Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Holy smokes. Is that paper by Parnell attached to the internet via a 300 baud modem or what? It's been trying to load that PDF file for an hour now.
 
MHD models of MR have a reconnection rate that is directly related to plasma velocity, i.e. the TRANSFER of magnetic field energy into kinetic energy.

Clinger's example doesn't do that. See a problem? There's a zero rate of transfer of particle kinetic energy even POSSIBLE in step 4 of Clinger's presentation. The possible rate of reconnection is zero. There are no particles to accelerate and no currents can be induced as a result of the field changes.
 
Last edited:
The null point can be in vacuum (see Somov's and W.D.Clinger's examples) or in plasma.

What is representing the null point that I can physically measure and experiment with?

There's zero magnetic / electric potential at this point which could be deduced via ion movement (or lack there-of) but is there a distinct property you can tie down to such a point?


The "distinct property" is that the magnetic field is zero.

Magnetic fields are normally measured with a magnetometer, but a magnetic compass such as the Suunto A-10, which can be purchased for less than $20 at REI, would suffice to demonstrate magnetic reconnection.

The cruder your instruments, the better you have to understand what you're measuring. As Michael Mozina has demonstrated, those who are completely clueless cannot afford to run experiments that demonstrate magnetic reconnection.
 
Clinger's example doesn't do that. See a problem?
W.D. Clinger's example doesn't have plasma. See a problem with still not understanding that, Michael Mozina?
No plasma = there is no reconnection rate defined.
Thus it is stupid to keep mentioning that there is no reconnection rate in his example when there is no plasma in his example.
It is even more stupid to state that the "possible rate of reconnection is zero" because we are not talking about this "rate of reconnection" and the reconnection rate is not zero in W.D. Clinger's example, it is undefined.

In fact it as dead as a parrot (which you seem determined to turn into :D)

W.D. Clinger's simple derivation of magnetic reconnection has no plasma :jaw-dropp !
 
Originally Posted by Michael Mozina
On the off chance you do actually want to discuss the maths and/or the physics of the process Priest describes in terms of sources and sinks, it's found here:

http://articles.adsabs.harvard.edu//...00539.000.html
PLASMA and CURRENT are required for "reconnection" and I showed you the exact two equations in Priests 'Source/Sink' paper to prove it.

Now, here are the two equations from Priest's paper that an adamant Mozina has doggedly claimed *PROVE* reconnection requires plasma:

Equation 16
[latex]\mu_0I(z) = 4\pi\alpha^{-1} cos(\alpha|z| +\phi__r)[/latex]
[latex] for z \leq0[/latex]

Equation 17:
[latex]\sigma(z) = -4\pi\alpha^{-1} sin(\alpha|z| + \phi_r) [/latex]
[latex] for z \leq 0[/latex]


So, here you are Mr. Mozina, exposed for all to see that you are incapable of explaining the mathematics that provides the proof you falsely claim. Are you a fraud incapable of discussing these equations? Have you been pretending to understand these equations? Have you been pretending they provide the proof you claim? Come on, explain the equations above and redeem yourself!
For starters explain why the current as a function of the z axis is multiplied by μ0. Remember, go slowly because I do have a background in mathematics but only a modest knowledge of physics.
 
Last edited:
Das,

Somewhere a few pages ago you asked me what wavelengths that sun might look "dark" against the background of the universe. Maybe these wavelengths:

http://science.nasa.gov/science-news/science-at-nasa/2012/16mar_theedge/

"Fermi is picking up crazy-energetic photons," says Dave Thompson, an astrophysicist at NASA's Goddard Space Flight Center. "And it's detecting so many of them we've been able to produce the first all-sky map of the very high energy universe."

“This is what the sky looks like near the very edge of the electromagnetic spectrum, between 10 billion and 100 billion electron volts.”
 
Last edited:
You are only lying to yourself when you claim that any of those published references are plasma optional.
You are only lying to everyone when you claim that any of those published references are plasma mandatory. They explicitly state that plasma is optional.
I will make this explicit (but you will ignore this in favor of your inability to read English).
Peer reviewed material that states plasma is optional in MR


P.S.
  1. MM: State your position on MR without plasma and list citations to support it
    Asked 20 March 2012
  2. MM: Why did Somov split "Reconnection in vacuum" from "Reconnection in plasma"?
    Asked on 18th March 2012
  3. MM What does "In a vacuum, magnetic reconnection is a trival process..." mean?
    Asked on 18th March 2012
 
Hmm, If I understand the video on Youtube correctly Das, it looks to me like the sun streaks down the right side of the image in red in the video, though it sometimes fades in intensity. There do seem to be "brighter" objects, but it looks like our sun spits out those wavelengths too. That wouldn't be surprising since the galaxy does seem to show up quite clearly.
 
Das,

Somewhere a few pages ago you asked me what wavelengths that sun might look "dark" against the background of the universe. Maybe these wavelengths:

http://science.nasa.gov/science-news/science-at-nasa/2012/16mar_theedge/
Actually only sometimes - the Sun is a source of gamma radation in solar flares and can be bright against the background of the universe. The study of those gamma rays is a mission objective of Fermi.

Astronomy Picture of the Day
What shines in the gamma-ray sky? The answer is usually the most exotic and energetic of astrophysical environments, like active galaxies powered by supermassive black holes, or incredibly dense pulsars, the spinning remnants of exploded stars. But on March 7, a powerful solar flare, one of a series of recent solar eruptions, dominated the gamma-ray sky at energies up to 1 billion times the energy of visible light photons.

ETA:
The SDO image"green line" is a processing artifact as confirmed by the NASA team was not taken using gamma rays!
 
Last edited:
You're SO good at twisting the truth. FYI, I gave up doubting it was a real process *IN PLASMA* when I first read Birn's paper on the topic over at Space.com, long BEFORE I ever posted to this website. I must have explained that now a DOZEN times already, not that you are interested in scientific accuracy.


Without running through the entire thread to find all the evidence demonstrating that is not true, I'll just use this quote from the second post...

Circuits disconnect and reconnect. Magnetic lines do not.

There are hundreds more examples.

I doubt you personally will ever get there because you have too much emotional attachment to the belief that electrical discharges cannot occur in conductors. Since that's wrong even in BASIC EM theory, it's pretty much hopeless for any chance you're going to see the light.


I have no emotional attachment, and the fact that lightning-like sparks can't occur within a conductor isn't a belief. It's just elementary physics.

My name is on those papers too! If you can call me a fraud to my face on this website based on satellite imagery analysis, I can call you a fraud too Mr "Electrical discharges cannot occur in conductors".


Oliver Manuel's attribution, "NASA and Lockheed Martin’s TRACE satellite team made the image of rigid structures beneath the fluid photosphere," is fraudulent. I don't really care who chooses to share the blame with him for his attempt to defraud the scientific community. And I don't really care who chooses to share his failure.

You're wrong about even BASIC EM THEORY! You're clueless when you claim to have some kind of expertize in high energy solar satellite imagery which is demonstrated by your refusal to embrace the fact that electrical discharges occur in flares as Birkeland explained in 1908, Dungey explained in the 50's and Bruce explained in the 50's.


Leaving aside the irrelevant and uncivil personal attack, what I know about the subject has nothing to do with anything Birkeland, Dungey, or Bruce allegedly explained. As far as I'm aware, none of them had any particular expertise in satellite imagery.

You have NO right to judge anyone based on their knowledge of solar satellite imagery. None! Zero. Zip!


I haven't seen any evidence that the electric/iron Sun community has any relevant knowledge of satellite imagery. All I've seen for over half a decade are unsupported assertions that some image or other looks like a solid surface or like lightning bolts. My quote was...

No effort has been made to quantitatively describe the process which allegedly allows us to see thousands of kilometers below the photosphere by doing a simple mathematical operation on the pixels of two images acquired thousands of kilometers above the photosphere. No effort has been made to explain how a RGB composite PR image with a 25% transparent circle overlaid allegedly allows us to see through 80,000 kilometers of opaque plasma. No effort has been made to duplicate any of the image manipulation processes or explain them in detail in order to demonstrate those ridiculous claims are even plausible.

That is true. Given almost seven years to do some quantitative objective analysis or explain how those processing techniques could provide the results claimed, there hasn't been a single word of such an explanation offered. It is certainly not my fault the electric/iron Sun supporters have failed.

You can't even correctly explain the light source of a standard iron ion wavelength, and you BOTCHED the explanation as the to color above the transition region in a combined wavelength image. The color has NOTHING to do with alignment errors as you claimed. Everything you've said has been wrong beyond belief. Talk about crackpot claims!


Again leaving aside the incivility, that is an unsupported assertion. My assessment of any satellite imagery I've analyzed corresponds directly to the assessment of the NASA, Lockheed, and Stanford astrophysicists who developed the programs to acquire that imagery, designed and built the equipment used to acquire it, who process it, and who analyze the results. Those folks and I hold a position which is in polar contrast to the electric/iron Sun community where no quantitative objective assessment has ever been attempted. Again...

No effort has been made to quantitatively describe the process which allegedly allows us to see thousands of kilometers below the photosphere by doing a simple mathematical operation on the pixels of two images acquired thousands of kilometers above the photosphere. No effort has been made to explain how a RGB composite PR image with a 25% transparent circle overlaid allegedly allows us to see through 80,000 kilometers of opaque plasma. No effort has been made to duplicate any of the image manipulation processes or explain them in detail in order to demonstrate those ridiculous claims are even plausible.

And again, it is not my fault the electric/iron Sun supporters have failed.
 
You are only lying to everyone when you claim that any of those published references are plasma mandatory. They explicitly state that plasma is optional.

If plasma is optional for reconnection to occur, then the rate of reconnection should also be mathematically quantifiable without plasma. Let's see it. Stop calling me a liar until you produce it.
 
There are hundreds more examples.

So what? I provided you at least a dozen published references to support it too. B lines have no sources and no sinks.

I have no emotional attachment, and the fact that lightning-like sparks can't occur within a conductor isn't a belief. It's just elementary physics.

That's not what you claimed. You claimed that electrical discharges could not occur in conductors when in fact they can ONLY occur in conductors. That is just basic physics. If you can't handle basic physics, you certainly can't hang in any discussion over PLASMA physics. Do you even own a plasma physics textbook?

Oliver Manuel's attribution, "NASA and Lockheed Martin’s TRACE satellite team made the image of rigid structures beneath the fluid photosphere," is fraudulent.

No, it's not. Every single image used in our papers comes from NASA and/or LMSAL sources. Every one of those RD images shows rigid features that persist for DAYS, even weeks and rotate uniformly, pole to equator to pole.

I don't really care who chooses to share the blame with him for his attempt to defraud the scientific community. And I don't really care who chooses to share his failure.

The only fraud is you pretending to know anything about solar RD images. You know absolutely nothing useful about them. You don't even understand the light source of the ORIGINAL images, nor can you correctly explain the transition region color in a standard composite image.

Leaving aside the irrelevant and uncivil personal attack, what I know about the subject has nothing to do with anything Birkeland, Dungey, or Bruce allegedly explained. As far as I'm aware, none of them had any particular expertise in satellite imagery.

Yes, but I do, I was an author. You don't the first thing about plasma physics, and that is obvious. "Discharges? What discharges? Math to explain the reconnection rate without plasma? What math?"

I haven't seen any evidence that the electric/iron Sun community has any relevant knowledge of satellite imagery.

Pfft. They all know discharges occur in flares as Dungey explained. That's light years ahead of where you will EVER be.

All I've seen for over half a decade are unsupported assertions that some image or other looks like a solid surface or like lightning bolts. My quote was...

Your quote and your opinions are utterly and completely meaningless. Until you embrace the fact that electrical discharges occur in conductors, you don't know the first thing about basic EM theory, let alone PLASMA physics.

Do you even own a book on the topic of plasma physics?
 
Last edited:
Michael Mozina's delusion that a reconnection rate exists without plasma

Clingers simple derivation of a standard quadrapolar magnetic field has no plasma to accelerate and therefore it has a reconnection rate of ZERO.
So this has turned into a delusion! Who would have guessed it :rolleyes: ?

The term "reconnection rate" is defined in resistive MHD models of magnetic reconnection, e.g. Sweet-Parker and Petschek (and probably other models). These models define reconnection rate in terms of the
Lundquist number which is a parameter of a plasma. The Lundquist number uses the Alfvén speed which is a characteristic of a wave in plasma.

Now what is MHD, Michael Mozina? Since you obviously have forgotten:
Magnetohydrodynamics
Magnetohydrodynamics (MHD) (magneto fluid dynamics or hydromagnetics) is an academic discipline which studies the dynamics of electrically conducting fluids. Examples of such fluids include plasmas, liquid metals, and salt water or electrolytes. The word magnetohydrodynamics (MHD) is derived from magneto- meaning magnetic field, and hydro- meaning liquid, and -dynamics meaning movement. The field of MHD was initiated by Hannes Alfvén,[1] for which he received the Nobel Prize in Physics in 1970.

Magnetic reconnection in plasma is described using MHD.
MR reconnection rates are only defined for plasma.

W.D. Clinger's simple derivation of magnetic reconnection has no plasma :jaw-dropp !
 
So this has turned into a delusion! Who would have guessed it :rolleyes: ?

No, it's more of the same denial-go-round at your end.

The term "reconnection rate" is defined in resistive MHD models of magnetic reconnection, e.g. Sweet-Parker and Petschek (and probably other models). These models define reconnection rate in terms of the
Lundquist number which is a parameter of a plasma. The Lundquist number uses the Alfvén speed which is a characteristic of a wave in plasma.

Now what is MHD, Michael Mozina? Since you obviously have forgotten:
Magnetohydrodynamics


Magnetic reconnection in plasma is described using MHD.
MR reconnection rates are only defined for plasma.

W.D. Clinger's simple derivation of magnetic reconnection has no plasma :jaw-dropp !

The jawdropping part is the fact that the reconnection process itself is only defined FOR PLASMA and charged particles, which is why the reconnection rate is related to plasma movement. You have a reconnect rate of zero if you have no plasma to accelerate. It's just that simple. Clinger's math only relates to the QUADRAPOLAR FIELD. It has nothing to do with reconnection or the rate of reconnection. He didn't even know what the term "reconnection" really means until last week when he finally found out how the measure and mathematically define a reconnection rate! The is no reconnection happening in Clinger's part 4 and there never could be any reconnection in part 4. There's no way to even define a rate of reconnection without plasma.
 
Last edited:
So what? [* Irrelevant complaints snipped. *]


Rant without substance and dishonest misrepresentation of my position noted. Also noted is the continued failure to address this issue...

No effort has been made to quantitatively describe the process which allegedly allows us to see thousands of kilometers below the photosphere by doing a simple mathematical operation on the pixels of two images acquired thousands of kilometers above the photosphere. No effort has been made to explain how a RGB composite PR image with a 25% transparent circle overlaid allegedly allows us to see through 80,000 kilometers of opaque plasma. No effort has been made to duplicate any of the image manipulation processes or explain them in detail in order to demonstrate those ridiculous claims are even plausible.
 
*IF* as you claim, plasma is optional in for reconnection to occur, then plasma would necessarily be optional to describe the rate of reconnection as well. Which is it, one or the other. You can't have it both ways.
 
Michael Mozina, What is the Alfvén speed for a vacuum

If plasma is optional for reconnection to occur, then the rate of reconnection should also be mathematically quantifiable without plasma. Let's see it. Stop calling me a liar until you produce it.
Michael Mozina's delusion that a reconnection rate exists without plasma!

But since you think it exists then you can do something very easy:
Work out the Alfvén velocity for a vacuum. You can then plug that into the reconnection rate in Sweet-Parker or Petschek models.
Alfvén wave
where
d5742827d055e40cd568fd71271f4681.png
is the magnetic field strength ...
dd7da5ba06f20b38216ae19a5b2de685.png
is the total mass density of the charged plasma particles.
where
15c92bc470410bcaa83f4f6f54e8534e.png
is the Alfvén velocity

This is math that a high school student will know about, Michael Mozina. Just divde B by zero. Plug this into the Lundquist number and then into the model.
 
Holy smokes. The fact Clinger never even bothered to find out what a reconnection rate meant BEFORE claiming plasma was optional should be your first clue.
 
Michael Mozina's delusion that a reconnection rate exists without plasma!

But since you think it exists then you can do something very easy:
Work out the Alfvén velocity for a vacuum. You can then plug that into the reconnection rate in Sweet-Parker or Petschek models.
Alfvén wave


This is math that a high school student will know about, Michael Mozina. Just divde B by zero. Plug this into the Lundquist number and then into the model.

What the heck are you talking about? The "mass density' is necessarily ZERO without plasma RC. You can't use the Lundquist number in the first place because it all relates to current sheets and plasma physics!
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom