Even More Fun with Homeopath Dana Ullman, MPH(!)

Dr. James Manby Gully: Water Cure Physician and Homeopathic Doctor

In case some of you didn't see my posting at Mr. Duck's website...enjoy this one.

Every biography of Charles Darwin that references his health acknowledges that the one physician who provided the best treatment to him was DR. JAMES MANBY GULLY. This is not controversial. This is fact.

Dr. James Manby Gully wrote a book called The Water Cure in Chronic Disease in 1846, and this popular book went through five editions. In the first edition to this book he was very articulate in his critique of conventional medicine of his day, though this critique is equally valid for medicine today. Gully was a strong critique of “polypharmacy,” the use of multiple medicines prescribed for a patient. Gully was concerned that each medicine causes serious symptoms which required yet another medicine to reduce its side effects. He wrote:

“I could show by not a few illustrations how this complex medication, this polypharmacy, necessitates the employment of each of the medicines comprehended in it, to obviate the effects of another; how the effect of the mercurials have to be combated by the opiates; how these, again produce a necessity for the purgatives (drugs that induce vomiting); these, for the remedies for flatulence; and these again, producing heart-burn, call for alkalis and opiates…the whole plan is radically wrong.” (page 46)

Gully poses the question of how can a physician find the “precise stimulus” to a real cure for the patient. He then asserts that homeopaths provide “a more rational plan.” Drawing from his own experiences, he affirms that despite the use of infinitesimal doses used in homeopathy, “It is well and wise to observe and investigate these things before laughing at them” (page 47).

In 1856 when this book was published in its fifth edition, he added the following strong statements about the value of homeopathic medicines. He writes that distinct from the use of conventional medicines in the treatment of chronic constipation where drugs do not cure and lead to relapse, it is significantly different with homeopathic care: “In fact, cases abound in which homeopathic treatment alone has effectually and permanently cure habitual costiveness” (page 48).

In reference to the treatment of headaches, the use of homeopathic medicines is “not only justifiable but desirable.”

Finally, Gully continues by asserting, “Homeopathic practitioners have observed that patients under the water cure are more susceptible to the action of their remedies than other persons, and that therefore the results may be more accurately calculated. I have found this assertion to be substantially correct; and it confirms the vivifying influence of the water cure over the bodily functions” (page 48).

The people on this list love to quote Andy's article at this website, and he has done a good job of missing many references that are in my book and others that are at my newly revised and expanded article on this subject.

Mr. Duck suggested that we end this conversation...so, I thanked him and add some parting thoughts...

Wow...thanx for letting me have the last word...I'm impressed.

Now, nobody can say that Darwin's favorite doctor wasn't a homeopath and that despite Darwin's skepticism for homeopathy, the results and Darwin's confirmation of these results stand...and stand tall.

I will soon be adding more information to my article, including some amazing information about John Chapman, the famous editor of the WESTMINSTER REVIEW, whose publication probably did more for the promulgation of Darwin's work than any other source.

Although biographical information about Chapman always mentions that he was a doctor, they NEVER mention that he was a homeopathic doctor. In fact, he was even Gully's homeopath (according to Desmond & Moore's bio on Darwin, p. 392). John Chapman was a very interesting man...and a leading homeopathic physician.

In any case, I hope that I helped educate some people here who are less fundamentalist than you.

Mr. Duck responded in his typically sophisticated and academically rich way: "Quack."

Hopefully, people on this list will be a tad more articulate (what else could I expect from a duck?).
 
Dana,

I can tentatively accept your claim without bothering to look into it myself because i, personally, don't give a damn about whether Darwin was a believer in homeopathy or not. I do not understand how this makes any valid point whatsoever aside from possibly being a trivial case of a historical blunder.

I am more interested in today's empirical evidence or non-evidence of the efficacy of homeopathy. Not in anecdotes or name-throwing.
 
Jaana,
Darwin was a real person, and his case was a real case. The results are there. If you think that it was just "coincidence" that he got better, you are much more metaphysical than I am.
And as much as I appreciate double-blind placebo controlled trials, you should not undergo most surgeries because they haven't been tested that way. Yeah, there are lots of things that you believe and even respect that you learned without a double-blind trial. But heck, this isn't about anything except your beliefs, not real science.
 
Dana, you seem to have forgotten the purpose of this thread. It is to give you the opportunity to answer one simple challenge.

GIVE ONE, YOU ONLY NEED ONE, INCONTROVERTIBLE EXAMPLE, WITH REFERENCES, OF HOMEOPATHY CURING A NON-SELF-LIMITING CONDITION.

I am sure I am not alone in saying that I am very bored of your silly book. It is quite clear you have distorted the evidence in order to sustain your unwarranted claims about the beliefs of some people who feature in it. But please get this into your skull, and I'll put it in purple because that seems to be the only colour homeopaths can see;
NO ONE IN THEIR RIGHT MIND CARES ABOUT YOUR BOOK AND ITS STORIES

It is literally pointless. Even if Darwin was a dyed-in-the-wool True Bleever in homeopathy it would make no difference, not one iota, it would matter not a jot, it would be irrelevant, it would have no bearing on the subject under discussion, it would not be germane to any consideration of homeopathy's efficacy. All it shows is your pathological need to feel validated by authority figures, which is typical of the whole homeopathic community. But, homeopaths' desperate personal need for validation has nothing to do with whether your little sugar pills can cure people. Though it does explain the motivations of those who sell them.

Now, I'd like you to give one clear-cut and properly documented case of AIDS being cured by homeopathy, or Type 1 Diabetes, or cirrhosis of the liver, or rabies, or Alzheimers, or end-stage renal failure, or metastatic melanoma, or Parkinson's disease, or CJD...

Off you go now, be a good boy and do your homework.
 
Jaana,
Darwin was a real person, and his case was a real case. The results are there. If you think that it was just "coincidence" that he got better, you are much more metaphysical than I am.

Of course it's not coincidence that he got better. It's just not due to the specific effects of special water. Rather the special water served as a way to mark improvement in an entirely non-specific manner (it could have been accomplished by painting purple stars across his forehead).

Copied from here.

"It's a matter of attention and anchoring.

Consider what happens when trying to recall these things. It's very difficult to get an accurate account of the course of symptoms/disease when taking a history. The heart attack that happened "two years ago" really happened ten years ago. The symptoms that have been "present for three months" were already complained about a year ago. This isn't done deliberately. We have difficulty estimating these things unless we can anchor them to something where the timing is known. If the heart attack happened at your daughter's wedding, there is no difficulty in recalling the date. But most of the time we don't really have the opportunity or inclination to track these things.

Add to that our tendency to notice only those things that are unusual in the first place. Regression almost guarantees that next time you ask, things will be better. It's just that most of the time we don't ask.

We have thousands of opportunities for success, but we squander most of them by not paying attention and by not providing a way to anchor the timing to a known event. Taking a homeopathic preparation solves both these problems. Now attention will be paid to that we would have ignored previously (the waxing and waning of eczema), and we have a specific event (the taking of a therapy) by which to time the course of events.

It doesn't require cherry-picking to find examples of success. Success is almost inevitable. It requires cherry-picking to find examples of failure. The error that Procida and the homeopaths make is not cherry-picking. It is that they falsely attribute homeopathy as the cause of the success when in reality it merely serves as the marker. Arguing that they are cherry-picking is unpersuasive to them because they can see that they are not cherry-picking.

The real cherry-picking occurs before the homeopath (or Procida) even becomes involved. Nobody goes to visit a homeopath because they are doing well. Procida doesn't choose to treat herself or a friend when the symptoms have waned. It's just that that part of the process is almost invisible.

The process of attention and anchoring should lead to success almost all of the time, so you should not express any surprise at Procida's success rate. The problem with comparing that to the homeopath's casebook is that you considered all events, not just those events that would have been marked by the process. The process of marking an event is cherry-picking, but once the event is marked, it doesn't require cherry-picking to find success."

And as much as I appreciate double-blind placebo controlled trials, you should not undergo most surgeries because they haven't been tested that way. Yeah, there are lots of things that you believe and even respect that you learned without a double-blind trial. But heck, this isn't about anything except your beliefs, not real science.

Jaana did not say "double-blind placebo controlled trials". She appropriately said "evidence". Evidence-based medicine is about looking at all the available information and evaluating it in a balanced manner, including a recognition of the reliability of different kinds of information. Homeopathy involves ignoring the bulk of the available information in favour of information that is recognized as being highly unreliable. Highly unreliable information is of little interest to us, so continuing to promote your own personal collection, no matter how meticulously gathered, is absolutely pointless.

However, every post you make flogging your useless book serves as proof that you know of no actual cases where homeopathy cured someone. I find it very revealing that you are willing to admit this.

Linda
 
Mr. Monkey: The "name" of this forum does not have YOUR name on it nor what you think the mission of this forum is. Sorry.

HCN: Just because you say or write it doesn't mean it is so. Your critique of many of the studies to which I have referred were weak or simply wrong or inadequate. Saying that you "wrote" them previously doesn't make the critique stronger.

And your referral to Mr. Duck's review of my book is totally LOL...and it is certainly not an authoritative or accurate review of my book, but at least, he told a lot of people that this book is worthy enough for him to attack it.

I'm so sorry that you are offended that I am flogging my new book. Perhaps you prefer that people remain ignorant about homeopathy. Perhaps you prefer if people believe you just because you say it. Perhaps you're planning a book burning.

Linda: You're so right. Darwin was really really stupid...and the letters that he wrote about the events of his day were simply fabricated or the result of selective memory. He probably didn't really write those letters but were written by a ghostwriter (whooops, you don't believe in ghosts). Worse still, his symptoms weren't probably real, so if they went away, there is no "evidence" that they were there to begin with. Anyway, the fact that he had most of these symptoms for 12+ years means that they were "self-limiiting" anyway. The fact that Darwin was so sick that he couldn't attend his own father's funeral simply suggests that this was really psychosomatic and that he probably had conflicting feelings about his own father. After all, the only people that you can really trust (and neve say anything bad about) are the people on THIS list, except that James Gully guy.

As for cherry-picking, some of you have simply asked for one case of homeopathy providing clear evidence for a real benefit. The fact that you choose to ignore ALL of the clinical studies and the various laboratory studies and ignoring ALL of the evidence that I provide in my newest book simply shows that closing your eyes (and your minds) works as an effective way to not learn.

Things I'm still waiting for:
-- responses to what I just posted about James Manby Gully (without doubt or controversy: Darwin's favorite physician)
--critique of Elia's work on thermodynamics
--critique of the various Canova studies
-- explanation for why the study on fibromyalgia published in RHEUMATOLOGY found different EEG readings in the homeopathic group than in the placebo group...and an explanation for why this respected journal would publish this study if, as one of you said, there really wasn't any clinical differences in the results of treatment.
--explanation for why Shang's inclusion of only the large studies was a good "unbiased" way to evaluate efficacy of homeopathic medicines
-- explanation for why ALL double-blind and placebo controlled studies of 50-80 subjects that are published in conventional medical journals are of no value, are somehow inherently "biased," and should not even be compared with "matched" allopathic studies (isn't ANYONE on this list a bit curious why Shang and his gang specifically chose not to do the statistical analysis of the 21 high quality homeopathic studies and the 9 high quality allopathic ones? WHY, WHY, WHY. Oh...because they would show that homeopathic medicines work. Hmmmm.
--Some type of critique of hormesis and the 1,000+ studies by a wide variety of scientists. Now that the people on this list acknowledge that the field of hormesis strongly confirms the power of very small (but still material) doses of certain substances have significant effects, the vast majority of homeopathic medicines sold in health food stores today which have a similar level of material doses have become an integral part of your own health care. Thanx...

Mr. Duck doesn't want to talk about the Darwin thing anymore because he has been shown to be wrong (again), while the people on this list no longer want to respond in any substantative fashion but instead insist that they wrote about it previously (in an unconvincing fashion), so now, it must be true. Pigs do fly.
 
Mr. Duck doesn't want to talk about the Darwin thing anymore because he has been shown to be wrong (again), while the people on this list no longer want to respond in any substantative fashion but instead insist that they wrote about it previously (in an unconvincing fashion), so now, it must be true.

I don't know what planet you're living on, but on the one we like to call Earth, you're the only that's been proved wrong so far. Over and over again. On the same claims every time. Can't you at least pretend to come up with something new?

Just because you say or write it doesn't mean it is so.

You so owe me a new irony meter.
 
Mr Duck doesn't need to talk about the Darwin thing anymore. I just googled "homeopathic revolution" and guess what the top result was...

;)
 
Mr Ullman, I fear you are starting to look and sound just like the Black knight from Monty Python and the Holy Grail
 
Last edited:
Mr. Monkey: The "name" of this forum does not have YOUR name on it nor what you think the mission of this forum is. Sorry.

No it's simply a matter of good forum etiquette not to deliberately 'derail' discussion threads especially when that derailing is deliberately done with the intent of trying to misdirect its participants from the topic.

If you'd like to you can create your own thread called "Dana Ullman's Enthusiastic Self-Promotion and Advertising his Tedious and Error-laden Little Tract". Then you can discuss your book to your heart's content and no one will complain.

I'm so sorry that you are offended that I am flogging my new book. Perhaps you prefer that people remain ignorant about homeopathy. Perhaps you prefer if people believe you just because you say it. Perhaps you're planning a book burning.

No, a traditional book-burning would be inappropriate. Better that the book's contents are widely seen and held up to the ridicule they deserve. Clearly though it would be better if you made no money from it, although your parasitism of the homeopathic industry is no more than they deserve.

Perhaps you might consider donating the printed copies so they can be put to good use.


Mr. Monkey: The "name" of this forum does not have YOUR name on it nor what you think the mission of this forum is. Sorry.

Not sorry enough.

"The James Randi Educational Foundation is a not-for-profit organization founded in 1996. Its aim is to promote critical thinking by reaching out to the public and media with reliable information about paranormal and supernatural ideas so widespread in our society today."

Things I'm still waiting for:
-- responses to what I just posted about James Manby Gully (without doubt or controversy: Darwin's favorite physician)
--critique of Elia's work on thermodynamics
--critique of the various Canova studies
-- explanation for why the study on fibromyalgia published in RHEUMATOLOGY found different EEG readings in the homeopathic group than in the placebo group...and an explanation for why this respected journal would publish this study if, as one of you said, there really wasn't any clinical differences in the results of treatment.
--explanation for why Shang's inclusion of only the large studies was a good "unbiased" way to evaluate efficacy of homeopathic medicines
-- explanation for why ALL double-blind and placebo controlled studies of 50-80 subjects that are published in conventional medical journals are of no value, are somehow inherently "biased," and should not even be compared with "matched" allopathic studies (isn't ANYONE on this list a bit curious why Shang and his gang specifically chose not to do the statistical analysis of the 21 high quality homeopathic studies and the 9 high quality allopathic ones? WHY, WHY, WHY. Oh...because they would show that homeopathic medicines work. Hmmmm.
--Some type of critique of hormesis and the 1,000+ studies by a wide variety of scientists. Now that the people on this list acknowledge that the field of hormesis strongly confirms the power of very small (but still material) doses of certain substances have significant effects, the vast majority of homeopathic medicines sold in health food stores today which have a similar level of material doses have become an integral part of your own health care. Thanx...

Where to begin?

Oh, yes, here...

GIVE ONE, YOU ONLY NEED ONE, INCONTROVERTIBLE EXAMPLE, WITH REFERENCES, OF HOMEOPATHY CURING A NON-SELF-LIMITING CONDITION.

T = 25d 21h 32m 38s

By the way, I love it when you mention hormesis.

"However, hormesis can explain only a few aspects of homeopathy"

Of course, wishful-thinking, lies, deception, stupidity and cupidity can explain rather more.
 
p.s. I'll leave the rest to others if they can be bothered, but bringing up Elia again just makes it look like you have amnesia. I invested good money in obtaining that piece of trash research, you could have the plain decency to respond to the simple question you were asked. Dog ate your homeowork?
 
I'm so sorry that you are offended that I am flogging my new book. Perhaps you prefer that people remain ignorant about homeopathy. Perhaps you prefer if people believe you just because you say it. Perhaps you're planning a book burning.

Self-promotion is simply considered bad manners in this type of forum to the point where this behaviour, carried to an extreme, is prohibited. It was bad luck, I suppose, that led you to a forum where people are generally expected to behave in a civilized manner.

Otherwise, the people that flock here tend to be analytical and interested in accuracy, reliability and validity. You will notice that if we are not fed regularly, we begin to chew off our own limbs. You are doing us a service by providing a vertitable feast of inaccurate and invalid information. If you and the other homeopaths would consider drying up the supply, I'm sure you could find some entertainment watching us fight over the bones.

Linda: You're so right. Darwin was really really stupid...and the letters that he wrote about the events of his day were simply fabricated or the result of selective memory. He probably didn't really write those letters but were written by a ghostwriter (whooops, you don't believe in ghosts). Worse still, his symptoms weren't probably real, so if they went away, there is no "evidence" that they were there to begin with. Anyway, the fact that he had most of these symptoms for 12+ years means that they were "self-limiiting" anyway. The fact that Darwin was so sick that he couldn't attend his own father's funeral simply suggests that this was really psychosomatic and that he probably had conflicting feelings about his own father. After all, the only people that you can really trust (and neve say anything bad about) are the people on THIS list, except that James Gully guy.

You misunderstand. Really smart people, who are making a considered attempt to be truthful, are still unreliable when it comes to conveying certain types of information. It is not the mental capacity and/or motivations of the individuals which are at issue. It is that information garnered through superficial observation, recorded only in the memory, and transmitted through narrative is easily transformed and necessarily incomplete.

As for cherry-picking, some of you have simply asked for one case of homeopathy providing clear evidence for a real benefit. The fact that you choose to ignore ALL of the clinical studies and the various laboratory studies and ignoring ALL of the evidence that I provide in my newest book simply shows that closing your eyes (and your minds) works as an effective way to not learn.

But we didn't ignore them. We very carefully went through each example that you presented to us. None of them fulfilled the criteria, as none of them ruled-out other, more mundane reasons for benefit.

Things I'm still waiting for:
-- responses to what I just posted about James Manby Gully (without doubt or controversy: Darwin's favorite physician)

The details are inadequate to determine the presence and/or source of benefit.

--critique of Elia's work on thermodynamics

Irrelevant to the question specifically or homeopathy in general.

--critique of the various Canova studies

You haven't told us specifically what you're talking about.

-- explanation for why the study on fibromyalgia published in RHEUMATOLOGY found different EEG readings in the homeopathic group than in the placebo group...and an explanation for why this respected journal would publish this study if, as one of you said, there really wasn't any clinical differences in the results of treatment.

It doesn't matter that Rhematology was willing to publish the study with the erroneous conclusions of the authors left intact. It may be because the editors realize that what is important is that the results are available for analysis and that evidence-based medicine essentially ignores whatever spin the authors wish to put on the results, considering that they are likely to be biased.

Regardless of what you or the authors wish to pretend, the results that they published did not show a difference until after they started playing around with them. And while I haven't gone through the EEG study with a fine tooth comb, I notice that we are not given the actual EEG results. We are only given the results that have been "adjusted". Considering that the very same authors created a clinical difference through the use of adjustment, it would be prudent to suspect that the EEG differences were similarly manufactured.

--explanation for why Shang's inclusion of only the large studies was a good "unbiased" way to evaluate efficacy of homeopathic medicines

Because they demonstrated that the strongest indicator (by far) for the presence or absence of bias was study size.

-- explanation for why ALL double-blind and placebo controlled studies of 50-80 subjects that are published in conventional medical journals are of no value, are somehow inherently "biased," and should not even be compared with "matched" allopathic studies (isn't ANYONE on this list a bit curious why Shang and his gang specifically chose not to do the statistical analysis of the 21 high quality homeopathic studies and the 9 high quality allopathic ones? WHY, WHY, WHY. Oh...because they would show that homeopathic medicines work. Hmmmm.

Because between group differences will be due to bias, making any other conclusions foolish.

--Some type of critique of hormesis and the 1,000+ studies by a wide variety of scientists. Now that the people on this list acknowledge that the field of hormesis strongly confirms the power of very small (but still material) doses of certain substances have significant effects, the vast majority of homeopathic medicines sold in health food stores today which have a similar level of material doses have become an integral part of your own health care. Thanx...

Irrelevant to our concerns. That some of these medicines could work says nothing about whether they do work.

Linda
 
Jaana,
Darwin was a real person, and his case was a real case. The results are there. If you think that it was just "coincidence" that he got better, you are much more metaphysical than I am.
And as much as I appreciate double-blind placebo controlled trials, you should not undergo most surgeries because they haven't been tested that way. Yeah, there are lots of things that you believe and even respect that you learned without a double-blind trial. But heck, this isn't about anything except your beliefs, not real science.

Did you not read my words? I said that I do not give a damn one way or another about whether Darwin had a pet Homeopath or not. Your "surgery" argument is echoed & trumpeted across the homeopathic world. Is this your only argument against EBM? If so, it is incredibly weak. Please do not insult my intelligence.

Just answer the simple question the people of this thread have repeatedly asked of you.
 
Perhaps while we are waiting, we could amuse ourselves with our own stories of people who have recovered from non self limiting diseases with the help of non-homeopathic medicine. Just so Dana can see what we are asking for - he seems to need a litle help...

I'm afraid this will have to be undocumented as I am not a medical professional.

About 12 years ago, my mam started to feel ill. First of all there was loss of concentration and some tiredness. She got gradually weaker and weaker, couldn't climb stairs on her own, sometimes fainted when she stood up, felt cold all the time and had no appetite. She had to give up her college course and couldn't even help with planning my older sister's wedding. If you looked at my sisters wedding photos you would see her looking like a little old lady (although one with a strangely dark tan). Every week that went by she looked and felt worse. Eventually, after a lot of tests and a few blind alleys she was diagnosed with Addison's disease, was prescribed pills to replace the steroids she can't produce and is now fitter than ever. She has since done a nursing degree, works full time and regularly goes hiking up mountains! Without those pills, she would now be dead.

Got anything like that Dana?
 
Got anything like that Dana?


I think Addison's disease was one of Rolfe's favourite examples.
(not sure of cats change colour though)

But, no, homoeopathy would have zero effect, in the long run, on a case of Addison's disease.
The person would die. Period.

No, give them a long chronic illness with no firm diagnosis, variable symptoms, indeterminate outcome, and lots of psychological overload and homoeopathy will extract the usual placebo effect.
 
Last edited:
Another example:

At the age of eight, one of my brothers developed osteomyelitis in his right leg. He was unable to walk because of severe pain and he was immediately admitted to hospital and treated with intravenous antibiotics and surgical excision of dead bone and drainage of pus.

With homoeopathic treatment he would be dead.
Period.
 
Last edited:
Every day I personally see (and have hundreds of outpatients on my books) who, for the lack of orthodox medicine, would be dead. Some die nevertheless- that is life. We constantly strive to improve survival, but not by throwing magic water at them.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom