Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Well, sort of. In the sense you're releasing stored EM energy, yes, that is in fact an "electrical discharge". It's not actually an "electrical discharge in plasma' however. I suppose you could suspend the magnets *IN* a plasma and release them. The FLUX CHANGES that occur will likely induce currents. Assuming you could store and release enough magnetic field energy, I suppose it COULD result in an ELECTRICAL DISCHARGE that might result in highly ionized iron, x-rays, gamma rays, etc.

What "sort of"? It is the release of stored magnetic energy. So it is by your definition an ELECTRICAL DISCHARGE . Why the insistence on plasma? That was not part of the given definition.
 
Mr. Mozina:
Perhaps you could help me to cut through some of the defined quantities to move things along. As I understand this (so far) a current (from equation 16:
[latex]\mu_0I(z) [/latex] is given as a function of α and φr, where I(z) is multiplied by the magnetic constant and is based on position along the z axis (below the solar photospheric plane). OK so far? So, now help me with the variables α (which on page 535 is defined as a "function if space, but constant along a field line) and φr. Would you direct me to where these symbols are defined or just define them for me?
 
Yes and no. Tim provided the relevant reference material. Your side keeps trying to ignore the fact that magnetic fields have no source and no sink. Yes, I've "pointed that out" to you folks in DOZENS of published works now. If you call that "fixation on scientific fact", so be it.

You're the only one here that requires such sources and sinks for magnetic reconnection. Beat your strawman as much as you like.

If you call that "fixation on scientific fact", so be it.


Do not attempt to attribute quotes to me that I did not say.


Are you attempting to assert magnetic monopoles as " scientific fact"?

My MOTIVES are "scientific truth". In TRUTH, magnetic fields have no source and no sink. They therefore do not BEGIN anywhere as Clinger claimed, nor do they END anywhere as he claimed. The only SOURCE that produces any "magnetic charges" that go into the X,Y axis is CURRENT!

Again, what is the magnitude and direction of the magnetic force vector at a null point?




Those two equations are based upon Ampere's law. They show the DEPENDENCE of the magnetic source upon CURRENT flowing up the Z axis. Clinger doesn't have any current to generate any magnetic charges at 17, so the only way his magnetic lines could "begin" or "end" anywhere is if MONOPOLES EXIST!

You should look at his post again, there is current yet no " magnetic charges" as your the only one here claiming they are required. Again you have your "17" equation by all means please use it to show mathematically that your " magnetic charges" are required for magnetic reconnection.


Will you folks deal with reality? Yes or no? Magnetic lines have no source and no sink. The SOURCE that Priest is describing is a SOURCE OF CURRENT up the Z axis. Clinger LEFT OUT THE CURRENT. His contraption won't generate any "magnetic sources", no "magnetic charges" up the Z axis to "reconnect" to the X,Y plane.

Again your the only one here requiring "magnetic charges" so your only beating on yourself with your own strawman. Hey here's an idea, why don't you use those or any other equations to show mathematically why such "magnetic charges" would be required?



Indeed. That's why I went to all the trouble to find and highlight the specific equations in Priests magnetic source paper.

To beat up on your own strawman? Hardly any trouble at all.


I barked the relevant maths. You folks just don't listen. I'm WHINING because Clinger left out CURRENT and there is no magnetic source, or magnetic charge in equations 16 and 17.

So you found some equations you don't understand hoping to prop up your own strawman. Again you've got your equations by all means please use them to show mathematical how your " magnetic charge"s are required for magnetic reconnection.


Show me something PUBLISHED then that agrees with you. No more HATER arguments. Show me something PUBLISHED that isn't based on MHD theory and shows "reconnection" in the absence of all physical particles.


How about resistive MHD? " in the absence of all physical particles"? Would that mean just in a vacuum? You sure you don't want it without using magnetic fields as well?


http://www.terrapub.co.jp/journals/EPS/pdf/2001/5306/53060463.pdf

If the filaments with
radius r0 are placed in vacuum as shown in Fig. 1(a), there
is nothing to stop the process; the filaments should merge in
a time (
√
π/2)τA, where τA = r0/VA and the Alfven speed
VA = Bp/
√
4πρ0 is defined using the rod mass density ρ0
and the poloidal magnetic field Bp on their surface (equation
(16) of Tanaka, 1995b). In a plasma of Fig. 1(b), by contrast, the electric field Et inevitably accelerates the plasma electrons,
forming the axial current J3 at the separatrix. It must
be noted that this current increases in time with its direction
opposite to that of the approaching filaments. The repulsive
forces acting between J1 and J3 and between J2 and J3 exceed
the attractive force between J1 and J2, which blocks
magnetic reconnection. However, if some mechanism exists
limiting the growth of the induced current J3, then the attractive
force between the filaments J1 and J2 can overcome
the repulsive ones, and magnetic reconnection proceeds. In
other words, if electrical resistivity is sufficiently large for a
given electric field Et ,
Et = ηJ3, (2)
the anti-reconnection current J3 = Et/η is kept small.

So far from saying reconnection requires an intervening plasma the very beginning of the paper asserts that the reconnection process happens faster in a vacuum, no intervening plasma. No doubt you will disqualify this paper in some way however the point is clear magnetic reconnection does not require an intervening plasma. Again you can demonstrate that to yourself with the simple experiments already recommended.
 
How exactly are you getting that claim that PLASMA is optional in these two papers from what tusenfem wrote?
Originally Posted by tusenfem
No mention of MHD in that paper, as it is from 1958 and my post is 2 pages back a the end of the page.

And please also read the Yamada paper, which once you thought would be a great starting point for a real scientific discussion of MRx.

The Sweet paper did not mention MHD because in 1958 MHD did not exist :eye-poppi!

It is obvious that tusenfem has read the Yamada paper since he suggested it as a great starting point for a real scientific discussion of MRx. The problem is that you have not bothered to start that discussion.

It was your assertion that something in these papers about MR in plasma "DEMONSTRATE CONCLUSIVELY that plasma is NOT OPTIONAL in the "reconnection" process".
That is ignorant since the presence of plasma is a basic assumption in these paper about MR in solar flares and other plasma!
That is ignorant since the you never cite where in the papers that conclusively demonstrate that plasma in mandatory for MR.


It is even more ignorant since MR without plasma is DEMONSTRATED CONCLUSIVELY to be a trivial, real process:
W.D. Clinger's derivation of magnetic reconnection in a vacuum explicitly shows MR in vacuum is a real process.
 
Last edited:
Yes, those are the two equations that demonstrate that plasma isn't optional in terms of magnetic charges and in terms of sources and sinks.
You remain wrong. There is no plasma in the equations. No electrons. No ions. There are only magnetic fields, currents and magnetic charges.
Michael Mozina's delusions about the Demoulin & Priest 1992 paper VI

The two equations demonstrate that magnetic charges are directly related to CURRENT.
Wrong:
Equation 16 demonstrates the use of Ampere's theorem (CURRENT is related to magnetic field - Duh :eye-poppi!).
Equation 17 demonstrates the use of Gauss's theorem.


Current isn't optional in "reconnection" events, and the only SOURCE of magnetic fields is CURRENT.
Michael Mozina's delusions about the Demoulin & Priest 1992 paper VI
You repeat your delusion that the paper is about MR.
 
Magnetic Reconnection In Vacuo X

Michael, will you answer a simple question for me? Do you agree with the arrangement of the lines in figure b on this page? ... http://www.schoolphysics.co.uk/age1...ism/Magnetism/text/Magnetic_fields/index.html


I already tried that. I posted essentially the same thing, but instead of being drawn, the field lines are illustrated using real magnets and iron filings, the images accompanied by the text quoted here:
Magnetic attraction is the direct consequence of magnetic field lines connecting the two poles that are attracted. Magnetic repulsion is a direct result of the magnetic field lines pushing each other away from the poles that are repelling each other. So if you move the magnetic poles from repulsion to attraction, you are moving from a regime where no magnetic field lines cross or connect at all, into a regime where all of the magnetic field lines connect from one pole to the other. These two states are easily demonstrated the old fashioned way, by putting bar magnets under paper with iron filings on them. Anyone can do this and literally see the field lines in both the repelling & attracting, unconnected & connected states, right in front of them. That magnetic reconnection must necessarily happen under such circumstances, in vacuo, is obvious.


Mozina never responded to my post, and did not respond to Phunk either. He has the habit of ignoring uncomfortable facts. But sometimes he slips up and actually responds, with amazing consequences. For instance, he did himself suggested a set of animations which clearly show magnetic field lines actually in the act of physically breaking, and physically reconnecting ...

Try this animation on REPULSION PS:

http://www.kjmagnetics.com/magneticfield.asp

http://www.kjmagnetics.com/images/MagneticFieldRepulsion.gif

No B lines "reconnect". They simply "spread out" or "bend and twist".


What, are you blind? Look at the animation entitled "A pair of D42 magnets attracting, animated" (second from bottom) on your first link ...

http://www.kjmagnetics.com/magneticfield.asp

Look at the magnetic field lines that connect the poles of the attracting magnets. Those B-field lines, in that animation, clearly break and reconnect as the poles pull apart. I can see it and I know you can see it too.


To this visual evidence so obvious that even small children can see it, Mozina replies ...

They are magnets in an attracting process. Where do you see the word "reconnection" on that page?


There you have it. Mozina is so overwhelmed by blind prejudice that he will actively deny that his eyes can see what they see, rationalizing everything away, because nobody actually used the word "reconnection" on the animation page. Mozina deliberately ignores the physics, the obvious and real reconnection of the magnetic field lines, which are absolutely required by the laws of physics to literally break and reconnect, and seen to do so in animations that he himself posted! Do rational people do that? Does anyone think it is possible to have a rational discourse with anybody who is so emotionally biased?

I have presented a list my posts, some of them fairly extensive, on the general topic of magnetic reconnection in a vacuum here: Magnetic Reconnection In Vacuo IX.
 
We have a case of Fractal Wrongness:

http://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Fractal_wrongness

The arguments just don't follow any rational line of thought, and therefore can't be reasoned with.

Thanks for posting this Almo. I have learned a lot about physics in this thread from all the responses to MM, but this is probably the most practically useful thing I have seen in this thread. :D
 
We have a case of Fractal Wrongness:

http://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Fractal_wrongness

The arguments just don't follow any rational line of thought, and therefore can't be reasoned with.

It's time for me to explore Thunderbolts. I've seen irrational, denial based, *PERSONAL ATTACK* oriented cults before, but no cult has *ANYTHING* over the irrational behaviors of EU haters. They take maths and terms SUBJECTIVELY from Dungey's work. The term "reconnection" registers, whereas the term 'electrical discharge' generates *PURE DENIAL*. They ignore those maths by Mann and Onel in terms of solar flares. They ignore the EMPIRICAL LABORATORY CONNECTIONS between "electrical discharges" and the 7 key high energy emissions seen in solar flares! *THOUSANDS* of papers demonstrate that plasma is *REQUIRED* to generate RECONNECTION, yet the "haters" are convinced of "truth", not based on PUBLISHED MATERIALS, but upon some guys *WEBSITE* that is clearly NEVER going to see the light of publishing day. Yep, EU haters and evolutionary theory haters always go for personal attacks, and unpublished website material the moment that their beliefs systems are threatened by physics and math.

"Electrical discharges is solar flares? What discharges? Maths in that Onel and Mann paper? What maths? Math's in Alfven's work on solar flares? What math?"

The EU hater position is based upon pure denial and an irrational blind bigotry toward the E orientation of physics to events in space. It's like arguing with 'flat Earthers" around here.
 
Last edited:
What "sort of"? It is the release of stored magnetic energy. So it is by your definition an ELECTRICAL DISCHARGE . Why the insistence on plasma? That was not part of the given definition.

Yes, actually it WAS a part of Peratt's definition. It was a definition of electrical discharges *IN* cosmic plasmas.
 
You're the only one here that requires such sources and sinks for magnetic reconnection. Beat your strawman as much as you like.

You (Clinger) can't claim that B lines "begin" and "end" and then run away like a frightened child from the SOURCE AND SINK aspects of PHYSICS! OMG. I'm taking a break from this place.

I can show you THOUSANDS of *PUBLISHED* works that demonstrate that plasma is *REQUIRED* in the mathematical models related to "reconnection". T could only find ONE or TWO papers that he CLAIMS are "plasma optional' and yet BOTH OF THEM are describing EVENTS IN PLASMAS! OMG.

Whereas I can ACCEPT that Sweet's crude mathematical model might actually WORK in plasma (even before MHD theory), there no evidence at all that Sweet himself claimed it would work *WITHOUT ANY PLASMA PARTICLES WHATSOEVER*. The whole thing a blatant red herring since Sweet MADE NO SUCH CLAIM!

IMO Yamada just misrepresented Sweet!
 
Looks like the correct Yamada et al paper, yes, however by just looking at the abstract of a paper you can easily draw the wrong conclusion. Similarly, when you just look at the links in my post without reading anything I wrote there. So, you will fit fine in thunderdolts, where the preferred way of doing science is through press releases.

IMO that's all you're doing with Yamada's claim. Sweet himself actually made no such claim in that paper T. Did you even happen to read that paper by Sweet? If so, QUOTE SWEET where SWEET claimed such a thing, not Yamada. As far as I can tell, Yamade is stuffing words in Sweet's mouth that simply aren't there. Sweet talked about a PERFECTLY CONDUCTING MEDIUM, not a vacuum. He describes CURRENTS, not a vacuum.

Waiting.....
 
Last edited:
I really do have to take a break from this place for my own sanity. I gave up arguing with creationist because, like EU haters, no amount of PHYSICS matters to them. Nevermind the fact that 7 key observations related to solar flares have been linked to "electrical discharges' here on Earth, and only *ONE* to "magnetic reconnection" theory. Nevermind the fact Dungey used the term "electrical discharge' in the same paper and PROCESS he used the term "reconnection", all the hater hears is "reconnection' and the haters simply DENY the other term entirely! Talk about irrational, purely subjective, bigoted nonsense!

Mann and Onel wrote a WONDERFUL paper on the E orientation to solar flares and tied it all back to solar satellite images. Nevermind....I'm wasting my breath. Denial is just denial.
 
Last edited:
It's time for me to explore Thunderbolts. I've seen irrational, denial based, *PERSONAL ATTACK* oriented cults before, but no cult has *ANYTHING* over the irrational behaviors of EU haters.
I really don't know what you hope to accomplish by continually repeating this sort of thing. Do you think you're convincing the lurkers that you're the rational one here? Is it cathartic? Are you hoping to guilt GeeMack, Tim, Tus, Ben, etc, into agreeing with you?

They take maths and terms SUBJECTIVELY from Dungey's work.

As I recall, Dungey made only one prediction in the papers presented here and even he acknowledged that it didn't fit well with observations.

The term "reconnection" registers, whereas the term 'electrical discharge' generates *PURE DENIAL*. They ignore those maths by Mann and Onel in terms of solar flares.

Well, they don't attach the importance to them that you do.

They ignore the EMPIRICAL LABORATORY CONNECTIONS between "electrical discharges" and the 7 key high energy emissions seen in solar flares!

Those 7 phenomena were all associated with high temperatures. Nothing about them was unique to electrical discharges, so all they do is support the observation that flares are very hot. Nobody here has disputed that. Your 7 phenomena provide exactly 0 support for electric discharge vs. any other energy source. There's nothing there to ignore.

*THOUSANDS* of papers demonstrate that plasma is *REQUIRED* to generate RECONNECTION, yet the "haters" are convinced of "truth", not based on PUBLISHED MATERIALS, but upon some guys *WEBSITE* that is clearly NEVER going to see the light of publishing day.

I have yet to see a paper that demonstrated that plasma was required. The fact that plasma may be present does not mean that it is required. And AFAIK, nobody here is basing their belief in vacuum reconnection on "some guy's website," they just thought the website provided a clear demonstration.

Yep, EU haters and evolutionary theory haters always go for personal attacks, and unpublished website material the moment that their beliefs systems are threatened by physics and math.
as above.

"Electrical discharges is solar flares? What discharges? Maths in that Onel and Mann paper? What maths? Math's in Alfven's work on solar flares? What math?"

This is beneath you, Michael. It's one thing to dispute the interpretations from Tim, GM, Ben, Sol, Zig, etc, but you know that nobody's disputing whether Alfven or O&M included any math.

The EU hater position is based upon pure denial and an irrational blind bigotry toward the E orientation of physics to events in space. It's like arguing with 'flat Earthers" around here.

Seriously, how does this sort of thing help you?

BTW, I still owe a long response to your response to my post a few weeks ago. I've been traveling so I haven't had the chance to devote a block of time to it, but hopefully this weekend.
 
It's time for me to explore Thunderbolts.


Where people are stupid enough to believe a running difference image actually shows an iron surface below the point where the Sun's atmosphere becomes opaque? Where they're so gullible they don't even wonder, in almost seven years of that nonsense being posted on the net, why the iron/electric Sun proponents haven't been able to quantitatively or objectively explain why each pixel in such an image is the color that it is, but accept the nonsense anyway based on nothing more than someone's mistaken understanding and an unsupported declaration that it really really looks like it. That'll be fun.

I've seen irrational, denial based, *PERSONAL ATTACK* oriented cults before, but no cult has *ANYTHING* over the irrational behaviors of EU haters.


It would be a gross misunderstanding of reality, or a lie, to suggest that the criticism of the iron/electric Sun conjectures in this thread have been attacks on individuals. The ideas are nutty. The conjectures are unsupportable. The arguments are twisted, dishonest distortions of reality. The process is bass-ackwards, the antithesis of the scientific process. But there is no cult. There are no EU haters. And nothing about the quantitative objective criticism of the electric Sun conjecture has been irrational, regardless of the persistent uncivil complaints and accusations to the contrary.

They take maths and terms SUBJECTIVELY from Dungey's work. The term "reconnection" registers, whereas the term 'electrical discharge' generates *PURE DENIAL*. They ignore those maths by Mann and Onel in terms of solar flares.


Re-read my post about how the electric Sun arguments are dishonestly assembled and presented...

Well, Peratt wrote, "An electrical discharge is a sudden release of electric or magnetic stored energy." So although a spring releasing its stored energy may not be an electrical discharge, a piece of paper falling to the floor when I pull a magnet off my refrigerator is.

The entire "electrical discharge" definition thing is a dishonest attempt to force agreement where there is none. It's the same juvenile tactic that DOC and yrreg try in the religion discussions. Get everyone to agree that the Universe is everything, and our imaginations exist in the Universe, and we can imagine gods, therefore gods exist. Get everyone to agree that miracles have no explanation, and everyone has seen something which he/she can't explain, therefore miracles exist. It probably works on stupid people and gullible people and people who already have the faith. But intelligent, objective people applying critical thinking and the scientific method aren't so easily fooled by such dishonest tactics. In great part that's why the electric/iron Sun conjectures have gotten no traction in this discussion, and why the bulk of the arguments allegedly supporting those conjectures have so completely and dismally failed.

That kind of dishonesty doesn't work for bible thumpers, except to convince other bible thumpers. And it won't work in a legitimate scientific discussion except, perhaps, to convince some cranks and crackpots who might be reading from the sidelines.

They ignore the EMPIRICAL LABORATORY CONNECTIONS between "electrical discharges" and the 7 key high energy emissions seen in solar flares!


Nonsense. That list of key connections was custom manufactured for the purpose of wishing a fantasy into reality. It is another failed attempt to dishonestly support what appears to be an unsupportable claim.

*THOUSANDS* of papers demonstrate that plasma is *REQUIRED* to generate RECONNECTION, yet the "haters" are convinced of "truth", not based on PUBLISHED MATERIALS, but upon some guys *WEBSITE* that is clearly NEVER going to see the light of publishing day.


First, I am willing to call that a lie. But the blatant dishonesty aside, who the hell cares if plasma is required for magnetic reconnection when the topic of the discussion is magnetic reconnection in the Sun's atmosphere where plasma most assuredly exists. Magnetic reconnection can be demonstrated to occur without plasma and in a vacuum, both mathematically and by moving around a couple of compasses. Magnetic reconnection in a plasma atmosphere occurs, well, in plasma.

Second, I note that the grade school kid experiment with refrigerator magnets has been ignored again in favor of complaining about failing.

Yep, EU haters and evolutionary theory haters always go for personal attacks, and unpublished website material the moment that their beliefs systems are threatened by physics and math.


Very few people in this discussion keep harping on the idea that belief systems are somehow involved. Notice how all of those people are advocating and none of them criticizing any electric/iron Sun conjectures.

"Electrical discharges is solar flares? What discharges? Maths in that Onel and Mann paper? What maths? Math's in Alfven's work on solar flares? What math?"

The EU hater position is based upon pure denial and an irrational blind bigotry toward the E orientation of physics to events in space. It's like arguing with 'flat Earthers" around here.


The dishonesty continues to fail. It's not the fault of contemporary mainstream physicists that every attempt to push an electric/iron Sun conjecture has failed. The failure belongs to those advocating for the against-the-mainstream position. And really, nothing in the above rant is an argument to support, well, anything. It's another complaint about failing. Complaining about failing is not likely to result in succeeding.
 
He compared this to the case of a vacuum nonconducting solar atmosphere in which the magnetic field would simply add vectorially and the neutral (N) point of intersection would simply shift from line to line with the consequence that some lines originally connected to a single dipole would end up connecting one sunspot to the other.

Um, technically Yamada did NOT misrepresent Sweet. Sweet *DID* cite the difference between what would occur when he moved the fields in a non conducting medium and a conducting one. He stated that the the non conducting medium wouldn't induce any current, whereas the conducting one would! That's all SWEET actually claimed.

IMO T, you're trying to build a federal case out of a single sentence taken out of context. Sweet didn't claim anything would reconnect *WITHOUT* plasma.
 
How about resistive MHD? " in the absence of all physical particles"? Would that mean just in a vacuum?

Er, no, that would simply be PLASMA physics that accounts for RESISTANCE in the PLASMA!

You sure you don't want it without using magnetic fields as well?

No, just *WITHOUT* any plasma particles as you folks keep HANDWAVING!

http://www.terrapub.co.jp/journals/EPS/pdf/2001/5306/53060463.pdf

So far from saying reconnection requires an intervening plasma the very beginning of the paper asserts that the reconnection process happens faster in a vacuum, no intervening plasma. No doubt you will disqualify this paper in some way however the point is clear magnetic reconnection does not require an intervening plasma. Again you can demonstrate that to yourself with the simple experiments already recommended.

It's pretty clear you don't understand what they wrote. Let me highlight the appropriate points for you:

If the filaments with radius r0 are placed in vacuum as shown in Fig. 1(a), there is nothing to stop the process; the filaments should merge in a time....

Nobody doubts that PLASMA FILAMENTS can merge and reconnect either in plasma or in a vacuum. The filaments themselves are COMPOSED OF PLASMAS! No plasma, no filament, no merging of filaments. Resistive MHD is *STILL MHD* theory!

Wow. This place is absolutely amazing.
 
Last edited:
Thanks for posting this Almo. I have learned a lot about physics in this thread from all the responses to MM, but this is probably the most practically useful thing I have seen in this thread. :D

I came across it in another thread here at JREF, and this thread immediately came to mind. The inability to pin Michael's arguments down to any real physics makes it impossible to discuss anything. It's like playing Tekken with someone who will only use cards. There's no connection, and no real communication.

Aside: a friend once said of Tekken, "You have to learn the language before you can have a meaningful conversation." For reference, Tekken is a one-vs-one fighting video game. By "meaningful conversation," he of course means "interesting fight." :)
 
Um, technically Yamada did NOT misrepresent Sweet. Sweet *DID* cite the difference between what would occur when he moved the fields in a non conducting medium and a conducting one. He stated that the the non conducting medium wouldn't induce any current, whereas the conducting one would! That's all SWEET actually claimed.

IMO T, you're trying to build a federal case out of a single sentence taken out of context. Sweet didn't claim anything would reconnect *WITHOUT* plasma.

Okay, to quote Sweet, page 124:

If the medium above PQ were a non-conductor, the two system would suffer a ruther interpenetratin and the value of A at the neutral point would increase to values A3, A4, etc., according to the extend of the displacement, as in Fig. 2. No currents are induced above PQ and the field here is called the equivalent potential field.

If you would look then to Fig. 2 you would understand how the neutral point moves from field line to field line. Yes, it would maybe ask a little creative thinking on your part, but to anyone else it is clear that there has to be reconnection to let the neutral point move to A3, A4 etc.

However, you will never understand this most simple case of reconnection of field lines in vacuum.

Maybe you should join up with MGmirkin with his comments "reconnection is just an exploding circuit," as it that actually explains something.
 
Mann and Onel wrote a WONDERFUL paper on the E orientation to solar flares and tied it all back to solar satellite images. Nevermind....I'm wasting my breath. Denial is just denial.

I have explaind the how and what of that paper to you. The fact that you don't understand the underlying physics is not my problem, you just never have had a real physics education, that is nothing to be ashamed of, but it does give you a disadvantage.

So, just go to MGmirkin, who can soooo well do physics with press releases, as with the Edegal et al. paper, where he absolutely does not understand what the message of the real paper is. It is not that magnetic field aligned electric fields are now "suddenly discovered" because mainstream space plasma physics already knows about these since the end of the 50s of the last century when they were shown to exist from rocket measurements, leading to a verification of Birkeland's ideas about the aurora. No, tell your new friend that the really interesting thing is that these electric fields happen over much greater distances than first expected, which can solve the so-called "electron problem."
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom