I haven’t bought (and don’t plan to buy) Amy Lansky’s book “Impossible Cure,” but I have read
her article on how homeopathy cured her son’s autism. The article was written before the book.
Some general comments first:
Lansky’s PhD is in computer science. She has no medical training. She does have homeopathic training, though, which she undertook after her son’s cure. According to her
self-written biographical summary, she is prominent in homeopathy now. The book “Impossible Cure” is primarily a book about homeopathy and was written after Amy’s rise in the homeopathic field.
She is also a follower of Deepak Chopra, a believer in acupuncture as well as reiki, quantum touch, chi, and emotional healing (meaning adding emotional emphasis to medical cures for physical ailments to materially aid the healing process). If her biographical summary is anything to go by, she is an original thinker in the fields of both computer science and Artificial Intelligence, and she is also a talented rock musician and singer of chants.
Specific comments about her son, Max:
She thinks his autism was caused by a vaccine.
He was never diagnosed as having autism.
The primary problem Lansky was attempting to address was lack of talkativeness, yet her homeopath prescribed Carcinosin because of
these symptoms:
-Desires milk which aggravates
-Dancing
-Very talented
-Head, hot on waking
-Hyperactivity
I suppose “like cures like” doesn’t apply to autism.
The Lansky’s had been trying other interventions—which they continued—prior to going to the homeopath. Primarily, they used a speech therapist.
They knew the homeopathic remedy was working because when they took Max to the therapist after beginning the remedy Max was able to follow two instructions at once instead of the usual one. But Lansky admits that Max had been able to follow two instructions prior to the homeopathic remedy, even if only rarely.
The dosage was not consistent throughout the one and a half year treatment period. Lansky stopped or reduced the treatment when she “felt like she wanted to” and increased or restarted the treatment when she “felt like she wanted to.”
Of course, there is no indication that she kept a strict record of any of this.
Intriguingly, Max’s greatest leap forward, according to Lansky herself, came in the four months AFTER they stopped homeopathic treatment altogether.
My last comment is beyond Max specifically. Lansky says that the homeopathic community did not expect to see such a dramatic improvement and were stunned by it. If this is so, and if the efficacy is so unquestionable, then why is there no paper on this cure of autism? Why were there no further studies? No papers? No anything at all?
Homeopathy found a cure for autism and simply let it slide from the view of the world.
I am not impressed. And my standards are no different for medicine than they are for homeopathy.