EU finally designates Hezbollah a terrorist organization.

Know what else is disconcerting? When a "political party" has a private military more powerful than the national military.
Consider what that says about said "nation". The Lebanese Shia aren't the only group to have a militia, everybody does - Druze, Sunnis, Maronites, Palestinians - and that's how it's been since independence. The only effective army it's had since the Ottomans was French, who created Lebanon in 1920 for their own imperial purposes.

And this private army has been used to attack Lebanon's neighboring countries.
In Syria they've acted in support of the government, which hardly constitutes an attack, and they're only separate countries anyway because the French and British drew lines on maps in Paris and London.

As for attacking Israel (the only other neighbour), I assume you're referring to their counter-bombarment in 2006, which strikes me as a perfectly legitimate tactic and one which has arguably kept the Israelis out of Southern Lebanon ever since.
 
As for attacking Israel (the only other neighbour), I assume you're referring to their counter-bombarment in 2006

Is this a riff on Ayatollah Khomenei's "Islam is not a pacifist religion. We will hit back. And sometimes we will hit back first!" ?
 
Or maybe Hezbollah is a terrorist organization which bombed a bus full of Israeli tourists, and The EU is 100% correct in their "nebulous" declaration.
Maybe so. Or maybe not. I'm afraid it's use of "maybe" which rather sets us two apart from the crowd here. As for "nebulous", most of the thread has been about that.

Gang related? Desperate much?
Checked out Bulgaria much? When people are holding up its judicial system as support for their maybe-free assertions, it's worth at least a tangential reference to the land of ricin-laden umbrellas. (Much the same with the Cypriots, I'm afraid.)

Verification is still sorely lacking. That can't be said for Hezbollah's involvement in their local war : no maybe about that.
 
Rhetorical question, since we both know the answer: were these "perfectly legitimate counter-bombardments" aimed at civilians or armed forces?

ETA
CapelDodger said:
The EU is clearly not persuaded by the Bulgarian bombing, since any attack on Jews will be blamed by Israel on Hezbollah.
News to me.
 
Last edited:
Hezbollah like most organisations of this type is a mixture of a terrorist body and a politcial one, Fatah was the same the IRA was the same nothing is balck and white in this sort of conflict and to try and simplify it like that and ignoring strategic realites will not help bring about a lasting peace in the area.

It's so unfair, isn't it? It doesn't matter how much you like Chianti and fava beans. But just eat one human liver, and that's all people remember you for.
 
To me, counter-killing a random person on the street and eating his liver seems like a perfectly legitimate response to the UK occupation. Surely it'll serve as a stern warning to keep the British imperialists out of Ireland :confused: ?
 
Here's (some extraction from) Nasrallah's statement on the issue from today:


Contains a bit of the obvious wondering about the limitations of that "designation" even our resident crusader urges clarification about, and touches on the parallel de-facto boycott of the NaZi settler's products and how much this or the other are of practical importance.
 
Last edited:
Rhetorical question, since we both know the answer: were these "perfectly legitimate counter-bombardments" aimed at civilians or armed forces?
Some were aimed at Israeli batteries which were firing into Lebanon, but indeed many weren't. The Israeli bombs dropped on Beirut were aimed at civilian targets, and they were warned there would be a response.

News to me.
Israel atrributed the Bulgarian attack to Hezbullah within 24 hours. That was sufficient time for their investigation, which suggests high-level sources within the organisation who knew about it but gave no warning. Maybe so, but these high-level sources never do seem to give any warning, which is odd.

When Hariri was murdered Israel had the investigation done within, you've guessed it, 24 hours and found it was Hezbullah - a finding I was unsurprised by. Maybe you weren't either.
 
Is Nasrallah head of the military wing or the political wing?

Why can't anyone answer this simple question?
Surely this has been flogged to death now. Even Hezbullah agrees the distinction is diplomatic double-speak, presumably required to get any agreement at all.

The weakness of the designation does not imply sudden acceptance of Hezbullah responsibility for the Bulgarian attack. That was a year ago, and the investigation was all done in 24 hours, you'll recall. There's nothing new on that front, but there is in the Levant. Hence my conclusion that it's Hezbullah's involvement in their local war which has prompted this designation.

(If anyone has a good source on the actual investigation I'd appreciate a link.)
 
When Hariri was murdered Israel had the investigation done within, you've guessed it, 24 hours and found it was Hezbullah - a finding I was unsurprised by. Maybe you weren't either.

I wasn't surprised by the finding, since they were right. The same culprit was, in all probability, responsible for the series of assassinations of anti-Syrian political figures which followed. Of course, the thugs over at "the party of god" predictably blamed their usual scapegoat for the crimes they themselves had committed. Hey, it worked before, why not try it again?

I guess it's only a matter of time before the Holocaust deniers known as Hezbollah finally identify the true culprits in the false flag tourist bus bombing.

It's 9/11 all over again!
 
Contains a bit of the obvious wondering about the limitations of that "designation" ...
I can take issue with much of his analysis of the EU decision itself, much of which can be put down to perspective. Nasrallah gets Israeli influence and European compliance way out of proportion, but if I'd lived a long life in Lebanon and had the French as my model for Europeans I'd likely make the same mistake. In much the same way, Hezbullah is a huge issue for Israel but not so much for everybody else.

I think the interesting part of the speech is at beginning and end, about the psychological and moral battleground. The repetition and stress on resistance is precisely what Israel wants to drown out by the designation "terrorist". The successful resistance of Hezbullah, and its implications, is not something they're comfortable thinking about (especially after the 2006 trap went click on so many careers).

Coincidentally, the resistance/terrorist theme works well with the French. They have fairly recent experience, but the word itself goes back to Napoleonic times - it's what the French called the Spanish Resistance. And it's what the Nazis called the French Resistance. Plus ca change (or chac'un son gout, maybe :)).
 
Nasrallah says there are only media reports but no official statements. I'd look it up but think the thread starter should provide us with that information.
There is going to be a full EU statement issued explaining the thinking and evidence behind the designation, which should prove illuminating. I can't find much about the actual investigation into the bombing, as it unfolded, but that's probably asking too much of my internet search skills.

There are many people who know fervently, and probably have since they first heard of the bombing, that Hezbullah was behind it. Israeli confirmation followed shortly after, but they'd hardly depend on that. They knew already.

When I first heard of the bombing I thought "Israel will blame Hezbullah for that". Shortly after, confirmation followed.
 
In much the same way, Hezbullah is a huge issue for Israel but not so much for everybody else.


Our little thread starter friend who claims to be in Australia started a lobby thread urging the numerous JREF forum posters with influence on EU decisions to prepare such a statement, at the threat of calling them a nutter and/or "anti-semite" I guess, so I think it should be on him to link to an official source for the thread title before we proceed with the lulz and/or can discuss the murky details of that move.

edit: I'm looking forward to it as well.
 
Last edited:
Hezbollah like most organisations of this type is a mixture of a terrorist body and a politcial one, Fatah was the same the IRA was the same nothing is balck and white in this sort of conflict and to try and simplify it like that and ignoring strategic realites will not help bring about a lasting peace in the area.

never forget Ivan is Human

And Ted Bundy was an upstanding member of the community.
 
I wasn't surprised by the finding, since they were right.
Were you not surprised by the rapidity of the investigation? Do you consider it credible, or are you agreeing that Israel was going to make the accusation anyway?

The same culprit was, in all probability, responsible for the series of assassinations of anti-Syrian political figures which followed.
In all probablility, the Syrians had more than sufficient assets in Lebanon to assassinate anybody they damn' well wanted to. They would not have to act through Hezbullah any more than the Iranians would have to act through Hezbullah to bomb a bus in Bulgaria.

Of course, the thugs over at "the party of god" predictably blamed their usual scapegoat for the crimes they themselves had committed. Hey, it worked before, why not try it again?
Did it ever for a moment cross your mind that Hezbullah might not have killed Hariri? It did them no good; they were cool with Hariri. It fits the Assad regime's Cold War brutalism, and some of Hariri's political rivals from the good old shooting-war days, and some of Mossad's more hare-brained schemes, but not Hezbullah.

Nasrullah blames Israel as instinctively as you blame Hezbollah, and both get each other entirely out of proportion to reality. Which is a result of circumstance.

I guess it's only a matter of time before the Holocaust deniers known as Hezbollah finally identify the true culprits in the false flag tourist bus bombing.

It's 9/11 all over again!
What has anybody gained from that bombing? What might anybody expect to gain from that bombing? Why are you bringing up Holocaust denial - are Hezbollah responsible for that too, in your mind?

There's so much to blame white Christian folk for, but it's expedient to blame other people for it. Holocaust denial is the product of Europeans just as the Holocaust was, but it's hardly why the Southern Lebanese have an issue with Israel. Three invasions in 65 years, 18 years of occupation, and an outstanding Zionist claim on their land and water are their issues.

There's no "maybe" about what happens to people who don't resist Israeli occupation, just as there's no "maybe" to what happens to an Israeli leader who compromises on the Zionist dream. The Lebanese expect Israel to come again, and they'd be fools not to.
 
Hezbollah like most organisations of this type is a mixture of a terrorist body and a politcial one, Fatah was the same the IRA was the same nothing is balck and white in this sort of conflict and to try and simplify it like that and ignoring strategic realites will not help bring about a lasting peace in the area.
Indeed, and the strategic realities can be very local. Some are timeless (such as geography), some are fleeting, most are in-between. On top of that come the societies evolved (and to some extent designed) to survive and feel good about themselves while doing so.

never forget Ivan is Human
Timeless advice. Only the name and enemy vary :).
 
Our little thread starter friend who claims to be in Australia started a lobby thread urging the numerous JREF forum posters with influence on EU decisions to prepare such a statement, at the threat of calling them a nutter and/or "anti-semite" I guess, so I think it should be on him to link to an official source for the thread title before we proceed with the lulz and/or can discuss the murky details of that move.
We have "Hezbollah Unmasked" from the NY times, which includes inter alia

"But evidence recovered from the bomber’s body included a fake Michigan identification card produced in Lebanon. Elsewhere in Bulgaria, investigators discovered that operatives used two other fake Michigan IDs. These led them to the true names of the bomber’s two accomplices. They traveled to Bulgaria using Australian and Canadian passports and then returned to Lebanon using a circuitous route to hide their trail. After sharing information with Australian and Canadian security officials, Bulgaria’s government stated that it believed both of these operatives were tied to Hezbollah’s military wing."
Bulgaria is so ignorant of Hezbollah, even after sharing information with Australia and Canada, that they think it has a military wing (and presumably a separate political one). Which has been well established by now, not least on this very thread, to be nonsensical. Frankly, my faith in the Bulgarian investigation has been shot away right there.

"Elsewhere in Bulgaria ...", now that's poetry. We're asked to believe that Lebanese villagers (which is basically what Hezbollah is) are better equipped and experienced to operate in foreign lands than the Iranains who assassinated dozens of dissidents in Europe during the 80's and 90's. It makes no sense, unless you begin with Hezbollah being an active and experienced international organisation which rose without trace to become the Iranian and Syrian weapon of choice during the privatisation frenzy of the 80's and 90's. Which is to say, not credible on any meaningful level.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom