Michael Mozina isn't telling the truth, part 2
False.
I demonstrated my claim by giving a
mathematical proof.
The only thing you "proved" is that the NULL is *NOT* unique in terms of satisfying Gauss's laws like you claimed.
False.
For starters, I never claimed that the null point is unique in terms of satisfying Gauss's laws. A few lines below,
Michael Mozina wrote "Nobody ever doubted that Guass's laws were satisfied EVERYWHERE, not just in the null." In other words, he agrees that I never made any claim to the contrary.
For another thing, I proved lots of things. I'm not going to hold that against
Michael Mozina, because his inability/refusal to bark math makes it impossible for him to recognize a mathematical proof, even when it smacks him in his eyeballs.
I and others have also cited published references, such as
Pontin's article, which is to appear in
Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society A: Mathematical, Physical and Engineering Sciences.
All your own references refuted your position because all those maths are based upon MHD theory. This is the only paper you cited and it's shoots your claim out of the water because it's based on MHD theory!
False.
That part of
Pontin's article does not depend on MHD or plasma. Instead, it cites
Parnell et al, which does not mention MHD at all, and mentions plasma only once, in the first sentence of its introduction, and even then plasma is mentioned only as motivation for the purely mathematical results to follow. Those results hold for neutral points in a vacuum as much as for neutral points in a plasma.
That web site does indeed prove that Gauss's law for magnetism, along with the rest of Maxwell's equations, is satisfied by all of the magnetic fields shown at that web site.
Nobody ever doubted that Guass's laws were satisfied EVERYWHERE, not just in the null.
So why did
Michael Mozina pretend, just a few lines above, that I had claimed otherwise?
Because
Michael Mozina isn't telling the truth.
I've argued from the start that "reconnection" is a process in PLASMA.
False.
As
Tim Thompson has documented,
Michael Mozina started out by denying magnetic reconnection in plasma. He routinely dismissed magnetic reconnection in plasma as pseudoscience.
You're the one moving the goal posts as fast as possible trying to hide the fact you haven't described any rates of reconnection.
False.
Michael Mozina has been moving the goal posts from magnetic reconnection (which refers to a
change in the topology of magnetic field lines, and can occur within a vacuum) to the reconnection rate, which is a plasma-specific concept.
Fortunately, many journal articles (such as
Yamada et al) make a clear distinction between magnetic reconnection and the reconnection rate.
Michael Mozina denied his denial of magnetic reconnection on
21 November 2011.
Tim Thompson demolished
Michael Mozina's denial of his denial the following day, in a post titled
Does Mozina Deny Magnetic Reconnection?.
I have NEVER claimed that the process called "reconnection" didn't occur. That is your own BLATANT misrepresentation of my position.
False.
Michael Mozina is hiding behind his own equivocation.
As
Tim Thompson has documented,
Michael Mozina has a long history of denying magnetic reconnection:
Notice the not too clever attempt at "bait & switch"?
Clinger is explicit about "denying
magnetic reconnection". But in his denials of denying, notice that
Mozina uses the word "reconnection" without the modifier "magnetic". Of course, as he has written it,
Mozina is quite correct. He has never denied the reality of "reconnection", always insisting on "circuit reconnection" or "current reconnection". But has
Mozina ever denied the reality of
magnetic reconnection?
It's fact check time.
...snip...
From 12 Feb 2009:
Magnetic lines lack physical substance, they form as a full and complete continuum, and they are physically *incapable* of "reconnecting". Did any of you folks take a class in basic electronics?
From 15 Feb 2009:
The magnetic lines lack physical substance, and they are physically incapable of "disconnecting" or "reconnecting" to any other magnetic field line. These are simply "particle/circuit reconnection" events, not "magnetic reconnection" events. It simply "current sheet acceleration", nothing more.
From 4 Jan 2010:
They clearly do "rule out" your pseudoscientific magnetic reconnection model in these two flares!
From 29 Jan 2010:
The "highly idiosyncratic" understanding/verbiage comes from the "mainstream" because Alfven himself called Parkers "magnetic reconnection" a form of "pseudoscience". Alfven was an electrical engineer by trade and he knew damn well that magnetic lines do not "disconnect' or 'reconnect' to any other magnetic line. The "reconnection" is between two "circuits", not simply two magnetic lines.
From 31 Jan 2010:
What part of "pseudoscience" is still "pseudoscience" don't your understand Tim? Alfven saw Parker's description of "magnetic reconnection' Tim. He knew MHD theory from *BOTH* the B *AND* E orientations. He was an electrical engineer by trade, and no such individual would ever make the mistake of calling a "current flow change" a "magnetic reconnection" event! It's still pseudoscience Tim, and time will not ever change that fact.
As explained above, I have used Maxwell's equations to give a rigorous
mathematical proof that two magnetic field lines end and another two magnetic field lines begin at the neutral point of the magnetic field
B4.
No lines "begin" in the neutral, no lines end there,
False.
Both
Pontin and
Parnell et al contradict
Michael Mozina's claim.
Both of those papers are rather mathematical. My own explanation, while rigorously mathematical, limits itself to sophomore-level mathematics:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=7746071&postcount=4813
no magnetic source exists there, no sink exists there.
True.
After all, I have given several proofs that
div B = 0 throughout those magnetic fields.
When
Michael Mozina pretends otherwise, he is being dishonest.
Michael Mozina does not understand the mathematics of basic electromagnetism, so he can't find any error in that proof. He can only repeat his unshakeable conviction that he's right.
Clinger doesn't even understand basic EM theory
False.
Michael Mozina doesn't bark math, so he doesn't even recognize the basic EM theory in my proofs.
or he'd know that magnetic lines form as full continuous loops, without begging and without ending, without a magnetic source, without a sink.
According to Gauss's law for magnetism, magnetic field lines have no source or sink.
For equipotential magnetic field lines, which are the only ones shown to most freshmen, that means the field lines have no beginning or end. For more complicated magnetic fields with neutral points, magnetic field lines can begin or end at those neutral points. Both
Pontin and
Parnell et al have written entire papers about that fact.
For one thing, my argument is based upon Maxwell's equations and their mathematical consequences.
So what? They also don't demonstrate what you claim they demonstrate.
False.
Michael Mozina doesn't bark math, so he has no idea of what the math means. Being completely ignorant of the math doesn't make it any harder for him to deny its meaning. Ignorance makes it easier for him to deny its meaning.
Your entire argument comes down to your own UNPUBLISHED website, and it's you vs the world of MHD theory!
False, as has already been explained above.
The math doesn't even show what you claim it shows.
False, as has already been explained above.
Furthermore your absurd claim that I deny that the plasma physics process called "Reconnection" is a real process is completely false.
False, as
Tim Thompson has documented.