Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
You're still confused Tim. The magnetic field *ALWAYS* propagates at the speed of light. In fact, the field is made *OF* photons. The "velocity" you describe is the "velocity" of the magnet Tim. Plasma and physical objects have a "velocity" that you can measure and change through "reconnection". Unless and until you change the velocity of a physical object, no "reconnection" has occurred because no transfer of magnetic field energy into particle kinetic energy has occurred.

Is that all you need a “transfer of magnetic field energy into particle kinetic energy”? No problem.

Again back to the same experiment recommended countless times that you can perform in your own home.

Take two bar magnets, one fixed and one free to rotate. Initially the magnets are North to South and the field lines connect directly from one magnet to the other. Rotate the free one 180 degrees and the magnets are now North to North or South to South (depending on how the fixed magnet is orientated). You have stored some of the kinetic energy you imparted by rotating the magnet in the new field configuration where the magnets fields are not directly connected to each other. Release the free magnet and it will rotate back to the original configuration. “magnetic field energy” has been turned back “ into particle kinetic energy” (of the free magnet). So there you have not only what is an “electrical discharge” by your definition of such but it is also “"reconnection"” as a “transfer of magnetic field energy into particle kinetic energy has occurred”. All your requirements for “”reconnection”” and “electrical discharge” in a single experiment you can do yourself, at home and with no intervening plasma.
 
As much the above has been demonstrated time and again to be a lie, what's more important here is this: There is no published peer reviewed literature that objectively concludes that the Sun has a solid, rigid, or iron surface.

Even that statement is false.
http://www.springerlink.com/content/906760626772561u/

And there is no published peer reviewed literature that objectively concludes that solar flares and CMEs are some kind of lightning-like sparks.

Dungey's work was peer reviewed and he called them electrical discharges. Bruce's materials were also peer reviewed an he called the electrical discharges too. You can't even tell the truth if you tried.

And all the dishonest attempts to avoid the burden of proof are, well, dishonest.

The only one deflecting the burden of proof is you. When I asked you to demonstrate your claim that particle physics is optional in reconnection, specifically the rate of 'reconnection' process, I got: "Math? What math?" Typical.
 
Is that all you need a “transfer of magnetic field energy into particle kinetic energy”? No problem.

Again back to the same experiment recommended countless times that you can perform in your own home.

Take two bar magnets, one fixed and one free to rotate. Initially the magnets are North to South and the field lines connect directly from one magnet to the other. Rotate the free one 180 degrees and the magnets are now North to North or South to South (depending on how the fixed magnet is orientated). You have stored some of the kinetic energy you imparted by rotating the magnet in the new field configuration where the magnets fields are not directly connected to each other. Release the free magnet and it will rotate back to the original configuration. “magnetic field energy” has been turned back “ into particle kinetic energy” (of the free magnet). So there you have not only what is an “electrical discharge” by your definition of such but it is also “"reconnection"” as a “transfer of magnetic field energy into particle kinetic energy has occurred”. All your requirements for “”reconnection”” and “electrical discharge” in a single experiment you can do yourself, at home and with no intervening plasma.

Since you were the original champion of this claim as I recall, perhaps you would be so kind as to provide us with some peer reviewed literature that describes this moving magnet process as 'reconnection' rather than in terms of flux change, attraction and repulsion between the magnets? That would be VERY helpful about now. The other thing you could do is mathematically express the rate of "reconnection" without it relating to mass acceleration. That would be even MORE helpful about now.
 
Last edited:
You need to learn to read. This crank paper states: "The Sun formed on the collapsed core of a supernova (SN) and is composed mostly of elements made near the SN core (Fe, O, Ni, Si, and S), like the rocky planets and ordinary meteorites."

The Fe is near the core, not on the surface.

Dungey's work was peer reviewed and he called them electrical discharges.
You are lying. Dungey never stated that solar flares are electrical discharges.

Bruce's materials were also peer reviewed an he called the electrical discharges too.
Wow. You cite one crank whose idea contradicts you and is easily debunked and follow it with another crank citation without citing any of his peer reviewed papers.
Bruce was deluded enough to believe that actual lightning happens on the Sun.

ETA: His papers were mostly published in The Observatory which states (at least currently) All papers and short contributions are subject to peer review by the normal refereeing process.
Bruce was not deluded enough to state that the Sun has solid, rigid, or iron surface.
So what GeeMack wote is still true:
Originally Posted by GeeMack
As much the above has been demonstrated time and again to be a lie, what's more important here is this: There is no published peer reviewed literature that objectively concludes that the Sun has a solid, rigid, or iron surface.

When I asked you to demonstrate your claim that particle physics is optional in reconnection, specifically the rate of 'reconnection' process, I got: "Math? What math?" Typical.
No what you got is astonishment at the state of your ignorance.
There is no "rate of 'reconnection' process".
MHD theory for MR in plasma has a reconnection rate that usede inward and outward plasma velocities.

MM: What is reconnection rate of the plasma inside a rock containing no plasma?
 
Last edited:
Alight Das, I've thought some more about your images. IMO it's unlike that the lines are going to remain at a constant strength during rotation. By the time you get to figure 4 the "lines" have probably faded to ZERO and any NEW lines that form on the other side of the rotation will form at a near ZERO strength and gain strength as the magnets rotate 180 degrees.

In short, I don't think those lines stay in existence beyond a specific point. They simply fade to zero and new lines form as the magnets continue to rotate IMO.

If we add plasma however, it might get more interesting. :)

Fade to zero? Have those permanent magnets suddenly become less magnetic just because you rotate them? So let me get this right “the "lines" have probably faded to ZERO” so the magnetic fields of the permanent magnets just disappear and “NEW lines”, a new magnetic field configuration, just spring forth and “gain strength”? All evidently just to suit your own Cognitive dissonance of the field configuration changes requiring reconnection of the field lines.
 
Maybe I'm misinterpreting you, but it seems that if the lines can stretch and twist but can't cross, break, or begin/end at a null, then even in a vacuum you'd get terribly twisted field lines. If we take a simple case of 2 bar magnets with some gap between them, and rotate one of the magnets 360 deg, wouldn't the field lines have to wrap around the magnet:

(pardon the quality of my art)
[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/picture.php?albumid=741&pictureid=5700[/qimg]

. . . I really don't think that's what happens, but are you asserting that it does? And if it doesn't, then wouldn't that violate some of your assertions?

P.S. the diagram would be slightly more clear if "N" and "S" didn't look exactly the same when rotated 180 deg.

Sorry I missed that before, nice work
 
Since you were the original champion of this claim as I recall, perhaps you would be so kind as to provide us with some peer reviewed literature that describes this moving magnet process as 'reconnection' rather than in terms of flux change, attraction and repulsion between the magnets? That would be VERY helpful about now. The other thing you could do is mathematically express the rate of "reconnection" without it relating to mass acceleration. That would be even MORE helpful about now.


"original champion of this claim"? The claims for those requirements of your “electrical discharge” and “"reconnection"” where only yours. Would you like them to be simply ignored now that it is obvious even to you that a simple experiment you can perform in your own home meets those requirement without any intervening plasma?
 
Fade to zero? Have those permanent magnets suddenly become less magnetic just because you rotate them? So let me get this right “the "lines" have probably faded to ZERO” so the magnetic fields of the permanent magnets just disappear and “NEW lines”, a new magnetic field configuration, just spring forth and “gain strength”? All evidently just to suit your own Cognitive dissonance of the field configuration changes requiring reconnection of the field lines.

Mozina has discovered Maxwell's unknown equation:

B(t) = B0e-kt
 
You need to learn to read. This crank paper states: "The Sun formed on the collapsed core of a supernova (SN) and is composed mostly of elements made near the SN core (Fe, O, Ni, Si, and S), like the rocky planets and ordinary meteorites."

The Fe is near the core, not on the surface.

I'll be the judge of what my papers says and doesn't say thank you very much. :) If you can't accept the fact the Dungey used the term "electrical discharges" in solar flare activity, there's no point in discussing my papers with you personally. That would be a pointless exercise in utter futility.

You are lying. Dungey never stated that solar flares are electrical discharges.

He did say electrical discharges occur in solar flare and 'reconnection' activity. His use of the term is actually 100% congruent with Peratt's definition of an electrical discharge in plasma. They both are describing the TRANSFER of magnetic field energy into particle kinetic energy. It's a pity you're stuck on that denial-go-round RC.

I won't waste my time on the rest of your nonsense.
 
Fade to zero? Have those permanent magnets suddenly become less magnetic just because you rotate them?

When you change the distance between points, and the orientations of the WHOLE FIELD, individual lines fade and gain in strength over time.

So let me get this right “the "lines" have probably faded to ZERO” so the magnetic fields of the permanent magnets just disappear and “NEW lines”, a new magnetic field configuration, just spring forth and “gain strength”? All evidently just to suit your own Cognitive dissonance of the field configuration changes requiring reconnection of the field lines.

Whatever FADING occurs somewhere in the WHOLE FIELD is made up for in a GAIN somewhere else. It's just flux change, attraction and repulsion between TWO ENTIRE FIELDS, not just a couple of lines here and there.

IMO it's really meaningless to talk about individual LINES to begin with since we're really describing WHOLE FIELD interactions. Your ideas about individual lines are PRIMITIVE in the first place, and the notion they "disconnect from" or "reconnect to" some other field line has *NOTHING WHATSOEVER* to do with the term from the field of plasma physics called "reconnection". MHD theory describes MASS IN MOTION, and the transfer of energy from the magnetic field to particle kinetic energy.
 
Last edited:
Do you REALLY think that I'm the only one that reads this thread that has noticed the fact that not a SINGLE one of you mathematical aficionados has stepped forth with a formula to express the rate of "reconnection" in the absence of the movement of mass?
 
Do you ever sleep michael? :)

When I must. :)

Actually I tend to sleep 7+ hours a night unless I'm on a programming binge. I just spend WAY too much of my awake time here. :( I really will "eventually" wean myself from this place and move on to healthier more productive discussions on Thunderbolts, but I was really curious to find out just how deep this denial of PHYSICAL fact would go. Now I know. They take it to the EXTREME! :)
 
Last edited:
Do you REALLY think that I'm the only one that reads this thread that has noticed the fact that not a SINGLE one of you mathematical aficionados has stepped forth with a formula to express the rate of "reconnection" in the absence of the movement of mass?
Do you REALLY KNOW that you are the only one that reads this thread that has not noticed the fact that a formula to express the rate of "reconnection" in the absence of the movement of mass was posted 4 days ago:
The Sweet-Parker model has a reconnection rate of
The dimensionless reconnection rate can then be written as
9567473f430340803975053589c8908e.png

where the dimensionless Lundquist number
5dbc98dcc983a70728bd082d1a47546e.png
is given by
c4bca0477871854bef9cbd717c20999f.png

​

Or maybe this is your insane demand to express the reconnection rate which uses plasma velocity and is defined friom MHD theory when there is no plasma.
MM: What is reconnection rate of the plasma inside a rock containing no plasma?
 
Last edited:
*ANY* honest scientific debate *REQUIRES* peer reviewed literature, otherwise it's young Earth creationism on a stick.
No it doesn't. For example, there is ample evidence for the fact that the Earth is a sphere not flat, and it orbits the Sun not the other way round. No need to go to peer reviewed papers to discover that. Similarly, an experiment that can be performed on a table with a pair of bar magnets and a compass doesn't require peer reviewed literature. It really is trivial.

You can't tell me me that peer reviewed literature isn't relevant, even NECESSARY to scientific debate.
It isn't necessary in the present case because it is trivial. Much like the flat/spherical Earth debate.

That statement of yours is just irrational nonsense that I would expect from any YEC.
Then you need to check your definition of irrational.

No, it has NOT.
Yes it has.

The two types of PUBLISHED literature that have been presented to date amount to papers on MHD theory which *ACTUALLY BLOW THEIR CLAIMS AWAY*, and SOMOV's/(fictional Bowlmov's) example. Somov no more created "reconnection" without moving charged particles than Bowlmov (my fictional scientist) created "reconnection' without his heavily charged, 15 pound bowling balls. You can't take the PHYSICS out of Somov's example because Somov's example is *INCLUSIVE*, not EXCLUSIVE of moving charged particles. Epic fail. They utterly failed to support the claim that physical charged particles are not involved and that kinetic energy transfers of energy to those charged particles is not involved in 'reconnection'. Even the very RATE of reconnection is based upon the RATE OF CHANGE OF THE VELOCITY OF MASSIVE (with mass) CHARGED PARTICLES.
You do realise that when you start randomly capitalising words for no reason this
a) utterly detracts from your credibility.
b) leads to me not reading what you wrote. If you can't make your point working with proper lower case letters then you really can't have much of a point.

Even in Somov's example it's quite clear that the E fields and the current do the real work in terms of providing all kinetic and magnetic energy to the point of RECONNECTION!
Pardon? By definition the magnetic energy comes from the configuration of the magnetic fields.

Ya, but none of you can find any PUBLISHED AND PEER REVIEWED literature to demonstrate that handwavy claim. It's pure BS. All the PUBLISHED stuff talked about the "bending and twisting' of lines, and the FLUX CHANGES related to the movements of magnets.
Michael, physics journals are used to publish cutting edge papers at the forefront of scientific discovery. Not to publish experiments that I could have performed in first year of high school. What next? Hooke's law? Pythagoras' theorem?

The really sad, ironic, and HORRIFIC part of your claim as mathematicians by trade is not one of you can even describe the rate of reconnection mathematically without using charged particle movement. It's just sad.
Neither can you. Hell, you have no idea what a plasma is. You thought a single electron was a plasma yesterday. Now that is really ironic.
 
What nonsense! From day one I have tried to explain to Clinger that he can't take the mass out of the PROCESS called "reconnection". The process called 'reconnection" is all related to "plasma physics", not basic EM field theory. Clinger couldn't even find a reference to the term "reconnection" in either of his textbooks. Basic EM field theory is quite clear that magnetic field LINES (B lines) are continuous, without beginning, without ending, without a source, without a sink, without the ability to disconnect from, nor reconnect to any other B line. I provided over a dozen published references that all said the same thing.

The term 'reconnection' is related to CHARGED PARTICLE PHYSICS. It's a term that expresses the process and the RATE OF TRANSFER of magnetic field energy into particle kinetic energy.

The fact that none of you can even mathematically express a rate of reconnection without charged particle movements is staggering. It shows the hypocrisy of your argument in NEON LIGHTS. "Math? What math?"

Michael, I don't read anything you write in capital letters or ridiculously big fonts.
 
If you placed any value in those equations, you'd put your collective heads together and mathematically express a rate of reconnection in a vacuum *WITHOUT* the movement of mass. You can't. You won't. Your supposed love and mastery of math, and preference for peer reviewed literature is only skin deep, and really nothing more than a charade in the final analysis.

My post wasn't about reconnection rate. Try to actually respond to what I wrote, not what you would like me to have written.
 


This has been discussed. First, the word "objectively" means that it has been analyzed independently by others familiar with the subject, and that they too have come to the same conclusion. No such thing can be said about the linked paper.

But most directly relevant to this discussion, Oliver Manuel is a crackpot who has attempted to perpetrate a fraud on the scientific community. He has made a seriously stupid mistake in believing some running difference images actually show something thousands of kilometers beyond the point where the photosphere becomes opaque. It is fraudulent of him to imply, as he has in the acknowledgements in a previous paper, that NASA made an "image of rigid structures beneath the fluid photosphere". NASA did no such thing, and to misrepresent the data as he has there makes him a flat out liar and makes his allegedly scientific papers worthless. He's a liar and a fraud.

Also, many years ago at the BAUT forums even Oliver Manuel admitted that he could not agree that the Sun has a solid or rigid surface.

Dungey's work was peer reviewed and he called them electrical discharges. Bruce's materials were also peer reviewed an he called the electrical discharges too.


The language in his paper may have been imprecise, incorrectly applied, misunderstood, or dishonestly misrepresented. Dungey could have called solar flares and CMEs popsicles for all it matters, it still does not objectivcely lead to that conclusion that they are some kind of lightning-like sparks. To claim it objectively reaches that conclusion demonstrates a gross misunderstanding of his work and of the term "objective", or maybe willful ignorance of pretty much all of the preceding discussion in this thread, or maybe simple dishonesty.

You can't even tell the truth if you tried.


The persistent and unsupported personal attack is noted.

The only one deflecting the burden of proof is you.


I have no responsibility to support the claims that the Sun has a solid/rigid surface or that solar flares and CMEs are some kind of gigantic electrical sparks. Those are the claims which are supposed to be supported here, regardless of the continued failure to do that. So clearly I'm not deflecting a burden of proof which is not mine. On the other hand, the continued demands that others somehow demonstrate that those claims are not true is deflecting the burden of proof. It is a logical fallacy. And it is dishonest.

When I asked you to demonstrate your claim that particle physics is optional in reconnection, specifically the rate of 'reconnection' process, I got: "Math? What math?" Typical.


The persistent misrepresentation of my position is, although expected, uncivil and dishonest.

So it still stands that there is no published peer reviewed literature that objectively concludes that the Sun has a solid, rigid, or iron surface and that there is no published peer reviewed literature that objectively concludes that solar flares and CMEs are some kind of lightning-like sparks. Objectively. Not by some attempt to dishonestly misrepresent the material in order to wish a sci-fi fantasy into reality. Objectively.
 
If you can't accept the fact the Dungey used the term "electrical discharges" in solar flare activity, there's no point in discussing my papers with you personally.
Dungey used the term "electrical discharges" in magnetic reconnection.

MM: Citing Dungey means that you are stating that the cause of solar flares is magnetic reconnection not your "electrical discharges" :jaw-dropp!
8th November 2011 (5 months and counting)

He did say electrical discharges occur in solar flare and 'reconnection' activity.
Dungey stated that large current densities happen in magnetic reconnection. He used the now obsolete term "electrical discharge" for the large current densities in magnetic reconnection.
Dungey's 'electric discharge' = high current density in magnetic reconnection

His use of the term is actually 100% congruent with Peratt's definition of an electrical discharge in plasma.
Dungey's and Peratt's definition of discharge are different.
13th January 2011 (15 months and counting)

Your nonsense of citing cranks who say that you are wrong:
The cranks O. Manuel, S. A. Kamat and M. Mozina (The Sun is a plasma diffuser that sorts atoms by mass) who state that the Fe is near the core.
They have obviously ignored all of solar physics, e.g. that stars do not difuse atoms by mass.
Neutron stars compress matter around them until fusion happens and the matter is blown off or plated onto the surface of the neutron star.
The idiocy of neutron emission from the central neutron star producing solar neutrinos.
We have observed neutron stars and there is no evidence that they produce the authors magical "neutron-emission".
The ignorance of M. Mozina who contributes an image from TRACE of Fe ions at a temperature of at least 160,000 K and states that this is light from a solid iron surface (from 1000's of km inside the Sun!). He is obviously ignorant of the melting point of Fe (or basic arithmetic).
He repeats this ignorance with SOHO images from Fe (XII) ions at a temperature of at least 500,000 K.

Charles Bruce who states that solar flares are acual lightning on the Sun without your fantasy of a solid iron crust.
 
When you change the distance between points, and the orientations of the WHOLE FIELD, individual lines fade and gain in strength over time.

“Change the distance between” what “points”. The fixed magnet does not change its orientation just the free one which changes the field configuration from connecting between the two magnets to just each magnet connecting to itself, two very distinct topologies.

“individual lines fade and gain in strength over time”? This is seriously what you want to claim now?


Whatever FADING occurs somewhere in the WHOLE FIELD is made up for in a GAIN somewhere else. It's just flux change, attraction and repulsion between TWO ENTIRE FIELDS, not just a couple of lines here and there.
“FADING” and ‘GAINING’ at the same time won’t help you . As it is where the field lines connect to that changes. From a composite field that encompasses both magnets to two individual fields encompassing each magnet separately. As I think Perpetual Student tried to explain to you before there is no homeomorphism between those two distinctly different topologies. So two whole field lines connecting between the different poles of both magnets would have to “FADE” into nonexistence before one individual field connecting between the poles of just one magnet and another individual field line connecting between the poles of the other magnet could “GAIN” from, well nonexistence.

IMO it's really meaningless to talk about individual LINES to begin with since we're really describing WHOLE FIELD interactions.

Fine, what was essentially one whole field becomes two whole (and opposing) fields and then back again. Your ‘opinion’ in this matter is no less easily accommodated by this experiment than your requirements for “electrical discharge” and “"reconnection"”. Though were you to animate the process (as W.D.Clinger did with current carrying rods) you would find that it doesn’t happen across the whole field simultaneously but just between pairs of opposing field lines that create a null point as the reconnection (and rotation) progresses.

Your ideas about individual lines are PRIMITIVE in the first place, and the notion they "disconnect from" or "reconnect to" some other field line has *NOTHING WHATSOEVER* to do with the term from the field of plasma physics called "reconnection". MHD theory describes MASS IN MOTION, and the transfer of energy from the magnetic field to particle kinetic energy.

Once again this experiment meets your requirements for “electrical discharge” and “"reconnection"” by “the transfer of energy from the magnetic field to particle kinetic energy”. So it has everything to do with your own claims about your “"reconnection"”.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom