Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
D'rok, if you want to see delusion, notice that MM remains wrong because a way to mathematically express a rate of reconnection in the absence of "mass acceleration" was posted on the 15th of March (Sweet-Parker model). That's a continually repeated ignorance, i.e. delusion.

Er, the delusion is believing that the Sweet and Parker model isn't based on mass acceleration. S is defined in terms that relate DIRECTLY to plasma physics. All those velocities he describes are velocities of the plasma in and plasma out! Talk about delusional nonsense!

Of course this "absence of mass acceleration" may be the insanity of demanding that there be no plasma: MM: What is reconnection rate of the plasma inside a rock containing no plasma?

WTF? Your side is then the INSANE side for claiming that 'reconnection' happens WITHOUT plasma particles! The rate of reconnection is ZERO if you have not plasma in or plasma out.
 
It's becoming painfully apparent that RC has completely and totally lost contact with reality if he believes that the Sweet and Parker brand of reconnection is plasma optional. That's just irrational nonsense.
 
Last edited:
Then cite some of these papers that state that magnetic reconnecvtion is only possible in plasma.

You're trying to shift the burden of proof and it won't work. Nobody here claims reconnection doesn't happen in PLASMA. Clinger claimed that the plasma was optional and so have every one of you.

I don't have to cite any sort of EXCLUSIVE anything. I just have to show that MHD theory describes "reconnection' in plasma, including several rates of reconnection, including the Sweet and Parker brand.

You have to demonstrate a rate of reconnection that is NOT based upon plasma movements. Your side has a burden of proof it could never hope to meet. Don't expect me to prove negatives. That's just more of your irrational nonsense.
 
There's plenty of scientific evidence to support that it's a sphere including parts we left on the moon. :)
Err, thats what I just said.

Any published textbook on astronomy will mention it! No need to rely on a few guys on some website.
Uh-huh.

Clinger already mentioned that neither of the EM field theory books even mentioned the term "reconnection'. I'm sure they explained induction, flux, attraction and repulsion however.
Two bar magnets $12, one tube of iron filings $8...

Do you know how that sounds from my side of the aisle?
Not really. You keep responding to my posts talking about things I've never even mentioned. So I have no idea how your brain works.

Imagine a YEC telling you that some religious text says so, some guy's website in cyberspace says so, therefore it's true?
But that's not what I'm saying. I'm telling you to go and do the table-top experiment to see for yourself. That could not be more in oppositon to the "my text says it is true therefore it is true" approach.

That's about the way I feel about the fact that none of you can come up with published literature to support you claim about moving magnet interactions.
Try a physics text book aimed at 11 year olds. Or just do the experiment for yourself.

It's so 'trivial' it's called "flux change". The term "reconnection' comes from and relates to PLASMA physics.
The term reconnection comes from how the topology of the fields appears to change I would imagine. Its fairly obvious when you look at the animations.

Oh boloney. A single electron or positron or ion in motion is a form of plasma and form of current.
No, it isn't. You clearly have no idea what constitutes a plasma. And yet you try to lecture everybody else on it.

It's a charged particle in motion. A single ion of iron is the same thing.
Nope. States of matter are large collections of molecules with specific properties. A single iron ion is simply a single iron ion.

That single atom has a specific STATE, a solid, liquid, gas or PLASMA.
No it doesn't. A single atom cannot exhibit the properties which are associated with the definitions of solid, liquid, gas or plasma.

A single ion is a PLASMA and exists in a plasma state, not a solid, not a liquid, not a gas.
A single ion is not any of these. It has no bulk properties or interactions.
 
No it doesn't. A single atom cannot exhibit the properties which are associated with the definitions of solid, liquid, gas or plasma.

That is not true. Whereas a single metallic, or ionized ion will be influenced by an EM field, that's not true of of non ionized neon. A single atom in a vacuum has all the properties of a gas unless it's ionized, in which case it has all the properties of a PLASMA.

A single ion is not any of these. It has no bulk properties or interactions.

Who cares about "bulk"? A single moving ionized atom of iron will still be influenced by an em field. The currents do have "bulk" properties by the way.
 
Last edited:
When one of you folks produces a PUBLISHED paper based on BASIC EM theory that describes two magnet interaction in terms of 'reconnection' rather than flux, bending and twisting, attraction and repulsion, let me know. Until then, the only place you hear that claim is by your little cult on this little website (and Clinger's website) and there is no peer reviewed literature on record to support that claim. It's like a young earth creationist cult that get's its knowledge from unpublished websites and evidently a clairvoyant understanding of the subject matter since most don't even own a book on plasma physics where 'reconnection' is actually discussed in terms of PHYSICS and the movements of physical mass.
 
Last edited:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnetic_reconnection

Magnetic reconnection is a physical process in highly conducting plasmas in which the magnetic topology is rearranged and magnetic energy is converted to kinetic energy, thermal energy, and particle acceleration. Magnetic reconnection occurs on timescales intermediate between slow resistive diffusion of the magnetic field and fast Alfvénic timescales.

Notice all the stuff I highlighted and that you all left out of the reconnection process? It *INCLUDES*, not excludes plasma. It describes a TRANSFER of energy from the field into particle kinetic energy. You left that out. All you have is flux change and NO charged particle acceleration. That's not "reconnection", that's a dumbed down, oversimplified, TOY understanding of what reconnection REALLY is. It's not about FLUX, it's about the transfer of that flux into PHYSICAL THINGS! You left out the PHYSICS, so of course you can't produce any math about the rate of reconnection.
 
Last edited:
No, I accept that claim.
Excellent.


What are you transferring kinetic energy to and from exactly? The physical magnets?

As already noted an number of times, some of the energy you apply in rotating the free magnet is stored in the new (two opposing) field configuration. When you release that magnet that energy is transferred to kinetic energy rotating the magnet back to the lower energy and original field configuration.

There aren't any magnets in the corona.
You have corona in your home? I expect only in the refrigerator and that ain’t the same type of corona you were referring to.


Now you've totally lost and confused me. What exactly have you demonstrated with your experiment other than the fact that the TRANSFER OF MAGNETIC FIELD ENERGY into KINETIC energy is a REQUIREMENT for "reconnection"?

That isn’t a demonstration of the experiment but just your stated requirement that the experiment complies with. Do the experiment and see what it does demonstrate to you.


Clinger didn't accelerate anything.
Your fixation with W.D. Clinger is of no concern to me or the experiment.

I said it wouldn't happen *WITHOUT* mass acceleration. Your example *INCLUDES* mass acceleration.
Ah so do you now accept that the experiment is an “electrical discharge” and “"reconnection"” as you profess those terms to mean?


Clinger's does not.
Again your fixation with W.D. Clinger is of no concern to me or the experiment.
 
Ah so do you now accept that the experiment is an “electrical discharge” and “"reconnection"” as you profess those terms to mean?

I don't know yet. Did it satisfy Peratt's other criteria?

1 .5 Electrίcal Discharges in Cosmic Plasma

An electrical discharge is a sudden release of electric or magnetic stored energy. This generally occurs when the electromagnetic stress exceeds some threshold for breakdown that is usually determined by small scale properties of the energy transmission medium. As such, discharges are local phenomena and are usually accompanied by violent processes such as rapid heating, ionization, the creation of pinched and filamentary conduction channels, particle acceleration, and the generation of prodigious amounts of electromagnetic radiation. As an example, multi-terawatt pulsed-power generators on earth rely on strong electrical discharges to produce intense particle beams, Χrays, and microwανes . Megajoules of energy are electrically stored in capacitor banks, whose volume may encompass 250 m^3 . This energy is then transferred to a discharge regίοn, located many meters from the source, viα a transmission line.

The discharge region, or load, encompasses at most a few cubic centimeters of space, and is the site of high-variability, intense, electromagnetic radiation (Figure 1 .2). On earth, lightning is another example of the discharge mechanism at work where electrostatic energy is stored in clouds whose volume may be of the order of 3,000 km3. This energy is released in a few cubic meters of the discharge channel.

You tell me.
 
Michael Mozina isn't telling the truth, part 2

False.

I demonstrated my claim by giving a mathematical proof.

The only thing you "proved" is that the NULL is *NOT* unique in terms of satisfying Gauss's laws like you claimed.
False.

For starters, I never claimed that the null point is unique in terms of satisfying Gauss's laws. A few lines below, Michael Mozina wrote "Nobody ever doubted that Guass's laws were satisfied EVERYWHERE, not just in the null." In other words, he agrees that I never made any claim to the contrary.

For another thing, I proved lots of things. I'm not going to hold that against Michael Mozina, because his inability/refusal to bark math makes it impossible for him to recognize a mathematical proof, even when it smacks him in his eyeballs.

I and others have also cited published references, such as Pontin's article, which is to appear in Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society A: Mathematical, Physical and Engineering Sciences.

All your own references refuted your position because all those maths are based upon MHD theory. This is the only paper you cited and it's shoots your claim out of the water because it's based on MHD theory!
False.

That part of Pontin's article does not depend on MHD or plasma. Instead, it cites Parnell et al, which does not mention MHD at all, and mentions plasma only once, in the first sentence of its introduction, and even then plasma is mentioned only as motivation for the purely mathematical results to follow. Those results hold for neutral points in a vacuum as much as for neutral points in a plasma.

That web site does indeed prove that Gauss's law for magnetism, along with the rest of Maxwell's equations, is satisfied by all of the magnetic fields shown at that web site.

Nobody ever doubted that Guass's laws were satisfied EVERYWHERE, not just in the null.
So why did Michael Mozina pretend, just a few lines above, that I had claimed otherwise?

Because Michael Mozina isn't telling the truth.

I've argued from the start that "reconnection" is a process in PLASMA.
False.

As Tim Thompson has documented, Michael Mozina started out by denying magnetic reconnection in plasma. He routinely dismissed magnetic reconnection in plasma as pseudoscience.

You're the one moving the goal posts as fast as possible trying to hide the fact you haven't described any rates of reconnection.
False.

Michael Mozina has been moving the goal posts from magnetic reconnection (which refers to a change in the topology of magnetic field lines, and can occur within a vacuum) to the reconnection rate, which is a plasma-specific concept.

Fortunately, many journal articles (such as Yamada et al) make a clear distinction between magnetic reconnection and the reconnection rate.

Michael Mozina denied his denial of magnetic reconnection on 21 November 2011. Tim Thompson demolished Michael Mozina's denial of his denial the following day, in a post titled Does Mozina Deny Magnetic Reconnection?.

I have NEVER claimed that the process called "reconnection" didn't occur. That is your own BLATANT misrepresentation of my position.
False.

Michael Mozina is hiding behind his own equivocation.

As Tim Thompson has documented, Michael Mozina has a long history of denying magnetic reconnection:

Notice the not too clever attempt at "bait & switch"? Clinger is explicit about "denying magnetic reconnection". But in his denials of denying, notice that Mozina uses the word "reconnection" without the modifier "magnetic". Of course, as he has written it, Mozina is quite correct. He has never denied the reality of "reconnection", always insisting on "circuit reconnection" or "current reconnection". But has Mozina ever denied the reality of magnetic reconnection?

It's fact check time.

...snip...

From 12 Feb 2009:
Magnetic lines lack physical substance, they form as a full and complete continuum, and they are physically *incapable* of "reconnecting". Did any of you folks take a class in basic electronics?


From 15 Feb 2009:
The magnetic lines lack physical substance, and they are physically incapable of "disconnecting" or "reconnecting" to any other magnetic field line. These are simply "particle/circuit reconnection" events, not "magnetic reconnection" events. It simply "current sheet acceleration", nothing more.


From 4 Jan 2010:
They clearly do "rule out" your pseudoscientific magnetic reconnection model in these two flares!


From 29 Jan 2010:
The "highly idiosyncratic" understanding/verbiage comes from the "mainstream" because Alfven himself called Parkers "magnetic reconnection" a form of "pseudoscience". Alfven was an electrical engineer by trade and he knew damn well that magnetic lines do not "disconnect' or 'reconnect' to any other magnetic line. The "reconnection" is between two "circuits", not simply two magnetic lines.


From 31 Jan 2010:
What part of "pseudoscience" is still "pseudoscience" don't your understand Tim? Alfven saw Parker's description of "magnetic reconnection' Tim. He knew MHD theory from *BOTH* the B *AND* E orientations. He was an electrical engineer by trade, and no such individual would ever make the mistake of calling a "current flow change" a "magnetic reconnection" event! It's still pseudoscience Tim, and time will not ever change that fact.


As explained above, I have used Maxwell's equations to give a rigorous mathematical proof that two magnetic field lines end and another two magnetic field lines begin at the neutral point of the magnetic field B4.

No lines "begin" in the neutral, no lines end there,
False.

Both Pontin and Parnell et al contradict Michael Mozina's claim.

Both of those papers are rather mathematical. My own explanation, while rigorously mathematical, limits itself to sophomore-level mathematics:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=7746071&postcount=4813

no magnetic source exists there, no sink exists there.
True.

After all, I have given several proofs that div B = 0 throughout those magnetic fields.

When Michael Mozina pretends otherwise, he is being dishonest.

Michael Mozina does not understand the mathematics of basic electromagnetism, so he can't find any error in that proof. He can only repeat his unshakeable conviction that he's right.

Clinger doesn't even understand basic EM theory
False.

Michael Mozina doesn't bark math, so he doesn't even recognize the basic EM theory in my proofs.

or he'd know that magnetic lines form as full continuous loops, without begging and without ending, without a magnetic source, without a sink.
According to Gauss's law for magnetism, magnetic field lines have no source or sink.

For equipotential magnetic field lines, which are the only ones shown to most freshmen, that means the field lines have no beginning or end. For more complicated magnetic fields with neutral points, magnetic field lines can begin or end at those neutral points. Both Pontin and Parnell et al have written entire papers about that fact.

For one thing, my argument is based upon Maxwell's equations and their mathematical consequences.

So what? They also don't demonstrate what you claim they demonstrate.
False.

Michael Mozina doesn't bark math, so he has no idea of what the math means. Being completely ignorant of the math doesn't make it any harder for him to deny its meaning. Ignorance makes it easier for him to deny its meaning.

Your entire argument comes down to your own UNPUBLISHED website, and it's you vs the world of MHD theory!
False, as has already been explained above.

The math doesn't even show what you claim it shows.
False, as has already been explained above.

Furthermore your absurd claim that I deny that the plasma physics process called "Reconnection" is a real process is completely false.
False, as Tim Thompson has documented.
 
Er, the delusion is believing that the Sweet and Parker model isn't based on mass acceleration.
The delusion is your inability to understand that the Sweet-Parker model is not based on "mass acceleration". It is based on MHD theory. A result of this is that the reconnection rate is non-zero and so we expect that MR in plasma will change the bulk velocity of the plasma.

The delusion is that you persist in assigning fantasies to me: I know that the Sweet-Parker model reconnection rate has plasma velocities in it. I knew this when I quoted the definition to you 5 days ago.
The dimensionless reconnection rate can then be written as
9567473f430340803975053589c8908e.png
where the dimensionless Lundquist number
5dbc98dcc983a70728bd082d1a47546e.png
is given by
c4bca0477871854bef9cbd717c20999f.png
In fact this reconnection rate just has one velocity in it - the Alfvén velocity but this is a result of the outflow velocity being of the order of the Alfvén velocity.

WTF? Your side is then the INSANE side for claiming that 'reconnection' happens WITHOUT plasma particles! The rate of reconnection is ZERO if you have not plasma in or plasma out.
WTF? You are the one who is insanely demanding that the reconnection rate defined for plasma be applied to MR happening without plasma. Thus my question which you have still not answered: MM: What is reconnection rate of the plasma inside a rock containing no plasma?

It is really simple, Michael Mozina.
If there is no plasma then
  1. There is no definition of reconnection rate.
  2. And there is "no plasma in or plasma out".
 
Cant we just get rid of all this replace the OP with this?

[Generate thread]
[start loop]
a) This idea is interesting
b) No its wrong, and I've got the maths to prove it
> Your maths is based on unreal constructs, proves nothing
> Vectors, lines, points, flux lines and infities are mathematically proven!
> Show me a real world object with th exact properties of a line, a point, a singularity, or something with an attribute that's infinite in nature then!
> You can't they dont really exist, they are for convenience in our models!
> Well then your models are based on made up things!
> Models are made up things in themselves
> That still need experiments to back them up
> Supplies link to such evidence
> that doesn't prove anything
IF "Idea is still interesting"
Do loop: from a), till infinity
Else: Find new idea.
[/Loop]
 
Last edited:
It's becoming painfully apparent that RC has completely and totally lost contact with reality if he believes that the Sweet and Parker brand of reconnection is plasma optional. That's just irrational nonsense.
It's becoming painfully apparent that MM has completely and totally lost the ability to read. I never stated that the Sweet and Parker brand of reconnection is plasma optional.
My point is exactly the opposite. The Sweet and Parker brand of reconnection (and all other brands because reconnection rate is a concept of models based on MHD concept) is plasma mandatory thus it is insane to ask about a reconnection rate where there is no plasma.
 
False.

For starters, I never claimed that the null point is unique in terms of satisfying Gauss's laws.

Yes you DID! You claimed B lines "begin" there, and "end" somewhere, specifically the NULL. They do absolutely no such thing. They don't even exist in a true NULL!

For another thing, I proved lots of things. I'm not going to hold that against Michael Mozina, because his inability/refusal to bark math makes it impossible for him to recognize a mathematical proof, even when it smacks him in his eyeballs.

What smacked me in the eyeballs about your math was it's primitiveness. There's not even any formula to describe the rate of reconnection. How sad can it get?

That part of Pontin's article does not depend on MHD or plasma.

Well, that's a blatantly false statement and easily disproved just from their abstract:

http://arxiv.org/abs/1202.4013

Magnetic reconnection is a fundamental process in a plasma that facilitates the release of energy stored in the magnetic field by permitting a change in the magnetic topology. In this article we present a review of the current state of understanding of magnetic reconnection. We discuss theoretical results regarding the formation of current sheets in complex 3D magnetic fields, and describe the fundamental differences between reconnection in two and three dimensions. We go on to outline recent developments in modelling of reconnection with kinetic theory, as well as in the MHD framework where a number of new 3D reconnection regimes have been identified. We discuss evidence from observations and simulations of solar system plasmas that support this theory, and summarise some prominent locations in which this new reconnection theory is relevant in astrophysical plasmas.

Didn't you see Pontin's talk about kinetic theory, and MHD theory, plasmas and current sheets?

Instead, it cites Parnell et al, which does not mention MHD at all, and mentions plasma only once, in the first sentence of its introduction, and even then plasma is mentioned only as motivation for the purely mathematical results to follow. Those results hold for neutral points in a vacuum as much as for neutral points in a plasma.

Well, I can't even seem to access that one at the moment, but I'm sure it talks about the transfer of field energy into other forms of energy. I'll keep trying it.

As Tim Thompson has documented, Michael Mozina started out by denying magnetic reconnection in plasma. He routinely dismissed magnetic reconnection in plasma as pseudoscience.

Just so you're clear and you have no rational EXCUSE to misrepresent my position on reconnection in the future:

I accept that the PROCESS called 'reconnection" in PLASMA is a real process that transfers field energy into particle kinetic energy. What you describe as 'reconnection" between non tangible B lines is pure pseudoscience, and that is the danger of using a really STUPID name to describe an electrical discharge process in plasma. "Discharge? What discharges?" Sheesh!


Fortunately, many journal articles (such as Yamada et al) make a clear distinction between magnetic reconnection and the reconnection rate.

You can't ride Yamada's coattails either. He's also using MHD theory to describe that rate of reconnection Clinger. You're SOL.

Both Pontin and Parnell et al contradict Michael Mozina's claim.

Nope. I can't see the Parnell paper yet, but Pontin was a bust for you. Pontin is using MHD theory, plasmas and current sheets to describe reconnection rates like everyone else that uses MHD theory to describe reconnection rates. I'll have to see how badly you're butchering Parnell after reading the link.

Both of those papers are rather mathematical. My own explanation, while rigorously mathematical, limits itself to sophomore-level mathematics:

It's so simplistic, it's OVERLY SIMPLISTIC. You don't even describe a RATE of reconnection!

Most of your stuff seems to be pure rehash, so I'll wait until I can get into Parnelll link so I can show you that there are no mathematical descriptions of the rate of reconnection in the absence of particle acceleration in that work either. You're just lucky I can't access that paper right now or I'd just shut you down right now. You're down to ONE and ONLY ONE paper. We'll see if there's a calculation for the rate in that paper. If there is, you should include it. Since you didn't, it must not be there, or must be related to charged particle acceleration like every other paper on the topic.
 
Last edited:
That is not true. Whereas a single metallic, or ionized ion will be influenced by an EM field, that's not true of of non ionized neon. A single atom in a vacuum has all the properties of a gas unless it's ionized, in which case it has all the properties of a PLASMA.
Nope. A single atom in a vacuum is not easy to compress and does not expand to fill its container, to give two astonishingly obvious indicators that a single atom is nothing like a gas.


Who cares about "bulk"? A single moving ionized atom of iron will still be influenced by an em field. The currents do have "bulk" properties by the way.
Gases and plasmas are defined by their bulk properties, interactions and tendencies. If something doesn't have bulk properties it cannot be reliably modelled as a quantity that is defined in terms of its bulk properties. Thus an atom, ionized or otherwise, cannot be reliably modelled as a gas or plasma.
 
It's becoming painfully apparent that MM has completely and totally lost the ability to read. I never stated that the Sweet and Parker brand of reconnection is plasma optional.
My point is exactly the opposite. The Sweet and Parker brand of reconnection (and all other brands because reconnection rate is a concept of models based on MHD concept) is plasma mandatory thus it is insane to ask about a reconnection rate where there is no plasma.

Do you even think about what you write? If it's insane to talk about the rate without plasma, it's insane to talk about the PROCESS without plasma too! :)
 
MM: State your position and list citations to support it

Nobody here claims reconnection doesn't happen in PLASMA.
That is not your postion. Your position seemed to be that reconnection is only possible in plasma.

If that is not correct then state your position and list citations to support it.

Maybe your position is now that MR does not need plasma (Peer reviewed material that states plasma is optional in MR )?

I just have to show that MHD theory describes "reconnection' in plasma...
That is trivially correct: MHD is a theory of plasma. So when it is used to describe MR it is describing MR in plasma and when models use MHD theory and define a reconnection rate then that is a reconnection rate defined for plasma :eye-poppi!

You have to demonstrate a rate of reconnection that is NOT based upon plasma movements.
No we do not because it would be insane to try to define a reconnection rate without plasma. Your "plasma movements" are an effect of reconnection in plasma.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom