Hey BillyJoe,
Thanx for bringing up the Heimlich maneuver. His wife, Jane Heimlich, wrote one of the popular homeopathic guidebooks (with M. Panos, MD). Thanx for reminding me of this one. You and your medical colleagues are surrounded by people who love and who have benefited from homeopathy.
So that makes Heimlich useful and his wife not so useful.
The only people I know who have benefited from homeopathy are those who make money by selling them water and lactose or writing books.
And because the people on this list insist upon double-blind placebo controlled trials, I know that none of you would consider undergoing the many surgical procedures that have not been tested with these scientific methods. As for me, I have a high respect for the appropriate use of surgery, despite the limitations of controlled clinical studies.
The strawman about surgery is adequately dealt with by BSM.
Oh well, there is so much in this world that is real and important and that cannot be tested in the same way by placebo-controlled trials (or that need important a research design that is sensitive to the therapeutic method tested).
Homeopathy is not one of them.
The wriggle factor is becoming very apparent.
Placebo controlled studies according to a homeopath:-
Homeopathy has been proved to work in placebo controlled studies
|
V
Well the so-called good studies showing it doesn't have flaws
|
V
Well placebo controlled studies are irrelevant because they can't be used in something completely different from homeopathy
-------
'Provings' as a test of Homeopathy by a homeopath:-
'Provings' show that homeopathic preparations, ie water/lactose are active
|
V
This trial shows that 'proving is correct.
|
V
'Proving' is a very difficult area to work in.
|
V
You just don't know anything about homeopathy.
-------
On 'potentiation' of preparations by a homeopath
Activity of samples without any material other than water/lactose through a memory effect has been shown biologically.
|
V
Well, we can show that they are different by physical means, showing that something is there.
|
V
Not being able to show any difference between water and water etc is totally irrelevant to homeopathy.
-------
Having been squeezed out of any logical, scientific or medical evidence based argument, what is a homeopath to do for his daily crust.
I know, let's write a book about famous people who may or may not have been fooled by this load of bollocks. I can still keep the money rolling in and who cares about anybody losing money for no treatment or dying because they haven't been treated with something that actually works.