Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
You can object all you want but you’re only objecting to matters of your own inclination (because you simply don’t look outside yourself) that don’t alter the magnetic reconnection demonstrated. Objecting to current carrying rods instead of filaments or insisting on a “reconnection rate” with no intervening plasma only demonstrate that you’re just objecting to simply object with no demonstrable relevance to the magnetic reconnection exemplified. If you truly do think any different then again use your objections to show exactly where he made any kind of mathematical mistake.

I think before I go to dinner, I will respond to the comment above as well as this one:

This “REQUIREMENT of PLASMA” is only in your imagination, again simply because you are denying the antecedent.

No, the REQUIREMENT of plasma and charged particle acceleration in the reconnection process is NOT my "imagination". I cited the Wiki page that describes it and defines all the terms including the RECONNECTION RATE. This rate is measured in terms of the change in particle velocities over time.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnetic_reconnection

Magnetic reconnection is a physical process in highly conducting plasmas in which the magnetic topology is rearranged and magnetic energy is converted to kinetic energy, thermal energy, and particle acceleration. Magnetic reconnection occurs on timescales intermediate between slow resistive diffusion of the magnetic field and fast Alfvénic timescales.


This brings us to the first paragraph I selected. I *DID* show you where Clinger made a mathematical mistake. He did NOT include a reconnection rate formula in part four. Without it, he FAILED to describe anything REMOTELY like "reconnection" in part 4.
 
Last edited:
Ya, you have to prove to me that you at least READ the paper and have made some attempt to understand it. I'm not going to explain the ENTIRE paper, and the last time you asked me questions, it was clear you had not even read the first page.

You have steadfastly said that reconnection requires plasma and that these two equations *PROVE* it. You have stalled, made excuses, postured and set me on one chase after another and still refuse to explain how these equations do what you claim.

If you want to talk about those two specific formulas, great. Start by explaining the variables now so I now you put a WEE bit of effort into UNDERSTANDING the paper, otherwise I simply distrust your motives and I see no point in continuing.

My motives are simple and unambiguous. I do not believe that the two equations do what you claim and I am asking you to demonstrate what you claim. It's quite ironic that you want me to explain the variables when you have not indicated the slightest understanding of the equations yourself.
I already gave you PLENTY of hints about how they are related.
That is a blatant lie! Show me one post where you have indicated any understanding of those equations or given any "hints."

I want to see that you've at least made some effort to understand what you read. I also want to know that you're interested in a DISCUSSION rather than an INQUISITION!

I’ll make one more attempt. The first equation (16) below:

[latex]\mu_0I(z) = 4\pi\alpha^{-1} cos(\alpha|z| +\phi_r)[/latex]

gives the current along the negative part of the z axis of the author’s figure 2. It is a function of z (negative position along the z axis of his figure). The I(z) term is multiplied by the permeability of space (μ0), for reasons unknown to me. This current is shown in the equation as determined by the cosine of the absolute value of z times α (CurlB) plus φr (defined as an arbitrary constant).

The second equation (17), which is similar in structure to the first, gives the density of magnetic charges σ(z) along the negative part of the z axis. I'll leave the rest of the details to you as you now explain how these two equation *PROVE* that reconnection requires plasma.

[latex]\sigma(z) = -4\pi\alpha^{-1} sin(\alpha|z| + \phi_r) [/latex]

Now, I have done my part, it's your turn to explain how these equations do what you claim.
 
:) If you go back and read what I wrote, your response is COMPLETELY inappropriate. :) No wonder I'm confused. You're not making a lot of sense.

If you go back and read what I wrote you will find your continued confusion is easly explained by your lack of reading comprehension. Please work to improve it.

Actually, they both (reconnection/discharge) do state the fact that they are both describing a PROCESS in PLASMA that results in PLASMA ACCELERATION, and energy releases consistent with flares.
I can describe a process of water flow in my toilet. However, that doesn’t mean all water flow must be in my toilet. Learn to read things as opposed to just reading what you want into them

You're the one attempting to CHANGE the conditions of both DEFINITIONS! :)
Nope, in one case the conditionality is explicit, thus your insistence on those as ‘requiments’ is patently false. In the other case the exclusivity you want is just not explicitly stated.

I think I'm going to go to dinner, have a drink, and chill for awhile. Then and only then will I respond to the rest of the downright 'silly/confusing' stuff you wrote.
I can hardly wait.
In the mean time, could you please show me where in part four of Clinger's derivation that he provide a reconnection RATE formula in that part of his presentation? What would be EXTREMELY helpful since you keep defending his work. That specific and highly important formula seems to be missing and absent. Without it, he didn't provide a way to describe "reconnection", just "flux changes" in a vacuum. PERIOD.
Still just equivocating magnetic reconnection with "flux changes" I see, oh well. When you get around to actually addressing “his work” as opposed to just your own confusion and equivocation then we might be able to see what you think needs “defending” in that work. By all means please tell us what you think the “reconnection RATE formula” should be for magnetic reconnection in a vacuum?
 
I think before I go to dinner, I will respond to the comment above as well as this one:



No, the REQUIREMENT of plasma and charged particle acceleration in the reconnection process is NOT my "imagination". I cited the Wiki page that describes it and defines all the terms including the RECONNECTION RATE. This rate is measured in terms of the change in particle velocities over time.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnetic_reconnection
Once again the exclusivity you insist upon is not explicitly stated in that article and certainly magnetic reconnection in plasma is going to involve an intervening, well, plasma. Just as water flow in a toilet is going to involve a toilet. Which is where this argument of yours ends up, just down the toilet.

This brings us to the first paragraph I selected. I *DID* show you where Clinger made a mathematical mistake. He did NOT include a reconnection rate formula in part four. Without it, he FAILED to describe anything REMOTELY like "reconnection" in part 4.

Fine show that formula and how it mathematically relates to magnetic reconnection in a vacuum. Particularly how it would alter the field line configurations as displayed or their calculations. Again equivocating your “"reconnection"” with magnetic reconnection is no ones problem but yours.
 
Last edited:
You have steadfastly said that reconnection requires plasma and that these two equations *PROVE* it. You have stalled, made excuses, postured and set me on one chase after another and still refuse to explain how these equations do what you claim.



My motives are simple and unambiguous. I do not believe that the two equations do what you claim and I am asking you to demonstrate what you claim. It's quite ironic that you want me to explain the variables when you have not indicated the slightest understanding of the equations yourself.

That is a blatant lie! Show me one post where you have indicated any understanding of those equations or given any "hints."



I’ll make one more attempt. The first equation (16) below:

[latex]\mu_0I(z) = 4\pi\alpha^{-1} cos(\alpha|z| +\phi_r)[/latex]

gives the current along the negative part of the z axis of the author’s figure 2. It is a function of z (negative position along the z axis of his figure). The I(z) term is multiplied by the permeability of space (μ0), for reasons unknown to me. This current is shown in the equation as determined by the cosine of the absolute value of z times α (CurlB) plus φr (defined as an arbitrary constant).

The second equation (17), which is similar in structure to the first, gives the density of magnetic charges σ(z) along the negative part of the z axis. I'll leave the rest of the details to you as you now explain how these two equation *PROVE* that reconnection requires plasma.

[latex]\sigma(z) = -4\pi\alpha^{-1} sin(\alpha|z| + \phi_r) [/latex]

Now, I have done my part, it's your turn to explain how these equations do what you claim.
Insert eating popcorn smilie here ... :p :)
 
Mozina:
I have made a bit more progress. I understand the basis for the expression [latex]\mu_0I(z)[/latex] -- Ampere's law.

So, I'm eagerly waiting to learn why and how the two equations *PROVE* plasma is required for reconnection.

OK, no more procrastination, diversions, deflections and posturing. Just give us your rational for these two equations providing the *PROOF* you claim.
 
Last edited:
One more note:

I noted a misstep above. α is curlB/B, not curlB as indicated in my post above. So, the α-1 term would be B/curlB

OK, no more procrastination, diversions, deflections and posturing. Just give us your rationale for these two equations providing the *PROOF* you claim.
 
Last edited:

Oh well, I think everyone here knows that the two equations do nothing even close to providing the proof Mozina claimed. The two equations are clearly an intermediate step defining the current and magnetic charge density in the authors configuration for the purpose of developing his thesis, which has nothing to do with proving reconnection requires plasma.
Mozina so boisterously repeated the mantra that the two equations *PROVED* reconnection requires plasma, so I think I finally had him pinned down to demonstrate his claim was nothing more than a blatant bluff. In any case, based on prior experiences, he would have just vanished from the exchange rather than admit his failed boast was exposed.
 
Last edited:
Oh well, I think everyone here knows that the two equations do nothing even close to providing the proof Mozina claimed. The two equations are clearly an intermediate step defining the current and magnetic charge density in the authors configuration for the purpose of developing his thesis, which has nothing to do with proving reconnection requires plasma.


All the evidence would indicate that those equations look like squiggly lines, alien symbols, and chicken scratchin's to Michael. In almost seven years of reading his nonsense on the 'net I have never seen him address any mathematical issue with any honesty or competence.

Mozina so boisterously repeated the mantra that the two equations *PROVED* reconnection requires plasma, so I think I finally had him pinned down to demonstrate his claim was nothing more than a blatant bluff. In any case, based on prior experiences, he would have just vanished from the exchange rather than admit his failed boast was exposed.


Correct. I've found the same to be true in all my years of trying to help him understand running difference graphs. He never did understand the simple math in their construction, or that a variety of inputs can result in identical outputs, or that a given output pixel can be brighter or darker than both corresponding input pixels. He never could understand that the "light" in a running difference image is caused by a mathematical function in the software and not by any actual light from the Sun. Hell, he recently claimed on another forum that the SDO PR image allowed him to verify his claim to within 32 kilometers of a particular location. But duh, even in the absolute maximum resolution from the SDO, a single pixel represents over 400 kilometers on each side. His argument is quantitatively non-existent, not to mention raw stupid. His incompetence in understanding satellite imagery is rivaled only by his incompetence at mathematics in general.

Yep. He had nothing to lose and everything to gain by getting himself booted. He can haul that cross of persecution all around the 'net and continue to whine about how real scientists conspire to silence the heretics. He'll go to his grave believing that someday you'll see, you'll all be sorry, someday you'll understand! :rolleyes:
 
This brings us to the first paragraph I selected. I *DID* show you where Clinger made a mathematical mistake. He did NOT include a reconnection rate formula in part four. Without it, he FAILED to describe anything REMOTELY like "reconnection" in part 4.

Well, the last thing he posted here was still wrong. I guess I can take him off ignore now.
 
All the evidence would indicate that those equations look like squiggly lines, alien symbols, and chicken scratchin's to Michael. In almost seven years of reading his nonsense on the 'net I have never seen him address any mathematical issue with any honesty or competence.




Correct. I've found the same to be true in all my years of trying to help him understand running difference graphs. He never did understand the simple math in their construction, or that a variety of inputs can result in identical outputs, or that a given output pixel can be brighter or darker than both corresponding input pixels. He never could understand that the "light" in a running difference image is caused by a mathematical function in the software and not by any actual light from the Sun. Hell, he recently claimed on another forum that the SDO PR image allowed him to verify his claim to within 32 kilometers of a particular location. But duh, even in the absolute maximum resolution from the SDO, a single pixel represents over 400 kilometers on each side. His argument is quantitatively non-existent, not to mention raw stupid. His incompetence in understanding satellite imagery is rivaled only by his incompetence at mathematics in general.

Yep. He had nothing to lose and everything to gain by getting himself booted. He can haul that cross of persecution all around the 'net and continue to whine about how real scientists conspire to silence the heretics. He'll go to his grave believing that someday you'll see, you'll all be sorry, someday you'll understand! :rolleyes:

Frankly, I will not miss him. Science is tough enough for a layman without Mozinas to make the waters even more murky. Before getting involved in this forum I had no idea such people even existed. RIP Michael Mozina!
 
Well I certainly would have preferred that he learned something. Occasionally it seemed that some things did get through but there was always that underlying distain simply for a term that describes a particular physical interaction, magnetic reconnection, that he just couldn’t get past even when it got him some of the other things he wanted (like ‘current reconnection’). Quite frankly I’d never even heard of magnetic reconnection before I stated posting on this forum almost five years ago now (I think it was Be A Chooser who first brought it up in a discussion we were having). Since then I’ve learned quite a bit both by researching for my own posts and from the excellent information posted by others. Sad and ironic that some can inspire education by their fixation on something they just wish was different yet just can’t seem to partake of that very education because of that same fixation.
 
Michael Mozina's delusion that a reconnection rate exists without plasma II

FYI, still no mathematical expression for the reconnection RATE in the absence of mass and mass acceleration. .
FYI: You are still inanely demanding that there be a reconnection rate for plasma when there is no plasma!
Michael Mozina's delusion that a reconnection rate exists without plasma!

Of course someone could do the following:
The Alfvén speed when there is no plasma:
15c92bc470410bcaa83f4f6f54e8534e.png
So the plasma density is zero and vA = B/0 (undefined :eye-poppi!)

The Lundquist number
but there is no plasma so what do we plug in for the plasma resisttivity :eye-poppi?

And then we finally get to the reconnection rate, e.g. in Petschek reconnection in plasma:
and the maximum reconnection rate becomes
97a13d780dac6bd7b37d47c98d9ca116.png
And this is undefined because .... that someone does not know that the reconnection rate is defined for plasma :eye-poppi.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom