Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
It appears the concept of a line is being grossly misunderstood here. Possibly because it is a mathematical concept.

A LINE is a ONE DIMENSIONAL mathematical concept. A FIELD is something that CURRENT actually CREATES as it moves! Lines aren't the problem. The irrational use of a 1 dimensional term for something enclosing a 4 dimensional flow of current is the problem.

Arguments about lines which are assembled without any understanding of the mathematical concept of lines are likely to result in failure. And in this thread, they pretty much universally have.

You've all universally failed to explain what you intend to use to measure the "rate of reconnection" in the absence of all forms of moving charged particles. Don't you figure others have noticed that GLARING EPIC FAILURE by now?
 
Last edited:
Just out of curiosity....

How would you expect the currents to become "enclosed in one field line" after reconnection if the currents don't move?

If you physically keep them apart by making the paths of the currents a SOLID PATH, how would they ever COMBINE into ONE LINE?


The concept of "line" is clearly misunderstood and is being used incorrectly here. Without understanding the fundamental mathematical concept of a line, any attempts to build arguments upon it are certain to fail.
 
The concept of "line" is clearly misunderstood and is being used incorrectly here. Without understanding the fundamental mathematical concept of a line, any attempts to build arguments upon it are certain to fail.

In terms of mathematics (and only mathematics) a LINE is a *ONE DIMENSIONAL* construct! A one dimensional construct cannot possibly *ENCLOSE* a *FOUR* dimensional flow of CURRENT. Get real.
 
A LINE is a ONE DIMENSIONAL mathematical concept. A FIELD is something that CURRENT actually CREATES as it moves! Lines aren't the problem. The irrational use of a 1 dimensional term for something enclosing a 4 dimensional flow of current is the problem.

You've interpreting the word "enclose" too literally. To say a field line, which is 3 dimensional by the way, is enclosing the current simply means that the current is passing through the loop formed by the line.
 
You've interpreting the word "enclose" too literally. To say a field line, which is 3 dimensional by the way, is enclosing the current simply means that the current is passing through the loop formed by the line.

Look, I'm the first to admit that Somov's work is FIRST RATE. The concept however of claiming that a CURRENT or any combination of current is "enclosed" in a LINE is simply sloppy use of terms. If he had used the term FIELD, I'd be fine with the term "enclosed". The term "enclosed" and "line" however don't belong together in that sentence. It's a simple misuse of terms, nothing to write the publisher over IMO.
 
Just out of curiosity....

How would you expect the currents to become "enclosed in one field line" after reconnection if the currents don't move?

Frankly, that question doesn't make sense to me. Why couldn't they be moved? Are you implying that current-carrying wires can't move? There's an extension cord by my foot; if you'd like I can try pushing it. I'm pretty confident that it will move.

I see nothing in that section that implies that the currents are being moved by the magnetic forces, if that's what you're assuming.

If you physically keep them apart by making the paths of the currents a SOLID PATH, how would they ever COMBINE into ONE LINE?

We're really not communicating here. Do you think the currents are being combined into one line? I see nothing in Somov to indicate that and, further, his figure 1.3b shows two separate currents after reconnection.
 
The really ridiculous part of this conversation is the fact that Somov is ultimately just describing the "magnetic attraction" that occurs between two current carrying filaments, and the fact they COMBINE into ONE current as a result of that attraction. None of it WORKS without CURRENT! If they had simply used the term "current flow", you people would NOT be trying to claim that PLASMA IS OPTIONAL. They just picked a STUPID name to call a CURRENT DRIVEN PROCESS. Even in Somov's SIMPLEST EXAMPLE, the actual PROCESS is CAUSED BY the E field and the FLOW OF CURRENT through the vacuum. Without charged particles to transfer the magnetic field energy into, all you end up with is FLUX and no transfer of stored magnetic field energy into particle kinetic energy.

I've seen denial and I've seen HARD CORE DENIAL too, but EU haters are in a class by themselves. "Charge particles in motion? What current?"
 
Look, I'm the first to admit that Somov's work is FIRST RATE. The concept however of claiming that a CURRENT or any combination of current is "enclosed" in a LINE is simply sloppy use of terms. If he had used the term FIELD, I'd be fine with the term "enclosed". The term "enclosed" and "line" however don't belong together in that sentence. It's a simple misuse of terms, nothing to write the publisher over IMO.

Well, keep in mind that the picture is showing a 2d slice of the field and current, and in those 2 dimensions, it is enclosed. I don't think it's all that sloppy, I think it makes sense in the context it's used in.
 
Michael, focus.

In Somov, how many currents are there before reconnection in the vacuum?
How many currents are there after reconnection in the vacuum?
 
The really ridiculous part of this conversation is the fact that Somov is ultimately just describing the "magnetic attraction" that occurs between two current carrying filaments, and the fact they COMBINE into ONE current as a result of that attraction.

No, he isn't! He's talking about the fields around the two currents, and describing how the fields merge. The currents never combine.
 
I'm *STILL WAITING* for you folks to explain the RATE OF RECONNECTION in the absence of mass flow. Everyone must notice by now that you're all avoiding that question like the plague.
 
The rate of reconnection you're asking about is a property of reconnection happening in a plasma. This does not mean that reconnection only happens in plasma anymore than the speed of light through water means that light only exists underwater.
 
No, he isn't! He's talking about the fields around the two currents, and describing how the fields merge. The currents never combine.

You left out an important part of his explanation:

1.1.2 Reconnection in vacuum
The X-type points constitute the most important topological peculiarity of a magnetic field. They are the places where redistribution of magnetic fluxes occurs, which changes the connectivity of field lines. Let us illustrate such a process by the simplest example of two parallel electric currents I of equal magnitude I in vacuum as shown in Figure 1.3.
The magnetic field of these currents forms three different fluxes in the plane (x, y). Two of them belong to the upper and the lower currents, respectively, and are situated inside the separatrix field line A1 which forms the eight-like curve with a zeroth X-point. The third flux situated outside this curve belongs to both currents and is situated outside the separatrix. If the currents are displaced in the direction of each other, then the following redistribution of a magnetic flux will take place. The current’s proper fluxes will diminish by the quantity δA (shown by two shadowed rings in Figure 1.3a), while their common flux will increase by the same quantity (shown by the shadowed area in Figure 1.3b), So the field line A2 will be the separatrix of the final state.
This process is realized as follows. Two field lines approach the X-point, merge there, forming a separatrix, and then they reconnect forming a field line which encloses both currents. Such a process is termed reconnection of field lines or magnetic reconnection. A2 is the last reconnected field line.

There's a CAUSE/EFFECT part of his explanation you seem to have missed. The currents have to MOVE toward each other, or none of this occurs.
 
The rate of reconnection you're asking about is a property of reconnection happening in a plasma. This does not mean that reconnection only happens in plasma anymore than the speed of light through water means that light only exists underwater.

Then you should be able to mathematically quantify the rate of reconnection in some other way that isn't dependent upon the flow of matter. I've yet to see your side produce such a thing. Tick.tick.tick...
 
Michael, focus.

In Somov, how many currents are there before reconnection in the vacuum?
How many currents are there after reconnection in the vacuum?

Notice the part I highlighted for phunk. The currents have to MOVE TOWARD ONE ANOTHER, or no "reconnection' takes place.
 
Wow. I don't think ANY of you will EVER explain the rate of reconnection, mathematically or otherwise in the absence of matter. This has to be the saddest, most denial oriented cult on the planet. EU haters RUN LIKE HELL from every tough question put before them.
 
Notice the part I highlighted for phunk. The currents have to MOVE TOWARD ONE ANOTHER, or no "reconnection' takes place.
FFS. Michael just answer the question.

And of course the currents move toward one another. Just like the magnets in the home experiment you refuse to do.

You are really going off the rails here.
 
FFS. Michael just answer the question.

And of course the currents move toward one another.

Wow. Notice how you just ignored the fact that "reconnection' is triggered by the MOVEMENT OF CHARGED PARTICLES in relationship to one another? Denial sucks.
 
Please answer.

Please answer "what"? The movement of the current CAUSES "reconnection" of the FULL CONTINUOUS FIELDS. The two separate fields attract, they flux, they join, they change over time and induce currents and particle movement in plasma as a result of that change. No plasma, no physics and no movement of physical particles and no magnetic reconnection.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom