Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
The origins of electrical resistivity in magnetic reconnection (MR in vacuum)

The origins of electrical resistivity in magnetic reconnection: Studies by 2D and 3D macro particle simulations
"A gedanken experiment that illustrates the meaning of electrical
resistivity for magnetic reconnection (a) in vacuum, and (b) in a plasma
(dots represent plasma ions and electrons). The currents J1 and J2 flow
in the flux bundles, while J3 in the plasma does not exist initially and is
induced by the electric field Et during the reconnection process."
 
If there is CURRENT PRESENT it's got plasma RC.
How ignorant. If there is CURRENT PRESENT it's got a CURRENT PRESENT MM.
Your statement is as stupid as stating that "If there is CURRENT PRESENT it's got a wire" :eye-poppi!

BS. He claimed CURRENT was present in that "vacuum". Wake up. Current *IS NON-NEUTRAL PLASMA*.
BS. Somov stated that there were currents creating the magnetic fields. Notging to do with plasma.
Maxwell also stated in his equations that there are currents creating magnetic fields. There is no plasma in Maxwell's equations :eye-poppi.

Wake up to your delusion that Current *IS NON-NEUTRAL PLASMA*.
A current is a current. A NON-NEUTRAL PLASMA is a NON-NEUTRAL PLASMA. Somov's chapter has currents in it. The only mention of plasma is collisionless plasma at the end.

Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section VI (etc.)

BS. Been there, looked at them.
BS. You are obviously lying about reading them:
 
The The term DISCHARGE doesn't go away just because RC says so.
Once again you are lying.
I did not say that the term electrical discharge went away. It has been in use for centuries and is still in use :eye-poppi !

I stated that Dungey's 'electric discharge' = high current density in magnetic reconnection.


But this was in the 1960's and there is no evidence that Dungey's 'electric discharge' = high current density in magnetic reconnection is used today. Thus it is
  1. outdated and
  2. obsolete
You are continuing with the insanity of citing Dungey and contradicting your own assertion:
MM: Citing Dungey means that you are stating that the cause of solar flares is magnetic reconnection :jaw-dropp!
8th November 2011 (5 months and counting)
 
Last edited:
You've never personally cited one of them.
I never cited any of them because this is the first time that you have asked that specific question.

I expected that PIC simulations of MR would not use MHD and they do not (however ny Google skills deserted me before):
Geospace Environmental Modeling(GEM) Magnetic ReconnectionChallenge (PDF)
and in case you cannot read a PDF
Collisionless magnetic reconnectionin the presence of a guide field
Both an implicit particle-in-cell (PIC) simulation method and a parallel explicit PIC code are used.

(Google Scholar for "PIC magnetic reconnection simulation energy" has ~5,900 results)
 
That's trivial alright. That's not what happens in a flare. There's your equivocation fallacy in a nutshell.
That's dumb alright: A flare is not a vacuum! Linking to a proton flux graph is dumb because if there are protons then it is not MR in a vacuum.
There's your ignorance of basic reading skills in a nutshell.

MR in a vacuum is descibed in Cosmic plasma physics By Boris V. Somov
Quote:
Chapter 4. Motion of a Particle in a Field
4.4.2 Reconnection in a Vacuum.
X-type points consist a topological peculiarity of a magnetic field. They are places where where redistribution of magnetic fluxes occurs, which changes the connectivity of field lines. Let us illustrate such a process by the simplest example of 2 parallel electric currents of equal magnitude I in vacuum as shown in Figure 4.17. The magnetic field of these currents forms three different fluxes in the plane (x,y). Two of them belong to the upper and the lower currents, respectively, and are situated inside the separatrix field line A, which forms the figure of the eight-like curve with zeroth X-point. The third flux belongs to both currents and is situated outside of the separatrix.

If the currents are displaced in the direction of each other, then the following magnetic flux redistribution will take place. The currents proper fluxes will diminish by the quantity dA, while their common flux will increase by the same quantity. So the field line A2 will be the separatrix of the final state.

This process is realized as follows: Two field lines approach the X-point, merge there, forming a separatrix, and then they reconnect forming a field line which encloses both currents. Such a process us termed reconnection of field lines or magnetic reconenction. A2 is that last reconnect field line.

Magnetic reconnection is of fundamental importance for the nature of many non-stationary phenomena in cosmic plasma. We shall discuss the physics of this process more fully in chapters 16 to 22. Suffice it to say that reconnection is inevitable associated with electric field generation. The field is the inductive one, since
[equation 4.65]
where A is the vector potential of magnetic field,
[equation 4.66]
In the above example, the electric field is directed along the z axis. It is clear if that if dt is the characteristic time of the reconnection process shown in Figure 4.17 then according to (4.65)
[equation 4.67]
the last equality will be justified n Section 9.2

Reconnection in vacuum is a real physical process: magnetic field lines move to the X-type neutral point and reconnect in it as well as
| the electric field is induced and can accelerate a charge particle or
| particles in the vicinity of the neutral point.

MR in a vacuum is mentioned in the scientific literature:
MR in a vacuum is a simple derivation from Maxwell's equations: to W.D. Clinger's simple derivation of magnetic reconnection
 
Magnetic Reconnection: In Plasma and In Vacuo

And for two years now you've utterly ignored that paper by Mann and Onel that disprove your claim. Why is that?


See my post Onel & Mann, Circuits, and Real Plasma Physics, dated 9 Aprl 2011, where I cleverly ignore the Onel & Mann paper by examining it in detail, including a comparison with Alfven's boundary conditions, discussing the physics of the paper and the value of the circuit paradigm. So much for me "ignoring" the Onel & Mann paper.


But you're simply mislabeling several *DIFFERENT* things "magnetic reconnection", and failing to support your claim with *PUBLISHED* material that plasma is OPTIONAL Tim! How can I deal with that "scientifically"?


I have in fact supported my claim with several published references to magnetic reconnection in a vacuum. Here is a list of my posts on the topic, which the industrious reader may wish to peruse for the various references therein.


Of course, Mozina has vociferously insisted that all of the references I have provided are MHD based. All of his claims amount to wishful thinking and sub standard reading skills, and are all without a doubt quite false. In each and every case, without exception, the reconnection of magnetic fields is presented in a true vacuum, no MHD, no plasma, none whatsoever.

And I am certainly not by any means "mislabeling several *DIFFERENT* things" as magnetic reconnection. I am in fact consistent and present one and only one definition of magnetic reconnection; see my post Magnetic Reconnection defined and Described. All of my sources present the same definition of magnetic reconnection, albeit in different words, and it is the one and only definition I have used, which I will present here in my own words of the moment: A change in the topology of the magnetic field, changing the connectivity of the lines of force of the magnetic field. There is an important distinction to make here:


First you seem to be relabeling "magnetic flux change/time in a vacuum" = "magnetic reconnection". Then you're relabeling an INDUCEMENT OF CURRENT IN A PLASMA that results in an "electrical discharge" the EXACT SAME TERM! See a problem there Tim?


No, I don't see any problem. Mozina is the one who is confused, thinking that the presence of plasma & current are a requirement of magnetic reconnection.

I'm still waiting for a ligitimate PUBLISHED reference for 'reconnection' that generates any energy that isn't based upon MHD theory. It's never going to happen either. Without plasma, as Sweet points out, no currents are INDUCED in the plasma. It's just a flux change that has no real effect on any real particles because no real particles are present. MHD theory doesn't even apply! No ENERGY EXCHANGE can occur. No CHARGED PARTICLE ACCELERATION can occur. No currents can be generated, and no DISCHARGE occurs. You can't take plasma out and still call it 'reconnection'. It's just "flux changes" that induce no current. No magnetic energy can be converted to charged particle kinetic energy.


There is no such reference. Then again, why should it be a relevant point? Nobody is making the absurd claim that magnetic reconnection produces current in a vacuum! Look at the definition I gave in my own words above, confirmed by the sources in my post: A change in the topology of the magnetic field, changing the connectivity of the lines of force of the magnetic field. This process almost always results in the magnetic field transitioning from a higher to a lower energy state (there my be exceptional cases where the energy of the field does not change, but they are surely very strange and not important for this discussion). If that happens in a vacuum, there will be no current induced, no electricity, no "discharge", none of that. How could there be? It's a vacuum! Nobody ever made such a claim that I am aware of, and I most certainly never have. However, if that process happens in a plasma environment, then instead of the excess energy simply radiating away unnoticed to the vacuum, it goes into the plasma when the post reconnection magnetic field relaxes from higher to lower energy. Only then do we get currents and all of the nifty plasma physics that comes out of magnetic reconnection. Nobody writes papers about the magnetic field reconnecting & relaxing in a vacuum because it's a really boring thing that does nothing worth writing about. On the other hand, everybody wants to write papers about the reconnection of magnetic fields in a plasma because lots of really fascinating stuff happens in that case.

Let me be clear about this: Magnetic reconnection is a process whereby the topology of the magnetic field changes. That's its raw definition. I have never defined the post reconnection plasma physics as magnetic reconnection and nobody should; although it might appear to be so in colloquial usage between experts who know what they are talking about, it is certainly not a proper or formal definition.


Let's see the fallacy is yours, then, because you equate a change of flux with magnetic reconnection.
Boloney. Tim did that. He essentially claimed that any FLUX CHANGE = "magnetic reconnection" and the NULL isn't "special" at all.


I did associate a change in flux with magnetic reconnection, but I certainly did not claim that "any flux change = magnetic reconnection". Go back and look what I actually did say:

Any change in the topology of the magnetic flux is magnetic reconnection by definition. See my earlier post Magnetic Reconnection Defined and Described (24 January 2012). The terms "magnetic flux" and "magnetic field" are related to each other as shown by the passages below ...


Any old change won't do, only a change in the topology. In that post I also show the definition of magnetic flux as the surface integral of the magnetic field. In associating the magnetic flux with magnetic reconnection, I imagine a small unit area, a nearly infinitesimal circle perhaps, over which the flux is integrated. If the volume of magnetic field is sufficiently sampled by the unit area integral, you will have a volume representation of the flux. The flux at each area element will be a vector parallel to the normal vector to the surface, if the sampling surface is small enough. That volume representation of the flux should have a topology related to the topology of the field, and if the field topology changes, then so must the topology of the volume representation of the flux. I was trying to use flux in a manner akin to Mozina's without being technically incorrect and thought I had succeeded.

But in any case, it has to be stressed that in the end there is one and only one correct definition of magnetic reconnection and that is the change in topology of the magnetic field, which will of course produce plasma phenomena only in the presence of a plasma and never in a vacuum.
 
Oh, Sweet himself explained the difference quite clearly. He noted that WITHOUT PLASMA no CURRENTS would be INDUCED! That's the part you can't handle.

Apparently you wish to "dumb down" the process to the point that ANY magnetic field FLUX CHANGE ends up being relabeled "magnetic reconnection", with or without plasma, with or without MHD theory, with or without *PUBLISHED MATH*. Actually WITHOUT published math.

Well srcew my nipple nuts and send me to alaska!
No plasma means no currents??? whoddatoughtdat!!!!
I have no idea what I can't handle, but maybe it is your blatand lack of knowledge of basic electrodynamics, let alone plasma physics. Let's look at your next paragraph, where, as usual you are misusing clearly defined physical terms and try to sound important, but instead sound ridiculous.
Your claim that "any magnetic field flux change" ends up beling labeled "magnetic reconnection" is so weird, that I cannot even fathom it, let alone accept that you have ever actually read Alfvén's work.

Example: If I have a coil and I crank up the current in the coil the magnetic field will increase and thus the flux will increase. Reconnection does not come anywhere close to describing this, because it has nothing to do with reconnection, it has to do with changing flux.

However, to you flux and topology apparently are the same thing. I cannot help here, I can only say read some real books about electrodynamics and maybe at some point you will understand that flux and topology are not the same.

Essentially you want to discuss particle VELOCITY, even without particles. I hate to break it to you t, but MHD theory (including the resistive type) is all about the BEHAVIORS OF CHARGED PARTICLES. You can't ignore that relationship and dumb down a current driven *ELECTRICAL DISCHARGE* process to a simply "magnetic flux change". I won't let you.

And? MHD theory is all about the behaviors of charged particles. With them, currents can be induced by those flux changes. Without them, no currents, no discharges, no flares.

No, I am not talking about particles when I talk about a vacuum, I do have that much knowledge.
Yes, MDH is about magnetized fluids, I know that, I am not applying MHD to vacuum though, I apply a vacuum superposition. I do hope you know that Maxwell's equations also apply in vacuum.
Your nagging about MHD makes no sense when I or Tim or anyone else claim to look at a vacuum model or a vacuum superposition. Really, what part of the word vacuum don't you understand?

It means you side doesn't care one iota about math in the final analysis. All that math *INSISTS* that particles are involved in the DISCHARGE/RECONNECTION process. You're trying to DUMB IT DOWN. That's the fallacy in play. As Sweet himself (from *YOUR* reference) noted, no plasma, no induced current as a result of the field movement over time.

No, it does not do that at all, math doesn't, that is your interpretation only. Like the claims above from the post by RC by Priest: "In a vacuum, magnetic reconnection is a trival process..." And added to that it is also rather uninteresting, because nothing interesting happens. The field will, because of the lack of plasma, be potential fields, and just gradually move from one state to the other, when we, e.g. bring the two Sweet loops together.

There *AREN'T* any *LINES*. Even that is *DUMBED DOWN* representation of FULL FIELD INTERACTION. No individualized "lines" exist, certainly not in the ABSENCE OF PARTICLES.

Guess you never played with iron shavings and a bar magnet?
As you are always so fond of saying "the magnetic field is a continuum" or something like that, and indeed it is a vector field. The only way to find out how a vector field looks like is by using equipotentials, which in the case of the magnetic field are the magentic field lines. No, they are not real, like said before, they are as real as height contours on a map. However, they play an important role in showing the topology of the magnetic field and they are also very useful to show the dynamics of the magnetic field. Therefore, though not real physical objects, they are useful.
They are, actually, as real as your resistor and capacitor and inductor in your circuit representation of a coronal loop.

Boloney. Tim did that. He essentially claimed that any FLUX CHANGE = "magnetic reconnection" and the NULL isn't "special" at all.

Boloney. The one thing Clinger actually did demonstrate is that in terms of Gauss's law, it's NOT SPECIAL IN ANY WAY! The laws are satisfied there like everywhere. Since magnetic fields have no source and no sink, they don't "disconnect", nor do they "reconnect". The only thing they do is "flux" and thereby INDUCE CURRENT in a CONDUCTOR.

No, you are confusing flux and induction with reconnection.

The magnetic null is special (in my opinion) because that is where the magnetic field has zero value and no direction: B = (0, 0, 0).

And really "the only thing they do is flux", can you please explain in full detail what you mean when you say that fields "flux." Flux is not a verb, it is a noun in physics.

No, it's not "magic". He moved BOTH FIELDS. Of course the Null moves accordingly. DUH! As Sweet points out however, no plasma, no induced current, and oh, no MHD theory.

So what, "he moves both fields" and how exactly is the null to move and please give a full description with drawings etc. like clinger did to show you are right.
An of course no MHD, you keep on hitting a dead horse, Mikey, it is only you who seems to have problems about when and when not MDH can be or is applied.

So what if they and Sweet "superimpose" the magnetic fields into a vacuum? The movement of the fields INDUCES current according to Sweet. The lack of any plasmas will result in NO INDUCED current and no flare.

So what? That does that do in the absence of plasma, particularly at a NULL? Nothing! The movement of the WHOLE FIELDS will induce current EVERYWHERE, not just some magic place. The more the field changes in some place or another, the more INDUCED CURRENT will occur, ONLY IN A CONDUCTOR!

No, movement of fields, in a vacuum or in a non-conducting atmosphere induce electric fields (as in the case when plasma is present, you know curl E ~ dB/dt), which however will not generate currents as there are no particles to carry the current.

As long as you cannot do electrodynamics in a vacuum (is like 1st year college stuff) then you are definitely not going to be able to do actual MHD, let along plasma physics.

Ya, it gets "fun" because the currents flow and then MHD theory actually applies. No particles, no velocities to talk about, no induced current, no energy transfer to charged particles as a result of WHOLE FIELD CHANGES.

And there can be energy stored in a system, when there is a plasma, unlike in vacuum where there is only the magnetic energy of the field, moving from one potential to another.

But Sweet sank your ship t. He specifically REQUIRED plasma and current to explain it, and specifically points out that it *WON'T INDUCE CURRENT* in a vacuum! He specifically REFUTES your claim!

I can see I'm going to have to stop by at least once or twice a week to see if any of you actually come up with a PUBLISHED reference to support this nonsense. Thus far, Sweet disproved everything you're claiming because he specifically cited the problem. He specifically noted that for currents to be INDUCED, current (a conductor) MUST be present.

Still waiting for a published paper that supports your claim t. Sweet *DESTROYED* your argument, he didn't help it.

The offhand rejection of any books and papers that talk about vacuum superposition and reconnection, just because in your mind there must be currents flowing, clearly shows that you are not willing whatsoever even to actually think about basic electrodynamics.

Of course it's based on "resistive" MHD because plasmas are NOT perfect conductors. The plasma particles have a PROPERTY of resistance, just like they have a property of being affected by EM fields and they have a property of behaving like a fluid in large numbers. All the properties are represented in RESISTIVE MHD theory, whereas the original brand is missing an important BEHAVIOR of plasma. It does become unstable in the presence of large currents, and "resistive" to that current.

The thing is, that MRx is actually not based on MDH, it is a fully plasmaphysical process and MHD, even resistive MDH is only an approximation of actual plasmaphysics. That is why I said that in my claim about the Sweet paper, because he would not have used MDH, but real plasma physics, as at the time that that paper was written the use of MHD was not ubiquitous.

One interesting thing is that these plasma particle, with their property of being affected by EM fields in the neighbourhood of the X-line are no longer affected by the magnetic field. First the ions decouple from the field and then the electrons decouple, creating the ion and electron diffusion regions. The claim of the EU/PU/EC/ES/PC proponents always comes back to that the charged particles are greatly affected by the magnetic fields and such, however, this is not always the case. There is a certain important quantity, usually called the plasma-beta, which determines what behaviour is more important, to say it simplified: the gas part or the frozen in part.
 
Y
BS. He claimed CURRENT was present in that "vacuum". Wake up. Current *IS NON-NEUTRAL PLASMA*.

Oh Michael, how often do we have to go through this basic plasma physics or for I care basic MHD?

Current is not a non-neutral plasma. Once more, but you finally should try to remember this, in plasma physics / MHD, neutrality is defined by the total charge density ρc being zero:

[latex]
rho_c = \Sigma_k n_k q_k = 0,
[/latex]

where nk and qk are the number density and charge of particle species k and k runs over all species of ions and electrons.

Now an electric current in a plasma is defined in the following way:

[latex]
{\bf j} = \Sigma_k n_k q_k {\bf v}_k
[/latex]

where vk is the velocity of species k.

Now, please explain why if there is a current j that the plasma needs be non-neutral?

And to quote from your non-neutral link:

wiki said:
Non-neutral plasma

The strength and range of the electric force and the good conductivity of plasmas usually ensure that the densities of positive and negative charges in any sizeable region are equal ("quasineutrality"). A plasma with a significant excess of charge density, or, in the extreme case, is composed of a single species, is called a non-neutral plasma. In such a plasma, electric fields play a dominant role. Examples are charged particle beams, an electron cloud in a Penning trap and positron plasmas.

Wow, this has absolutely nothing to do with a quasi-neutral plasma with a current. (ofcourse we remember that your definition of neutral is not the usual definition of neutral as given in the equation above, but that is yet another example of you using perfectly defined physics terms in a different way. Fluxing isn't it?)
 
Oh Michael, how often do we have to go through this basic plasma physics or for I care basic MHD?

Current is not a non-neutral plasma. Once more, but you finally should try to remember this, in plasma physics / MHD, neutrality is defined by the total charge density ρc being zero:

Who cares? It's not WITHOUT PLASMA! You folks can't talk about particle species and particle velocity because CLINGER doesn't have particles in the first place! Somov's work does NOT support Clinger's outrageously FALSE claim. I have one of Somov's books on plasma physics. RC doesn't. He (and now you) are ignoring the fact that to have CURRENT you need CHARGED PARTICLES. Somov's vacuum contains PARTICLES.
 
Last edited:
Who cares? It's not WITHOUT PLASMA! You folks can't talk about particle species and particle velocity because CLINGER doesn't have particles in the first place! Somov's work does NOT support Clinger's outrageously FALSE claim. I have one of Somov's books on plasma physics. RC doesn't. He (and now you) are ignoring the fact that to have CURRENT you need CHARGED PARTICLES. Somov's vacuum contains PARTICLES.


As usual, that isn't an argument. It's a complaint about failing to understand an argument. And as always, that strategy will never result in success.
 
As usual, that isn't an argument. It's a complaint about failing to understand an argument. And as always, that strategy will never result in success.

My big complaint is that you all blatantly FAIL to embrace PHYSICAL fact. Unlike Clinger's vacuum, Somov's 'vacuum' and maths (like every other reference you've cited) *INCLUDES PHYSICAL CURRENT, PARTICLES, and PHYSICAL PARTICLE MOVEMENT! No particles, no "reconnection/electrical discharge".

The EU hater denial-go-round is never ending around here.
 
Last edited:
See my post Onel & Mann, Circuits, and Real Plasma Physics, dated 9 Aprl 2011, where I cleverly ignore the Onel & Mann paper by examining it in detail, including a comparison with Alfven's boundary conditions, discussing the physics of the paper and the value of the circuit paradigm. So much for me "ignoring" the Onel & Mann paper.

Ya, but note you still won't accept the mathematical legitimacy of the CIRCUIT orientation to these very same events Tim. You see one orientation B as always being superior (you're sort of Alfven's alter ego) and refusing to embrace BOTH sides (like Alfven).

I have in fact supported my claim with several published references to magnetic reconnection in a vacuum. Here is a list of my posts on the topic, which the industrious reader may wish to peruse for the various references therein.

You NEVER PROVIDED EVEN *TOY* math! I guess your "best" attempt to address the fact they used MHD THEORY in the end was based on THIS one paragraph:

Paragraph 1
"We have constructed a toy model for vacuum reconnection driven by the motion of photospheric sources and have presented the results in the accompanying CD-ROM. We calculate the potential magnetic field due to two, three or four sources in the solar surface and then extend it to a many-source case in which the surrounding fields generally limit the motions of the field lines in response to the footpoint motions to much smaller amplitudes than in the few-source case. The sources are slowly moved around and we assume that the field remains potential. Although this is an oversimplified model, the resulting motion of the field lines is instructive and it is a useful preliminary for the resistive MHD numerical model that we are planning to undertake."

You've utterly *IGNORED* the fact that they are championing a resistive MHD *REAL* model, and you've never personally provided ANY math related to the TOY version. Get a grip! If their REAL version is base on MHD theory, their papers doesn't support your claim. If you've provided any MATHS on the TOY BRAND, I've yet to see it. Maybe I missed it?

The rest of your links look to be related to this one paper, and/or the same "magnetic flux change in a vacuum" = "reconnection" equivocation fallacy. You're utterly ignoring the fact that as Sweet mentioned, no conductive environment, no electrical current.

Where's the TOY MATH? I guess that's the whole basis of your argument and I've never even SEEN that math from you. Like I said, maybe I missed it.

Of course, Mozina has vociferously insisted that all of the references I have provided are MHD based.

The are, including the paper in question. Did you not see the line about RESISTIVE MHD theory Tim?

All of his claims amount to wishful thinking and sub standard reading skills, and are all without a doubt quite false. In each and every case, without exception, the reconnection of magnetic fields is presented in a true vacuum, no MHD, no plasma, none whatsoever.

Boloney. The paper in question is based on MHD theory Tim. We're evidently now arguing about the meaning of "toy model".

All of my sources present the same definition of magnetic reconnection, albeit in different words,

Ya, and different maths, including resistive MHD theory. I don't recall seeing any resistive MHD equations in Clinger's work.

and it is the one and only definition I have used, which I will present here in my own words of the moment: A change in the topology of the magnetic field, changing the connectivity of the lines of force of the magnetic field.

Your entire argument is one giant equivocation fallacy. You've essentially turned *ANY* sort of "flux change" into "reconnection". That's not "reconnection", that's only the *FIRST STEP* in a process that *REQUIRES* the *INDUCEMENT OF CURRENT* and an "electrical discharge/reconnection" of that current.
 
Last edited:
I never cited any of them because this is the first time that you have asked that specific question.

I expected that PIC simulations of MR would not use MHD and they do not (however ny Google skills deserted me before):
Geospace Environmental Modeling(GEM) Magnetic ReconnectionChallenge (PDF)
and in case you cannot read a PDF
Collisionless magnetic reconnectionin the presence of a guide field


(Google Scholar for "PIC magnetic reconnection simulation energy" has ~5,900 results)

Let me highlight the relevant PHYSICS for you:

The results of kinetic simulations of magnetic reconnection in Harris current sheets are analyzed. A range of guide fields is considered to study reconnection in plasmas characterized by different β values, β>me/mi. Both an implicit particle-in-cell (PIC) simulation method and a parallel explicit PIC code are used. Simulations with mass ratios up to the physical value are performed.

What part of "current sheets" *IN PLASMAS* and MASS RATIOS don't you understand? Wow! I've never seen such a LAME attempt at supporting such a RIDICULOUS claim in my life.

Folks, get REAL! Plasma is not "optional' in the 'reconnection" process. As Sweet *ELOQUENTLY* explained, you NEED a conductive environment to INDUCE current in that environment as a result of the field changes. The conductor and the physics isn't optional. The current doesn't flow without a conductor when the fields change. The fields just FLUX/MOVE/CHANGE and nothing happens. Wow!
 
Last edited:
Michael, the reason people are talking about reconnection in a vacuum is that YOU stated it couldn't happen in a vacuum. We're trying to get you to understand what reconnection is.

The fact that it causes interesting effects in a plasma doesn't mean plasma is required for reconnection.
 
Michael, the reason people are talking about reconnection in a vacuum is that YOU stated it couldn't happen in a vacuum. We're trying to get you to understand what reconnection is.

The fact that it causes interesting effects in a plasma doesn't mean plasma is required for reconnection.

I own, have read, and I've pretty reasonably understood at least 5 books now on *PLASMA PHYSICS*. Many (all?) of them describe the "reconnection" process in plasma. In addition, I've read HUNDREDS of papers on the topic of RECONNECTION based upon MHD theory and MHD maths. What I have NEVER seen *PUBLISHED* is anything that REMOTELY supports your claim.

Got it? Yes or no?

I know what RECONNECTION is. You don't. Plasma isn't optional in the 'reconnection" process, and not one paper you've cited claims otherwise.
 
I own, have read, and I've pretty reasonably understood at least 5 books now on *PLASMA PHYSICS*. Many (all?) of them describe the "reconnection" process in plasma. In addition, I've read HUNDREDS of papers on the topic of RECONNECTION based upon MHD theory and MHD maths. What I have NEVER seen *PUBLISHED* is anything that REMOTELY supports your claim.

That's like saying you've read lots of books on fish, and none of them claim gills are optional, so breathing outside of water is impossible.

Got it? Yes or no?

I know what RECONNECTION is. You don't. Plasma isn't optional in the 'reconnection" process, and not one paper you've cited claims otherwise.

Clearly, you are the one who doesn't get it.

Please, explain what happens with the magnetic field lines of two permanent magnets when their opposing poles are brought together. Without plasma.
 
Please, explain what happens with the magnetic field lines of two permanent magnets when their opposing poles are brought together. Without plasma.
OMG! They *FLUX*!


(Sorry. Couldn't hold it in).
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom