Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
The only difference between the two examples in Somov's book is that in the 'vacuum' example there are just two currents already flowing in the vacuum, and nothing surrounding the two currents. The existence of the CURRENTS exists in BOTH examples t. Talk about BLATANT denial. How did you intend to discuss RECONNECTION RATES without PHYSICAL CHARGED PARTICLES and changes in the velocities of those particles?

The currents are just two wires, NO NEED FOR PLASMA IF YOU WANT A CURRENT.
Or are you implying that the dynamo on your bicylce has plasma in it instead of copper wires?
 
No. Go back and read the quotes again. He specifically said "wavelength of the filed lines", and was called out on it rightfully, and now you're defending him by talking about OTHER uses of the word wavelength that have nothing to do with what he said. Just stop, you're sounding even more desperate to avoid concession than usual.

I'm simply stunned that he can know so much about plasma physics, point out to Clinger that the "rate of reconnection' is related to PARTICLE VELOCITY changes, yet STILL defend the notion of "reconnection" in the absence of ALL plasma, including those charged particles that Somov calls "CURRENT"!
 
The currents are just two wires,

Boloney. They are CHARGED PARTICLES in motion that are added to Somov's vacuum IN ADDITION TO THE VACUUM. Whether you put them in a wire or you don't, you still added charged particles to the 'vacuum'. Give it a rest! The denial routine won't save you by kludging it up with wires. You simply added TWO new elements by adding wires, current *AND* a conductor that will experience induction in the presence of flux change. Somov added CHARGED PARTICLES to his 'vacuum'. Deal with it already.

NO NEED FOR PLASMA IF YOU WANT A CURRENT.

No need to embrace what Somov ACTUALLY said when you can muddy the waters with unrelated distractions that STILL ADD CHARGED PARTICLES to the vacuum!

Give it a rest already. That whole "wires" in the vacuum is nonsense. All you did is add conductors *AND* charged particles in motion. Wow, big deal. You *STILL ADDED PHYSICAL STUFF TO THAT VACUUM*! Get real.
 
Last edited:
The reconnection rate is the ratio of the inflowing plasma velocity to the out flowing plasma velocity. It tells you things like the characteristic time over which the reconnection happens.

The Sweet-Parker model has a reconnection rate of

c4bca0477871854bef9cbd717c20999f.png


RC, what is VsubA in the absence of all charged particles?
 
Last edited:
Boloney. They are CHARGED PARTICLES in motion that are added to Somov's vacuum IN ADDITION TO THE VACUUM. Whether you put them in a wire or you don't, you still added charged particles to the 'vacuum'. Give it a rest! The denial routine won't save you by kludging it up with wires. You simply added TWO new elements by adding wires, current *AND* a conductor that will experience induction in the presence of flux change. Somov added CHARGED PARTICLES to his 'vacuum'. Deal with it already.



No need to embrace what Somov ACTUALLY said when you can muddy the waters with unrelated distractions that STILL ADD CHARGED PARTICLES to the vacuum!

Give it a rest already. That whole "wires" in the vacuum is nonsense. All you did is add conductors *AND* charged particles in motion. Wow, big deal. You *STILL ADDED PHYSICAL STUFF TO THAT VACUUM*! Get real.

Madness hath a name and it's mozina
 
Right. You can't handle the fact that PHYSICAL OBJECTS (charged particles) are *REQUIRED* for "reconnection" and REQUIRED to describe VELOCITIES and rates of reconnection. What a pity.

No they are NOT required as is clearly shown in the Somov book, in the section that I completely copied in my post. The fact that you cannot handle anything that goes against your preconceptions that e.g. currents have to be plasmas, is not of my concern. I know what is happening with the magnetic field lines and I know that it works like Somov states in his section "reconnection in vacuum." That would be vacuum as in NO PLASMA as in nothing there (except for the two copper wires that carry the electric current in his figure 1.3), dear sir.

One might even come up with an expression for the reconnection rate in Somov's example of vacuum reconnection, the fact that the Alfven velocity comes in when a plasma is present should not be surprising, however, an exactly same set up can be made for the example in Somov's vacuum reconnection, where the current wires are moving slowly together or apart, and then we take a look at how the magnetic field develops. You might do this as a homework problem.

And by the way, you still need to give a full explanation for the "wavelength of the field lines" or are you hoping that Zeuzzz will do that for you?
 
Last edited:
No they are NOT required as is clearly shown in the Somov book, in the section that I completely copied in my post.

Boloney! Let me highlight all the references to current and plasma!

1.1.2 Reconnection in vacuum
The X-type points constitute the most important topological peculiarity of a magnetic field. They are the places where redistribution of magnetic fluxes occurs, which changes the connectivity of field lines. Let us illustrate such a process by the simplest example of two parallel electric currents I of equal magnitude I in vacuum as shown in Figure 1.3.
The magnetic field of these currents forms three different fluxes in the plane (x, y). Two of them belong to the upper and the lower currents, respectively, and are situated inside the separatrix field line A1 which forms the eight-like curve with a zeroth X-point. The third flux situated outside this curve belongs to both currents and is situated outside the separatrix. If the currents are displaced in the direction of each other, then the following redistribution of a magnetic flux will take place. The current’s proper fluxes will diminish by the quantity δA (shown by two shadowed rings in Figure 1.3a), while their common flux will increase by the same quantity (shown by the shadowed area in Figure 1.3b), So the field line A2 will be the separatrix of the final state.
This process is realized as follows. Two field lines approach the X-point, merge there, forming a separatrix, and then they reconnect forming a field line which encloses both currents. Such a process is termed reconnection of field lines or magnetic reconnection. A2 is the last reconnected field line.

How in the WORLD can you miss all those references to CURRENT and MOVING CHARGE PARTICLES (and associated mass) that are present *INSIDE OF* Somov's "vacuum"?
 
Last edited:
This is bizarre. You've evidently latched on to ONE WORD of Somov's book (his use of the term "vacuum") and you've UTTERLY IGNORED the PHYSICS (and current) that he actually describes.
 
This is bizarre. You've evidently latched on to ONE WORD of Somov's book (his use of the term "vacuum") and you've UTTERLY IGNORED the PHYSICS (and current) that he actually describes.
Michael, in your opinion, what conductive medium is the current flowing through?
 
It doesn't hurt to admit ignorance.

If you don't believe me, you should conduct an experiment.

Well, it's been about a year long experiment already hasn't it? :)

Suffice to say that the rate of reconnection is related to the velocity changes of charged particles (neutrons won't work) as stored magnetic field energy is converted into particle (mass) kinetic energy. To talk about velocity changes due to reconnection (rate of reconnection), mass is REQUIRED.

You're right though, admitting ignorance isn't a bad thing. I just wish you'd done that a year ago. It would have made for a much "simpler" (and less hostile) conversation. ;)
 
Last edited:
Michael, in your opinion, what conductive medium is the current flowing through?

IMO you're already missing the point. A conductive medium (namely the current/plasma particles in motion) is already present in the vacuum. It already contains two "currents". Even if they were "dumbed down' to their very simplest form, say two cathode rays, there are particles of plasma (yes electrons are plasma) in motion, in the vacuum from the START! The VACUUM is never empty. There are charged particles of mass being accelerated by the flux changes. That is what Somov is describing.
 
IMO you're already missing the point. A conductive medium (namely the current/plasma particles in motion) is already present in the vacuum. It already contains two "currents". Even if they were "dumbed down' to their very simplest form, say two cathode rays, there are particles of plasma (yes electrons are plasma) in motion, in the vacuum from the START! The VACUUM is never empty. There are charged particles of mass being accelerated by the flux changes. That is what Somov is describing.
You know, it might make it simpler if you just made a short list of the terms that use to mean the accepted definition. And it would be a very short list.

Current=plasma? Electrons=plasma? Even I know that that is idiotic.
 
You know, it might make it simpler if you just made a short list of the terms that use to mean the accepted definition. And it would be a very short list.

Current=plasma? Electrons=plasma? Even I know that that is idiotic.

Oy Vey. I really (honestly) suggest that you pickup an actual textbook on plasma physics. If you don't accept the fact that electrons in motion, (aka CURRENT) are a form of plasma in motion, then you don't know anything about plasma physics I'm afraid.
 
Oy Vey. I really (honestly) suggest that you pickup an actual textbook on plasma physics. If you don't accept the fact that electrons in motion, (aka CURRENT) are a form of plasma in motion, then you don't know anything about plasma physics I'm afraid.

So, electricity flowing through a wire is actually plasma? An electron beam is plasma (it might be, I'm a little vague on the definition there)? A baseball, which contains many, many electrons, is actually plasma if it's moving through the air?
 
So, electricity flowing through a wire is actually plasma?

That question is technically a red herring. Somov starts with only a vacuum and never once mentions the term 'wire'. That's a strawman argument to begin with.

An electron beam is plasma (it might be, I'm a little vague on the definition there)?

That's a valid question, and the answer is yes.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plasma_(physics)#Non-neutral_plasma

A baseball, which contains many, many electrons, is actually plasma if it's moving through the air?

Strike two on the red herring questions. We're talking about the influence of EM field changes on charged particles and "conductors". ;)

FYI, I know I owe you some replies to some other posts. I'll get to them as I can, but it may not be today. :(
 
That question is technically a red herring. Somov starts with only a vacuum and never once mentions the term 'wire'. That's a strawman argument to begin with.

Nor does he mention plasma, or even any plasma-related terms such as, say, Debye length or conductivity or ionization. And he never gives any indication that the currents are being moved around by the magnetic fields, while that's precisely what makes plasma interesting.

Of the two obvious ways to conduct a current - e.g. wire and plasma, you chose the one that directly conflicts with the title of the section and is not consistent with the rest of the text. Seriously, are you suggesting that Somov doesn't know what a vacuum is?

Strike two on the red herring questions. We're talking about the influence of EM field changes on charged particles and "conductors".

You can't have it both ways. If "electrons in motion" necessarily means plasma, then a baseball is plasma. If "electrons in motion" does not necessarily mean plasma, then your contention that Somov's use of the word "current" requires a plasma is non sequitur.

ETA:
FYI, I know I owe you some replies to some other posts. I'll get to them as I can, but it may not be today.

Yeah, I can't cop too much of an attitude on that part. I think I still owe a response to a longish, multipart post from a week or so back.
 
Last edited:
Oy Vey. I really (honestly) suggest that you pickup an actual textbook on plasma physics. If you don't accept the fact that electrons in motion, (aka CURRENT) are a form of plasma in motion, then you don't know anything about plasma physics I'm afraid.
I guess that makes two of us.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom