Again your confusion stems from your inability to simply read your own reference and what you cited from it. " Peratt's definition includes" the phrase “usually accompanied by” meaning none of those are required for his "definition of a "discharge"".
No Sir. The confusion stems from your inability to not only "read", but also 'accept' *ALL* of the stated conditions, not only of Peratt's definition of a discharge, but also the definition of "reconnection".
Both Peratt's definition of a discharge and the Wiki definition of reconnection begin *IN PLASMA*. Peratt's definition explicitly states that electrical discharges are a process that occurs *IN PLASMA*. He makes that clear from the title of the DEFINITION. Likewise the definition of "reconnection" begins *IN PLASMA*. Both the WIKI definition of reconnection and Peratt's definition of an electrical discharge describe the acceleration of CHARGED PARTICLES/PLASMA!
The confusion begins at your end when you *INTENTIONALLY* begin to "dumb down" a three part process, a process that EXPLICITLY occurs in plasma and results in plasma acceleration.
You're now in a DESPERATE need to NOT READ, nor ACKNOWLEDGE the REQUIREMENT of PLASMA. That's where the confusion begins. In the first quote you cited, I noted that you had not fulfilled the IN PLASMA requirement, nor had you described the ENERGY RELEASE. Since you seem to be EXCLUDING plasma, your 'experiment' neither satisfies the definition of 'reconnection', nor does it satisfy Peratt's definition of an electrical discharge *IN PLASMA*. Unless and until you *INCLUDE* rather than EXCLUDE the presence and the acceleration of plasma, I'm afraid I can't give your thought experiment a passing grade. Sorry, no discharge, and no 'reconnection' in the events you have described.
The reason for your backpedaling is irrelevant to the fact that you now simply want to distance yourself from your own claim.
No, your side is 'backpedaling' from the REQUIREMENT of PLASMA and PLASMA ACCELERATION. That's where the backpedaling begins.
A definition easily refuted by the simple experiment already recommended and the papers already provided. Your 'current reconnection' is dead in the water without the magnetic reconnection of the fields.
No, it's 'dead in the water' without FLUX CHANGES in the fields. I'll go that far with you. It is indeed a THREE step process. Both definitions start IN plasma, require CHANGES in the fields, which transfers magnetic field energy into particle kinetic energy by inducing currents in the plasma that results in plasma acceleration.
Your requirements for particles being accelerated and magnetic energy being transferred to kinetic energy were accommodated by the recommended experiment.
First off, let's start with clarifying the fact that this is not *MY PERSONAL* set of requirements. I had NOTHING to do with the creation of the WIKI page on "reconnection" and I cited a reference OUTSIDE of myself when describing "electrical discharges". Both of them begin *IN PLASMA*. How is that MY PERSONAL requirement in your opinion?
Perhaps you should try to come up with better requirements and better strawman analogies.
The strawman begins when you take out the requirement of plasma and plasma acceleration. That's the strawman in play and it's also the oversimplification fallacy in play. It's also the equivocation fallacy in play.