Magnetic Reconnection In Vacuo XII
I have in fact supported my claim with several published references to magnetic reconnection in a vacuum. Here is a list of my posts on the topic, which the industrious reader may wish to peruse for the various references therein.
You NEVER PROVIDED EVEN *TOY* math! I guess your "best" attempt to address the fact they used MHD THEORY in the end was based on THIS one paragraph:
Paragraph 1
"We have constructed a toy model for vacuum reconnection driven by the motion of photospheric sources and have presented the results in the accompanying CD-ROM. We calculate the potential magnetic field due to two, three or four sources in the solar surface and then extend it to a many-source case in which the surrounding fields generally limit the motions of the field lines in response to the footpoint motions to much smaller amplitudes than in the few-source case. The sources are slowly moved around and we assume that the field remains potential. Although this is an oversimplified model, the resulting motion of the field lines is instructive and it is a useful preliminary for the resistive MHD numerical model that we are planning to undertake."
You've utterly *IGNORED* the fact that they are championing a resistive MHD *REAL* model, and you've never personally provided ANY math related to the TOY version. Get a grip! If their REAL version is base on MHD theory, their papers doesn't support your claim. If you've provided any MATHS on the TOY BRAND, I've yet to see it. Maybe I missed it?
Nice try, but it's all propaganda, and not very well done even for that. You will find the phrase "toy model" is quite common in the physics literature (a quick look at ADS reveals 332 papers with the phrase "toy model" in their title; no telling how often it shows up buried in the text). A "toy model" is a model that everyone knows is oversimplified, but nobody cares. Its purpose is to elucidate fundamental behavior. Once that is done, then successive waves of detail & complication are included until the "toy" model morphs into a "real" model. In this case, the model is a "toy" because it deals with magnetic reconnection in a vacuum, where the complications of the plasma environment can be ignored. That elucidates the fundamental behavior of the magnetic fields. The toy model will then be upgraded to include details of plasma physics deliberately left out for the "toy". By making models that are increasingly complicated, step by step, physicists are able to tell which of the many competing physical processes are more important or have a larger affect on the system, and which are the lesser players. It is a fairly common practice. And the "toy" math is there in the paper.
Now,
Mozina chooses to highlight the words "
photospheric" and "
solar surface". I choose to highlight the phrase "
vacuum reconnection driven by the motion of photospheric source".
Mozina tells us this means the authors are using plasma, not a vacuum.
Mozina is wrong, it says and does no such thing; neither plasma nor MHD is in any way involved. The real photosphere sits under the plasma of the chromosphere, the transition region and the corona. The toy photosphere sits under a vacuum (that's why it's a "toy" model). So the magnetic field loops that look like real coronal magnetic field loops extend not into a plasma but into a vacuum, where reconnection takes place (that's why it's called "vacuum reconnection"). Real coronal magnetic field loops are eventually anchored in the photosphere, at two places called "footpoints". In the toy model the footpoints move just like t,e real footpoints in the real photosphere. In a real model, one would use plasma physics & MHD and the "frozen flux" approximation to generate footpoint motion in a plasma photosphere. But that is not done here. No plasma, no MHD. Just motion of the footpoints that mimics real motions. No plasma, no MHD,
Mozina is wrong again. Neither the use of the word "photosphere" nor the words "solar surface" has anything at all to do with plasma physics or MHD in the toy model as presented in this paper.
Also note that
Mozina chooses to highlight "
resistive MHD numerical model and then scold me with, "
You've utterly *IGNORED* the fact that they are championing a resistive MHD *REAL* mode". Now allow me to highlight the authors words in an alternative fashion: "
Although this is an oversimplified model, the resulting motion of the field lines is instructive and it is a useful preliminary for the resistive MHD numerical model that we are planning to undertake." First, I point out the phrase "
that we are planning to undertake" which clearly refers to a resistive MHD model that does not yet exist, but will exist in the future, and not one that is used here & now, in this simulation of vacuum reconnection. The fact that they champion a model they plan to undertake at some undefined time in the future is irrelevant to what is happening in the here & now, in the toy model under question. In fact, despite
Mozina's strident propaganda to the contrary, he is unable to show any use of plasma of MHD at all in the toy model.
The rest of your links look to be related to this one paper, and/or the same "magnetic flux change in a vacuum" = "reconnection" equivocation fallacy. You're utterly ignoring the fact that as Sweet mentioned, no conductive environment, no electrical current.
This "equivocation fallacy" is a figment of your overactive imagination. The whole point is that the prime & fundamental definition of magnetic reconnection is that of a change in topology of the magnetic field. That definition is entirely independent of plasma. The fallacy would exist only if the definition of magnetic reconnection required or included the presence of some electric current or accelerated plasma, but it does not. Hence, no fallacy. All of the definitions I supplied are basically & physically the same and are strictly limited to the magnetic field, independent of all plasma.
You've essentially turned *ANY* sort of "flux change" into "reconnection".
Not at all. Like I said before, and you have ignored, ...
Any old change won't do, only a change in the topology. In that post I also show the definition of magnetic flux as the surface integral of the magnetic field. In associating the magnetic flux with magnetic reconnection, I imagine a small unit area, a nearly infinitesimal circle perhaps, over which the flux is integrated. If the volume of magnetic field is sufficiently sampled by the unit area integral, you will have a volume representation of the flux. The flux at each area element will be a vector parallel to the normal vector to the surface, if the sampling surface is small enough. That volume representation of the flux should have a topology related to the topology of the field, and if the field topology changes, then so must the topology of the volume representation of the flux. I was trying to use flux in a manner akin to Mozina's without being technically incorrect and thought I had succeeded.
That's not "reconnection", that's only the *FIRST STEP* in a process that *REQUIRES* the *INDUCEMENT OF CURRENT* and an "electrical discharge/reconnection" of that current.
Absolutely dead wrong. There is
nothing in the definition of magnetic reconnection that requires any inducement of current. That happens if and only if the reconnection of the magnetic field happens in a plasma. I have said this before too ...
Nobody is making the absurd claim that magnetic reconnection produces current in a vacuum! Look at the definition I gave in my own words above, confirmed by the sources in my post: A change in the topology of the magnetic field, changing the connectivity of the lines of force of the magnetic field. This process almost always results in the magnetic field transitioning from a higher to a lower energy state (there my be exceptional cases where the energy of the field does not change, but they are surely very strange and not important for this discussion). If that happens in a vacuum, there will be no current induced, no electricity, no "discharge", none of that. How could there be? It's a vacuum! Nobody ever made such a claim that I am aware of, and I most certainly never have. However, if that process happens in a plasma environment, then instead of the excess energy simply radiating away unnoticed to the vacuum, it goes into the plasma when the post reconnection magnetic field relaxes from higher to lower energy. Only then do we get currents and all of the nifty plasma physics that comes out of magnetic reconnection. Nobody writes papers about the magnetic field reconnecting & relaxing in a vacuum because it's a really boring thing that does nothing worth writing about. On the other hand, everybody wants to write papers about the reconnection of magnetic fields in a plasma because lots of really fascinating stuff happens in that case.
Bottom line: I have already fully justified magnetic reconnection in a vacuum, but
Mozina has ignored my primary arguments and badly fouled up on those he chooses to respond to, usually ignoring the fact that things have already been said, while ho goes off on some tangent about how we have not done or said something that was done & said long ago. This is going to get boring, if it isn't already.