Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Magnetic reconnection can happen in a vacuum.


Just as vacuums can happen in vacuums. Comprende?
Just do the bar magnet experiment in a vacuum.


I Just did. Nothing physically happened :s

W.D.Clinger's simple derivation of magnetic reconnection just needs 4 wires in a vacuum. But hey - maybe Maxwell's equations are wrong :rolleyes:!

You can derive it all you want. Its correct, I know.

But, can you now link to measurable experimental evidence proving the derived energies to physically tested effects ?

Your anology is wrong. Only an idiot would think that magnetic field lines or map lines are real things that you can "physically bump into".


Exactly. "Only an idiot would think that magnetic field lines or map lines are real things". Thus why magnetic reconection in a vacuum is a misnomer past mathematical abstraction.
 
Last edited:
So where do things stand?


We've advanced from the point where one person was vehemently denying the existence of magnetic reconnection to the point where we all agree it occurs. We're only a grade school kid's experiment away from agreeing magnetic reconnection occurs in a vacuum or not in a vacuum, in plasma or not, on a kitchen table or on the Sun. But at the current pace and with the continued refusal to actually conduct that experiment, it may be years before we get there.

We still have claims being made about the composition of the Sun which are backed by fraudulent scientific papers, misrepresented research done by a guy who died almost 100 years ago, and non-objective non-quantitative declarations based on looks-like-a-bunny pseudoscience. There has been absolutely no progress on that front in almost seven years. No effort has been made to quantitatively describe the process which allegedly allows us to see thousands of kilometers below the photosphere by doing a simple mathematical operation on the pixels of two images acquired thousands of kilometers above the photosphere. No effort has been made to explain how a RGB composite PR image with a 25% transparent circle overlaid allegedly allows us to see through 80,000 kilometers of opaque plasma. No effort has been made to duplicate any of the image manipulation processes or explain them in detail in order to demonstrate those ridiculous claims are even plausible.

We still have dishonest attempts to deflect the burden of proof for the claims that the Sun has a solid/rigid surface and that solar flares are some kind of lightning-like phenomenon. We have dishonest efforts to evade relevant questions about those claims. We still have the electric/iron Sun conjectures being supported by intentional dishonest distortions of legitimate science and as demonstrated many, many times in this thread, outright lies.

Where do things stand now? The electric/iron Sun advocates have given every single argument they have. It has come down to reruns of reruns of reruns. There are absolutely no new developments, and no work is actually being done to support the claims, well, other than repeating the reruns with upper case, asterisks, cryptic application of quote marks, complaints about failing, and unconventional use of fairly standard terminology. Where do things stand now? The honest, objective assessment is there has been a total failure to support any electric/iron Sun claims.
 
I think 80% of this thread is just down equivocation misunderstandings.

Electricty did it / Magnetism did it, is a classic, for example.

Someone versed in basic electromagnetism will know they are at a basic level, the same. The difference is way we conceptualize them. Magnetism with field lines, flux strength, vector fields, etc, and other constructs. Currents with motion, charge, particle properties, vector fields, etc. But you can still define magnetism with the concepts I list after currents, and vice versa. Are EM fields constant, or quantized? Both. But they can't be, really. We end up back at 'is it a particle or wave?' type debate by the end. Or Bu and Ej approaches to various plasma related geo/stellar physics models.

Both can lead to totally different results/predictions/models on occasions, as the conceptualizations used for both is different.
Wrong! What we have here is someone whose education and knowledge of physics and mathematics is totally inadequate* to understand the topic that appears to consume his life -- solar physics, plasma physics, astrophysics, etc. This person, who believes in pseudo-science (iron sun, EU, whatever), has engaged people who do have the required knowledge and skills and who have tried futilely to educate him. They have failed because he engages in pretend -- looks like a bunny -- physics and is not capable of genuine understanding.

*As an example, some weeks ago he claimed two certain equations from a certain paper "proved" that reconnection requires plasma. When I tried to have him explain how these equations did this, he refused to answer, thereby revealing his ignorance and pretense of knowledge.
 
Really? That’s not what you asserted before….

Well, sort of. In the sense you're releasing stored EM energy, yes, that is in fact an "electrical discharge". It's not actually an "electrical discharge in plasma' however. I suppose you could suspend the magnets *IN* a plasma and release them. The FLUX CHANGES that occur will likely induce currents. Assuming you could store and release enough magnetic field energy, I suppose it COULD result in an ELECTRICAL DISCHARGE that might result in highly ionized iron, x-rays, gamma rays, etc....yes, that is in fact an "electrical discharge". It's not actually an "electrical discharge in plasma' however.

I don't know yet. Did it satisfy Peratt's other criteria?

1 .5 Electrίcal Discharges in Cosmic Plasma

An electrical discharge is a sudden release of electric or magnetic stored energy. This generally occurs when the electromagnetic stress exceeds some threshold for breakdown that is usually determined by small scale properties of the energy transmission medium. As such, discharges are local phenomena and are usually accompanied by violent processes such as rapid heating, ionization, the creation of pinched and filamentary conduction channels, particle acceleration, and the generation of prodigious amounts of electromagnetic radiation. As an example, multi-terawatt pulsed-power generators on earth rely on strong electrical discharges to produce intense particle beams, Χrays, and microwανes . Megajoules of energy are electrically stored in capacitor banks, whose volume may encompass 250 m^3 . This energy is then transferred to a discharge regίοn, located many meters from the source, viα a transmission line.

The discharge region, or load, encompasses at most a few cubic centimeters of space, and is the site of high-variability, intense, electromagnetic radiation (Figure 1 .2). On earth, lightning is another example of the discharge mechanism at work where electrostatic energy is stored in clouds whose volume may be of the order of 3,000 km3. This energy is released in a few cubic meters of the discharge channel.
You tell me.

Have you lost some of that knowledge between then and now?

No, actually you never elaborated fully enough to answer your question. As I stated the first time, there's an explicit heating of physical particles, specific wavelengths of energy, etc, that are typical and highly indicative of an "electrical discharge" as Peratt describes it.

Do your magnets actually generate the kinds of things that Peratt describes, like pinches and high energy wavelengths of light?

I can't answer your question without a few 'details' about the process you're describing. If you just move a couple of magnets a few centimeters, no. If you generate an electrical discharge, 'probably'.
 
Last edited:
I know that 80% of this thread is just down to the inabilty to understand (or accept) what people have written in scientific papers and textbooks.

There are few "equivocation misunderstandings". There have been some instances of context misunderstanding, e.g. that "electrical discharge" in the context of a few old papers about MR causing flares does not mean lightning!.

It does mean a release of stored EM energy RC, one that includes plasma pinches, x-rays, gamma rays, neutron capture signatures, etc. You can't take the physics out of plasma physics and still call it reconnection.

Somov used CHARGE PARTICLES in his vacuum. Everyone who talks about reconnection talks about the movement of charged particles including Somov and including my fictional Bowlmov.

The term "reconnection" is related to plasma physics. Clinger's stuff CANNOT explain reconnection because it defines no rate of reconnection. Get real. Wait, let me guess. "Math? What math?"

You can't claim 'reconnection' is happening without defining a way to describe the rate. Since Clinger didn't describe the rate of reconnection in step four, he didn't describe 'reconnection' at all. Hell, he didn't even know what the rate of reconnection was related to until LAST WEEK!

I already highlighted the wiki page and text on reconnection that blows your argument out of the water in the very first sentence. It's all related to PLASMA PHYSICS.

It's really simple. No particles, no velocity changes, no TRANSFER of field energy into kinetic energy, no RECONNECTION!
 
Last edited:
To get up to speed I'd suggest you read the approximately 11,600 posts in this thread and this thread.

He doesn't want to answer you because he has no intention of having an honest debate. When I asked him to define the rate of reconnection in the absence of mass acceleration, I got dead silence. He's not really much into math or physics or trying to clarify terms. He won't even retract the claim that electrical discharges cannot occur in conductors even though electrical discharges can ONLY happen in and through conductors. Trust me, he's not interested in honest scientific dialog or word clarification in hopes of moving anything forward.
 
Just as vacuums can happen in vacuums. Comprende?
Just as described in the literature, e.g.
Cosmic plasma physics By Boris V. Somov
Peer reviewed material that states plasma is optional in MR
And easily seen using undergraduate physics: W.D. Clinger's simple derivation of magnetic reconnection

Comprende?

But, can you now link to measurable experimental evidence proving the derived energies to physically tested effects ?
No because this is a trivaial process that no one bothers experimenting with when there are much more interesting stuff happening in MR in plasma.

Exactly. "Only an idiot would think that magnetic field lines or map lines are real things". Thus why magnetic reconection in a vacuum is a misnomer past mathematical abstraction.
Perhaps I should have mentioned the other side of this:
Only an idiot would think that magnetic field lines or map lines are real things.
​
which is
Only an idiot would think that magnetic field lines do not describe the topology of magnetic fields. That is their definition!
​
There can be magnetic field topology changes where the visualization of the magnetic field topology using magnetic field lines has the phenomena of the field lines reconnecting at a null point. The null point can be in vacuum (see Somov's and W.D.Clinger's examples) or in plasma.
Hmmm - maybe we should call this magnetic reconnection :rolleyes:.
 
Exactly. "Only an idiot would think that magnetic field lines or map lines are real things". Thus why magnetic reconection in a vacuum is a misnomer past mathematical abstraction.

Ya, way past. Like into the twilight zone. Somehow they want me to believe that peer reviewed math is the king of physics, and they're the kings, but they haven't got a published penny in their collective pocket. The term "rate of reconnection" directly relates to rate of the TRANSFER of field into other forms of (kinetic) energy. Clinger didn't even understand that until a week ago! Holy cow!
 
Geemack, what do you consider to be "electric/iron Sun claims"
I suggest that we should not derail this thread more than it has been already. MM's idea about an ""electric/iron Sun" has been discussed and debunked elsewhere.
ETA: Micheal Mozina's iron crust has been totally debunked

The OP was that solar flares are "electrical discharges" (whatever Michael Mozina thinks thiose are).
That has been resolved. Flares cannot be caused by actual electrical discharges (as in lightning) because they happen when a dielectric medium breaks down.
Dungey was instrumental in establishing the theory that magnetic reconnection causes solar flares. The modern scientific consensus is that magnetic reconnection causes solar flares. MM citing Dungey detroys the OP assertion.

The current topic is MM not understanding that MR happens in both in vacuum (a trivial case) and plasma.
 
Last edited:


No. First link does not work, and the other is based on maxwells theories and how we conceptualize a field with quantized constructs. I see no more physical evidence of magnetic reconnection in a vacuum than I do physical evidence of a vacuum within a vacuum.

The null point can be in vacuum (see Somov's and W.D.Clinger's examples) or in plasma.

What is representing the null point that I can physically measure and experiment with?

There's zero magnetic / electric potential at this point which could be deduced via ion movement (or lack there-of) but is there a distinct property you can tie down to such a point?
 
Last edited:
[latex]\mu_0I(z) = 4\pi\alpha^{-1} cos(\alpha|z| +\phi_r)[/latex]

Mozina claims this is one the equations that "proves" reconnection requires plasma, but he has no clue what it means. In fact, an illiterate Kenyan shepherd might have a better chance of reading and understanding Alice in Wonderland.
 
Last edited:
We've advanced from the point where one person was vehemently denying the existence of magnetic reconnection to the point where we all agree it occurs.

You're SO good at twisting the truth. FYI, I gave up doubting it was a real process *IN PLASMA* when I first read Birn's paper on the topic over at Space.com, long BEFORE I ever posted to this website. I must have explained that now a DOZEN times already, not that you are interested in scientific accuracy.

We're only a grade school kid's experiment away from agreeing magnetic reconnection occurs in a vacuum or not in a vacuum, in plasma or not, on a kitchen table or on the Sun. But at the current pace and with the continued refusal to actually conduct that experiment, it may be years before we get there.

I doubt you personally will ever get there because you have too much emotional attachment to the belief that electrical discharges cannot occur in conductors. Since that's wrong even in BASIC EM theory, it's pretty much hopeless for any chance you're going to see the light.

We still have claims being made about the composition of the Sun which are backed by fraudulent scientific papers,

My name is on those papers too! If you can call me a fraud to my face on this website based on satellite imagery analysis, I can call you a fraud too Mr "Electrical discharges cannot occur in conductors". You're wrong about even BASIC EM THEORY! You're clueless when you claim to have some kind of expertize in high energy solar satellite imagery which is demonstrated by your refusal to embrace the fact that electrical discharges occur in flares as Birkeland explained in 1908, Dungey explained in the 50's and Bruce explained in the 50's. You have NO right to judge anyone based on their knowledge of solar satellite imagery. None! Zero. Zip!

You can't even correctly explain the light source of a standard iron ion wavelength, and you BOTCHED the explanation as the to color above the transition region in a combined wavelength image. The color has NOTHING to do with alignment errors as you claimed. Everything you've said has been wrong beyond belief. Talk about crackpot claims!
 
Last edited:
...they haven't got a published penny in their collective pocket.
You are lying: Peer reviewed material that states plasma is optional in MR

...
The term "rate of reconnection" directly relates to rate of the TRANSFER of field into other forms of (kinetic) energy.
More ignorance: There is no term "rate of reconnection".

MHD models of MR have a reconnection rate that is directly related to plasma velocity, i.e. the TRANSFER of magnetic field energy into kinetic energy. This is basic stuff - MR happens, induces electric fields and these accelerate charged particles. Thus plasma is accelerated, (the inflowing and outflowing velocities into the MR region will differ).
See the last 2 paragraphs in Cosmic plasma physics By Boris V. Somov section "Reconnection in vacuum" before he goes onto "Reconnection in plasma".
It is rather dumb to keep mentioning reconnection rates when everyone knows that they are only defined for MR in plasma which you have no problem with.
 
I think 80% of this thread is just down equivocation misunderstandings.

Electricty did it / Magnetism did it, is a classic, for example.

Someone versed in basic electromagnetism will know they are at a basic level, the same. The difference is way we conceptualize them. Magnetism with field lines, flux strength, vector fields, etc, and other constructs. Currents with motion, charge, particle properties, vector fields, etc. But you can still define magnetism with the concepts I list after currents, and vice versa. Are EM fields constant, or quantized? Both. But they can't be, really. We end up back at 'is it a particle or wave?' type debate by the end. Or Bu and Ej approaches to various plasma related geo/stellar physics models.

Both can lead to totally different results/predictions/models on occasions, as the conceptualizations used for both is different.

Actually however, *IT* is more fundamental then even the debate as to whether IT was done by E or B. *IT* (reconnection) is particle acceleration and the TRANSFER of energy INTO particle kinetic energy. It doesn't matter whether you prefer a B or E orientation, you still need particle acceleration either way.

I'm afraid the denial-go-round is pretty much never ending around here.
 
No. First link does not work, and the other is based on maxwells theories and how we conceptualize a field with quantized constructs.
No. First link does work (for me).
ETA: But the text of these 2 pages is in one of the posts about MM's inability to read understand this setion. Start with Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section IX!
You missed out Peer reviewed material that states plasma is optional in MR
W.D. Clinger's simple derivation of magnetic reconnection is based on Maxwell's laws. You stated you have no problem with it. If MR in a vacuum does not exist then Maxwell's laws are wrong.

I see no more physical evidence of magnetic reconnection in a vacuum than I do physical evidence of a vacuum within a vacuum.
That is the point! There is no physical evidence in the scientific literature because MR in vacuum is (almost) as trivial as a vacuum in a vacuum.

What is representing the null point that I can physically measure and experiment with?
B=0.

There's zero magnetic / electric potential at this point which could be deduced via ion movement (or lack there-of) but is there a distinct property you can tie down to such a point?
That is gibberish.
The definition of a null point is where B=0. This is a fundamental concept in magnetic reconnection so I suggest that you learn about it and MR.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom