Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Yet given every opportunity to support those claims, including some help by providing sample images to demonstrate them, the response is unsupported assertions and an admission of willful ignorance.

The only one willfully ignorant is you since you're not even sure if you own a book on plasma physics. You have no business even discussing BASIC physics since you claimed discharges could not occur in conductors and you think B lines BEGIN somewhere! You clearly don't know what you're talking about, and you have no idea how to discuss solar physics PROCESSES like "reconnection" that require PLASMA and PLASMA acceleration!

Also, just as with the photosphere having a particular definition, the transition region is defined. It is the region between the chromosphere and the corona.

It's not there in the SDO image. It's not at the top of the 304A ring, it's UNDER the photosphere/chromosphere boundary!

Its location is easily observed and easily measured.

Yep, it's 4832KM UNDER the photosphere in that SDO image. I measured it. I also used Kosovichev's work to correctly PREDICT it's ACTUAL location BEFORE SDO went into service.

Attempting to redefine commonly understood terms in an effort to wish a sci-fi fantasy into reality is not only dishonest, it is certain to result in failure.

That's why your denial of Dungey's use of the term "electrical discharge" in relationship to reconnection and flare events is UTTERLY dishonest. "Discharges? What discharges?" "Cited actual source at SDO? What source?" Typical BS.
 
Last edited:
The light from the light source reflects off rigid structures that aren't measured in million of degrees.
The light source is the Sun. The instrument, with that filter, is incapable of capturing anything from the light source that isn't measured in millions of degrees. Every image from TRACE using that filter contains nothing but regions where the temperature is measured in millions of degrees. You are beyond delusional.
 
The problem with that claims is that it's not located between the chromosphere/corona boundary. The "transition region" seen in the composite SDO image is actually located UNDER the photosphere, it's not sitting at the very top of the orange ring that defines the chromosphere in that image.

The light from the light source reflects off rigid structures that aren't measured in million of degrees.


Yet given every opportunity to support those claims, including some help by providing sample images to demonstrate them, the response has been more unsupported assertions and admissions of willful ignorance.
 
The light source is the Sun.

No, it's not just "the sun". The photosophere is only 6000 degrees Kelvin. It doesn't produce that light. There's a specific KIND of plasma arrangement/structure that generates that light.

The instrument, with that filter, is incapable of capturing anything from the light source that isn't measured in millions of degrees.

Reflected photons don't have to reflect from surfaces that are millions of degrees. You're still not listening, INTENTIONALLY!
 
Yet given every opportunity to support those claims, including some help by providing sample images to demonstrate them, the response has been more unsupported assertions and admissions of willful ignorance.

Who was your source at SDO that told you that the green color of the transition region in an iron ion composite image was related to a 'misalignment' of RGB images? You wouldn't have lied about contacting them, and you wouldn't be committing fraud by misrepresenting NASA would you?
 
Last edited:
Reflected photons don't have to reflect from surfaces that are millions of degrees. You're still not listening, INTENTIONALLY!

Those rigid structures are beneath opaque plasma, the "reflected" light would have to pass through that plasma *twice*. We've already shown how unlikely it is for any given photon to get through it once. You really want to claim the rigid surface is illuminated by sources above the photosphere?
 
No, it's not just "the sun". The photosophere is only 6000 degrees Kelvin. It doesn't produce that light. There's a specific KIND of plasma arrangement/structure that generates that light.
Yeah. The Transition Region And Corona that is being Explored. TRACE.



Reflected photons don't have to reflect from surfaces that are millions of degrees. You're still not listening, INTENTIONALLY!
There is a filter on the telescope. As a result, anything outside the 160,000 to 200,000,000 Kelvin passband is attenuated, therefore not visible in the images. You are making a fool of yourself.

Oh, and running difference images are representations of change and are therefore incapable of showing rigid structures.
 
Those rigid structures are beneath opaque plasma, the "reflected" light would have to pass through that plasma *twice*.

No, just once. Most of the light comes from plasma features near the surface, and the photosphere isn't opaque in the SDO images!
 
The only one willfully ignorant is you since you're not even sure if you own a book on plasma physics. You have no business even discussing BASIC physics since you claimed discharges could not occur in conductors and you think B lines BEGIN somewhere! You clearly don't know what you're talking about, and you have no idea how to discuss solar physics PROCESSES like "reconnection" that require PLASMA and PLASMA acceleration!

It's not there in the SDO image. It's not at the top of the 304A ring, it's UNDER the photosphere/chromosphere boundary!

Yep, it's 4832KM UNDER the photosphere in that SDO image. I measured it. I also used Kosovichev's work to correctly PREDICT it's ACTUAL location BEFORE SDO went into service.


On a few preceding pages the raw materials have been provided to demonstrate that those claims have some validity. But still, given those opportunities and the sample images, the response has been nothing but unsupported assertions and admitted willful ignorance. It should be noted that is a poor strategy which has inevitably resulted in failure.

That's why your denial of Dungey's use of the term "electrical discharge" in relationship to reconnection and flare events is UTTERLY dishonest. "Discharges? What discharges?" "Cited actual source at SDO? What source?" Typical BS.


The persistent incivility and dishonesty in lieu of a substantive objective explanation is noted.
 
Oh, and running difference images are representations of change and are therefore incapable of showing rigid structures.


Indeed. And all the arguments to the contrary are unequivocally unqualified. But it is math, something like...

(IMG2 + 50% GRAY) - IMG1 = IMGRD​

People who can't do freshman high school level algebra might have trouble with it.
 
Yeah. The Transition Region And Corona that is being Explored. TRACE.

Nobody doubts that they observe a "transition region". We're only debating WHERE it's located in relationship to the surface of the photosphere/chromosphere.

There is a filter on the telescope. As a result, anything outside the 160,000 to 200,000,000 Kelvin passband is attenuated, therefore not visible in the images. You are making a fool of yourself.

The only one making a fool of themselves is the one NOT explaining the light source. No REAL conversation is possible until you understand it. From there we can discuss other things. If you don't understand the light source, it's *LITERALLY IMPOSSIBLE* to have a logical conversation about even BASIC images, let alone RD images.

Oh, and running difference images are representations of change and are therefore incapable of showing rigid structures.

That's false too. Go checkout any LASCO -C2 or C3 RD images. You'll see a series of highly persistent black white/dots. They have 'rigid features, AKA background stars' in them. Anything that is PERSISTENT will show up as PERSISTENT over time. Anything that isn't, won't. The rigid features are "real objects", just as those background stars are real objects. Rigid doesn't NECESSARILY imply SOLID by the way. That will be important *IF* (and only if) one of you comes up with the CORRECT light source.
 
Last edited:
That's false too. Go checkout any LASCO -C2 or C3 RD images. You'll see a series of highly persistent black white/dots. They have 'rigid features, AKA background stars' in them. Anything that is PERSISTENT will show up as PERSISTENT over time. Anything that isn't, won't. The rigid features are "real objects", just as those background stars are real objects. Rigid doesn't NECESSARILY imply SOLID by the way. That will be important *IF* (and only if) one of you comes up with the CORRECT light source.

Background stars will only show up in an RD image if they move from frame to frame.
 
Likewise the sun has to rotate some distance before anything "persistent' can be observed in a RD image in an iron ion wavelength (or any wavelength for that matter).

Except everything you see in the RD image can be easily identified as a non-rigid atmospheric feature of the sun by simply comparing the RD image to one of it's source images.
 
Except everything you see in the RD image can be easily identified as a non-rigid atmospheric feature of the sun by simply comparing the RD image to one of it's source images.

If that were the case we wouldn't see those persistent features (in the RD image) remaining "persistent" for days and weeks on end.
 
Last edited:
Huh? I'm terribly confused now. I posted Peratt's *ENTIRE* definition of a "discharge" to this thread. It's describes the process as a transfer of *LARGE* amounts of EM energy into particle kinetic energy. It describes the 'pinches', the high energy wavelengths, etc. From day one, I have acknowledged that his definition is *INCLUSIVE*, not "exclusive" of 'reconnection". Reconnection by the way is described as being a process in PLASMA whereby magnetic field energy is transferred into particle kinetic energy. By DEFINITION, Peratt's 'electrical discharge' and "magnetic reconnection" describe the same PROCESS in PLASMA. Both of the processes occur *IN PLASMA*. Peratt's definition includes (doesn't exclude) A) plasma, B) MASSIVE releases of energy inside that plasma that results in pinches and high energy wavelengths.

Again your confusion stems from your inability to simply read your own reference and what you cited from it. " Peratt's definition includes" the phrase “usually accompanied by” meaning none of those are required for his "definition of a "discharge"".

The "backpeddling" going on is directly related to to the equivocation fallacy that each of you is guilty of. Instead of acknowledging all the components, you want to remove all but one!

The reason for your backpedaling is irrelevant to the fact that you now simply want to distance yourself from your own claim.


The DEFINITION of reconnection is clearly specified on Wiki as a process *INSIDE* (not without) plasma. It clearly specifies an ACCELERATION process, a HEATING process, and a TRANSFER OF ENERGY process. You're trying to dumb the whole thing down to localized "flux change", with or without plasma, with or without particle acceleration! Sorry, that oversimplification fallacy/equivocation fallacy is dead in the water.

A definition easily refuted by the simple experiment already recommended and the papers already provided. Your 'current reconnection' is dead in the water without the magnetic reconnection of the fields.


The analogy that comes to mind is someone comes up with a definition of drag racing that describes it as a PROCESS whereby two or more VEHICLES turn potential chemical energy (battery or gas, or something else) into vehicle acceleration for up to 1/4 mile to see who can accelerate the fastest, and reach the finish line first. Both vehicles have to begin at the same time via a series of lights telling each driver when to accelerate.

You guys find a full gas can in your garage, and say "Hey look, there's been drag racing taking place in our garage, and we're already DRAG RACERS!" All you have is potential chemical energy in a can. You ignored the need for the vehicles. You didn't TRANSFER that potential chemical energy into kinetic energy, you didn't race, but you you want to call the gas in the can "drag racing" in your garage. Boloney.

Your requirements for particles being accelerated and magnetic energy being transferred to kinetic energy were accommodated by the recommended experiment. Perhaps you should try to come up with better requirements and better strawman analogies.

FYI, I will be busy today catching up from being out of the office all day yesterday so I could attend a meeting at LMSAL. I probably won't respond much for a few days while I take care of business and get caught up at work.

Best of luck with that.
 
Ok, you're next. Did you figure out what the variables represent yet? I'm sure at least one of the variables that you asked me about is explained very clearly in the opening part of paper. Have you actually READ THE ENTIRE PAPER?

OK, I have read the paper. I looked at the definitions of the mathematical symbols. I have printed the paper and have it before me. I have an MS in mathematics and understand the mathematics. I am ready for you to explain how and why these two equations *PROVE* that reconnection requires plasma.

For convenience the two equations are shown below:

Equation 16:

[latex]\mu_0I(z) = 4\pi\alpha^{-1} cos(\alpha|z| +\phi__r)[/latex]

Equation 17:

[latex]\sigma(z) = -4\pi\alpha^{-1} sin(\alpha|z| + \phi_r) [/latex]
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom