Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
When you put MANY of those charged particles into CURRENTS, in a vacuum, YES, that's a PLASMA in a vacuum.

Well
1) That depends. For example, the electrons moving in a copper wire in an otherwise evacuated chamber do not constitute a plasma.
2) That wasn't what you just said. You just said "The first moment a moving charged particle was created in a "vacuum", "plasma" existed and current existed." Clearly that statement is false.
 
The "trick" here is DUMBING DOWN the STREAM OF MOVING PARTICLES, AKA "current" and calling it a "magnetic line' that "encloses the current'. What a bunch of confused BS by claiming that a LINE encloses current.

No one, other than you, has ever done what you just described. We all know that a field line is a path through a field, that has nothing to do with particles, and that a circle can enclose something without touching it.
 
can Michael Mozina even tie his shoes?

Start with just one line. How does a "magnetic line" (as opposed to a whole field) "enclose" any current? The whole concept is ridiculous and physically impossible. To then claim a "magnetic line' now "encloses" two DIFFERENT CURRENTS is equally absurd. The "trick" here is DUMBING DOWN the STREAM OF MOVING PARTICLES, AKA "current" and calling it a "magnetic line' that "encloses the current'. What a bunch of confused BS by claiming that a LINE encloses current.

It's not even LOGICAL to talk about a "magnetic line" enclosing a current or any combination of currents in the first place. What's the WIDTH of that "line" now anyway? How is it even logical to talk about a LINE (not a whole field) enclosing a current?


Take a couple of long aluminum rods. Tie a piece of string around them.

If those rods were infinitely long, you couldn't remove the piece of string from around those rods without untying it or cutting it.

That's the sense in which a magnetic field line encloses those currents.

For pictures, see
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=7739880&postcount=4661

For an animation of magnetic reconnection that involves field lines surrounding one, two, or four currents (in conducting rods that run perpendicular to the plane shown in the animation), see
http://www.cesura17.net/~will/Ephemera/Nerdliness/MR/
 
It's not even LOGICAL to talk about a "magnetic line" enclosing a current or any combination of currents in the first place. What's the WIDTH of that "line" now anyway? How is it even logical to talk about a LINE (not a whole field) enclosing a current?


People who don't/can't understand math might have difficulty with the concept of magnetic field lines.
 
Well
1) That depends. For example, the electrons moving in a copper wire in an otherwise evacuated chamber do not constitute a plasma.

STRAWMAN fallacy! Equivocation fallacy too. Somov only introduced 'current' into his vacuum. More importantly his "current" has the capacity to physically MOVE and be "enclosed" by a SINGLE magnetic something-or-other, after "reconnection", certainly not actually a single magnetic LINE.

2) That wasn't what you just said. You just said "The first moment a moving charged particle was created in a "vacuum", "plasma" existed and current existed." Clearly that statement is false.

No, technically it's not false. The very first moving CHARGED particle was CURRENT. In it's IONIZED state, any particle is a plasma, and electrons and positrons in their RAW (in a vacuum) state are PLASMA. When FLOWING through a VACUUM, they are "current".

You're now attempting to CHANGE Somov's VACUUM+CURRENT to INCLUDE something he did NOT include, namely a SOLID wire. Sorry, no such fallacies allowed.
 
Last edited:
Take a couple of long aluminum rods. Tie a piece of string around them.

When you add a bunch of lines together and integrate the whole thing you end up with a FIELD. I'm fine with claiming that a couple of currents are enclosed inside of a FIELD. The term LINE is completely inadequate and highly imprecise.

It's more correct to suggest that the CURRENT generates a magnetic FIELD and that magnetic field PINCHES the current into a filament and 'encloses" the current. The concept of a single line here is meaningless in terms of "enclosing" the whole current filament.

I love Somov's work, but that sentence is, well, not precise.
 
No one, other than you, has ever done what you just described.

Nah, I've seen it done all the time. When astronomers usually talk about measured magnetic "lines", that experience topology changes, they're usually talking about PLASMAS that move through time, form filaments. That's particularly true in solar physics and MHD theory where "streams" become "lines" all too easily.
 
Last edited:
You're now attempting to CHANGE Somov's VACUUM+CURRENT to INCLUDE something he did NOT include, namely a SOLID wire. Sorry, no such fallacies allowed.

Perhaps he was confused by Somov's Figure 1.10. This figure illustrates "two parallel electric currents in a vacuum," and unlike the earlier figures, this one is more 3D. In Figure 1.10, the currents are shown flowing through two long, slim, rod-like entities.

Perhaps I am also being confused, because they sure look like wires to me.
 
Last edited:
People who don't/can't understand math might have difficulty with the concept of magnetic field lines.

People who can't understand the physics have a difficulty with the concept of "clean debate". You're a one trick personal attack pony. BORING!
 
Perhaps he was confused by Somov's Figure 1.10. This figure illustrates "two parallel electric currents in a vacuum," and unlike the earlier figures, this one is more 3D. In Figure 1.10, the currents are shown flowing through two long, slim, rod-like entities.

Have you ever seen a plasma filament inside a plasma ball before? They form long, slim, "rod-like" entities. That's what current carrying plasma does. Somov's whole book (well at least my book) is all about plasma physics. I've never seen anything EXCEPT that type of rod-like entity used in his work to convey a filament.

Perhaps I am also being confused, too, because they sure look like wires to me.

Alfven actually called them "wires" too by the way.
 
When you add a bunch of lines together and integrate the whole thing you end up with a FIELD. I'm fine with claiming that a couple of currents are enclosed inside of a FIELD. The term LINE is completely inadequate and highly imprecise.

It's more correct to suggest that the CURRENT generates a magnetic FIELD and that magnetic field PINCHES the current into a filament and 'encloses" the current. The concept of a single line here is meaningless in terms of "enclosing" the whole current filament.

I love Somov's work, but that sentence is, well, not precise.


It appears the concept of a line is being grossly misunderstood here. Possibly because it is a mathematical concept. Arguments about lines which are assembled without any understanding of the mathematical concept of lines are likely to result in failure. And in this thread, they pretty much universally have.
 
Have you ever seen a plasma filament inside a plasma ball before? They form long, slim, "rod-like" entities.

They're not straight with hard edges and constant circular cross-sections.

That's what current carrying plasma does. Somov's whole book (well at least my book) is all about plasma physics. I've never seen anything EXCEPT that type of rod-like entity used in his work to convey a filament.

I flipped through the book (430 pages!) and couldn't find any other figures with rods like that, but it's possible that I missed some. Do you have any references?
 
Why? Can't you handle the fact that Somov's vacuum *INCLUDES* moving charged particles t? That piece of info just rocks your world or what?

hang on, I didn't see that at all. Where did you see that the currents merged into a field line? I saw field lines merging, but never currents merging to form a field line.

I don't even know what it would mean for currents to merge into a field line. It's a lot like saying that two mountains merged to form a contour line.

It is called creative reading, and don't tell MM that he might have misread because he is the expert on everything plasma, including in his bicycle dynamo.
 

You know.....

The reason your "stuff" could never be published is because it's factually INCORRECT from the start. For instance, I don't deny that reconnection happens. I deny that it happens in the ABSENCE OF PHYSICAL PARTICLES. You don't know how to distinguish truth from your own hate and that's a problem in the publishing world. Anyone can put up a factually incorrect website in cyberspace. Did you ever intend to get any of your stuff on "reconnection" published through any peer review process?
 
They're not straight with hard edges and constant circular cross-sections.

Just out of curiosity....

How would you expect the currents to become "enclosed in one field line" after reconnection if the currents don't move?

If you physically keep them apart by making the paths of the currents a SOLID PATH, how would they ever COMBINE into ONE LINE?
 
I flipped through the book (430 pages!) and couldn't find any other figures with rods like that, but it's possible that I missed some. Do you have any references?

I'd have to go through my book on plasma physics by Somov and it's at home. I'll check it out when I get home. It's not at all unusual to treat magnetic ropes as "wires". Alfven himself used that term in fact.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom