None of you can come up with a way to even EXPRESS the rate of reconnection in the absence of charged particles.
[/quote3p
The only one of us ignorant enough to ask this question is you:
MM: What is reconnection rate of the plasma inside a rock containing no plasma?
You need PHYSICAL OBJECTS to transfer magnetic field energy into particle kinetic energy. There is just no way around that PHYSICAL FACT.
How dumb. No one disagrees with this. You need PHYSICAL OBJECTS to transfer magnetic field energy into particle kinetic energy.
There is just no way around that PHYSICAL FACT.
The fact remains that MR does not need this to exist.
Peer reviewed material that states plasma is optional in MR
A textbook that states that plasma is optional for MR:
Cosmic plasma physics By Boris V. Somov .
W.D. Clinger's simple derivation of magnetic reconnection (no plasma

!)
The utterly amazing thing to me is that a whole YEAR after starting his project, Clinger didn't even KNOW what the term "rate of reconnection" even means in terms of plasma physics.
The utterly amazing thing to me is a whole YEAR after W.D. Clinger started and ended his project of deriving magnetic reconnection from Maxwell's equations, you still cannot understand it enough to find any errors in his mathematics!
You do not know enough physics to even anwser:
MM: Magnetic field around a single current carrying rod? (asked on 18th October 2011)
The utterly amazing thing to me is you make this assertion without evidence. W.D. Clinger can read. He has read the posts stating what
reconnection rate. He KNOWS what the term
reconnection rate means in terms of plasma physics (which is the only place that it is defined).
He probably read
my reply to his question about what
reconnection rate means in plasma physics.
The utterly amazing thing to me is that a FEW WEEKS after
reconnection rate was first mentioned in this thread, you still cannot get the term correct.
The utterly amazing thing to me is that a FEW WEEKS after
reconnection rate was first mentioned in this thread, you still do not understand that it is defined in MHD theory. It is meaningless whithout plasma.
WOW! I've seen denial play out in groups before, but EU haters are AMAZING!
WOW! I've seen ignorance play out in for people before, but science haters are AMAZING!