Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.

Yes! Read the WIKI link. It specifically notes that the process called 'reconnection', occurs *IN* (not without) plasma. It specifically states that flux changes occur. It specifically states that PARTICLE ACCELERATION occurs in the process. It specifically talks about the rate occurring in ALFVENIC timescales, not C!

You're all trying to DUMB DOWN the term 'drag racing' to the point of absurdity. You think just because you have some gas, you're already drag racing! Baloney. You have to ACCELERATE CHARGED PARTICLES and transfer magnetic field energy into particle kinetic energy to call it "reconnection"!
 

All of them *INCLUDE* and do not EXCLUDE charged particles in the RECONNECTION process. You are now attempting to dumb down the term "vacuum" to mean "CURRENTS + vacuum." Everything you folks believe in is based upon an equivocation fallacy and something UNPUBLISHED* that you read on a website somewhere in cyberspace.
 
Last edited:
All of them *INCLUDE* and do not EXCLUDE charged particles in the RECONNECTION process. You now attempting to dumb down the term "vacuum" to mean "CURRENTS + vacuum." Everything you folks believe in is based upon an equivocation fallacy and something UNPUBLISHED* that you read on a website somewhere in cyberspace.
Somov is published. He is right. You are wrong. Your wilfull misreading of his work is laughable. You brandish your ignorance like a sword and a shield.

Let's put this as simply as possible. You believe there are mountains on the sun. Nothing you say can possibly be taken seriously. Your sole source of value on this forum is to trigger mini-science lessons from people with actual knowledge and expertise.

So carry on.
 
Somov is published. He is right.

Yes, he INCLUDED (did not exclude) CURRENT and noted that the PROCESS occurs only *IF* there is MOVEMENT of that CURRENT!

You are wrong.

No, you are wrong. His vacuum *INCLUDES* current.

Your wilfull misreading of his work is laughable. You brandish your ignorance like a sword and a shield.

Speaking of a laughable brandishing of ignorance like a sword, do you even personally own a plasma physics textbook? I do own and I've read at least one of Somov's whole BOOKS on the topic of PLASMA physics. Have you?

Let's put this as simply as possible. You believe there are mountains on the sun. Nothing you say can possibly be taken seriously.

Even that concept is bogus. I could be wrong about one thing (mountains on the sun) and right about the other (reconnection requires plasma). That's not even a valid argument!

Your sole source of value on this forum is to trigger mini-science lessons from people with actual knowledge and expertise.

So carry on.

Whatever. Note however that I'm the one who's position AGREES with the WIKI page, whereas the position of your people with so called "knowledge" does not! The WIKI page *INCLUDES* plasma. It INCLUDES particle acceleration. It INCLUDES the transfer of magnetic field energy into particle kinetic energy.

If you insist on remaining in DENIAL OF THESE SCIENTIFIC FACTS, carry on. It's no skin off my nose if you can't tell the difference between plasma diffusion timescales and C.
 
Current is not plasma. Somov's example uses two idealized currents to generate magnetic fields. The reconnection happens in the vacuum region when the currents move towards each other. The currents are not in the vacuum region. Even if they were, two copper wires in a vacuum could still produce magnetic reconnection in a vacuum with no plasma.

If I can understand this, why can't you?
 
Whatever. Note however that I'm the one who's position AGREES with the WIKI page, whereas the position of your people with so called "knowledge" does not! The WIKI page *INCLUDES* plasma. It INCLUDES particle acceleration. It INCLUDES the transfer of magnetic field energy into particle kinetic energy.

If you insist on remaining in DENIAL OF THESE SCIENTIFIC FACTS, carry on. It's no skin off my nose if you can't tell the difference between plasma diffusion timescales and C.
It has been explained to you over and over that magnetic reconnection is only interesting in plasma, thus the focus on studying its effects in plasma. If you choose to remain ignorant of this so that you can cling to your delusions about the sun, this is your loss.
 
I think I'll start a list of FALSE PHYSICS that EU hater's believe to be true:

EU haters believe that:

Electrical discharges cannot occur in conductors even through they can ONLY occur in/through conductors.

They believe that B lines (no mass involved) are capable of 'beginning and ending' even though no PUBLISHED work makes such a claim, and all the PUBLISHED materials state exactly the opposite. They ignore PUBLISHED material in favor of common cult values that evidently all spawn from some guys website that didn't even know what the term "reconnection rate" even related to until last week, AFTER he created that website!

EU Haters think PLASMA is optional in the 'reconnection' process, even though all the PUBLISHED MHD PAPERS and PUBLISHED books *ABSOLUTELY INCLUDE* and do not exclude CHARGED PARTICLES in the process.

They all think "drag racing" occurs when one puts gas into a gas can, not when they actually accelerate anything!

They all think WIKI lies when it claims that reconnection occurs IN a plasma and *INCLUDES* (doesn't exclude) charged particle kinetic energy transfers from the field to the particles.

Most of them think they can gain credible knowledge of plasma physics based not on actual textbooks on the topic, but rather based upon what they read on some website in cyberspace. Not that most (in some cases ALL) of the this stuff is written by guys that don't own any textbooks on the topic! It's like clairvoyant physics 101 around here, and WIKI be damned.
 
Last edited:
Electrical discharges cannot occur in conductors even through they can ONLY occur in/through conductors.

Nope. People that understand basic physics know that electrical discharges (such as lightning) occur when a dielectric medium breaks down and becomes conductive. They also know that a discharge (such as lightning) cannot occur in a normally conductive medium because conductors do not allow for any significant build-up of charge because... wait for it... they are conductive.
 
Current is not plasma.

Yes, a moving charged particle in a vacuum (current) is a particle in the PLASMA state! A single moving iron ion (current) is still a single atom in a PLASMA state! The a charged particle in movement in a vacuum is a particle in a PLASMA state! I even provided you with a link that talked cathode rays in a vacuum being a FORM of PLASMA!

Somov's example uses two idealized currents to generate magnetic fields.

Bingo. The movement of the particles CREATES the magnetic field. There is no FIELD without charged particle movement in the VACUUM! Somov's example is *INCLUSIVE* of charged particle movement. In fact he claims the process occurs *IF* the currents MOVE TOWARD EACH OTHER. He even describes the cause/effect relationship between the movement of current and the change in the magnetic field.

The reconnection happens in the vacuum region when the currents move towards each other.

No, the FLUX happens in that region. The RECONNECTION took place between the two CURRENTS as the line "encloses" (still don't like that word) both CURRENTS and has a PHYSICAL EFFECT on BOTH CURRENTS!

The currents are not in the vacuum region.

Yes, they ARE IN the vacuum CREATING those fields, and the VACUUM doesn't accelerate due to the flux changes, the CURRENTS experience ACCELERATION from that FLUX CHANGE.

Even if they were, two copper wires in a vacuum could still produce magnetic reconnection in a vacuum with no plasma.

If I can understand this, why can't you?

For starters, because Somov didn't include any WIRES. That's another of you EQUIVOCATION fallacies. Secondly, even if you did, those WIRES and those MOVING CHARGED PARTICLES still experience the "reconnection", not the "vacuum"! Wake up and smell the coffee. Read the Wiki link. It's a THREE PART process, not a ONE FLUX CHANGE PROCESS.

It REQUIRES plasma, it REQUIRES flux changes, and it REQUIRES a transfer of magnetic field energy *INTO* particle kinetic energy. It's not 'flux happens'.

It's just like my drag racing analogy. You guys don't even understand the idea correctly. You think just because you found some gas in a can that you *ALREADY* did some drag racing. You'll have to ACCELERATE something PHYSICAL to call it "drag racing/reconnection".
 
Nope. People that understand basic physics know that electrical discharges (such as lightning) occur when a dielectric medium breaks down and becomes conductive.

People that know physics know that the electrical discharge process doesn't STOP when the dielectric breakdown occurs. They know the difference between the actual DISCHARGE PROCESS and the FIRST STEP in CREATING A CONDUCTIVE PATH that allows the ELECTRICAL DISCHARGE to occur.

They also know that a discharge (such as lightning) cannot occur in a normally conductive medium because conductors do not allow for any significant build-up of charge because... wait for it... they are conductive.

Tell it to Dungey and Bruce and Birkeland and Peratt. They know better.
 
Speaking of a laughable brandishing of ignorance like a sword, do you even personally own a plasma physics textbook? I do own and I've read at least one of Somov's whole BOOKS on the topic of PLASMA physics. Have you?

Talk about walking before you can run. I had to explain to you the other day that a single charged particle does not constitute a plasma. Maybe you should take the time to understand the basics of plasma physics (like what a plasma is) before bragging about how your ownership of a plasma physics text book makes you some sort of demi-god.
 
Follow this line...

The continued refusal to quantitatively objectively explain the alleged evidence is noted.


It has been concluded that there is no objective quantitative explanation for the claim that the TRACE running difference image shows a solid/rigid/iron surface thousands of kilometers below the photosphere. Regarding the image below, which is also claimed to show a surface several thousand kilometers below the photosphere...

sdo000.jpg

The original image was at the full resolution available to the SDO AIA, 4096x4096 pixels. This is a 800x600 pixel crop, resized to 640x480 pixels to reduce file size. It comes from a PR image which accompanied a press release in early April, 2010. The image, according to the SDO science team, is a RGB composite assembled using data from individual images gathered on March 30, 2010, plus a semi-transparent round overlay. Although NASA doesn't make any such claim, according to electric/iron Sun proponents it allows us to see through 80,000 kilometers of opaque plasma. The greenish rim around the Sun's disk is claimed to be plasma which has somehow become semi-transparent by applying some sort of image processing technique.

Here are seven images cropped to match the size and location of the image above. All of these were acquired within a few seconds of each other, about 15:00 UTC on March 20, 2012. They are from the AIA filters aboard the SDO satellite, the same instruments and from the same original sized images as were used to create the PR image that allegedly gives us a sort of X-ray vision through 80,000 kilometers of plasma...

sdo094.jpg


sdo131.jpg


sdo171.jpg


sdo193.jpg


sdo211.jpg


sdo304.jpg


sdo335.jpg

Since the claim about the results of the image are, for all practical and technical purposes, impossible, it would be helpful to get a detailed explanation. These questions have been ignored for almost two years now. Maybe we'll get more cooperation this time.

Provide a quantitative objective analysis of the PR image as it relates to the original data images, similar examples of which are posted above. Explain exactly the process that must be applied to the data images to generate a result which significantly matches the PR image. Duplicate the process as nearly as possible. Explain exactly where the data comes from, how we can objectively verify that, and how we can independently reproduce the results. Explain how the process and the results can be objectively analyzed by solar physicists so they can also arrive at the conclusion that they're seeing through 80,000 kilometers of plasma in the photosphere.

I can link the black disk overlay in 100% and in 25% opacity, too. Depending on the software used to process the images, one of them will probably be necessary to recreate the results.
 
Last edited:
People that know physics know that the electrical discharge process doesn't STOP when the dielectric breakdown occurs. They know the difference between the actual DISCHARGE PROCESS and the FIRST STEP in CREATING A CONDUCTIVE PATH that allows the ELECTRICAL DISCHARGE to occur.
Not really relevant is it? No dielectric medium, no lightning-like discharge.

Tell it to Dungey and Bruce and Birkeland and Peratt. They know better.
Do they talk about lightning in the absence of a dielectric medium. If so, please quote them. Otherwise I completely fail to see the relevance of these names.
 
Michael, the CURRENTS don't reconnect, the VACUUM doesn't reconnect, the MAGNETIC FIELD LINES reconnect IN THE VACUUM.

Sheesh.

I still sincerely believe you may have a learning disability related to reading. This is because I wish to have a charitable explanation for your behaviour.
 
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnetic_reconnection

Magnetic reconnection is a physical process in highly conducting plasmas in which the magnetic topology is rearranged and magnetic energy is converted to kinetic energy, thermal energy, and particle acceleration.

You folks still can't tell the difference between "flux change/gas in a can" and "reconnection/drag racing'. FYI, the first two require no acceleration of matter to occur. The last two PROCESSES require an acceleration process to occur. Wake up and smell the coffee!
 
Not really relevant is it? No dielectric medium, no lightning-like discharge.

Not all atoms in the solar atmosphere are fully ionized. There are some NON ionized particles that WILL be ionized during the process. Likewise some ions exist in the atmosphere BEFORE lightning occurs.

You're again hiding behind an equivocation fallacy that equates "dialectric breakdown' as a REQUIREMENT for a discharge when no such requirement exists. An electrical discharge can occur in a solid and NEVER ionized that solid! You're literally CHANGING the definition of electrical discharge to suit yourselves, not in the way Dungey uses the term or the way Peratt uses the term.

Do they talk about lightning in the absence of a dielectric medium. If so, please quote them. Otherwise I completely fail to see the relevance of these names.

Dungey used the term "electrical discharge" in the same "process" of reconnection that occurs in solar flares. You don't like it. You don't want to deal with it. You therefore make up excuses to NOT deal with it.
 
Last edited:
Dungey used the term "electrical discharge" in the same "process" of solar flares. You don't like it. You don't want to deal with it. You therefore make up excuses to NOT deal with it.
I visited my university library. I looked up that paper. I downloaded it using my university access. I posted Dungey's definition of "electrical disharge" from that paper in this very thread. It has been quoted to you multiple times. You completely deny his definition yet you continue to cite him as support for yours.

This is profoundly dishonest of you. Stop it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom