Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Michael Mozina, List the "light sources" of the original 171A TRACE images

Let's follow you as you run from my question about the LIGHT sources of 171A ORIGINAL images! What are they GM?
That is rather dumb - GM is not running away from the question.
He knows that you cannot understand the answer because you have not been able to understand it for years now (at least 6 years since you first revealed your fantasy of an iron surface on the Sun).

The answer is there is only one light source for any image taken on the Sun - the plasma emitting the light (Duh!). Or if you like you can consider it as billions and billions of light sources (every ion in the plasma).

In this case, the plasma in the transition region (thousands of kilometers above the photosphere) has been heated to > 160,000 K and is emitting light. The majority of the light comes from Fe ions.

This plasma happens to be heating on one side of the flares in the images and cooling on the other side of the flares. Thus taking a running difference between the images gives dark and light areas on each side of the flares. This gives the illusion of "mountain ranges" on which you base your delusions:
The delusional nature of Michael Mozina's fantasy about the TRACE RD 171A movie!.

But it would be good to get your scientific analysis (:rolleyes:) of the images that pinpoints the light sources in the images so:
Michael Mozina, List the "light sources" of the original 171A TRACE images.
 
Last edited:
That is rather dumb - GM is not running away from the question.
He knows that you cannot understand the answer because you have not been able to understand it for years now (at least 6 years since you first revealed your fantasy of an iron surface on the Sun).

The answer is there is only one light source for any image taken on the Sun - the plasma emitting the light (Duh!). Or if you like you can consider it as billions and billions of light sources (every ion in the plasma).

In this case, the plasma in the transition region (thousands of kilometers above the photosphere) has been heated to > 160,000 K and is emitting light. The majority of the light comes from Fe ions.

This plasma happens to be heating on one side of the flares in the images and cooling on the other side of the flares. Thus taking a running difference between the images gives dark and light areas on each side of the flares. This gives the illusion of "mountain ranges" on which you base your delusions:
The delusional nature of Michael Mozina's fantasy about the TRACE RD 171A movie!.

But it would be good to get your scientific analysis (:rolleyes:) of the images that pinpoints the light sources in the images so:
Michael Mozina, List the "light sources" of the original 171A TRACE images.

Errh, I think you're wasting your time here. MM is banned. :D
 
I don't doubt that claim, but it doesn't invalidate my beliefs in any way.
That is because your beliefs are delusions because the facts that D'rok pointed out have been told to you for years:
Originally Posted by D'rok
30 seconds on NASA's site reveal two pieces of information that, by themselves, completely invalidate your claims about seeing deep into the interior of the Sun and about solid features on the surface.

1. The instrument is called the Transition Region and Coronal Explorer
2. The filter used for those images captures a temperature passband of 160,000 to 200,000,000 Kelvin
and you persist with the "beliefs" that
  1. The transition region is below the photosphere :eye-poppi.
  2. That a solid iron surface exists at temperatures of 160,000 to 200,000,000 Kelvin :eye-poppi.
And even more delusions, e.g. that the less than 1 photon emitted per year from 4800 km below the surface of the Sun can be detected :eye-poppi.
 
It's UNDER the photosphere in the SDO images!
The SDO image"green line" is a processing artifact as confirmed by the NASA team.

And a blatant mistake: Your delusion is that the transition region is below the photosphere in one SDO public relations image.

The stupidity and ignorance of claiming that the transition region is below the photosphere is abysmal- the transition region is above the photosphere by definition, no light is detectable from below the photosphere.

Michael Mozina delusion that light is detectable from 4800 km "under the photosphere"!

ETA: MM: Why have you never in almost 2 years, contacted the SDO team about the image?
 
Last edited:
Farewell to Michael Mozina

As of his final post, Michael Mozina had posted 2983 of the 7442 posts in this thread.

That's 40.08%.

I'll miss him too. He was kinda cute when we were just sniggering, but he couldn't handle being told he was wrong, especially when the refutations involved math—which, given the nature of physics, they often did.

If not for Michael Mozina, I'd never have heard of magnetic reconnection, and I doubt whether I'd ever have read any of Alfvén's papers.

Even before I encountered Michael Mozina, I had heard it said that magnetic field lines never begin or end, and that this was a consequence of Gauss's law for magnetism. I had never encountered that myth in a physics course, or in a text or paper I trusted, but it sounded plausible enough for me to try to prove it. I failed, and reserved judgement on whether it was true. Now, thanks in part to Michael Mozina's unfaltering opposition to truth in physics, I know a simple counterexample.

So I learned a few things from him, despite his best efforts to the contrary.
 
+1 I've learned a lot about astrophysics just from seeing MMs wrongitude corrected.
Me too.

W.D.Clinger wrote up a very nice piece collecting his work here on magnetic reconnection into a single page: Magnetic Reconnection. As long as that page remains up, there's an excellent, single source for material on this topic. You can use that next time you encounter magnetic reconnection wrongitude (lovely word that!), which you surely will.

However, it would be wonderful to have all of Tim Thompson's excellent posts similarly collected into a single page, preferably not on JREF, for easy reference. For example, the series of posts starting here (though that's just a small subset of all the great posts on the topic that he wrote).

Anyone have any suggestions on how that might be done?
 
dasmiller said:
Wowsers! I certainly understood his occasional suspensions, but I never thought he'd get himself banned.
It's not the first time---he was banned on BAUT and Sciforums a long time ago.
And from some ten days' ago:

Actually I tend to sleep 7+ hours a night unless I'm on a programming binge. I just spend WAY too much of my awake time here. :( I really will "eventually" wean myself from this place and move on to healthier more productive discussions on Thunderbolts, but I was really curious to find out just how deep this denial of PHYSICAL fact would go. Now I know. They take it to the EXTREME! :)
He seems to have been good to his word, posting at a pretty furious rate there recently.

I wonder how long it will be before he's banned there too?
 
I expect this thread will fade away soon. Before it does I would really like to thank the many posters who, over several years of replying to and correcting MM, have provided us less knowledgable folks with some good education in real physics/astrophysics. I will not mention all by name because I would likely miss someone, and that would not be fair, but your efforts and patience (even if a bit strained at times) are very much appreciated.
 
I expect this thread will fade away soon. Before it does I would really like to thank the many posters who, over several years of replying to and correcting MM, have provided us less knowledgable folks with some good education in real physics/astrophysics. I will not mention all by name because I would likely miss someone, and that would not be fair, but your efforts and patience (even if a bit strained at times) are very much appreciated.

ditto
 
What is amazing in the number of views compared to the number of posts.
7,472 / 121,334

or 16x more views than posts, and amazing thing in SMT, or at least for this old a thread.

(I know the statistics are against me. :D )
 
W.D.Clinger wrote up a very nice piece collecting his work here on magnetic reconnection into a single page: Magnetic Reconnection. As long as that page remains up, there's an excellent, single source for material on this topic. You can use that next time you encounter magnetic reconnection wrongitude (lovely word that!), which you surely will.


Yes, Michael's willful ignorance and convoluted misunderstanding of that issue alone was (and will undoubtedly continue to be) epic.

However, it would be wonderful to have all of Tim Thompson's excellent posts similarly collected into a single page, preferably not on JREF, for easy reference. For example, the series of posts starting here (though that's just a small subset of all the great posts on the topic that he wrote).


Yes, too. Pretty much all the pro-electric/iron Sun arguments were shown to be nonsense by reading Tim's thorough and well written posts and perusing his links. Tim has been at this for many years. When I first heard of the electric Sun/Universe stuff back around 2004 or 2005, I looked around to find the real science. I found it in some of his rebuttals posted around the 'net. When he joined this forum and started posting in these electric/iron Sun pseudoscience threads, I was pleased to find out it was the same Tim Thompson.

As for my own fluency in solar/astro/plasma physics, I'd compare it to my ability in the French language. I learned a lot of it in school and more by self teaching. It was a very long time ago. I can read it pretty well and understand what I read, write it a little but not with much confidence, and I don't really speak it very well. Many of the other posters here are far more articulate, knowledgeable, and organized than I. And I appreciate that. I've learned a lot here.

As for my contribution, much of Michael's wrongness is built on his misunderstanding of a couple of optical illusions and some intentional misrepresentation of various satellite imagery. I have a blog page which explains running difference images and Michael's serious errors in using them to support his nutty fantasy. It's a few short pages, and although it's somewhat disjointed, it should be a little informative to anyone who wants to know more about it. You can find those pages through this link.
 
Comments on Solar Silliness

About a month ago, I predicted that Mozina would choose to deliberately get himself banned ...

Why is it that Mozina is only too happy to call anybody who disagrees with him a "hater", while at the same time deliberately ignoring the non hate-based reasons for disagreeing with him? I don't think Mozina will stop posting here because he loves to be insulted, to feel insulted, and to insult back. In fact, rather than leave, I think he will deliberately get himself banned as a badge of honor. Anything to avoid any real discussion of real science.


I confess some surprise that he did it quite so soon, but I do believe that he did it deliberately. Now he can crow about being suppressed by a fearful mainstream establishment that would rather run than fight. He is completely delusional and unable to deal with reality. But of course, you already know that.

I have been of doing more useful things than dealing with the frustration of being forced by civility to pretend that Mozina deserves any kind of serious respect. Good riddance. I am flattered by the suggestion that my posts should be archived somewhere and I will look into that.
 
I confess some surprise that he did it quite so soon, but I do believe that he did it deliberately. Now he can crow about being suppressed by a fearful mainstream establishment that would rather run than fight.

Yeah, I think that's a strong possibility. It may not have been an entirely conscious decision, but like I said earlier, I was surprised to see him get banned. I wasn't surprised at his occasional suspensions, but IMO he'd previously stayed well clear of anything bannable. Perhaps even he realized that he was getting deeper into the weird with the reconnection discussion. "Reconnection in vacuum is a real physical process" means that reconnection cannot occur in a vacuum? Lordy . . .

He is completely delusional and unable to deal with reality. But of course, you already know that.

Frankly, I'm a bit puzzled by this. Certainly, some of his fixations seemed almost schizophrenic to me (caveat: IANAP) but he seemed to have a successful career in programming, so I'd think that he had to be fairly functional IRL. I didn't notice any other symptoms of schizophrenia (word salad, neologisms, way-out-of-the-box connections, etc). But on the the whole astrophysics thing, yeah, "delusional and unable to deal with reality" seems like a reasonable description.

He seemed to have a profound aversion to ever admitting he was wrong about anything, and that forced him into stranger and stranger positions. Maybe that was the real problem; he'd come up with some ideas that seemed plausible, and rather than admit they were wrong, he had to keep adding to his increasingly-strange, increasingly-elaborate worldview.
 
Why was he banned?

Its a hell of a lot of time he's put into this thread and others.

I gave up trying to argue a lot of things on the internet. Someone on the internet is always wrong, you could waste your life here arguing with people and never getting anywhere.

Someone-is-wrong-on-internet.png
 
Its a hell of a lot of time he's put into this thread and others.


Yes. Michael first started spouting his nonsense on the Internet almost seven years ago. There are people who were just getting out of high school when he started, people who have gone on to acquire masters degrees in physics in the mean time. And in that time while thousands of people went from high school kids to professionals in various fields of physics, actually advancing their understanding of physics and the relevant math, Michael hasn't added a single productive thing to his repertoire. Without a doubt he has written millions of words on various forums, and he's still just as wrong as the day he started.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom