Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Michael, the reason people are talking about reconnection in a vacuum is that YOU stated it couldn't happen in a vacuum. We're trying to get you to understand what reconnection is.


Indeed. Magnetic reconnection occurs. It can be demonstrated with a few refrigerator magnets. It will occur in your living room and it will occur in space. If two refrigerator magnets are inside an evacuated bell jar and one refrigerator magnet is outside the bell jar, magnetic reconnection can occur between the vacuum and the non-vacuum regions. It's a grade school science experiment and it doesn't even require any understanding of math to observe the results. Math idiots could get it.

The fact that it causes interesting effects in a plasma doesn't mean plasma is required for reconnection.


Indeed again. Magnetic reconnection, as it applies to the atmosphere of the Sun which is the environment under discussion, necessarily entails plasma. And all the dishonest distraction and silly semantic nonsense isn't going to change that.

Also, given that it is the responsibility of the against-the-mainstream advocates to support their own claims, what we're seeing is more dishonest deflection of the burden of proof, dishonest evasion, and another complete failure to objectively quantitatively support any electric/iron Sun conjecture.
 
Who cares? It's not WITHOUT PLASMA! You folks can't talk about particle species and particle velocity because CLINGER doesn't have particles in the first place! Somov's work does NOT support Clinger's outrageously FALSE claim. I have one of Somov's books on plasma physics. RC doesn't. He (and now you) are ignoring the fact that to have CURRENT you need CHARGED PARTICLES. Somov's vacuum contains PARTICLES.

Sorry to break it to you, but it is you who keeps on claiming that a current is a non-neutral plasma, not only this last time, but many a time in the years before in this thread and in other threads.

Otherwise, we seem to be stuck again in an idiotic discussion here, where we probably have to "come to a middle ground", which means we just have to give in to you, which we naturally will not do, because you don't understand what is being told to you.

Vacuum superpostion and reconnection do not have currents because it is in a vacuum.
Reconnection in a plasma does have currents associated with it.

A claim like above Somov's vacuum contains particles is too idiotic to even discuss.

However, I see that your answers are getting more and more devoid of any science, you won't even discuss physics and your misunderstandings about flux and current etc. The only things that are increasing again are CAPITALS and ***CAPITALS BRACKETED WITH STARS***
 
Last edited:
However, I see that your answers are getting more and more devoid of any science, you won't even discuss physics and your misunderstandings about flux and current etc. The only things that are increasing again are CAPITALS and ***CAPITALS BRACKETED WITH STARS***
Yes.
 
Clearly, you are the one who doesn't get it.

Please, explain what happens with the magnetic field lines of two permanent magnets when their opposing poles are brought together. Without plasma.

Such statements, without clearly defining such things as reconnection rate, are nothing much more than theoretical hypostatized hyperbole.
 
Such statements, without clearly defining such things as reconnection rate, are nothing much more than theoretical hypostatized hyperbole.

That wasn't a statement or hyperbole, it was a question. I want to know how he thinks magnetic fields merge without reconnection.
 
^ Ok. Well I guess this is more a case of how you define λ than an explicit fault with the system.

Still, such things need to be clearly defined before productive discussion can continue on this subject.
 
Magnetic Reconnection In Vacuo XI

Please, explain what happens with the magnetic field lines of two permanent magnets when their opposing poles are brought together. Without plasma.
Such statements, without clearly defining such things as reconnection rate, are nothing much more than theoretical hypostatized hyperbole.


I disagree. I think you are making things more complicated than they need to be. One need only look at either of the images provided by phunk (post 6553, 29 Feb 2012) or myself (Magnetic Reconnection In Vacuo, 20 May 2011) and see that when the opposite polarity ends of a bar magnet face each other, then the magnetic field lines from either magnet are fully connected to those of the other, while in the case of same polarity ends the magnetic field lines of either magnet are fully disconnected from those of the other. Simply rotating one magnet with respect to the other creates a transition from a fully connected to a fully disconnected state, or vice-versa. That is all you need to see & know, to know that the field lines of the two magnets have to change their connectivity, or in other words, the field lines must reconnect. Now, if we want to talk about the process in some more detail, then all of the technical details you talk about must come into play. However, simply to establish the minimal condition that some form of reconnection takes place does not require anything beyond a visual inspection of the field line images.
 
Let me highlight the relevant PHYSICS for you:
...rant about MR in plasma requiring plasma - Duh :eye-poppi...
Let me highlight the relevant ENGLISH for you.
You asked:
Originally Posted by Michael Mozina
I'm still waiting for a ligitimate PUBLISHED reference for 'reconnection' that generates any energy that isn't based upon MHD theory.
I answered:
Originally Posted by Reality Check
I never cited any of them because this is the first time that you have asked that specific question.

I expected that PIC simulations of MR would not use MHD and they do not (however ny Google skills deserted me before):
Geospace Environmental Modeling(GEM) Magnetic Reconnection Challenge (PDF)
and in case you cannot read a PDF
Collisionless magnetic reconnectionin the presence of a guide field

These are legitimate PUBLISHED references for MR that generates any energy that are not based upon MHD theory.

Your rant though suggests that we are back to your delusions about MR in vacuum:
MR in a vacuum is descibed in Cosmic plasma physics By Boris V. Somov
MR in a vacuum is mentioned in the scientific literature:

MR in a vacuum is a simple derivation from Maxwell's equations: W.D. Clinger's simple derivation of magnetic reconnection.
 
Last edited:
Many (all?) of them describe the "reconnection" process in plasma. In addition, I've read HUNDREDS of papers on the topic of RECONNECTION based upon MHD theory and MHD maths.
Thes are books and papers on magnbreic reconnection in plasma and MHD (a theory about plasma).
It would be idiotic to think that they would ignore plasma!.

What I have NEVER seen *PUBLISHED* is anything that REMOTELY supports your claim.
The only way that you are not lying yet again is if you you are saying that you have never read any of the *PUBLISHED* sources for MR in vacuum.

So here the citations yet again:
Try reading them and tell us what Somov meant by his title "Reconnection in a Vacuum" when he follows with a definition of magnetic reconnection in a vacuum :eye-poppi!

You have not picked up on your hypocrisy yet.
You have stated that Peratt's section titled "Electrical Discharges in Cosmic Plasma" means he is about to define electrical discharges that happen in plasma. But the section is just about normal electrical discharges and their role in creating terrestrial plasma thus Michael Mozina's fantasy about Anthony Peratt's definition of electrical discharge!

So why is Somov section titled "Reconnection in a Vacuum" not a mean that he is about to define MR in a vacuum when it is followed by a definition of MR in a vacuum?
 
Last edited:
Such statements, without clearly defining such things as reconnection rate, are nothing much more than theoretical hypostatized hyperbole.
Such statements, without actually understanding the post, are nothing much more than theoretical hypostatized hyperbole :rolleyes:.

This is refering to the example of MR using fridge magnets.The "reconnection rate" is the rate at which you choose to turn the magnets around (not as they are "brought together" as in phunks post).

Of course we have much better descriptions of MR in a vacuum - Cosmic plasma physics By Boris V. Somov and W.D. Clinger's simple derivation of magnetic reconnection.
 
Last edited:
I have one of Somov's books on plasma physics. RC doesn't.
That is irrelevant unless in the book by Somov that you have he states that MR in vacuum is impossible. Does he?

It is totally irrelevant because the chapter of Cosmic plasma physics By Boris V. Somov is available in Google Books. I have quoted Somov explaining MR in vacuum.

He (and now you) are ignoring the fact that to have CURRENT you need CHARGED PARTICLES. Somov's vacuum contains PARTICLES.
Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section VI (etc.)

You are ignoring the fact Somov's vacuum contains general CURRENTS without any physical mechanism specified. They could be currents in WIRES.
You are ignoring the fact that Maxwell's equations contain CURRENTS. Do you think that they only apply to plasma?
 
Last edited:
Circuits & E vs B (comments)

See my post Onel & Mann, Circuits, and Real Plasma Physics, dated 9 Aprl 2011, where I cleverly ignore the Onel & Mann paper by examining it in detail, including a comparison with Alfven's boundary conditions, discussing the physics of the paper and the value of the circuit paradigm. So much for me "ignoring" the Onel & Mann paper.
Ya, but note you still won't accept the mathematical legitimacy of the CIRCUIT orientation to these very same events Tim. You see one orientation B as always being superior (you're sort of Alfven's alter ego) and refusing to embrace BOTH sides (like Alfven).


Once again, wrong on several levels. First, I do accept the mathematical & physical validity of the circuit model (it's not an "orientation" it's a "model") for astrophysical plasmas. One need only go back and look at what I have actually said.

Now let me repeat myself with slightly altered emphasis: "Alfven established faulty boundary conditions because he was guided by a faulty paradigm, ... ", that faulty paradigm being the circuit paradigm. Certainly "faulty" is an unfortunate choice of words, since it arguably puts me in the position of being self-contradictory, which fortunately for me went unnoticed by certain others ...
{ ... }
Certainly the circuit paradigm is not wrong or faulty in any general sense. However, it is an approximation of limited use. Better for me to say that Alfven was misled by an oversimplified paradigm, rather than a faulty one. So I will correct myself to that extent.
{ ... }
But the only real point that one can take home from this is that the circuit paradigm is not wrong in the general sense. One can also argue, assuming that Onel & Mann make a valid point, that not all flare electrons are accelerated by magnetic reconnection. But then nobody ever made that claim that I am aware of anyway.
{ ... }
I agree with tusenfem, there is no "middle ground", and it is not true that the circuit orientation is "equally viable" or "equally well suited". As I said myself in a quote above, the circuit paradigm in an approximation which, as tusenfem correctly points out, hides all of the real physics that's going on in the plasma, behind a wall of averages & approximations.


Those are my own words from April 2011 and they clearly show that Mozina's claim regarding myself and the circuit paradigm for plasma physics is not justified by facts.

On the matter of the "E" paradigm vs the "B" paradigm, I do indeed accept one as superior to the other. Physics is not an egalitarian democracy; rather, the laws of physics rule with an "iron" fist. See my post Plasma Physics: "E Orientation" of "B Orientation"?. A plasma is made of particles and all particles obey the laws of physics. In the case of a non-relativistic plasma, all particles must simultaneously obey both Maxwell's equations and Newton's laws of motion. There is no choice, it's not "either, or", it's both at once, always. It is in most cases not possible to do this if one deals with the plasma using the "E orientation", and therefore necessary to resort to the "B orientation". It's not always the case, but it usually is the case. That is not some arbitrary choice, unless you think the decision to respect all of the laws of physics, instead of just some of the laws of physics, is somehow a capricious choice to make. In this case, "being able to embrace both sides" is just a propaganda piece. It's all about embracing whatever works and whatever respects the laws of physics.
 
Magnetic Reconnection In Vacuo XII

I have in fact supported my claim with several published references to magnetic reconnection in a vacuum. Here is a list of my posts on the topic, which the industrious reader may wish to peruse for the various references therein.
You NEVER PROVIDED EVEN *TOY* math! I guess your "best" attempt to address the fact they used MHD THEORY in the end was based on THIS one paragraph:
Paragraph 1
"We have constructed a toy model for vacuum reconnection driven by the motion of photospheric sources and have presented the results in the accompanying CD-ROM. We calculate the potential magnetic field due to two, three or four sources in the solar surface and then extend it to a many-source case in which the surrounding fields generally limit the motions of the field lines in response to the footpoint motions to much smaller amplitudes than in the few-source case. The sources are slowly moved around and we assume that the field remains potential. Although this is an oversimplified model, the resulting motion of the field lines is instructive and it is a useful preliminary for the resistive MHD numerical model that we are planning to undertake."
You've utterly *IGNORED* the fact that they are championing a resistive MHD *REAL* model, and you've never personally provided ANY math related to the TOY version. Get a grip! If their REAL version is base on MHD theory, their papers doesn't support your claim. If you've provided any MATHS on the TOY BRAND, I've yet to see it. Maybe I missed it?


Nice try, but it's all propaganda, and not very well done even for that. You will find the phrase "toy model" is quite common in the physics literature (a quick look at ADS reveals 332 papers with the phrase "toy model" in their title; no telling how often it shows up buried in the text). A "toy model" is a model that everyone knows is oversimplified, but nobody cares. Its purpose is to elucidate fundamental behavior. Once that is done, then successive waves of detail & complication are included until the "toy" model morphs into a "real" model. In this case, the model is a "toy" because it deals with magnetic reconnection in a vacuum, where the complications of the plasma environment can be ignored. That elucidates the fundamental behavior of the magnetic fields. The toy model will then be upgraded to include details of plasma physics deliberately left out for the "toy". By making models that are increasingly complicated, step by step, physicists are able to tell which of the many competing physical processes are more important or have a larger affect on the system, and which are the lesser players. It is a fairly common practice. And the "toy" math is there in the paper.

Now, Mozina chooses to highlight the words "photospheric" and "solar surface". I choose to highlight the phrase "vacuum reconnection driven by the motion of photospheric source". Mozina tells us this means the authors are using plasma, not a vacuum. Mozina is wrong, it says and does no such thing; neither plasma nor MHD is in any way involved. The real photosphere sits under the plasma of the chromosphere, the transition region and the corona. The toy photosphere sits under a vacuum (that's why it's a "toy" model). So the magnetic field loops that look like real coronal magnetic field loops extend not into a plasma but into a vacuum, where reconnection takes place (that's why it's called "vacuum reconnection"). Real coronal magnetic field loops are eventually anchored in the photosphere, at two places called "footpoints". In the toy model the footpoints move just like t,e real footpoints in the real photosphere. In a real model, one would use plasma physics & MHD and the "frozen flux" approximation to generate footpoint motion in a plasma photosphere. But that is not done here. No plasma, no MHD. Just motion of the footpoints that mimics real motions. No plasma, no MHD, Mozina is wrong again. Neither the use of the word "photosphere" nor the words "solar surface" has anything at all to do with plasma physics or MHD in the toy model as presented in this paper.

Also note that Mozina chooses to highlight "resistive MHD numerical model and then scold me with, "You've utterly *IGNORED* the fact that they are championing a resistive MHD *REAL* mode". Now allow me to highlight the authors words in an alternative fashion: "Although this is an oversimplified model, the resulting motion of the field lines is instructive and it is a useful preliminary for the resistive MHD numerical model that we are planning to undertake." First, I point out the phrase "that we are planning to undertake" which clearly refers to a resistive MHD model that does not yet exist, but will exist in the future, and not one that is used here & now, in this simulation of vacuum reconnection. The fact that they champion a model they plan to undertake at some undefined time in the future is irrelevant to what is happening in the here & now, in the toy model under question. In fact, despite Mozina's strident propaganda to the contrary, he is unable to show any use of plasma of MHD at all in the toy model.

The rest of your links look to be related to this one paper, and/or the same "magnetic flux change in a vacuum" = "reconnection" equivocation fallacy. You're utterly ignoring the fact that as Sweet mentioned, no conductive environment, no electrical current.


This "equivocation fallacy" is a figment of your overactive imagination. The whole point is that the prime & fundamental definition of magnetic reconnection is that of a change in topology of the magnetic field. That definition is entirely independent of plasma. The fallacy would exist only if the definition of magnetic reconnection required or included the presence of some electric current or accelerated plasma, but it does not. Hence, no fallacy. All of the definitions I supplied are basically & physically the same and are strictly limited to the magnetic field, independent of all plasma.

You've essentially turned *ANY* sort of "flux change" into "reconnection".


Not at all. Like I said before, and you have ignored, ...
Any old change won't do, only a change in the topology. In that post I also show the definition of magnetic flux as the surface integral of the magnetic field. In associating the magnetic flux with magnetic reconnection, I imagine a small unit area, a nearly infinitesimal circle perhaps, over which the flux is integrated. If the volume of magnetic field is sufficiently sampled by the unit area integral, you will have a volume representation of the flux. The flux at each area element will be a vector parallel to the normal vector to the surface, if the sampling surface is small enough. That volume representation of the flux should have a topology related to the topology of the field, and if the field topology changes, then so must the topology of the volume representation of the flux. I was trying to use flux in a manner akin to Mozina's without being technically incorrect and thought I had succeeded.


That's not "reconnection", that's only the *FIRST STEP* in a process that *REQUIRES* the *INDUCEMENT OF CURRENT* and an "electrical discharge/reconnection" of that current.


Absolutely dead wrong. There is nothing in the definition of magnetic reconnection that requires any inducement of current. That happens if and only if the reconnection of the magnetic field happens in a plasma. I have said this before too ...

Nobody is making the absurd claim that magnetic reconnection produces current in a vacuum! Look at the definition I gave in my own words above, confirmed by the sources in my post: A change in the topology of the magnetic field, changing the connectivity of the lines of force of the magnetic field. This process almost always results in the magnetic field transitioning from a higher to a lower energy state (there my be exceptional cases where the energy of the field does not change, but they are surely very strange and not important for this discussion). If that happens in a vacuum, there will be no current induced, no electricity, no "discharge", none of that. How could there be? It's a vacuum! Nobody ever made such a claim that I am aware of, and I most certainly never have. However, if that process happens in a plasma environment, then instead of the excess energy simply radiating away unnoticed to the vacuum, it goes into the plasma when the post reconnection magnetic field relaxes from higher to lower energy. Only then do we get currents and all of the nifty plasma physics that comes out of magnetic reconnection. Nobody writes papers about the magnetic field reconnecting & relaxing in a vacuum because it's a really boring thing that does nothing worth writing about. On the other hand, everybody wants to write papers about the reconnection of magnetic fields in a plasma because lots of really fascinating stuff happens in that case.


Bottom line: I have already fully justified magnetic reconnection in a vacuum, but Mozina has ignored my primary arguments and badly fouled up on those he chooses to respond to, usually ignoring the fact that things have already been said, while ho goes off on some tangent about how we have not done or said something that was done & said long ago. This is going to get boring, if it isn't already.
 
The real photosphere sits under the plasma of the chromosphere, the transition region and the corona. The toy photosphere sits under a vacuum (that's why it's a "toy" model). So the magnetic field loops that look like real coronal magnetic field loops extend not into a plasma but into a vacuum, where reconnection takes place (that's why it's called "vacuum reconnection").
Perhaps this is something that we have not emphasized enough to Mozina (or that he has chosen to ignore): MR in a vacuum is "in a vacuum" because it happens at the null point which is in vacuum.
So even if someone was ignorant enough to replace the idealized current flowing through a point in 2D with an infinitesimally thin, non-physical wire (or even plasma magically constrained to flow through a point!), the MR would still happen in a vacuum.
 
Hey, LMSAL is *FINALLY* starting to figure it out!

LOCKHEED MARTIN SOLAR AND ASTROPHYSICS LABORATORY SEMINAR

Date : Tuesday, 20 March 2012

Time : 3:00 PM

Place: 2nd FLOOR CONFERENCE ROOM, Bldg. 252,
3176 Porter Drive, Palo Alto, CA 94304

Speaker: Christoph Kuckein
(Instituto de Astrofisica de Canarias)

Title: An active region filament studied simultaneously in the photosphere and chromosphere

Abstract: We present new results regarding the magnetic structure, magnetic field strength and Doppler velocities found in a compact active region (AR) filament. The observed structure is best described as a flux rope that emerges from below the photosphere, where it is recognized as an orphan penumbral system,and makes its way up into the chromosphere. Spectropolarimetric data sets, which comprise the photospheric Si I 10827 AA line and the chromospheric He I 10830 AA triplet, were acquired with the Tenerife Infrared Polarimeter (TIP-II @ VTT, Tenerife, Spain) in 2005. Hence, the filament can be studied simultaneously in the photosphere and chromosphere. The four Stokes profiles were inverted with different inversion codes to retrieve the vector magnetic field and the line-of-sight (LOS) velocities. The velocities were calibrated on an absolute scale. To describe the evolution of this AR filament we also used SOHO/MDI, BBSO, and images of the Dutch Open Telescope (La Palma, Spain).

A widening of the polarity inversion line (PIL), simil! ar to the 'sliding door' effect shown by Okamoto et al. 2008, was seen in our data. The inferred vector magnetic fields of the filament suggest a flux rope topology. However, the very low-lying filament seems to be divided in two parts: one that lies in the chromosphere while the other part is trapped in the photosphere and hence develop an orphan penumbral system. The filament region displays upward motions of the horizontal magnetic field lines in the photosphere. In the chromosphere, only localized upflow patches of the horizontal fields are seen above the orphan penumbrae. Photospheric supersonic downflows that last for tens of minutes are detected below the filament along the PIL.

Emphasis mine. It's about TIME! They are FINALLY realizing that the coronal loops originate *UNDER* the photosphere and can be tracked up the SIDE of UMBRA! WOW! That's progress. Now if I can just get them to describe the relationships between the filters, and the fact the iron ion line can be seen traversing the surface of the photosphere, we can actually have a real conversation about solar satellite images. I wonder where they now place "solar moss" in relationship to the surface of the photosphere now that they FINALLY understand that magnetic rope/Bennett pinch begins UNDER the photosphere? That's is progress IMO.

I may actually see if I can figure out a way to go to that particular meeting. It sounds positively FASCINATING. I'm curious to know how deeply into the photosphere they are able to see. :)

Cool!
 
Such statements, without clearly defining such things as reconnection rate, are nothing much more than theoretical hypostatized hyperbole.

Clinger's maths are *WAY* too primitive to describe rates of reconnection, or anything of the sort. They are destined to NEVER see the light of publishing day. IMO DRD's conversation about the usefulness of published works is ironic, particularly when applied to this topic. The EU haters utterly ignore the fact that not one of them has produced a *PUBLISHED* work that supports their claim that plasma physical particles are 'optional', let alone anything that describes the rate of reconnection in the absence of plasma physics. The whole thing is an ironic sham, because their position on this topic is a pathetic house of cards. They could NEVER produce a published work to support their nonsense that describes the rate of reconnection in the absence of plasma and they know it.

They don't really care about publishing or mathematics. When it comes right down to it, they cling to a NON PUBLISHED piece of nonsense on the internet and fail to produce ANYTHING PUBLISHED that even REMOTELY supports their claim. Irony overload.
 
Wow! The more I think about that presentation at LMSAL next week, the more I'm stoked and excited. It's about time that the mainstream finally acknowledges that the coronal loops TRAVERSE the surface of the photosphere and they are "lit up" and achieve million degree temperatures UNDER the surface of the photosphere. It's definitely progress IMO.
 
Indeed. Magnetic reconnection occurs. It can be demonstrated with a few refrigerator magnets.

BS. It's just "flux". You folks will NEVER produce a PUBLISHED work that makes that claim, let alone demonstrate that reconnection occurs in the ABSENCE of plasma. It's never going to happen. It can't physically happen in fact. No physical charged particles means no transfer of stored magnetic field energy can take place into particle kinetic energy. Therefore no discharge, and no 'reconnection'.
 
Last edited:
Sorry to break it to you, but it is you who keeps on claiming that a current is a non-neutral plasma, not only this last time, but many a time in the years before in this thread and in other threads.

You keep trying to tap dance around the point. :) Somov's "vacuum" contains *PLASMA*. Get a grip. Get RC to get a grip.

IMO the mainstream keep ignoring the physics! It's not JUST about math, it's also about the PHYSICAL PARTICLES that do the work!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom