Even More Fun with Homeopath Dana Ullman, MPH(!)

Deetee - Some die nevertheless, often because of doctors errors. Conventional Medicine is almost perfect: the real problems are many doctors, nurses and the system that in UK allows nurses to prescribe.
 
Deetee - Some die nevertheless, often because of doctors errors. Conventional Medicine is almost perfect: the real problems are many doctors, nurses and the system that in UK allows nurses to prescribe.
I suppose you can cite reliable data ...

That would be refreshing, since you never have done so.
 
Deetee - Some die nevertheless, often because of doctors errors. Conventional Medicine is almost perfect: the real problems are many doctors, nurses and the system that in UK allows nurses to prescribe.
Yes - some die because of medical error. But it is certainly not "often", taken in the context of how many are successfully treated.

To paraphrase someone else on this forum (I forget who), I am afraid that if you want to cut down trees, you need to use a saw, not a feather. Then by the end of the day you will have cleared a forest. However, since "accidents" happen despite the best of intentions, you may occasionally have an injury to one of your lumberjacks. I admit some lumberjacks are sloppy and use their equipment badly - there is always room for improvement.

You might well find some "data" to show JJM, but I bet it will be out of context. There will be no denominator to indicate how many lives conventional therapy has saved. Can you tell us a reliable study showing clear evidence that homeopathy has ever saved a single life, ever?

But let's not move off topic - remember that there is still Dana here to have fun with. We are still waiting for him to come up with

ONE INCONTROVERTIBLE EXAMPLE, WITH REFERENCES, OF HOMEOPATHY CURING A NON-SELF-LIMITING CONDITION.

or, alternatively,

One example, with references, where the independent data safety monitoring board (DSMB) terminated a study early because of the benefits homeopathy demonstrated over placebo or conventional therapy.
 
I will soon be adding more information to my article, including some amazing information about John Chapman, the famous editor of the WESTMINSTER REVIEW, whose publication probably did more for the promulgation of Darwin's work than any other source.


The "amazing information" presumably being that the treatment Chapman prescribed for Darwin was not homoeopathic. As Dana says elsewhere,
The only treatment that Darwin writes about from Chapman is his use of ice...which initially had some benefits but didn't adequately work for him. There is no reference to homeopathic medicines from Chapman. Ultimately, Darwin sought Chapman's care for only 2 months.
 
Oh and...

When I lodged a boiled sweet in my trachea my father instantly applied the heimlich manoeuvre and saved my life.
I am glad he wasn't a homoeopath.

(Okay, a little joke)

(Although it did happen)
 
To paraphrase someone else on this forum (I forget who), I am afraid that if you want to cut down trees, you need to use a saw, not a feather.

'Twas me, though actually said elsewhere and cited by Rolfe here.

Never let it be said that Dana is the only one who wants to groom his ego with every opportunity for self-promotion.
 
Friends,
One of the things that you folks don't seem to get (and/or don't seem to want to understand) is that the vast majority of homeopaths are trained as physicians (this is particularly true in Germany, France, Netherlands, Italy, Argentina, Brazil, Columbia, and India). As such, they prefer to use safer methods before resorting to some dangerous medical treatments. They, therefore, have a referral network within CAM and within orthodox medicine so that they can provide for their patients extensive options and provide real integrative medicine for our modern-age.

Integrating the best of conventional medicine and the best from safe natural therapies is an ideal and is a common approach used by homeopaths worldwide.

Rolf's mam got better after Addison's disease. I'm happy for her and Rolf. It is just that homeopaths find that an unusally high percentage of our patients have a "spontaneous remission" or cure (whatever you want to call it). What would you say if one of the highly distinguished medical doctors and contributors to modern medicine and surgery (who also happened to be a homeopathic physician) said that he and his colleagues had a 60-70% cure rate in treating people with chronic diseases. Hmmmm.

Since Rolf wanted an example, I will quote from my book's chapter on "Physicians and Scientists: Coming out of the Medicine Closet:"

Harold Randall Griffith, MD
Although the name of Dr. Harold Griffith (1894–1985) may not be familiar, he was a giant in the field of anesthesia. In fact, one of Dr. Griffith’s biographers succinctly summarized his medical contribution: “It has been said there are only two eras in anesthesia, before Harold Griffith and after” (Canadian Anesthesiologists’ Society).

Harold Griffith’s father was Alexander Randall Griffith, MD, who graduated from New York Homeopathic Medical College in 1891 and from New York Ophthalmic Hospital’s specialty program in 1892. Dr. Alexander Griffith was medical chief of the Montreal Homeopathic Hospital from 1898 until his death in 1936, at which time his son, Harold, succeeded him. Harold’s brother James was surgeon-in-chief from 1937 to 1966.

As children, Harold and his older brother Hugh contracted diphtheria, and with both conventional and homeopathic treatment, they were among the few people to survive this deadly disease.

Harold Griffith was trained in medicine at McGill University, but due to his special interest in homeopathy, he obtained a homeopathic medical degree from the Hahnemann Medical College in Philadelphia. He moved back to Montreal to work alongside his father and brother, both of whom were homeopathic physicians at the Homeopathic Hospital of Montreal. He became chief of anesthesia at the hospital, where for forty-three years he served as chief anesthetist and thirty-nine years as medical superintendent (today, this hospital is known as Queen Elizabeth Hospital). Under his direction, the Homeopathic Hospital of Montreal was the first in Canada to have a surgical recovery room (Shephard, 2004).

Griffith made medical history in 1942 when he became the first doctor in the world to use curare to relax the muscles of a patient undergoing an appendectomy. He was the first president of the Canadian Anesthetists’ Society upon its founding in 1943, and in 1955 became founding president of the World Federation of Societies of Anesthesiologists. In 1951, he became chairman of the department of anesthesiology at McGill University.

One of Griffith’s classmates at the Hahnemann Medical College was Henry Ruth, MD, who stayed and practiced in Philadelphia. Ultimately, this fellow homeopath Dr. Ruth became the founding editor of the leading journal in their field, Anesthesiology, which was published by the American Society of Anesthetists.

Griffith maintained a lifelong appreciation for homeopathic medicines to prevent the need for surgery, but he was ready, willing, and certainly able to provide his surgical skills when necessary. He prescribed homeopathic medicines to many patients pre- and post-surgery to help in their recovery. During his years at the homeopathic hospital, the most commonly treated diseases included pneumonia, typhoid fever, tuberculosis, puerperal fever as a complication of childbirth, syphilis, pernicious anemia, and diabetes. Despite the serious nature of these and other illnesses, Griffith maintained that homeopathic medicines were a useful therapy in which 60–70 percent of patients responded favorably (Bodman and Gillies, 1996, 38).

Although Griffith was strongly partial to homeopathic treatment, he insisted that the hospital maintain an “open door” policy of employing both homeopathic and allopathic (conventional) physicians.
 
Dana, Rolfe's mam is the one who can still see in spite of having had glaucoma for 25 years, thanks to pharmacotherapeutic medical and surgical treatment. If you read the posts, it is Professor Yaffle's mam who is the well-stabilised Addison's patient.

The reason I regard Addison's as a good example of a condition where a one-off homoeopathy cure would be impressive, is that in my experience spontaneous recoveries after properly-confirmed diagnosis don't happen. Got one to show us?

Thought not.

Now, why don't you try actually reading people's posts and understanding what they have said and who has said it before firing off in all directions.

Then you could expain exactly what your maunderings about Griffith have to do with the price of fish. And then, how this "integrative medicine" idea sits with the belief of many homoeopathe that real medicine is incompatible with homoeopathy because it will antidote the remedies and in fact make the patient worse.

Then you could provide that evidence for the vast majority of homoeopaths being trained physicians.

Rolfe.
 
What would you say if one of the highly distinguished medical doctors and contributors to modern medicine and surgery (who also happened to be a homeopathic physician) said that he and his colleagues had a 60-70% cure rate in treating people with chronic diseases. ....Griffith maintained that homeopathic medicines were a useful therapy in which 60–70 percent of patients responded favorably

That is just deeply and exasperatingly stupid. This third-hand nonsense counts for nothing.

Yes, Dana, customer satisfaction surveys of homeopaths do report that 70% of patients can be recorded as showing an improvement in their condition at some point after treatment, but to call this a 'cure rate' is just another of those canards put forth by homeopaths that would be much better referred to by what it is: a BIG FAT LIE.

Hanging around with chronically ill-patients and waiting for their condition to improve at some point and when it does writing this down in your big book of case records then walking briskly away does not count as a cure. THESE PATIENTS ARE NOT CURED. The homeopath has just stopped keeping track. This is why real medicine defines its endpoints at the beginning of a study and uses end-points that are equivalent between control and treatment groups.

This 70% figure is often used by idiots on your side to engender surprise and disbelief that a placebo effect can be so powerful, and hence that we should take the alternative, viz an effect of sugar pills, seriously. But this is another of your irritating strawman arguments. No-one is trying to say that placebo can 'cure' 70% of patients. All that we say is that chronically fluctuating disease fluctuate. Will you agree to stop using this particularly stupid argument? No, I thought not.
 
Last edited:
As a brief derail while everyone is waiting for the evidence, I came across a list of Doctor's acronyms, used in patients notes to disguise comments. One of these was "TEETH", which stands for Tried Everything Else, Try Homoeopathy. Well, it amused me, but that doesn't take a lot.

End of derail.

James Gully, please supply ONE INCONTROVERTIBLE EXAMPLE, WITH REFERENCES, OF HOMEOPATHY CURING A NON-SELF-LIMITING CONDITION.

or, alternatively,

One example, with references, where the independent data safety monitoring board (DSMB) terminated a study early because of the benefits homeopathy demonstrated over placebo or conventional therapy.

Dave
 
Last edited:
Hey BillyJoe,
Thanx for bringing up the Heimlich maneuver. His wife, Jane Heimlich, wrote one of the popular homeopathic guidebooks (with M. Panos, MD). Thanx for reminding me of this one. You and your medical colleagues are surrounded by people who love and who have benefited from homeopathy.

And because the people on this list insist upon double-blind placebo controlled trials, I know that none of you would consider undergoing the many surgical procedures that have not been tested with these scientific methods. As for me, I have a high respect for the appropriate use of surgery, despite the limitations of controlled clinical studies.

Oh well, there is so much in this world that is real and important and that cannot be tested in the same way by placebo-controlled trials (or that need important a research design that is sensitive to the therapeutic method tested).
 
Well, that's an improvement. We've gone from 150-year-old mostly irrelevant, poorly documented, vaguely worded support for homeopathy to 100-year-old irrelevant, poorly documented, vaguely worded support for homeopathy.

Linda
 
WARNING!! WARNING!! STRAWMAN ALERT!!

H
And because the people on this list insist upon double-blind placebo controlled trials, I know that none of you would consider undergoing the many surgical procedures that have not been tested with these scientific methods. As for me, I have a high respect for the appropriate use of surgery, despite the limitations of controlled clinical studies.

Listen, brains, everyone in the field accepts that the difficulties of blinding surgical techniques are a serious weakness of the surgical literature. No one is proud of this. No one thinks this is a good position to be in. Inevitably it must mean that some bad choices are being made in surgery. Surgeons acknowledge this. I tell people this every time I advise on performing surgery in animals where more than one technique exists for the same problem. This is what real clinicians do, which is in deep contrast to fools like homeopaths who pretend they have all the answers.

But, the problem is intrinsic to the physical nature of surgical technique. Homeopathy is indeed fortunate not to suffer from this problem which is why it is eminently suitable for performing controlled trials to see if the little sugar pills work. If you were to find a valid trial showing an effect from homeopathy it could be discussed in the relevant thread.

This thread, though, gives you the chance to answer one, and now two, questions;

James Gully, please supply ONE INCONTROVERTIBLE EXAMPLE, WITH REFERENCES, OF HOMEOPATHY CURING A NON-SELF-LIMITING CONDITION.

or, alternatively,

One example, with references, where the independent data safety monitoring board (DSMB) terminated a study early because of the benefits homeopathy demonstrated over placebo or conventional therapy.
 
....Just popping in to wish you all Happy Holidays!

Has Dana answered the question yet?
Ah, No... Of course not....
I must give you all credit: you folks have much more patience than I do.
:czwacky::wackygoofy::czhypnotic::wackygoofy::czwacky:​

Hoping your Holiday Season is Happy, Joyous, and ....Edible!
​

AlooooooooHa!​
 
....and remember....christmas spirit is NOT WHAT YOU DRINK! :mad:


:D
(hey, santa, pass us that bottle will ya.)
 
Last edited:
Oh, I dunno, one of the packages under the tree (a gift from a client) looks suspiciously bottle-shaped.

And I thought all was perfect, everything bought, wrapped, posted, found, assembled and all the rest, even the Christmas avatar resurrected, and I'm resting on my laurels, and the bloody gas fire, the positive living centrepiece to the perfect Christmas, goes out. I still haven't figured how to monitor usage. And the gas cylinder supplier won't be open till Thursday I suppose.

So, whatever is in that bottle, I'm planning on drinking it.

But now I'm going to sign off and head for church for the Midnight Service.

Happy Christmas everyone!

Rolfe.
 
Deetee - Last week I visited a 92 years old patient. She had a Heart Attack 40 years ago and a Coronary Bypass 32 years ago. She regularly takes conventional drugs and is doing very well for her age (reads and drives the car). On the other hand, I never came across a case where Homeopathy saved a life, and I'm not aware of a single person, with a non-self-limiting condition, being cured by Homeopathy.

JamesGully is right when he says that the majority of homeopaths, in some countries (e.g. France and Italy) are doctors. This is because Homeopathy is considered a medical act (not mentioning its effectivness) and therefore can be practiced only by doctors.
There are about 3,000 MDs homeopaths in Italy. Two months ago I attended the AGM of homeopaths. There were about 350 homeopaths present. Only one of them was a "pure" homeopath, meaning he had a private practice where he practised only Homeopathy. All other MDs had another job (employed in hospitals, GPs etc.). I asked many of them whether they are MDs or Homeopaths, and almost all of them replied that they are MDs and then homeopaths ( not telling the truth because you cannot be both, e.g. no one can be at the same time a Catholic and a Protestant). I think that 99% of them are doctors using homeopathic remedies and not homeopaths and, I think, they do it only to increase their income. I must also say that patients visiting them are generally very satisfied. My explanation is that they (doctors) take more time with their paying patients and know very well how to use conventional drugs. "Successes" in Homeopathy are probably due to Conventional Medicine.
 
Rolfe,

This is our cat:

6ycexx1.jpg


Does he look a bit like yours?
(I tried to get a christmas hat on his head but he refused! :mad: )
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom