Even More Fun with Homeopath Dana Ullman, MPH(!)

Untreated, only 3.7 percent are alive and disease free at 10 years.

Linda
First of all, thank you, Linda, for the examples. Do you happen to have a reference for the above statistic? I didn't find that in the cited reference; they did not have an untreated control group. Thanks.

In the interests of skepticism and impartial analysis, I would like to propose an exercise. We all have confirmation bias (the tendency to look for evidence that supports our own biases), which results in our being more lenient with evidence we like than evidence we don't like. Something I do on a regular basis, to challenge my own confirmation bias, is to read a study I like and imagine it to be a study I don't like. Then I rip it apart.

For example, take the breast cancer study. Substitute say, Belladonna 30 C, for lumpectomy and Sulphur 200C for irradiation. Imagine that Dana submitted this exact study as "incontrovertible" proof of a cure for a non-self-limiting condition. Would it be sufficient proof for you? If not, what would be wrong with the study? How would you rip it apart?

All studies have flaws and limitations. I am trying to get a feel for how many flaws and how much limitation you would tolerate and still consider it to fall in the "incontrovertible" category. I know what *I* would do. But I am trying to get a feel for what everyone here would consider to be an "incontrovertible" standard for effectiveness.

If there is a challenge, terms like "incontrovertible" should be explored and defined more precisely, right?
 
Hey Linda...I'm glad that you can make such pronouncements and that you think that you have some authority or knowledge. You are a regular dictionary, but as compared with a dictionary, you make it up out of thin air. In the United States, "allopathic" is used by the American Medical Association, the National Residency Matching Program, and the Association of American Medical Colleges. The word "allopathy" is alive and living. Live with it.

Allopathy was coined by Hahnemann in 1842 to distinguish homeopathy and conventional medicine at the time. If Hahnemann coined it it is perfectly alright for fls to start to decoin it.

But how unusual for a purveyor of fake medicine to completely ignore the main point of the post, ie conventional medicine cures people, homeopathy doesn't, and concentrate on a minor point of definition.
 
First of all, thank you, Linda, for the examples. Do you happen to have a reference for the above statistic? I didn't find that in the cited reference; they did not have an untreated control group. Thanks.
Linda's study showed there was a 14% recurrence rate of cancer following treatment with lumpectomy and radiotherapy. In other words, the treatment cured 86% of women who have an incurable condition. Breast cancer will not go away on its own, so there is no need for an "untreated" control group in this study (It would be unethical anyway).
I don't know where Linda got the other data from - perhaps she will say.
In the interests of skepticism and impartial analysis, I would like to propose an exercise. We all have confirmation bias (the tendency to look for evidence that supports our own biases), which results in our being more lenient with evidence we like than evidence we don't like. Something I do on a regular basis, to challenge my own confirmation bias, is to read a study I like and imagine it to be a study I don't like. Then I rip it apart.

For example, take the breast cancer study. Substitute say, Belladonna 30 C, for lumpectomy and Sulphur 200C for irradiation. Imagine that Dana submitted this exact study as "incontrovertible" proof of a cure for a non-self-limiting condition. Would it be sufficient proof for you? If not, what would be wrong with the study? How would you rip it apart?

All studies have flaws and limitations. I am trying to get a feel for how many flaws and how much limitation you would tolerate and still consider it to fall in the "incontrovertible" category. I know what *I* would do. But I am trying to get a feel for what everyone here would consider to be an "incontrovertible" standard for effectiveness.

If there is a challenge, terms like "incontrovertible" should be explored and defined more precisely, right?
The evolution of therapy for cancer is progressive, with hundreds of successive studies each showing incremental gains and improvements on current knowledge.
Many studies are published which show a new intervention may be useful. However it is extremely rare for any single study to gain acceptance and become standard practice without plenty of corroboration. This would apply for Belladonna as a cure for breast cancer too. The homeopathic literature is sprinkled with supposedly wonderful therapies which do not stand up to scrutiny when looked at in proper quality studies. As soon as there is one which does, then I will be among the first to acclaim its success.

The basic premise of the challenge is clear - Find a homeopathic remedy which has cured a disease that would otherwise be fatal/incurable. Semantics about defining "incontrovertible" are just a way of avoiding adressing the question.

If you prefer, find an answer to my second challenge -
Find one single instance where the independent Data Safety Monitoring Board has discontinued a trial because homeopathy was found to be superior to placebo or conventional therapy, and therefore it was deemed to be unethical to continue the study.
 
Last edited:
The word "allopathy" is alive and living. Live with it.


"Allopathy" is indeed alive and kicking, and is practised widely (especially in India where ironically many of its practitioners are also homoeopaths) under the name "Ayurveda". It only has three humours (or "doshas"), rather than the four of Western medicine in Hahnemann's time, but the basic principles are those of "allopathy".
 
In the United States, "allopathic" is used by the American Medical Association, the National Residency Matching Program, and the Association of American Medical Colleges. The word "allopathy" is alive and living. Live with it.


"Allopathy" simply means "the method of treating disease by the use of agents that produce effects different from those of the disease treated".

In other words, any remedy that is not homoeopathic is allopathic.
Conventional medicine is therefore merely a subset of allopathy.
If you want to be clear about what you are talking about, I'm afraid you're going to have to use the more exact and specific term. ;)

Thank-you!

On the other hand, perhaps we should use the term "Evidence-based medicine" to distinguish it from all forms of non-evidence based medicine, which includes parts of conventional, and most of alternative, integrative, and complimentary medicine....and all of homoeopathy :cool:.
 
Last edited:
Originally Posted by fls
Untreated, only 3.7 percent are alive and disease free at 10 years.
Do you happen to have a reference for the above statistic? I didn't find that in the cited reference; they did not have an untreated control group. Thanks.


Linda must have obtained that figure elsewhere.

They would not have used a control (no treatment) group, because it would be unethical to give any patient less than what is presently considered optimal treatment based on the results of previous studies.

She probably got it from a source such as this one:

http://www.what-is-cancer.com/papers/newmedicine/untreated.htm


untreated1.jpg



Refer to the first graph (the other is not relevant)
This looks at the survival of women who presented so late that no treatment other than palliative care could be provided.

It looks about 3-4% at 10 years to me, with none surviving beyond 15 years.
 
Last edited:
I was just wondering if you can give one incontrovertible example, with references, of allopathy curing a non-self-limiting condition?


You know, I don't recall studying anything called "allopathy" at college, and I'm pretty sure Badly Shaved Monkey didn't either. So technically, you're asking us to comment on something we know nothing about.

However, I'll assume that, like so many homoeopaths, you're repeating Hahnemann's insultingly-coined word for conventional medicine, in a modern context. As I got censored for saying before, if you look up the n-word in any dictionary, you'll find it defined as meaning a person with dark-coloured skin. Does that mean it's not an insult, and it's OK to use it? No? Well get the message then.

So, if we take your probable meaning, antibacterial treatment for things like TB, syphillis, scarlet fever, we could go on as there are many. Anthelmintics, some antivirals, the whole field of antimicrobial chemotherapy really. We were only asking Dana for a well-documented case report after all, and there are squillions of such things in real medicine. We even asked him for detailed documentation of such a case he'd treated himself if there was nothing in the literature - I'm sure every one of us here practising actual medicine has a good number of such cases.

However, this challenge ignores a major area of benefit in conventional medicine, which wasn't included because it isn't really part of homoeopathy's claims. That of long-term maintenance therapy for conditions which are not curable as such. Good examples are hormone replacement therapy for hormone deficiency diseases which would otherwise be fatal, such as type 1 diabetes, Addison's disease, hypothyroidism and so on. Nobody would claim to "cure" these conditions, as the patient still has the condition and would quickly relapse and die without continuing treatment, but just ask a patient which he'd rather be - dead, or taking permanent maintenance treatment?

AIDS treatment is another one in this category. Medicine can't cure AIDS, but it has changed it from a fairly rapidly fatal condition into a chronic condition that can be lived with for many many years.

Homoeopathy doesn't seem to claim to be able to do this. All the claims we hear are of "cure", a word which real medicine uses quite sparingly. We don't hear about long-term stabilisation and maintenance therapy from the homoeopaths. However, if we did, that's another effect we'd consider as evidence, if evidence could be produced.

It's back to the chain saw and feather analogy. Very few homoeopaths have the temerity to claim that real medicine doesn't cure people, or help people. Their criticisms are usually confined to long lists of potential adverse side-effects - available, ironically, because real medicine investigates and documents such occurrences, unlike homoeopathy, where no system of adverse reaction reporting is in place.

We're interested to discover if a homoeopathic remedy (as opposed to the "complex intervention" including the "therapeutic consultation" which obviously can have a similar effect to counselling) can actually affect a patient's health in any way at all. That is, do something which obviously isn't coincidence or wishful thinking.

Now, I don't think anyone at all would even begin to claim that real medicine does nothing at all, and all the effects (good or bad) are merely coincidence and wishful thinking. However, that is the position homoeopathy finds itself in. Unable to show that the remedies do anything.

We ask for a well-documented case report showing a cure of something which could not have got better by itself as something which, if the claims of the homoeopaths have any basis in fact, should be easy to find. However, apparently it is not.

Look, just anything, OK? Any unarguable, incontrovertible effect of a homoeopathic remedy on a patient or even a healthy person, that quite obviously isn't the result of coincidence or wishful thinking.

If you asked me to do that for any conventional drug, I'd probably simply pick up a syringe with a large dose of pentobarbitone in it and kill something. No argument with that, especially as I can do it as many times as you like, or have expendable subjects for the test. Less lethally, anaesthetics. After the third or fourth patient has gone obediently to sleep, we have to concede that there is a real effect there.

Got anything at all that doesn't require complex ifs and buts and rose-tinted spectacles, homoeopaths?

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:
First of all, thank you, Linda, for the examples. Do you happen to have a reference for the above statistic? I didn't find that in the cited reference; they did not have an untreated control group. Thanks.

Oops. I had my reference all ready (I think I had even pressed ctrl-C) and I forgot to follow through (I blame chocolate). I was using this for the number.

In the interests of skepticism and impartial analysis, I would like to propose an exercise. We all have confirmation bias (the tendency to look for evidence that supports our own biases), which results in our being more lenient with evidence we like than evidence we don't like. Something I do on a regular basis, to challenge my own confirmation bias, is to read a study I like and imagine it to be a study I don't like. Then I rip it apart.

For example, take the breast cancer study. Substitute say, Belladonna 30 C, for lumpectomy and Sulphur 200C for irradiation. Imagine that Dana submitted this exact study as "incontrovertible" proof of a cure for a non-self-limiting condition. Would it be sufficient proof for you? If not, what would be wrong with the study? How would you rip it apart?

The study itself would fulfill the requirements of what we asked for from Mr. Ullman, with the caveat that there would need to be a fuller description/analysis of the use of mastectomy, lumpectomy and lumpectomy with irradiation (i.e. the use of any others treatments which could reasonably be expected to be effective) in addition to the homeopathic treatments.

All studies have flaws and limitations. I am trying to get a feel for how many flaws and how much limitation you would tolerate and still consider it to fall in the "incontrovertible" category. I know what *I* would do. But I am trying to get a feel for what everyone here would consider to be an "incontrovertible" standard for effectiveness.

If there is a challenge, terms like "incontrovertible" should be explored and defined more precisely, right?

That is a reasonable question, but to be honest, exploration of the details seems pointless until we are presented with something that requires any degree of precision. A meter may make a difference if someone is standing in the same room, but it makes no difference if they are standing in the next county.

Linda
 
HelenSan - Homeopathy is unable even to cure constipation or diarrhoea. How can you expect Homeopathy to cure cancer? Belladonna 30 CH and Sulphur 200 CH are inactive and therefore ineffective. The chances that these remedies work are the same as that of resuscitating a dead person.
 
Hey Linda...I'm glad that you can make such pronouncements and that you think that you have some authority or knowledge. You are a regular dictionary, but as compared with a dictionary, you make it up out of thin air. In the United States, "allopathic" is used by the American Medical Association, the National Residency Matching Program, and the Association of American Medical Colleges. The word "allopathy" is alive and living. Live with it.

I realize that "allopathy" has entered into common use. However, as a qualifier it is meaningless or redundant. If used simply to refer to medicine as practiced by medical doctors, then the word "medicine" can be used all by itself. If used as a way to distinguish a particular type of medicine, it doesn't represent a necessary or sufficient (or even arguably real) way to describe a useful category.

I'm trying to take a pro-active role. That this is likely to join my other seemingly useless efforts ("I couldn't care less." "Oh the inhumanity.") matters not. Like the homeopaths, I continue to bludgeon others with my feather. ;)

Linda
 
Last edited:
hmm, yes.

I finally did get that hat on him - round his neck and then he ran off. I found him later trying to get off the top of the cupboard. Everytime he made an attempt, the hat slung down obstructing his view of the floor below, and he would have to clamber back up again. After about a dozen attempts and boisterous laughter, he finally took a wild leap into the unknown.

All's well though - he landed safely, as cats tend to do.
(or is that another myth?)

BJ

IIRC, cats have a non-fatal terminal velocity. If a cat has time to right itself (i.e., falling from higher than 6-7 floors up) before it hits the ground, it should survive the fall.
 
There's certainly a study showing that the more severe injuries occur in cats falling from relatively low heights compared to upper floors. And I recall taking a panic-stricken phone call at 8.30am from a woman who said her cat had just fallen from a second floor window (third floor to the colonials) and could I Come At Once! I explained that I was due to begin morning surgery at nine, and her best bet was to scoop the cat up and come hotfoot to me, ASAP. She actually turned up while I was seing a patient, and barged her way into the consulting room past a horrified receptionist. She was clutching an entirely uninjured cat.

However, I wouldn't like to be too confident about the non-lethal terminal momentum. I think it's borderline, and the nature of the surface the cat falls on also plays an important role.

Rolfe.
 
Oh, thank-you, I thought my pussy was all forgotten about!

IIRC, cats have a non-fatal terminal velocity. If a cat has time to right itself (i.e., falling from higher than 6-7 floors up) before it hits the ground, it should survive the fall.


Yes, I can verify from personal experimentation that this is so. :cool:
(I'm joking, of course)

There's certainly a study showing that the more severe injuries occur in cats falling from relatively low heights compared to upper floors.

However, I wouldn't like to be too confident about the non-lethal terminal momentum. I think it's borderline, and the nature of the surface the cat falls on also plays an important role.


Well, there you go, you can't trust anything.

(third floor to the colonials)


Oh yeah. :mad:
 
Rolfe,

I have to congratulate you on your reply to HelenSan.
It's the most entertaining post I've come across for quite some time.
And to the point, goddammit!

I could just hear you saying that. :)

BillyJoe
 
Is it just me, or is "lumpectomy" a way to obvious name for a medical procedure? There must be a more obtuse word than "lump" available to have "ectomy" tagged on the end of it.

How else are you doctors going to maintain the (im)balance of power in the consulting room if plebs can guess what you're talking about?;)
 
Is it just me, or is "lumpectomy" a way to obvious name for a medical procedure? There must be a more obtuse word than "lump" available to have "ectomy" tagged on the end of it.

How else are you doctors going to maintain the (im)balance of power in the consulting room if plebs can guess what you're talking about?;)
I guess you could call the lump a tumour - but this would panic patients who don't realise there are benign lumps as well as malign lumps.
So lump will do just fine, and lumpectomy seems to have gained favoured status, but you are right, we should really have a long complicated name for it to keep up the mystique of supreme godliness.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom