Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.

What do you mean "nope'? Even single ions have various PROPERTIES such as EM field sensitivity, velocity, mass, etc. Bulk properties are simply derived from the individual particle tendencies, such as their direction of movement in an EM field, their total mass, etc.

A single atom in a vacuum is not easy to compress and does not expand to fill its container, to give two astonishingly obvious indicators that a single atom is nothing like a gas.

Well, the single neutral atom is going to bounce around the chamber like any ordinary gas and be unaffected by any EM fields we introduce. A plamsa particle will also bounce around like a gas whereas it WILL be affected by EM fields because it's a PLASMA. The "pressure" in a vacuum is typically a function of the molecules present it the chamber. Even one atom means the pressure in the vacuum is greater than zero.

Gases and plasmas are defined by their bulk properties, interactions and tendencies. If something doesn't have bulk properties it cannot be reliably modelled as a quantity that is defined in terms of its bulk properties.

You're telling me that the "currents" don't have any bulk properties, even when there are many charged particles present in the current?

Thus an atom, ionized or otherwise, cannot be reliably modelled as a gas or plasma.

Boloney. I can even make predictions about it's movement in an EM field based on the STATE of the matter based on whether it's an ion (plasma form) or not. I can make reliable models based on the movement of one particle. I can even give you the approximate pressure of that one particle in a vacuum if you give me the dimensions, and the temperature. PV=nRT.
 
Last edited:
Magnetic reconnection doesn't happen in a vaccum in the real world, despite what the field lines say; likewise, I wont ever physically bump into the equator of the Earth, despite what the map lines might say.

Can people agree on this analogy?
 
Last edited:
Notice that this is a Wikipedia article on magnetic reconnection in plasma?

We have a textbook that has a section on reconnection in vacuum (followed by a chapter on reconecdtion in plasma :eye-poppi!): Cosmic plasma physics By Boris V. Somov.

We have Peer reviewed material that states plasma is optional in MR

Whic reminds me: A couple of outstanding questions for you MM:
 
At least Sisyphus got the rock up to the top of the mountain before its ultimate tumble. The rock being pushed by RC, Clinger, The Man, et al. just seems to rattle around with no net movement.
 
That is not your postion.

Yes, it is my position.

Your position seemed to be that reconnection is only possible in plasma.

No. Discharges occur in gasses and solids and liquids too RC. The common denominator is PHYSICAL THINGS.

No we do not because it would be insane to try to define a reconnection rate without plasma.

Yes, and therefore it's insane to try to claim reconnection occurs in a vacuum in the absence of charged particles. That's why Clinger's contraption was doomed from the start. He removed THE most important THING in "reconnection" process, specifically the plasma.
 
Last edited:
I don't know yet. Did it satisfy Peratt's other criteria?
You really shot yourself in the foot there, Michael Mozina :eek:!
For months you have been insisting that Peratt's definition just included the first sentence on that page. Now you have added the third sentence as part of the definition ("other criteria"). But what is the second sentence:
This generally occurs when the electromagnetic stress exceeds some threshold for breakdown that is usually determined by small scale properties of the energy transmission medium.
Another one of Peratt's criteria!

I suspect that we will be back to Michael Mozina's fantasy about Anthony Peratt's definition of electrical discharge! really soon now!
 
For months you have been insisting that Peratt's definition just included the first sentence on that page.

Is anything that comes out of your mouth related to me or EU theory in general actually accurate? If so, I've never seen it. I posted more than one sentence RC.

Now you have added the third sentence as part of the definition ("other criteria"). But what is the second sentence:

Another one of Peratt's criteria!

So what? That can be a breakdown of the circuit. That can be just about anything. The release of energy however has to have some tangible effect on PHYSICAL THINGS in a way that might actually explain a solar flare, including gamma rays, x-rays, filamentary pinches, etc. You can't leave out any of it, or cherry-pick parts of it like you.


I suspect you'll cling to the denial-go-round for a lot longer. :(
 
Notice that this is a Wikipedia article on magnetic reconnection in plasma?

We have a textbook that has a section on reconnection in vacuum (followed by a chapter on reconecdtion in plasma :eye-poppi!): Cosmic plasma physics By Boris V. Somov.

We have Peer reviewed material that states plasma is optional in MR

Whic reminds me: A couple of outstanding questions for you MM:

Well, you batted 1000. You misrepresented everyone and every link you provided, all of which are based on MHD theory and/or charged particle movement including Somov who included, not excluded MOVING CHARGED PARTICLES in his example.
 
It honestly blows my mind that a bunch of math aficionados can't come up with a formula for the rate of reconnection in the absence of plasma, and yet they don't see a problem? Wow! Mindboggling!
 
I don't know yet.

Really? That’s not what you asserted before….
Well, sort of. In the sense you're releasing stored EM energy, yes, that is in fact an "electrical discharge". It's not actually an "electrical discharge in plasma' however. I suppose you could suspend the magnets *IN* a plasma and release them. The FLUX CHANGES that occur will likely induce currents. Assuming you could store and release enough magnetic field energy, I suppose it COULD result in an ELECTRICAL DISCHARGE that might result in highly ionized iron, x-rays, gamma rays, etc.
Have you lost some of that knowledge between then and now?
Did it satisfy Peratt's other criteria?
Got “Cosmic Plasma” in your home now too? Been hitting those coronas perchance?

Did you miss the “usually accompanied by” in what you did bold?

Do you understand what that means?

You certainly seemed to before, perhaps that is the knowledge you seem now to have lost?

You tell me.
No again I’ll let you do it…
...yes, that is in fact an "electrical discharge". It's not actually an "electrical discharge in plasma' however.
So the question of “do you now accept that the experiment is an “electrical discharge”” has already passed, the outstanding one is “and “"reconnection"” as you profess those terms to mean”?
 
MM: State your position on MR without plasma and list citations to support it

Yes, it is my position.
So your position is that MR is possible in plasma. Wow - you just happen to agree with the actual science that everyone here agrees with!

We though can show that it is also possible without plasma:
Cosmic plasma physics By Boris V. Somov
Peer reviewed material that states plasma is optional in MR
W.D. Clinger's simple derivation of magnetic reconnection (no plasma :jaw-dropp!)

What is your position on MR without plasma?

If it is that MR without plasma is possible then we have been wasting our time over the last few months. The simple fact is then that MR at the null point (in vacuum) can happen when distant currents change as in Somov and W.d. Clinger's examples.

If it is that MR without plasma is impossible then list citations.

No. Discharges occur in gasses and solids and liquids too RC. The common denominator is PHYSICAL THINGS.
Who cares about discharges, MM? They are not MR.
If you want "PHYSICAL THINGS" then put "PHYSICAL THINGS" in Somov and W.D. Clinger's examples and MR in vacuum still happens at the null point where there are no "PHYSICAL THINGS".

The fact remains that MR happens at the null point. The null point is in vacuum in Somov's textbook example and W.D. Clinger's simple derivation of magnetic reconnection. Thus MR in vacuum.
And actual plasma scientist have no problem with MR in vacuum: Peer reviewed material that states plasma is optional in MR

Yes, and therefore it's insane to try to claim reconnection occurs in a vacuum in the absence of charged particles
No one should be ignorant enough to think that the reconnection rate (defined only for plasma) means that reconnection cannot happen in a vacuum.

It is insane to ignore that fact that reconnection occurs in a vacuum away from any currents (Somov and W.D. Clinger) or your fantasy of charged particles in Somov's example.
 
So your position is that MR is possible in plasma. Wow - you just happen to agree with the actual science that everyone here agrees with!

No. Every single one of you believe in nonsense, not actual "peer reviewed science". No publications claim plasma is optional in the reconnection process.,
 
Magnetic reconnection doesn't happen in a vaccum in the real world, despite what the field lines say; likewise, I wont ever physically bump into the equator of the Earth, despite what the map lines might say.

Can people agree on this analogy?
Magnetic reconnection can happen in a vacuum. Just do the bar magnet experiment in a vacuum. W.D.Clinger's simple derivation of magnetic reconnection just needs 4 wires in a vacuum. But hey - maybe Maxwell's equations are wrong :rolleyes:! Or maybe you can go through W.D.Clinger's derivation and show us the mistake?

Your anology is wrong. Only an idiot would think that magnetic field lines or map lines are real things that you can "physically bump into".
 
Last edited:
I think 80% of this thread is just down equivocation misunderstandings.

Electricty did it / Magnetism did it, is a classic, for example.

Someone versed in basic electromagnetism will know they are at a basic level, the same. The difference is way we conceptualize them. Magnetism with field lines, flux strength, vector fields, etc, and other constructs. Currents with motion, charge, particle properties, vector fields, etc. But you can still define magnetism with the concepts I list after currents, and vice versa. Are EM fields constant, or quantized? Both. But they can't be, really. We end up back at 'is it a particle or wave?' type debate by the end. Or Bu and Ej approaches to various plasma related geo/stellar physics models.

Both can lead to totally different results/predictions/models on occasions, as the conceptualizations used for both is different.
 
Then it doesn't help you at all.
Who said it did?

This reconnection topic came up because Zeuzzz mentioned it wrt MR in experiments. I then cited the definition of reconneciton rate which is only defined in plasma. You then went off on a tangent about demanding that it has to be defined without plasma.

But it seems that we agree now. Reconnection rate is defined in models that are based on MHD theory. MHD theory describes plasma. Thus reconnection rates only apply to plasma.
 
I think 80% of this thread is just down equivocation misunderstandings.
I know that 80% of this thread is just down to the inabilty to understand (or accept) what people have written in scientific papers and textbooks.

There are few "equivocation misunderstandings". There have been some instances of context misunderstanding, e.g. that "electrical discharge" in the context of a few old papers about MR causing flares does not mean lightning!.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom