EU finally designates Hezbollah a terrorist organization.

Indeed, and the strategic realities can be very local. Some are timeless (such as geography), some are fleeting, most are in-between. On top of that come the societies evolved (and to some extent designed) to survive and feel good about themselves while doing so.

Serbian Death Squads also set up "humanitarian" operations just to get good pr. Doesn't mean they weren't murderous scumbags who deserved being at the business end of an A-10.

Timeless advice. Only the name and enemy vary :).

And Jimmy Savile ran children's charities. :rolleyes:
 
You have missed the point once again, and the strategic relaites, Hezzbollah is a politcal organisation that ahs a military side and a non military side, most organisations like this do and to reduce these organisations to jsut terrorism is a blunder that will onyl make matter worse in the long run.

It is ridiculous to think its all about absoulutes and jsut one bloc or thing.

As I said before, I'm sure you can find examples of Serbian death squads operating "humanitarian" fronts in the vain hope that they didn't get A-10s paying visits to them.
 
The difference between the Political and Military wing of the Hezbollah is a textbook example of "A distinction without a difference".
Resorting to cheap semeantic tricks is one of the favorite tactics of those who support terrorists groups as "fellow Anti Imperalist Revolutionaries" but don;t want to be seen to do so openly.
And Hexbollah has no shortage of Useful Idiots in the West.
Even a few on the JREF forums. Go figure.
And Jimmy Savile ran children's charities. :rolleyes:
Was that on the political or military side of things? :confused:
 
Hezbollah like most organisations of this type is a mixture of a terrorist body and a politcial one, Fatah was the same the IRA was the same nothing is balck and white in this sort of conflict and to try and simplify it like that and ignoring strategic realites will not help bring about a lasting peace in the area.

never forget Ivan is Human

Hezbollah international relations official Ammar Moussawi:

“Everyone knows that Hezbollah’s political and military wings are one and the same”.

Damn Hezbollah simplifying things and ignoring strategic realities and not helping bring about lasting peace in the area.
 
I think the interesting part of the speech is at beginning and end, about the psychological and moral battleground. The repetition and stress on resistance is precisely what Israel wants to drown out by the designation "terrorist". The successful resistance of Hezbullah, and its implications, is not something they're comfortable thinking about (especially after the 2006 trap went click on so many careers).
You speak at length about the political situations and motivations of various countries, but what about yourself? You just called it a "legitimate move" to fire rockets at perfectly innocent civilians.

So what's your own views? Do you consider this terrorism? Is Hezbollah a terrorist organization? If not, why not?

And Jimmy Savile ran children's charities. :rolleyes:
And Breivik was just an innocent worker trying to make a living running Breivik GeoFarms.
 
As for attacking Israel (the only other neighbour), I assume you're referring to their counter-bombarment in 2006, which strikes me as a perfectly legitimate tactic and one which has arguably kept the Israelis out of Southern Lebanon ever since.

Yes - let's commit war crimes in response to war crimes committed on us! That will surely end war crimes.
 
It's like that Onion interview with the al Qaeda spokesman who is offended that conspiracy theorists don't think they did the 9/11 attacks.

Parody becomes reality.
I love it when Onion works come true, particularly the more outlandish ones:D.
 
Do you consider it credible, or are you agreeing that Israel was going to make the accusation anyway?

I gave no weight to the original Israeli statement, outside of the small possibility they had intercepted important communication. I wasn't surprised that they turned out to be right in this case, since Hezbollah was one of the prime suspects.

In all probablility, the Syrians had more than sufficient assets in Lebanon to assassinate anybody they damn' well wanted to.

Yes. They call those assets "Hezbollah".

They would not have to act through Hezbullah any more than the Iranians would have to act through Hezbullah to bomb a bus in Bulgaria.

There are great advantages to using third party (often local) terrorist groups to do your dirty work. Which is why Israel used MEK in Iran, Iran used Hezbollah in Bulgaria, and Syria used Hezbollah in Lebanon. And why the NY mafia created and employed Murder Incorporated during the 30's and 40's.

It did them no good; they were cool with Hariri.

Hariri's anti-Syrian stance threatened both Hezbollah and Syrian interests. His capitulation to Nasrallah was not enough to protect him.

It fits the Assad regime's Cold War brutalism,

Certainly.

and some of Mossad's more hare-brained schemes

Didn't think anyone was gullible enough to swallow this nonsense, but I guess Nasrallah knows his target audience better than I do.

but not Hezbullah.

Of course not. Perish the thought.

Nasrullah blames Israel as instinctively as you blame Hezbollah,

Neither myself nor Nasrallah is blaming anyone "instinctively". I'm blaming those who seem most likely (IMO) to be responsible. Nasrallah is trying to scapegoat the Zionists for his own dirt; which is a standard and effective tactic throughout the ME.

What might anybody expect to gain from that bombing?

Iran gets to impose a price-tag on Israel for killing several nuclear experts. Hezbollah gets to enhance its relationship with one of its most important sponsors.

Why are you bringing up Holocaust denial

Because the group being discussed denies the Holocaust?

are Hezbollah responsible for that too, in your mind?

Are Hezbollah responsible for their denial of the Holocaust? Yes.

Holocaust denial is the product of Europeans

There are both European and Middle Eastern deniers of the Holocaust (Nasrallah would be an example of the latter). Shocking, I know.

just as the Holocaust was

I didn't claim Hezbollah committed the Holocaust, just denied it.
 
Last edited:
Also add in that one of the founders of the modern Palestinian Movement ran two Waffen-SS units in ww2, and so far, the palestinians haven't disavowed him.
 
The non-military wing of the PIRA was called Sinn Fein. It's still around.

Not quite. Though clearly linked, they have always maintained they are separate organizations.

Sure, the same way Congress and the Army are part of the same organization.

Sometimes I really don't understand you or what you're trying to say.

The US Army wouldn't exist without Congress. Congress provides the funding and the support, and to some extent directs its activities and goals. It would be impossible to pretend the actions of the US Army were not directed and controlled by the US Government. If we accept your analogy, it's more reason, not less,to hold the "political wing" culpable for the actions of the militants.

What is it that you're trying to communicate here?
 
The EU is clearly not persuaded by the Bulgarian bombing, since any attack on Jews will be blamed by Israel on Hezbollah. There are any number of neo-Nazis in that part of the world who might have had a hand in it, or it might be gang-related. I doubt we'll ever know the truth of it.


Your conspiracy theory is that Mossad framed Hezbollah for a terrorist attack that was actually performed by a previously unknown neo-Nazi terrorist group. You know, because Israel would find that so much more useful politically than they would find the existence of militant neo-Nazis.

You know that's silly, right?
 
As for attacking Israel (the only other neighbour), I assume you're referring to their counter-bombarment in 2006, which strikes me as a perfectly legitimate tactic and one which has arguably kept the Israelis out of Southern Lebanon ever since.

Unbelievable.

Care to remind us what, exactly, got the Israelis into Lebanon in 2006?
 
Israel atrributed the Bulgarian attack to Hezbullah within 24 hours. That was sufficient time for their investigation, which suggests high-level sources within the organisation who knew about it but gave no warning. Maybe so, but these high-level sources never do seem to give any warning, which is odd.

Does it?

You seem to be full of conspiracy theories today.
 
Your conspiracy theory is that Mossad framed Hezbollah for a terrorist attack that was actually performed by a previously unknown neo-Nazi terrorist group. You know, because Israel would find that so much more useful politically than they would find the existence of militant neo-Nazis.

You know that's silly, right?

You need to read more RT and PressTV. Then you would understand that Israel regularly slaughters its own vacationing citizens (as well as other random Jews) in order to fool the world into believing that courageous "resistors" are actually terrorists.

A good rule of thumb is that all attacks on Israelis are actually false-flag Zionist frame ups.
 
Last edited:
Your conspiracy theory is that Mossad framed Hezbollah for a terrorist attack that was actually performed by a previously unknown neo-Nazi terrorist group. You know, because Israel would find that so much more useful politically than they would find the existence of militant neo-Nazis.
That's a remarkable strawman. I said that Israel would blame Hezbollah for the attack regardless of whether they were actually responsible. There seems to be no disagreement about that.

You know that's silly, right?
That's what strawmen always are. That's their point.
 
I gave no weight to the original Israeli statement, outside of the small possibility they had intercepted important communication. I wasn't surprised that they turned out to be right in this case, since Hezbollah was one of the prime suspects.
Of course it was a prime suspect : Israel accused it automatically. That has no bearing on whether they were involved.

Yes. They call those assets "Hezbollah".
This strikes me as emblematic of the towering Hezbollah edifice developed by those who feel a need to. It shows not the slightest appreciation of Syria's involvement in Lebanon since their independence, or the various shady groups they've fostered, or the Syrian army occupations, let alone the Syrian security services - KGB-trained and supplied, decades of experience keeping the Assads in power while playing power-games in Beirut, and at the time in control of all Syria. All this for decades before Hezbollah existed.

Now they've dismantled all that because they're outshone by the Titanic power which is Hezbollah. The power which drove Israel out of occupied territory - well, that has to be mighty.

If the Syrians killed Hariri (and they very likely did, it has their brutalist 60's and 70's feel to it) they wouldn't farm it out and thereby let more people in on the scheme. When Hezbollah (a political entity as well as a military one, as I'm sure we all agree) said they knew nothing of it they'd be telling the truth - why make liars of them?

There are great advantages to using third party (often local) terrorist groups to do your dirty work.
And great disadvantages, such as losing control of the operation and bringing more people into the conspiracy. Look what's happened to Pakistan, where they farmed out their dirty work in Afghanistan and Kashmir to terrorist groups. Now they're fighting them at home. And as for Hezbollah being local, Beirut is local to Damascus. Not a big place Lebanon, and not a legitimate state as far as any Damascus regime has accepted.

Which is why Israel used MEK in Iran, Iran used Hezbollah in Bulgaria, and Syria used Hezbollah in Lebanon. And why the NY mafia created and employed Murder Incorporated during the 30's and 40's.
Let's not forget Iran having to act through Hezbollah now, giving their amazing sophistication and reach, far eclipsing anything the Iranians could do in the dark days before Hezbollah.

Your beliefs in what Iran, Israel and Syria have done in these cases are still unproven, and at least in the case of Iran and Syria not particularly likely.

Hariri's anti-Syrian stance threatened both Hezbollah and Syrian interests. His capitulation to Nasrallah was not enough to protect him.
Certainty is definitely one of your features. The "capitulation" thing is neat - those evil bullying monsters Hezbollah, it suggests, who would otherwise be recognised as the world-spanning Haliburton of the terrorist world. Or something.

Leaving aside the emotive terms, revealing though they are, you do have to acknowledge Hezbollah as a legitimate part of Lebanon's make-up.

Neither myself nor Nasrallah is blaming anyone "instinctively". I'm blaming those who seem most likely (IMO) to be responsible.
Which your instincts tell you is Hezbullah acting for Iran. Only coincidentally is does it match the instinctive Israeli accusation, and there's nothing Pavlovian about it at all. I get it.

Nasrallah is trying to scapegoat the Zionists for his own dirt; which is a standard and effective tactic throughout the ME.
"Dirt" is a bit much, I think, it lacks subtlety and can put people off.

Iran gets to impose a price-tag on Israel for killing several nuclear experts.
Israel is deliberately murdering innocent civilians in a foreign country? Someone should get onto the EU about that.

You seem to have forgotten the price-tag charged in SE Asia, where attacks were blamed on Iran acting through some local group as I recall. It all seemed very confused and half-assed.

Hezbollah gets to enhance its relationship with one of its most important sponsors.
There is absolutely no need for any such thing. Iran, Syria and Hezbullah are not just allies of choice they're allies of necessity.

Because the group being discussed denies the Holocaust?
What do they know about the Holocaust except that they didn't do it but it's used as a justification for Israel evicting local people from their homes? So they'll believe in Holocaust denial.

Are Hezbollah responsible for their denial of the Holocaust? Yes.
So what? What does any of this have to do with the Holocaust?

There are both European and Middle Eastern deniers of the Holocaust (Nasrallah would be an example of the latter). Shocking, I know.
Not really. Despicable in the Europeans, who absolutely should know better, but it's no big thing in the Middle East (except insofar as it keeps getting brought up by defenders of Israel). It's no big thing in China either.

I didn't claim Hezbollah committed the Holocaust, just denied it.
A big issue for you, obviously. Not so much for Hezbullah. A bigger issue for them is the Zionist claim to their land and the coming conflict that implies.
 
Last edited:
I'd have thought so. This wouldn't be something known to many in the organisation, in fact only a small elite, so for Israel to get an answer so quickly they would have to have a go-to guy somewhere high-up. Intercepted communications is another possibility perhaps, but a very distant one if Hezbollah is the super-sophisticated terrorist group it's made out to be - everybody's choice to work through. Even unsophisticated groups have heard of chatter, and don't make noises around the crucial time. They don't need to report what's happened, that's on the news. Something of a FAIL apparently.

You seem to be full of conspiracy theories today.
I wouldn't class having a high-level source as a conspiracy theory. It's a conspiracy, true, but one every intelligence organisation aspires to.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom