Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
This is weird. I asked you for two simple things;

I asked you folks for PEER REVIEWED material to support your claims that plasma is OPTIONAL in the reconnection process. That's never happened. I also asked you for a mathematical description of the rate of reconnection without PLASMA. That has never happened either. Don't you think others are noticing that not one of you can even define the RATE of reconnection in the absence of plasma? Doesn't that bother you?
 
You're still clearly out of the loop. Copper wires are still something you're ADDING to the vacuum, not Somov. The vacuum itself cannot experience reconnection without particle flow inside Somov's vacuum. Whether you put that particle flow inside or outside of a solid is irrelevant. You still have to move the currents toward each other get get "reconnection". Somov's example of reconnection is NOT plasma optional.
In my simplistic understanding of the text, the currents, wires or whatever, where outside the vacuum region while the fields reconnected in the vacuum region,

Can one of the sane posters confirm or correct me on this?
 
Holy hell. Now, according to Michael, an electron - a single electron - is plasma.

:jaw-dropp

Yep, a single electron traveling through a vacuum is a single plasma particle in a vacuum like a single atom of gold traveling through that same vacuum is still gold inside of a vacuum.
 
This is weird. I asked you for two simple things;

I asked you folks for PEER REVIEWED material to support your claims that plasma is OPTIONAL in the reconnection process. That's never happened. I also asked you for a mathematical description of the rate of reconnection without PLASMA. That has never happened either. Don't you think others are noticing that not one of you can even define the RATE of reconnection in the absence of plasma? Doesn't that bother you?
Where is the plasma in a copper wire?
 
I'm really the only one here that notices that none of you can even define a rate of reconnection in the absence of matter? WOW!
 
Where is the plasma in a copper wire?

In that case (an example that is completely *DIFFERENT* from the one Somov actually described) the electrons are flowing through a SOLID rather than a VACUUM. That electron flow is still NOT OPTIONAL. The electrons still have to move TOWARD ONE ANOTHER, for "reconnection" to occur. You still added current and a conductor to your vacuum to achieve "reconnection". Reconnection did NOT occur in the vacuum *WITHOUT* that conductor and without that charged particle movement.
 
In that case (an example that is completely *DIFFERENT* from the one Somov actually described) the electrons are flowing through a SOLID rather than a VACUUM. That electron flow is still NOT OPTIONAL. The electrons still have to move TOWARD ONE ANOTHER, for "reconnection" to occur. You still added current and a conductor to your vacuum to achieve "reconnection". Reconnection did NOT occur in the vacuum *WITHOUT* that conductor and without that charged particle movement.
Where is the plasma in a copper wire?
 
All these mathematical aficionados and still no mathematical expression for a rate of reconnection definition? I thought that you guys claimed that physics is all about math? Where's your mathematical expression for the rate of reconnection in the absence of all plasma? I've seen you folk run *LIKE HELL* from that question now for DAYS now! Is there anyone here willing to answer it, yes or no?
 
Last edited:
Where is there a copper wire in Somov's presentation? Talk about strawman arguments.
In classic Mozina doublethink, you are simultaneously holding two mutually contradictory positions. You assert both that a)magnetic reconnection can occur using fields generated by current in copper wires, and b)magnetic reconnection cannot occur without the presence of plasma.

It's mildy amusing and diverting on a slow Friday afternoon at the office.
 
In that case (an example that is completely *DIFFERENT* from the one Somov actually described) the electrons are flowing through a SOLID rather than a VACUUM.

How is it different? Specifically, how would figures 1.3a and 1.3b look any different whatsoever?

Seriously, I'm very interested in your answer to that.

That electron flow is still NOT OPTIONAL.

Nobody is denying that for a hypothetical case involving electric current, there will necessarily be some movement of charged particles. They don't technically have to be electrons, but electrons are generally the most convenient to work with.

Now about those pesky permanent magnets . . no, I'll get back to that later.

The electrons still have to move TOWARD ONE ANOTHER, for "reconnection" to occur.

Technically, no, it's not necessary for the electrons to actually move toward one another. The currents have to move toward each other, but the individual electrons can keep moving perpendicular to Somov's x,y plane.

You still added current and a conductor to your vacuum to achieve "reconnection". Reconnection did NOT occur in the vacuum *WITHOUT* that conductor and without that charged particle movement.

I think that we're all comfortable with the idea that we don't have a massless way to generate magnetic fields and that without magnetic fields there is no magnetic reconnection. I'm not sure who you think would be disagreeing with you on that.
 
In classic Mozina doublethink, you are simultaneously holding two contradictory positions. You assert both that a)magnetic reconnection can occur using fields generated by current in copper wires, and b)magnetic reconnection cannot occur without the presence of plasma.

It's mildy amusing and diverting on a slow Friday afternoon at the office.

It's more than mildly amusing that you folks are still trying to use a NON PUBLISHED strawman example to support your claims when I specifically asked you for a PUBLISHED WORK. You can't actually find any published, peer reviewed works to support your claim, so off you go on another strawman argument.

It's down right HYSTERICAL that all these math gurus that all claim that math is king in the field of physics can't even mathematically express a rate of reconnection in the absence of plasma. That's funny!
 
It's more than mildly amusing that you folks are still trying to use a NON PUBLISHED strawman example to support your claims when I specifically asked you for a PUBLISHED WORK. You can't actually find any published, peer reviewed works to support your claim, so off you go on another strawman argument.

It's down right HYSTERICAL that all these math gurus that all claim that math is king in the field of physics can't even mathematically express a rate of reconnection in the absence of plasma. That's funny!
Somov isn't published?
 
Still waiting for that mathematical expression of a rate of reconnection in the absence of plasma. You can't even come up with it. Who do you think you're fooling anyway?
 
Somov never used the term WIRE in conjunction with that VACUUM in his published works. That's EU hater strawman BS.
Oh, I see.

Then no doubt you'll stop talking about PLASMA in conjuntion with that VACUUM in his published works. Or is it ok to insert that term which he also did not use?
 
It really doesn't bother all these math gurus that not one of you can even dream up a mathematical expression for the rate of "reconnection' without plasma? Really? I better NEVER hear you folks lecture me again about how important math is to your beliefs. Math has NOTHING to do with your beliefs because all the MATH related to the rate of 'reconnection" is related to the flow of plasma.
 
Last edited:
Oh, I see.

Then no doubt you'll stop talking about PLASMA in conjuntion with that VACUUM in his published works. Or is it ok to insert that term which he also did not use?

Somov's whole book is related to PLASMA physics and current inside of a vacuum is plasma in a vacuum, just as a line of gold atoms in a vacuum is a line of gold in a vacuum. You can't simply TAKE OUT or ADD what you don't like to his vacuum. He added the current on his own.
 
Somov never used the term WIRE in conjunction with that VACUUM in his published works.

So, if I understand you right:

When Somov wrote "Reconnection in vacuum is a real physical process," he actually meant "Reconnection cannot happen in a vacuum because it requires a plasma," and we know this because he used neither the word "wire" nor the word "plasma" in his description of "Reconnection in vacuum."

Do I understand that right?
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom