Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
I lost count of how many times I've said reconnection can happen in a vacuum without charged particles. I'm flabbergasted that you can say that I believe the opposite.

I'm sorry if I misrepresented your position. How on EARTH can you ignore Somov's stated 'cause/effect' relationship? He specifically states that the currents must MOVE closer together for FLUX to occur. That FLUX can indeed affect a CHARGED PARTICLE, but without one, it's just FLUX because no energy has been converted from the magnetic field into charged particle kinetic energy. I'm flabbergasted you can't see that yet.
 
I'm sorry if I misrepresented your position. How on EARTH can you ignore Somov's stated 'cause/effect' relationship? He specifically states that the currents must MOVE closer together for FLUX to occur. That FLUX can indeed affect a CHARGED PARTICLE, but without one, it's just FLUX because no energy has been converted from the magnetic field into charged particle kinetic energy. I'm flabbergasted you can't see that yet.


The persistent and dishonest attempt to redefine terms in order to wish a sci-fi crank fantasy into reality is noted.
 
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=8117329&postcount=6967

FYI, I think my confusion started with a beer and a misread of this specific post. :)

I think the bottom line here is what you're calling "reconnection" is simple "flux change". Without any charged particles, Somov's process doesn't work. His process requires that currents (charged particles) actually MOVE TOWARD EACH OTHER. That's a basic requirement that he states quite clearly.

If there are no charged particles to pass on kinetic energy to, then no 'reconnection' actually occurs as a result of the 'flux change'. What you're calling "reconnection" isn't "reconnection' at all. It's simply a "flux change", and you still fail to accept that any FIELD is a direct result of CURRENT! In Somov's example, the E field DRIVES the current and put the particle kinetic energy, and associated magnetic fields at the point of 'reconnection'. All the actual ENERGY comes from the CURRENT and the E field(s) driving that current.
 
The persistent and dishonest attempt to redefine terms in order to wish a sci-fi crank fantasy into reality is noted.

Your persistent denial of scientific fact is noted. Somov's VACUUM isn't EMPTY at all. It *INCLUDES* (not excludes) charged particle FLOW inside and through that vacuum. The RECONNECTION occurs when magnetic field energy is *CONVERTED* into particle kinetic energy. The FLUX that Somov's describes is CAUSED BY THE MOVEMENT OF CURRENTS TOWARD EACH OTHER.

EVERY SINGLE paper on MHD theory PROVES BEYOND ALL DOUBT that "reconnection' and the "rate of reconnection" is directly related to CHARGED PARTICLE MOVEMENTS! Talk about dishonest, denial based behaviors!
 
You folks only give math and peer reviewed science lip service. Not a single one of you actually cares one iota that the "rate" of reconnection is measured in PARTICLE FLOW changes over time. Without the charged particles, the rate of reconnection drops to ZERO, and no flux is even possible in Somov's example because his example REQUIRES the movement of CURRENT to occur for 'reconnection' to even happen in the first place!

You've still provided no way to mathematically express a 'rate of reconnection' in the absence of all charged particles, and you've provided no way to generate, let alone TRANSFER magnetic field energy into particle kinetic energy.

Your argument is fundamentally flawed at every single PHYSICAL and MATHEMATICAL level. You don't care about math or the fact you can't even EXPRESS a rate of reconnection without particles.

If physics is all about math, and math is king, your king is dead. I can provide you with THOUSANDS of papers based on MHD theory, each and every one of which demonstrates conclusively and PHYSICALLY that 'reconnection" is a process that REQUIRES charged particle movement. You've got zip in terms of even being able to express a rate of reconnection without charged particle movement. You're king is a mathematical disaster, and dead in the water.

The worst part is not one of you has brought a real peer reviewed paper to this discussion that actually supports your case, and you have the nerve to call *ME* a "crackpot' and a 'crank'. Wow! Talk about projection!
 
Last edited:
That sentence is very precise.

He's also quite precise about the fact that the moving charged particles (current) in his example has to MOVE TOWARD another charged particle/current for any 'reconnection' to occur. I don't blame Somov for anything. It's actually your fault, not his. He's very clear about both the EXISTENCE of the charged particles in the vacuum and the fact they MOVE toward one another. Whatever denial routines come from your side, they have NOTHING to do with Somov or his explanation of events. He even explains the order of the cause/effect process of events as CURRENTS move toward each other.
 
Honestly, this is just sad at this point. You folks claim that math is oh so important, but not one of you can or ever will come up with a single formula (let alone multiple ones like MHD theory) to describe a 'rate' of reconnection without particles. You've tried to take the PHYSICS out of particle physics. That doesn't work! It doesn't work mathematically either. You've literally cut off your physical and mathematical noses and none of you care! None of you can produce a peer reviewed paper on "reconnection" that *IS NOT* based upon MHD theory or particle movement. You've literally got NOTHING.
 
Last edited:
View Post Today, 10:17 AM
Remove user from ignore listMichael Mozina
This message is hidden because Michael Mozina is on your ignore list.

View Post Today, 10:21 AM
Remove user from ignore listMichael Mozina
This message is hidden because Michael Mozina is on your ignore list.
View Post Today, 10:30 AM
Remove user from ignore listMichael Mozina
This message is hidden because Michael Mozina is on your ignore list.

View Post Today, 10:44 AM
Remove user from ignore listMichael Mozina
This message is hidden because Michael Mozina is on your ignore list.

View Post Today, 10:49 AM
Remove user from ignore listMichael Mozina
This message is hidden because Michael Mozina is on your ignore list.

View Post Today, 10:52 AM
Remove user from ignore listMichael Mozina
This message is hidden because Michael Mozina is on your ignore list.
:cool:
 
You folks only give math and peer reviewed science lip service. [* Standard barrage of complaints about failure snipped. *]


There is no math or peer reviewed science that would bring us to the objective conclusion that the Sun has a solid/rigid surface. There is no math or peer reviewed science that would bring us to the objective conclusion that solar flares are or are caused by lightning-like electrical discharges. To claim otherwise would be a demonstration of gross ignorance or abject dishonesty.
 
I think the bottom line here is what you're calling "reconnection" is simple "flux change". [* More complaints about failing snipped. *]


Magnetic reconnection is not "simple flux change". This appears to come from ignorance of the preceding thousands of posts, or dishonestly trying to redefine terms in order to wish a sci-fi crank fantasy into reality.
 
You folks only give math and peer reviewed science lip service. Not a single one of you actually cares one iota that the "rate" of reconnection is measured in PARTICLE FLOW changes over time.

Phunk covered that. We understand it just fine. I'd say we even care about it, though I don't care enough to send it a birthday card or drive it to the airport.

Without the charged particles, the rate of reconnection drops to ZERO

so far, so good . . .

and no flux is even possible in Somov's example because his example REQUIRES the movement of CURRENT to occur for 'reconnection' to even happen in the first place!

Flux requires some motion of charged particles. A steady current moving in a straight, infinitely long line gives the easiest flux to model, and that's why Somov used it. As far as "REQUIRES the movement of CURRENT" - if you mean the currents need to move with respect to each other to get flux, then, no. Current creates flux, period.

You've still provided no way to mathematically express a 'rate of reconnection' in the absence of all charged particles,

asked and answered, sheesh!

and you've provided no way to generate, let alone TRANSFER magnetic field energy into particle kinetic energy.

In vacuum reconnection, none of the magnetic field energy is transferred to stray particles drifting around in the vacuum. The field lines simply reconnect. That's why vacuum reconnection is so much less interesting than plasma reconnection.

Your argument is fundamentally flawed at every single PHYSICAL and MATHEMATICAL level.

Our argument is very different from your characterization of our argument.

You don't care about math

Oh, we care about math. I'd drive math to the airport. I'd even keep an eye on its house while it was away.

or the fact you can't even EXPRESS a rate of reconnection without particles.

you're right, we don't care about that one, any more than we care that we can't express the impartiality of indigo.

<a bunch of repetition snipped>

The worst part is not one of you has brought a real peer reviewed paper to this discussion that actually supports your case, and you have the nerve to call *ME* a "crackpot' and a 'crank'. Wow! Talk about projection!

Michael, you have taken Somov's statement that "Reconnection in vacuum is a real physical process" to mean that reconnection cannot happen in a vacuum. Honestly, how could anything that we might show you have any impact on your views?
 
Phunk covered that. We understand it just fine. I'd say we even care about it, though I don't care enough to send it a birthday card or drive it to the airport.

:)

Flux requires some motion of charged particles. A steady current moving in a straight, infinitely long line gives the easiest flux to model, and that's why Somov used it.

But therein lies the first rub. Charged particles do NOT move in a "straight line' in the presence of magnetic fields, even stable magnetic fields. They move in corkscrew pattern through time, even electrons and positrons. They create a tornado like vortex as they move, a Birkeland current when flowing inside plasma.

Even Somov however described the relationship between "reconnection" and charged particle movements (currents). The currents come first, they move, they generate "flux" which in turn has an effect on the kinetic energy state of other particles. The particle/field relationship can't be taken apart like you're trying to take it apart. Somov didn't do that, and for good reason. You need PARTICLES to measure RATES of reconnection and PARTICLES are what are affected by that FLUX you're actually describing in a vacuum.

As far as "REQUIRES the movement of CURRENT" - if you mean the currents need to move with respect to each other to get flux, then, no. Current creates flux, period.

But that's just it. Somov moved the current to create the flux and uses the current to create the FIELDS he's reconnecting. There's no separation of particles from the "reconnection" process in Somov's example. They are INTIMATELY related.

In vacuum reconnection, none of the magnetic field energy is transferred to stray particles drifting around in the vacuum.

Then there is no transfer of magnetic field energy into particle kinetic energy and rate of reconnection will always be zero.

The field lines simply reconnect.

No, they bend and twist and FLUX. The "reconnection" is the transfer of that flux energy into particle kinetic energy. Without the transfer of energy, it's just 'flux'.

That's why vacuum reconnection is so much less interesting than plasma reconnection.

Ya, nothing happens. :)

Our argument is very different from your characterization of our argument.

Of course, but then again, I'm not having to fight and argue over ONE SINGLE reference (Somov) which actually doesn't even support my claim. :) I've got THOUSANDS of papers based on MHD theory that show that 'reconnection' and the "rate of reconnection' is directly related to the transfer of magnetic field energy into particle kinetic energy.

Oh, we care about math. I'd drive math to the airport. I'd even keep an eye on its house while it was away.

You have to see the irony from my perspective at least, right? I've been LAMBASTED for the fact that I won't bark math on command, yet I've had NO trouble citing mathematical descriptions of "reconnection" in plasma. Without it, you folks can't even come up with a logical way to mathematically express a rate of reconnection without charged particle movement, but you're all still convinced anyway? What can I say. It's an epic sized irony overload from my perspective. It's like 10,000 published papers on math to NONE. How can math matter to you folks but it not matter that you can't come up with a mathematical expression for the rate of reconnection without particle movement?

Michael, you have taken Somov's statement that "Reconnection in vacuum is a real physical process" to mean that reconnection cannot happen in a vacuum.

No, I've taken Somov at his word. I've taken his statement that reconnection in a vacuum that *INCLUDES MOVING CHARGED PARTICLES OF KINETIC ENERGY* will result in charged particle acceleration and a transfer of magnetic field energy into particle acceleration. I have no idea how you can all overlook all his references to current/charge particle movements.

Honestly, how could anything that we might show you have any impact on your views?

If you could come up with some math to express a rate of reconnection without charged particle movements, maybe. Without it, I doubt it.
 
Last edited:
It would be insane for someone using MHD to state that there is no plama.

It's equally insane to believe that "reconnection" happens in the absence of charged particle movement too, but that doesn't seem to stop anyone from promoting the concept, with or without a mathematical model. If mathematics is the currency of physics, your side is penniless.
 
Magnetic Reconnection In Vacuo XVI

EVERY SINGLE paper on MHD theory PROVES BEYOND ALL DOUBT that "reconnection' and the "rate of reconnection" is directly related to CHARGED PARTICLE MOVEMENTS! Talk about dishonest, denial based behaviors!


Of course this is entirely true. After all, since MHD is a theory of plasma physics (not a theory of vacuum physics), it comes as no surprise that moving charged particles are involved.

However, there is something else implied here that very much bothers me, and that is: Are you seriously claiming that, according to "our side", we can have magnetic fields without the motion of charged particles? I cannot imagine how such a notion could ever have entered your mind.

On 15 February 2009 I said ...
You need moving charged particles to generate a magnetic field, and that is not necessarily a classical electric current, which is a flow of charged particles all of which have the same charge (i.e., a stream of electrons or protons, typically electrons in our daily lives). The bulk motion of a charge neutral plasma will generate a magnetic field, and that's where the magnetic fields in cosmology & astrophysics come from, not from streams of classical electric currents. This has been proven in both theory & practice and is a simple fact of nature.


And again on 12 March 2009 I said ...
Nobody ever said that magnetic fields are independent of charged particles. What we do say is that the classical electric currents, as in pure streams of electrons (or protons or other charged particles), are not the only way to generate magnetic fields, and that indeed most of the magnetic fields in the cosmos are not generated by such currents.


Of course it is a given fact, and always has been, that all magnetic fields always require some pre-existing motion of charged particles.

Now, if you look at my post "Magnetic Reconnection Defined and Described" you will see that in each and every example, despite the slightly differing language, all of the definitions of magnetic reconnection boil down to "a topological rearrangement of magnetic field lines". Now, nobody ever even hinted at the suggestion that there are no moving charged particles anywhere in the universe whereby one might generate the given magnetic field, that is so painfully obvious it is simply assumed that everyone already knows that. But note that those charged particles are not directly involved in the immediate reconnection process ...

All magnetic fields are originally generated by electric currents. However, while the current flows in a confined volume, the consequent magnetic field will fill a vastly larger volume than the current. Hence it is possible to measure an active and time variable magnetic field in a vacuum far removed from the current that generated it. This is a point which seems to be overlooked to me so I want to make sure the point is made explicitly somewhere. Furthermore, magnetic fields and plasmas commonly couple together, so that the plasma will carry the "frozen in" magnetic field with it. So a plasma can be magnetized by a magnetic field that is not generated by that plasma, but by another completely independent plasma far away. As an example, the solar wind carries the solar magnetic field along with it. The magnetic field was originally generated in the sun, but is carried to the outermost reaches of the solar system by the solar wind, which can deform that magnetic field, but has nothing to do with the generation of that magnetic field. Likewise, magnetic fields generated deep inside the sun will pass through the photosphere of the sun and couple with it, despite not being formed in the photosphere by the plasma it is coupled to. So it is important to understand that we can have a magnetic field in a plasma, but not assign the task of generating that magnetic field to that particular plasma.


The topological rearrangement of magnetic field lines can and will happen at a point or locus of points that are situated in a vacuum, but certainly does not preclude the existence of plasma or electric current somewhere else that is generating the magnetic field that is doing the vacuum reconnection. This is in fact exactly what happens in the Somov vacuum reconnection process; the actual reconnection of magnetic field lines takes place in a vacuum, but of course there is a current flowing somewhere else which generates the magnetic field, and in the absence of that current the magnetic field would not only not reconnect, it would not even exist. But is this supposed to be your great revelation? How can you imagine that anyone has ever argued that this is not exactly the case?

Consider this (again!) ...
One need only look at either of the images provided by phunk (post 6553, 29 Feb 2012) or myself (Magnetic Reconnection In Vacuo, 20 May 2011) and see that when the opposite polarity ends of a bar magnet face each other, then the magnetic field lines from either magnet are fully connected to those of the other, while in the case of same polarity ends the magnetic field lines of either magnet are fully disconnected from those of the other. Simply rotating one magnet with respect to the other creates a transition from a fully connected to a fully disconnected state, or vice-versa. That is all you need to see & know, to know that the field lines of the two magnets have to change their connectivity, or in other words, the field lines must reconnect. Now, if we want to talk about the process in some more detail, then all of the technical details you talk about must come into play. However, simply to establish the minimal condition that some form of reconnection takes place does not require anything beyond a visual inspection of the field line images.


Put those two bar magnets in a vacuum and you have magnetic fields in a vacuum rearranging their topology, and that is, by definition, magnetic reconnection. However, everyone agrees that the magnetic fields in the vacuum are generated by microscopic electric currents inside the non-vacuum environment of the magnets themselves. In this case the rate of reconnection is the ratio of the velocity of the "incoming" magnetic field to the "outgoing" magnetic field, which is necessarily 1 in all cases, since there is only one relative velocity between the two magnets.

Reality Check did provide a formula for the rate of reconnection (see post #6801), in terms of the plasma velocity, and I told you how that translates to the vacuum case ...

The magnetic reconnection rate is set by the velocity of the magnetic field, not by the velocity of the plasma. The reason the velocity of the plasma is used is that outside the separatrix area where reconnection actually happens, the magnetic field is frozen to the plasma, so that the two velocities are the same (see, e.g, "Magnetic Reconnection: MHD Theory and Applications", Priest & Forbes, Cambridge University Press 2000, page 36). Magnetic reconnection in a vacuum is both trivial and unavoidable, happening very easily. However, as a general rule, magnetic reconnection is much harder to achieve in an astrophysical plasma because the fields are usually frozen to the plasma in astrophysical applications; e.g., magnetic reconnection is impossible in non-resistive, "ideal", MHD, which is the form originally invented by Alfven. Only in the presence of resistive plasma where the magnetic field can diffuse through the plasma can magnetic reconnection in a plasma actually take place.


So, in conclusion, let me be clear about what "mainstream physics", and more importantly perhaps, I myself, mean by plasma being "optional" in magnetic reconnection. First, "magnetic reconnection" is by definition a topological rearrangement of magnetic field lines of force. Second, the point or locus of points where this topological rearrangement takes place may or may not be in a vacuum. Third, all magnetic fields are ultimately generated by moving electrically charged particles. Finally, plasma certainly is "optional" in the sense that there need not be any charged particles at, or even near, the locus of points where magnetic reconnection takes place, but moving charged particles (which may or may not constitute a "plasma") are certainly not optional in the sense that there must be charged particles in motion somewhere in the universe, from which the magnetic field is generated.

Now, is there anything in what I have said here, that is known to be factually incorrect?
 
Of course this is entirely true. After all, since MHD is a theory of plasma physics (not a theory of vacuum physics), it comes as no surprise that moving charged particles are involved.

They are also involved in the acceleration process and the transfer of magnetic field energy in kinetic energy Tim. You can't take away the TRANSFER OF KINETIC ENERGY out of the process and still call it "reconnection". Even Somov explains that the CURRENTS MOVE and that is what causes "FLUX". The flux accelerates particles and thereby transfers magnetic field energy into particle kinetic energy. If you don't transfer any energy, it's just 'flux" Tim, it's just that simple.
This is in fact exactly what happens in the Somov vacuum reconnection process; the actual reconnection of magnetic field lines takes place in a vacuum,

No, FLUX takes place in the vacuum itself. The RECONNECTION PROCESS is the transfer of that flux energy into particle acceleration. You missed a step Tim.

Reality Check did provide a formula for the rate of reconnection (see post #6801), in terms of the plasma velocity, and I told you how that translates to the vacuum case ...

Ya, I find it ironic that he accepts and understands the fact that the rate of reconnection relates to the acceleration of real particles, but then ignores that fact anyway.

The magnetic reconnection rate is set by the velocity of the magnetic field, not by the velocity of the plasma.

Huh? Didn't you read the grilling that Zeuzz got over that confusion? Magnetic fields propagate at the speed of light Tim. Plasma has various "velocities".

So, in conclusion, let me be clear about what "mainstream physics", and more importantly perhaps, I myself, mean by plasma being "optional" in magnetic reconnection. First, "magnetic reconnection" is by definition a topological rearrangement of magnetic field lines of force.

No Tim, you're DUMBING DOWN the PHYSICAL ACCELERATION PROCESS! It's not JUST about generating magnetic FLUX it's about the EFFECT that flux has on CHARGED PARTICLES. "Reconnection" is the transfer of stored magnetic field energy into particle kinetic energy. It's not FLUX CHANGE. FLUX CHANGE is caused by the change in the distance of the currents according to Somov, but that flux change results in particle acceleration in Somov's RECONNECTION example in a vacuum. His vacuum INCLUDES charged particle movements Tim. That's not optional.

You're all guilty of the same exact fallacy, specifically an equivocation fallacy. You're trying to claim FLUX change is the same as "reconnection", but the rate of reconnection is measured in CHARGED PARTICLE ACCELERATION. You can't take the particles out of the process or no magnetic field energy is converted into particle kinetic energy. It's just FLUX CHANGE, and NO TRANSFER of energy. They are not equal. No equivocation fallacies allowed Tim.
 
Last edited:
The magnetic reconnection rate is set by the velocity of the magnetic field, not by the velocity of the plasma.

I don't know how I missed this earlier, but I think this paragraph needs some explaining on your part. What is the velocity of the magnetic field Tim?

The reason the velocity of the plasma is used is that outside the separatrix area where reconnection actually happens, the magnetic field is frozen to the plasma, so that the two velocities are the same (see, e.g, "Magnetic Reconnection: MHD Theory and Applications", Priest & Forbes, Cambridge University Press 2000, page 36).

They MUST be the same in ANY Birkeland current scenario Tim. There's no such thing as a field line being "frozen' into plasma. The movement of the plasma generates the field Tim.

Magnetic reconnection in a vacuum is both trivial

It's trivial alright, so trivial it's called "flux change", not "reconnection". Reconnection is a term that relates to PLASMA PHYSICS, not VACUUM physics.

and unavoidable,

It's not only avoidable, it's IMPOSSIBLE if you don't get particle acceleration from it.

happening very easily.

No. Flux change happens very easily. Particle acceleration doesn't occur, so no "reconnection" has occurred.

However, as a general rule, magnetic reconnection is much harder to achieve in an astrophysical plasma

Nah, all it takes is lots and lots of current Tim.

because the fields are usually frozen to the plasma in astrophysical applications;

Even Alfven dissed that whole "frozen in' concept, and he came up with it! He regretted ever using the idea even in DENSE plasma because astronomers started applying it recklessly to light, current carrying plasmas. There is no such thing as a magnetic line being "frozen" into plasma Tim. That was a GROSS OVERSIMPLIFICATION that Aflven himself came to regret ever using. It's been ABUSED since then by being applied to LIGHT plasma, even coronal plasmas! Alfven explicitly rejected that claim.

e.g., magnetic reconnection is impossible in non-resistive, "ideal", MHD, which is the form originally invented by Alfven. Only in the presence of resistive plasma where the magnetic field can diffuse through the plasma can magnetic reconnection in a plasma actually take place.

The "resistive" aspect is directly related to the BEHAVIORS OF PLASMA, just like every other attribute of MHD theory. It's still MHD theory and it still REQUIRES the presence of plasma.
 
Last edited:
They are also involved in the acceleration process and the transfer of magnetic field energy in kinetic energy Tim. You can't take away the TRANSFER OF KINETIC ENERGY out of the process and still call it "reconnection". Even Somov explains that the CURRENTS MOVE and that is what causes "FLUX". The flux accelerates particles and thereby transfers magnetic field energy into particle kinetic energy. If you don't transfer any energy, it's just 'flux" Tim, it's just that simple.
Pardon.

No, FLUX takes place in the vacuum itself.
Huh? How can flux (or FLUX if you refer) take place? It isn't an event.
 
Pardon.


Huh? How can flux (or FLUX if you refer) take place? It isn't an event.

It is an 'event' that is "caused" by the movement of currents toward one another according to Somov. His vacuum is *INCLUSIVE* of charged particles, and results in charged particle acceleration. You folks can't ignore the fact that a rate of reconnection relates to the rate of particle acceleration. If there is no particle acceleration, the rate of reconnection is always and forever ZERO. No particles=zero particle acceleration due to flux changes over time=no reconnection.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom