I was just wondering if you can give one incontrovertible example, with references, of allopathy curing a non-self-limiting condition?
You know, I don't recall studying anything called "allopathy" at college, and I'm pretty sure Badly Shaved Monkey didn't either. So technically, you're asking us to comment on something we know nothing about.
However, I'll assume that, like so many homoeopaths, you're repeating Hahnemann's insultingly-coined word for conventional medicine, in a modern context. As I got censored for saying before, if you look up the n-word in any dictionary, you'll find it defined as meaning a person with dark-coloured skin. Does that mean it's not an insult, and it's OK to use it? No? Well get the message then.
So, if we take your probable meaning, antibacterial treatment for things like TB, syphillis, scarlet fever, we could go on as there are many. Anthelmintics, some antivirals, the whole field of antimicrobial chemotherapy really. We were only asking Dana for a well-documented case report after all, and there are squillions of such things in real medicine. We even asked him for detailed documentation of such a case he'd treated himself if there was nothing in the literature - I'm sure every one of us here practising actual medicine has a good number of such cases.
However, this challenge ignores a major area of benefit in conventional medicine, which wasn't included because it isn't really part of homoeopathy's claims. That of long-term maintenance therapy for conditions which are not curable as such. Good examples are hormone replacement therapy for hormone deficiency diseases which would otherwise be fatal, such as type 1 diabetes, Addison's disease, hypothyroidism and so on. Nobody would claim to "cure" these conditions, as the patient still has the condition and would quickly relapse and die without continuing treatment, but just ask a patient which he'd rather be - dead, or taking permanent maintenance treatment?
AIDS treatment is another one in this category. Medicine can't cure AIDS, but it has changed it from a fairly rapidly fatal condition into a chronic condition that can be lived with for many many years.
Homoeopathy doesn't seem to claim to be able to do this. All the claims we hear are of "cure", a word which real medicine uses quite sparingly. We don't hear about long-term stabilisation and maintenance therapy from the homoeopaths. However, if we did, that's another effect we'd consider as evidence, if evidence could be produced.
It's back to the chain saw and feather analogy. Very few homoeopaths have the temerity to claim that real medicine doesn't cure people, or help people. Their criticisms are usually confined to long lists of potential adverse side-effects - available, ironically, because real medicine investigates and documents such occurrences, unlike homoeopathy, where no system of adverse reaction reporting is in place.
We're interested to discover if a homoeopathic remedy (as opposed to the "complex intervention" including the "therapeutic consultation" which obviously can have a similar effect to counselling) can actually affect a patient's health in any way at all. That is, do something which obviously isn't coincidence or wishful thinking.
Now, I don't think anyone at all would even begin to claim that real medicine does nothing at all, and all the effects (good or bad) are merely coincidence and wishful thinking. However, that is the position homoeopathy finds itself in. Unable to show that the remedies do
anything.
We ask for a well-documented case report showing a cure of something which could not have got better by itself as something which, if the claims of the homoeopaths have any basis in fact, should be easy to find. However, apparently it is not.
Look, just
anything, OK? Any unarguable, incontrovertible effect of a homoeopathic remedy on a patient or even a healthy person, that quite obviously isn't the result of coincidence or wishful thinking.
If you asked me to do that for any conventional drug, I'd probably simply pick up a syringe with a large dose of pentobarbitone in it and kill something. No argument with that, especially as I can do it as many times as you like, or have expendable subjects for the test. Less lethally, anaesthetics. After the third or fourth patient has gone obediently to sleep, we have to concede that there is a real effect there.
Got
anything at all that doesn't require complex ifs and buts and rose-tinted spectacles, homoeopaths?
Rolfe.