EU finally designates Hezbollah a terrorist organization.

Yes, there seems to be a case of: If you support democracy then you must support a democratically elected government when it decides to invade Poland.

Logic fail 101.

You could even avoid the Godwin by saying, "If you support democracy you must support a democratically elected government when it decides to dissolve any future form of democratic elections." I.e., where Morsi was heading.
 
Pretty hard to present such evidence when you pull the age-old semantics card of re-branding all terrorism to "resistance fighting" :rolleyes:.
I'm not. I'm treating what Hezbollah did to the IDF in Southern Lebanon as resistance. That's all. Bus bombings are terrorism.
It's like a bad Monty Python skit:
Classic FAIL.

ETAA statement for which you have provided zero evidence other than "but they decided so quickly!!".
The evidence is in the fact that they do accuse Hezbollah automatically of any terrorist incident they remotely can (plausibly or not). They don't do this because they have investigated, since they do it within hours. Ergo Israeli accusations are not evidence. That's my position.
 
Again: I think there's some part of the concept of "innocent civilians" that is lost on you. Yes, I can indeed call Hezbollah terrorists when they bomb and fire rockets upon innocent bystanders, the same way I can call you a bank robber if you robbed a bank.
So you can, and you can call the bombers of Dresden terrorists, and the Israelis when they're bombing and shelling Lebanese cities and villages. None of it's what any of us would want, but the situation is what it is. The Israelis bombed Beirut and shelled Southern Lebanon, and Hezbollah fired back.

An innocent civilian is an innocent civilian, be it a youth politician killed at a summer camp, a Manhattan office worker killed by a hijacked plane, or an Israeli child killed by a rocket attack as she is having supper in her house.
Or even Lebanese civilians.

Why innocents are murdered, or what is gained by their deaths, is immaterial -- what matters is that they are not combatants, and thus should not be deliberately harmed.
It's easy for us to sit in safety and make judgements, but it's not so easy when you're in a conflict. Dresden was bombed to kill civilians and keep Stalin happy, and I'm glad I didn't have to make that call. I'm not going to condemn it now.

I do condemn Israeli bombing and shelling of civilians, which was something they did repeatedly during the occupation and after. You'll have seen that they'd been hitting "Hezbullah installations" in response to Hezbullah terrorism against the IDF in Lebanon, but as was proved in 2006 the IDF had no idea where those installations actually were.

Hezbollah responded in kind, and I don't see why they should be held to a higher standard than the people shelling them. They gave fair warning.

I suppose just admitting that "yes, of course Hezbollah is a terrorist organization, but I support that wholeheartedly" would require more bravery than you can muster.
Clearly evidence that Hezbullah is a terrorist organisation eludes you, but you hold it as an article of faith.
 
So Middle Eastern Holocaust Deniers are actually "more advanced" because their denial of objective historical fact indicates that they are "not placing Europeans and what they did to European Jews at the centre of things". By implication, non-Holocaust deniers in the ME are actually primitive in comparison; stuck as they are in Eurocentric darkness.
Most non-Holocaust deniers have never heard of the Holocaust. Your false assumption that everybody must have heard of it is what underlies your implication.

So no, that isn't the implication. There is a particular issue with Eurocentrism because Europeans (or Westerners, which is essentially the same thing) have been top dogs recently.

Regarding objective historical fact, the naqba is such a fact and very visible in Israel's neighbours, such as Lebanon. An historical fact of life, even. When they see this being denied by Zionists why should they believe them about the Holocaust? Just how carefuly do you examine things beyond hearing something you like - such as Hezbullah being a terrorist organisation?

Racism and willful ignorance indicating an "advanced" and sophisticated mind.
Well, that's a new one.
Another FAIL I'm afraid, due to your false assumption.
 
Another very predictable dodge ("he's got a point there... quick, say somethign about the 'zionists'!").
You dodged my point.

You say it's highly important to understand the people you live with, which is a very reasonable opinion. Zionists never saw it that way, any more than 99% of Europeans did in the early 20thCE. Not ideal, you'll agree, and we can see the result now.

This is objective historical fact; nobody found racism embarrassing at the time, and and there's a mass of newspapers, pamphlets, books, speeches and Zionist Congress proceedings available if you care to look. Try searching out any mention of the natives. The only time current inhabitants are discussed it's the British colonists already in Kenya who, it was felt, deserved consideration as fellow white people.

The implications of this, hardly more than a century ago, can not be ignored. What other outcome do you imagine could have emerged if not the continuing conflict? It's not as if people didn't predict it.

How much effort do you imagine Israelis today are putting into understanding their neighbours? They made no effort during their Lebanese occupation, but then the usual Israeli experience is that occupied people soon move o so why bother?

And nothing. War is Hell, and re-working Augustine isn't going to change that. Since 2006 all has been quiet on the Blue Line, which is a good thing for all concerned. Let's hope it stays that way.
 
Yes, there seems to be a case of: If you support democracy then you must support a democratically elected government when it decides to invade Poland.
The Nazi government wasn't democratically elected, it staged a putsch after the Rechstag Fire. When the Nazis invaded Poland Britain and France declared war on Germany. Sadly the US thought better of it; their assistance would have been invaluable. So it goes.

Logic fail 101.
Information fail. This is basic 20thCE European History, in which the Holocaust definitely was a defining moment. We boomers grew up in the shadow of it; our parents saw the newsreels and the touring exhibitions, the soldiers coming home brought their tales. Europe was in a state of shock for decades.

I will touch on the personal to say that I am grossly offended by the way some Israelis reach for the Holocaust as their first rhetorical device. I don't think Israelis understand it as viscerally as we older Europeans do, but it was distant from them and they had their own war of conquest to prepare for.
 
I'm not. I'm treating what Hezbollah did to the IDF in Southern Lebanon as resistance. That's all. Bus bombings are terrorism.
Classic FAIL.
What about combatants disguising themselves as civilians and operating out of civilian areas?
 
I will touch on the personal to say that I am grossly offended by the way some Israelis reach for the Holocaust as their first rhetorical device. I don't think Israelis understand it as viscerally as we older Europeans do

ha ha, wait... seriously?
 
You dodged my point.
What?! Try the other way around. Let's recap, shall we?

We were discussing Hezbollah's Holocaust denial, and you made it clear you didn't think this was a big deal. I then said that surely it is an important point, given that the Lebanese are after all the neighbours of the Israelis, and that it is paramount that you understand the background and situation of the people you live next to and interact with.

Then you changed the topic of the conversation from Hezbollah's Holocaust denial to "Zionists" and Jewish atrocities, which no one had mentioned with a word up until then, and which weren't at all what we were talking about. Then, when I reacted to this, you for some reason accused me of downplaying the events of 1948:confused:.
 
I will touch on the personal to say that I am grossly offended by the way some Israelis reach for the Holocaust as their first rhetorical device. I don't think Israelis understand it as viscerally as we older Europeans do

T1zr7.gif
 
The strangest thing is, I virtually never hear of "Zionists" using the Holocaust as a rhetorical device.
I do, however, very often hear of their detractors using Zionists who use the Holocaust as a rhetorical device as a rhetorical device.
There seems to be a disrepancy here.
 
The problem with Anti Zionists is that horse left the barn about 70 Years ago. Whether or not the creation of Israel was a good ,bad,or indifferent idea is sort of irrevelent. It is here,and Five Million Isrealis don't show any signs of wanting to move elsewhere.
 
Hezbollah has engaged in numerous terrorist acts at home and abroad. I don't see what the issue is besides just being a supporter.


Who else would blow up the lead investigator in a car bomb who was investigating Hezbollah members for the implicated blowing up of prime minister Hariri in a car bomb?

Recorded telephone conversations, telephone use locations of the implicated Hezbollah members, and physical evidence, remove any doubt that there would be any plausible perpetrators of the assassination besides Hezbollah.

Just another act added to the long list of terrorist acts committed by Hezbollah. The only issue is whether you support the group, and their actions or not.
 
Most non-Holocaust deniers have never heard of the Holocaust.

You're under the impression that most Middle Easterners who don't subscribe to Holocaust denial have never heard of the Holocaust?

I'm curious, exactly which toxic pool of ignorance provided you with this idiotic gem?

Another FAIL I'm afraid, due to your false assumption.

My false assumption that most non-Israeli ME residents have heard of the Holocaust?
Maybe if you simply repeat the word "fail" enough times, readers won't notice this drivel. But I doubt it.

I will touch on the personal to say that I am grossly offended by the way some Israelis reach for the Holocaust as their first rhetorical device. I don't think Israelis understand it as viscerally as we older Europeans do, but it was distant from them and they had their own war of conquest to prepare for.

After you finish explaining the Holocaust to Israeli Jews, maybe you can move on to educating African Americans on chattel slavery. I hear they really appreciate pompous lectures from "grossly offended" pretentious white guys.
 
Just a small point: this thread is about Hezbollah, and their finally being correctly recognized in the EU as a terrorist organization, not the Holocaust. Can be get back on topic?

Hezbollah has gone after more folks than Jews in their efforts to do their thing.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom