GeeMack
Banned
- Joined
- Aug 21, 2007
- Messages
- 7,235
When you change the distance between points, and the orientations of the WHOLE FIELD, individual lines fade and gain in strength over time.
Incorrect. Individual lines are quantitative representations of where the strength does not fade or gain. It's a math thing, and without understanding math even at a rudimentary level it might be difficult to understand what a field line actually is.
Whatever FADING occurs somewhere in the WHOLE FIELD is made up for in a GAIN somewhere else. It's just flux change, attraction and repulsion between TWO ENTIRE FIELDS, not just a couple of lines here and there.
At any given instant in time, magnetic reconnection can be represented by just a couple of lines. W. D. Clinger did that with his mathematical example which was described at great length many months ago.
IMO it's really meaningless to talk about individual LINES to begin with since we're really describing WHOLE FIELD interactions. Your ideas about individual lines are PRIMITIVE in the first place, and the notion they "disconnect from" or "reconnect to" some other field line has *NOTHING WHATSOEVER* to do with the term from the field of plasma physics called "reconnection". MHD theory describes MASS IN MOTION, and the transfer of energy from the magnetic field to particle kinetic energy.
The idea of magnetic field lines is a mathematical concept, very elementary. It doesn't even require understanding addition or subtraction to get it. Without understanding math at that simple level it may be difficult or even impossible to understand magnetic reconnection. And without grasping the basic quantitative issue of magnetic field lines and how they mathematically show that magnetic reconnection actually occurs, it may just be meaningless to try to move the discussion to anything more complicated.