Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Oy Vey. I really (honestly) suggest that you pickup an actual textbook on plasma physics. If you don't accept the fact that electrons in motion, (aka CURRENT) are a form of plasma in motion, then you don't know anything about plasma physics I'm afraid.
Perhaps you could point me to the textbook on plasma physics that contradicts Wikipedia's definition of plasma?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plasma_(physics)

Alternatively, since Wikipedia is obviously in error, perhaps you should edit this article so that it conforms to the "correct" definition of plasma.
 
Then you have no business even trying to defend Clinger's nonsense in the first place.
...usual delusional rant, e.g. MR requiring plasma snipped...
Then you need to learn to understand what you read.
A definition of reconnection rate is a ratio between plasma flow velocities. It does not exist in vacuum.

W.D. Clinger's simple derivation of magnetic reconnection starts with no plasma and shows that MR happens. Also see Cosmic plasma physics By Boris V. Somov, section 4.2.2 Reconnection in vacuum.

Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section VIII
 
Last edited:
Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section IX

Yes he did. He specifically adds CHARGED PARTICLES OF MASS to his vacuum and describes their velocity changes. His VACUUM includes charged particles which is what enables him to discuss *VELOCITY* in the first place!
Another delusion :eye-poppi!

He specifically adds CHARGED PARTICLES OF MASS to his vacuum after his description of MR in vacuum.

Somov has just described MR in vacuum. There were no particles in the vicinity of the neutral point. There were 2 idealized currents.

He now states that an electric field is induced and can accelerate a charge particle or particles in the vicinity of the neutral point. To get those particles there you have to add them to the vicinity of the neutral point where there were no particles before :eye-poppi .

Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section VIII
Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section VII
Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section VI.
Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section V
Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section IV
Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section III
Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section II
Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section
 
The only difference between the two examples in Somov's book is that in the 'vacuum' example there are just two currents already flowing in the vacuum, and nothing surrounding the two currents.

The currents are idealized currents as in Maxwell's equations. No one should be stupid enough to say that the J in Maxwell's equations is plasma. LIkewise it takes a special ignorance to think that the J in section 4.2.2 is a plasma.

If you want to make these idealized currents "physical" then replace them with zero width wires.

The point that you remain unable to understand is that this "nothing" is a vacuum. It is what the MR happens in. The MR happens outside of the currents at the neutral point. That is where the electric field is induced. If you introduce charged particles into this vacuum in the vicinity of the neutral point then they can be accelerated.
 
What does VELOCITY relate to t in the ABSENCE of all particles of mass, *INCLUDING* current?
The ACCELERATION relates to Somov finishing the description of MR in vacuum and setting up for the next section on MR in plasma.
He mentions that if you have charged particles in the vacuum around the neutral point then they can be accelerated.
 
Boloney! Let me highlight all the references to current and plasma!
Boloney!
Let me highlight all the references to vacuum and reconnection in vacuum!

Cosmic plasma physics By Boris V. Somov

Chapter 4. Motion of a Particle in a Field
4.4.2 Reconnection in a Vacuum.
The X-type points constitute the most important topological peculiarity of a magnetic field. They are the places where redistribution of magnetic fluxes occurs, which changes the connectivity of field lines. Let us illustrate such a process by the simplest example of two parallel electric currents I of equal magnitude I in vacuum as shown in Figure 1.3.
The magnetic field of these currents forms three different fluxes in the plane (x, y). Two of them belong to the upper and the lower currents, respectively, and are situated inside the separatrix field line A1 which forms the eight-like curve with a zeroth X-point. The third flux situated outside this curve belongs to both currents and is situated outside the separatrix. If the currents are displaced in the direction of each other, then the following redistribution of a magnetic flux will take place. The current’s proper fluxes will diminish by the quantity δA (shown by two shadowed rings in Figure 1.3a), while their common flux will increase by the same quantity (shown by the shadowed area in Figure 1.3b), So the field line A2 will be the separatrix of the final state.
This process is realized as follows: Two field lines approach the X-point, merge there, forming a separatrix, and then they reconnect forming a field line which encloses both currents. Such a process us termed reconnection of field lines or magnetic reconenction. A2 is that last reconnect field line.

Magnetic reconnection is of fundamental importance for the nature of many non-stationary phenomena in cosmic plasma. We shall discuss the physics of this process more fully in chapters 16 to 22. Suffice it to say that reconnection is inevitable associated with electric field generation. The field is the inductive one, since
[equation 4.65]
where A is the vector potential of magnetic field,
[equation 4.66]
In the above example, the electric field is directed along the z axis. It is clear if that if dt is the characteristic time of the reconnection process shown in Figure 4.17 then according to (4.65)
[equation 4.67]
the last equality will be justified n Section 9.2

Reconnection in vacuum is a real physical process: magnetic field lines move to the X-type neutral point and reconnect in it as well as
| the electric field is induced and can accelerate a charge particle or
| particles in the vicinity of the neutral point.

In this sense, a collisionless reconnection – the physical process in a hightemperature rarefied plasma such as the solar corona, geomagnetic tail, fusion plasmas, and so on – is simpler for understanding than reconnection in a highly-conducting collisional space plasma.
 
Last edited:
This is bizarre. You've evidently latched on to ONE WORD of Somov's book (his use of the term "vacuum") and you've UTTERLY IGNORED the PHYSICS (and current) that he actually describes.
This is bizarre. You've evidently latched on to ONE WORD of Somov's section on Reconnection in vacuum (his use of the term "plama"?) and you've UTTERLY IGNORED the PHYSICS AND ENGLISH (and idealized current) that he actually wrote.
In his description the MR happens at the neutral point. This is in vacuum.
 
Last edited:
Magnetic Reconnection In Vacuo XIV

Let me highlight all the references to vacuum and reconnection in vacuum!

Cosmic plasma physics By Boris V. Somov
Chapter 4. Motion of a Particle in a Field
4.4.2 Reconnection in a Vacuum.
The X-type points constitute the most important topological peculiarity of a magnetic field. They are the places where redistribution of magnetic fluxes occurs, which changes the connectivity of field lines. Let us illustrate such a process by the simplest example of two parallel electric currents I of equal magnitude I in vacuum as shown in Figure 1.3.
{ ... }


I would like to point out that it is critical to look at figure 1.3, on page 103. The currents that generate the magnetic fields flow in a line perpendicular to the page in two marked spots (little circles with an x in them). Everywhere else is a vacuum with no current flow, in particular the null point marked "X". This null point, where the magnetic fields actually do their reconnecting, are completely embedded in a vacuum, there are no particles and there is no current flow at or near that point. This is a direct illustration of the reconnection of magnetic field lines in a vacuum.



The reconnection rate is the ratio of the inflowing plasma velocity to the out flowing plasma velocity.

Ding, ding, DING!


"Ding, ding" is what happens when amateurs try to do science by exegesis instead of actually understanding what's happening. The magnetic reconnection rate is set by the velocity of the magnetic field, not by the velocity of the plasma. The reason the velocity of the plasma is used is that outside the separatrix area where reconnection actually happens, the magnetic field is frozen to the plasma, so that the two velocities are the same (see, e.g, "Magnetic Reconnection: MHD Theory and Applications", Priest & Forbes, Cambridge University Press 2000, page 36). Magnetic reconnection in a vacuum is both trivial and unavoidable, happening very easily. However, as a general rule, magnetic reconnection is much harder to achieve in an astrophysical plasma because the fields are usually frozen to the plasma in astrophysical applications; e.g., magnetic reconnection is impossible in non-resistive, "ideal", MHD, which is the form originally invented by Alfven. Only in the presence of resistive plasma where the magnetic field can diffuse through the plasma can magnetic reconnection in a plasma actually take place.

Consider this:

One need only look at either of the images provided by phunk (post 6553, 29 Feb 2012) or myself (Magnetic Reconnection In Vacuo, 20 May 2011) and see that when the opposite polarity ends of a bar magnet face each other, then the magnetic field lines from either magnet are fully connected to those of the other, while in the case of same polarity ends the magnetic field lines of either magnet are fully disconnected from those of the other. Simply rotating one magnet with respect to the other creates a transition from a fully connected to a fully disconnected state, or vice-versa. That is all you need to see & know, to know that the field lines of the two magnets have to change their connectivity, or in other words, the field lines must reconnect. { ... } simply to establish the minimal condition that some form of reconnection takes place does not require anything beyond a visual inspection of the field line images.


That reconnection absolutely must happen in a vacuum is so plainly obvious that Mozina's continual denial is simply stunning.
 
Boloney! Let me highlight all the references to current and plasma!

How in the WORLD can you miss all those references to CURRENT and MOVING CHARGE PARTICLES (and associated mass) that are present *INSIDE OF* Somov's "vacuum"?

Indeed madness!

Since when is a "current" immediately synonymous with "plasma"?
Like I already asked you, do you have plasma in you bicycle dynamo or is it really copper wire?
The only things you highlighted was the words "current" and I can do exactly the same thing that Somov did here in the lab with two copper wires and a board with compasses and you see how the magnetic field changes through the changes of the compass needles. And we can safely say that in my laboratory there is no plasma present.

Currents and moving charged particles can be in a vacuum without having a plasma, and the main reason therefore is that the current is flowing through a copper wire. Please specifically quote in Somov's text where he says there is a plasma. MMM, you can't, because Somov does not say there is a plasma, he says there is a vacuum.

MM this is getting so frakking tedious, with all this stupidity coming from your keyboard, with your preconceptions about what is right and what it wrong. You wanted published stuff about "vacuum reconnection", we give you the book from an author you seemed to trust, who has a whole section about "vacuum reconnection" and you twist his words by equating current to plasma to invalidate the whole section of this book called vacuum reconnection just because it does not fit your preconceptions.
 
Indeed madness!

Madness indeed. I've seen LAME, denial based arguments in my day, but you folks take the cake!

Since when is a "current" immediately synonymous with "plasma"?

Since literally the "dawn of time". The first moment a moving charged particle was created in a "vacuum", "plasma" existed and current existed.

Like I already asked you, do you have plasma in you bicycle dynamo or is it really copper wire?

Horse pucky! Somov JOINS his two 'currents' into one. Rigid wires won't work. His example is specifically related to CHARGED PARTICLE MOVEMENTS OVER TIME. In order for the currents to 'reconnect' the particles have to MOVE. There MUST BE a KINETIC ENERGY TRANSFER between the magnetic field *TO* a *CHARGED PARTICLE* in order for "reconnection" to occur! You need MOVING current streams that can 'reconnect' in Somov's example, not SOLID WIRES. What a RIDICULOUS argument!

Let's look at just how *RIDICULOUS* your argument really is by turning charged particles in bowling balls for a second:

Bowlmov said:
Chapter 1. Motion of 15 pound, highly charged bowling balls in a Field

1.1.1 Reconnection in vacuum

The X-type points constitute the most important topological peculiarity of a magnetic field. They are the places where redistribution of magnetic fluxes occurs, which changes the connectivity of field lines. Let us illustrate such a process by the simplest example of two parallel electric currents composed of moving charged bowling balls I of equal magnitude I in vacuum as shown in Figure 1.3.
The magnetic field of these currents of moving charged bowling balls forms three different fluxes in the plane (x, y). Two of them belong to the upper and the lower streams of bowling balls, respectively, and are situated inside the separatrix field line A1 which forms the eight-like curve with a zeroth X-point. The third flux situated outside this curve belongs to both streams of bowling balls and is situated outside the separatrix. If the moving steams of charged bowling balls are displaced in the direction of each other, then the following redistribution of a magnetic flux will take place. One bowling ball stream’s proper fluxes will diminish by the quantity δA (shown by two shadowed rings in Figure 1.3a), while their common flux will increase by the same quantity (shown by the shadowed area in Figure 1.3b), So the field line A2 will be the separatrix of the final state.
This process is realized as follows. Two field lines approach the X-point, merge there, forming a separatrix, and then they reconnect forming a field line which encloses both streams of highly charged bowling balls. Such a process is termed reconnection of field lines or magnetic reconnection. A2 is the last reconnected field line.

Somov no more describes the "reconnection" of two current streams in the absence of plasma (charged particles) than Bowlmov describes the reconnection of bowling ball streams in the absence of a constant flow of charged bowling balls.

Your argument is UTTERLY ABSURD from the start. The "reconnection" process describes the *TRANSFER OF ENERGY* from the magnetic field to CHARGED PARTICLE KINETIC ENERGY! MHD theory describes the mathematical relationships between PHYSICAL THINGS, specifically charged particles, and magnetic fields. You can't take the mass out of the equation or there can be no transfer of magnetic field energy into particle kinetic energy, and there can be no MAGNETIC FIELD in the first place.

In both SOMOV's example of Bowlmov's example the *REAL ENERGY* is the E field that is actually driving and producing *BOTH CURRENTS* and providing the real kinetic energy at the point of 'reconnection'. You're *STILL* ignoring the fact that the E field does the actual work of generating both CURRENTS to begin with. If we shut off Bowlmov's supply of moving bowling ball streams, no "reconnection' happens.

You guys are trying to take the PHYSICS (physical particles) out of plasma physics. That won't fly.

Somov's example REQUIRES charged particles and INTRODUCES plasma into the vacuum the moment he uses the term "current". The term "current" relates DIRECTLY to the movement of charged particles. The movement of charged particles in a vacuum is called the movement of PLASMA in a vacuum. Somov's "vacuum" is never empty. It's never devoid of moving charged particles anymore than Bowlmov's examples is devoid of 15 pound, highly charged bowling balls. In fact, in order for Bowlmovs example to work, the balls MUST exist and *MUST* be "charged" and they must be MOVING to start with!
 
Last edited:
Perhaps you could point me to the textbook on plasma physics that contradicts Wikipedia's definition of plasma?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plasma_(physics)

Alternatively, since Wikipedia is obviously in error, perhaps you should edit this article so that it conforms to the "correct" definition of plasma.

Actually, Wiki is right. (at least in this case *BEFORE* anyone's "tinkered" with it during our conversation. :) )

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plasma_(physics)#Non-neutral_plasma

Non-neutral plasma

The strength and range of the electric force and the good conductivity of plasmas usually ensure that the densities of positive and negative charges in any sizeable region are equal ("quasineutrality"). A plasma with a significant excess of charge density, or, in the extreme case, is composed of a single species, is called a non-neutral plasma. In such a plasma, electric fields play a dominant role. Examples are charged particle beams, an electron cloud in a Penning trap and positron plasmas.[25]
 
There are no words.

Sure there are, there are Somov's OWN WORDS:

Somov said:
1.1.2 Reconnection in vacuum
The X-type points constitute the most important topological peculiarity of a magnetic field. They are the places where redistribution of magnetic fluxes occurs, which changes the connectivity of field lines. Let us illustrate such a process by the simplest example of two parallel electric currents I of equal magnitude I in vacuum as shown in Figure 1.3.
The magnetic field of these currents forms three different fluxes in the plane (x, y). Two of them belong to the upper and the lower currents, respectively, and are situated inside the separatrix field line A1 which forms the eight-like curve with a zeroth X-point. The third flux situated outside this curve belongs to both currents and is situated outside the separatrix. If the currents are displaced in the direction of each other, then the following redistribution of a magnetic flux will take place. The current’s proper fluxes will diminish by the quantity δA (shown by two shadowed rings in Figure 1.3a), while their common flux will increase by the same quantity (shown by the shadowed area in Figure 1.3b), So the field line A2 will be the separatrix of the final state.
This process is realized as follows. Two field lines approach the X-point, merge there, forming a separatrix, and then they reconnect forming a field line which encloses both currents. Such a process is termed reconnection of field lines or magnetic reconnection. A2 is the last reconnected field line.
 
OMG. Somov takes two CURRENTS composed of moving charged particles, merges them into a single "field line" that encloses BOTH streams of moving charged particles and you're STILL claiming that no charged particles are involved in the process! Like I said, I've seen denial in my day, but EU haters are in a class by themselves.
 
OMG. Somov takes two CURRENTS composed of moving charged particles, merges them into a single "field line"

hang on, I didn't see that at all. Where did you see that the currents merged into a field line? I saw field lines merging, but never currents merging to form a field line.

I don't even know what it would mean for currents to merge into a field line. It's a lot like saying that two mountains merged to form a contour line.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom