Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
So, if I understand you right:

When Somov wrote "Reconnection in vacuum is a real physical process," he actually meant "Reconnection cannot happen in a vacuum because it requires a plasma," and we know this because he used neither the word "wire" nor the word "plasma" in his description of "Reconnection in vacuum."

Do I understand that right?


Excellent! :)
 
So, if I understand you right:

When Somov wrote "Reconnection in vacuum is a real physical process," he actually meant "Reconnection cannot happen in a vacuum because it requires a plasma," and we know this because he used neither the word "wire" nor the word "plasma" in his description of "Reconnection in vacuum."

Do I understand that right?

No. Somov means that "reconnection" in a vacuum that *INCLUDES* (not excludes) current/plasma is a "real physical process", just as my fictional "Bowlov" would claim his brand of "reconnection" is "physically real" as long as the charged bowling balls keep flowing through that same vacuum. Neither one of them would claim you can get "reconnection" without that constant stream of plasma/charged balls/charged physical objects! Nothing "physically real" can "reconnect" unless there are PHYSICALLY REAL things present in the vacuum.

You can't remove that flow of charged particles from the PROCESS of reconnection. There's nothing left to 'reconnect' the moment the flow of charged items stops flowing THROUGH the vacuum.
 
Last edited:
I really wish one of you "excellent" mathematicians would express the 'rate of reconnection' for us MATHEMATICALLY in a vacuum in the absence of plasma/physical objects. I guess that will happen when HELL FREEZES OVER. :)
 
Last edited:

Yes. I even showed you the WIKI link about extreme cases where only one type of particle exists dude. :) Get real. How MANY individual electrons does it take to turn it into a 'plasma' in your SUBJECTIVE opinion?

How many of them inside of that vacuum will it take for you to realize that their presence *ISN'T OPTIONAL* in the reconnection process?
 
Not me. Any *SINGLE* electron in motion through a vacuum is:

A) plasma
B) current

Nope. A plasma is a state of matter. States of matter are defined in terms of bulk properties and the relationships between them. A single electron does not have any bulk properties.

Just as any single molecule of water is still water.
Err a single molecule of water is a single molecule of water. But a single molecule of water cannot be described as a solid, liquid or gas.

Yes it is. It's every bit as effected by magnetic fields as any plasma. You're essentially claiming a single molecule of water isn't really water.
No I'm not. I'm claiming a single, isolated, molecule of water cannot be considered as solid, liquid or gas.

Look, if you want to be a part of the conversation, fine. If not fine. Don't however start off on some tangent unless you have some idea what I'm discussing.
It is not a tangent. You are arguing about plasmas. I am simply pointing out that you clearly have no idea what a plasma is.

Electrons and protons and positrons are all forms of plasma, either individually or collectively just as a single molecule of water is still water and single gold atom is still gold.
If we take a single molecule of water we couldn't say it was solid, liquid or gas. Ditto with an atom of gold. These states of matter are all defined in terms of bulk quantities. Plasma is a state of matter. It is only defined in terms of bulk quantities.
 
In my simplistic understanding of the text, the currents, wires or whatever, where outside the vacuum region while the fields reconnected in the vacuum region,

Can one of the sane posters confirm or correct me on this?


That's correct.

By the way, magnetic reconnection can occur without the two currents moving toward each other. Magnetic reconnection will also occur if the two currents move away from each other instead of toward each other. You can also get magnetic reconnection by leaving the currents exactly where they are but decreasing or increasing the magnitude of one current.
 
I really wish one of you "excellent" mathematicians would express the 'rate of reconnection' for us MATHEMATICALLY in a vacuum in the absence of plasma/physical objects. I guess that will happen when HELL FREEZES OVER. :)

What you're asking for is nonsense. It's like asking how fast gas flows in a vacuum with no gas.

Reconnection rate is a term used in plasma physics. It does not apply in a vacuum. That doesn't mean reconnection doesn't happen, it means there's no matter entrained in the fields that are reconnecting. In a vacuum, magnetic field changes propagate at the speed of light.
 
Nope. A plasma is a state of matter. States of matter are defined in terms of bulk properties and the relationships between them. A single electron does not have any bulk properties.

Even *individually* an electron and a positron will behave uniquely even in a stable magnetic field. The bulk properties, like bulk mass, relate right back to the individual particles too.

Ok, so HOW MANY electrons present in the vacuum will it take to call it a "plasma" according to you? How many will be required (minimum) to get "reconnection"?
 
What you're asking for is nonsense. It's like asking how fast gas flows in a vacuum with no gas.

Bingo. Tell that to Clinger. He claimed plasma is optional in the reconnection process.

Reconnection rate is a term used in plasma physics. It does not apply in a vacuum.

I agree with you on that point.

That doesn't mean reconnection doesn't happen, it means there's no matter entrained in the fields that are reconnecting. In a vacuum, magnetic field changes propagate at the speed of light.

I'm sorry, but I just can't find anything to disagree with you about. Now if you would please explain all that to Clinger, we should get along famously. :)
 
No. Somov means that "reconnection" in a vacuum that *INCLUDES* (not excludes) current/plasma is a "real physical process", just as my fictional "Bowlov" would claim his brand of "reconnection" is "physically real" as long as the charged bowling balls keep flowing through that same vacuum.

A vacuum with plasma in it is not a vacuum.

Neither one of them would claim you can get "reconnection" without that constant stream of plasma/charged balls/charged physical objects! Nothing "physically real" can "reconnect" unless there are PHYSICALLY REAL things present in the vacuum.

The currents do not reconnect in Somov's example. Field lines reconnect. Field lines do not require plasma to exist, nor do they require plasma to reconnect. The field lines are created by the motion of charged particles, but the reconnection itself can happen at great distance from any charged particles.

You can't remove that flow of charged particles from the PROCESS of reconnection. There's nothing left to 'reconnect' the moment the flow of charged items stops flowing THROUGH the vacuum.

True, but not terribly relevant.
1) the charged particles are not necessarily in the form of a plasma
2) the charged particles are not necessarily present where the reconnection is occurring
 
Even *individually* an electron and a positron will behave uniquely even in a stable magnetic field.
Pardon.

The bulk properties, like bulk mass, relate right back to the individual particles too.
So what is the pressure of an individual electron? What is the average inter-atomic spacing of a single electron? What is the temperature of a single electron?

Ok, so HOW MANY electrons present in the vacuum will it take to call it a "plasma" according to you?
Well, for a collection of particles to be considered a gas, I'd say that you'd need enough so that, if there was no input or output of energy from the system, the distribution of velocities would closely resemble a Maxwell-Boltzmann distribution. For a plasma, thermal equilibrium is a bit more of a complex subject. But I think the number you get for a gas would be as good a marker as any (though those more knowledgeable should feel free to correct me).


How many will be required (minimum) to get "reconnection"?
Pardon?
 
Then you agree that reconnection can occur in a vacuum.

As long as you *INCLUDE* physical particles, sure. At that point it becomes possible to transfer magnetic field energy into particle kinetic energy, but without charged particles in that vacuum, foregetaboutit.
 

Let me amend that:

Even *individually* a *MOVING* electron and a *MOVING* positron will behave uniquely even in a stable magnetic field. The bulk properties, like bulk mass, bulk speed/energy state, relate right back to the individual particles too.
 
You're still clearly out of the loop. Copper wires are still something you're ADDING to the vacuum, not Somov.
I haven't added anything to any vacuum. I don't have a vacuum to play with at the minute.

The vacuum itself cannot experience reconnection without particle flow inside Somov's vacuum.
What if you stick two current carrying wires outside the vacuum in question?

Whether you put that particle flow inside or outside of a solid is irrelevant. You still have to move the currents toward each other get get "reconnection".
No you don't.

Somov's example of reconnection is NOT plasma optional.
His example of reconnection in plasma is not plasma optional. But that's obvious.
 
Magnetic Reconnection In Vacuo XV

That doesn't mean reconnection doesn't happen, it means there's no matter entrained in the fields that are reconnecting. In a vacuum, magnetic field changes propagate at the speed of light.
I'm sorry, but I just can't find anything to disagree with you about. Now if you would please explain all that to Clinger, we should get along famously. :)


Is this not an explicit agreement from Mozina that magnetic fields will reconnect in a vacuum?
 
As long as you *INCLUDE* physical particles, sure. At that point it becomes possible to transfer magnetic field energy into particle kinetic energy, but without charged particles in that vacuum, foregetaboutit.

The only need for physical anything is to generate the field. There is no need for any physical particles anywhere near the area where reconnection occurs.
 
Well, for a collection of particles to be considered a gas, I'd say that you'd need enough so that, if there was no input or output of energy from the system, the distribution of velocities would closely resemble a Maxwell-Boltzmann distribution. For a plasma, thermal equilibrium is a bit more of a complex subject. But I think the number you get for a gas would be as good a marker as any (though those more knowledgeable should feel free to correct me).

FYI, the basic argument is whether or not their presence in the vacuum is optional for "reconnection" to occur. It's not optional.
 
Let me amend that:

Even *individually* a *MOVING* electron and a *MOVING* positron will behave uniquely even in a stable magnetic field.
Well obviously an electron and a positron will behave differently in a magnetic field. What they won't do is behave like a plasma.

The bulk properties, like bulk mass, bulk speed/energy state, relate right back to the individual particles too.
That doesn't make any sense. By definition, the bulk properties of something cannot relate exclusively to the properties of a single entity. Some bulk properties don't even have a meaningful single-particle analogue!
 
The only need for physical anything is to generate the field. There is no need for any physical particles anywhere near the area where reconnection occurs.

There's no need for any physical particles to be anywhere near where that FLUX occurs, but for that FLUX to accelerate any charged particles, charged particles will be required.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom