Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
They are FINALLY realizing that the coronal loops originate *UNDER* the photosphere and can be tracked up the SIDE of UMBRA! WOW!

Really! The fact that you seem to think that mainstream does not know that coronal loops come from inside the Sun shows clearly that you have not got the foggiest idea about mainstream solar physics. Not that we are suprised.
 
You keep trying to tap dance around the point. :) Somov's "vacuum" contains *PLASMA*. Get a grip. Get RC to get a grip.

IMO the mainstream keep ignoring the physics! It's not JUST about math, it's also about the PHYSICAL PARTICLES that do the work!

Oh, yeah, I guess Somov is a real idiot, that he writes "vacuum" but means "plasma", it is a mistake that happens often. So let's quote from Somov's book Plasma Astrophysics - Part 2: Reconnection and Flares, chapter 1.1.2

Somov said:
1.1.2 Reconnection in vacuum
The X-type points constitute the most important topological peculiarity of a magnetic field. They are the places where redistribution of magnetic fluxes occurs, which changes the connectivity of field lines. Let us illustrate such a process by the simplest example of two parallel electric currents I of equal magnitude I in vacuum as shown in Figure 1.3.

Naturally MM will say "hey there are currents so there must be plasma" and the answer would be a resounding NO as the two currents in Figure 1.3 can just be two copper wires with the current flowing through them, which makes sense because Somov is talking about vacuum

He then continues:

Somov said:
The magnetic field of these currents forms three different fluxes in the plane (x, y). Two of them belong to the upper and the lower currents, respectively, and are situated inside the separatrix field line A1 which forms the eight-like curve with a zeroth X-point. The third flux situated outside this curve belongs to both currents and is situated outside the separatrix. If the currents are displaced in the direction of each other, then the following redistribution of a magnetic flux will take place. The current’s proper fluxes will diminish by the quantity δA (shown by two shadowed rings in Figure 1.3a), while their common flux will increase by the same quantity (shown by the shadowed area in Figure 1.3b), So the field line A2 will be the separatrix of the final state.

This process is realized as follows. Two field lines approach the X-point, merge there, forming a separatrix, and then they reconnect forming a field line which encloses both currents. Such a process is termed reconnection of field lines or magnetic reconnection. A2 is the last reconnected field line.
Magnetic reconnection is of fundamental importance for the nature of many non-stationary phenomena in astrophysical plasma. We shall discuss the physics of this process more fully in Chapters 2 to 14. Suffice it to note that reconnection is inevitably associated with electric field generation. This field is the inductive one, since:

[latex]
{\bf E} = - c^{-1} \frac{\partial {\bf A}}{\partial t} ~~~ (1.2)
[/latex]

where A is the vector potential of magnetic field,

[latex]
{\bf B} = {\rm curl} {\bf A} ~~~(1.3)
[/latex]

In the above example the electric field is directed along the z axis. It is
clear that, if δt is the characteristic time of the reconnection process shown
in Figure 1.3, then according to (1.2)

[latex]
E \approx \frac{1}{c} \frac{\partial A}{\partial t} \approx \frac{1}{c} \frac{A_2 - A_1}{\patial t} ~~~(1.4)
[/latex]

the last equality is justified in vol. 1, Section 14.2.
Reconnection in vacuum is a real physical process: magnetic
field lines move to the X-type neutral point and reconnect in it as well as

the electric field is induced and can accelerate a charged particle or
particles in the vicinity of the neutral point.


In this sense, a collisionless reconnection – the physical process in a hightemperature rarefied plasma such as the solar corona, geomagnetic tail, fusion plasmas, and so on – is simpler for understanding than reconnection in a highly-conducting collisional space plasma.

Then the next section of Somov's book is called:

1.1.3 Reconnection in plasma

So, either Somov and I are crazy, or it really is the case that in section 1.1.2 there is vacuum and no plasma or MM is right and Somov and I do not understand what is written in this book.
 
Really! The fact that you seem to think that mainstream does not know that coronal loops come from inside the Sun shows clearly that you have not got the foggiest idea about mainstream solar physics. Not that we are suprised.

Unfortunately your side thinks those current carrying, Bennett pinch coronal loops come up "cold" and get magically heated up to millions of degrees somewhere in the "transition region", 1200KM *ABOVE* the photosphere. What a bunch of baloney. Those loops are "lit up" and operating at a million plus degrees *BEFORE* they even exit the photosphere! They are visible LONG before they reach the surface of the photosphere in MANY different wavelengths, including 171A, 193A, 284A, and all the other iron ion wavelengths, as well as silicon ion wavelengths.
 
Last edited:
Oh, yeah, I guess Somov is a real idiot, that he writes "vacuum" but means "plasma", it is a mistake that happens often. So let's quote from Somov's book Plasma Astrophysics - Part 2: Reconnection and Flares, chapter 1.1.2

Originally Posted by Somov
1.1.2 Reconnection in vacuum
The X-type points constitute the most important topological peculiarity of a magnetic field. They are the places where redistribution of magnetic fluxes occurs, which changes the connectivity of field lines. Let us illustrate such a process by the simplest example of two parallel electric currents I of equal magnitude I in vacuum as shown in Figure 1.3.

Emphasis mine. Notice that Somov understands the difference between "magnetic fluxes" and the PROCESS he calls "reconnection" which REQUIRES those "currents", AKA *PLASMA PARTICLES*!

OMG. I'm utterly stunned that you can't tell the difference between FLUX and RECONNECTION. Wow! You really should reread Somov's work. You need to listen to the part where he *ADDS CURRENT* to his "flux" to achieve 'reconnection". You evidently missed the part where he adds plasma to get "reconnection" rather than "magnetic fluxes" that do absolutely nothing by themselves. Without particles added to the vacuum, nothing happens. "Reconnection" requires *PARTICLES*.
 
You are lying: We have produced several papers that mention magnetic reconnection in the absence of all plasma.
Only someone truly ignorant of science would think that scientific papers would cover MR in the absence of all plasma. That is a trivial and well established process covered in textbooks, e.g. Somov's textbook.

You and GM are the two SLEAZIEST debators I've ever met in cyberspace. People who disagree with you are not necessarily "lying". In fact in this case the only liar is you, and you're only lying to yourself. All Somov got from his CURRENTLESS vacuum was "magnetic flux". He achieves "reconnection" by adding two CURRENTS, composed of MOVING CHARGED *PARTICLES*. Your LIE begins with an equivocation fallacy. Magnetic flux in a vacuum is *NOT* "reconnection". Reconnection requires CURRENT and particle acceleration! Somov is able to differentiate between "magnetic fluxes" and the PROCESS that he calls "reconnection' that involves *TWO CURRENTS* which he placed into that "vacuum".
 
Last edited:
OMG. I've seen DENIAL based behaviors in my life, but EU haters have taken that process to a whole new level. Somov CLEARLY notes that all he achieves is "magnetic fluxes" in his "vacuum" prior to introducing CURRENTS/PLASMA to that 'vacuum" to achieve 'reconnection' involving PARTICLES and PARTICLE ACCELERATION. RC doesn't even OWN a book by Somov!
 
Oh dear - more ignorance :eye-poppi.

Astronomers have been saying for decades that coronal loops originate *UNDER* the photosphere.

Ya, at relatively *COLD* temperatures of LESS THAN A MILLION DEGREES! They seem to think the loops get "heated up" in some magic "transition region' 1200KM above the photosphere where they suddenly go from a few thousand degrees in temperature up to a million plus degrees. That's just ABSURD! The loops are CURRENT CARRYING BENNETT PINCHES in plasma. They are radiating at a million plus degrees BEFORE they even exit the photosphere.
 
Last edited:
Indeed. The term "photosphere" has a pretty simple definition which necessarily requires it to be opaque.

The term "opaque" doesn't even mean what you claim it means. Even with three "opaque" socks over a flashlight lens, it's possible to see a light shine though all three "opaque" socks.


Again really. There's a fairly fundamental reason particular filters have been selected for acquiring the satellite images. It has to do with observing thermal characteristics at various levels in the solar atmosphere.

Well, that is about the only thing you got right.

And we know we're viewing those particular levels because being a sphere, the Sun provides us the luxury of making those observations at the limb.

Ya, and I counted all those pixels at the limb in the first light SDO composite images that show the "transition region" in relationship to the photosphere/chromosphere boundary. It's 4800KM *UNDER* the surface of the photosphere!

http://www.thesurfaceofthesun.com/images/sdo/447006main_fulldiskmulticolor-orig_new1_full.jpg

sd01.jpg


You're clueless about even the process the creates the COLOR in this image, not to mention the light source. "Discharges? What discharges?" Oy Vey.
 
Michael Mozina said:
The term "opaque" doesn't even mean what you claim it means. Even with three "opaque" socks over a flashlight lens, it's possible to see a light shine though all three "opaque" socks.
Pure gold.
Indeed.

Someone should start collecting these; in a distilled form they might even be as dangerous as knives; you know, death by laughter ...
 
Ya, and I counted all those pixels at the limb in the first light SDO composite images that show the "transition region" in relationship to the photosphere/chromosphere boundary. It's 4800KM *UNDER* the surface of the photosphere!
One wonders why NASA isn't aware of this astounding new discovery using their own data.
 
No. None of the images are hidden are they? They published that first light image didn't they? What conspiracy?
Sigh. So why aren't they trumpeting this astounding new discovery? Why are we only hearing about it from you?
 
Sigh. So why aren't they trumpeting this astounding new discovery?

What "new discovery"? I've already been talking about it for almost 7 years now. I even PLACED the location of that "transition region" CORRECTLY based on Kosovichev's 'stratification subsurface" findings at around 4800KM. The SDO images worked out to something like 4832KM +- 1200KM as I recall.

Why are we only hearing about it from you?

Beat's me. Didn't you read Kosovichev's stratification subsurface paper?

http://arxiv.org/abs/astro-ph/0510111
 
What "new discovery"? I've already been talking about it for almost 7 years now. I even PLACED the location of that "transition region" CORRECTLY based on Kosovichev's 'stratification subsurface" findings at around 4800KM. The SDO images worked out to something like 4832KM +- 1200KM as I recall.



Beat's me. Didn't you read Kosovichev's stratification subsurface paper?

http://arxiv.org/abs/astro-ph/0510111
Quit dodging. Why isn't NASA aware of your amazing analysis of their imagery? Are you seriously suggesting that they agree with you? Careful now.
 
You and GM are the two SLEAZIEST debators I've ever met in cyberspace. People who disagree with you are not necessarily "lying". In fact in this case the only liar is you, and you're only lying to yourself. All Somov got from his CURRENTLESS vacuum was "magnetic flux". He achieves "reconnection" by adding two CURRENTS, composed of MOVING CHARGED *PARTICLES*.

You misunderstood that completely.

There were no magnetic fields at all until the current was added, the current is the source of the field, not the cause of reconnection. The currents could be a pair of wires in a vacuum, no plasma is required.

Your LIE begins with an equivocation fallacy. Magnetic flux in a vacuum is *NOT* "reconnection". Reconnection requires CURRENT and particle acceleration! Somov is able to differentiate between "magnetic fluxes" and the PROCESS that he calls "reconnection' that involves *TWO CURRENTS* which he placed into that "vacuum".

YOUR lie begins with a strawman. No one is saying that flux is reconnection. In fact we've pointed out to you many times exactly what flux and reconnection are, and it's clear no one here is confusing them except you.

Reconnection does not require current or particle acceleration. He uses current because the field around a current carrying wire is the simplest example possible.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom