W.D.Clinger
Philosopher
[latex]
\[
\mathbf{B} \cdot d \mathbf{S}
\]
[/latex]
\[
\mathbf{B} \cdot d \mathbf{S}
\]
[/latex]
It's just "flux".
You keep using that word. I do not think it means what you think it means.
It's just "flux".
[latex]
\[
\mathbf{B} \cdot d \mathbf{S}
\]
[/latex]
You keep using that word. I do not think it means what you think it means.
Nice try, but it's all propaganda, and not very well done even for that. You will find the phrase "toy model" is quite common in the physics literature (a quick look at ADS reveals 332 papers with the phrase "toy model" in their title; no telling how often it shows up buried in the text). A "toy model" is a model that everyone knows is oversimplified, but nobody cares.
I really can't believe you still don't know what magnetic reconnection is.
You seem to care Tim. Their "full" version is based on resistive MHD theory!Nice try, but it's all propaganda, and not very well done even for that. You will find the phrase "toy model" is quite common in the physics literature (a quick look at ADS reveals 332 papers with the phrase "toy model" in their title; no telling how often it shows up buried in the text). A "toy model" is a model that everyone knows is oversimplified, but nobody cares.
You evidently latched on to a single word, in this case "vacuum" and are trying to build a federal case *WITHOUT ANY SUPPORTING MATH!*
Unless and until you can produce a math that *ISN'T* based on MHD theory, you didn't support your claim.
That paper *IS* based upon MHD theory. Their TOY brand is therefore ALSO based on MHD theory according to you.
I don't care. But more to the point, you don't understand. The model presented in the paper is not based on MHD in any way. It is a pure vacuum reconnection model. No MHD. No plasma. All of your arguments to the contrary are falsified by facts.
In this review paper we discuss several aspects of magnetic reconnection theory, focusing on the field-line motions that are associated with reconnection. A new exact solution of the nonlinear MHD equations for reconnective annihilation is presented which represents a two-fold generalization of the previous solutions. Magnetic reconnection at null points by several mechanisms is summarized, including spine reconnection, fan reconnection and separator reconnection, where it is pointed out that two common features of separator reconnection are the rapid flipping of magnetic field lines and the collapse of the separator to a current sheet. In addition, a formula for the rate of reconnection between two flux tubes is derived.
Au contraire, mon ami. I have provided all of the relevant supporting math, which you will find here: Aspects of Three-Dimensional Magnetic Reconnection - (Invited Review); Priest & Schrijver, Solar Physics 19(1/2): 1-24, December 1999. Read it or don't, but I see no reason why I should go to the trouble of copying from there to here.
As I read this, by your own admission, you never even looked at the vacuum reconnection model presented by Priest & Schrijver, never even considered it at all, ignored it altogether.
All you need to see is that the paper is about plasma physics, and you simply assume that everything is plasma physics, even when the authors of the paper are explicit in saying it is a vacuum model.
I didn't fixate on the word "vacuum"; rather, that is the exact word used by the authors. So, why do you ignore it? Or maybe you now wish to accuse Priest & Schrijver of deliberately lying, claiming a vacuum model when the knew very well that it was not?
You allow your own blindfolding prejudice to show through too easily. You routinely deny the existence of things you can see right in front of you, rather than admit the truth.
In the case of MR in a vacuum those particles are called photons. The change in magnetic field topology means that the energy stored in the magnetic decreases. The release energy is in the form of light (photons).There's no release of stored EM energy without particles.
In the case of MR in a vacuum those particles are called photons. The change in magnetic field topology means that the energy stored in the magnetic decreases. The release energy is in the form of light (photons).
Oh dear - more ignoranceThey are FINALLY realizing that the coronal loops originate *UNDER* the photosphere and can be tracked up the SIDE of UMBRA!
...
.Now if I can just get them to describe the relationships between the filters, and the fact the iron ion line can be seen traversing the surface of the photosphere
Wow! You really repeat your ignorance and inability to understand what you read.Wow! The more I think about that presentation at LMSAL next week, the more I'm stoked and excited. It's about time that the mainstream finally acknowledges that the coronal loops TRAVERSE the surface of the photosphere and they are "lit up" and achieve million degree temperatures UNDER the surface of the photosphere. It's definitely progress IMO.
Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section VI (etc.)Somov's "vacuum" contains *PLASMA*.
I really can't believe this science hater is STILL in hardcore denial of the fact that plasma is optional in MR.I really can't believe the EU haters are STILL in hardcore denial of the fact that plasma is NOT optional in the 'reconnection' process. There can be no transfer of magnetic field energy into particle kinetic energy without particles! Get real!
!You are lying: We have produced several papers that mention magnetic reconnection in the absence of all plasma.That is why you cannot and never will produce a published paper on "magnetic reconnection" in the absence of all plasma.
Photons created from the energy released from the magnteic field!Photons from WHAT? You don't have a plasma particle to your name!
Emphasis mine. It's about TIME! They are FINALLY realizing that the coronal loops originate *UNDER* the photosphere and can be tracked up the SIDE of UMBRA!
Astronomers have been saying for decades that coronal loops originate *UNDER* the photosphere.
WOW! That's progress.
Here is a study of a coronal loop "best described as a flux rope" that starts below the photosphere where pressure makes it float upward. That means that the top of the loop starts to pokes out through the photosphere and so becomes visible (it is impossible to see light from below the photosphere). It continues to rise into the chromosphere.
Now if I can just get them to describe the relationships between the filters, and the fact the iron ion line can be seen traversing the surface of the photosphere, [...]
There is no "relationships between the filters". They are merely the filters that they decided to use to look at the loop:
The fact that FE ions can be detected on the the surface of the photosphere is because there are Fe atoms (0.16% by mass) in the photosphere which is hot enough to ionize them
- photospheric Si I 10827 AA line (silicon ionized once)
- chromospheric He I 10830 AA triplet (helium ionized once)
!
For example FeII forms at temperatures between 4000 K and 10,000 K.
[...] we can actually have a real conversation about solar satellite images. I wonder where they now place "solar moss" in relationship to the surface of the photosphere [...]
I'm curious to know how deeply into the photosphere they are able to see.