Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Even before "reconnection" occurs, each 'magnetic line' is actually composed of MOVING CHARGED PARTICLES to begin with, and the real kinetic energy comes from the E field that drives the charged particle movement in the first place!

What in a name? The name "magnetic reconnection' is SO lame, you STILL think plasma is "optional" even when Somov EXPLICITLY USES CURRENT to drive the parade!
 
Even before "reconnection" occurs, each 'magnetic line' is actually composed of MOVING CHARGED PARTICLES to begin with

Hold on a minute, didn't you say that magnetic field lines are not physical things, they're just visualization tools? Now you say they are actual streams of particles?
 
hang on, I didn't see that at all. Where did you see that the currents merged into a field line? I saw field lines merging, but never currents merging to form a field line.

I highlighted the appropriate text in yellow and used the largest font I could find in a few posts above yours. :)

I don't even know what it would mean for currents to merge into a field line. It's a lot like saying that two mountains merged to form a contour line.

Ultimately the confusion stems from the fact that the mainstream intentionally "dumbs down" a "Bennett Pinch', and calls it a "magnetic line'. When two or more of these current carrying filaments "reconnect", they call it "magnetic reconnection'. The confusion comes from "dumbing down' the process to ONE orientation, specifically in this case, the B orientation.
 
Hold on a minute, didn't you say that magnetic field lines are not physical things, they're just visualization tools? Now you say they are actual streams of particles?

Maybe I wasn't clear. The CURRENTS are streams of charged particles. The movement of those charged particles creates the magnetic field. No current that is composed of moving charged particles, no magnetic field.
 
I highlighted the appropriate text in yellow and used the largest font I could find in a few posts above yours. :)


.
You highlighted text that shows two magnetic field lines merging into one. The currents are unchanged. There are still two of them. They haven't merged into anything. The language is crystal clear about that.

This is a serious question: Have you ever been diagnosed with a learning disability related to reading?
 
How does any field line "enclose both currents"? The only way you can make that claim is by claiming a 'magnetic line" has a WIDTH that is at least equal to the width of an electron. The whole "game" here is associating a current with a LINE.
 
Yes I saw what you hilighted in yellow. You clearly once again don't know what it means. The hilighted text means that what was once 2 field lines, one around each current, merges to form a single field line, surrounding both currents. It does NOT imply that the currents merged, or that there were any charged particles along the field lines.
 
How does any field line "enclose both currents"? The only way you can make that claim is by claiming a 'magnetic line" has a WIDTH that is at least equal to the width of an electron. The whole "game" here is associating a current with a LINE.

Draw a dot on a piece of paper. Then draw a circle around it. Does the circle need to touch the dot to enclose it?
 
How does any field line "enclose both currents"? The only way you can make that claim is by claiming a 'magnetic line" has a WIDTH that is at least equal to the width of an electron. The whole "game" here is associating a current with a LINE.
No.
 
I highlighted the appropriate text in yellow and used the largest font I could find in a few posts above yours. :)

Despite the large font and hilighting, I could still find no indication that the currents were merging. The field lines were merging. No current required.

Ultimately the confusion stems from the fact that the mainstream intentionally "dumbs down" a "Bennett Pinch', and calls it a "magnetic line'.

the phrase "magnetic line" does not appear in that Somov quote. I believe that when Somov referred to "field lines," he actually meant "field lines."

Do you agree that one can draw field lines for a permanent magnet in a vacuum? Wouldn't it be necessarily true that those field lines would not be current-carrying filaments?
 
Last edited:
Yes I saw what you hilighted in yellow. You clearly once again don't know what it means. The hilighted text means that what was once 2 field lines, one around each current,

Start with just one line. How does a "magnetic line" (as opposed to a whole field) "enclose" any current? The whole concept is ridiculous and physically impossible. To then claim a "magnetic line' now "encloses" two DIFFERENT CURRENTS is equally absurd. The "trick" here is DUMBING DOWN the STREAM OF MOVING PARTICLES, AKA "current" and calling it a "magnetic line' that "encloses the current'. What a bunch of confused BS by claiming that a LINE encloses current.

The CURRENTS merge and the fields merge. The moving charged particle filaments create a magnetic field around the current and that magnetic field is attracted to the magnetic field of the other current stream. The currents merge due to that "attraction' of whole fields. No LINE could ever 'enclose" any current. That whole claim is a "dumbed down" concept from the starts so they can associate LINES with CURRENTS!
 
Last edited:
Since literally the "dawn of time". The first moment a moving charged particle was created in a "vacuum", "plasma" existed and current existed.

Erm, no. A single, moving charged particle does not make a plasma. Much the same as a single stationary, uncharged particle doesn't make a solid.
 
Despite the large font and hilighting, I could still find no indication that the currents were merging. The field lines were merging. No current required.

It's not even LOGICAL to talk about a "magnetic line" enclosing a current or any combination of currents in the first place. What's the WIDTH of that "line" now anyway? How is it even logical to talk about a LINE (not a whole field) enclosing a current?
 
Start with just one line. How does a "magnetic line" (as opposed to a whole field) "enclose" any current?

How about we start by visualizing the x,y plane, as Somov describes, and then assume that the two currents are parallel to the z-axis. In such a visualization, the two currents would appear to be points, and it's very easy to circle two points with a line.

The whole concept is ridiculous and physically impossible. To then claim a "magnetic line' now "encloses" two DIFFERENT CURRENTS is equally absurd.

Somov did not use the term "magnetic line," he said "field line." In fact, he said "field line which encloses both currents." Should I assume that you're dismissing the entire Somov article as being "ridiculous and physically impossible?"
 
Erm, no. A single, moving charged particle does not make a plasma. Much the same as a single stationary, uncharged particle doesn't make a solid.


When you put MANY of those charged particles into CURRENTS, in a vacuum, YES, that's a PLASMA in a vacuum.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom