Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
I've learned more lurking in this thread than you have in all your years of self-taught idiocy.

No you haven't. Three guys that haven't read a single plasma physics textbook between, not even in the year they've participated in this thread, talking about 'reconnection' sounds like three blind mice to me. Clinger didn't even know what the rate of reconnection referred to until LAST WEEK! What you SHOULD have learned and what you THINK you learned are two entirely different things.
 
So where do things stand?

Rate of reconnection in the absence of mass acceleration: "Math? What math?"
Dungey's work on reconnection and electrical discharges in flares? "Discharges? What Discharges?"
Request for peer reviewed material to support your claim that plasma is optional: "Peer reviewed material? What peer reviewed material?"

Bah. You people just give science a bad name. Published materials don't mean a thing to you. They all demonstrate that reconnection is a process that occurs in PLASMA! They all demonstrate that magnetic lines do not begin, or end, or have a source or a sink. Math doesn't mean anything to you folks because you're all incapable of mathematically expressing a rate of reconnection without mass acceleration. You've never be able to produce a two magnetic experiment in a vacuum that claims the process is anything other than flux, attraction and/or repulsion or even MENTIONS the word "reconnection" of those lines. They all used terms "bending and twisting" even on the websites where the diagrams came from!

Don't ever lecture me about math again. You don't give a damn about math or you'd abandon your position because you can't produce any math to describe the rate of reconnection.
 
Last edited:
What a surprise. Reversion to untenable position complete.
 
Incorrect. Individual lines are quantitative representations of where the strength does not fade or gain. It's a math thing,

Since the magnets are moving, it's a PHYSICS thing.

and without understanding math even at a rudimentary level it might be difficult to understand what a field line actually is.

A field line is something that has no source, no sink, no beginning, and no end. It's physically incapable of disconnecting from, or reconnecting to any other "line". Even the concept of a LINE is a GROSS oversimplification since its a two full field interaction, not just a couple of lines here and there.

At any given instant in time, magnetic reconnection can be represented by just a couple of lines. W. D. Clinger did that with his mathematical example which was described at great length many months ago.

Neither you or Clinger has offered us a rate of reconnection in the absence of plasma. Math? What math?

The idea of magnetic field lines is a mathematical concept, very elementary. It doesn't even require understanding addition or subtraction to get it.

Likewise, the understanding that a field line is a continuous loop, without beginning, without end, without a source and without a sink is easy to understand. It's a pity some folks have such a poor grasp of PHYSICS even BASIC EM theory.

Without understanding math at that simple level it may be difficult or even impossible to understand magnetic reconnection.

I didn't find the maths to be complicated to understand, but I also understand that all those math formulas relate to the behaviors of PLASMA!

And without grasping the basic quantitative issue of magnetic field lines and how they mathematically show that magnetic reconnection actually occurs, it may just be meaningless to try to move the discussion to anything more complicated.

Since not a single one of you can come up with mathematical expression of the rate of reconnection in the absence of particle acceleration, the quantitative breakdown is YOUR FAULT, not mine. I can't understand something you can't even dream up.
 
What a surprise. Reversion to untenable position complete.

What untenable position? I've got THOUSANDS, maybe tens of thousands of MHD papers on the topic of reconnection that all support my position. I've provided a DOZEN or more papers demonstrating that B lines have no source, no sink, no beginning and no end. I've got MATHEMATICAL expressions for the rate of reconnection, in fact MULTIPLE ones to work with!

Your side can't even express the rate mathematically WITHOUT particle acceleration or produce any peer reviewed literature to support your claims that plasma is optional in the reconnection process. Talk about untenable positions.
 
Last edited:
Clinger should demand his money back on those books on EM theory.

Evidently neither one of them even mentioned "magnetic reconnection" and they must not have ever described two magnet interaction. What useless books!
 
You know, I have two Russian colleagues. I'm tempted to get them to translate an email for me to send to Somov. I wonder what he would say if I asked him about plasma in his vacuum example? What do you think he would say, Michael?
 
Where is the plasma in Somov's vacuum?

Where are the bowling balls in my fictional Bowlmov example?

Somov *INCLUDED* current in his vacuum. The term "current" involves moving charged physical objects. In fact Somov explicitly states that the MOVEMENT of the currents (Bowlmov's streams of bowling balls) toward each other is what allows the process to occur in the first place! I highlighted the sentence and everything.
 
Where are the bowling balls in my fictional Bowlmov example?

Somov *INCLUDED* current in his vacuum. The term "current" involves moving charged physical objects. In fact Somov explicitly states that the MOVEMENT of the currents (Bowlmov's streams of bowling balls) toward each other is what allows the process to occur in the first place! I highlighted the sentence and everything.
Hmmm..so no plasma then. Just idealized currents outside the vacuum region.
 
You know, I have two Russian colleagues. I'm tempted to get them to translate an email for me to send to Somov. I wonder what he would say if I asked him about plasma in his vacuum example? What do you think he would say, Michael?

I think he would say that his example *INCLUDES* not excludes moving charged particles of mass. I believe (I could be wrong) that Somov is plenty fluent in English by the way.
 
Hmmm..so no plasma then.

Boloney! Even a SINGLE iron ion can be in a PLASMA state. The term "plasma" describes a STATE of matter that involved CHARGE PARTICLES and charged particle moments. An moving iron ion (current) in a vacuum is not a solid, a liquid or a gas, it's a plasma.

Just idealized currents outside the vacuum region.

No, his currents are *IN* the vacuum. He specifically puts the current *INTO* the "vacuum".
 
Last edited:
I think he would say that his example *INCLUDES* not excludes moving charged particles of mass. I believe (I could be wrong) that Somov is plenty fluent in English by the way.
Do you think he would say that his vacuum reconnection example includes plasma?
 
I think he would say it *INCLUDES* (does not exclude) moving charged particles in a plasma state.
So, your answer is "yes". Interesting. I'll see if I can summon the motivation to ask him what will surely be the stupidest question he has ever been asked about his work. Stay tuned.
 
Michael Mozina's statements often become more accurate when quoted out of context. For example:

What a surprise. Reversion to untenable position complete.

What untenable position? I've got THOUSANDS, maybe tens of thousands



A field line is something that has no source, no sink,
That's true for magnetic field lines because the magnetic field satisfies div B = 0.

no beginning, and no end.
No, that's a myth. Most magnetic field lines have no beginning or end, but magnetic field lines can begin or end at neutral points, as in the field generated by four parallel conducting rods, with equal currents in the north and south rods and equal but oppositely directed currents in the west and east rods.

It's a pity some folks have such a poor grasp of PHYSICS even BASIC EM theory.
True.

I didn't find the maths to be complicated to understand,
False.

If Michael Mozina understood the math of basic EM theory, he'd understand the math at that web site. That math derives magnetic reconnection in a vacuum as a simple consequence of Maxwell's equations.

but I also understand that all those math formulas relate to the behaviors of PLASMA!
False.

Maxwell's equations describe the magnetic field generated by any current. Maxwell's equations are not limited to describing the behaviors of plasma. The magnetic fields shown at that web site are generated by electrical currents within the conducting rods. Absolutely no plasma is involved.
 
Last edited:
Michael Mozina's statements often become more accurate when quoted out of context. For example:

That's true for magnetic field lines because the magnetic field satisfies div B = 0.

FYI, there's a more fundamental PHYSICAL reason. All magnetic fields are CREATED BY the movement of charged particles.

No, that's a myth. Most magnetic field lines have no beginning or end, but magnetic field lines can begin or end at neutral points,

False. I showed you over a dozen *PUBLISHED* references that said they had no beginning and no ending, *EVER*. They made no such references to special locations or neutral points. That's entirely YOUR claim, and you've never demonstrated it.

as in the field generated by four parallel conducting rods, with equal currents in the north and south rods and equal but oppositely directed currents in the west and east rods.

No, that particular website is UNPUBLISHED NONSENSE that *ACTUALLY* demonstrates that the NULL point is NOT special in any way and Guass's laws are satisfied in the NULL just like everywhere else in the chamber!

Furthermore I know for a fact that the author of that particular website is KNOWN to make, and continues to make highly erroneous and inaccurate statements. For instance the same author claims that I personally deny that magnetic reconnection is a real process. I deny no such thing.

Since the author can't be trusted to even represent my position on this topic accurately, it's clearly unreliable, unpublished, unpublishable nonsense. Individual magnetic B lines do not begin, they do not end they do not have a source, they do not have a sink. In fact a FIELD forms as a FULL continuum. Individual lines are incapable of "reconnecting" to other LINES because there really aren't any "lines" in the first place! There are just two *ENTIRE FIELDS* that interact and flux and change over time.

If Michael Mozina understood the math of basic EM theory, he'd understand the math at that web site. That math derives magnetic reconnection in a vacuum as a simple consequence of Maxwell's equations.

Your entire argument comes down to "because I say so even though the published material says otherwise". Worse yet you cannot, nor have you EVER even attempted to show us any mathematical expression for the rate of reconnection in the absence of charged particle acceleration. Since your mathematics (lack thereof) turns out to be an EPIC fail (utterly missing a rate of reconnection in fact) we can EASILY dismiss your claim of "reconnection" as nonsense. You didn't even know what the rate of reconnection even relates to until AFTER you wrote that stuff!
 
Last edited:
So where do things stand?

Exactly where they’ve stood for sometime now. At an experiment you can perform in your own home which meets your requirements for “electrical discharge” and “"reconnection"” by “the transfer of energy from the magnetic field to particle kinetic energy” with no intervening plasma. You can run around all you want insisting that people dance to your tune but the music has stopped and you have left yourself without a chair.
 
False. I showed you over a dozen *PUBLISHED* references that said they had no beginning and no ending, *EVER*. They made no such references to special locations or neutral points. That's entirely YOUR claim, and you've never demonstrated it.

Does a vector with 0 magnitude have a direction?
 
So, your answer is "yes". Interesting. I'll see if I can summon the motivation to ask him what will surely be the stupidest question he has ever been asked about his work. Stay tuned.

Oh, I'm sure you're going to misrepresent what I said.

If I put an atom of non ionized iron into a vacuum a give it momentum, it's in the "gas" state. If I ionize that same moving atom, it's in a "plasma" state, and it's also a form of "current'. Likewise, electrons encased in non-ionized particles are just electrons. Free electrons that are moving through a vacuum are particles in the plasma state and also a form of current. You guys act as though a PLASMA state is not a state of MATTER!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom