Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
You misunderstood that completely.

There were no magnetic fields at all until the current was added, the current is the source of the field, not the cause of reconnection.

No. It's both the source of the field *AND* the "cause" of "reconnection". The "reconnection" process is possible *ONLY* because of the presence of charged PARTICLES in that vacuum. As Sweet pointed out for us, the CONDUCTIVE ENVIRONMENT is REQUIRED in order for that magnetic flux change to induce any CURRENTS, or cause any particle acceleration. You can't take the PHYSICS out of the MHD equations. They all relate to the BEHAVIORS of plasma.
 
Last edited:
Reconnection does not require current or particle acceleration.

You folks have *NEVER* provided a PUBLISHED paper or book to corroborate that RIDICULOUS claim.

He uses current because the field around a current carrying wire is the simplest example possible.

He uses CURRENT because it's "not optional" in the "reconnection" process. The particle acceleration is a PROCESS that is CAUSED by the 'flux changes'.
 
Michael, I'll ask again. What happens to the magnetic field lines when two permanent magnets are brought together?
 
So no reconnection?

The terms "twisting and bending" came directly from the website where PS found his original magnet images. They apply to the WHOLE FIELD interactions extremely accurately. There aren't even individualized "lines" without "particles", just "whole continuous fields". There are no discrete "lines" to "disconnect" from, nor "reconnect to" any other "lines".
 
So you don't know what magnetic field lines are. That's not surprising I guess.
 
So you don't know what magnetic field lines are. That's not surprising I guess.

When you add "pieces of matter" into the mix, you can indeed create "discrete lines". Without matter however, all you end up with is a "twisting and bending of whole continuous fields". There's no induced current without matter, and no discrete "lines" without matter as you imagine in your overly simplistic understanding of whole field interactions. Even the notion of a "line" is a gross oversimplification that is just a "handy concept" in terms of mathematics. The concept of individualized lines is more 'useful' once you apply MHD theory because you now have MATTER to work with, discrete current streams to work with, etc. Currents can now be induced as a result of the twisting and bending of the fields and stored magnetic field energy can be transferred into particle kinetic energy.

Without matter, no "reconnection' is possible, and no discrete "lines" actually exist. There are just two FIELDS that 'twist and bend' and no stored magnetic field energy is converted into particle kinetic energy.
 
When you add "pieces of matter" into the mix, you can indeed create "discrete lines". Without matter however, all you end up with is a "twisting and bending of whole continuous fields". There's no induced current without matter, and no discrete "lines" without matter as you imagine in your overly simplistic understanding of whole field interactions. Even the notion of a "line" is a gross oversimplification that is just a "handy concept" in terms of mathematics. The concept of individualized lines is more 'useful' once you apply MHD theory because you now have MATTER to work with, discrete current streams to work with, etc. Currents can now be induced as a result of the twisting and bending of the fields and stored magnetic field energy can be transferred into particle kinetic energy.

Without matter, no "reconnection' is possible, and no discrete "lines" actually exist. There are just two FIELDS that 'twist and bend' and no stored magnetic field energy is converted into particle kinetic energy.


Wrong, matter has nothing to do with magnetic field lines other than to make them visible. A magnetic field is continuous, yes. It is not built of lines. But at the same time, there are an infinite number of lines.

A field line is a path through space that follows the direction of the magnetic field. Pick any point in the field, follow the direction of the field at that point an infinitesimal amount, and repeat from the new location. You will end up tracing a magnetic field line in a loop that ends up back where you started.

When two permanent magnets are far apart, the field lines remain separate, such that a line started from the pole of one magnet will loop around to the opposite pole of the same magnet. When you bring them together to form one bigger magnet, the fields merge in such a way that the lines come together at a null point, and swap connectivity, so that the line that was looping through one magnet joins with a line from the other magnet, forming a new loop that passes through both. That is the simplest example of reconnection, and it requires no plasma or charged particles (other than the ones making up the atoms of the magnets).
 
Wrong, matter has nothing to do with magnetic field lines other than to make them visible. A magnetic field is continuous, yes. It is not built of lines.

We seemed to be in agreement to this point, but...

But at the same time, there are an infinite number of lines.

Your concept of individualized lines have no "real" meaning without PHYSICAL expression. They are just two WHOLE CONTINUOUS FIELDS that twist and bend. Whatever cross sections you take are meaningless without physical particles in terms of their effect on "reality". It's just a mathematical handy tool *DEVOID* of physical meaning.

The discrete physical kinetic energy transfer unit in MHD theory is the CHARGED PARTICLE. It has a specific shape and size and mass. MHD theory applies to CHARGED particles and describes the behaviors of charged particles. It's therefore meaningful in MHD theory to talk about the 'reconnection' of physical things.

Without PHYSICS however, all you end up with is twisting and bending of two WHOLE CONTINUOUS FIELDS, and no transfer of magnetic field energy into particle kinetic energy (reconnection/discharge). There cannot be a transfer of stored magnetic field energy into particle kinetic energy as described in MHD theory until and unless you add plasma.
 
Last edited:
Transfer of energy to charged particles is NOT reconnection, it is the effect of fields moving in the presence of charged particles.

Why did you ignore the rest of my post? Do you agree that lines reconnect with permanent magnets?

I find it funny that up until recently, YOU were the one obsessed with lines being continuous and not having a source or sink. YOU made a big deal about them not being able to reconnect because they would have to break first (your own strawman). YOU started this line of conversation by denying basic facts of magnetism. But you won't even try to explain how you get from two fields to one field, without plasma, without lines reconnecting.
 
Transfer of energy to charged particles is NOT reconnection, it is the effect of fields moving in the presence of charged particles.

Yes, Sweet noted that a CONDUCTOR was necessary to induce current.

Why did you ignore the rest of my post?

Because it didn't seem relevant to the main point.

Do you agree that lines reconnect with permanent magnets?

I have ALREADY agreed in this thread that "magnet reconnection" occurs when you RECONNECT the PHYSICAL MAGNETS, and H lines "reconnect" accordingly. I've also explained that without TOUCHING THEM TOGETHER, all you get is a "twisting and bending" of WHOLE CONTINUOUS FIELDS, not overly-simplified "lines" as you imagine them. What more can I offer you on that topic?

I find it funny that up until recently, YOU were the one obsessed with lines being continuous and not having a source or sink.

If you mean I'm "obsessed with *PUBLISHED* physical FACT, sure. Magnetic fields are CREATED by CURRENT and the movement of charged particles. That is published fact. It's also published fact that magnetic fields lines have no source and no sink. That too is PUBLISHED fact. Clingers claims about B lines "beginning" somewhere or "ending" somewhere is utterly bogus nonsense. Nothing of the sort is PHYSICALLY possible. That is *PUBLISHED* fact.

All you guys have is one website that destroys it's own claim. All Clinger demonstrated is that in spite of his original claim, the NULL point is *NOT* special in terms of satisfying Guass's laws, and no lines "begin" there!

YOU made a big deal about them not being able to reconnect because they would have to break first (your own strawman).

You're starting with an oversimplification fallacy. There are no PHYSICAL "lines" without PARTICLES! There are just WHOLE CONTINUOUS FIELDS that interact with each other, CONTINUOUSLY, EVERYWHERE.

YOU started this line of conversation by denying basic facts of magnetism.

Not me. Your side did that the moment they claimed that B lines "begin" somewhere. I must have posted two dozen published references that demonstrate that claims is FALSE! I've explained that CONTINUOUS magnetic fields are caused by the movement of CHARGED PARTICLES.

But you won't even try to explain how you get from two fields to one field, without plasma, without lines reconnecting.

There are two whole fields until you physically and literally RECONNECT the physical magnets. That that point you've RECONNECTED the PHYSICAL THINGS that can 'reconnect'. The H lines "reconnect" inside the magnet where they touch. The B "lines" were never actually discrete "lines" to begin with, but the whole FIELDS join and become one when you RECONNECT the PHYSICAL magnets. What more is there to explain? We've been through this a dozen or more times now.
 
Last edited:
You're clueless about even the process the creates the COLOR in this image, not to mention the light source.
You are delusional about even the process the creates the COLOR in this image, not to mention being totally ignorant about the light source.
The light source is the Sun!

The SDO image"green line" is a processing artifact as confirmed by the NASA team.
You keep on embarrassing yourself by persisting with this delusion abut this public relations image.
But this is not unexpected because you have similar delusions about other images, e.g.
 
Last edited:
I've also explained that without TOUCHING THEM TOGETHER, all you get is a "twisting and bending" of WHOLE CONTINUOUS FIELDS, not overly-simplified "lines" as you imagine them. What more can I offer you on that topic?

<snip>

It's also published fact that magnetic fields lines have no source and no sink. That too is PUBLISHED fact. Clingers claims about B lines "beginning" somewhere or "ending" somewhere is utterly bogus nonsense. Nothing of the sort is PHYSICALLY possible. That is *PUBLISHED* fact. <snip>All you guys have is one website that destroys it's own claim. All Clinger demonstrated is that in spite of his original claim, the NULL point is *NOT* special in terms of satisfying Guass's laws, and no lines "begin" there!

<snip>

There are two whole fields until you physically and literally RECONNECT the physical magnets. That that point you've RECONNECTED the PHYSICAL THINGS that can 'reconnect'. The H lines "reconnect" inside the magnet where they touch. The B "lines" were never actually discrete "lines" to begin with, but the whole FIELDS join and become one when you RECONNECT the PHYSICAL magnets. What more is there to explain? We've been through this a dozen or more times now.

Maybe I'm misinterpreting you, but it seems that if the lines can stretch and twist but can't cross, break, or begin/end at a null, then even in a vacuum you'd get terribly twisted field lines. If we take a simple case of 2 bar magnets with some gap between them, and rotate one of the magnets 360 deg, wouldn't the field lines have to wrap around the magnet:

(pardon the quality of my art)
picture.php


. . . I really don't think that's what happens, but are you asserting that it does? And if it doesn't, then wouldn't that violate some of your assertions?

P.S. the diagram would be slightly more clear if "N" and "S" didn't look exactly the same when rotated 180 deg.
 
You are delusional about even the process the creates the COLOR in this image, not to mention being totally ignorant about the light source.
The light source is the Sun!

The SDO image"green line" is a processing artifact as confirmed by the NASA team.
You keep on embarrassing yourself by persisting with this delusion abut this public relations image.

But this is not unexpected because you have similar delusions about other images, e.g.
It's been just about two years since NASA informed us, thanks to GeeMack, that Michael was counting pixels in a processing artifact and calling it the surface of the sun. And he still persists. Michael is the tenacious bulldog of fractal wrongness.
 
It's been just about two years since NASA informed us, thanks to GeeMack,

Er, no. We have nothing but more HERESAY claims that were made by GM. This is also the same guy who made an utterly BOGUS claim about the green color above the "transition region" of a standard composite image being due to a "misalignment" of RGB images. He's clueless about the CAUSE of the light seen above the transition region in even a standard composite image. I therefore wouldn't trust him with a ten foot pole to ACCURATELY represent "NASA" as a whole about satellite images, even if he actually worked at NASA himself as a "graphic artist". He clearly knows NOTHING about solar physics, starting with that claim that electrical discharges cannot occur in conductors. They can *ONLY* occur in and through *CONDUCTORS*. GM doesn't understand anything about solar satellite imagery and he definitely doesn't speak for everyone or even ANYONE at NASA. The only person he speaks for is himself.
 
Last edited:
Michael Mozina repeats his ignorance about the definition of photosphere

Ya, and I counted all those pixels at the limb in the first light SDO composite images that show the "transition region" in relationship to the photosphere/chromosphere boundary. It's 4800KM *UNDER* the surface of the photosphere!
Oy Vey - the ignorance :jaw-dropp!
Firstly, it is totally insane to try to process a PR image with a processing artefact as if it was the actual data.

Photosphere
The photosphere of an astronomical object is the region from which externally received light originates.
It is impoosible to detect light from *UNDER* the surface of the photosphere by definition.

This ignorance is compounded by the physical fact that less than 1 photon per year can come from 4800KM *UNDER* the surface of the photosphere:
How can we detect the less than 1 photon per year from your iron crust?
 
Er, no. We have nothing but more HERESAY claims that were made by GM. This is also the same guy who made an utterly BOGUS claim about the green color above the "transition region" of a standard composite image being due to a "misalignment" of RGB images. He's clueless about the CAUSE of the light seen above the transition region in even a standard composite image. I therefore wouldn't trust him with a ten foot pole to ACCURATELY represent "NASA" as a whole about satellite images, even if he actually worked at NASA himself as a "graphic artist". He clearly knows NOTHING about solar physics, starting with that claim that electrical discharges cannot occur in conductors. They can *ONLY* occur in and through *CONDUCTORS*. GM doesn't understand anything about solar satellite imagery.
Well, in that case, since you've had two years in which to contact NASA yourself...what did they say about the image when you asked?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom