EU finally designates Hezbollah a terrorist organization.

He meant to say "Zionist", or it was mistranslated according to some professor in Germany, or something. But we can be sure he didn't mean "Jew", because he's a democratically elected freedom fighter who is so beloved by the people he can't appear in public.

What makes you think that? Which member of Lebanon's Parliament is reported as saying this? Has he confirmed it?

Imagine what play one could make with statements of US Republicans or UK Tories or Israeli cabinet ministers.

Some things we can surely agree on : where Hezbullah has really made its presence really felt is when they attacked members of an occupying army. Resistance to an occupying army is not terrorism. Hezbollah had no need to develop a terrorist organisation in order to drive Israel out of Southern Lebanon.

Hezbollah can't be accused of terrorism for their resistance in Lebanon, but the attribution of terrorist attacks abroad rose with their increasing effectiveness. While the occupation was bleeding body-bags across the Blue Line and the Israeli public were wondering what it was for the "terrorist" label was meant to shut down thinking, but it didn't work. Israelis aren't fools, any more than the Lebanese are. Not in abnormal numbers, anyway.

In the outside world, of course, there are still those who'll fall for it. Shallow thinking is no problem when your future doesn't depend on what you're thinking about. For Israel and its neighbours that's not an option.
 
On the contrary, if you're going to live next to and interact with another ethnic group, I personally find it highly important to understand them, their history, and their point of view.
Absolutely. And that is exactly what the Zionists didn't do. They didn't even care what local Jews were like or cared about (Weizmann dismissed them as "no use to us", too primitive to appreciate his vision, just living their lives generation to generation, no ambition).

My position being that you shouldn't fire rockets at civilians, and that this by definition is a terrorist act?
My position is that I would if pushed to it. Israel bombed civilian targets despite warnings : how else is that to be prevented in future but by deterrence?

I, however, don't understand your position at all.

You say it's okay to fire rockets at innocent bystanders (including elderly, children and infants) in a war.
The subject of what's justified in war and what wars are just has occupied legions of great minds, and no general conclusion has ever been reached.

You call an organization that does this a "legitimate presence", presumably becuase they at some point won some kind of election.
If that's a measure of your knowledge of the situation I have to ask why you're satisfied with it.

You call the murder of civilians in another country a "defensive" tactic.
Israel calls it collateral damage, but terminology makes no difference on the ground.

Then you throw in a No True Scotsman argument about how they're not a real terrorist organization, because so and so.
"Because so-and-so"? Really? Take a moment and ask yourself if that's all you've got. I appreciate that you believe Hezbollah is a terrorist organisation, and even if it's the only thing you know about them the rest can be inferred, but that isn't evidence.

(You should look up the "True Scotsman" argument as well, it's a bit of a minefield. I find "nothing is as simple as it sounds" a useful rule-of-thumb.)
 
What makes you think that?
Isn't that how it always is?

Remember the German professor who claimed Ahmadinejad didn't say "Israel must be wiped off the map", that it was a mistranslation? The Iranians didn't even go there.
 
The subject of what's justified in war and what wars are just has occupied legions of great minds, and no general conclusion has ever been reached.
But what we know for sure is that Israel commits war crimes every single day, and they get away with it because the Jews Zionists control the world.
 
Isn't that how it always is?

Remember the German professor who claimed Ahmadinejad didn't say "Israel must be wiped off the map", that it was a mistranslation? The Iranians didn't even go there.

I think it would be difficult for even the most "anti-Zionist" German professor to misinterpret the statement by either Nasrallah or one of his legislators. Try as he/she might.
 
Thanks for the expansion.

Hezbollah is a major party in a democratic country. Serbian death squads were thugs and death-squads who engaged in ethnic cleansing (are you sure you want the conversation to go that way?) and looting (ditto on that). The Hezbollah military is based on part-time village and block defence teams manned and commanded by locals; Serbian death-squads defended nothing and no-one, they looted where the army had already passed.

If you want to use scum like Arkan in an analogy it would work perfectly for the Irgun, but not at all for Hezbullah. It's not enough to simply juxtapose a hate-figure and your target; there has to be at least some resemblence, some subconscious link in your target's mind, for the association to form. Failing that you just appear weird and your target associates that with your argument or product or candidate or whatever it is you're selling.

See above, obviously. I know rule-of-thumb is to associate the target with paedophilia if possible, but not at all costs. Some judgement is needed, because the technique is getting pretty hackneyed. You might want to try tweeted rape-threats as an alternative, I hear it's trending.

You'll appreciate now my confusion, given the fundamental disparity between mass-movements such as Hezbollah and roaming gangs of nationalist thugs in a war-zone. The former is defensive, the latter offensive. There's no vision of Greater Southern Lebanon, there was a vision of Greater Serbia.

For what it's worth there is a vision of Greater Israel, which includes Southern Lebanon. Not everybody knows that, but everybody in Southern Lebanon does.

- major party in a democratic country
- mass-movement
bonus category: Wants to kill all the Jews it can


Sorry, just had a bit of deja-weimar-u there...
 
Some things we can surely agree on : where Hezbullah has really made its presence really felt is when they attacked members of an occupying army. Resistance to an occupying army is not terrorism. Hezbollah had no need to develop a terrorist organisation in order to drive Israel out of Southern Lebanon.
Again: I think there's some part of the concept of "innocent civilians" that is lost on you. Yes, I can indeed call Hezbollah terrorists when they bomb and fire rockets upon innocent bystanders, the same way I can call you a bank robber if you robbed a bank. An innocent civilian is an innocent civilian, be it a youth politician killed at a summer camp, a Manhattan office worker killed by a hijacked plane, or an Israeli child killed by a rocket attack as she is having supper in her house. Why innocents are murdered, or what is gained by their deaths, is immaterial -- what matters is that they are not combatants, and thus should not be deliberately harmed.

I suppose just admitting that "yes, of course Hezbollah is a terrorist organization, but I support that wholeheartedly" would require more bravery than you can muster.

eta
- major party in a democratic country
- mass-movement
bonus category: Wants to kill all the Jews it can
First thing I thought of, too ;). Except you forgot "Just Defending Their Country™".

eta2
One can also make the argument that deliberately killing innocents is detrimental to your stated goal. It has a nasty tendency to infuriate the population you're hitting, and/or rallying them in support of your destruction. Which is indeed what's happening now, with the EU condemnation which would not have happened had Hezbollah played by the rules.
 
Last edited:
On the contrary, if you're going to live next to and interact with another ethnic group, I personally find it highly important to understand them, their history, and their point of view.
Absolutely. And that is exactly what the Zionists didn't do. They didn't even care what local Jews were like or cared about (Weizmann dismissed them as "no use to us", too primitive to appreciate his vision, just living their lives generation to generation, no ambition).
Another very predictable dodge ("he's got a point there... quick, say somethign about the 'zionists'!").

You call the murder of civilians in another country a "defensive" tactic.
Israel calls it collateral damage, but terminology makes no difference on the ground.
...and again.

You say it's okay to fire rockets at innocent bystanders (including elderly, children and infants) in a war.
The subject of what's justified in war and what wars are just has occupied legions of great minds, and no general conclusion has ever been reached.
...and?
 
Last edited:
The reason is that your objective knowledge about the topic is severely lacking. Instead of trying to demonize him, you should be asking questions. Did you google "naqba denial" like he recommended?
It's no big deal over here, so I don't know anything about it other than that crimes against Palestinians never happened and that the Arabs use it as an excuse to kill Jews. I don't know any better, and why should I? It's not like I have a computer with Internet connection.

(or at least ,that's what I would be answering if I argued like C.D. ;) ).
 
Not placing Europeans and what they did to European Jews in the mid-20thCE at the centre of things does not imply the primitive to my mind. Had there been a substantial number of Muslims in Europe at the time it would perhaps have been different, but they'd long been eliminated apart from some recent inclusions in the Balkans. Pagans? Fuggedaboudit.

I don't regard it as primitive not to think history is all about Europe, I regard it as more advanced than the average European's position.

So Middle Eastern Holocaust Deniers are actually "more advanced" because their denial of objective historical fact indicates that they are "not placing Europeans and what they did to European Jews at the centre of things". By implication, non-Holocaust deniers in the ME are actually primitive in comparison; stuck as they are in Eurocentric darkness.

Racism and willful ignorance indicating an "advanced" and sophisticated mind.
Well, that's a new one.
 
So Middle Eastern Holocaust Deniers are actually "more advanced" because their denial of objective historical fact indicates that they are "not placing Europeans and what they did to European Jews at the centre of things". By implication, non-Holocaust deniers in the ME are actually primitive in comparison; stuck as they are in Eurocentric darkness.

Racism and willful ignorance indicating an "advanced" and sophisticated mind.
Well, that's a new one.

Not really. It's very 1930s.
 
That's a remarkable strawman. I said that Israel would blame Hezbollah for the attack regardless of whether they were actually responsible.

Why? What makes Hezbollah so special among all of Israel's other enemies? One of the silly bits of your conspiracy theory is that it's reasoning applies just as well to any of them. Just imagine if it could have been shown to Iran. That would be a political two-fer. Iran gets a political black-eye, making a possible military first strike against Iran doable. Then Hezbollah also loses for its close ties to Iran.



There seems to be no disagreement about that.

I disagree.

Don't read too much in myself or others not voicing their disagreement. Pointing out the flaws in your point of view is a little like duck-hunting. You may see a whole flock of ducks, but you only have time to shoot one or two.

That's what strawmen always are. That's their point.

Precious little straw to it. You got a right-good conspiracy theory going here.
 
Thanks for the expansion.

Hezbollah is a major party in a democratic country.

So was the Nazi Party in the Weimar Republic.

I know I am risking a Godwin, but could not resist that.

And as for "Greater Israel" that is only held in Israel by a few extremists, who are considered loons by 90% of Israelis.
 
That's a classic dodge with HAMAS, too -- "but, but they're democratically elected!". For all the good that does.

And as for "Greater Israel" that is only held in Israel by a few extremists, who are considered loons by 90% of Israelis.
He knows that, he just needed to change the subject somehow.
 
That's a classic dodge with HAMAS, too -- "but, but they're democratically elected!". For all the good that does.

Yes, there seems to be a case of: If you support democracy then you must support a democratically elected government when it decides to invade Poland.

Logic fail 101.
 
The exception of course being the USA and Israel, who are bound to follow the rules, both the official ones and the ones that their detractors make up on the spot, no matter the circumstances.

Try to reply to criticism of Israel with "but, but the Likud is a democratically elected party!", however, and they'll just look at you funny. Apparently we don't get to play by their rules, which is a shame.
 
Why? What makes Hezbollah so special among all of Israel's other enemies? One of the silly bits of your conspiracy theory is that it's reasoning applies just as well to any of them. Just imagine if it could have been shown to Iran. That would be a political two-fer. Iran gets a political black-eye, making a possible military first strike against Iran doable. Then Hezbollah also loses for its close ties to Iran.
Israel has, the last I heard, blamed Iran for the Bulgarian bomb acting through Hezbollah. They blamed the killing of Hariri on Syria acting through Hezbollah. The bombing in Buenos Aries was originally blamed on the Iranian Guards, then some time later a "Hezbollah operative" was tacked onto the list. Hezbollah have been blamed for bombs in Saudi Arabia while acting for Al Qaeda, for crying out loud. Nothing is too nutty if it promotes Hezbollah as a world-spanning monster, and yet the world remains unconvinced.

Hezbollah do have a special distinction : they beat Israel. Nobody else in the region can claim that, and Israel is hardly likely to let that go lightly. To justify going back into Lebanon they need to paint Hezbollah as a terrorist organisation, not the resistance which drove them out.

Don't read too much in myself or others not voicing their disagreement. Pointing out the flaws in your point of view is a little like duck-hunting. You may see a whole flock of ducks, but you only have time to shoot one or two.
You just missed one here. I'll believe people have got something if they show it, and I don't think many people here have anything at all. Beyond accusations of racism and an obsession with The Jews some are presenting nothing.

Precious little straw to it. You got a right-good conspiracy theory going here.
No content again.

I have stated that Israel will automatically accuse Hezbollah of any terrorist attack they remotely can, and will do it within hours of the event. From this you have constructed a strawman and a conspiracy theory entirely to your own design.

So still we're not seeing evidence that Hezbollah is a terrorist organisation.
 
But what we know for sure is that Israel commits war crimes every single day, and they get away with it because the Jews Zionists control the world.
Israel gets away with international crimes every day, but not war crimes. And your impression of Jewish power in the world is bizarrely inflated.
 
So still we're not seeing evidence that Hezbollah is a terrorist organisation.
Pretty hard to present such evidence when you pull the age-old semantics card of re-branding all terrorism to "resistance fighting" :rolleyes:. It's like a bad Monty Python skit:

Attorney: I intend to prove to the jury that the accused robbed the Glascow bank on Friday the 13th...
CapelDodger the lawyer: no he didn't!
Attorney: but we have witness testimony and CCTV footage of him entering the bank with a handgun, discharging two shots, and leaving with two plastic bags full of money and a suitcase of fermented cod!
CapelDodger (outraged): that's not bank robbery!
Attorney (flustered): the defendant walked into a bank, shot a guard and a child without provocation, and said to the nearest clerk that he would, quote, "blow his *********** brains out" if he didn't give him all the money in the vault!
CapelDodger: but he was defending himself from Zionist bank robbers!

Reminds me of a rather sad story from my hometown... during the "graduation party period" just before high schools close for the summer, a girl from one part of Bergen reported being raped by boys from another part of town.
To avenge her, boys from her district went to the offenders' district and raped a random girl there.
Most of us have moved away from this sickening "eye for an eye, innocent bystander for innocent bystander" mentality.
Others, apparently, haven't quite gotten that far :(.

ETA
Israel gets away with international crimes every day
I'm sorry, but I don't care too much about moral lectures from people who handwave Holocaust denial and promote the targetted killing of civilians for the horrible crime of being born into a country that does things you don't like.
(waiting for you to reply to this with "but, but Israel!").

ETA
I have stated that Israel will automatically accuse Hezbollah of any terrorist attack they remotely can
A statement for which you have provided zero evidence other than "but they decided so quickly!!".
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom