building an elaborate system of magic.

This has been discussed here (follow the links within the thread to other discussions, as well).

Linda
 
I have never made any claims about homeopathy on this list,
So you weren't implying that Lansky's account of her son's autism cure was a demonstration of homeopathic efficacy? My mistake and my apologies.

We are in agreement that Lansky's account has no merit whatsoever in regard to establishing homeopathic efficacy.


HelenSan said:
nor did I ever made the suggestion to give "homeopathy a try."
I didn't say you did. I said you gave reasons why you gave homeopathy a try. You implied your experience with homeopathy provides evidence of its efficacy. It does not.


HelenSan said:
You must have misinterpreted reasons that I presented for why *I* use homeopathy.
No. I didn't discuss reasons you use it at all.


HelenSan said:
I just want to clarify my position and my purpose for being on this board. I have no desire to convince anyone that homeopathy is efficacious. I have no desire to convince anyone to give hom homeopathy a try.
That is a shame. For my part, I would love to find an easy, inexpensive method of handling my family's medical issues; I truly would. If you or any other homeopath could demonstrate that it works, then I'd be all over it and might even cancel my expensive medical insurance.


HelenSan said:
I do not believe there is scientfic evidence to date that homeopathy (in general) is effective. I do not believe there is any scientific evidence to date that homeopathy (in general) is ineffective either. Using the same standards, I do not believe that there is scientific evidence to date that medicine (in general) is effective or ineffective. This is because human experimentation in studying disease processes and treatment is largely unethical. Doing "science" with huge ethical constraints results in a sort of "cargo cult science," where you have the trappings of an experiment, but none of the scientific rigor. What these studies provide is data and information that could be useful for clinicians in making treatment choices. But none of it should be construed to be scientific. (And yes, data can be useful even if it is not scientific). I believe there are studies on homeopathy that are comparable to studies in medicine, with similar flaws and limitations.
fls' response to this was right on the money.


HelenSan said:
My purpose on this board is to assess if the terms of the "Give one incontrovertible example" challenge can be defined and if meeting the terms of this challenge would result in any change in opinion.

No more, no less.
It can and has.



HelenSan said:
(Well, ok, I do have some curiosity on why people here don't find the placebo effect of value, but that is for another thread, if I have time after this one.)
Again, fls' response is right on the money. I strongly suggest following her link to find a great deal of valuable information on the placebo effect.
 
Hmmm. I would like to have it demonstrated that it is possible to tell any homoeopathic remedy from the stock solvent/carrier material.

I would like to have even one example where a homoeopathic remedy self-evidently had any effect at all on a living organism that could not be explained by either coincidence of wishful thinking.

For that second one, you don't even need formal trials or statistics. Remember my anaesthetic example? Even one alert person obediently falling asleep when I inject the pentobarbitone is a pretty good demonstration the injection is having an effect.

In real medicine, there is no problem in distinguishing between an active substance and the carrier material, given suitable analytical equipment. And there is no difficulty showing that some of the drugs used have an unargable effect on the body.

If homoeopathy managed either one of these two very very basic demonstrations, maybe it would be time to start asking whether it can actually cure people.

Rolfe.
 
I would like to have even one example where a homoeopathic remedy self-evidently had any effect at all on a living organism that could not be explained by either coincidence of wishful thinking.


The thing is that even if we took Dullman's misconstruction of the Shang meta-analysis at face value, we would still be left in a situation where we are debating piddling little effects at the margins of statistical significance. Among his many failings is a lack of appreciation of the difference between clinical significance and statistical significance: we looked at 1,000,000 patients and found that Drug X reduced the duration of the common cold (p<0.000001) by an average of 0.03 seconds.

Accepting the risk of being repetitious, but there is a rather stark contrast between their dramatic claims and the trivial effects that even the most incompetently biased studies can actually show. That alone should be enough to make these tedious fools shut-up and go away. But it doesn't.
 
Exactly. That's why I said "self-evident".

The double-blind placebo-controlled trial isn't really the gold standard in medical research, for just the reason you outline. What it's good at is deciding whether a small, perhaps doubtful, effect is actually there or not. It's just not necessary for the majority of things, or even ethical - where "does this new idea actually give the patients a better outcome than the standard approach" is far more appropriate.

But homoeopathy can't even get anything through a blinded, placebo-controlled trial with any certainty, never mind show anything self-evident.

Rolfe.
 
<snip>

I would like to have even one example where a homoeopathic remedy self-evidently had any effect at all on a living organism that could not be explained by either coincidence of wishful thinking.

For that second one, you don't even need formal trials or statistics. Remember my anaesthetic example? Even one alert person obediently falling asleep when I inject the pentobarbitone is a pretty good demonstration the injection is having an effect.

<snip>

Rolfe.

Don't [stage] hypnotists do this trick?
 
So you weren't implying that Lansky's account of her son's autism cure was a demonstration of homeopathic efficacy?
I was suggesting Lansky's account, with documentation, as a possible example to meet the terms of the challenge in this thread.

Remember that I don't believe scientific evidence of efficacy of any type of treatment is ethically possible. However, you guys do think it is possible. Any case that I present would not meet *my* personal critieria for proof, but it might meet yours. That is why I requested examples on what *you* would accept as proof and am trying to precisely define your criteria for acceptance.
We are in agreement that Lansky's account has no merit whatsoever in regard to establishing homeopathic efficacy.
I believe Lansky's son had symptoms consistent with a diagnosis of autism, and that those symptoms disappeared after 2 years of using homeopathy and other CAM's. While I wouldn't go so far as saying "no merit whatsoever," I believe this case demonstrates, at best, only a temporal correlation and does not constitute proof of the efficacy of homeopathy.

You implied your experience with homeopathy provides evidence of its efficacy. It does not.
I did not make any implication, and I apologize if somehow my wording wasn't sufficiently clear. Temporal correlations alone, while worthy of further investigation, cannot provide evidence of efficacy or causation.

If you or any other homeopath could demonstrate that it works, then I'd be all over it and might even cancel my expensive medical insurance.
Not that it has any bearing on the current argument, but as an aside, I *have* cancelled my expensive medical insurance.

Again, fls' response is right on the money. I strongly suggest following her link to find a great deal of valuable information on the placebo effect.
Thank you (and thank you Linda). The discussion is fascinating, and I will follow it more closely when I have time.
 
I was suggesting Lansky's account, with documentation, as a possible example to meet the terms of the challenge in this thread.
Ah. Then the answer is simply that No, the Lansky account does not meet the terms of the challenge in this thread. Given that the terms have been laid out and that among them are (my wording) the patient having a clinically diagnosed condition which medical records show is no longer there, and given that Lansky did not even take her son to a physician, her son was not diagnosed with autism, and not even her homeopath documented the treatment or the cure, I wonder why you thought it might.


HelenSan said:
Remember that I don't believe scientific evidence of efficacy of any type of treatment is ethically possible. However, you guys do think it is possible.
I think that is too broad a statement but will leave it to the professionals participating in this thread.


HelenSan said:
Any case that I present would not meet *my* personal critieria for proof, but it might meet yours.
So the Lansky case did not meet your criteria for proof? But you thought it might meet ours, despite failing in the most critical of the conditions?


HelenSan said:
That is why I requested examples on what *you* would accept as proof and am trying to precisely define your criteria for acceptance.
Again, I will leave that to the professionals here.


HelenSan said:
I believe Lansky's son had symptoms consistent with a diagnosis of autism,
Is Lansky's account in the book more detailed than her account in the article I linked? If not, I fail to see how you reach this conclusion.


HelenSan said:
and that those symptoms disappeared after 2 years of using homeopathy and other CAM's.
And nonCAM. His primary treatment was speech therapy, during which he showed improvement (the ability to follow two instructions as opposed to just one) prior to beginning homeopathic treatment.

Also remember, as I pointed out earlier, the prescribed homeopathic treatment was for symptoms which were not the ones "cured."


HelenSan said:
While I wouldn't go so far as saying "no merit whatsoever," I believe this case demonstrates, at best, only a temporal correlation and does not constitute proof of the efficacy of homeopathy.
Apparently the homeopathic community agrees as none of them have written a paper on it complete with all the details necessary for determination.


HelenSan said:
I did not make any implication, and I apologize if somehow my wording wasn't sufficiently clear.
No problem.


HelenSan said:
Temporal correlations alone, while worthy of further investigation, cannot provide evidence of efficacy or causation.
True on the last part. Sometimes true of the "worthy of further investigation" part. I submit that the Lansky case is not so worthy. No diagnosis. No review afterward. No consistent treatment. Other treatments simultaneously. It's a mess.


HelenSan said:
Not that it has any bearing on the current argument, but as an aside, I *have* cancelled my expensive medical insurance.
I sincerely hope it works out.


HelenSan said:
Thank you (and thank you Linda). The discussion is fascinating, and I will follow it more closely when I have time.
On Linda's behalf, you're welcome, but only on her behalf. I had nothing to do with any of that. It is far beyond my expertise.
 
Why is this so hard?
I know this is a rhetorical question. But it brings up a good point that I'd like to address.

1. There are relatively few people who use homeopathy. It is hard to do large scale studies, and it is hard to find subjects for studies.

2. Of the relatively few people who use homeopathy, many of them try it after becoming disillusioned with medicine. That means they don't go to doctors, which means diagnosis, treatment monitoring, or any of the documentation you are looking for is absent. Take Lansky's "autistic" son, who had all the symptoms consistent with a dx of autism. She apparently never bothered getting an official dx.

3. Of the relatively few people who use homeopathy, many of them try it out of desperation. This means they not only try homeopathy, but everything else they can think of. They throw the kitchen sink at the problem and hope something works. The reason many people conclude homeopathy is what worked has to do with subjective observations that symptoms get better or disappear shortly after the use of a remedy, sometimes within minutes or seconds. As time goes on, they will try fewer and fewer other things, and begin to use homeopathy exclusively. But their cases have already been confounded. People simply don't treat themselves as subjects of a scientific experiment, where everything is meticulously documented, and confounders are controlled. You examine the case after the fact, and they are all a mess.

4. People who are now using homeopathy exclusively definitely do not go to doctors. So if they get sick again, they treat it themselves, and again, there is no documentation.


I'm not saying it is impossible or making excuses. Just explaining that's how it is. It'll take some effort to find a good case that has documentation and as a few confounders as possible.

Homeopathy is a different world. It is hard (not impossible, but hard) to bring the measuring sticks of conventional medicine into a world where most patients don't care about making a case or proving anything.
 
I know this is a rhetorical question. But it brings up a good point that I'd like to address.

1. There are relatively few people who use homeopathy. It is hard to do large scale studies, and it is hard to find subjects for studies.

2. Of the relatively few people who use homeopathy, many of them try it after becoming disillusioned with medicine. That means they don't go to doctors, which means diagnosis, treatment monitoring, or any of the documentation you are looking for is absent. Take Lansky's "autistic" son, who had all the symptoms consistent with a dx of autism. She apparently never bothered getting an official dx.

3. Of the relatively few people who use homeopathy, many of them try it out of desperation. This means they not only try homeopathy, but everything else they can think of. They throw the kitchen sink at the problem and hope something works. The reason many people conclude homeopathy is what worked has to do with subjective observations that symptoms get better or disappear shortly after the use of a remedy, sometimes within minutes or seconds. As time goes on, they will try fewer and fewer other things, and begin to use homeopathy exclusively. But their cases have already been confounded. People simply don't treat themselves as subjects of a scientific experiment, where everything is meticulously documented, and confounders are controlled. You examine the case after the fact, and they are all a mess.

4. People who are now using homeopathy exclusively definitely do not go to doctors. So if they get sick again, they treat it themselves, and again, there is no documentation.


I'm not saying it is impossible or making excuses. Just explaining that's how it is. It'll take some effort to find a good case that has documentation and as a few confounders as possible.

Homeopathy is a different world. It is hard (not impossible, but hard) to bring the measuring sticks of conventional medicine into a world where most patients don't care about making a case or proving anything.

Which may all be true, but there are millions of people around the world on whom homeopaths are inflicting their erroneous practices. Can you not find one single instance of a homeopath curing AIDS?

Even as I write this, there will be poor Africans being tucked up in their beds by homeopaths preening themselves over what a wonderful job they are doing.

Need I remind you that homeopathy is a "complete system of medicine". That's not my claim but from your world. So, show me.
 
He was never diagnosed as having autism.
She doesn't talk about getting the diagnosis, either in the article or in the book. From her description, her son's symptoms meet criteria in the DSM-IV for a diagnosis of Autistic Disorder. But you're right. Thank you for alerting me to the possibility that she might not have ever gotten an official dx and therefore would not qualify for the challenge. However, other "cure stories" on her website might have, and some of them might have been officially diagnosed. Dx is a relatively minor point, if autism qualifies as a "non-self-limiting condition" for the purposes of the challenge.

The primary problem Lansky was attempting to address was lack of talkativeness, yet her homeopath prescribed Carcinosin because of these symptoms:

-Desires milk which aggravates
-Dancing
-Very talented
-Head, hot on waking
-Hyperactivity


I suppose “like cures like” doesn’t apply to autism.
Homeopathy works very differently from medicine. In medicine, treatments fit symptoms and diagnoses. In homeopathy, remedies fit the picture of the whole person, including personality, preferences, and other characteristics that seemingly have no relationship to the symptoms themselves. It is thought that symptoms that aren't specifically "treated" by the remedy would go away anyway when the whole person is healthy.

One reason homeopathy doesn't do well in RCT's is this very problem. The research designs are borrowed from a medical model and don't fit homeopathy well. It is no surprise that the remedies don't work well; they aren't supposed to work that way.

Matching a correct remedy to the whole person picture requires a tremendous amount of skill. When remedies don't work, most in the homeopathic community question not the remedies, but the skill of the prescribing homeopath. There are very few skilled homeopaths around; many get their training piecemeal and hang out a shingle.

Here is a design that would better approximate how homeopathy is supposed to work. Not that it is perfect, but it is more consistent with homeopathic philosphy.

Take patients from a flu outbreak. With their consent of course, randomly assign them to either a doctor and a homeopath. Within each group, randomly assign them to a placebo or real treatment. A doctor would most likely prescribe the same medication to all his patients. A homeopath would most likely prescribe different remedies for all his clients--even though they all have the same symptoms and conditions--because they all have different individual pictures. Then compare documented symptom alleviation in all 4 groups. Then replicate this design with other conditions and with other homeopaths. Now this still doesn't constitute proof of anything, but it can offer a glimpse at how effective homeopathy might be, when it is used the way it is supposed to.

Of course, there is no indication that she kept a strict record of any of this.
Indeed, that is a problem for the purposes of this challenge. While doctors are trained to keep good records (for legal as well as medical reasons), people who treat themselves very rarely do. Homeopaths they consult can keep records of what symptoms are self-reported, and what remedies are recommended. But there is rarely any objective assessment such as lab analysis or imaging results. There is simply no incentive for them to seek such procedure unless they are trying to prove something--and most people who are "cured" aren't trying to make a point. They just wanted to be well.

Also homeopathy works differently from medicine in that dosing is subjective. How "strong" and how often one takes the remedy depends on the presentation of symptoms. If there is no change in symptoms, homeopathy consumers take it again or make the remedy stronger. If they see an improvement in symptoms, they wait until the improvement stops and the symptoms come back before taking another dose. If they see an aggravation of symptoms, they either make the remedy weaker or change remedies altogether. Dosing completely depends on how one's symptoms "react" to the remedy, and this doesn't just vary from individual to individual, but also across time in the same individual.

If this is so, and if the efficacy is so unquestionable, then why is there no paper on this cure of autism? Why were there no further studies? No papers? No anything at all?

Homeopathy found a cure for autism and simply let it slide from the view of the world.
Well, she did write a book. ;)

All I can say is I have observed a different culture in the homeopathic community than in the medical one. They value anecdotal and clinical details more so than objective appraisal. They don't feel like they have to prove that something works, so it is sufficient to gather enough clinical information to pass on to others. In contrast, "proof" of effectiveness dominates the medical mindset, so naturally, papers are the first thing a doctor would write. It is hard to bridge this cultural gap, to prove something in a world where no one cares about proof, to an audience that cares only about proof.
 
Last edited:
I know this is a rhetorical question. But it brings up a good point that I'd like to address.

1. There are relatively few people who use homeopathy. It is hard to do large scale studies, and it is hard to find subjects for studies.

2. Of the relatively few people who use homeopathy, many of them try it after becoming disillusioned with medicine. That means they don't go to doctors, which means diagnosis, treatment monitoring, or any of the documentation you are looking for is absent. Take Lansky's "autistic" son, who had all the symptoms consistent with a dx of autism. She apparently never bothered getting an official dx.

3. Of the relatively few people who use homeopathy, many of them try it out of desperation. This means they not only try homeopathy, but everything else they can think of. They throw the kitchen sink at the problem and hope something works. The reason many people conclude homeopathy is what worked has to do with subjective observations that symptoms get better or disappear shortly after the use of a remedy, sometimes within minutes or seconds. As time goes on, they will try fewer and fewer other things, and begin to use homeopathy exclusively. But their cases have already been confounded. People simply don't treat themselves as subjects of a scientific experiment, where everything is meticulously documented, and confounders are controlled. You examine the case after the fact, and they are all a mess.

4. People who are now using homeopathy exclusively definitely do not go to doctors. So if they get sick again, they treat it themselves, and again, there is no documentation.


I'm not saying it is impossible or making excuses. Just explaining that's how it is. It'll take some effort to find a good case that has documentation and as a few confounders as possible.

Homeopathy is a different world. It is hard (not impossible, but hard) to bring the measuring sticks of conventional medicine into a world where most patients don't care about making a case or proving anything.


But Helen, homoeopaths can (and do) spend much time and effort carrying out extremely poorly-controlled (or uncontrolled) trials, and touting them around as "evidence". Why can they not spend that time and effort demonstrating something to a reasonable standard?

Is it perhaps that they have nothing in their pharmacopoeia that has a self evident effect on anything?

Is it perhaps that there is no way at all to distinguish a potentised remedy from the stock solvent/carrier material?

Homoeopathy is big business. Boiron alone is making many millions of euros from it. There are homoeopathic hospitals with qualified doctors in them, who carry out research and publish it. These guys would give their right arms for a convincing demonstration that homoeopathic pills have biological (or indeed any) activity, and some of them spend quite a lot of time trying to find some such proof. Look at all the fuss about Benveniste, and even Roy.

But none of them has ever managed either of these two tasks. They have plenty of time, money and material to carry out bad studies, and then try to twist the results to make out that they show something. However, if they have ever exerted themselves to carry out a good study, and got a positive result, they haven't told us about it.

How would you expect the world to look if homoeopathic remedies were simple sugar pills, and did nothing different from any old sugar pill?

Why, exactly as it does look.

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:
Take Lansky's "autistic" son, who had all the symptoms consistent with a dx of autism. She apparently never bothered getting an official dx.
I'm not sure about the rest of your post, but I am curious why you say this.

From Lansky's article, she says that Max, 28 days, had surgery for pyloric stenosis

Then these things directly from Lansky’s article about her son:

In general, he has always tended to be thin, muscular, and coordinated. However, by age two, he was still not speaking. He knew the entire alphabet, could count to twenty, and could stack blocks like nobody's business, but he did not know more than about 10 words. Temperamentally, he was friendly and cheerful, but also showed a kind of detachment. He was less cuddly than his brother Izaak and was content to play on his own and watch TV, not seeking to be the center of attention. At the time, I thought he was merely late to talk, mature, and self-contained. One unusual characteristic was his attachment to his milk bottle; it was his "lovie". He wanted a "baba" so often that it was not unusual for him to drink 8 bottles (a half gallon!) of milk in a day.

…
Besides his early love for cow's milk, Max has also always had a strong desire for salt as well as a liking of fatty/spicy and sour foods. As a toddler he would willingly eat spicy dishes and suck on lemons. Though he rejects spicy foods now, he still covets salt and will even resort to shaking the salt shaker into his mouth! As a young child, he loved fatty meats (no longer), enjoyed sucking on ice cubes, and enjoyed chocolate (he now prefers vanilla ice cream over chocolate!) . All of these cravings are characteristic of Carcinosin.
…

Though non-verbal, Max was a happy toddler. It was not until he began in preschool that his problems began to crystallize. When he was two, we enrolled him in a 2-day/week 2-hour preschool program. At about this time, our nanny suddenly left without notice to tend to her mother dying of cancer. Our new nanny was kind but, in retrospect, detached emotionally and probably did not engage with Max very much.
…

Max was initially joyful in his preschool program. His teacher remarked upon his "joie de vivre". However, he did not settle in and relied on his "baba" for comfort. Among the behaviors that emerged at school were the following: he could not sit at circle-time unless held in someone's lap; he would tend to wander off to other places in the classroom or to other classrooms; lowered eye contact; self-stimulation activities such as spinning; and unresponsiveness to questions. At the same time, he clearly showed signs of great intelligence. If he was engaged in something that interested him, he could sit for very long stretches with intense concentration. He could build complex structures with amazing skills of symmetry and balance; he also showed sophisticated strategic and dexterity skills at computer games. At age 2.5, when our usual nanny was gone for a month and a far more engaging replacement nanny stepped in, Max finally began to talk more. It was single words, but it was a start.

At this point, Max was still a happy child at home. However, it became increasingly clear that this was not the case at school. I myself began to sense the teaching staff's judgement of him. Some of the teachers did not greet him in the morning with a welcoming tone. I also sensed that Max was keenly aware of their attitude and that it was harming him.

Eventually, the teachers began to drop hints that something was wrong with Max. At the time, I suspected they were thinking it was autism, but I convinced myself that Max's problem was ADD. At home, he had become increasingly antsy. Though he did not run about the house, he could not sit still. He would fidget, as if an engine were running inside him. He could not sit quietly and let me read a story to him. Instead, he would squirm all over the bed -- he would even stand on his head, with his feet against the wall. He would run his fingers up and down things, the table, the wall.

He also developed a habit of repeatedly poking or stabbing his finger
against people's chest -- not to hurt them, but a kind of nervous poking contact. Sometimes he would also butt his head against them. This kind of "poking" contact is characteristic of autistic children. It is also mentioned in Hoa's article on Carcinosin that appeared in the British Homoeopathic Journal in July 1963:
…

As Max approached his third birthday, I knew that something was truly wrong. The teachers at his school called us into conference and suggested we get professional help. I was on a mission. On the advice of a speech therapist friend, we opted against having Max tested at a highly-medicalized child development center attached to the university. Instead, we took him to see a respected speech and language therapist, a woman considered to be the best in the Palo Alto area, Donna Dagenais. Donna did not label Max as autistic or as anything at all -- she merely began working with him. In addition to his private therapy sessions, she also placed him into a group session with two other children -- one who had been diagnosed as PDD (mild autism) and the other with a severe fear-related disorder. Of the three, Max was the best behaved but the least verbal.


From this site, we have the following; bolded items are symptoms he is not said by Lansky to have:

Infants with the disorder often display abnormal reactions to sensory stimuli (i.e., senses may be over- or underactive). Touches may be experienced as painful, smells may be overwhelmingly unpleasant, and ordinary daily noises may be painful. Loud noises (e.g., motorcycle going by, vacuum cleaner) and bright lights may cause inconsolable crying.

Other signs of the disorder in infants include the following:
  • Appears indifferent to surroundings
  • Appears content to be alone, happier to play alone
  • Displays lack of interest in toys
  • Displays lack of response to others
  • Does not point out objects of interest to others (called protodeclarative pointing)
  • Marked reduction or increase in activity level
  • Resists cuddling
Young children with autism usually have impaired language development. They often have difficulty expressing needs (i.e., use gestures instead of words) and may laugh, cry, or show distress for unknown reasons. Some autistic patients develop rudimentary language skills that do not serve as an effective form of communication. They may develop abnormal patterns of speech that lack intonation and expression and may repeat words or phrases repetitively (called echolalia). Some children with autism learn to read.

Autistic children do not express interest in other people and often prefer to be alone. They may resist changes in their routine, repeat actions (e.g., turn in circles, flap their arms) over and over, and engage in self-injurious behavior (e.g., bite or scratch themselves, bang their head).
Other symptoms in young children include the following:
  • Avoids cuddling or touching
  • Frequent behavioral outbursts, tantrums
  • Inappropriate attachments to objects
  • Maintains little or no eye contact
  • Over- or undersensitivity to pain, no fear of danger
  • Sustained abnormal play
  • Uneven motor skills
  • Unresponsiveness to normal teaching methods and verbal clues (may appear to be deaf despite normal hearing)
It seems to me that Lansky is engaging in unsupported diagnosis.

And I will say again that the prescribed homeopathic treatment (carcinocis (sp?)) was not something that addressed any of the symptoms Max had.

You are reading into the Lansky account what she wants you to read into it, but it isn't really there.
 
Last edited:
She doesn't talk about getting the diagnosis, either in the article or in the book.
In the article she mentions that she and her husband actively decided NOT to seek a medical diagnosis and went straight to a speech therapist who did NOT diagnosis autism.


HelenSan said:
From her description, her son's symptoms meet criteria in the DSM-IV for a diagnosis of Autistic Disorder.
I'll let others address this. My previous post did not use the DSM-IV, so I do not know how they differ.

HelenSan said:
But you're right. Thank you for alerting me to the possibility that she might not have ever gotten an official dx and therefore would not qualify for the challenge.
You're welcome.


HelenSan said:
However, other "cure stories" on her website might have, and some of them might have been officially diagnosed.
"Might" and "might." It's a poor foundation upon which to build a medicine.


HelenSan said:
Dx is a relatively minor point, if autism qualifies as a "non-self-limiting condition" for the purposes of the challenge.
Umm...I'd say it's a critical point.


HelenSan said:
Homeopathy works very differently from medicine.
The culture certainly does. The treatment cannot legitimately be said to work at all.


HelenSan said:
In homeopathy, remedies fit the picture of the whole person, including personality, preferences, and other characteristics that seemingly have no relationship to the symptoms themselves. It is thought that symptoms that aren't specifically "treated" by the remedy would go away anyway when the whole person is healthy.
1. "Like cures like" is a central tenet to homeopathy (each variation of it). That in the Lansky case the prescribed cure was for a set of symptoms not associated with the named illness should be very troubling.

2. You are saying that all the over-the-counter homeopathic medicines are worthless. Have your treatments been individually prescribed or have you bought them OTC?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom