EU finally designates Hezbollah a terrorist organization.

Meanwhile Israel the Apartheid state continues its program of extermination of the Arab people.

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/b/bc/Population_of_Israel.png

Or something.
You wish. Nobody, as far as I know, ever suggested killing the Arab population of Palestine. Some would have to be killed, obviously, they're not going to go without a fight after all (who would?), but only enough to get the rest on their feet. Then you just have to chivvy them along until they're out of your hair and somebody else's problem. As was done, you may recall.

What exactly constitutes Israel for the purposes of the graph, who counts as the population, and why does it start in 1950? If you don't mind me asking. A lot has happened on the ground since 1950, after all.

If I was an Israeli Arab I would be very worried by that graph. Where does it become a problem? 20% Muslim? 25%? Looking at that trajectory it must inevitably end with the extinction of the Jewish State unless something is done about it, and I seem to recall there are elected Israeli politicians saying exactly that. Such talk is always dangerous to an alien minority (which, to many Jewish Israelis, is what they are) in unsettled political climates. Add to that the genocidally anti-Muslim propaganda one can find on the internet which an array of political chancers might well choose to exploit and keeping a bag packed and your capital abroad is to be advised.

On the positive side, Israeli Arabs don't have much capital sunk into land or property. That became state property back in 1949, and their opportunities to buy more have been rather constrained since.
 
While pretending that "Zionist" is just a code word for "Jew".
Irritating, I know : fail to distinguish between Jews and Zionists and be called an anti-semite, make the distinction and be called a coded anti-semite. Opposition to Zionism, and its product Israel, which is not based on anti-semitism is believed to be inconceivable. So it goes.

(You'd think at least the outrageous way Zionists treated Palestinian Jews would be worth examining, but no.)

Evidence for Hezbullah as a terrorist organisation has not materialised anywhere I've looked recently, but to be honest there are more interesting things going on. The talks, for instance (which I'm not going to be so daft as to comment on before 2015 at least, when they'll be long over one way or another). And Turkey. Also Egypt. Not so much Syria, though, which is becoming a stalemate like the Lebanese Civil War or the Western Front.

Interesting times.
 
Okay, duck hunting time. Remember, cant shoot 'em all, there is just too many.



It is, of course, inevitable that the Holocaust will be brought into any discussion involving Israel and its environs, relevant or not.

That is called, "poisoning the well", and you are talented at it.

The times it has, and the people it happened to, are what are most evident to Israel's neighbours.

What, exactly? You know you're responding to Safe-Keeper telling you you're wrong about the Holocaust being brought up in every conversation. I'll go a step further and say it's not relevant. It's repugnant of you to imply that if it were brought up it would be somehow inappropriate or even gauche of the person who brought it up.

As to those who remain on their land they would have included the last of the Bedouin a few years ago, and a many thousands on the West Bank, but the list gets that much shorter all the time.

Oh, portray Israelis as land-stealers. But don't say it outright, just imply it. If you say it outright someone might ask you to prove it, and then you have a messy argument on your hands instead of a clever jape.


As to the Arabs in Israel proper, so to speak, not every Zionist ever accepted anything less than a racially pure Jewish state and not every Israeli does either. The religio-nationalist settlers, for instance. The future of Arabs in Israel (or on any land they take) is highly insecure; perhaps if they were Jewish you might be able to empathise. They'd be foolish not to keep a bag packed.

I love that "not every" dodge. Not every US citizen has refrained from eating human flesh.

Does that sound like a fair representation of USians tendencies towards cannibalism? It's literally accurate, so that's all I would have to defend. Jeffery Dahmer was born in the USA, right? Case closed! Except it implies cannibalism is pretty widespread, and even people who aren't cannibals gave it enough consideration that they had to "refrain".

Brilliant.


Despite some bizarre beliefs, such as the Arabs handing over their property to the Jews voluntarily...

You had a great line, how did it go..? "That's what strawmen always are. That's their point." Even if I disagree with you, you do have a way with words that is admirable. I'm totally stealing that line from you someday.


I'll use it right now. Your straw-man is silly, but that's the point. I get it.

it was always a requirement of Zionism that a very substantial part of the existing population would have to leave.

This is just ugly. The foundational documents of Israel, the Balfour declaration, the Israeli Declaration of Independence, the Israeli Basic Law...all speak of protecting the rights of all inhabitants and of different peoples living together in peace. What you're asserting as truth is the projection of your own biases.





Whatever a Jewish State actually is it would surely have to have a large Jewish majority, and the Zionists carefully calculated how many people the land could sustain. It was nowhere near enough to create a majority by addition. So there are two options : abandon the project or evict a large part of the population. Since the population weren't even white, let alone Jewish, out they had to go, and sure enough out they went.

I can't look at this without smiling. You've literally got a Zionist conspiracy theory here. Congratulations! :D


Inevitable. The conflict in Palestine was caused by thousands of Ashkenazis turning up with the stated intention of taking the place for themselves, and blaming it on the inhabitants for not complying (as seems to be happening here) is deeply strange. Israel didn't just happen, it was made to happen. Israel has no qualms about stealing people's land and everybody knows it.

Just so we don't think you don't like all Jews, be sure to identify the sub-set you think are the really bad ones.

That's what "settlement expansion" means - they're not just building higher, they're expanding into other people's land.

Yeah, except when it doesn't. This meme that every inch of land East of the Green Line belongs to some Palestinian and that stepping on it bumps him off... It's land, and land everywhere is bought and sold and taxed and measured, and recorded at the local court-house or title office, and a bunch of it defaults to the government, and developers get to work up huge swaths of it for fun and profit.
 
Irritating, I know : fail to distinguish between Jews and Zionists and be called an anti-semite, make the distinction and be called a coded anti-semite. Opposition to Zionism, and its product Israel, which is not based on anti-semitism is believed to be inconceivable. So it goes.

Yeah bro. That's why you've been going on about the difference between good and bad Holocaust deniers for four pages.


Evidence for Hezbullah as a terrorist organisation has not materialised anywhere I've looked recently, but to be honest there are more interesting things going on. The talks, for instance (which I'm not going to be so daft as to comment on before 2015 at least, when they'll be long over one way or another). And Turkey. Also Egypt. Not so much Syria, though, which is becoming a stalemate like the Lebanese Civil War or the Western Front.

Interesting times.

Key words highlighted. You won't see much if you shut your eyes and put your fingers in your ears like the truwfers do.
 
If I was an Israeli Arab I would be very worried by that graph. Where does it become a problem? 20% Muslim? 25%?
A problem to whom? Your strawman Lebensraum Zionist?

Looking at that trajectory it must inevitably end with the extinction of the Jewish State unless something is done about it, and I seem to recall there are elected Israeli politicians saying exactly that.
As in Norway, Sweden, Germany, the UK, and any other country on the planet with a significant and/or rising immigrant population. Your point?

You said:
Me said:
Yes. This is what inevitably and automatically happen when Israelis come. That's a very fair and objective depiction there:rolleyes:.
It is.
Wow.

eta
You wish. Nobody, as far as I know, ever suggested killing the Arab population of Palestine.
...I didn't say anything about killing...:confused:
eta2 uhm, yes, I did, though it should've been obvious to anyone I didn't mean it litterally :p.
 
Last edited:
Those Arab armies actually captured many Jews and didn't kill them. The Arab states (which had gained their independence shortly) did not oppose the creation of Israel in order to kill all the Jews. They did so because they lacked legitimacy (being the groomed successors of the European powers) and the Arab public regarded Israel as a tool of Imperialists, particularly the US.

That's a common conspiracy theory among Arabs now, but can you document that it was widely believed back in the '30's and '40's?

...Which is understandable. Jews in the Middle East are as old and familiar as Noah, and however incompetent you think Arabs are they would have killed them long before Herzl got the secular Zionist movement going in 1897, let alone before any Zionists actually visited the region.

Where do you get this straw-man that Arabs have always been genocidal towards Jews? Nobody is claiming that.

If Arabs have become genocidal anti-semites since the foundation of the World Zionist Organisation (and they clearly weren't before, given all the Jews that were in the Middle East at that time) then the implications of that are something to think about.

Yes, let's take a moment to think about how awful those Zionist Jews were. So if someone wants to kill them, they kinda have it coming, don't you think?

That seems to be what you're arguing.

I've heard similar arguments made by Holocaust deniers. Jews were waging "economic warfare" against Germany, so if they were rounded up and put in camps, they kinda had it coming. Didn't they?

It would suggest that Zionism created genocidal anti-semitism in the Middle East, presumably through the behaviour of the Zionists.

So when those Jews get uppity, normal people just can't help but want to kill them.

And no, I'm not accusing you of being racist. You're clearly distinguishing between the "good Jews" and the "bad Jews". The bad ones are the ones that want things like self-determination and safety, and who take steps to change the way of things so they might have it. The good ones are the ones that keep to themselves, don't bother anyone, and just accept and endure whatever happens to them.

Haj Amin didn't organise a division of Muslim troops in Bosnia, he was shipped off there to recruit for an existing unit which was used in anti-Partisan fighting. It played no part in killing the Jews because the Serbs and Croats had already done that before they turned to finishing off the Muslims (and each other, of course).

I guess the message here is there literally is no degree of anti-Semitism from Arabs you will not hand-wave away. Holocaust denial, genocidal warfare, and now literally joining the Waffen SS.

Waffen SS were not merely German soldiers, they were the armed wing of the Nazi party. You can't distance them from the ideals of the political party they literally signed up to fight and possibly die for. I can't see that it matters that this unit never got the opportunity to kill Jews outright when they joined the military wing of another nations political party that had killing Jews as a fundamental part of their party platform.

The levels of denial exhibited in your argument is just breath-taking.

Haj Amin was from a local Palestinian family of some minor influence; when the British turned up he persuaded them he was a man who could look after their interests, and they appointed him Grand Mufti (a title, a salary, nothing else : a very Ottoman institution). He was a political chancer with an eye to the future and saw that the increasing Zionist presence after the Balfour declaration and their behaviour was building a constituency for someone and he went for it. His inablity to organise anything is rather obvious from his long career as a failure.

Sure, he joined the Nazi's, became their propaganda puppet, recruited for them, urged Himmler to kill Jews in even greater numbers...but that's nothing that can't be hand-waved away. Just attribute it all to the lesser evils of opportunism and incompetence. :oldroll:

After the outbreak of WW2 Haj Amin approached the German Forein Ministry with the idea of an Arab uprising against the British, which the FO liked but the Nazis slapped down immediately. Inferior races rebelling against their white overlords were not on their agenda at all, under any circumstances. The FO found themselves with a spare Arab on their hands until someone suggested Sarajevo and he was packed off there.

Nice story. Let's see you back it up.

So no, the Muslims had nothing to with the Holocaust, which happened in Europe. The Nazis would be infuriated at the suggestion, as well as at the idea that an Arab would be allowed to organise any part of the quasi-mythical Aryan Champions that was (and, in many Austrian homes, still is) the SS.

Right. Except that portion that they did organize. You know, that part we've been talking about.

I've watched the growth of the Haj Amin myth over the last few decades with some interest. If I reach my three-score-and-ten I expect to hear he was at the Wannsee Conference, perhaps chaired it, and may well have inspired the whole plan, after which they all had a beer and took him to a brothel where he could impregnate some German women. OK, maybe not all of that, but definitely some.

Spoken as though you knew Haj Amin personally. What is this "argument from personal recollection" nonsense? Bring some facts to the table or admit you have none. Nobody is fooled.

Haj Amin is only remembered because something's needed to keep opposition to Israel connected to the Holocaust, and, of course, it isn't. Israel was a process set in motion long before that, and not in order to save Jews from genocidal anti-semitism.

I like the way you simultaneously hold Zionists responsible for the future by labeling it (in hindsight) "inevitable", then turn around and complain they couldn't possibly have known the future, that European anti-Semitism would become genocidal. You want to have your cake and eat it too.

Zionism certainly was a response to anti-Semitism. That it hadn't yet become genocidal is immaterial. Only a very twisted mind would dismiss the motivating influence of European anti-Semitism altogether simply because they didn't yet know how bad it would ultimately get.

It is meant to save Jews from miscegenation through assimilation, leading to the end of the pure-bred Jewish race. Only in modern times has that become an embarrassment, ...

Wrong on so many levels, wrongs compounding other wrongs, it's hard to know where to begin.

First, I'll point out the hypocrisy of anti-Zionists who constantly complain when pro-Zionists suggest that many anti-Zionists are motivated by racism, themselves have no problem suggesting that all Zionist are themselves racist. All of them. I'm sure the irony is lost on you.

Second, it's just not true. Far from creating a haven against assimilation and "miscegenation", Zionism was founded by people at the forefront of assimilation. They were secular Jews. They were people who didn't hide themselves away in insular communities. They participated in the world, did their part to shape it and were shaped by it. They did this by choice, knowing it would lead their children to do the same.

Theodore Herzl, a secular Jew, refused to have his son circumcised and purposefully raised him non-religiously. That son, Hans Herzl, grew up and converted to Christianity.

David Ben-Gurion, not particularly religious, was fundamental in establishing the non-theocratic nature of Israel that protected the religious freedoms of everyone. His son, Amos, married a non-Jewish Irish woman. He had Dad's blessing in doing it, too.

Your untruth goes above and beyond simply being wrong. It's a purposeful slander. Amazingly, you even described Zionism as a secular movement earlier in this very post, so we know you know better.

...hence the attempt to keep minds away from the whole story. Just the 40's, and always get Israel and the Holocaust into the same sentence if even remotely possible. And these days make sure to say "Muslims" not "Arabs", to make US Americans shudder.

Or frame that story by suggesting any anti-Semitic meme you can think of. Jews consider themselves a master race? Check. Jews talk about the Holocaust and make accusations of anti-Semitism to gain advantage? Check. Blame the Jews themselves for hatred and violence directed against them? Check. I could go on, but as I said before, nobody has time to shoot every duck in the flock.
 
Hezbollah yes has a militant wing but they also give food and medicines to refugees and other needy peoples.
 
It is good that EU did this soon before saing they will no do business and work with the illegal zionist settlements.
 
We've already been through this. There is no meaningful distinction between the military and political wing of Hezbollah. Even Hezbollah itself is clear on this. I don't think Virus' analogy was meant to imply Hezbollah is as bad as the Nazis (which would take a lot;)), but that every organization has both a military and political (and/or humanitarian) wing, even the most horrific mass murderers in human history.
 
Hezbollah yes has a militant wing but they also give food and medicines to refugees and other needy peoples.

In choosing to support humanitarian organizations, it's best to choose those that do not have "militant wings".

The idea is to discourage barbaric and thuggish behavior. So even if it were true that Hezbollah had different "wings", and it it not, the existence of a militant wing should disqualify it from receiving any kind of foreign aid. That aid should go to a different organization that does not have a "militant wing", and if one cannot be found, one can be created.

Imagine for a moment if the Salvation Army had a "militant wing" that sometimes carried out bus bombings or fired rockets into populated areas. Would you make excuses for that just because they also ran soup kitchens and homeless shelters? Or would you shift your support to another agency that only ran soup kitchens and homeless shelters, and promise the Salvation Army to resume your support when they dismantled their military wing?

Choosing the second option not only allows your aid to help people in need, but you also leverage that aid to reduce the violence. It's a win-win.
 
Thanks, I'm flattered. :)

It's my opinion that those who promote this false distinction in Hezbollah (and Hamas and probably the IRA and possibly other organizations as well) are simply looking for a loophole that allows them to deal with, support, and legitimize causes they agree with. I believe they're fine with the "militancy" aspect, though they will keep up appearances by feigning reluctance.
 
True, to an extent. However, there's a difference here.

If an Israeli national kills a Palestinian, he is arrested, condemned and probably sentenced to jailtime. You also won't find people here who support him or make ridiculous excuses for him. I, for one, find terrorism a vile "tactic" regardless of who it kills, or why, and that of course Israel, as other militaries, should follow internationally recognized rules of engagement, as indeed they tend to do, and do well (they kill fewer civilians per military dead than does NATO, for example).

There are, however, plenty of posters here ready to defend both deranged individuals and organizations such as Hezbollah and HAMAS. There are several who are crystal clear on their support for terrorism, one of whom has posted frequently in this thread. Another has gone as far, in a different thread, as to call our outrage at the murder of civilians "whining".

Should an Israeli shoot to death an Arab in cold blood, he would be arrested, condemned, and probably given a lengthy prison sentence. Was he to fire a rocket into a Palestinian apartment block, or even into empty desert in Palestinian territory, you would certainly find no one here who would support such an act.

Should a Palestinian in Gaza do the same to an Israeli, however, he would be lauded as a hero by his government, media and people and given the monetary reward that the Palestinian authorties award to anyone who kills Jews. Then the usual suspects on this forum would explain to us how he was "just defending his country" or that the Israelis had it coming. Even your own first post seemed very reluctant, for some reason to condemn Hezbollah, even though it is a known terrorist organization. I wonder if you would be as hesistant, or come up with any excuses, had it been a faction elsewhere in the world, killing other people than Israelis.

One side has a minority of extremists, which it condemns.
The other side has a minority of extremists, organized and encouraged at governmental level.
Who are you with?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom