Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
They are also involved in the acceleration process and the transfer of magnetic field energy in kinetic energy Tim. You can't take away the TRANSFER OF KINETIC ENERGY out of the process and still call it "reconnection".

This is wrong. Transfer of energy certainly happens when reconnection occurs in plasma, but it is a side effect of reconnection, it is not the reconnection itself. Reconnection is the rearrangement of the magnetic fields, not the motion induced in the plasma.
 
It is an 'event' that is "caused" by the movement of currents toward one another according to Somov. His vacuum is *INCLUSIVE* of charged particles, and results in charged particle acceleration. You folks can't ignore the fact that a rate of reconnection relates to the rate of particle acceleration. If there is no particle acceleration, the rate of reconnection is always and forever ZERO. No particles=zero particle acceleration due to flux changes over time=no reconnection.

Do you consider a permanent magnet moving an inch to be "particle acceleration"?
 
It is an 'event' that is "caused" by the movement of currents toward one another according to Somov.
What? Magnetic flux is a quantity, often measured in Weber's. There is no meaningful sense in which it can be called an event any more than a force, speed or mass can be considered an event.
 
What? Magnetic flux is a quantity, often measured in Weber's.

It's a CHANGING quantity due to the field changes, which are CAUSED BY charged particle movement in Somov's example. At no time is Somov's vacuum EXCLUSIVE of particles. At all times it *INCLUDES* moving charged particles.

There is no meaningful sense in which it can be called an event any more than a force, speed or mass can be considered an event.

Is a solar flare an "event" in your opinion? Does it have a trigger? An end?
 
This is wrong.

No, it's not.

Transfer of energy certainly happens when reconnection occurs in plasma, but it is a side effect of reconnection, it is not the reconnection itself. Reconnection is the rearrangement of the magnetic fields, not the motion induced in the plasma.

No, you have that backwards. The movement of field lines is simply movement of the field lines. No transfer of energy is taking place. It's only *AS* you accelerate a charged particle with that moving field that you can call it "reconnection". The rate of "reconnection" is the rate at which magnetic field energy is CONVERTED into particle kinetic energy. No acceleration, no "reconnection".

Again, you're confusing localized flux CHANGES over time that do not transfer magnetic field energy into anything, with the ACCELERATION PROCESS called "reconnection". It's an equivocation fallacy of EPIC proportions to claim that the acceleration process is optional when the rate of reconnection is clearly defined in terms of particle acceleration! Talk about blatant fallacies.
 
It's a CHANGING quantity due to the field changes, which are CAUSED BY charged particle movement in Somov's example. At no time is Somov's vacuum EXCLUSIVE of particles. At all times it *INCLUDES* moving charged particles.
None of this explains the sentence: "No, FLUX takes place in the vacuum itself."

Is a solar flare an "event" in your opinion? Does it have a trigger? An end?
Pardon.
 
But therein lies the first rub. Charged particles do NOT move in a "straight line' in the presence of magnetic fields, even stable magnetic fields.

They do if they're constrained. Take, say, a wire, or a thin tube of saltwater conducting the current.

Even Somov however described the relationship between "reconnection" and charged particle movements (currents). The currents come first,
so far, so good

they move, they generate "flux" which in turn has an effect on the kinetic energy state of other particles.

That part may be confused. Currents generate magnetic fields, and those fields affect charged particles. The currents don't need to move to create flux, though particles move to create currents.

The particle/field relationship can't be taken apart like you're trying to take it apart. Somov didn't do that, and for good reason.

Actually, you can take it apart like that and Somov did so. One can simply force current to flow through a couple of wires in a vacuum, for example, which will create a magnetic field with a certain topology. One could then move those wires closer to each other, causing the field topology to change, and that would be magnetic reconnection in a vacuum. To first order, one can simply ignore how the currents in the wires affect each other.

You need PARTICLES to measure RATES of reconnection and PARTICLES are what are affected by that FLUX you're actually describing in a vacuum.
Again, I'll refer you to phunk and now Tim. In the absence of plasma, the topology changes propagate at c.

But that's just it. Somov moved the current to create the flux and uses the current to create the FIELDS he's reconnecting. There's no separation of particles from the "reconnection" process in Somov's example. They are INTIMATELY related.

Tim covered this better than I could. We're not saying that there's no matter present in the universe. We're saying that reconnection can happen in regions that don't have any matter in them. The magnetic fields are generated by matter, but that matter may be remote from the reconnections. Take Somov's figure 1.3, for example: there's mass at the two points where the current flows; the rest (where the reconnection takes place) is vacuum. That's why he called it "vacuum reconnection."

Then there is no transfer of magnetic field energy into particle kinetic energy and rate of reconnection will always be zero.

<shrug> I'd say it's undefined, but I'll defer to Tim or phunk.

No, they bend and twist and FLUX. The "reconnection" is the transfer of that flux energy into particle kinetic energy. Without the transfer of energy, it's just 'flux'.

It's my understanding that magnetic reconnection is actually just magnetic field topology changes. Those topology changes will transfer energy to any charged particles nearby (and those would, in turn, have their own impact on the field), but even without the charged particles, the topology changes, and that's reconnection.

Of course, but then again, I'm not having to fight and argue over ONE SINGLE reference (Somov) which actually doesn't even support my claim. :) I've got THOUSANDS of papers based on MHD theory that show that 'reconnection' and the "rate of reconnection' is directly related to the transfer of magnetic field energy into particle kinetic energy.

Michael, part of your problem here is that you've poisoned your own well. I've looked at papers that you've cited and my conclusions were very, very different from yours (as were the authors'). This Somov book is only the latest example, but I didn't find anything terribly supportive in either of the Dungey papers, your gamma-ray paper had nothing to do with the CNO fusion that you claimed it showed, that SERTS paper didn't show what you claimed, the Wu, Chen, and Li paper that you cited as proof of electric solar flares didn't actually have any data about solar flares, and when I waded through that list of papers from post 3356, I found that a lot of them were simply irrelevant (solar wind interaction with Mars? terrestrial aurorae?) or directly contradicted you. You've played the "this paper will explain" it card too many times; I'm not reading any more papers for you and I'm sure as **** not taking your word for what any paper says.

In the interest of avoiding run-ins with the JREF mods, I'm going to stop there and take a break from this thread.

<remainder snipped>
 
None of this explains the sentence: "No, FLUX takes place in the vacuum itself."

Magnetic field changes can take place in an EMPTY vacuum, but particle acceleration cannot. The rate of reconnection is measure in terms of particle acceleration, not magnetic field changes.


Flux can be consistent or variable over time. All you're doing is varying the flux, you're not accelerating anything. To get "reconnection" you have to accelerate something.
 
Frozen Flux Approximation Redux

Even Alfven dissed that whole "frozen in' concept, and he came up with it!


Alfven did no such thing.

Alfven from Cosmic Plasma:
II.3 Magnetic Field Lines
The concept of 'frozen-in magnetic field lines' has played a central role in plasma physics due to the fact that in several situations, but far from all, it is legitimate to use it.


As you have pointed out yourself, over a year ago, Alfven did not "diss" the frozen flux concept. Rather, he correctly points out that in many cases its use is proper.

{ ... }
One must fully comprehend that Mozina's blind reliance on Alfven, to the exclusion of everything done in science since Alfven was active, is purely religious and has nothing at all to do with science. That kind of blind faith in any authoritative figure in science must always be rejected, no matter what the science, and no matter the qualifications of the authoritative figure. Science succeeds or fails on its own internal strengths & weaknesses, not on the declarations of authority, despite Mozina's obvious belief that authoritative imprimatur is all that science requires. Why bother with observations? Why bother with controlled laboratory experiments? What use could they possibly be, when the authority of Alfven settles everything?
{ ... }
But what else does Alfven say? He says this: "we find that under cosmic conditions, [latex]\sigma[/latex]|| is usually so large that we can regard it as infinite." And what does that mean in any practical sense? It simply means that the mobility of the magnetic field lines relative to the plasma depends on the conductivity. The higher the conductivity, the slower the diffusion of the magnetic field through the plasma, and the more "practically frozen" (not of course literally frozen) it will appear to be. Now, if you are interested in physics that happens in the plasma on a time scale short compared to the diffusion time scale (set by the conductivity), then you can treat the magnetic field for that application as being "frozen". On the other hand, if you are interested in physics that happens on time scales that are long compared to the diffusion time scale of the magnetic field in the plasma, then you cannot use the "frozen" approximation at all, and must be mindful of the mobility of the magnetic field in that application. This in fact is exactly how the frozen field approximation is used in astrophysical plasma physics, and it is in fact precisely in keeping with the rules laid down by Alfven. His mistake was in his assessment of the physical characteristics of the plasma, for which he had not enough factual information at hand. But his assessment that magnetic fields are never really frozen into a plasma was correct, and modern plasma physics adheres to that assessment.
{ .... }
Finally, let me finish with an interesting relevant paragraph:

"The remarkable freezing of magnetic field lines into a plasma can be traced to the large induction L of a typical large scale astrophysical plasma and a correspondingly small resistance R. In electrical circuits the timescale for decay of currents is L/R and, correspondingly, the time scale during which flux freezing holds is L/R and in astrophysics is generally very large."
Plasma Physics for Astrophysics, Russell M. Kulsrud, Princeton University Press 2005, page 2.
​


My use if the frozen flux approximation is exactly consistent with the rules Alfven laid down for its use. You cannot hide behind the false claim that Alfven dismissed the frozen flux approximation.
 
They do if they're constrained. Take, say, a wire, or a thin tube of saltwater conducting the current.

Somov didn't mention any of those things.

That part may be confused. Currents generate magnetic fields, and those fields affect charged particles. The currents don't need to move to create flux, though particles move to create currents.

Somewhere a few pages back I highlighted Somov's statement about the currents MOVING closer together as the CAUSE of the 'reconnection'. I still can't believe you're on their side of this argument considering the fact that the rate of "reconnection" is a measurement of conversion of magnetic field energy into particle kinetic energy. It's like you're all ignoring the units of measurement and none of you care! Physics be damned.

Actually, you can take it apart like that and Somov did so.

No, he didn't. His "vacuum" *INCLUDED* and did not EXCLUDE charged particle movement and it *INCLUDED* charged particle acceleration.

One can simply force current to flow through a couple of wires

You're adding PHYSICAL THINGS again to that vacuum. You're also going to accelerate PHYSICAL CHARGED PARTICLES again too. You're also talking about a NON PUBLISHED STRAWMAN that has nothing to do with Somov's example.

Tim covered this better than I could. We're not saying that there's no matter present in the universe. We're saying that reconnection can happen in regions that don't have any matter in them.

But that's just it. It can't. Only magnetic field changes over time can happen in regions that don't have any matter in them. Only regions with matter can accelerate matter. Reconnection is the process of converting magnetic field energy into charged particle acceleration.

The magnetic fields are generated by matter, but that matter may be remote from the reconnections. Take Somov's figure 1.3, for example: there's mass at the two points where the current flows; the rest (where the reconnection takes place) is vacuum. That's why he called it "vacuum reconnection."

But you're still ignoring the fact that his so called "vacuum" isn't actually just a vacuum. It INCLUDES charges particles and INCLUDES charged particle acceleration. How can you just ignore that?

It's my understanding that magnetic reconnection is actually just magnetic field topology changes.

That is an incorrect understanding because the rate of reconnection isn't measured in field changes, it's measured in particle acceleration. You're still ignoring the units of measurement. :)

Michael, part of your problem here is that you've poisoned your own well.

I can't stop you from feeling that way (at the moment), but this issue and this point has NOTHING to do with solar theory, and nothing to do with anything other than plasma physics. It's not related to other aspects of our conversations or any papers you pulled randomly from that list. I can't help it if you aren't impressed by LABORATORY demonstrations of highly ionized iron due to 'discharges', even though none of you can do that with 'reconnection'.

I'm going to ignore the rest of your complaints at the moment because I'm not letting you off the hook on this topic.

Check your units of measurement on the rate of reconnection. Are they measurements of field changes, or measurements particle acceleration? It's an EASY question to answer, but you won't like the answer. It will lead you to the life giving water (of truth) even it it tastes like poison. :)
 
Last edited:
You're all making the oldest mathematical mistake on the planet. You all forgot to check your units of measurement. :) The rate of reconnection is *NOT* measured in magnetic field changes, it's measured in particle acceleration. Wake up and smell the coffee folks.
 
Last edited:
Magnetic Reconnection In Vacuo XVII

The magnetic reconnection rate is set by the velocity of the magnetic field, not by the velocity of the plasma.
Huh? Didn't you read the grilling that Zeuzz got over that confusion? Magnetic fields propagate at the speed of light Tim. Plasma has various "velocities".


I must have missed it. Magnetic fields in a vacuum do not necessarily propagate at the speed of light (see below).

The magnetic reconnection rate is set by the velocity of the magnetic field, not by the velocity of the plasma.
I don't know how I missed this earlier, but I think this paragraph needs some explaining on your part. What is the velocity of the magnetic field Tim?


If I move a bar magnet at 1 meter/second, then the magnetic field of that bar magnet must also move through space at 1 meter/second. Is that not fairly obvious? Now, if I move a bar magnet at 1 meter/second, the change in magnetic field, as a result of the motion of the magnet, will propagate away from the magnet at the speed of light. So, if I move the magnet say 1 millimeter to the left, a measurement device located 10 meters away, will see the magnetic field change at its location {10 meters / speed of light} seconds later. So there are two different velocities for the magnetic field, one being the bulk motion of the field and the other being the change in the field.

So let's go back to the paragraph you try so hard to ignore ...

One need only look at either of the images provided by phunk (post 6553, 29 Feb 2012) or myself (Magnetic Reconnection In Vacuo, 20 May 2011) and see that when the opposite polarity ends of a bar magnet face each other, then the magnetic field lines from either magnet are fully connected to those of the other, while in the case of same polarity ends the magnetic field lines of either magnet are fully disconnected from those of the other. Simply rotating one magnet with respect to the other creates a transition from a fully connected to a fully disconnected state, or vice-versa. That is all you need to see & know, to know that the field lines of the two magnets have to change their connectivity, or in other words, the field lines must reconnect. Now, if we want to talk about the process in some more detail, then all of the technical details you talk about must come into play. However, simply to establish the minimal condition that some form of reconnection takes place does not require anything beyond a visual inspection of the field line images.


The velocity of the magnetic field is the velocity of motion of the bar magnets. As I said before, the ratio of incoming & outgoing velocities is necessarily 1 and therefore the reconnection rate do defined must always be exactly 1 in a vacuum.
 
You're all making the oldest mathematical mistake on the planet. You all forgot to check your units of measurement. :) The rate of reconnection is *NOT* measured in magnetic field changes, it's measured in particle acceleration. Wake up and smell the coffee folks.

Have you actually read anybodies responses to your post. Seriously?
 
Reconnection Rate Units

You're all making the oldest mathematical mistake on the planet. You all forgot to check your units of measurement. :) The rate of reconnection is *NOT* measured in magnetic field changes, it's measured in particle acceleration. Wake up and smell the coffee folks.


Nonsense. The reconnection rate is defined as a ratio of velocities, which means it is a unitless number (i.e., it has no units of measure, certainly not acceleration of anything).
 
No, you have that backwards. The movement of field lines is simply movement of the field lines.

No. We're not talking about simply the movement of field lines, we're talking about the reconnection of field lines. In the example with the wires, when they are far apart you can draw a single field line as a circle around each wire. When they get closer together, those lines will come together and merge, changing from 2 loops to one larger one. THAT IS RECONNECTION. The plasma acceleration is just a consequence of reconnection when it happens in plasma.
 
I must have missed it. Magnetic fields in a vacuum do not necessarily propagate at the speed of light (see below).

If I move a bar magnet at 1 meter/second, then the magnetic field of that bar magnet must also move through space at 1 meter/second. Is that not fairly obvious? Now, if I move a bar magnet at 1 meter/second, the change in magnetic field, as a result of the motion of the magnet, will propagate away from the magnet at the speed of light. So, if I move the magnet say 1 millimeter to the left, a measurement device located 10 meters away, will see the magnetic field change at its location {10 meters / speed of light} seconds later. So there are two different velocities for the magnetic field, one being the bulk motion of the field and the other being the change in the field.

You lost me. The two velocities (if I'm following you correctly) relate to the speed of light and the speed of the movement of the physical object in question, in this case the magnetic (or plasma particles in plasma).

So let's go back to the paragraph you try so hard to ignore ...

Simply rotating one magnet with respect to the other creates a transition from a fully connected to a fully disconnected state, or vice-versa.

No. No B lines never "disconnect", or "reconnect". They don't have a beginning or an end. Monopoles do not exist. Magnetic fields have no source and no sink. They are CREATED by the movement of charged particles. Even the concept of a LINE is a GROSS OVERSIMPLIFICATION of two FIELDS interacting.

The velocity of the magnetic field is the velocity of motion of the bar magnets.

No. The velocity of the magnetic field is the speed of light and the velocity of the magnet is the velocity of the magnet. They aren't the same. More equivocation fallacies in play I see.

As I said before, the ratio of incoming & outgoing velocities is necessarily 1 and therefore the reconnection rate do defined must always be exactly 1 in a vacuum.

Nonsense. It's exactly ZERO in a vacuum because ZERO velocity changes have been achieved as a result of moving anything. You don't lose any energy from the movement of your magnet just by moving it. If you move it around in a conductor like a plasma you might transfer some energy to particle kinetic energy, but unless you transfer energy, no 'Reconnection" could ever occur in a 'vacuum" devoid of all charged particles.
 
Last edited:
No. We're not talking about simply the movement of field lines, we're talking about the reconnection of field lines.

There is no such thing as a "disconnection" or a "reconnection" of B lines. They have no beginning and no ending. They have no source. They have no sink. Monopoles do not exist.
 
You're talking about a twisting and bending of B lines, a FLUX CHANGE of B lines through some geographic region. You aren't talking about charged particle velocity changes, so you aren't talking about the 'rates of reconnection'!
 
Have you actually read anybodies responses to your post. Seriously?

I've tried to read and respond to almost all of them. I pretty much ignore RC's responses these days (since it's mostly personal attack nonsense), but I occasionally read them too.

The really amusing part is that many of the EU haters have me on ignore because they can't handle (nor do they want to hear) *BOTH* sides of the debate, and most of them don't even own a plasma physics textbook. ;) It's like self imposed ignorance on a stick!
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom