Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Oh, I'm sure you're going to misrepresent what I said.

If I put an atom of non ionized iron into a vacuum a give it momentum, it's in the "gas" state. If I ionize that same moving atom, it's in a "plasma" state, and it's also a form of "current'. Likewise, electrons encased in non-ionized particles are just electrons. Free electrons that are moving through a vacuum are particles in the plasma state and also a form of current. You guys act as though a PLASMA state is not a state of MATTER!

No, YOU are acting as if plasma is not a state of matter. States of matter are only defined for large groups of atoms. An individual ion is just an ion, not plasma, just like an individual atom is not solid, liquid, or gas.
 
Exactly where they’ve stood for sometime now. At an experiment you can perform in your own home which meets your requirements for “electrical discharge” and “"reconnection"” by “the transfer of energy from the magnetic field to particle kinetic energy” with no intervening plasma. You can run around all you want insisting that people dance to your tune but the music has stopped and you have left yourself without a chair.

You've made that two magnet claim a bunch of times but every time I ask you to support that claim with PUBLISHED materials, you refuse/run. The only one doing any dancing here is your side. You all keep paroting the exact same claim and all keep refusing to provide PUBLISHED SUPPORT for that very same claim.

I've seen MANY textbooks on basic EM theory that describe the interactions of two magnets in a vacuum. I have NEVER seen the term 'reconnection" used in them. Clinger's books don't include the term 'reconnection" either. Why is that? Why is it that you all run like hell when I ask for a PUBLISHED reference to support that claim that reconnection occurs between two magnets in a vacuum without even accelerating a single particle? Somov certainly didn't make that claim.
 
Last edited:
No, YOU are acting as if plasma is not a state of matter. States of matter are only defined for large groups of atoms. An individual ion is just an ion, not plasma, just like an individual atom is not solid, liquid, or gas.

You'd need two or more atoms in a vacuum to call it a solid or a liquid because those two states of matter relate to the COMBINED PROPERTIES of multiple atoms. A single atom in a vacuum is either in a gas state or a plasma state depending on it's ionization state. A single ionized iron atom moving through a vacuum is a still an iron atom in the plasma state, and it's movement makes it a form of "current'.
 
Since the author can't be trusted to even represent my position on this topic accurately, it's clearly unreliable, unpublished, unpublishable nonsense. Individual magnetic B lines do not begin, they do not end they do not have a source, they do not have a sink. In fact a FIELD forms as a FULL continuum. Individual lines are incapable of "reconnecting" to other LINES because there really aren't any "lines" in the first place! There are just two *ENTIRE FIELDS* that interact and flux and change over time.

Where as you can always be trusted to simply ignore what you have already been told. The field lines are just a way to visualize the magnetic force vector field. As that vector field (the magnitude and direction of the vectors) changes the lines that represent that field also change topology. Magnetic reconnection refers to a specific topology where one set of opposing field lines can have two different configurations (the lower energy one usually dominating). As a result the vector field can now change in a way it was constrained fro m before (the vectors weren’t pointing in the right directions). It is a basic and fundamental aspect of magnetism that again you can demonstrate with a simple experiment in your own home.
 
Where as you can always be trusted to simply ignore what you have already been told. The field lines are just a way to visualize the magnetic force vector field. As that vector field (the magnitude and direction of the vectors) changes the lines that represent that field also change topology. Magnetic reconnection refers to a specific topology where one set of opposing field lines can have two different configurations (the lower energy one usually dominating). As a result the vector field can now change in a way it was constrained fro m before (the vectors weren’t pointing in the right directions). It is a basic and fundamental aspect of magnetism that again you can demonstrate with a simple experiment in your own home.

I have no doubt that "flux change happens", attraction happens, repulsion happens, etc. What CANNOT happen is "reconnection" unless and until you ACCELERATE something physical because of those flux changes.
 
Ya know.....

The rate of reconnection question is your Waterloo. If you think I'm letting it go, foregetaboutit. If you can't come up with a rate of reconnection in the absence of mass acceleration, then you can't call it "reconnection'. Reconnection is the PROCESS of converting field energy into particle kinetic energy and the RATE of reconnection is the RATE at which that occurs. :) You're up a metaphysical creek without a physical paddle. :)
 
You've made that two magnet claim a bunch of times but every time I ask you to support that claim with PUBLISHED materials, you refuse/run. The only one doing any dancing here is your side. You all keep paroting the exact same claim and all keep refusing to provide PUBLISHED SUPPORT for that very same claim.

What claim is that exactly. That you can perform the experiment in your own home? That it doesn’t involve intervening plasma? That it meets your requirements for “electrical discharge” and “"reconnection"” by “the transfer of energy from the magnetic field to particle kinetic energy”? What exactly of those claims to you anticipate should be in “PUBLISHED materials”? Were not your requirements for “electrical discharge” and “"reconnection"” by “the transfer of energy from the magnetic field to particle kinetic energy” derived from your own interpretation of “PUBLISHED materials”? What more would you expect of an “electrical discharge” and “"reconnection"” experiment other than it meet your professed requirements?

I've seen MANY textbooks on basic EM theory that describe the interactions of two magnets in a vacuum. I have NEVER seen the term 'reconnection" used in them. Clinger's books don't include the term 'reconnection" either. Why is that? Why is it that you all run like hell when I ask for a PUBLISHED reference to support that claim that reconnection occurs between two magnets in a vacuum without even accelerating a single particle? Somov certainly didn't make that claim.

Yet this experiment with two magnets meets your stated requirements for “electrical discharge” and “"reconnection"” by “the transfer of energy from the magnetic field to particle kinetic energy”.

In case you’ve missed it or simply refuse to accept it, I’ve given you exactly what you asked for and you’re the only one now simply trying to run away from yourself.
 
I have no doubt that "flux change happens", attraction happens, repulsion happens, etc. What CANNOT happen is "reconnection" unless and until you ACCELERATE something physical because of those flux changes.

The free magnet gets accelerated in the recommended experiment. So again it meets your requirement of ""reconnection"". You’ve been given exactly what you assert you require yet still claim it "CANNOT happen".
 
What claim is that exactly. That you can perform the experiment in your own home?

No, I accept that claim.

That it doesn’t involve intervening plasma? That it meets your requirements for “electrical discharge” and “"reconnection"” by “the transfer of energy from the magnetic field to particle kinetic energy”?

What are you transferring kinetic energy to and from exactly? The physical magnets? There aren't any magnets in the corona.

What exactly of those claims to you anticipate should be in “PUBLISHED materials”? Were not your requirements for “electrical discharge” and “"reconnection"” by “the transfer of energy from the magnetic field to particle kinetic energy” derived from your own interpretation of “PUBLISHED materials”? What more would you expect of an “electrical discharge” and “"reconnection"” experiment other than it meet your professed requirements?

Yet this experiment with two magnets meets your stated requirements for “electrical discharge” and “"reconnection"” by “the transfer of energy from the magnetic field to particle kinetic energy”.

In case you’ve missed it or simply refuse to accept it, I’ve given you exactly what you asked for and you’re the only one now simply trying to run away from yourself.

Now you've totally lost and confused me. What exactly have you demonstrated with your experiment other than the fact that the TRANSFER OF MAGNETIC FIELD ENERGY into KINETIC energy is a REQUIREMENT for "reconnection"? Clinger didn't accelerate anything.
 
Michael Mozina isn't telling the truth, part 1

No, that's a myth. Most magnetic field lines have no beginning or end, but magnetic field lines can begin or end at neutral points,

False. I showed you over a dozen *PUBLISHED* references that said they had no beginning and no ending, *EVER*. They made no such references to special locations or neutral points. That's entirely YOUR claim, and you've never demonstrated it.
False.

I demonstrated my claim by giving a mathematical proof.

I and others have also cited published references, such as Pontin's article, which is to appear in Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society A: Mathematical, Physical and Engineering Sciences.

as in the field generated by four parallel conducting rods, with equal currents in the north and south rods and equal but oppositely directed currents in the west and east rods.

No, that particular website is UNPUBLISHED NONSENSE that *ACTUALLY* demonstrates that the NULL point is NOT special in any way
False.

and Guass's laws are satisfied in the NULL just like everywhere else in the chamber!
True.

That web site does indeed prove that Gauss's law for magnetism, along with the rest of Maxwell's equations, is satisfied by all of the magnetic fields shown at that web site.

Michael Mozina, however, had been trying to argue that Gauss's law is not satisfied by the fields shown at that web site. Maybe he forgot what he's trying to argue.

Furthermore I know for a fact that the author of that particular website is KNOWN to make, and continues to make highly erroneous and inaccurate statements. For instance the same author claims that I personally deny that magnetic reconnection is a real process. I deny no such thing.
False.

Michael Mozina denied his denial of magnetic reconnection on 21 November 2011. Tim Thompson demolished Michael Mozina's denial of his denial the following day, in a post titled Does Mozina Deny Magnetic Reconnection?.


Since the author can't be trusted to even represent my position on this topic accurately, it's clearly unreliable, unpublished, unpublishable nonsense.
False.

Since Michael Mozina can't be trusted to present his own position honestly, his opinions of others' opinions are clearly unreliable nonsense.

Individual magnetic B lines do not begin, they do not end
False.

As explained above, I have used Maxwell's equations to give a rigorous mathematical proof that two magnetic field lines end and another two magnetic field lines begin at the neutral point of the magnetic field B4.

Michael Mozina does not understand the mathematics of basic electromagnetism, so he can't find any error in that proof. He can only repeat his unshakeable conviction that he's right.

If Michael Mozina understood the math of basic EM theory, he'd understand the math at that web site. That math derives magnetic reconnection in a vacuum as a simple consequence of Maxwell's equations.

Your entire argument comes down to "because I say so even though the published material says otherwise".
False.

For one thing, my argument is based upon Maxwell's equations and their mathematical consequences. Real scientists accept such arguments. Pseudoscientists who can't handle the math reject such arguments.

For another thing, my argument is buttressed by a number of citations. Somov discussed magnetic reconnection in a vacuum. Pontin clearly stated that magnetic field lines can begin or end at null points.

Michael Mozina can only deny those publications. His entire argument comes down to flooding this forum with so many shouted denials that readers will forget Michael Mozina isn't telling the truth.
 
Last edited:
The free magnet gets accelerated in the recommended experiment. So again it meets your requirement of ""reconnection"". You’ve been given exactly what you assert you require yet still claim it "CANNOT happen".

I said it wouldn't happen *WITHOUT* mass acceleration. Your example *INCLUDES* mass acceleration. Clinger's does not.
 
False.

I demonstrated my claim by giving a mathematical proof.

The only thing you "proved" is that the NULL is *NOT* unique in terms of satisfying Gauss's laws like you claimed.

I and others have also cited published references, such as Pontin's article, which is to appear in Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society A: Mathematical, Physical and Engineering Sciences.

All your own references refuted your position because all those maths are based upon MHD theory. This is the only paper you cited and it's shoots your claim out of the water because it's based on MHD theory!

http://arxiv.org/abs/1202.4013

That web site does indeed prove that Gauss's law for magnetism, along with the rest of Maxwell's equations, is satisfied by all of the magnetic fields shown at that web site.

Nobody ever doubted that Guass's laws were satisfied EVERYWHERE, not just in the null.

Michael Mozina, however, had been trying to argue that Gauss's law is not satisfied by the fields shown at that web site. Maybe he forgot what he's trying to argue.

Er, no. I've argued from the start that "reconnection" is a process in PLASMA. You're the one moving the goal posts as fast as possible trying to hide the fact you haven't described any rates of reconnection.


Michael Mozina denied his denial of magnetic reconnection on 21 November 2011. Tim Thompson demolished Michael Mozina's denial of his denial the following day, in a post titled Does Mozina Deny Magnetic Reconnection?.

I have NEVER claimed that the process called "reconnection" didn't occur. That is your own BLATANT misrepresentation of my position.

Since Michael Mozina can't be trusted to present his own position honestly, his opinions of others' opinions are clearly unreliable nonsense.

BS.

As explained above, I have used Maxwell's equations to give a rigorous mathematical proof that two magnetic field lines end and another two magnetic field lines begin at the neutral point of the magnetic field B4.

No lines "begin" in the neutral, no lines end there, no magnetic source exists there, no sink exists there. The only thing that exists at the NULL is another unremarkable point in the chamber that satisfies Gauss's laws, just like every point in the chamber.

Michael Mozina does not understand the mathematics of basic electromagnetism, so he can't find any error in that proof. He can only repeat his unshakeable conviction that he's right.

Clinger doesn't even understand basic EM theory or he'd know that magnetic lines form as full continuous loops, without begging and without ending, without a magnetic source, without a sink. The unshakable conviction that I'm right comes from the fact that the rate of reconnection is a measurement of the transfer of magnetic field energy into charged particle kinetic energy and you left out the charged particles! That's why your rate of reconnection math is MIA and will ALWAYS be MIA.

For one thing, my argument is based upon Maxwell's equations and their mathematical consequences.

So what? They also don't demonstrate what you claim they demonstrate.

Real scientists accept such arguments. Pseudoscientists who can't handle the math reject such arguments.

Real scientists at least attempt to [URL="http://www.springerlink.com/content/906760626772561u/"]get their stuff published in peer reviewed journals[/URL]. Psueodscientists just build websites.

For another thing, my argument is buttressed by a number of citations. Somov discussed magnetic reconnection in a vacuum.

BZZZT. Somov's "vacuum" includes charged particles and charged particle acceleration. Epic Fail!

Your entire argument comes down to your own UNPUBLISHED website, and it's you vs the world of MHD theory! The math doesn't even show what you claim it shows. There is no rate of reconnection formula found there. Furthermore your absurd claim that I deny that the plasma physics process called "Reconnection" is a real process is completely false. There's nothing on that website of actual value.
 
Last edited:
So your claim and GM's claim that electrical discharges cannot occur in conductors is *ABSOLUTELY FALSE*. ;)
So the claim that anyone who knows anything about physics that electrical discharges cannot occur in conductors is is *ABSOLUTELY TRUE*. :jaw-dropp

Dungey's obsolete usage of the term 'electric discharge' = high current density in magnetic reconnection
and what you are still unable to understand:
MM: Citing Dungey means that you are stating that the cause of solar flares is magnetic reconnection not your "electrical discharges" :jaw-dropp!
8th November 2011 (5 months and counting)
 
MM: a reconnection rate in the absence of mass acceleration (15 March 2012)

D'rok, if you want to see ignorance, notice that nobody yet has offered us a way to mathematically express a rate of reconnection in the absence of mass acceleration. That's ignorance. If published, peer reviewed mathematics is the currency of physics, your side is penniless.
D'rok, if you want to see delusion, notice that MM remains wrong because a way to mathematically express a rate of reconnection in the absence of "mass acceleration" was posted on the 15th of March (Sweet-Parker model). That's a continually repeated ignorance, i.e. delusion.

Of course this "absence of mass acceleration" may be the insanity of demanding that there be no plasma: MM: What is reconnection rate of the plasma inside a rock containing no plasma?
 
It is profoundly ignorant to believe "reconnection* occurs without particle acceleration if you can't describe the RATE of reconnection without it!
We are talking about the reconnection rate. This is not the RATE of reconnection.
It sounds more and more that you are profoundly ignorant of what the reconnection rate is, e.g. in the Sweet-Parker model.
 
Last edited:
Outstanding questions for Michael Mozina

So where do things stand?

Rate of reconnection in the absence of mass acceleration: "Math? What math?"
Dungey's work on reconnection and electrical discharges in flares? "Discharges? What Discharges?"
Request for peer reviewed material to support your claim that plasma is optional: "Peer reviewed material? What peer reviewed material?".
So where do things stand?

The inability to understand that we are not discussing any "rate of reconnection".

The inability to understand that a reconnection rate "in the absence of mass acceleration" is defined, e.g. in the Sweet-Parker model.
Or the insanity of demanding that a quantity defined for plasma be defined without plasma: MM: What is reconnection rate of the plasma inside a rock containing no plasma?

The delusion that Dungey states that there are actual electrical discharges in flares: Dungey's obsolete usage of the term 'electric discharge' = high current density in magnetic reconnection

The stupidity of continuously citing someone who says that Michael Mozina is wrong: MM: Citing Dungey means that you are stating that the cause of solar flares is magnetic reconnection not your "electrical discharges" :jaw-dropp!
8th November 2011 (5 months and counting)

Lying about no citations for peer reviewed material staing that plasma is optional for MR: Peer reviewed material that states plasma is optional in MR
We have also cited a textbook that states that plasma is optional for MR: Cosmic plasma physics By Boris V. Somov.
It also only needs undergraduate sphysic knowledge to show that MR in a vacuum exist: W.D. Clinger's simple derivation of magnetic reconnection (no plasma :jaw-dropp!)

P.S. A couple of outstanding questions for you MM:
 
MM: Cite some papers that state that MR is only possible in plasma

I've got THOUSANDS, maybe tens of thousands of MHD papers on the topic of reconnection that all support my position.
Then cite some of these papers that state that magnetic reconnecvtion is only possible in plasma.

You cannot because there are THOUSANDS,maybe tens of thousands, of MHD papers on the topic of reconnection in plasma. You seem to be forgotten (or maybe never knew!)that MHD is a theory about plasma. Any MHD paper is based on the premise that there is plasma :eye-poppi!
 
Last edited:
If I ionize that same moving atom, it's in a "plasma" state, and it's also a form of "current'.
Luckily you put plasma in quotes (but given your random quoting it is probably an accident :eek:).
The science is that a single ionized atom is ... a single ionized atom!
States of matter refer to collections of atoms.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom