Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Nonsense. The reconnection rate is defined as a ratio of velocities, which means it is a unitless number (i.e., it has no units of measure, certainly not acceleration of anything).

Incredible. You can't even come up with a formula to describe the rate of "reconnection" without describing charged particle velocity changes. If you disagree, show otherwise.
 
There is no such thing as a "disconnection" or a "reconnection" of B lines.


That is either a demonstration of willful ignorance of the past several hundred (several thousand?) posts, or it acknowledges an inability to understand those posts, or it is a lie. It displays a fundamental misunderstanding of reality. Magnetic reconnection occurs. A sci-fi fantasy about the way the Sun works cannot be wished into reality by ignoring reality.
 
MM: Why did Somov split "Reconnection in vacuum" from "Reconnection in plasma"

How on EARTH can you ignore Somov's stated 'cause/effect' relationship? He specifically states that the currents must MOVE closer together for FLUX to occur
...more FLUX insanity...
How on EARTH can you ignore what Somov wrote. There is always "FLUX" in his example of reconnection in vacuum.

MR in vacuum is caused by a change in the magnetic field topology (or as Somov states a "magnetic flux redistribution").
Somov specifies one cause of the change in the magnetic field topology as being that the currents are displaced a small distance closer.
A change in the magnetic field topology can also be caused by moving the current further apart or by changing one current.

Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section IX!

P.S. You missed a question from a couple of days ago
MR in a vacuum is described in Cosmic plasma physics By Boris V. Somov


But you persist in the delusion that this section is about MR in plasma. However look at the titles and contents of this section and the next section
  • 4.4.2 Reconnection in vacuum
  • 4.4.3 Reconnection in plasma
Do you really think that Somov was dumb enough to think that a section titled "Reconnection in vacuum" that really contains plasma (according to you) should not be separate from a section titled "Reconnection in plasma".
(emphasis added)

Michael Mozina: Why did Somov split "Reconnection in vacuum" from "Reconnection in plasma"?
What is the difference? Could it be that there is no plasma in the first section?
 
Last edited:
I think the bottom line here is what you're calling "reconnection" is simple "flux change".
The bottom line is what we are calling "magnetic reconnection" is simply not "flux change".

The bottom line is that this is a magnetic field change (or magnetic flux change) in the presence of a null point. That means magnetic field lines breaking because they cross that null point because the definition of field line states that they do not exist at a null point!

This is something they you really need to learn so here it is yet again:
  • The definition of field line states that they do not exist where B = 0.
  • A null point is where B = 0.
  • A field line that crosses a null point cannot exist at the null point. The field line has to stop before the null point and start again after the null point.
 
MM What does "In a vacuum, magnetic reconnection is a trival process..." mean

You folks only give math and peer reviewed science lip service. Not a single one of you actually cares one iota that the "rate" of reconnection is measured in PARTICLE FLOW changes over time.
I for one care on iota that MR in plasma has a reconnection rate (not your delusion of a "rate" of reconnection).
I know that is a rato of plasma velocities.

Without the charged particles, the rate of reconnection drops to ZERO
And now you go off the rails yet again.
Without the plasma, there is no defined reconnection rate.
MM: What is reconnection rate of the plasma inside a rock containing no plasma?

There is no defined reconnection rate for "charged particles".

You even fail simple math :eye-poppi!
If the reconnection rate is ZERO then that means that the inflowing plasma velocity is ZERO (or the outflowing plasma velocity is infinte!).

The worst part is not one of you has brought a real peer reviewed paper to this discussion that actually supports your case,
The worst part is that you are lying yet again.
Peer reviewed material that states plasma is optional in MR

Michael Mozina:
What does "In a vacuum, magnetic reconnection is a trival process..." mean?
What does "A CD-ROM attached to this paper presents the results of a toy model of vacuum reconnection..." mean?
What doees "magnetic reconnection (a) in vacuum, and (b) in a plasma" mean?
 
He's also quite precise about the fact that the moving charged particles (current) in his example has to MOVE TOWARD another charged particle/current for any 'reconnection' to occur.
Somov is quite precise about the fact that the current in his example has to MOVE TOWARD another current for any magnetic reconnection in vacuum to occur.
Somov is precise in not mentioning charged particles until after he has described MR in vacuum.
 
You folks claim that math is oh so important, but not one of you can or ever will come up with a single formula (let alone multiple ones like MHD theory) to describe a 'rate' of reconnection without particles.
...
You've literally got NOTHING.
Reconnection rate is part of MHD theory.
You've literally got NOTHING except the delusion that MHD theory has a "rate of reconnection". One more time it is a reconnection rate. It is nothing to do with a rate of reconnection which would be a frequency of reconnection events.

You've literally got NOTHING except the insanity of demanding that people use MHD theory on a vaccum!
MM: What is reconnection rate of the plasma inside a rock containing no plasma?

You've literally got NOTHING except the delusion that a reconnection rate defined only for plasma modles using MHD theory has anything to do with the documented existence of MR in vacuum:
Peer reviewed material that states plasma is optional in MR
Cosmic plasma physics By Boris V. Somov
W.D. Clinger's simple derivation of magnetic reconnection
 
Last edited:
I guess we can all now see that the mathematical emperors have no mathematical clothes on. :)
I guess we can all now see that the reading comprehenshion emperor have no reading comprehenshion clothes on. :)

What is so hard to understand about Somov's "Reconnection in vacuum" section describing reconnection in vacuum?
(Gasp! Horror! Somov actually described .... reconnection in vacuum!)
What does "In a vacuum, magnetic reconnection is a trival process..." mean?
What does "A CD-ROM attached to this paper presents the results of a toy model of vacuum reconnection..." mean?
What doees "magnetic reconnection (a) in vacuum, and (b) in a plasma" mean?
Where is the plasma in W.D. Clinger's simple derivation of magnetic reconnection?
 
It's equally insane to believe that "reconnection" happens in the absence of charged particle movement too, but that doesn't seem to stop anyone from promoting the concept, with or without a mathematical model. If mathematics is the currency of physics, your side is penniless.

What people here and in the scientific community know is that the physics states that:
  • Physical currents (from whatever source) produce magnetic fields.
  • That these currents can be arranged to produce magnetic fields with a null point.
  • If you change the currents then you get MR at the null point, i.e. in vacuum.
  • We call this "MR in vacuum".
  • We also call the MR in Somov's example what he calls it - MR in vacuum - because the currents there are idealized currents (the same as the currents in Maxwell's equations).
W.D. Clinger's simple derivation of magnetic reconnection. If mathematics is the currency of physics, we are wealthy!
But you are persisting with the insanity of thinking that MHD theory can be applied to an example containing no plasma!

Peer reviewed material that states plasma is optional in MR
Cosmic plasma physics By Boris V. Somov
 
Last edited:
You can't take away the TRANSFER OF KINETIC ENERGY out of the process and still call it "reconnection".
The definition of magnetic reconnection has nothing to do with the transfer of kinetic energy. That is an effect of MR in plasma, see "Magnetic Reconnection Defined and Described".

Somov's" Reconnection in vacuum" section describes MR without plasma and happening in vacuum and still calls it "reconnection".
 
Ya, I find it ironic that he accepts and understands the fact that the rate of reconnection relates to the acceleration of real particles, but then ignores that fact anyway.
I accept and understand the fact that the rate of reconnection(does not exist) reconnection rate relates to the ratio of velocities of plasma, i.e. the acceleration of real particles.

I find it amazing that you think that I ignore that fact. I gave you the definition in the Sweet-Parker Model. Here is the maximum reconnection rate in the Petschek model
97a13d780dac6bd7b37d47c98d9ca116.png
Wow: A change in velocity of incoming and outgoing plasma - the acceleration of real particles!

You may be referring to me pointing out the obvious insanity of you demanding that this MHD concept be applied to a situation with no plasma.
Thus: MM: What is reconnection rate of the plasma inside a rock containing no plasma?
 
You're all making the oldest mathematical mistake on the planet. You all forgot to check your units of measurement. :) The rate of reconnection is *NOT* measured in magnetic field changes, it's measured in particle acceleration. Wake up and smell the coffee folks.
You're making the oldest mathematical mistake on the planet. You forgot to check your units of measurement. :) The rate of reconnection is *NOT* measured in particle acceleration. Wake up and smell the coffee Michael Mozina.

For a start there is not such thing as a "rate of reconnection".
There is the reconnection rate. It is a number. Its has no units of measurement.
 
Incredible. You can't even come up with a formula to describe the rate of "reconnection" without describing charged particle velocity changes. If you disagree, show otherwise.
Incredible. You seem to be unable to understand that a velocity divided by a velocity gives no units of measurement so you repeat your insanity of ignoring the definition of reconnection rate as the ratio of inward and outward plasma velocities :eye-poppi!
 
Magnetic Reconnection In Vacuo XVIII

If I move a bar magnet at 1 meter/second, then the magnetic field of that bar magnet must also move through space at 1 meter/second. Is that not fairly obvious? Now, if I move a bar magnet at 1 meter/second, the change in magnetic field, as a result of the motion of the magnet, will propagate away from the magnet at the speed of light. So, if I move the magnet say 1 millimeter to the left, a measurement device located 10 meters away, will see the magnetic field change at its location {10 meters / speed of light} seconds later. So there are two different velocities for the magnetic field, one being the bulk motion of the field and the other being the change in the field.
You lost me. The two velocities (if I'm following you correctly) relate to the speed of light and the speed of the movement of the physical object in question, in this case the magnetic (or plasma particles in plasma).


Simple. Place a measuring device at some distance "d" from the bar magnet. Move the bar magnet at 1 meter/second. Measure the speed with which the magnetic field is moving with the measuring device. It will measure 1 meter/second, the same speed as the magnetic. Since the magnetic field is rigidly connected to the magnet, how can it be possible for the magnetic field to move with any velocity other than that of the magnet?

Now consider a similar experiment, except that instead of measuring the speed of the magnetic field, we will measure the strength of the magnetic field, and instead of moving the magnet at a constant velocity, we will move (or displace) the magnet over a relatively small, fixed distance (say 1 centimeter). Since the magnetic field has a shape unique to the magnet (but generally a dipole shape), any displacement of the magnet from its original position will cause the magnetic field strength at the measuring device to change. The change in the magnetic field will propagate through the magnetic field at the speed of light. So at a time x/c after the magnet moves, the measuring device will record the change in the magnetic field.

The field itself cannot move at any speed other than the speed of the magnet. But a change in the magnetic field propagates as a wave along the magnetic field lines, at the speed of light.


So let's go back to the paragraph you try so hard to ignore ...
One need only look at either of the images provided by phunk (post 6553, 29 Feb 2012) or myself (Magnetic Reconnection In Vacuo, 20 May 2011) and see that when the opposite polarity ends of a bar magnet face each other, then the magnetic field lines from either magnet are fully connected to those of the other, while in the case of same polarity ends the magnetic field lines of either magnet are fully disconnected from those of the other. Simply rotating one magnet with respect to the other creates a transition from a fully connected to a fully disconnected state, or vice-versa. That is all you need to see & know, to know that the field lines of the two magnets have to change their connectivity, or in other words, the field lines must reconnect. Now, if we want to talk about the process in some more detail, then all of the technical details you talk about must come into play. However, simply to establish the minimal condition that some form of reconnection takes place does not require anything beyond a visual inspection of the field line images.
No. No B lines never "disconnect", or "reconnect". They don't have a beginning or an end. Monopoles do not exist. Magnetic fields have no source and no sink. They are CREATED by the movement of charged particles. Even the concept of a LINE is a GROSS OVERSIMPLIFICATION of two FIELDS interacting.


Whether or not the magnetic field lines end is quite irrelevant since there is no need for the lines to end in order to reconnect. They simply reconnect at the crossing points necessarily created by the motion of the magnets. Like I said, One need only look at either of the images to see that "no" is a logically impossible answer. The magnetic field lines are absolutely required to reconnect, by obvious and simple visual logic. If you don't think so, then why don't you explain how lines that are fully connected can become lines that are fully disconnecte, without ever actually disconnecting?

And no, the concept of a line is by no means a "gross oversimplification". Just look at the image of the iron filings. Don't you find it the slightest bit interesting that the physical iron filings align in the magnetic field in exact conformity with the concept of field lines? You can literally see the field lines, with your own eyes, made of iron filings.



The velocity of the magnetic field is the velocity of motion of the bar magnets.
No. The velocity of the magnetic field is the speed of light and the velocity of the magnet is the velocity of the magnet. They aren't the same. More equivocation fallacies in play I see.


No "equivocation fallacy" here. There is no logic that allows for the velocity of the magnetic field to be anything other than the velocity of the magnetic.

As I said before, the ratio of incoming & outgoing velocities is necessarily 1 and therefore the reconnection rate do defined must always be exactly 1 in a vacuum.
Nonsense. It's exactly ZERO in a vacuum because ZERO velocity changes have been achieved as a result of moving anything. You don't lose any energy from the movement of your magnet just by moving it. If you move it around in a conductor like a plasma you might transfer some energy to particle kinetic energy, but unless you transfer energy, no 'Reconnection" could ever occur in a 'vacuum" devoid of all charged particles.


Hah! Nonsense yourself, you're quite full of it today. Must be feeling your oats, as they say. So, you think if I move a bar magnet its magnetic field does not move at all? Remember, we are not talking about one magnet, we are talking about two magnets, as illustrated in the figures attached to my post Magnetic Reconnection In Vacuo. Transitioning from one state to the other must reconnect the magnetic field lines, and whether or not any charged particles are directly affected by the change in the magnetic field is also seriously irrelevant, since no charged particles of any kind are ever required to be at or near the locus of points where the topological rearrangement of magnetic field lines takes place.


Nonsense. The reconnection rate is defined as a ratio of velocities, which means it is a unitless number (i.e., it has no units of measure, certainly not acceleration of anything).
Incredible. You can't even come up with a formula to describe the rate of "reconnection" without describing charged particle velocity changes. If you disagree, show otherwise.


I disagree, and evidently you can't read (like that's news).
The magnetic reconnection rate is set by the velocity of the magnetic field, not by the velocity of the plasma. The reason the velocity of the plasma is used is that outside the separatrix area where reconnection actually happens, the magnetic field is frozen to the plasma, so that the two velocities are the same (see, e.g, "Magnetic Reconnection: MHD Theory and Applications", Priest & Forbes, Cambridge University Press 2000, page 36). Magnetic reconnection in a vacuum is both trivial and unavoidable, happening very easily. However, as a general rule, magnetic reconnection is much harder to achieve in an astrophysical plasma because the fields are usually frozen to the plasma in astrophysical applications; e.g., magnetic reconnection is impossible in non-resistive, "ideal", MHD, which is the form originally invented by Alfven. Only in the presence of resistive plasma where the magnetic field can diffuse through the plasma can magnetic reconnection in a plasma actually take place.
In this case the rate of reconnection is the ratio of the velocity of the "incoming" magnetic field to the "outgoing" magnetic field, which is necessarily 1 in all cases, since there is only one relative velocity between the two magnets.


You knew very well that I was talking about the velocity of the magnetic field, not the plasma, but you deliberately chose to claim I was talking about a plasma velocity anyway. That is not an honest thing to do.
 
The really amusing part is that many of the EU haters have me on ignore because they can't handle (nor do they want to hear) *BOTH* sides of the debate, and most of them don't even own a plasma physics textbook. ;) It's like self imposed ignorance on a stick!

This is hilarious. Many many posters have taken the time to show you where you have gone wrong, time and time again. And yet you go round and round and round in circles with the same debunked arguments over and over and over and over again. And you accuse others of self-imposed ignorance! Astonishing.
 
There is no such thing as a "disconnection" or a "reconnection" of B lines. They have no beginning and no ending. They have no source. They have no sink. Monopoles do not exist.

Get a pair of bar magnets. Place them end to end. Rotate one of them round and round. What happens?
 
Simple. Place a measuring device at some distance "d" from the bar magnet. Move the bar magnet at 1 meter/second. Measure the speed with which the magnetic field is moving with the measuring device. It will measure 1 meter/second, the same speed as the magnetic. Since the magnetic field is rigidly connected to the magnet, how can it be possible for the magnetic field to move with any velocity other than that of the magnet?

You're still confused Tim. The magnetic field *ALWAYS* propagates at the speed of light. In fact, the field is made *OF* photons. The "velocity" you describe is the "velocity" of the magnet Tim. Plasma and physical objects have a "velocity" that you can measure and change through "reconnection". Unless and until you change the velocity of a physical object, no "reconnection" has occurred because no transfer of magnetic field energy into particle kinetic energy has occurred.

Now consider a similar experiment, except that instead of measuring the speed of the magnetic field, we will measure the strength of the magnetic field, and instead of moving the magnet at a constant velocity, we will move (or displace) the magnet over a relatively small, fixed distance (say 1 centimeter). Since the magnetic field has a shape unique to the magnet (but generally a dipole shape), any displacement of the magnet from its original position will cause the magnetic field strength at the measuring device to change. The change in the magnetic field will propagate through the magnetic field at the speed of light. So at a time x/c after the magnet moves, the measuring device will record the change in the magnetic field.

Same issue. You're not describing the change of the speed of the MAGNETIC FIELD, you're describing the rate of change in the magnetic field strength. The field will still propagate at the speed of light, but the density of the plasma might have an effect on the movement of the plasma.

The field itself cannot move at any speed other than the speed of the magnet.

The magnetic is moving, and current is moving in plasma. The field is moving accordingly, but it's always propagating at the speed of light.

But a change in the magnetic field propagates as a wave along the magnetic field lines, at the speed of light.

I guess you really didn't read that REAMING that t gave Zuezz over notion that the WAVE that you're describing is the "field". It's a PARTICLE WAVE Tim! You're constantly confusing the movement of OBJECTS (ultimately current in plasma) with the movement of MAGNETIC LINES.

Whether or not the magnetic field lines end is quite irrelevant since there is no need for the lines to end in order to reconnect.

The whole notion of a "line" is a DUMBED DOWN idea in the first place Tim. It's not a LINE, it's an *ENTIRE FIELD* that generates FLUX change as it bends and twists and changes over time. B lines do not have a source or a sink. They can't DISCONNECT FROM, nor RECONNECT TO any other magnetic line. They don't even have MASS to begin with. You're talking about the change in the direction of PARTICLES, which is why the rate of 'reconnection" is a measurement of velocity changes over time.

All the websites where you folks got those images (the ones you didn't draw) all talked about the "bending and twisting" of the magnetic B lines. They said ABSOLUTELY NOTHING about 'reconnection'. Only here on this website do you see anyone claiming that B lines "reconnect" or that "reconnection" (the process) occurs *WITHOUT* charged particles.

And no, the concept of a line is by no means a "gross oversimplification". Just look at the image of the iron filings.
Yes it is, and you just added mass to get actual "lines"! Lines as you call them may FORM AND FADE over time as the magnet moves Tim, but but only massive objects (like charged particles and iron) can "disconnect" or "reconnect". Magnetic field lines form as full continuous loops as t's plasma physics for dummies website explains!

No "equivocation fallacy" here. There is no logic that allows for the velocity of the magnetic field to be anything other than the velocity of the magnetic.

Boloney. Big time fallacy. You ignored the fact that reconnection is measurement of how fast magnetic field energy is converted into particle kinetic energy. You *REFUSE* to offer us a mathematical alternative to describe the rate of reconnection ANOTHER WAY. Give me a break!

I'll skip the redundant stuff.

I disagree, and evidently you can't read (like that's news).

I didn't see that post actually, but now I *FINALLY* understand your problem. You are STILL confusing the movement of OBJECTS with the movement of the field LINES themselves. That's where your error begins. When you talk about the movement of field "lines", and WAVES, you're talking about the movements of the PLASMA, not the magnetic field itself.

Even the notion that a coronal loop is a simple "magnetic line" is a misnomer. It's a current carrying Bennett pinch in plasma according to Alfven. If two or more of those magnetic ropes 'reconnect', the CURRENTS will be doing the "reconnecting", the circuit orientations will change accordingly.

You knew very well that I was talking about the velocity of the magnetic field, not the plasma, but you deliberately chose to claim I was talking about a plasma velocity anyway. That is not an honest thing to do.

I simply didn't realize the nature of your mistake because I missed one of your posts. I now understand that when you're talking about the movement of the magnetic field, you're really talking about movement of physical things, like the magnetic in your example, or the current in plasma that generates and regulates the magnetic field.
 
Last edited:
Get a pair of bar magnets. Place them end to end. Rotate one of them round and round. What happens?

This has been discussed ad nauseum. Unfortunately putting someone on "ignore" still allows one to see quoted comments and responses. In any case, the predicted responses will be:

A. They are H lines, not B lines. H lines can reconnect.

B. I don't understand the point you're making.

C. There is no *PLASMA* so the lines can't reconnect.

D. The lines dissipate.

E. EU haters who don't have a "plasma" book to their name and don't understand the "kinetic" energy of the *PLASMA* needed to *reconnect* the current and *particle acceleration* and can't show the math of the rate of *reconnection* which makes the "monopoles" in your pocket a source and a sink which can't happen for B lines so your side should wake up and smell the coffee.
 
This is hilarious. Many many posters have taken the time to show you where you have gone wrong, time and time again. And yet you go round and round and round in circles with the same debunked arguments over and over and over and over again. And you accuse others of self-imposed ignorance! Astonishing.

The "astonishing" part is that they all parrot one another, but they all completely refuse to support their statements with PUBLISHED material that actually supports their case! They first tried to hand me a bunch of papers based on MHD theory, each of which conclusively demonstrates that *PLASMA IS REQUIRED* in the "reconnection" process! Then they tried to hand me Somov's work which *REQUIRES PARTICLE MOVEMENT IN THE VACUUM*. Not a single one of them ever will (or can) put forth a "rate of reconnection" that isn't related to particle movement. How ridiculous can this charade get?
 
Unless and until you change the velocity of a physical object, no "reconnection" has occurred because no transfer of magnetic field energy into particle kinetic energy has occurred.

Could you explain why acceleration is called reconnection? What is reconnecting in your scenario?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom