EU finally designates Hezbollah a terrorist organization.

Just a small point: this thread is about Hezbollah, and their finally being correctly recognized in the EU as a terrorist organization, not the Holocaust. Can be get back on topic?
Hezbollah's beliefs, including extreme anti-Semitism, which lead them to commit terrorist acts is certainly relevant to this thread.
 
What?! Try the other way around. Let's recap, shall we?

We were discussing Hezbollah's Holocaust denial, and you made it clear you didn't think this was a big deal.
Holocaust denial isn't evidence of terrorism. The Holocaust itself was nothing to with the Middle East. Holocaust denial itself only became an issue after a some Europeans had the smart idea of having a conference in Iran - something they'd have no chance of holding in Europe. Ahmedinejad, a self-basting small-town ignoramus, fell for the whole thing. That was only a few years ago, and is of no real significance.

The only reason the Holocaust has come into this at all is that it always does when the subject turns to Israel and its environs.

I then said that surely it is an important point, given that the Lebanese are after all

the neighbours of the Israelis, and that it is paramount that you understand the background and

situation of the people you live next to and interact with.
It would seem to me arrogant not to, especially if I was the one moving in.

Then you changed the topic of the conversation from Hezbollah's Holocaust denial to

"Zionists" and Jewish atrocities ...
I made no mention of atrocities. I pointed out that the Zionists utterly neglected something you think of as of paramount importance. It's hardly surprising thing haven't turned out well, is it? Nothing to do with Holocaust denial, or the fact that the immigrants were Jewish. They were arrogant Europeans who trod on everybody's toes without a care, and that was before things got really nasty.

... which no one had mentioned with a word up until then, and which weren't at all what we were talking about. Then, when I reacted to this, you for some reason accused me of downplaying the events of 1948.
The events of 1948 are extremely relevant in what we're talking about, which is the nature of Hezbollah. Everyone around Israel has lived with the consequences to some extent or other, and they've seen what happens to people after the Israelis come. They end up living in camps, strangers in a strange land, never to go home again, to be pitied but strangers all the same. In Lebanon, already an ethnic balancing act, they were the last thing anybody needed, and that was before the PLO was forced out of Jordan and shunted into Lebanon by the Syrians. By the time the Israelis invaded in 1982 the Southern Lebanese and PLO were in open warfare.

Had it not been for the events of 1948, or the plans of the Zionists from the 1890's on, none of that would have happened. The Palestinians would still be in Palestine. The Holocaust would still have happened. The "Jewish Experience" of the Zonists is the Ashkenazi experience, but they were completely deaf to that idea and found Middle Eastern Jews to be very confused about their own historical experience. They also found them mired in religion, and looked forward to bringing them the benefits of European Enlightenment. However unwelcome it might be.

When the Israelis invaded Lebanon in 1982 they were initially welcomed by the Southern Lebanese Shia (whose main militia was then Amal) as they saw off the PLO to Tunisia in short order. When the Israelis were still there a year or two later it didn't arouse too much concern. After a few years things started to look familiar. After five there was no doubt left. Do something or end up like the Palestinans, and nobody wants to end up like those losers.

Amal was too implicated and corrupt for the job by then, hence the emergence of Hezbullah. (For those who might think otherwise, Hezbollah didn't kill IDF soldiers in Lebanon because they were Jewish.) The naqba is central to the story. The Holocaust isn't.
 
Hezbollah's beliefs, including extreme anti-Semitism, which lead them to commit terrorist acts is certainly relevant to this thread.
I do not find anti-Semitism (which takes a variety of forms) to be necessarily the topic "Holocaust." Can you understand that? Can you even bother to try? The Inquisition wasn't the Holocaust, but it sure was anti Semitism, or at least part of it was.

Part of Hezbollah's political stance is to play the "Israel is the root of all evil" card, for sure; however, its original aim was to the get the Israelis out of Lebanon, where the Israelis had come to deal with the ultimate patsies of the Arab world, those now referred to as the Palestinians. Those losers, who King Hussein of Jordan had sent packing during and around Black September, were using Lebanon as a privileged sanctuary (well, they tried, and it didn't work, see various blue lines and such) from which to attack Israel.

A part of that larger mess ended up with some folks in a truck blowing up the Marine Barracks, when the French and Americans tried to come in and do something about that mess and help ... which didn't go all that well. I do recall USS New Jersey accomplishing a bit of urban renewal and landscaping, for what good that did.

The Holocaust don't enter into it, or barely does as background noise: there is sufficient local crapola and hate to go around that it, Hezbollah, can remain its own area of interest without constant Godwinning once again commencing.

Hezbollah: intensely disliking Israelis, and Jews? Want 'em outta the neighborhood? Yeah, that's part of their appeal, and a standard political platform in that region.
 
Last edited:
The events of 1948 are extremely relevant in what we're talking about, which is the nature of Hezbollah. Everyone around Israel has lived with the consequences to some extent or other, and they've seen what happens to people after the Israelis come. They end up living in camps, strangers in a strange land, never to go home again, to be pitied but strangers all the same.
Yes. This is what inevitably and automatically happen when Israelis come. That's a very fair and objective depiction there:rolleyes:.

Edit:
The events of 1948 are extremely relevant in what we're talking about, which is the nature of Hezbollah.
Except there and then we weren't talking about the situation as a whole, but of Hezbollah's Holocaust denial. I had said nothing about the "naqba" in this thread (or elsewhere on the forum, to my knowledge) up until then, certainly nothing to warrant the strange request for me to Google "naqba denial". Trying to get someone to stay on topic isn't "downplaying" anything.

Edit2:
The only reason the Holocaust has come into this at all is that it always does when the subject turns to Israel and its environs.
Except all the times when it doesn't, see for example part two of the "General Israel/Palestine thread".
 
Last edited:
Holocaust denial isn't evidence of terrorism. The Holocaust itself was nothing to with the Middle East. Holocaust denial itself only became an issue after a some Europeans had the smart idea of having a conference in Iran - something they'd have no chance of holding in Europe. Ahmedinejad, a self-basting small-town ignoramus, fell for the whole thing. That was only a few years ago, and is of no real significance.
"This conference bears a clear Zionist goal, aimed at forging history by hiding the truth about the so-called Holocaust, which is an alleged and invented story with no basis." - Hamas, January 2000

Was that before or after Ahmadinejad stirred the [feces]? :rolleyes:
 
I do not find anti-Semitism (which takes a variety of forms) to be necessarily the topic "Holocaust." Can you understand that? Can you even bother to try? The Inquisition wasn't the Holocaust, but it sure was anti Semitism, or at least part of it was.
The topic isn't "Holocaust". It's terrorism by Hezbollah, which is fueled in no small part by extreme anti-Semitism which includes Holocaust denial.
 
The evidence is in the fact that they do accuse Hezbollah automatically of any terrorist incident they remotely can (plausibly or not). They don't do this because they have investigated, since they do it within hours. Ergo Israeli accusations are not evidence. That's my position.

Yes, you've unmasked the conspiracy. :oldroll:

Regarding objective historical fact, the naqba is such a fact and very visible in Israel's neighbours, such as Lebanon. An historical fact of life, even. When they see this being denied by Zionists why should they believe them about the Holocaust? Just how carefuly do you examine things beyond hearing something you like - such as Hezbullah being a terrorist organisation?

What specifically is denied by these supposed "Naqba deniers"?


How much effort do you imagine Israelis today are putting into understanding their neighbours? They made no effort during their Lebanese occupation, but then the usual Israeli experience is that occupied people soon move o so why bother?

Can you cite some examples of this Israeli experience?

I will touch on the personal to say that I am grossly offended by the way some Israelis reach for the Holocaust as their first rhetorical device. I don't think Israelis understand it as viscerally as we older Europeans do, but it was distant from them and they had their own war of conquest to prepare for.

So...your claim is really that non-Jewish Europeans understand the Holocaust more viscerally than the predominantly Jewish Israelis, many of whom either fled the Holocaust personally or are descended from people who fled or died in the Holocaust?

I'm pretty skeptical of that claim. Could you either clarify or provide some evidence?
 
Israel has, the last I heard, blamed Iran for the Bulgarian bomb acting through Hezbollah. They blamed the killing of Hariri on Syria acting through Hezbollah. The bombing in Buenos Aries was originally blamed on the Iranian Guards, then some time later a "Hezbollah operative" was tacked onto the list. Hezbollah have been blamed for bombs in Saudi Arabia while acting for Al Qaeda, for crying out loud. Nothing is too nutty if it promotes Hezbollah as a world-spanning monster, and yet the world remains unconvinced.

You make it sound as though Israel and only Israel believes Hezbollah is linked to these events, which even a cursory examination shows not to be true.

Also, rather than the rest of the world being "unconvinced", closer to the truth is the rest of the world doesn't give a squat. From their point of view, it's either somebody else's problem, or an inconvenient obstacle to peace.

Hezbollah do have a special distinction : they beat Israel. Nobody else in the region can claim that, and Israel is hardly likely to let that go lightly. To justify going back into Lebanon they need to paint Hezbollah as a terrorist organisation, not the resistance which drove them out.

You think Hezbollah beat Israel? I've heard some Hezbollah fan-boys make that claim before, but they usually fall silent when challenged to come up with an objective standard of victory that would apply. Unless you call mere survival "victory", I don't think very many will agree with you.

By that standard, any organization that still exists and has opposed Israel could be said to have "beat" Israel. Seriously, what measuring stick would make Hezbollah a victor that wouldn't also make Hamas or Fatah a victor?

I have stated that Israel will automatically accuse Hezbollah of any terrorist attack they remotely can, and will do it within hours of the event. From this you have constructed a strawman and a conspiracy theory entirely to your own design.

No, the conspiracy theory is of your design. Your theory is that Israel will attribute any terrorist action they can to Hezbollah because supposedly Hezbollah beat Israel. By implication, that also means Israel is willing to overlook real threats in order to smear Hezbollah. Why would Israel do this? I don't know, but somehow it makes sense in your mind.

So still we're not seeing evidence that Hezbollah is a terrorist organisation.

http://www.iranfocus.com/en/?option=com_content&task=view&id=9042

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TWA_Flight_847

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2006/12/22/AR2006122200455.html

I suppose you could be using the logic that cutting down just a few trees doesn't make someone a lumber-jack, but that reasoning doesn't normally apply to terrorism.
 
I suppose you could be using the logic that cutting down just a few trees doesn't make someone a lumber-jack
I tried this approah, only changing "terrorism" to "bank robbery". He braned it a "classic FAIL".
 
I tried this approah, only changing "terrorism" to "bank robbery". He braned it a "classic FAIL".

The comparison is apt. Insisting that Hezbollah is not a terrorist organization in the face of examples of Hezbollah terrorism is reminiscent of the Monty Python sketch where the guy insists the parrot is alive when it's clearly dead.
 
The events of 1948 are extremely relevant in what we're talking about, which is the nature of Hezbollah. Everyone around Israel has lived with the consequences to some extent or other, and they've seen what happens to people after the Israelis come. They end up living in camps, strangers in a strange land, never to go home again, to be pitied but strangers all the same.

By "the events of 1948" do you mean when the Arab states started a war, ganged up and tried to kill the Jews but ended up getting their asses kicked because their armies were incompetent and couldn't fight?

And that's BS the Arabs had nothing to do with the Holocaust. The Grand Mufti of Jerusalem, Haj Amin al-Husseini (Yasser Arafat's uncle) was a Nazi collaborator who lived in Germany and organized a Muslim division of the Waffen SS in the Balkans. Nazi propaganda was extensive in the Arab world. Husseini delivered broadcasts on Nazi-sponsored radio stations calling on Muslims to kill the Jews.
 
Last edited:
"By "the events of 1948" do you mean when the Arab states started a war, ganged up and tried to kill the Jews but ended up getting their asses kicked because their armies were incompetent and couldn't fight?"
I bet two candy bars he'll reply that the war was an inevitable result of borders drawn up by self-centered European imperialism.
 
The events of 1948 are extremely relevant in what we're talking about, which is the nature of Hezbollah. Everyone around Israel has lived with the consequences to some extent or other, and they've seen what happens to people after the Israelis come. They end up living in camps, strangers in a strange land, never to go home again, to be pitied but strangers all the same.

Hmm, why are the decedents of the 600,000 Arabs who often left voluntarily in 1948 still "living in camps, strangers in a strange land" when the 800,000 Jews who were expelled from Arab countries are integrated in a new country? Is that Israel's fault?

It's not so much that the naqba is an essential part of the problem. It's that the Arabs appear to be unwilling to swallow their pride and move on already ffs!
 
Hmm, why are the decedents of the 600,000 Arabs who often left voluntarily in 1948 still "living in camps, strangers in a strange land" when the 800,000 Jews who were expelled from Arab countries are integrated in a new country? Is that Israel's fault?

It's not so much that the naqba is an essential part of the problem. It's that the Arabs appear to be unwilling to swallow their pride and move on already ffs!
It's not like Hezbollah is working to get 3 or 4 generations of "refugees" Lebanese citizenship and the right to vote and work and live outside of "refugee camps".
 
Yes. This is what inevitably and automatically happen when Israelis come. That's a very fair and objective depiction there:rolleyes:.
It is.

Except there and then we weren't talking about the situation as a whole, but of Hezbollah's Holocaust denial. I had said nothing about the "naqba" in this thread (or elsewhere on the forum, to my knowledge) up until then, certainly nothing to warrant the strange request for me to Google "naqba denial". Trying to get someone to stay on topic isn't "downplaying" anything.
To get back to the question of evidence of Hezbullah terrorism then, Holocaust-denial is not evidence of terrorism. We left that topic when the Holocaust was introduced, because that has no bearing on the discussion. It is, of course, inevitable that the Holocaust will be brought into any discussion involving Israel and its environs, relevant or not.

Except all the times when it doesn't, see for example part two of the "General Israel/Palestine thread".
The times it has, and the people it happened to, are what are most evident to Israel's neighbours. As to those who remain on their land they would have included the last of the Bedouin a few years ago, and a many thousands on the West Bank, but the list gets that much shorter all the time.

As to the Arabs in Israel proper, so to speak, not every Zionist ever accepted anything less than a racially pure Jewish state and not every Israeli does either. The religio-nationalist settlers, for instance. The future of Arabs in Israel (or on any land they take) is highly insecure; perhaps if they were Jewish you might be able to empathise. They'd be foolish not to keep a bag packed.

Despite some bizarre beliefs, such as the Arabs handing over their property to the Jews voluntarily, it was always a requirement of Zionism that a very substantial part of the existing population would have to leave. Whatever a Jewish State actually is it would surely have to have a large Jewish majority, and the Zionists carefully calculated how many people the land could sustain. It was nowhere near enough to create a majority by addition. So there are two options : abandon the project or evict a large part of the population. Since the population weren't even white, let alone Jewish, out they had to go, and sure enough out they went.

Inevitable. The conflict in Palestine was caused by thousands of Ashkenazis turning up with the stated intention of taking the place for themselves, and blaming it on the inhabitants for not complying (as seems to be happening here) is deeply strange. Israel didn't just happen, it was made to happen. Israel has no qualms about stealing people's land and everybody knows it. That's what "settlement expansion" means - they're not just building higher, they're expanding into other people's land.
 
By "the events of 1948" do you mean when the Arab states started a war, ganged up and tried to kill the Jews but ended up getting their asses kicked because their armies were incompetent and couldn't fight?
Those Arab armies actually captured many Jews and didn't kill them. The Arab states (which had gained their independence shortly) did not oppose the creation of Israel in order to kill all the Jews. They did so because they lacked legitimacy (being the groomed successors of the European powers) and the Arab public regarded Israel as a tool of Imperialists, particularly the US. Which is understandable. Jews in the Middle East are as old and familiar as Noah, and however incompetent you think Arabs are they would have killed them long before Herzl got the secular Zionist movement going in 1897, let alone before any Zionists actually visited the region.

If Arabs have become genocidal anti-semites since the foundation of the World Zionist Organisation (and they clearly weren't before, given all the Jews that were in the Middle East at that time) then the implications of that are something to think about. It would suggest that Zionism created genocidal anti-semitism in the Middle East, presumably through the behaviour of the Zionists.

And that's BS the Arabs had nothing to do with the Holocaust. The Grand Mufti of Jerusalem, Haj Amin al-Husseini (Yasser Arafat's uncle) was a Nazi collaborator who lived in Germany and organized a Muslim division of the Waffen SS in the Balkans. Nazi propaganda was extensive in the Arab world. Husseini delivered broadcasts on Nazi-sponsored radio stations calling on Muslims to kill the Jews.
Haj Amin didn't organise a division of Muslim troops in Bosnia, he was shipped off there to recruit for an existing unit which was used in anti-Partisan fighting. It played no part in killing the Jews because the Serbs and Croats had already done that before they turned to finishing off the Muslims (and each other, of course).

Haj Amin was from a local Palestinian family of some minor influence; when the British turned up he persuaded them he was a man who could look after their interests, and they appointed him Grand Mufti (a title, a salary, nothing else : a very Ottoman institution). He was a political chancer with an eye to the future and saw that the increasing Zionist presence after the Balfour declaration and their behaviour was building a constituency for someone and he went for it. His inablity to organise anything is rather obvious from his long career as a failure.

After the outbreak of WW2 Haj Amin approached the German Forein Ministry with the idea of an Arab uprising against the British, which the FO liked but the Nazis slapped down immediately. Inferior races rebelling against their white overlords were not on their agenda at all, under any circumstances. The FO found themselves with a spare Arab on their hands until someone suggested Sarajevo and he was packed off there.

So no, the Muslims had nothing to with the Holocaust, which happened in Europe. The Nazis would be infuriated at the suggestion, as well as at the idea that an Arab would be allowed to organise any part of the quasi-mythical Aryan Champions that was (and, in many Austrian homes, still is) the SS.

I've watched the growth of the Haj Amin myth over the last few decades with some interest. If I reach my three-score-and-ten I expect to hear he was at the Wannsee Conference, perhaps chaired it, and may well have inspired the whole plan, after which they all had a beer and took him to a brothel where he could impregnate some German women. OK, maybe not all of that, but definitely some.

Haj Amin is only remembered because something's needed to keep opposition to Israel connected to the Holocaust, and, of course, it isn't. Israel was a process set in motion long before that, and not in order to save Jews from genocidal anti-semitism. It is meant to save Jews from miscegenation through assimilation, leading to the end of the pure-bred Jewish race. Only in modern times has that become an embarrassment, hence the attempt to keep minds away from the whole story. Just the 40's, and always get Israel and the Holocaust into the same sentence if even remotely possible. And these days make sure to say "Muslims" not "Arabs", to make US Americans shudder.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom