Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
[latex]
\[
\mathbf{B} \cdot d \mathbf{S}
\]
[/latex]​




You keep using that word. I do not think it means what you think it means.

I don't think you know what the term "reconnection' means, so we're even.

Did you intend to published that "stuff" you wrote, yes or no? If not, you're blowing unpublished smoke at me like any creationist on the planet.

Without a CONDUCTOR, you won't induce any CURRENT because of those field changes. No current, no discharge, no 'reconnection' because no magnetic field energy can be converted to particle kinetic energy. Nothing happens but flux change/time.
 
Nice try, but it's all propaganda, and not very well done even for that. You will find the phrase "toy model" is quite common in the physics literature (a quick look at ADS reveals 332 papers with the phrase "toy model" in their title; no telling how often it shows up buried in the text). A "toy model" is a model that everyone knows is oversimplified, but nobody cares.

You seem to care Tim. Their "full" version is based on resistive MHD theory! The fact it's based on MHD theory shoots your claim in the foot! You evidently latched on to a single word, in this case "vacuum" and are trying to build a federal case *WITHOUT ANY SUPPORTING MATH!*

Unless and until you can produce a math that *ISN'T* based on MHD theory, you didn't support your claim. That paper *IS* based upon MHD theory. Their TOY brand is therefore ALSO based on MHD theory according to you.

The rest of your post seems to be a rehash of the fact that you refuse to come to grips with the fact that their paper is based on MHD theory, leaving you folks HIGH AND DRY without a plasma particle to your name, and without a published paper to support your absurd and ridiculous claims!
 
I really can't believe the EU haters are STILL in hardcore denial of the fact that plasma is NOT optional in the 'reconnection' process. There can be no transfer of magnetic field energy into particle kinetic energy without particles! Get real!
 
I really can't believe you still don't know what magnetic reconnection is.
 
I really can't believe you still don't know what magnetic reconnection is.

I know what PUBLISHED materials tell me it is in terms of the math and the physics. The math is based on MHD theory which *REQUIRES* physical particles. I know the difference between a PROCESS in PLASMA called "reconnection" which results in an electrical "discharge", and a simple "flux" without a conductor present, therefore no induced current, no transfer of magnetic field energy into particle kinetic energy, and no discharge.

You folks do not. That is why you cannot and never will produce a published paper on "magnetic reconnection" in the absence of all plasma. Foregetaboutit. You sound about as credible as a creationist waving away at a website in cyberspace. I doubt that anyone in this conversation besides Tim, tusenfem and myself even owns a book on plasma physics, and that is the only kind of physics text book that describes "magnetic reconnection".
 
Last edited:
You folks literally can't tell the difference between "magnetic flux change" in the absence of a conductor, and an electrical discharge in plasma. How pitiful. No wonder you can't produce anything PUBLISHED to support this handwavy nonsense.
 
Magnetic Reconnection In Vacuo XIII

Nice try, but it's all propaganda, and not very well done even for that. You will find the phrase "toy model" is quite common in the physics literature (a quick look at ADS reveals 332 papers with the phrase "toy model" in their title; no telling how often it shows up buried in the text). A "toy model" is a model that everyone knows is oversimplified, but nobody cares.
You seem to care Tim. Their "full" version is based on resistive MHD theory!


I don't care. But more to the point, you don't understand. The model presented in the paper is not based on MHD in any way. It is a pure vacuum reconnection model. No MHD. No plasma. All of your arguments to the contrary are falsified by facts.

You evidently latched on to a single word, in this case "vacuum" and are trying to build a federal case *WITHOUT ANY SUPPORTING MATH!*


Au contraire, mon ami. I have provided all of the relevant supporting math, which you will find here: Aspects of Three-Dimensional Magnetic Reconnection - (Invited Review); Priest & Schrijver, Solar Physics 19(1/2): 1-24, December 1999. Read it or don't, but I see no reason why I should go to the trouble of copying from there to here.

Unless and until you can produce a math that *ISN'T* based on MHD theory, you didn't support your claim.


I already have; e.g., see Magnetic Reconnction: In Plasma and In Vacuo. I have provided several sources which include descriptions of pure vacuum magnetic reconnection; no plasma, no MHD. However, the evidence to date suggests that you are neither intellectually no emotionally able to deal with these facts. And as additional evidence, consider this:

That paper *IS* based upon MHD theory. Their TOY brand is therefore ALSO based on MHD theory according to you.


As I read this, by your own admission, you never even looked at the vacuum reconnection model presented by Priest & Schrijver, never even considered it at all, ignored it altogether. All you need to see is that the paper is about plasma physics, and you simply assume that everything is plasma physics, even when the authors of the paper are explicit in saying it is a vacuum model. I didn't fixate on the word "vacuum"; rather, that is the exact word used by the authors. So, why do you ignore it? Or maybe you now wish to accuse Priest & Schrijver of deliberately lying, claiming a vacuum model when the knew very well that it was not? Or maybe you just want to accuse them of being too stupid to know the difference between a plasma and a vacuum?

You allow your own blindfolding prejudice to show through too easily. You routinely deny the existence of things you can see right in front of you, rather than admit the truth. You habitually call anyone who disagrees with a "hater" so you can vilify them and consequently rationalize away any need to deal with the actual physics presented. You do that to me constantly, and don't think I don't notice. Unless and until you change yourself into a person willing to deal with real physics, you can't support any of your claims.
 
I don't care. But more to the point, you don't understand. The model presented in the paper is not based on MHD in any way. It is a pure vacuum reconnection model. No MHD. No plasma. All of your arguments to the contrary are falsified by facts.

Bull!

In this review paper we discuss several aspects of magnetic reconnection theory, focusing on the field-line motions that are associated with reconnection. A new exact solution of the nonlinear MHD equations for reconnective annihilation is presented which represents a two-fold generalization of the previous solutions. Magnetic reconnection at null points by several mechanisms is summarized, including spine reconnection, fan reconnection and separator reconnection, where it is pointed out that two common features of separator reconnection are the rapid flipping of magnetic field lines and the collapse of the separator to a current sheet. In addition, a formula for the rate of reconnection between two flux tubes is derived.

Did you miss that SECOND feature Tim and that reference to the CURRENT SHEET they describe?

Au contraire, mon ami. I have provided all of the relevant supporting math, which you will find here: Aspects of Three-Dimensional Magnetic Reconnection - (Invited Review); Priest & Schrijver, Solar Physics 19(1/2): 1-24, December 1999. Read it or don't, but I see no reason why I should go to the trouble of copying from there to here.

Huh? That's just a link back that SAME MHD PAPER Tim! It's based on MHD THEORY! You didn't support your case with math, you literally blew your case out of the water with that math. That math is all based on MHD THEORY Tim.

Get real.

You took ONE WORD out of their presentation ("vacuum") and ignored the math and the physics entirely. Nice try, but it won't fly. Their entire presentation is based upon MHD theory Tim. The TOY brand isn't even mathematically quantified in that link independently from any of the other MATHS.
 
Last edited:
As I read this, by your own admission, you never even looked at the vacuum reconnection model presented by Priest & Schrijver, never even considered it at all, ignored it altogether.

No. I simply note it is based upon MHD theory, just like any other paper on reconnection theory, which kills your claim like any other paper based upon MHD theory and/or plasma behaviors!

All you need to see is that the paper is about plasma physics, and you simply assume that everything is plasma physics, even when the authors of the paper are explicit in saying it is a vacuum model.

So what? Somov uses the term "vacuum" in that very same context but also includes CURRENT in that very same "vacuum". The one term "vacuum" isn't the telling feature Tim. The telling physical feature is the fact it's ultimately all based on MHD theory.

I didn't fixate on the word "vacuum"; rather, that is the exact word used by the authors. So, why do you ignore it? Or maybe you now wish to accuse Priest & Schrijver of deliberately lying, claiming a vacuum model when the knew very well that it was not?

I'm sure THEY knew what they meant by that term just as SOMOV knew what he meant by that term when he *INCLUDED* current. They also based their models on MHD theory Tim! Nothing like ignoring the fact that their maths are based on MHD theory just because they used the term "vacuum" and "toy" in the same paper. Oy Vey.
 
You allow your own blindfolding prejudice to show through too easily. You routinely deny the existence of things you can see right in front of you, rather than admit the truth.

That's kind of ironic coming from you on this topic. The TRUTH is that without PARTICLES to accelerate, and without a conductor to induce currents as Sweet explained, your flux change does nothing. There's no release of stored EM energy without particles. Your entire argument is one giant equivocation fallacy. You're ignoring the fact the math is based on MHD theory.
 
In the case of MR in a vacuum those particles are called photons. The change in magnetic field topology means that the energy stored in the magnetic decreases. The release energy is in the form of light (photons).

Photons from WHAT? You don't have a plasma particle to your name!
 
Hey, LMSAL has *ACTUALLY* stated what has been known for decades

They are FINALLY realizing that the coronal loops originate *UNDER* the photosphere and can be tracked up the SIDE of UMBRA!
...
Oh dear - more ignorance :eye-poppi.

Astronomers have been saying for decades that coronal loops originate *UNDER* the photosphere.

Here is a study of a coronal loop "best described as a flux rope" that starts below the photosphere where pressure makes it float upward. That means that the top of the loop starts to pokes out through the photosphere and so becomes visible (it is impossible to see light from below the photosphere). It continues to rise into the chromosphere.

ETA
Now if I can just get them to describe the relationships between the filters, and the fact the iron ion line can be seen traversing the surface of the photosphere



There is no "relationships between the filters". They are merely the filters that they decided to use to look at the loop:
  • photospheric Si I 10827 AA line (silicon ionized once)
  • chromospheric He I 10830 AA triplet (helium ionized once)
The fact that FE ions can be detected on the the surface of the photosphere is because there are Fe atoms (0.16% by mass) in the photosphere which is hot enough to ionize them :eek: !
For example FeII forms at temperatures between 4000 K and 10,000 K.
 
Last edited:
Wow! The more I think about that presentation at LMSAL next week, the more I'm stoked and excited. It's about time that the mainstream finally acknowledges that the coronal loops TRAVERSE the surface of the photosphere and they are "lit up" and achieve million degree temperatures UNDER the surface of the photosphere. It's definitely progress IMO.
Wow! You really repeat your ignorance and inability to understand what you read.
The mainstream has acknowledged that the coronal loops TRAVERSE the surface of the photosphere for decaded - they have observed them moving!

The presentation abstract does not state that coronal loops achieve million degree temperatures UNDER the surface of the photosphere.

This is espcially ignorant since the presentation is images from SiI and HeI which are at thousands of degree temperatures.
 
Last edited:
I really can't believe the EU haters are STILL in hardcore denial of the fact that plasma is NOT optional in the 'reconnection' process. There can be no transfer of magnetic field energy into particle kinetic energy without particles! Get real!
I really can't believe this science hater is STILL in hardcore denial of the fact that plasma is optional in MR.
MR in a vacuum is described in Cosmic plasma physics By Boris V. Somov

MR in a vacuum is mentioned in the scientific literature:
MR in a vacuum is a simple derivation from Maxwell's equations: to W.D. Clinger's simple derivation of magnetic reconnection

I really can't believe this science hater cannot understand that the "transfer of magnetic field energy into particle kinetic energy" is for MR in a plasma :eye-poppi !
MR without plasma means that there is transfer of magnetic field energy into photons.
 
That is why you cannot and never will produce a published paper on "magnetic reconnection" in the absence of all plasma.
You are lying: We have produced several papers that mention magnetic reconnection in the absence of all plasma.
Only someone truly ignorant of science would think that scientific papers would cover MR in the absence of all plasma. That is a trivial and well established process covered in textbooks, e.g. Somov's textbook.

This is despite your delusion that there is plasma in his section about MR in a vacuum (Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section VI etc.).

W.D. Clinger's simple derivation of magnetic reconnection has absolutely no plasma in it.
 
Photons from WHAT? You don't have a plasma particle to your name!
Photons created from the energy released from the magnteic field!

There are no "plasma particle" in a vacuum. You remain deluded about MR in a vacuum: Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section VI (etc.) .

Also:
 
Emphasis mine. It's about TIME! They are FINALLY realizing that the coronal loops originate *UNDER* the photosphere and can be tracked up the SIDE of UMBRA!


Astronomers have been saying for decades that coronal loops originate *UNDER* the photosphere.


Really. It would require pretty much blind ignorance of the past couple of decades of solar science to think this idea is somehow a new discovery.

WOW! That's progress.


It's an interesting refinement of observations we've already been aware of, at least those of us who have been paying attention to solar science for the last several years.

Here is a study of a coronal loop "best described as a flux rope" that starts below the photosphere where pressure makes it float upward. That means that the top of the loop starts to pokes out through the photosphere and so becomes visible (it is impossible to see light from below the photosphere). It continues to rise into the chromosphere.


Indeed. The term "photosphere" has a pretty simple definition which necessarily requires it to be opaque. And the physics which show us the depth at which the photosphere becomes opaque are damned simple, too, at least conceptually. The desperation required to ignore those facts in order to cling to some imagined surface 4800 kilometers further down is astounding.

Now if I can just get them to describe the relationships between the filters, and the fact the iron ion line can be seen traversing the surface of the photosphere, [...]


There is no "relationships between the filters". They are merely the filters that they decided to use to look at the loop:
  • photospheric Si I 10827 AA line (silicon ionized once)
  • chromospheric He I 10830 AA triplet (helium ionized once)
The fact that FE ions can be detected on the the surface of the photosphere is because there are Fe atoms (0.16% by mass) in the photosphere which is hot enough to ionize them :eek: !
For example FeII forms at temperatures between 4000 K and 10,000 K.


Again really. There's a fairly fundamental reason particular filters have been selected for acquiring the satellite images. It has to do with observing thermal characteristics at various levels in the solar atmosphere. And we know we're viewing those particular levels because being a sphere, the Sun provides us the luxury of making those observations at the limb. We confirm our understanding with geometry, high school math. There's no magic to it. And no amount of wild guessing will force the data to mean something other than what it is.

[...] we can actually have a real conversation about solar satellite images. I wonder where they now place "solar moss" in relationship to the surface of the photosphere [...]


Somewhere in the neighborhood of 1500 to 5000 kilometers above the photosphere, same as we figured out over a decade ago with some of the early data acquired by the TRACE satellite. We have observed it, measured it, and confirmed the measurements. It would require a severe ignorance of the last decade or more of solar research to believe otherwise.

I'm curious to know how deeply into the photosphere they are able to see.


About 400 to 500 kilometers. Given the density of the plasma, no light can penetrate from beyond that depth. It's fairly simple physics. People have been explaining it for years. It would require a severe ignorance of what's been going on in these forum discussions to not be aware of that.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom