Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Get a pair of bar magnets. Place them end to end. Rotate one of them round and round. What happens?

Did you happen to read my conversation with PS about his magnet image? The website where he actually found the image talked *ONLY* about the B lines "twisting and bending". It never said a word about 'reconnection'. Only this crew is so ignorant as to believe that B lines "begin" or "end" anywhere. Most folks that understand EM theory understand that B lines are CONTINUOUS, without a source, without a sink, without the ability to "disconnect" or "reconnect". "Reconnection" is process that occurs in PLASMA when magnetic field energy is converted into particle kinetic energy. It has *NOTHING* to do with B lines (without mass) "disconnecting" or 'reconnecting". Flux changes over time. That flux change induces current in a conductor as Sweet explained. Simple physics, but you can't take the physical particles out of the process.
 
Hmm. So you think that figure 4 is correct, then?

ETA: for those of you watching at home, we're talking about this figure:
[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/picture.php?albumid=741&pictureid=5700[/qimg]

Alight Das, I've thought some more about your images. IMO it's unlike that the lines are going to remain at a constant strength during rotation. By the time you get to figure 4 the "lines" have probably faded to ZERO and any NEW lines that form on the other side of the rotation will form at a near ZERO strength and gain strength as the magnets rotate 180 degrees.

In short, I don't think those lines stay in existence beyond a specific point. They simply fade to zero and new lines form as the magnets continue to rotate IMO.

If we add plasma however, it might get more interesting. :)
 
Last edited:
Could you explain why acceleration is called reconnection? What is reconnecting in your scenario?

Ultimately two "magnetic ropes" or "Bennett Pinches" in plasma, or two "circuits" are 'reconnecting' over time. The topology of the magnetic ropes changes over time. The "reconnection" occurs when the magnetic field energy is TRANSFERRED into particle kinetic energy, which is why the rate of reconnection is based upon particle velocity changes over time.

I'm stunned that you can't accept the fact that the reconnection rate is a ratio of particle velocities. None of you can come up with a way to even EXPRESS the rate of reconnection in the absence of charged particles. Come on! Get real, physically real. You need PHYSICAL OBJECTS to transfer magnetic field energy into particle kinetic energy. There is just no way around that PHYSICAL FACT.

The utterly amazing thing to me is that a whole YEAR after starting his project, Clinger didn't even KNOW what the term "rate of reconnection" even means in terms of plasma physics. Amazingly he still believes that his primitive little math exercise shows "reconnection" even though he's clueless how to go about expressing the rate of reconnection *WITHOUT CHARGED PARTICLE MOVEMENT*! WOW! I've seen denial play out in groups before, but EU haters are AMAZING!
 
Last edited:
The "astonishing" part is that they all parrot one another, but they all completely refuse to support their statements with PUBLISHED material that actually supports their case! They first tried to hand me a bunch of papers based on MHD theory, each of which conclusively demonstrates that *PLASMA IS REQUIRED* in the "reconnection" process! Then they tried to hand me Somov's work which *REQUIRES PARTICLE MOVEMENT IN THE VACUUM*. Not a single one of them ever will (or can) put forth a "rate of reconnection" that isn't related to particle movement. How ridiculous can this charade get?

That's a mighty case of denial you've got going on there. None of this requires peer reviewed literature (though it has been supplied in abundance). All anybody (other than you) needs to see that you are wrong is two bar magnets and some iron filings or a small compass.
 
Did you happen to read my conversation with PS about his magnet image? The website where he actually found the image talked *ONLY* about the B lines "twisting and bending". It never said a word about 'reconnection'. Only this crew is so ignorant as to believe that B lines "begin" or "end" anywhere. Most folks that understand EM theory understand that B lines are CONTINUOUS, without a source, without a sink, without the ability to "disconnect" or "reconnect". "Reconnection" is process that occurs in PLASMA when magnetic field energy is converted into particle kinetic energy. It has *NOTHING* to do with B lines (without mass) "disconnecting" or 'reconnecting". Flux changes over time. That flux change induces current in a conductor as Sweet explained. Simple physics, but you can't take the physical particles out of the process.

Sigh. Most folk that understand EM theory (usually those with some formal training in it) know that what matters is Maxwell's equations, not some short-hand way of vaguely stating what Maxwell's equations might mean for those that don't have a clue. All that matters is whether or not a process violates Maxwell's equations. It has been shown repeatedly that magnetic reconnection does no such thing. That would be the end of the argument for anybody that had a clue.
 
I'm stunned that you can't accept the fact that the reconnection rate is a ratio of particle velocities. None of you can come up with a way to even EXPRESS the rate of reconnection in the absence of charged particles. Come on! Get real, physically real. You need PHYSICAL OBJECTS to transfer magnetic field energy into particle kinetic energy. There is just no way around that PHYSICAL FACT.

You've just been ranting about how reconnection rate had a unit of velocity and that meant everybody else was getting it wrong. And now you're ranting about it being a ratio of velocities. What is clear from this is that you can't even keep a consistent argument for 1 day.
 
You're still confused Tim. The magnetic field *ALWAYS* propagates at the speed of light.
You are the one who is confused, Michael Mozina.
The magnetic field *NEVER* "propagates".
The electric field *NEVER* "propagates".
The gravitational field *NEVER* "propagates".
It is changes in the field that propagate. These propagate at the speed of light.

In fact, the field is made *OF* photons.
In fact the electromagnetic field is made *OF* virtual photons.
This has nothing to do with the physical fact that changes in the magnetic field propagate at the speed of light.

The "velocity" you describe is the "velocity" of the magnet Tim
And that is his point :eye-poppi!
If you move a magnet relative to a point then the the magnetic field at the point changes at the speed of the magnet.
This debunks your assertion that the magnetic field always changes at the speed of light. The physics is that it is changes in the magnetic field that propagate at the speed of light.
 
Ultimately [...]


This is not an argument to support any electric/iron Sun conjecture. It is a complaint about failing to make such an argument. Complaints about failing will never result in succeeding.

Is there any quantitative objective support for the claim that some lightning-like phenomenon is or causes solar flares and CMEs? Is there any objective quantitative support for the claim that the Sun has a solid/rigid surface which exists below the point where the photosphere becomes completely opaque?
 
Alight IMO it's unlike that the lines are going to remain at a constant strength during rotation. By the time you get to figure 4 the "lines" have probably faded to ZERO and any NEW lines that form on the other side of the rotation will form at a near ZERO strength and gain strength as the magnets rotate 180 degrees.

In short, I don't think those lines stay in existence beyond a specific point. They simply fade to zero and new lines form as the magnets continue to rotate IMO.
You are wrong about the "probably faded to ZERO" because field lines have no "strength". The density of filed lnes is usally chosen to represent the strength of the

However you have sort of stated what we have been telling you for weeks! Magnetic field lines do not exist when the magnetic field is zero. The magnetic field is zero halfway between the magnets. As you rotate the magnet, field lines cross the place where magnetic field is zero.

So what happens there MM?
The answer is simple, the lines break.
 
So what happens there MM?
The answer is simple, the lines break.

But you don't have a *PUBLISHED* paper to your name to support that the "B lines" break. Monopoles propagating at the speed of light cause the *flux* to twist and bend into the reconnecting kinetic energy of the current, also known as *NON-NEUTRAL* plasma. Drink the coffee EU haters!
 
That's a mighty case of denial you've got going on there. None of this requires peer reviewed literature

*ANY* honest scientific debate *REQUIRES* peer reviewed literature, otherwise it's young Earth creationism on a stick. You can't tell me me that peer reviewed literature isn't relevant, even NECESSARY to scientific debate. That statement of yours is just irrational nonsense that I would expect from any YEC.

(though it has been supplied in abundance).

No, it has NOT.

The two types of PUBLISHED literature that have been presented to date amount to papers on MHD theory which *ACTUALLY BLOW THEIR CLAIMS AWAY*, and SOMOV's/(fictional Bowlmov's) example. Somov no more created "reconnection" without moving charged particles than Bowlmov (my fictional scientist) created "reconnection' without his heavily charged, 15 pound bowling balls. You can't take the PHYSICS out of Somov's example because Somov's example is *INCLUSIVE*, not EXCLUSIVE of moving charged particles. Epic fail. They utterly failed to support the claim that physical charged particles are not involved and that kinetic energy transfers of energy to those charged particles is not involved in 'reconnection'. Even the very RATE of reconnection is based upon the RATE OF CHANGE OF THE VELOCITY OF MASSIVE (with mass) CHARGED PARTICLES.

Even in Somov's example it's quite clear that the E fields and the current do the real work in terms of providing all kinetic and magnetic energy to the point of RECONNECTION!

All anybody (other than you) needs to see that you are wrong is two bar magnets and some iron filings or a small compass.

Ya, but none of you can find any PUBLISHED AND PEER REVIEWED literature to demonstrate that handwavy claim. It's pure BS. All the PUBLISHED stuff talked about the "bending and twisting' of lines, and the FLUX CHANGES related to the movements of magnets.

The really sad, ironic, and HORRIFIC part of your claim as mathematicians by trade is not one of you can even describe the rate of reconnection mathematically without using charged particle movement. It's just sad.
 
Last edited:
You've just been ranting about how reconnection rate had a unit of velocity and that meant everybody else was getting it wrong. And now you're ranting about it being a ratio of velocities. What is clear from this is that you can't even keep a consistent argument for 1 day.

What nonsense! From day one I have tried to explain to Clinger that he can't take the mass out of the PROCESS called "reconnection". The process called 'reconnection" is all related to "plasma physics", not basic EM field theory. Clinger couldn't even find a reference to the term "reconnection" in either of his textbooks. Basic EM field theory is quite clear that magnetic field LINES (B lines) are continuous, without beginning, without ending, without a source, without a sink, without the ability to disconnect from, nor reconnect to any other B line. I provided over a dozen published references that all said the same thing.

The term 'reconnection' is related to CHARGED PARTICLE PHYSICS. It's a term that expresses the process and the RATE OF TRANSFER of magnetic field energy into particle kinetic energy.

The fact that none of you can even mathematically express a rate of reconnection without charged particle movements is staggering. It shows the hypocrisy of your argument in NEON LIGHTS. "Math? What math?"
 
Last edited:
But you don't have a *PUBLISHED* paper to your name to support that the "B lines" break. Monopoles propagating at the speed of light cause the *flux* to twist and bend into the reconnecting kinetic energy of the current, also known as *NON-NEUTRAL* plasma. Drink the coffee EU haters!

Cool! I couldn't have said it better myself. ;) The fact Clinger couldn't even find the term "Reconnection' in his UPPER CLASS or LOWER CLASS textbook says VOLUMES. Do you mean to tell me that neither of them described magnetic flux changes, and attraction and repulsion between two magnets in a vacuum?

The term "reconnection' isn't even related to basic EM theory. It's a term related to PLASMA PHYSICS! WOW!
 
Last edited:
Michael Mozina, What is the "rate of reconnection"

Ultimately two "magnetic ropes" or "Bennett Pinches" in plasma, or two "circuits" are 'reconnecting' over time.
The first is basically what happens in solar flares (not MR in general plasma).
The last two are fantasies.


The topology of the magnetic ropes changes over time.
And when the topology of the magnetic ropes chnages to make field lines cross a null point, MR happens.


The "reconnection" occurs when the magnetic field energy is TRANSFERRED into particle kinetic energy,
Wrong - MR has already happened.
The energy release in a plasma occurs when the magnetic field energy is TRANSFERRED into particle kinetic energy.

which is why the rate of reconnection is based upon particle velocity changes over time.
What is the "rate of reconnection"?

It looks like a symptom of an inability to read because there is the reconnection rate. This has nothing to do energy. It is just the ratio of the a ratio of inwardf and outward plasma velocities

I'm stunned that you can't accept the fact that the reconnection rate is a ratio of particle velocities.
You are wrong - no one here has stated that the reconnection rate is not a ratio of plasma velocities. Everyone has accepted that fact.

Your "ratio of particle velocities" is wrong. The reconnection rate is the bulk velocities not the particle velocities (which are much higher then bilk velocities).

None of you can come up with a way to even EXPRESS the rate of reconnection in the absence of charged particles.
[/quote3p
The only one of us ignorant enough to ask this question is you:
MM: What is reconnection rate of the plasma inside a rock containing no plasma?

You need PHYSICAL OBJECTS to transfer magnetic field energy into particle kinetic energy. There is just no way around that PHYSICAL FACT.
How dumb. No one disagrees with this. You need PHYSICAL OBJECTS to transfer magnetic field energy into particle kinetic energy. There is just no way around that PHYSICAL FACT.

The fact remains that MR does not need this to exist.
Peer reviewed material that states plasma is optional in MR
A textbook that states that plasma is optional for MR: Cosmic plasma physics By Boris V. Somov .
W.D. Clinger's simple derivation of magnetic reconnection (no plasma :jaw-dropp!)

The utterly amazing thing to me is that a whole YEAR after starting his project, Clinger didn't even KNOW what the term "rate of reconnection" even means in terms of plasma physics.
The utterly amazing thing to me is a whole YEAR after W.D. Clinger started and ended his project of deriving magnetic reconnection from Maxwell's equations, you still cannot understand it enough to find any errors in his mathematics!
You do not know enough physics to even anwser: MM: Magnetic field around a single current carrying rod? (asked on 18th October 2011)

The utterly amazing thing to me is you make this assertion without evidence. W.D. Clinger can read. He has read the posts stating what reconnection rate. He KNOWS what the term reconnection rate means in terms of plasma physics (which is the only place that it is defined).
He probably read my reply to his question about what reconnection rate means in plasma physics.

The utterly amazing thing to me is that a FEW WEEKS after reconnection rate was first mentioned in this thread, you still cannot get the term correct.


The utterly amazing thing to me is that a FEW WEEKS after reconnection rate was first mentioned in this thread, you still do not understand that it is defined in MHD theory. It is meaningless whithout plasma.

WOW! I've seen denial play out in groups before, but EU haters are AMAZING!
WOW! I've seen ignorance play out in for people before, but science haters are AMAZING!
 
[* Ranting complaint about failing snipped. *] Ya, but none of you can find any PUBLISHED AND PEER REVIEWED literature to demonstrate that handwavy claim.


As much the above has been demonstrated time and again to be a lie, what's more important here is this: There is no published peer reviewed literature that objectively concludes that the Sun has a solid, rigid, or iron surface. And there is no published peer reviewed literature that objectively concludes that solar flares and CMEs are some kind of lightning-like sparks. And all the dishonest attempts to avoid the burden of proof are, well, dishonest.
 
Sigh. Most folk that understand EM theory (usually those with some formal training in it) know that what matters is Maxwell's equations, not some short-hand way of vaguely stating what Maxwell's equations might mean for those that don't have a clue. All that matters is whether or not a process violates Maxwell's equations. It has been shown repeatedly that magnetic reconnection does no such thing. That would be the end of the argument for anybody that had a clue.

If you placed any value in those equations, you'd put your collective heads together and mathematically express a rate of reconnection in a vacuum *WITHOUT* the movement of mass. You can't. You won't. Your supposed love and mastery of math, and preference for peer reviewed literature is only skin deep, and really nothing more than a charade in the final analysis.
 
Last edited:
[* Complaint about failing snipped. *]


Magnetic reconnection is so simple that it can be demonstrated by grade school kid experiments using a couple of bar magnets and some iron filings. And as always, the persistent acknowledgement of failure and the complaints about that failure are not going to result in success.
 
Sorry, GeeMack you are wrong :rolleyes:!
[sarcasm]
The all knowing god, Michael Mozina, has declared that MR only hapopens when the magnetic field energy is TRANSFERRED into particle kinetic energy. His holy book (a JREF forum thread says so) because he has written his holy word there.
[/sarcasm]
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom