Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
The interesting thing to me about that paper is that you seem to be ignoring the fact that his "vacuum" is *INCLUSIVE*, not EXCLUSIVE of two FILAMENTS that MERGE! He's talking about the RECONNECTION or merging of two PLASMA FILAMENTS in a VACUUM. The interesting thing is you're both ignoring the fact that charged particles 'reconnect' in his example.

Nope, both the paper and I explicitly asserted the reconnection of the currents J1 and J2 under two of the conditions. If you look back you will find my references to a lack a plasma as a lack of "intervening plasma" even when referring to the reconnection of the fields of two magnets. You are, evidently, deliberately confusing 'in a vacuum' (the lack of intervening particles) for 'being a vacuum' (the lack of any and all particles). Again I recommend you get yourself some better strawman to beat as these are obvious and futile.


Given your assertion " He's talking about the RECONNECTION or merging of two PLASMA FILAMENTS in a VACUUM". You obviously now feel your " RECONNECTION or merging of two PLASMA FILAMENTS" can happen "in a VACUUM". Congratulations you might just have beck peddled your way into some knowledge.

What exactly do you figure he means by the term "filaments" and merging of "filaments"?

The currents J1 and J2 as explicitly asserted in both the paper and by me. What exactly do you figure those two currents referred to?
 
I guess you just did a Google search for the terms "Reconnection" and "Vacuum" and you don't much care what that VACUUM contains. It doesn't matter if it contains current filaments, currents, or 15 pound, heavily charged bowling balls. If it's not devoid of moving charged objects, it's not "reconnection' *WITHOUT* charged objects!

This still all comes back to my drag racing example. You want to dumb down the term to the point of meaningless so that the mere finding of a gas can with a gallon of gas makes you a bunch of drag racers.

First you'll need to BUILD/GET/ACQUIRE a vehicle/plasma, ACCELERATE that vehicle/plasma and then you can call yourselves drag racers. :)

"in a vacuum refers" specifically to a lack of intervening particles as opposed to simply "a vacuum" which refers to the lack of all particles in some given volume. I suppose given your demonstrable lack of experience with physics it is understandable that you might confuse the two. So 'two charged particles in a vacuum' simply refers to two charged particles with no intervening particles between them. While just "a vacuum" would exclude even one particle (charged or otherwise). However, as you have previously asserted "He's talking about the RECONNECTION or merging of two PLASMA FILAMENTS in a VACUUM." you at least understand that difference to some degree now. So you can stop beating on your strawman whenever you feel like it.
 
BS. According to Somov the particle movement is the CAUSE of the change in the field. According to the second author, two PLASMA FILAMENTS ARE REQUIRED! They aren't optional and Clinger claimed plasma was optional.

No, the "second author" simply uses two "PLASMA FILAMENTS" as an example. Actually the particle movement (or more specifically the movement of the two currents towards each other) is caused by the magnetic fields reconnecting, that's where the energy comes from. It is stored in the configuration of the two fields and is released as those fields reconnect into one field around both currents then just one current as those currents finally merge. Certainly some particle movement can cause a change in the magnetic fields but neither that movement nor change in the magnetic fields need be conducive to magnetic reconnection and thus the movement of the currents towards each other.

The FLUX is CAUSED because the currents move toward one another. The "reconnection" happens when that "flux" accelerates charged particles.

Actually in the case of the non-resistive plasma the current J3 is induced in the intervening plasma. That would be the 'acceleration of charged particles'. Yet the currents J1 and J2 don't "move toward one another". So "The "reconnection"" doesn't happen in that case specifically because charged particles are accelerated (J3) in opposition to J1 and J2. The difference of course being that the vacuum condition and the resistive plasma condition both permit magnetic reconnection of J1 and J2 while the non-resistive plasma doesn't.


It doesn't matter! It's REQUIRES FILAMENTS in order for "reconnection' to occur! Nothing like blatantly denying the blatantly obvious.

Where are the "FILAMENTS" in the magnet experiment recommended? Your 'current reconnection' may require "FILAMENTS" but magnetic reconnection doesn't and your 'current reconnection' requires magnetic reconnection.


No, FLUX happens away from the filaments, but the FLUX change has a direct affect ON THE FILAMENTS (ON OBJECTS).

Gas can drag racers. That's what I'll just call you from now on. :(


Wait, "No, FLUX happens away from the filaments"? So the magnetic fields don't extend beyond "the filaments"? You really sure that's what you want to claim now?
 
Last edited:
Yes! Read the WIKI link. It specifically notes that the process called 'reconnection', occurs *IN* (not without) plasma. It specifically states that flux changes occur. It specifically states that PARTICLE ACCELERATION occurs in the process. It specifically talks about the rate occurring in ALFVENIC timescales, not C!


While indeed that article does assert..

"Magnetic reconnection is a physical process in highly conducting plasmas in which the magnetic topology is rearranged and magnetic energy is converted to kinetic energy, thermal energy, and particle acceleration. Magnetic reconnection occurs on timescales intermediate between slow resistive diffusion of the magnetic field and fast Alfvénic timescales.

...and I don't think there is anyone here who has said magnetic reconnection can't happen in plasma. What the article doesn't specifically state and you just want to add is the "(not without)" part. Nowhere does the article claim magnetic reconnection can not happen without an intervening plasma. In fact from what we already know magnetic reconnection can't happen when the intervening plasma is non-resistive. The fallacy you are engaging in is called denying the antecedent.


You're all trying to DUMB DOWN the term 'drag racing' to the point of absurdity. You think just because you have some gas, you're already drag racing! Baloney. You have to ACCELERATE CHARGED PARTICLES and transfer magnetic field energy into particle kinetic energy to call it "reconnection"!

You're the only one trying to " DUMB DOWN" things even to the point of you running away from what you said before was an "electrical discharge".


...yes, that is in fact an "electrical discharge". It's not actually an "electrical discharge in plasma' however.

Again the recommend experiment does "ACCELERATE CHARGED PARTICLES and transfer magnetic field energy into particle kinetic energy" yet you just won't " call it "reconnection"". So what you want to call "reconnection" is evidently just too "DUMB" for you to even call it, well, "reconnection".



Once again I implore you...

By all means, please, inquire as to what "few 'details' about the process" of the recommended experiment you feel may be lacking in the explicit descriptions already given.

Only you can stop yourself from trying to "DUMB DOWN" things to the point where your own assertions are now just too dumb even for you.
 
Last edited:
Again your confusion stems from your inability to simply read your own reference and what you cited from it. " Peratt's definition includes" the phrase “usually accompanied by” meaning none of those are required for his "definition of a "discharge"".

No Sir. The confusion stems from your inability to not only "read", but also 'accept' *ALL* of the stated conditions, not only of Peratt's definition of a discharge, but also the definition of "reconnection".

Both Peratt's definition of a discharge and the Wiki definition of reconnection begin *IN PLASMA*. Peratt's definition explicitly states that electrical discharges are a process that occurs *IN PLASMA*. He makes that clear from the title of the DEFINITION. Likewise the definition of "reconnection" begins *IN PLASMA*. Both the WIKI definition of reconnection and Peratt's definition of an electrical discharge describe the acceleration of CHARGED PARTICLES/PLASMA!

The confusion begins at your end when you *INTENTIONALLY* begin to "dumb down" a three part process, a process that EXPLICITLY occurs in plasma and results in plasma acceleration.

You're now in a DESPERATE need to NOT READ, nor ACKNOWLEDGE the REQUIREMENT of PLASMA. That's where the confusion begins. In the first quote you cited, I noted that you had not fulfilled the IN PLASMA requirement, nor had you described the ENERGY RELEASE. Since you seem to be EXCLUDING plasma, your 'experiment' neither satisfies the definition of 'reconnection', nor does it satisfy Peratt's definition of an electrical discharge *IN PLASMA*. Unless and until you *INCLUDE* rather than EXCLUDE the presence and the acceleration of plasma, I'm afraid I can't give your thought experiment a passing grade. Sorry, no discharge, and no 'reconnection' in the events you have described.

The reason for your backpedaling is irrelevant to the fact that you now simply want to distance yourself from your own claim.

No, your side is 'backpedaling' from the REQUIREMENT of PLASMA and PLASMA ACCELERATION. That's where the backpedaling begins.

A definition easily refuted by the simple experiment already recommended and the papers already provided. Your 'current reconnection' is dead in the water without the magnetic reconnection of the fields.

No, it's 'dead in the water' without FLUX CHANGES in the fields. I'll go that far with you. It is indeed a THREE step process. Both definitions start IN plasma, require CHANGES in the fields, which transfers magnetic field energy into particle kinetic energy by inducing currents in the plasma that results in plasma acceleration.

Your requirements for particles being accelerated and magnetic energy being transferred to kinetic energy were accommodated by the recommended experiment.

First off, let's start with clarifying the fact that this is not *MY PERSONAL* set of requirements. I had NOTHING to do with the creation of the WIKI page on "reconnection" and I cited a reference OUTSIDE of myself when describing "electrical discharges". Both of them begin *IN PLASMA*. How is that MY PERSONAL requirement in your opinion?

Perhaps you should try to come up with better requirements and better strawman analogies.

The strawman begins when you take out the requirement of plasma and plasma acceleration. That's the strawman in play and it's also the oversimplification fallacy in play. It's also the equivocation fallacy in play.
 
Last edited:
OK, I have read the paper. I looked at the definitions of the mathematical symbols. I have printed the paper and have it before me. I have an MS in mathematics and understand the mathematics. I am ready for you to explain how and why these two equations *PROVE* that reconnection requires plasma.

For convenience the two equations are shown below:

Equation 16:

[latex]\mu_0I(z) = 4\pi\alpha^{-1} cos(\alpha|z| +\phi__r)[/latex]

Equation 17:

[latex]\sigma(z) = -4\pi\alpha^{-1} sin(\alpha|z| + \phi_r) [/latex]

Ok, but let's make sure you have at least ATTEMPTED to understand that paper, and you understand how the variables relate to PHYSICAL reality. Please now explain the variables to us, and then we'll talk about how the two equations are related to PLASMA PHYSICS. Then we'll discuss how the two equations are PHYSICALLY RELATED to one another.
 
Nope, both the paper and I explicitly asserted the reconnection of the currents J1 and J2 under two of the conditions. If you look back you will find my references to a lack a plasma as a lack of "intervening plasma" even when referring to the reconnection of the fields of two magnets. You are, evidently, deliberately confusing 'in a vacuum' (the lack of intervening particles) for 'being a vacuum' (the lack of any and all particles). Again I recommend you get yourself some better strawman to beat as these are obvious and futile.

You know...

It's entirely possible you don't quite understand CLINGER's dilemma, nor care about it, because you're not helping his case any. :)

Somov notes that the CURRENTS move toward one another and the LINE encloses both CURRENTS. Likewise your example starts with CURRENTS in the vacuum that move. These are PLASMA particles in motion that result in plasma particle acceleration. These have NOTHING to with part 4 of Clinger's nonsense, and they don't describe the PROCESS as being UNRELATED TO PLASMA and charged particle/plasma acceleration. Both examples begin with PLASMA in the VACUUM.

Given your assertion " He's talking about the RECONNECTION or merging of two PLASMA FILAMENTS in a VACUUM". You obviously now feel your " RECONNECTION or merging of two PLASMA FILAMENTS" can happen "in a VACUUM". Congratulations you might just have beck peddled your way into some knowledge.

Something like 5 years ago, after reading the paper by Birn, I FINALLY gained that knowledge. I realized what he described was the same thing that Alfven described, aka a plasma filament with Alfven called a "circuit" in relationship to coronal loops, and what Birn called a 'magnetic line' (with charged particle running along the line). :)

I think it's news to you folks that PLASMA filaments in the vacuum are a REQUIREMENT in both examples.

The currents J1 and J2 as explicitly asserted in both the paper and by me. What exactly do you figure those two currents referred to?

They refer to the filaments that are present in Somov's vacuum and in your author's vacuum, and utterly and completely absent in part 4 of Clinger's nonsense.
 
No, the "second author" simply uses two "PLASMA FILAMENTS" as an example.

Ultimately both authors used plasma filaments in their examples IMO. The current and/or the filaments are missing in Clinger's example in part 4, and he didn't even understand what the term reconnection RATE referred to until a couple of weeks ago, AFTER writing that stuff.

Actually the particle movement (or more specifically the movement of the two currents towards each other) is caused by the magnetic fields reconnecting, that's where the energy comes from.

You and I are VERY close to communicating at this point. I agree that the flux changes result in particle acceleration in both filaments.

It is stored in the configuration of the two fields and is released as those fields reconnect into one field around both currents then just one current as those currents finally merge.

The "release" you describe is a release of magnetic field energy into particle kinetic energy, no?

Certainly some particle movement can cause a change in the magnetic fields but neither that movement nor change in the magnetic fields need be conducive to magnetic reconnection and thus the movement of the currents towards each other.

But the "flux changes"/reconnection is going to have a direct physical effect on CHARGED particles, correct?

Actually in the case of the non-resistive plasma the current J3 is induced in the intervening plasma. That would be the 'acceleration of charged particles'. Yet the currents J1 and J2 don't "move toward one another". So "The "reconnection"" doesn't happen in that case specifically because charged particles are accelerated (J3) in opposition to J1 and J2. The difference of course being that the vacuum condition and the resistive plasma condition both permit magnetic reconnection of J1 and J2 while the non-resistive plasma doesn't.

I think the key issue here is that without a charged particle acceleration process as a result of the field change, it's not actually 'reconnection'. That's also why Clinger's example in part 4 is NOT reconnection, nor is it a DISCHARGE.

I'm going to stop here and hope you read this response, BEFORE the magnet experiment response. We're MUCH closer to agreement on what's occurring in PLASMA filaments, and that is HUGE progress IMO.

Though is may be ENTIRELY irrelevant to you, I have no problem with calling Somov's example 'reconnection' or your cited reference. Both authors explicitly INCLUDE, and do not exclude charged particles and charged particle acceleration. Both authors likewise satisfy Peratt's definition of an "electrical discharge" IN PLASMA since it includes plasma.
 
While indeed that article does assert..
...and I don't think there is anyone here who has said magnetic reconnection can't happen in plasma. What the article doesn't specifically state and you just want to add is the "(not without)" part. Nowhere does the article claim magnetic reconnection can not happen without an intervening plasma. In fact from what we already know magnetic reconnection can't happen when the intervening plasma is non-resistive. The fallacy you are engaging in is called denying the antecedent.

Actually what I have asked you and Clinger and everyone else to do is to DEMONSTRATE your claim if you deviate from MHD theory and PLASMA physics. Thus far your cited references do not actually deviate from the INCLUSION of particles in the PLASMA state. Clinger's part 4 is DEVOID of such FILAMENTS running up the Z axis which is why it's just a qaudrapolar magnetic field with a null!


Again the recommend experiment does "ACCELERATE CHARGED PARTICLES and transfer magnetic field energy into particle kinetic energy" yet you just won't " call it "reconnection"". So what you want to call "reconnection" is evidently just too "DUMB" for you to even call it, well, "reconnection".

Ya know...

IMO you're ignoring the fact that I looked OUTSIDE Of myself when looking for definitions of reconnection and electrical discharges, and fixating on a single "dumbed down" concept related to MY slip of the tongue somewhere. I'm not the one that wrote the Wiki page, nor Peratt's definition. Don't use a conversational simplication of the argument distract you from the ACTUAL requirements listed on Wiki.

Only you can stop yourself from trying to "DUMB DOWN" things to the point where your own assertions are now just too dumb even for you.

No Sir, I think you really just don't understand where I've drawn the line in the sand, and you haven't really been following my debate with Clinger (I guess). FYI, I have no problem when you INCLUDE plasma filaments. It's the fact that Clinger EXCLUDED them that I objected to, and the fact he NEVER described the reconnection rate in part 4, nor will he ever do so.

What *HE* describes is *NOT* reconnection, and B *LINES* do not BEGIN in the NULL, nor END in the Null as he claimed. That's my beef, not the claim the 'reconnection happens" between two current carrying PLASMA FILAMENTS.
 
Likewise the sun has to rotate some distance before anything "persistent' can be observed in a RD image in an iron ion wavelength (or any wavelength for that matter).


That is absolute nonsense, to the point of being a just plain stupid argument. It's an opinion, clearly incorrect, and apparently based on a demonstrated lack of qualification to understand the math involved in assembling a running difference graph and the results of the process.
 
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnetic_reconnection

Magnetic reconnection is a physical process in highly conducting plasmas in which the magnetic topology is rearranged and magnetic energy is converted to kinetic energy, thermal energy, and particle acceleration. Magnetic reconnection occurs on timescales intermediate between slow resistive diffusion of the magnetic field and fast Alfvénic timescales.

I guess I'll list and highlight all three of the posted requirements for "reconnection" that are still listed on WIKI, while they're still listed there, just in case they change mid debate. I wouldn't be the first time someone went to all the trouble to rewrite WIKI to make some point (I suppose about WIKI itself).
 
Last edited:
That is absolute nonsense, to the point of being a just plain stupid argument. It's an opinion, clearly incorrect, and apparently based on a demonstrated lack of qualification to understand the math involved in assembling a running difference graph and the results of the process.

I'm still waiting for you to correctly identify the light source in ORIGINAL iron ion wavelength images, and to provide us with the identity of your source in the SDO team that told you that the green transition line color was related to a misalignment of RGB images. Care to pony up either answer?
 
No Sir. The confusion stems from your inability to not only "read", but also 'accept' *ALL* of the stated conditions, not only of Peratt's definition of a discharge, but also the definition of "reconnection".
Ah so you accept that your confusion is based on your inability to read, excellent. Perhaps you’re just so confused you forgot it was you claiming confusion?


Both Peratt's definition of a discharge and the Wiki definition of reconnection begin *IN PLASMA*. Peratt's definition explicitly states that electrical discharges are a process that occurs *IN PLASMA*. He makes that clear from the title of the DEFINITION. Likewise the definition of "reconnection" begins *IN PLASMA*. Both the WIKI definition of reconnection and Peratt's definition of an electrical discharge describe the acceleration of CHARGED PARTICLES/PLASMA!
Peratt's “title” is of the section not of the definition. Again do please try to learn to read your own references and you will find that neither explicitly sate electrical discharges or magnetic reconnection happen only “*IN PLASMA*”.

Your own assertions attest to the fact that you must understand this to at least some degree.

It's not actually an "electrical discharge in plasma' however.
He's talking about the RECONNECTION or merging of two PLASMA FILAMENTS in a VACUUM.

The confusion begins at your end when you *INTENTIONALLY* begin to "dumb down" a three part process, a process that EXPLICITLY occurs in plasma and results in plasma acceleration.
Well, as I recommended before you should probably just stop trying to "dumb down" things and you might be less confused.

You're now in a DESPERATE need to NOT READ, nor ACKNOWLEDGE the REQUIREMENT of PLASMA. That's where the confusion begins. In the first quote you cited, I noted that you had not fulfilled the IN PLASMA requirement, nor had you described the ENERGY RELEASE. Since you seem to be EXCLUDING plasma, your 'experiment' neither satisfies the definition of 'reconnection', nor does it satisfy Peratt's definition of an electrical discharge *IN PLASMA*. Unless and until you *INCLUDE* rather than EXCLUDE the presence and the acceleration of plasma, I'm afraid I can't give your thought experiment a passing grade. Sorry, no discharge, and no 'reconnection' in the events you have described.

This “REQUIREMENT of PLASMA” is only in your imagination, again simply because you are denying the antecedent.

No, your side is 'backpedaling' from the REQUIREMENT of PLASMA and PLASMA ACCELERATION. That's where the backpedaling begins.
Earlier it was the acceleration of charged particles, now it is “PLASMA ACCELERATION”. Perhaps you are beginning to understand that simply accelerating charged particles doesn’t constitute accelerating plasma. You just might be back peddling your way into some knowledge after all or perhaps some understanding that your attempts to “dumb down" things hasn’t been helping you.


No, it's 'dead in the water' without FLUX CHANGES in the fields. I'll go that far with you. It is indeed a THREE step process. Both definitions start IN plasma, require CHANGES in the fields, which transfers magnetic field energy into particle kinetic energy by inducing currents in the plasma that results in plasma acceleration.
As already explained to you before not all changes in field topology (your “FLUX CHANGES “) constitute magnetic reconnection. So again stop trying to "dumb down" things and you might be less confused. Also as already noted the acceleration of plasma (in the non-resistive case) will actually prevent your filaments from ‘reconnecting’. So once again your attempts to “dumb down" things has gotten you confused and you’ve missed the bus again.



First off, let's start with clarifying the fact that this is not *MY PERSONAL* set of requirements. I had NOTHING to do with the creation of the WIKI page on "reconnection" and I cited a reference OUTSIDE of myself when describing "electrical discharges". Both of them begin *IN PLASMA*. How is that MY PERSONAL requirement in your opinion?
Your deliberate misrepresentation of those texts, again denying the antecedent and trying to “dumb down" things is nothing but your own “PERSONAL requirement”.


The strawman begins when you take out the requirement of plasma and plasma acceleration. That's the strawman in play and it's also the oversimplification fallacy in play. It's also the equivocation fallacy in play.

Well, they’re your plays (and strawmen), you do seem to understand it’s an “oversimplification” and “equivocation” but simply refuse to recognize that they’re just yours.

Let me try to simplify it for you, just because some paper of article asserts “electrical discharges” or magnetic reconnection can happen “*IN PLASMA*” in no way infers any “REQUIREMENT of PLASMA” for “electrical discharges” or magnetic reconnection.
 
You know...

It's entirely possible you don't quite understand CLINGER's dilemma, nor care about it, because you're not helping his case any. :)

It’s evidently apparent that you just don’t understand the “dilemma” is simply yours and until you do you’re not helping your case.
Somov notes that the CURRENTS move toward one another and the LINE encloses both CURRENTS.
“the LINE”? Just what line is that?

Likewise your example starts with CURRENTS in the vacuum that move. These are PLASMA particles in motion that result in plasma particle acceleration. These have NOTHING to with part 4 of Clinger's nonsense, and they don't describe the PROCESS as being UNRELATED TO PLASMA and charged particle/plasma acceleration. Both examples begin with PLASMA in the VACUUM.
As already explained to you in the non-resistive plasma example there is a “plasma particle acceleration” (the J3 current) that results in the “CURRENTS” no moving toward each other.

Again your fixation with W.D.CLINGER is of no concern to me.

Once again we see you have no problem with such “CURRENTS in the vacuum” (at least now). So before you simply didn’t understand or were being deliberately obtuse?


Something like 5 years ago, after reading the paper by Birn, I FINALLY gained that knowledge. I realized what he described was the same thing that Alfven described, aka a plasma filament with Alfven called a "circuit" in relationship to coronal loops, and what Birn called a 'magnetic line' (with charged particle running along the line). :)
Hence your equivocation fallacy, a magnetic field line is not a field aligned current. Evidently you just didn’t gain knowledge and still haven’t. Also as already explained to you a field aligned current can’t be the origin of that field line. Again if you’d just stop trying to “dumb down" things you might be less confused.
I think it's news to you folks that PLASMA filaments in the vacuum are a REQUIREMENT in both examples.
Your thinking would be wrong; no one has claimed that they are not required parts of the given examples. However, “PLASMA filaments” certainly aren’t requirements for magnetic reconnection. Again something you can demonstrate to yourself with the recommended experiment. Again we see your equivocation fallacy that “a REQUIREMENT in both examples” is somehow a requirement of magnetic reconnection (also denying the antecedent) as well as equivocating your “current reconnection” and “FLUX CHANGES” with magnetic reconnection . When it comes to equivocation, Michael Mozina, you certainly are full of it.


They refer to the filaments that are present in Somov's vacuum and in your author's vacuum, and utterly and completely absent in part 4 of Clinger's nonsense.
Again your fixation with W.D.CLINGER is simply your own problem, but it does demonstrate that such “filaments” are not required for magnetic reconnection as does the recommended magnet experiment. Again Michael Mozina, stop equivocating things that suit your fancy, stop trying to “dumb down" things so you can put them in terms you can better just, well, equivocate.
 
Ok, but let's make sure you have at least ATTEMPTED to understand that paper, and you understand how the variables relate to PHYSICAL reality. Please now explain the variables to us, and then we'll talk about how the two equations are related to PLASMA PHYSICS. Then we'll discuss how the two equations are PHYSICALLY RELATED to one another.

OK, you said:
Quote:
Originally Posted by Michael Mozina
On the off chance you do actually want to discuss the maths and/or the physics of the process Priest describes in terms of sources and sinks, it's found here:

http://articles.adsabs.harvard.edu//...00539.000.html
...

PLASMA and CURRENT are required for "reconnection" and I showed you the exact two equations in Priests 'Source/Sink' paper to prove it.
Now you're asking me to "explain the variables." I have nothing to prove; I am a retired mathematician. I have made it quite clear to you that I am not a physicist. You have claimed expertise in this area and further claimed that the two equations in question *PROVE* magnetic reconnection requires plasma. I have been asking you to explain how these two equations do that for many weeks now and you have used one diversion after another to avoid answering. Now you want me to explain the variables. I have read the paper as you requested, I have identified all the variables in the two equations. I have no idea how they can *PROVE* plasma is required for reconnection. So, I am asking you, one again, to show how these two equations do that. There are many people on this thread who might benefit from this revelation. Assume, I understand the variables and explain your logic as to how these equations *PROVE* your assertion. Can you do that or not?

For your convenience, I again show the the two equations below:

Equation 16:

[latex]\mu_0I(z) = 4\pi\alpha^{-1} cos(\alpha|z| +\phi_r)[/latex]
[latex] for z \leq0[/latex]

Equation 17:

[latex]\sigma(z) = -4\pi\alpha^{-1} sin(\alpha|z| + \phi_r) [/latex]
[latex] for z \leq 0[/latex]

Now, STOP STALLING!
 
Ultimately both authors used plasma filaments in their examples IMO. The current and/or the filaments are missing in Clinger's example in part 4, and he didn't even understand what the term reconnection RATE referred to until a couple of weeks ago, AFTER writing that stuff.

The derivation posted by W.D.Clinger did have currents, please look at it again.


You and I are VERY close to communicating at this point. I agree that the flux changes result in particle acceleration in both filaments.

Again “flux changes” does not require magnetic reconnection. Again please stop trying to dumb down things just so you can equivocate. Until you do we will not be “close to communicating” on any point. Magnetic reconnection is a change in the field topology where there is no homeomorphism between the two different topologies.

The "release" you describe is a release of magnetic field energy into particle kinetic energy, no?

Yes, also when you release the free magnet in the recommended experiment that is “a release of magnetic field energy into particle kinetic energy”.


But the "flux changes"/reconnection is going to have a direct physical effect on CHARGED particles, correct?

Just the field itself will have “a direct physical effect on CHARGED particles” moving through the field (a current) without any "flux changes”. While the “"flux changes"” will have “a direct physical effect on CHARGED particles” that are stationary with respect to the changing field.


I think the key issue here is that without a charged particle acceleration process as a result of the field change, it's not actually 'reconnection'. That's also why Clinger's example in part 4 is NOT reconnection, nor is it a DISCHARGE.

Yet it is magnetic reconnection and hence the problem with you equivocating your “'reconnection'” or ‘current reconnection’ with magnetic reconnection.

I'm going to stop here and hope you read this response, BEFORE the magnet experiment response.

Too late, you know what they say ‘hope in one hand and …’

..well “equivocate” in the other and see which confuses you first.

We're MUCH closer to agreement on what's occurring in PLASMA filaments, and that is HUGE progress IMO.

Until you can accept the basics of magnetic reconnection (which again you can demostright to yourself in your own home) and stop equivocating it to what you want (your ‘current reconnect’) we’re not going to be any closer to agreement.

Though is may be ENTIRELY irrelevant to you, I have no problem with calling Somov's example 'reconnection' or your cited reference. Both authors explicitly INCLUDE, and do not exclude charged particles and charged particle acceleration. Both authors likewise satisfy Peratt's definition of an "electrical discharge" IN PLASMA since it includes plasma.

I’m well aware of that you have no problem simply calling things just what you want to enable your equivocation, as that is precisely the point it is hardly “irrelevant”, except perhaps evidently just to you.
 
Actually what I have asked you and Clinger and everyone else to do is to DEMONSTRATE your claim if you deviate from MHD theory and PLASMA physics. Thus far your cited references do not actually deviate from the INCLUSION of particles in the PLASMA state. Clinger's part 4 is DEVOID of such FILAMENTS running up the Z axis which is why it's just a qaudrapolar magnetic field with a null!
No you asked for papers referring to our claims that magnetic reconnection can happen in a vacuum. You were given them and now want to claim you asked for something else that I certainly never, and I don’t think anyone here, claimed. I’m not even sure what you think “if you deviate from MHD theory and PLASMA physics” means.
Ya know...

IMO you're ignoring the fact that I looked OUTSIDE Of myself when looking for definitions of reconnection and electrical discharges, and fixating on a single "dumbed down" concept related to MY slip of the tongue somewhere. I'm not the one that wrote the Wiki page, nor Peratt's definition. Don't use a conversational simplication of the argument distract you from the ACTUAL requirements listed on Wiki.

You just let your own “dumbed down" concepts and personal “simplication of the argument distract” you from your own equivocations, so you have never actually “looked OUTSIDE Of” yourself. This starts when you first drop the ‘magnetic’ from magnetic reconnection and then start referring to it as “reconnection” or ‘reconnection’ and equivocating it to whatever “”reconnection”” or “requirements” you want demonstrating you are still primarily ensconced in just yourself.


So you just can’t stop yourself from trying to "DUMB DOWN" things to the point where your own assertions are now just too dumb even for you?
I think you really just don't understand where I've drawn the line in the sand, and you haven't really been following my debate with Clinger (I guess). FYI, I have no problem when you INCLUDE plasma filaments. It's the fact that Clinger EXCLUDED them that I objected to, and the fact he NEVER described the reconnection rate in part 4, nor will he ever do so.
You can object all you want but you’re only objecting to matters of your own inclination (because you simply don’t look outside yourself) that don’t alter the magnetic reconnection demonstrated. Objecting to current carrying rods instead of filaments or insisting on a “reconnection rate” with no intervening plasma only demonstrate that you’re just objecting to simply object with no demonstrable relevance to the magnetic reconnection exemplified. If you truly do think any different then again use your objections to show exactly where he made any kind of mathematical mistake.

What *HE* describes is *NOT* reconnection, and B *LINES* do not BEGIN in the NULL, nor END in the Null as he claimed. That's my beef, not the claim the 'reconnection happens" between two current carrying PLASMA FILAMENTS.

It is magnetic reconnection, though I do note that you didn’t write “reconnection” or ‘reconnection’. So that’s a step in the right direction at least. Again magnetic reconnection happens between two magnets not just two “current carrying PLASMA FILAMENTS” or current carrying rods. So your “beef” is still explicitly with just magnetic reconnection that again you can demonstrate to yourself in your own home.
 
Michael Mozina, since you still seem to be having some problems with written language, let’s change the topics of two of your quoted texts to more common considerations and see if that helps.
1 .5 Electrίcal Discharges in Cosmic Plasma

An electrical discharge is a sudden release of electric or magnetic stored energy. This generally occurs when the electromagnetic stress exceeds some threshold for breakdown that is usually determined by small scale properties of the energy transmission medium.As such, discharges are local phenomena and are usually accompanied by violent processes such as rapid heating, ionization, the creation of pinched and filamentary conduction channels, particle acceleration, and the generation of prodigious amounts of electromagnetic radiation.

1.5 Dinner in a restaurant

Dinner is an evening meal following lunch. This is generally the last meal of the day and usually the most social. As such, dinners are usually accompanied by friends and family, the service of wait staff, considerable organization and a culinary selection particular to the local establishment.

While this in some ways describes dinner in a restaurant it neither limits dinners to restaurants nor requires all the conditions given for one to have dinner, even in a restaurant. This is explicitly asserted by the conditional modifiers “generally” and “usually”. In this case the definition of dinner is simply “an evening meal following lunch”, just as in the above the definition of “An electrical discharge” is simply “a sudden release of electric or magnetic stored energy”.

Magnetic reconnection is a physical process in highly conducting plasmas in which the magnetic topology is rearranged and magnetic energy is converted to kinetic energy,thermal energy, and particle acceleration. Magnetic reconnection occurs on timescales intermediate between slow resistive diffusion of the magnetic field and fast Alfvénictimescales.

Automobile repair is a physical process in automobile dealerships in which problems are diagnosed and then corrected by service personnel. Automobile repairs occur on timescales of minutes to hours or perhaps longer when the underlying problem is difficult to identify.

While the assertion is true “Automobile repair is a physical process in automobile dealerships in which problem are diagnosed and then corrected by service personnel.”. The fact that it doesn’t say “Automobile repair is a physical process only in automobile dealerships in which problem are diagnosed and then corrected by service personnel..” means that such repairs are not being specifically limited to “automobile dealerships”. So unlike the above where the conditionality is being explicitly asserted (by “generally” and “usually”) here it is simply implicitly asserted by the lack of the exclusive modifier “only”.

So in one case you are ignoring conditionality that is explicitly stated and in the other you’re introducing exclusivity that isn’t explicitly stated.

I hope this helps you.
 
Michael Mozina said:
No Sir. The confusion stems from your inability to not only "read", but also 'accept' *ALL* of the stated conditions, not only of Peratt's definition of a discharge, but also the definition of "reconnection".

Both Peratt's definition of a discharge and the Wiki definition of reconnection begin *IN PLASMA*. Peratt's definition explicitly states that electrical discharges are a process that occurs *IN PLASMA*. He makes that clear from the title of the DEFINITION. Likewise the definition of "reconnection" begins *IN PLASMA*. Both the WIKI definition of reconnection and Peratt's definition of an electrical discharge describe the acceleration of CHARGED PARTICLES/PLASMA!
Ah so you accept that your confusion is based on your inability to read, excellent. Perhaps you’re just so confused you forgot it was you claiming confusion?

:) If you go back and read what I wrote, your response is COMPLETELY inappropriate. :) No wonder I'm confused. You're not making a lot of sense.

Peratt's “title” is of the section not of the definition. Again do please try to learn to read your own references and you will find that neither explicitly sate electrical discharges or magnetic reconnection happen only “*IN PLASMA*”.

Actually, they both (reconnection/discharge) do state the fact that they are both describing a PROCESS in PLASMA that results in PLASMA ACCELERATION, and energy releases consistent with flares.

You're the one attempting to CHANGE the conditions of both DEFINITIONS! :)

I think I'm going to go to dinner, have a drink, and chill for awhile. Then and only then will I respond to the rest of the downright 'silly/confusing' stuff you wrote.

In the mean time, could you please show me where in part four of Clinger's derivation that he provide a reconnection RATE formula in that part of his presentation? What would be EXTREMELY helpful since you keep defending his work. That specific and highly important formula seems to be missing and absent. Without it, he didn't provide a way to describe "reconnection", just "flux changes" in a vacuum. PERIOD.
 
Last edited:
OK, you said:

Now you're asking me to "explain the variables." I have nothing to prove;

Ya, you have to prove to me that you at least READ the paper and have made some attempt to understand it. I'm not going to explain the ENTIRE paper, and the last time you asked me questions, it was clear you had not even read the first page.

If you want to talk about those two specific formulas, great. Start by explaining the variables now so I now you put a WEE bit of effort into UNDERSTANDING the paper, otherwise I simply distrust your motives and I see no point in continuing.

I already gave you PLENTY of hints about how they are related. I want to see that you've at least made some effort to understand what you read. I also want to know that you're interested in a DISCUSSION rather than an INQUISITION!
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom