Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
You left out an important part of his explanation:



There's a CAUSE/EFFECT part of his explanation you seem to have missed. The currents have to MOVE toward each other, or none of this occurs.

I didn't leave it out, it's been said multiple times already so I didn't think I had to repeat it again. The cause is the fields overlapping. This is achieved by moving the currents that are creating the fields closer together. The currents never combine, they are just moved a little closer together so that the fields around them combine. You could achieve the same thing by increasing the magnitude of the currents without moving them closer together, so that the fields grow larger.
 
Notice the part I highlighted for phunk. The currents have to MOVE TOWARD ONE ANOTHER, or no "reconnection' takes place.

No, they don't. They can also change in magnitude without getting closer together, and reconnection will occur.
 
Wow. Notice how you just ignored the fact that "reconnection' is triggered by the MOVEMENT OF CHARGED PARTICLES in relationship to one another? Denial sucks.
The fields are being generated by the current. The wires carrying the current are held apart such that their individual fields do not come into contact with one another. The wires are moved towards each other, their fields come into contact, merge and connect. Move the wires away, the fields come apart. Move towards, they reconnect. etc., etc.

It's *********** simple.

Now answer my question if you can.
 
D'rok,

The MOVEMENT of the currents TOWARD EACH OTHER is what allows 'reconnection' to occur. The logical OUTCOME of that attraction is that the currents will eventually merge into a single current carrying thread over time. That continuous movement of the currents TOWARD EACH OTHER is what allows "reconnection" to occur in Somov's example. You can't take that MOVEMENT OF PARTICLES out of the example and claim it's not required. It's an INTEGRAL part of why the "reconnection" happens. It's CAUSED by PARTICLE MOVEMENTS.
 
No, they don't. They can also change in magnitude without getting closer together, and reconnection will occur.

That *ISN'T* the example Somov used. Even then, you're INCREASING THE CURRENT to achieve that change in magnitude, at least in Somov's example.
 
Answer the question.

I just did. It doesn't matter. The RECONNECTION process is DIRECTLY RELATED TO PARTICLE MOVEMENT in Somov's example. Whether the currents are fully merged after reconnection or not is IRRELEVANT to the argument. The PARTICLE MOVEMENT is what CAUSES that "reconnection' of lines in Somov's example. He explained it VERY CLEARLY.
 
I just did. It doesn't matter. The RECONNECTION process is DIRECTLY RELATED TO PARTICLE MOVEMENT in Somov's example. Whether they are fully merged or not is IRRELEVANT to the argument. The PARTICLE MOVEMENT is what CAUSES "reconnection' in Somov's example. He explained it VERY CLEARLY.
Would it be simpler if I made it multiple choice?

The answer is either:

a)1
b)2

Please tell me your answer.
 
Would it be simpler if I made it multiple choice?

The answer is either:

a)1
b)2

Please tell me your answer.

If they are "combined into one" they can't move toward each other anymore and they can't "reconnect" and further. As long as the currents can still move toward each other, more 'reconnection' can occur. How much simpler can it be to demonstrate that CHARGED PARTICLE MOVEMENT is the CAUSE of "reconnection"?
 
STRAWMAN fallacy! Equivocation fallacy too. Somov only introduced 'current' into his vacuum. More importantly his "current" has the capacity to physically MOVE and be "enclosed" by a SINGLE magnetic something-or-other, after "reconnection", certainly not actually a single magnetic LINE.
Not in the slightest. I was responding to your comment "When you put MANY of those charged particles into CURRENTS, in a vacuum, YES, that's a PLASMA in a vacuum." I didn't mention Somov in that post. By making out that I did it is you that is constructing a strawman.

No, technically it's not false. The very first moving CHARGED particle was CURRENT. In it's IONIZED state, any particle is a plasma, and electrons and positrons in their RAW (in a vacuum) state are PLASMA. When FLOWING through a VACUUM, they are "current".
Nope. States of matter are described in terms of their bulk properties. A single particle doesn't have any bulk properties. It is not a plasma.

You're now attempting to CHANGE Somov's VACUUM+CURRENT to INCLUDE something he did NOT include, namely a SOLID wire. Sorry, no such fallacies allowed.
Regardless of whether or not Somov did or did not do this, the above statement is blatantly false. In fact, if you check back through my post history I think you will find that prior to this post I had never even mentioned Somov. So the suggestion that I have been trying to change Somov's words are laughably absurd. The hypocrisy of accusing a poster of constructing a strawman and then constructing a strawman about what that poster has said is hilarious.
 
Like current in a copper wire?

You would still have charged particle movement though the copper wire and the copper wire would still be conductor like any other form of plasma. If all you need is a "conductor", why not just add a few PLASMA PARTICLES to get "wires"? Oh ya, you can't handle the fact that PHYSICAL THINGS are required for "reconnection" to occur.
 
If they are "combined into one" they can't move toward each other anymore and they can't "reconnect" and further. As long as the currents can still move toward each other, more 'reconnection' can occur. How much simpler can it be to demonstrate that CHARGED PARTICLE MOVEMENT is the CAUSE of "reconnection"?
Your refusal to answer the question is noted.
 
You would still have charged particle movement though the copper wire and the copper wire would still be conductor like any other form of plasma. If all you need is a "conductor", why not just add a few PLASMA PARTICLES to get "wires"? Oh ya, you can't handle the fact that PHYSICAL THINGS are required for "reconnection" to occur.
I take this to be your admission that current in a copper wire would be sufficient.

Now show me the plasma.
 
You would still have charged particle movement though the copper wire and the copper wire would still be conductor like any other form of plasma.
My bolding: "like any other form of plasma". This sounds to me like you are suggesting copper wire with a current through it is a plasma. :jaw-dropp

If all you need is a "conductor", why not just add a few PLASMA PARTICLES to get "wires"? Oh ya, you can't handle the fact that PHYSICAL THINGS are required for "reconnection" to occur.
What? It is you who has been arguing that a plasma is necessary. So when its shown clearly that copper wires would do you go on capitalising random words as if it is others who are being thick. Very very odd behaviour.
 
Not in the slightest. I was responding to your comment "When you put MANY of those charged particles into CURRENTS, in a vacuum, YES, that's a PLASMA in a vacuum." I didn't mention Somov in that post. By making out that I did it is you that is constructing a strawman.

Not me. Any *SINGLE* electron in motion through a vacuum is:

A) plasma
B) current

Just as any single molecule of water is still water.

Nope. States of matter are described in terms of their bulk properties. A single particle doesn't have any bulk properties. It is not a plasma.

Yes it is. It's every bit as effected by magnetic fields as any plasma. You're essentially claiming a single molecule of water isn't really water.

Regardless of whether or not Somov did or did not do this, the above statement is blatantly false. In fact, if you check back through my post history I think you will find that prior to this post I had never even mentioned Somov. So the suggestion that I have been trying to change Somov's words are laughably absurd. The hypocrisy of accusing a poster of constructing a strawman and then constructing a strawman about what that poster has said is hilarious.

Look, if you want to be a part of the conversation, fine. If not fine. Don't however start off on some tangent unless you have some idea what I'm discussing. Electrons and protons and positrons are all forms of plasma, either individually or collectively just as a single molecule of water is still water and single gold atom is still gold.
 
My bolding: "like any other form of plasma". This sounds to me like you are suggesting copper wire with a current through it is a plasma. :jaw-dropp


What? It is you who has been arguing that a plasma is necessary. So when its shown clearly that copper wires would do you go on capitalising random words as if it is others who are being thick. Very very odd behaviour.

You're still clearly out of the loop. Copper wires are still something you're ADDING to the vacuum, not Somov. The vacuum itself cannot experience reconnection without particle flow inside Somov's vacuum. Whether you put that particle flow inside or outside of a solid is irrelevant. You still have to move the currents toward each other get get "reconnection". Somov's example of reconnection is NOT plasma optional.
 
Last edited:
Not me. Any *SINGLE* electron in motion through a vacuum is:

A) plasma
B) current

Just as any single molecule of water is still water.

Holy hell. Now, according to Michael, an electron - a single electron - is plasma.

:jaw-dropp
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom