It's time for me to explore Thunderbolts.
Where people are stupid enough to believe a running difference image actually shows an iron surface
below the point where the Sun's atmosphere becomes opaque? Where they're so gullible they don't even wonder, in almost seven years of that nonsense being posted on the net, why the iron/electric Sun proponents haven't been able to quantitatively or objectively explain why each pixel in such an image is the color that it is, but accept the nonsense anyway based on nothing more than someone's mistaken understanding and an unsupported declaration that
it really really looks like it. That'll be fun.
I've seen irrational, denial based, *PERSONAL ATTACK* oriented cults before, but no cult has *ANYTHING* over the irrational behaviors of EU haters.
It would be a gross misunderstanding of reality, or a lie, to suggest that the criticism of the iron/electric Sun conjectures in this thread have been attacks on individuals. The
ideas are nutty. The
conjectures are unsupportable. The
arguments are twisted, dishonest distortions of reality. The
process is bass-ackwards, the antithesis of the scientific process. But there is no cult. There are no EU haters. And nothing about the quantitative objective criticism of the electric Sun conjecture has been irrational, regardless of the persistent uncivil complaints and accusations to the contrary.
They take maths and terms SUBJECTIVELY from Dungey's work. The term "reconnection" registers, whereas the term 'electrical discharge' generates *PURE DENIAL*. They ignore those maths by Mann and Onel in terms of solar flares.
Re-read my post about how the electric Sun arguments are dishonestly assembled and presented...
Well, Peratt wrote, "An electrical discharge is a sudden release of electric or magnetic stored energy." So although a spring releasing its stored energy may not be an electrical discharge, a piece of paper falling to the floor when I pull a magnet off my refrigerator is.
The entire "electrical discharge" definition thing is a dishonest attempt to force agreement where there is none. It's the same juvenile tactic that DOC and yrreg try in the religion discussions. Get everyone to agree that the Universe is everything, and our imaginations exist in the Universe, and we can imagine gods, therefore gods exist. Get everyone to agree that miracles have no explanation, and everyone has seen something which he/she can't explain, therefore miracles exist. It probably works on stupid people and gullible people and people who already have the faith. But intelligent, objective people applying critical thinking and the scientific method aren't so easily fooled by such dishonest tactics. In great part that's why the electric/iron Sun conjectures have gotten no traction in this discussion, and why the bulk of the arguments allegedly supporting those conjectures have so completely and dismally failed.
That kind of dishonesty doesn't work for bible thumpers, except to convince other bible thumpers. And it won't work in a legitimate scientific discussion except, perhaps, to convince some cranks and crackpots who might be reading from the sidelines.
They ignore the EMPIRICAL LABORATORY CONNECTIONS between "electrical discharges" and the 7 key high energy emissions seen in solar flares!
Nonsense. That list of key connections was custom manufactured for the purpose of wishing a fantasy into reality. It is another failed attempt to dishonestly support what appears to be an unsupportable claim.
*THOUSANDS* of papers demonstrate that plasma is *REQUIRED* to generate RECONNECTION, yet the "haters" are convinced of "truth", not based on PUBLISHED MATERIALS, but upon some guys *WEBSITE* that is clearly NEVER going to see the light of publishing day.
First, I am willing to call that a lie. But the blatant dishonesty aside,
who the hell cares if plasma is required for magnetic reconnection when the topic of the discussion is magnetic reconnection in the Sun's atmosphere where plasma most assuredly exists. Magnetic reconnection can be demonstrated to occur without plasma and in a vacuum, both mathematically and by moving around a couple of compasses. Magnetic reconnection in a plasma atmosphere occurs, well, in plasma.
Second, I note that the grade school kid experiment with refrigerator magnets has been ignored
again in favor of complaining about failing.
Yep, EU haters and evolutionary theory haters always go for personal attacks, and unpublished website material the moment that their beliefs systems are threatened by physics and math.
Very few people in this discussion keep harping on the idea that belief systems are somehow involved. Notice how all of those people are advocating and none of them criticizing any electric/iron Sun conjectures.
"Electrical discharges is solar flares? What discharges? Maths in that Onel and Mann paper? What maths? Math's in Alfven's work on solar flares? What math?"
The EU hater position is based upon pure denial and an irrational blind bigotry toward the E orientation of physics to events in space. It's like arguing with 'flat Earthers" around here.
The dishonesty continues to fail. It's not the fault of contemporary mainstream physicists that every attempt to push an electric/iron Sun conjecture has failed. The failure belongs to those advocating for the against-the-mainstream position. And really, nothing in the above rant is an argument to support, well, anything. It's another complaint about failing. Complaining about failing is not likely to result in succeeding.