EU finally designates Hezbollah a terrorist organization.

Serbian Death Squads also set up "humanitarian" operations just to get good pr. Doesn't mean they weren't murderous scumbags who deserved being at the business end of an A-10.



And Jimmy Savile ran children's charities. :rolleyes:
Unless you can rustle up some semblence of sequitur please don't quote me as if you're somehow responding with your bizarre stream of consciousness. I find it rude, frankly.
 
You speak at length about the political situations and motivations of various countries, but what about yourself? You just called it a "legitimate move" to fire rockets at perfectly innocent civilians.
In the circumstances I believe it was. Israel bombed civilian targets in Beirut, and had been warned this would lead to retaliation in kind. There was (and still is) no other way to remove the Israeil sense of impunity because they own the sky.

So what's your own views? Do you consider this terrorism? Is Hezbollah a terrorist organization? If not, why not?
The onus is not on me to prove a negative. I don't consider Hezbollah a terrorist organisation any more than I regard the French Resistance to have been.

The Lebanese, and particularly the Southern Lebanese, have been subjected to Israeli bombardment uncounted times. Hezbollah launch an operation, Israel shells some villages. Body-bags trickle south across the Blue Line and Hezbollah are condemned as terrorists. Eventually the politicians stab the army in the back and withdraw - even though they weren't beaten. Six years later they go back for revenge and walk straight into a trap. No wonder they have to be made into such a monster of evil.

Where's the terrorism if not on both sides? And who invaded who and occupied their land for 18 years, killing who knows how many Lebanese (their families remember, of course) in the process? Resistance is legitimate, as is retaliation.

And Breivik was just an innocent worker trying to make a living running Breivik GeoFarms.
You people have some strange conversations.

All this hate-talk is not conducive to rational analysis, but then I don't suppose it's intended to be.
 
Yes - let's commit war crimes in response to war crimes committed on us! That will surely end war crimes.
It ended the Israeli bombardment, which was the point. And it put Israel on notice that its impunity is over. Not because of bungled bombings in Bulgaria but because of their weaponry and the devastating effects it can have on political and military careers.
 
Unless you can rustle up some semblence of sequitur please don't quote me as if you're somehow responding with your bizarre stream of consciousness. I find it rude, frankly.

No, the comparison is valid. I see little, if any difference between Hezbollah and the likes of Serbian death squads. Or was Zeljko Raznatovic "separate" from Karadzic? :rolleyes:
 
All this hate-talk is not conducive to rational analysis, but then I don't suppose it's intended to be.
Oh, sorry, we'll stop the hindering hate speech and let you justify the mass murder of civilians in peace. Good day:rolleyes:.

ETA:
The onus is not on me to prove a negative. I don't consider Hezbollah a terrorist organisation

(...)

Where's the terrorism if not on both sides?
You sound confused.
 
Last edited:
CapelDodger said:
A big issue for you, obviously. Not so much for Hezbullah.
So we can add holocaust denial to the list of things that don't bother you? Why do you...

A bigger issue for them is the Zionist claim to their land and the coming conflict that implies.
...oh, you've already changed the subject. Never mind.
 
Where's the terrorism if not on both sides? And who invaded who and occupied their land for 18 years, killing who knows how many Lebanese (their families remember, of course) in the process? Resistance is legitimate, as is retaliation.

By your logic, was Serbia right to try and engage in a genocidal campaign, since they were "resisting" the disintegration of Yugoslavia?
 
Where's the terrorism if not on both sides? And who invaded who and occupied their land for 18 years, killing who knows how many Lebanese (their families remember, of course) in the process?
I think there's something about the "innocent civilian" concept that's lost on you:confused:.
 
Of course it was a prime suspect : Israel accused it automatically.

Hezbollah would have been a prime suspect to anyone who pays serious attention to the area, excluding those who's agenda requires them to frantically avoid any such suspicion.

This strikes me as emblematic of the towering Hezbollah edifice developed by those who feel a need to.

The assassination of a series of of Lebanese politicians and journalists by a Lebanese terrorist organization requires a "towering edifice"? I don't think so.

If the Syrians killed Hariri (and they very likely did, it has their brutalist 60's and 70's feel to it) they wouldn't farm it out

They sure would, and using a proxy who shared their interests would be ideal.

And great disadvantages, such as losing control of the operation and bringing more people into the conspiracy.

Which is why powerful nations and crime syndicates never use proxies for handling certain problematic situations, because...

Oh...wait.

And as for Hezbollah being local, Beirut is local to Damascus.

Hezbollah is a local Lebanese paramilitary organization; As-Sa'iqa is not.

Let's not forget Iran having to act through Hezbollah now, giving their amazing sophistication and reach, far eclipsing anything the Iranians could do in the dark days before Hezbollah.

I wonder how the USG ever projected force in South America in the dark days before the Contras.

Your beliefs in what Iran, Israel and Syria have done in these cases are still unproven

The odds against you concluding Hezbollah ran the Bulgarian operation is about the same as The New Black Panther party concluding that OJ murdered his ex-Wife and her friend.

and at least in the case of Iran and Syria not particularly likely.

So it's likely that Israel employed a proxy to do some of its dirty work, but not Iran and Syria. Why am I not surprised?

My conclusions regarding all three of these actors are exceedingly likely, despite your ideological discomfort.

The "capitulation" thing is neat

Thanks.

- those evil bullying monsters Hezbollah, it suggests, who would otherwise be recognised as the world-spanning Haliburton of the terrorist world. Or something.

I would describe this as a strawman argument, but that wouldn't be fair to those who actually put some thought into their strawman arguments.

Leaving aside the emotive terms,

Well, if you think you can.

revealing though they are,

More than you'll ever know.

you do have to acknowledge Hezbollah as a legitimate part of Lebanon's make-up.

Depends on what you mean by "legitimate".

Which your instincts tell you is Hezbullah acting for Iran. Only coincidentally is does it match the instinctive Israeli accusation,

Which is why I "instinctively" concluded Israel used MEK in Iran, the US used the Contras in Nicaragua, and Israel used Phalange forces in Lebanon. Because I'm "instinctively" inclined to those type of conclusions.

Or maybe this is just some silly tactic you use to explain how anyone could possibly disagree with you.

I get it.

I have doubts.

"Dirt" is a bit much, I think,

Really? I thought it quite tame, considering the crimes under question.

it lacks subtlety

You mean the kind of subtlety featured in your comments?

and can put people off.

The kinds of people who think Holocaust denial is no big deal?
I can live with that.

Israel is deliberately murdering innocent civilians in a foreign country? Someone should get onto the EU about that.

Yes, someone should pressure the EU to re-list the military wing of MEK as a terrorist group. That would be consistent with how the EU has handled the Bulgarian incident, and we want to be consistent, right?

There is absolutely no need for any such thing. Iran, Syria and Hezbullah are not just allies of choice they're allies of necessity.

And this meaningless distinction prevents Hezbollah from finding advantage in strengthening its position regarding its sponsors- how?

What do they know about the Holocaust

I believe it made the papers.

So they'll believe in Holocaust denial.

Hold on...I called Holocaust deniers Holocaust deniers? Inexcusable!


Me: ...Holocaust deniers over at Hezbollah...
You: Why are you calling them that?
Me: Because they deny the Holocaust?
You: Are they responsible for holocaust denial?
Me: They are when it's them doing the denying.
You: So what?
Me: :rolleyes:

What does any of this have to do with the Holocaust?

What does Holocaust denial have to do with the Holocaust?

Despicable in the Europeans, who absolutely should know better, but it's no big thing in the Middle East

I believe lying about mass extermination and attempted genocide in order to dehumanize the victims of that program is "a big thing" and despicable no matter where it takes place.
 
What do they know about the Holocaust except that they didn't do it but it's used as a justification for Israel evicting local people from their homes? So they'll believe in Holocaust denial.
Were I a native of these countries, I would be offended by the level of patronizing you guys put into your arguments. Listen to yourself. We're not talking about savages in a remote jungle here, we're discussing industrialised nations with TVs and Internet connection. How would they not about the Holocaust?

Oh, and good job in managing to shoehorn an accusation against Israel in there:rolleyes:.

Despicable in the Europeans, who absolutely should know better, but it's no big thing in the Middle East
Yeah, we can't hold the primitives to the standard of us civilized people, can we?
 
Last edited:
No, the comparison is valid. I see little, if any difference between Hezbollah and the likes of Serbian death squads.
Thanks for the expansion.

Hezbollah is a major party in a democratic country. Serbian death squads were thugs and death-squads who engaged in ethnic cleansing (are you sure you want the conversation to go that way?) and looting (ditto on that). The Hezbollah military is based on part-time village and block defence teams manned and commanded by locals; Serbian death-squads defended nothing and no-one, they looted where the army had already passed.

If you want to use scum like Arkan in an analogy it would work perfectly for the Irgun, but not at all for Hezbullah. It's not enough to simply juxtapose a hate-figure and your target; there has to be at least some resemblence, some subconscious link in your target's mind, for the association to form. Failing that you just appear weird and your target associates that with your argument or product or candidate or whatever it is you're selling.

Or was Zeljko Raznatovic "separate" from Karadzic? :rolleyes:
See above, obviously. I know rule-of-thumb is to associate the target with paedophilia if possible, but not at all costs. Some judgement is needed, because the technique is getting pretty hackneyed. You might want to try tweeted rape-threats as an alternative, I hear it's trending.

You'll appreciate now my confusion, given the fundamental disparity between mass-movements such as Hezbollah and roaming gangs of nationalist thugs in a war-zone. The former is defensive, the latter offensive. There's no vision of Greater Southern Lebanon, there was a vision of Greater Serbia.

For what it's worth there is a vision of Greater Israel, which includes Southern Lebanon. Not everybody knows that, but everybody in Southern Lebanon does.
 
You can nitpick his examples all you want, but I think you understood his point -- that no matter how many good things thugs do on the side, fact remains they're still thugs. Hezbollah can be a "major party in a democratic country" all they want, they're still a terrorist organization. This is what we're trying to convey to you. Do you understand, or don't you?

ETA:
CapelDodger said:
You'll appreciate now my confusion...
I don't register confusion. All I see is you squirming by pointing out various big and small, relevant and irrelevant differences between Hezbollah and the subjects in our analogies.
 
Last edited:
Were I a native of these countries, I would be offended by the level of patronizing you guys put into your arguments. Listen to yourself. We're not talking about savages in a remote jungle here, we're discussing industrialised nations with TVs and Internet connection. How would they not about the Holocaust?

I doubt they prioritise "The Nazis : A Lesson From History" on their to-see list. There is so much on the Internet that one has to pick and choose. Mid-20thCE European History is not terribly relevant in the Middle East.

Oh, and good job in managing to shoehorn an accusation against Israel in there:rolleyes:.
Anybody who's lived near Israel after 1949 knows that Israel evicted thousands of people from their homes because those people have been living amongst them since then, forbidden to return and shot if they try. They know that the Holocaust is often used as a justification for that, and the emergence of Holocaust-denial on a thread about Hezbollah does rather support that. Of course it would require internet access to see that, but who knows, maybe somebody in Lebanon is reading this.

The enormity you assign to Holocaust-denial while even mention of the Naqba - something Israel's neighbours don't need internet to appreciate - is shoehorning in an accusation against Israel. Picture that wired-in Southern Lebanese person who, until 2000, lived under Israeli occupation and wonder what he's looking up the way you look up Holocaust denial. Try it yourself : search on naqba denial.

If the difference in scale bothers you, remember that all politics is local. Christians killing non-Christians on an industrial scale is nothing new.

Regarding "patronising" : while Holocaust denial can be strained from speeches by Hezbollah leaders, this does not mean that every member or supporter of Hezbollah slavishly holds that opinion. Holocaust denial does not direct the party's policy or purpose in any manner at all, and forms only the tiniest fragment of what's said.

Yeah, we can't hold the primitives to the standard of us civilized people, can we?
Not placing Europeans and what they did to European Jews in the mid-20thCE at the centre of things does not imply the primitive to my mind. Had there been a substantial number of Muslims in Europe at the time it would perhaps have been different, but they'd long been eliminated apart from some recent inclusions in the Balkans. Pagans? Fuggedaboudit.

I don't regard it as primitive not to think history is all about Europe, I regard it as more advanced than the average European's position.
 
Last edited:
Hezbollah leadership clearly spells out some of their "unique" perspective, to avoid any misunderstanding.

Lebanese writer, Amal Saad-Ghorayeb quotes Hasan Nasrallah as saying, "If we searched the entire world for a person more cowardly, despicable, weak and feeble in psyche, mind, ideology and religion, we would not find anyone like the Jew. Notice, I do not say the Israeli."[20] Charles Glass questions the attribution of the quote to Nasrallah, noting that both the footnote in Saad-Ghorayeb's book and her original dissertation instead attribute the quote to an interview she conducted with a Hezbollah member of the Lebanese Parliament
 
Hezbollah leadership clearly spells out some of their "unique" perspective, to avoid any misunderstanding.
He meant to say "Zionist", or it was mistranslated according to some professor in Germany, or something. But we can be sure he didn't mean "Jew", because he's a democratically elected freedom fighter who is so beloved by the people he can't appear in public.
 
You can nitpick his examples all you want, but I think you understood his point -- that no matter how many good things thugs do on the side, fact remains they're still thugs. Hezbollah can be a "major party in a democratic country" all they want, they're still a terrorist organization. This is what we're trying to convey to you. Do you understand, or don't you?

I understand your beliefs, really I do. It's just that I don't share them, and am yet to be convinced otherwise. In fact I find them utterly bizarre.

ETA:
I don't register confusion. All I see is you squirming by pointing out various big and small, relevant and irrelevant differences between Hezbollah and the subjects in our analogies.
Big and relevant differences are exactly what make analogies inappropriate. And, in the process, make you seem weird.

You believe that Hezbollah is a terrorist organisation. I get that. You don't like terrorists, and I get that. You don't like Serbian death-squads, I get that. But that doesn't make Hezbollah a terrorist organisation.

I'm old enough to remember real Middle Eastern terrorist organisations, and something they all have in common is their visibility in the real world. They didn't emerge fully-fledged and in their final form the way Hezbollah is said to have done. The "evidence" for Hezbullah terrorism comes down to Israeli acusation, US complicance, and that's it. As an effort to distract from Hezbullah's victory over Israeli occupying forces it only works inside the echo-chamber.
 
I doubt they prioritise "The Nazis : A Lesson From History" on their to-see list. There is so much on the Internet that one has to pick and choose. Mid-20thCE European History is not terribly relevant in the Middle East.
On the contrary, if you're going to live next to and interact with another ethnic group, I personally find it highly important to understand them, their history, and their point of view.

I understand your beliefs, really I do. It's just that I don't share them, and am yet to be convinced otherwise. In fact I find them utterly bizarre.
My position being that you shouldn't fire rockets at civilians, and that this by definition is a terrorist act?

You believe that Hezbollah is a terrorist organisation. I get that. You don't like terrorists, and I get that. You don't like Serbian death-squads, I get that. But that doesn't make Hezbollah a terrorist organisation.
I, however, don't understand your position at all.

You say it's okay to fire rockets at innocent bystanders (including elderly, children and infants) in a war. You call an organization that does this a "legitimate presence", presumably becuase they at some point won some kind of election. You call the murder of civilians in another country a "defensive" tactic. Then you throw in a No True Scotsman argument about how they're not a real terrorist organization, because so and so.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom