Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
When you change the distance between points, and the orientations of the WHOLE FIELD, individual lines fade and gain in strength over time.


Incorrect. Individual lines are quantitative representations of where the strength does not fade or gain. It's a math thing, and without understanding math even at a rudimentary level it might be difficult to understand what a field line actually is.

Whatever FADING occurs somewhere in the WHOLE FIELD is made up for in a GAIN somewhere else. It's just flux change, attraction and repulsion between TWO ENTIRE FIELDS, not just a couple of lines here and there.


At any given instant in time, magnetic reconnection can be represented by just a couple of lines. W. D. Clinger did that with his mathematical example which was described at great length many months ago.

IMO it's really meaningless to talk about individual LINES to begin with since we're really describing WHOLE FIELD interactions. Your ideas about individual lines are PRIMITIVE in the first place, and the notion they "disconnect from" or "reconnect to" some other field line has *NOTHING WHATSOEVER* to do with the term from the field of plasma physics called "reconnection". MHD theory describes MASS IN MOTION, and the transfer of energy from the magnetic field to particle kinetic energy.


The idea of magnetic field lines is a mathematical concept, very elementary. It doesn't even require understanding addition or subtraction to get it. Without understanding math at that simple level it may be difficult or even impossible to understand magnetic reconnection. And without grasping the basic quantitative issue of magnetic field lines and how they mathematically show that magnetic reconnection actually occurs, it may just be meaningless to try to move the discussion to anything more complicated.
 
*ANY* honest scientific debate *REQUIRES* peer reviewed literature, otherwise it's young Earth creationism on a stick.


You must not have much experience with honest scientific debate or peer review.

Cutting-edge scientific debate is often conducted via informal, interpersonal channels. That's one of the reasons scientists go to conferences.

Scientists don't limit themselves to discussing peer-reviewed literature. By the time some result has been peer-reviewed and published, it's likely to be old news. Cutting-edge discussion is likely to involve arXiv preprints and results that are so new they haven't even been posted at arXiv.

Dungey's work was peer reviewed


Are you sure?

You're referring to Dungey's 1958 paper, which was published in Electromagnetic Phenomena in Cosmical Physics, B Lehnert (editor). That appears to be the proceedings of "International Astronomical Union Symposium No. 6".

The word "symposium" comes from the Greek word for a drinking party. Scientists generally use the word "symposium" to refer to fairly informal meetings whose technical papers are subjected to even less review than the papers presented at a conference.

The question-and-answer session that appears in the proceedings immediately after Dungey's paper is typical for a symposium or a fairly informal conference. I think it's rather unlikely that Dungey's 1958 paper was peer-reviewed.
 
The currents are idealized currents. This is the same as the current J in Maxwell's equations. Somov thus describes reconnection in vacuum because there is nothing physical there.

The magnetic field lines reconnect at the null (or neutral) point which is distant from the currents. So even if someone assumes that the currents are actual wires or magically constrained plasma or magically constrained charged particles, the MR still happens in vacuum.

That's correct.

By the way, magnetic reconnection can occur without the two currents moving toward each other. Magnetic reconnection will also occur if the two currents move away from each other instead of toward each other. You can also get magnetic reconnection by leaving the currents exactly where they are but decreasing or increasing the magnitude of one current.

Thank you both.

And thank you Michael for your belligerent ignorance that allows lurkers to learn from the explanations your betters provide.
 
Do you REALLY KNOW that you are the only one that reads this thread that has not noticed the fact that a formula to express the rate of "reconnection" in the absence of the movement of mass was posted 4 days ago:

You absolutely have no idea what you're talking about. That rate of reconnection, along with EVERY SINGLE rate of 'reconnection' is based upon PLASMA and movements of PLASMA. S is all about PLASMA by the way.

Honestly, it's just sad that all these hot shot math jocks can't even DREAM UP (make up, pull out of their back pocket) a way to express the rate of reconnection in the absence of the acceleration of mass. It's pathetic that you cling to some ridiculous notion that you can't even express mathematically, and then have the AUDACITY to chastise me about math. Clingers stuff IS INCAPABLE of expressing a rate of reconnection. In fact he was CLUELESS what the the term even meant in terms of plasma physics until LAST WEEK!

Or maybe this is your insane demand to express the reconnection rate which uses plasma velocity and is defined friom MHD theory when there is no plasma.

You're the one insane enough to claim the "reconnection" is occurring when there is no plasma or charged particle movement. The evidence for you insanity is found in the fact that you can't even express the rate of reconnection that is supposedly occurring mathematically. It's just nonsense to claim 'reconnection' occurs without mass acceleration.

I've seen denial play out in groups before, but WOW!
 
Thank you both.

And thank you Michael for your belligerent ignorance that allows lurkers to learn from the explanations your betters provide.

Considering the fact that I don't think the three of you even own a *SINGLE* plasma physics textbook between you, and none of you can mathematically express the rate of reconnection in the absence of mass, that's really amusing. Talk about belligerent ignorance. :)
 
No it doesn't. For example, there is ample evidence for the fact that the Earth is a sphere not flat,

There's plenty of scientific evidence to support that it's a sphere including parts we left on the moon. :)

and it orbits the Sun not the other way round. No need to go to peer reviewed papers to discover that.

Any published textbook on astronomy will mention it! No need to rely on a few guys on some website.

Similarly, an experiment that can be performed on a table with a pair of bar magnets and a compass doesn't require peer reviewed literature. It really is trivial.

Clinger already mentioned that neither of the EM field theory books even mentioned the term "reconnection'. I'm sure they explained induction, flux, attraction and repulsion however.

Do you know how that sounds from my side of the aisle? Imagine a YEC telling you that some religious text says so, some guy's website in cyberspace says so, therefore it's true? That's about the way I feel about the fact that none of you can come up with published literature to support you claim about moving magnet interactions.

It isn't necessary in the present case because it is trivial. Much like the flat/spherical Earth debate.

It's so 'trivial' it's called "flux change". The term "reconnection' comes from and relates to PLASMA physics.

I'll skip the redundant stuff.

Neither can you. Hell, you have no idea what a plasma is. You thought a single electron was a plasma yesterday. Now that is really ironic.

Oh boloney. A single electron or positron or ion in motion is a form of plasma and form of current. It's a charged particle in motion. A single ion of iron is the same thing. That single atom has a specific STATE, a solid, liquid, gas or PLASMA. A single ion is a PLASMA and exists in a plasma state, not a solid, not a liquid, not a gas.
 
Considering the fact that I don't think the three of you even own a *SINGLE* plasma physics textbook between you, and none of you can mathematically express the rate of reconnection in the absence of mass, that's really amusing. Talk about belligerent ignorance. :)
I am ignorant. So are you. The difference between us is I know it and you don't. Know thyself - still words to live by all these centuries later. It is obvious that you are completely deluded about your own level of knowledge on this subject.
 
Last edited:
You must not have much experience with honest scientific debate or peer review.

Certainly not on this board. It's all about personal attack around here. Worse yet, not one of you can even produce a SINGLE peer reviewed publication that supports your claim, nor can you even IMAGINE a mathematical expression for the rate of reconnection in the absence of mass acceleration. There hasn't been anything SCIENTIFICALLY HONEST about your side of the debate. It's been nothing but handwaves.

Cutting-edge scientific debate is often conducted via informal, interpersonal channels.

This isn't cutting edge anything. Two magnet interactions have been around since the dawn of time. Why do you think that neither of your two textbooks on EM theory mention the term 'reconnection'?

Scientists don't limit themselves to discussing peer-reviewed literature.

Neither do young Earth creationists. That's not saying much.

Are you sure?

I'm not sure about the one paper, but I'm sure his work on plasma physics has been well peer reviewed. They all describe mass acceleration in plasma Clinger. That's just the sad fact from your perspective. Whether ONE paper was peer reviewed or not, all his papers describe plasma acceleration and the transfer of magnetic field energy into particle acceleration. That's just documented fact. He personally did call it an 'electrical discharge' as does pretty much any EU proponent, including Peratt. Peratt even clearly defined the term in a way that is congruent with either Dungey's use of the the term, *OR* Bruce's use of the term, *OR* Birkeland's use of that same term in his published work from over *100* years ago.
 
I actually see a little bit of progress in Michael's latest rejection of reality. He's been furiously refusing to acknowledge that magnetic reconnection happens in a vacuum because, according to his fantasy physics, it absolutely, positively can't happen without plasma. The result? He's acknowledged that magnetic reconnection happens in plasma.

This is a pretty big concession and is a complete about-face from his previous position on magnetic reconnection, period. Bravo.
 
I am ignorant. So are you. The difference between us is I know it and you don't.

Ya, that and 5 or so books on plasma physics sitting on my shelf.

Know thyself - still words to live by all these centuries later. It is obvious that you are completey deluded about your own level of knowledge on this subject.

Knowing thyself and knowing one is ignorant is fine as long as you don't INTENTIONALLY stay that way and never lift a finger to READ anything about the topic in PUBLISHED literature, and make an attempt to understand it. For God sake, Clinger didn't even know what the 'rate of reconnection' meant in terms of plasma physics until LAST WEEK! Wow.

We all start off ignorant and we all remain ignorant to some degree or another. That doesn't mean I'm obligated to WALLOW and BASK in self imposed ignorance forever and ever. The real difference between us is that I've read at least 5 books on plasma physics, which is 5 more than than the 3 of you put together. That's the real difference between us, and I know that too.
 
D'rok, if you want to see ignorance, notice that nobody yet has offered us a way to mathematically express a rate of reconnection in the absence of mass acceleration. That's ignorance. If published, peer reviewed mathematics is the currency of physics, your side is penniless.
 
Ya, that and 5 or so books on plasma physics sitting on my shelf.



Knowing thyself and knowing one is ignorant is fine as long as you don't INTENTIONALLY stay that way and never lift a finger to READ anything about the topic in PUBLISHED literature, and make an attempt to understand it. For God sake, Clinger didn't even know what the 'rate of reconnection' meant in terms of plasma physics until LAST WEEK! Wow.

We all start off ignorant and we all remain ignorant to some degree or another. That doesn't mean I'm obligated to WALLOW and BASK in self imposed ignorance forever and ever. The real difference between us is that I've read at least 5 books on plasma physics, which is 5 more than than the 3 of you put together. That's the real difference between us, and I know that too.
You have read some material, yet you remain profoundly ignorant, belligerently insisting that your ignorance is knowledge and your fantasies factual, completely unaware that you remain totally ignorant about the subject you are so devoted to. This is worse than simple ignorance and clearly demonstrates your complete lack of self knowledge.
 
Last edited:
D'rok, if you want to see ignorance, notice that nobody yet has offered us a way to mathematically express a rate of reconnection in the absence of mass acceleration. That's ignorance. If published, peer reviewed mathematics is the currency of physics, your side is penniless.
If I want to see ignorance, I would point out your belligerent repetition of this idiotic question which has been answered at least a dozen times already. No one can force you to abandon your lunacy; you will have to take the first step yourself. Maybe acknowledging that magnetic reconnection is a real, physical phenomenon, which you have done, is that first step, but I doubt it.
 
Last edited:
But most directly relevant to this discussion, Oliver Manuel is a crackpot who has attempted to perpetrate a fraud on the scientific community. He has made a seriously stupid mistake in believing some running difference images actually show something thousands of kilometers beyond the point where the photosphere becomes opaque.

It is fraudulent of him to imply, as he has in the acknowledgements in a previous paper, that NASA made an "image of rigid structures beneath the fluid photosphere". NASA did no such thing, and to misrepresent the data as he has there makes him a flat out liar and makes his allegedly scientific papers worthless. He's a liar and a fraud.

....

The persistent misrepresentation of my position is, although expected, uncivil and dishonest.

Emphasis mine. What do you know about "civil" or "honest" scientific debate? You used the term liar, fraud, stupid, etc so many times I just stopped counting. Worse yet, your declared 'reason' is directly related to *ME*, solar satellite imagery, and my part of those very same published papers. I've seen SLEAZY debate tactics in my life, but you're the worst of the worst. Instead of attacking me personally you attack someone I wrote the paper with who doesn't post to this thread so you can effectively call me a FRAUD. The rules at this board mean nothing. Math means nothing to you. Your math skills are meaningless because when I asked you to come up with a rate of reconnection, I got "Math? What math?", just like a got "Discharges in plasma? What discharges?" You have no right to call ANYONE a fraud. You have NO knowledge of solar physics AT ALL. Do you even own a book on plasma physics, yes or no?

What kind of rule BS is this anyway? It's somehow "OK" to call my coauthors a "fraud" here, and use MY WORK as a rationale. Where's the fairness in terms of debate? Honest scientific debate at JREF based on published peer reviewed material and mathematically expressed ideas? What published material? What math? What honest debate?
 
If I want to see ignorance, I would point out your belligerant repetition of this idiotic question which has been anwered at least a dozen times already.

Because the answer isn't an 'answer' at all. It's effectively an ADMISSION OF GUILT, followed by more denial of physics.

Maybe acknowledging that magnetic reconnection is a real, physical phenomenon, which you have done, is that first step, but I doubt it.

OMG. I did that YEARS ago. "Reconnection" is a term related to PLASMA PHYSICS, not basic EM theory. Why is that? Do you HONESTLY think Clinger's textbooks which according to him do NOT mention "reconnection' didn't describe two magnet interactions? What terminology did they use in your opinion?
 
Last edited:
OMG. I did that YEARS ago. "Reconnection" is a term related to PLASMA PHYSICS, not basic EM theory. Why is that? Do you HONESTLY think Clinger's textbooks which according to him do NOT mention "reconnection' didn't describe two magnet interactions? What terminology did they use in your opinion?
No you didn't. You've been calling it "curcuit" reconnection and trying, and failing, to show that this actually happens.

Acknowledging that magnetic reconnection is real is a huge concession.
 
You have read some material, yet you remain profoundly ignorant,

It is profoundly ignorant to believe "reconnection* occurs without particle acceleration if you can't describe the RATE of reconnection without it!

At least I took the time to educate myself and read TEXTBOOKS and many dozens of papers on the topic of "reconnection". What I learned is that 'plasma isn't optional' in the reconnection process, nor is "education". Ignorance need not be a permanent state of mind, but I somehow doubt that any of the three of you will ever invest in a plasma physics textbook, let alone take the time to read it.

Not that your ignorance will stop you from participating in a topic you clearly know nothing about.
 
It is profoundly ignorant to believe "reconnection* occurs without particle acceleration if you can't describe the RATE of reconnection without it!

At least I took the time to educate myself and read TEXTBOOKS and many dozens of papers on the topic of "reconnection". What I learned is that 'plasma isn't optional' in the reconnection process, nor is "education". Ignorance need not be a permanent state of mind, but I somehow doubt that any of the three of you will ever invest in a plasma physics textbook, let alone take the time to read it.

Not that your ignorance will stop you from participating in a topic you clearly know nothing about.
I've learned more lurking in this thread than you have in all your years of self-taught idiocy.
 
No you didn't. You've been calling it "curcuit" reconnection and trying, and failing, to show that this actually happens.

Because that *IS* what happens in a "reconnection" event! Alfven referred to coronal loops as "circuits". If you "reconnect' two of them, it's "circuit reconnection". The fact you folks cannot and will not embrace the circuit side of plasma physics is no skin off my nose.

Acknowledging that magnetic reconnection is real is a huge concession.

I acknowledge that the PROCESS called "reconnection' is real. It's involves "real' particles of matter that REALLY get accelerated. ;)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom