Those Arab armies actually captured many Jews and didn't kill them. The Arab states (which had gained their independence shortly) did not oppose the creation of Israel in order to kill all the Jews. They did so because they lacked legitimacy (being the groomed successors of the European powers) and the Arab public regarded Israel as a tool of Imperialists, particularly the US.
That's a common conspiracy theory among Arabs now, but can you document that it was widely believed back in the '30's and '40's?
...Which is understandable. Jews in the Middle East are as old and familiar as Noah, and however incompetent you think Arabs are they would have killed them long before Herzl got the secular Zionist movement going in 1897, let alone before any Zionists actually visited the region.
Where do you get this straw-man that Arabs have always been genocidal towards Jews? Nobody is claiming that.
If Arabs have become genocidal anti-semites since the foundation of the World Zionist Organisation (and they clearly weren't before, given all the Jews that were in the Middle East at that time) then the implications of that are something to think about.
Yes, let's take a moment to think about how awful those Zionist Jews were. So if someone wants to kill them, they kinda have it coming, don't you think?
That seems to be what you're arguing.
I've heard similar arguments made by Holocaust deniers. Jews were waging "economic warfare" against Germany, so if they were rounded up and put in camps, they kinda had it coming. Didn't they?
It would suggest that Zionism created genocidal anti-semitism in the Middle East, presumably through the behaviour of the Zionists.
So when those Jews get uppity, normal people just can't help but want to kill them.
And no, I'm not accusing you of being racist.
You're clearly distinguishing between the "good Jews" and the "bad Jews". The bad ones are the ones that want things like self-determination and safety, and who take steps to change the way of things so they might have it. The good ones are the ones that keep to themselves, don't bother anyone, and just accept and endure whatever happens to them.
Haj Amin didn't organise a division of Muslim troops in Bosnia, he was shipped off there to recruit for an existing unit which was used in anti-Partisan fighting. It played no part in killing the Jews because the Serbs and Croats had already done that before they turned to finishing off the Muslims (and each other, of course).
I guess the message here is there literally is no degree of anti-Semitism from Arabs you will not hand-wave away. Holocaust denial, genocidal warfare, and now literally joining the Waffen SS.
Waffen SS were not merely German soldiers, they were the armed wing of the Nazi party. You can't distance them from the ideals of the political party they literally signed up to fight and possibly die for. I can't see that it matters that this unit never got the opportunity to kill Jews outright when they joined the military wing of
another nations political party that had killing Jews as a fundamental part of their party platform.
The levels of denial exhibited in your argument is just breath-taking.
Haj Amin was from a local Palestinian family of some minor influence; when the British turned up he persuaded them he was a man who could look after their interests, and they appointed him Grand Mufti (a title, a salary, nothing else : a very Ottoman institution). He was a political chancer with an eye to the future and saw that the increasing Zionist presence after the Balfour declaration and their behaviour was building a constituency for someone and he went for it. His inablity to organise anything is rather obvious from his long career as a failure.
Sure, he joined the Nazi's, became their propaganda puppet, recruited for them, urged Himmler to kill Jews in even greater numbers...but that's nothing that can't be hand-waved away. Just attribute it all to the lesser evils of opportunism and incompetence.
After the outbreak of WW2 Haj Amin approached the German Forein Ministry with the idea of an Arab uprising against the British, which the FO liked but the Nazis slapped down immediately. Inferior races rebelling against their white overlords were not on their agenda at all, under any circumstances. The FO found themselves with a spare Arab on their hands until someone suggested Sarajevo and he was packed off there.
Nice story. Let's see you back it up.
So no, the Muslims had nothing to with the Holocaust, which happened in Europe. The Nazis would be infuriated at the suggestion, as well as at the idea that an Arab would be allowed to organise any part of the quasi-mythical Aryan Champions that was (and, in many Austrian homes, still is) the SS.
Right. Except that portion that they did organize. You know, that part we've been talking about.
I've watched the growth of the Haj Amin myth over the last few decades with some interest. If I reach my three-score-and-ten I expect to hear he was at the Wannsee Conference, perhaps chaired it, and may well have inspired the whole plan, after which they all had a beer and took him to a brothel where he could impregnate some German women. OK, maybe not all of that, but definitely some.
Spoken as though you knew Haj Amin personally. What is this "argument from personal recollection" nonsense? Bring some facts to the table or admit you have none. Nobody is fooled.
Haj Amin is only remembered because something's needed to keep opposition to Israel connected to the Holocaust, and, of course, it isn't. Israel was a process set in motion long before that, and not in order to save Jews from genocidal anti-semitism.
I like the way you simultaneously hold Zionists responsible for the future by labeling it (in hindsight) "inevitable", then turn around and complain they couldn't possibly have known the future, that European anti-Semitism would become genocidal. You want to have your cake and eat it too.
Zionism certainly was a response to anti-Semitism. That it hadn't yet become genocidal is immaterial. Only a very twisted mind would dismiss the motivating influence of European anti-Semitism altogether simply because they didn't yet know how bad it would ultimately get.
It is meant to save Jews from miscegenation through assimilation, leading to the end of the pure-bred Jewish race. Only in modern times has that become an embarrassment, ...
Wrong on so many levels, wrongs compounding other wrongs, it's hard to know where to begin.
First, I'll point out the hypocrisy of anti-Zionists who constantly complain when
pro-Zionists suggest that many anti-Zionists are motivated by racism, themselves have no problem suggesting that all Zionist are themselves racist. All of them. I'm sure the irony is lost on you.
Second, it's just not true. Far from creating a haven against assimilation and "miscegenation", Zionism was founded by people at the
forefront of assimilation. They were secular Jews. They were people who
didn't hide themselves away in insular communities. They participated in the world, did their part to shape it and were shaped by it. They did this by choice, knowing it would lead their children to do the same.
Theodore Herzl, a secular Jew, refused to have his son circumcised and purposefully raised him non-religiously. That son, Hans Herzl, grew up and converted to Christianity.
David Ben-Gurion, not particularly religious, was fundamental in establishing the non-theocratic nature of Israel that protected the religious freedoms of everyone. His son, Amos, married a non-Jewish Irish woman. He had Dad's blessing in doing it, too.
Your untruth goes above and beyond simply being wrong. It's a purposeful slander. Amazingly, you even described Zionism as a secular movement earlier in this very post, so we know you know better.
...hence the attempt to keep minds away from the whole story. Just the 40's, and always get Israel and the Holocaust into the same sentence if even remotely possible. And these days make sure to say "Muslims" not "Arabs", to make US Americans shudder.
Or frame that story by suggesting any anti-Semitic meme you can think of. Jews consider themselves a master race? Check. Jews talk about the Holocaust and make accusations of anti-Semitism to gain advantage? Check. Blame the Jews themselves for hatred and violence directed against them? Check. I could go on, but as I said before, nobody has time to shoot every duck in the flock.