Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
BOTH! OMG!

Tell me what they mean PS. If you want to talk math, explain them. They demonstrate CONCLUSIVELY that the magnetic CHARGES are directly and mathematically linked to CURRENT up the Z axis, and that requires PLASMA.


Attempting to deflect the burden of proof is not an argument. It is a dishonest fallacy.
 
It is a complaint about failing. Yes, failing.

Yes. Haters FAIL to deal with the mathematical evidences they don't like. They subjectively FAIL to acknowledge the 7 key high energy observations associated with flares and "electrical discharges" in the lab. They FAIL to deal with the relevant materials and they FAIL more by attacking individuals. I do in fact rant against pure hater behaviors, be they creationists/(Evolutionary theory haters), or EU haters. The behavior of pure denial is a giant FAIL at the level of PHYSICS.
 
Michael Mozina's raving is surreal.

If I didn't care about math, I wouldn't have earned a doctoral degree in that subject, and I certainly wouldn't have completed that degree through the pure math program at one of the world's most selective departments.

You're utterly and totally subjective about WHICH maths you'll deal with. Do you accept Dungey's claim (and maths) that demonstrate that *ELECTRICAL DISCHARGES* occur in flares yet? Yes or no?

If I didn't care about math, I wouldn't have bothered to write up a fairly detailed proof that magnetic reconnection, in a vacuum, without plasma, is a simple consequence of Maxwell's equations. If I didn't care about math, I wouldn't have taken the trouble to illustrate that proof with accurate graphs and animations.

If you REALLY cared about math, you'd get your nonsense*PUBLISHED* somewhere and demonstrate it's REALLY what you claim it to be. You don't CARE about math Clinger.

You've never even cited a single published work that actually supports your claim that reconnection can occur in the absence of plasma. All the papers you've cited are based upon MHD theory. You don't have a plasma particle to your name, so you can't USE MHD THEORY to support your nonsense.

If I didn't care about math, I wouldn't have replicated the main result of Dungey's 1958 paper.

You can't ride Dungey's coattails because you A) don't have plasma, and B) disagree with Dungey about the fact that ELECTRICAL DISCHARGES occur in RECONNECTION events!

If Michael Mozina cared about math, he'd have learned some.

I learned nothing I didn't already know. Folks that don't care about SCIENCE put up nothing but websites. Even I bothered to publish some of my material Clinger. Put up (publish or provide published support), or give it up. Websites in cyberspace are meaningless as it relates to science. Everyone except a HATER already knows that.
 
I think the only way to stop rehashing it is for us to turn the thread into an echo chamber.

It's about to become a monument to EU hater behaviors. I'm so bored here now I could scream.

FYI, I really am going to spend some time over at Thunderbolts for awhile. I need a break from the pure denial based behaviors.
 
Again as already asserted multiple times, the fixation on "sources and sinks" for magnetic reconnection is entirely yours.

Yes and no. Tim provided the relevant reference material. Your side keeps trying to ignore the fact that magnetic fields have no source and no sink. Yes, I've "pointed that out" to you folks in DOZENS of published works now. If you call that "fixation on scientific fact", so be it.

Your above assertion confirms that I haven't been lying about your motives. Why do you continue to do so when it is so blatantly obvious?

My MOTIVES are "scientific truth". In TRUTH, magnetic fields have no source and no sink. They therefore do not BEGIN anywhere as Clinger claimed, nor do they END anywhere as he claimed. The only SOURCE that produces any "magnetic charges" that go into the X,Y axis is CURRENT!

Well you got's your two equations. Again please show mathematically exactly where W.D.Clinger's calculations " would require magnetic monopoles" using those or any other equations?

Those two equations are based upon Ampere's law. They show the DEPENDENCE of the magnetic source upon CURRENT flowing up the Z axis. Clinger doesn't have any current to generate any magnetic charges at 17, so the only way his magnetic lines could "begin" or "end" anywhere is if MONOPOLES EXIST!

Will you folks deal with reality? Yes or no? Magnetic lines have no source and no sink. The SOURCE that Priest is describing is a SOURCE OF CURRENT up the Z axis. Clinger LEFT OUT THE CURRENT. His contraption won't generate any "magnetic sources", no "magnetic charges" up the Z axis to "reconnect" to the X,Y plane.


Again the purported requirement is simply yours.

Indeed. That's why I went to all the trouble to find and highlight the specific equations in Priests magnetic source paper.

Heck, I wish you could show it mathematically, it would then be a confirmation of magnetic monopoles and a major advancement of physics. Oops sorry, that's right you don't just 'bark math' but do just bark whine.

I barked the relevant maths. You folks just don't listen. I'm WHINING because Clinger left out CURRENT and there is no magnetic source, or magnetic charge in equations 16 and 17.

Nope, you can demonstrate magnetic reconnection, sans plasma, with any of the simple experiments you can perform in your own home already recommend to you. If you just don't like math, try them and report your results.

Show me something PUBLISHED then that agrees with you. No more HATER arguments. Show me something PUBLISHED that isn't based on MHD theory and shows "reconnection" in the absence of all physical particles.
 
I know, it's maddening. You put Mozina on ignore for a while, and all is well. Then someone quotes him saying something to which you have an apparently-indisputable response---I think it was something about the neutron star in the core of the Sun this time. He ignores that,

I only "ignored" that because I personally don't happen to think that a neutron core is the "best" or "only' explanation I can think of, nor is it the solar model that I PERSONALLY prefer. It doesn't change anything related to SOLAR FLARES, which was in fact the topic of my ORIGINAL thread.

I asked you enough about your original discussion with Manuel to understand your objections, but I also explained to you that I personally prefer a fusion model at this point in time. What more did you expect?

and before you know it you're reading rants about Alfven, terellas, and circuits again.

That is because they are all related to solar flares.

You're right, though. Back on ignore he goes. Almo, help me out: if I show up in this thread again in less than 12 months, please call me an idiot and tell me to go away.

Bye!
 
Last edited:
Apparently you missed my message where Yamada says that vacuum reconnection was presented by Sweet in 1958

Did Sweet use MHD theory in that paper?

in a peer reviewed published paper and I even gave the link to the paper (and the Yamada paper is available from me).

Before I look at it (again probably), does it use MHD THEORY?

Very convenient Mikey to always not notice those messages that exactly give you what you are asking for.

It's also very convenient that you keep citing MHD theory to support "reconnection". All that does is DEMONSTRATE CONCLUSIVELY that plasma is NOT OPTIONAL in the "reconnection" process!

Cite the links again, but answer those questions about whether or not they are dependent upon MHD theory. Clinger doesn't have a plasma particle to his name, so nothing based upon MHD theory supports his claim.
 
You don't like the fact that your magnetic source, and those magnetic charges are ENTIRELY DEPENDENT UPON THE FLOW OF CURRENT (ampere's law), so you simply deny it's even relevant to the conversation!
You don't like the fact that you are simply deluded about what the paper contains.
Ampere's law is used to derive THE FLOW OF CURRENT from the magnetic source
Michael Mozina's delusions about the Demoulin & Priest 1992 paper IV VI

BS. If it was *TRIVIAL* you'd have published works to support it,
You are lying:
W.D. Clinger's derivation of magnetic reconnection in a vacuum explicitly shows that you are wrong.
 
Do you accept Dungey's claim (and maths) that demonstrate that *ELECTRICAL DISCHARGES* occur in flares yet?
Dungey was not stupid enough to think that *ELECTRICAL DISCHARGES* occur in flares.

What he stated was that *HIGH CURRENT DENSITIES* happen in *MAGNETIC RECONNECTION* and that *MAGNETIC RECONNECTION* was the cause of solar flares. He

Michael Mozina's delusion about electrical discharges in plasma!
The totally inane citation of Dungey with
 
Dèmoulin & Priest, 1992 IX

On the off chance you do actually want to discuss the maths and/or the physics of the process Priest describes in terms of sources and sinks, it's found here:
http://articles.adsabs.harvard.edu//full/1992A&A...258..535D/0000539.000.html
OK, I have printed that page (from the link above) and have it before me. I'm ready. Which of the equations provides the proof you mentioned?:
BOTH! OMG!

Tell me what they mean PS. If you want to talk math, explain them. They demonstrate CONCLUSIVELY that the magnetic CHARGES are directly and mathematically linked to CURRENT up the Z axis, and that requires PLASMA.


It's about the PROCESSES involved! OMG. The denial quotient around here is simply off scale. You don't like the fact that your magnetic source, and those magnetic charges are ENTIRELY DEPENDENT UPON THE FLOW OF CURRENT (ampere's law), so you simply deny it's even relevant to the conversation!


That which you claim to be a fact is not in fact a fact, it is in fact a fake fact of your own personal invention. Look at the page which you provided ... http://articles.adsabs.harvard.edu//full/1992A&A...258..535D/0000539.000.html ... and find this: "Ampere's theorem gives a current along the z-axis of magnitude ... {equation} ... Gauss' theorem applied to a core starting at the origin gives a density for magnetic charges along the z-axis of ...{equation}". The magnetic charges are derived from Gauss' theorem, which at once firmly rules out any dependence on current flow. Only the current depends on current flow, but the magnetic charges do not.

Also see this at the top of the page: "Equation 15 gives a singular field only on the negative part of the z-axis. Here both currents and magnetic charges are present: ..." Equation 15 is actually a set of 3 equations on the previous page, which are the solutions to equation 11 on the page before that, and equation 11 is a multipole expansion of the magnetic field (as stated in the text immediately before the equation). The magnetic charges are then simply the sources for the multipole expansion, and again are seen to be magnificently independent from any current flow.

Of course the presence of magnetic charges is not physically possible, which everyone acknowledges with no problem. However, that physical impossibility is in fact not relevant to any of the conclusions reached in the paper, as I have already explained in some detail, and you have ignored in equal detail ...

Furthermore, these equations, and this paper, are vastly overblown and exaggerated by Mozina. This trick of using magnetic charges appears in only a few papers, and they are all early in the process of describing the physics of magnetic reconnection. Its sole purpose is to play a role in multipole expansions of the magnetic field. But superior methods soon arrived and this methodology of using magnetic charges, which was even then esoteric & obscure, disappeared altogether, never to be seen again. It does not appear in any text book on plasma physics, field modeling, or magnetic reconnection that I have seen. That's why I said I didn't want to talk about this, because it is irrelevant. irrelevant. The current state of the physics of magnetic field modeling and magnetic reconnection does not involve any of this at all.


Here is what is really going on in the paper, the truth that sails so far beyond Mozina, he doesn't even feel the intellectual breeze. Out in the plasma where they want to study the physics, including magnetic reconnection, there is a magnetic field. The field obviously comes from somewhere, but it certainly is not generated by the plasma co-located with the magnetic field, it is generated elsewhere. We know that magnetic fields are physically generated by the motion of electrically charged particles, which can be expressed as charge neutral plasma flow or by the usual electrically charged current flow. If the magnetic field has a complicated geometry or topology (those two words are not synonymous) the physical current patterns required to generate them can be too mathematically complicated to allow a numerical computation of the desired field. So, one good computational trick is to just use monopoles, which always make the job of computing the field a lot easier. So, what Dèmoulin & Priest are doing is creating a small array of monopoles and simple currents and placing them under the model photosphere where they will then computationally create the magnetic field where they want it, with geometry & topology to match those observed, and then that field/plasma interaction physics can be studied. The monopoles and currents that appear in equations 16 & 17 are never used anywhere in the paper in any direct way and have absolutely nothing at all to do with the physics under study, other than to computationally generate the desired remote magnetic field.

Furthermore, pay attention to the my self-quoted paragraph above. This trick appears only in early papers, and in very few of them, and is quite literally never seen again. Once more powerful computers allow more powerful computational capability, the need for this kind of computational trick is gone. The ability to model magnetic fields with more realistic current and plasma flow is obviously an improvement. So Mozina "tilts at windmills"; he has no idea what those two equations are really doing, and ignores the fact that nothing like it appears in any text book and nothing like it is used in any of the current studies, and ignores the fact that his entire argument, aside from being 100% wrong, is also 100% irrelevant.


You wanted an explanation ...

Tell me what they mean PS. If you want to talk math, explain them.


I have given you an explanation, more than once. And ben_m has provided an explanation as well, along much the same lines as mine, ...

Of all the postdoc-research-projects, in all the towns, in all the world, that Michael Mozina's ignorance could have walked into, it walked into mine.

I've done exactly this computational trick myself. I helped supervise a grad student once on a numerical-magnetostatics project, and believe me, the simulation of our (actual, physical, laboratory) system was chock-full of fictional "magnetic charges". If you have a curlless, divergenceless vector field, you can represent it either as the curl of a (fictional) vector potential, or as the gradient of a (fictional) scalar potential. It so happens that any scalar-potential calculation looks, mathematically, exactly as though you were calculating a "potential" due to your 1/r distance from a "charge". I remember this grad student and I poring over the geometry of our magnets to figure out whether the inner solution was valid only out to the closest position of a physical electrode, or out to the (larger) closest position of a fictional charge. I remember going over the graphs that confirmed that the monopoles-calculation corresponded to exactly the same fields as the (slow) Ampere's Law calculation.

You really thought that Priest did something wrong, used actual magnetic monopoles, etc., and that you, the non-math-using amateur had correctly unmasked their mistake? Well, you thought wrong. Now you know. Thanks for the laugh.


You want explanations, you got explanations. Are you going to deal with them or ignore them? Or are you just going to run off to some more "friendly" place, where people don't really care that you don't really have any idea what you are talking about?
 
Mr. Mozina:
You said:
Originally Posted by Michael Mozina
I claimed that PLASMA and CURRENT are required for "reconnection" and I showed you the exact two equations in Priests 'Source/Sink' paper to prove it. Deal with it, or don't deal with it, but it's right there in a black and white in the two equations I cited.
I would like to pursue your position that the equations below prove that plasma and current are required for reconnection. Before I spend a lot of time on this, do I have the right equations?

These are taken from the link you provided:

Equation 16
[latex]\mu_0l(z) = 4\pi\alpha^{-1} cos(\alpha|z| +\phi__r)[/latex]
[latex] for z \leq0[/latex]

Equation 17:
[latex]\sigma(z) = -4\pi\alpha^{-1} sin(\alpha|z| + \phi_r) [/latex]
[latex] for z \leq 0[/latex]

Now, I have already made it very clear that I am not a physicist -- far from it: I do have a master's degree in mathematics, I have studied some physics and have some specific military training and work experience in electronics. You have accused me of not being diligent enough to study the papers you have provided here.
It will be somewhat a struggle for me so. After you have confirmed that I am looking at the right equations, it is my intention to review the context and see if I can understand the conclusions and your position. Fair enough?
 
Last edited:
Did Sweet use MHD theory in that paper?



Before I look at it (again probably), does it use MHD THEORY?



It's also very convenient that you keep citing MHD theory to support "reconnection". All that does is DEMONSTRATE CONCLUSIVELY that plasma is NOT OPTIONAL in the "reconnection" process!

Cite the links again, but answer those questions about whether or not they are dependent upon MHD theory. Clinger doesn't have a plasma particle to his name, so nothing based upon MHD theory supports his claim.

No mention of MHD in that paper, as it is from 1958 and my post is 2 pages back a the end of the page.

And please also read the Yamada paper, which once you thought would be a great starting point for a real scientific discussion of MRx.
 
No mention of MHD in that paper, as it is from 1958 and my post is 2 pages back a the end of the page.

And please also read the Yamada paper, which once you thought would be a great starting point for a real scientific discussion of MRx.

Let me be sure we're talking about the same two papers.

Yamada:

http://esoads.eso.org/abs/2010RvMP...82..603Y


Abstract
The fundamental physics of magnetic reconnection in laboratory and space plasmas is reviewed by discussing results from theory, numerical simulations, observations from space satellites, and recent results from laboratory plasma experiments. After a brief review of the well-known early work, representative recent experimental and theoretical works are discussed and the essence of significant modern findings are interpreted. In the area of local reconnection physics, many findings have been made with regard to two-fluid physics and are related to the cause of fast reconnection. Profiles of the neutral sheet, Hall currents, and the effects of guide field, collisions, and microturbulence are discussed to understand the fundamental processes in a local reconnection layer in both space and laboratory plasmas. While the understanding of the global reconnection dynamics is less developed, notable findings have been made on this issue through detailed documentation of magnetic self-organization phenomena in fusion plasmas. Application of magnetic reconnection physics to astrophysical plasmas is also discussed.


Sweet:

http://cdsads.u-strasbg.fr/cgi-bin/...GH&whole_paper=YES&type=PRINTER&filetype=.pdf

I evidently can't copy and past from the Sweet PDF, but he's describing events in a CONDUCTIVE MEDIUM, and discussing solar flares!

How exactly are you claiming that PLASMA is optional in these two papers?
 
Last edited:
Mr. Mozina:
You said:

I would like to pursue your position that the equations below prove that plasma and current are required for reconnection. Before I spend a lot of time on this, do I have the right equations?

These are taken from the link you provided:

Equation 16
[latex]\mu_0l(z) = 4\pi\alpha^{-1} cos(\alpha|z| +\phi__r)[/latex]
[latex] for z \leq0[/latex]

Equation 17:
[latex]\sigma(z) = -4\pi\alpha^{-1} sin(\alpha|z| + \phi_r) [/latex]
[latex] for z \leq 0[/latex]

Now, I have already made it very clear that I am not a physicist -- far from it: I do have a master's degree in mathematics, I have studied some physics and have some specific military training and work experience in electronics. You have accused me of not being diligent enough to study the papers you have provided here.
It will be somewhat a struggle for me so. After you have confirmed that I am looking at the right equations, it is my intention to review the context and see if I can understand the conclusions and your position. Fair enough?

Yes, those are the two equations that demonstrate that plasma isn't optional in terms of magnetic charges and in terms of sources and sinks. The two equations demonstrate that magnetic charges are directly related to CURRENT. Current isn't optional in "reconnection" events, and the only SOURCE of magnetic fields is CURRENT.
 
Current isn't optional in "reconnection" events, and the only SOURCE of magnetic fields is CURRENT.


:dl:​

Really. That's about as rock bottom stupid as an argument against magnetic reconnection can get. Pull a couple of magnets off the refrigerator, get them really close together without them actually touching, move them back apart, and stick them back on the refrigerator. Magnetic reconnection has occurred, not magnet reconnection, without current, and not in plasma.
 
Let me be sure we're talking about the same two papers.

Yamada:

http://esoads.eso.org/abs/2010RvMP...82..603Y

Sweet:

http://cdsads.u-strasbg.fr/cgi-bin/...GH&whole_paper=YES&type=PRINTER&filetype=.pdf

I evidently can't copy and past from the Sweet PDF, but he's describing events in a CONDUCTIVE MEDIUM, and discussing solar flares!

How exactly are you claiming that PLASMA is optional in these two papers?

Looks like the correct Yamada et al paper, yes, however by just looking at the abstract of a paper you can easily draw the wrong conclusion. Similarly, when you just look at the links in my post without reading anything I wrote there. So, you will fit fine in thunderdolts, where the preferred way of doing science is through press releases.

Anywho! Let me quote the important part of my post, which you obviously skipped:

Naturally, all the early investigations of MRx started off with vacuum. To quote the excellent review paper on MRx by Yamada et al. (2010, pdf available):

yamada said:
In Sweet’s model for magnetic reconnection, he considered what would happen if two pairs of sunspots approached each other as in Fig. 14. Each pair has its own magnetic dipole field and as these sunspot pairs approach
each other their dipole fields frozen in the solar atmosphere would be crushed together forming a thin layer. He compared this to the case of a vacuum nonconducting solar atmosphere in which the magnetic field would simply add vectorially and the neutral (N) point of intersection would simply shift from line to line with the consequence that some lines originally connected to a single dipole would end up connecting one sunspot to the other.

And you can find Sweet's model in "Sweet, P., 1958, in Electromagnetic Phenomena in Cosmical Physics, edited by B. Lehnert Cambridge University Press, New York, p. 123." Which I unfortunately do not posess, but thank you ADS, section 2 of the paper first discusses a non-conducting atmosphere, which is the same for the fields as a vacuum.

Well, that is enough for now I think. I am sure you will not accept this anyway.

I think the bold and red part speak for itself. But I am sure you will find something to bitch about again, of it being unrealistic, or inappropriate or non-phyiscal or whatever way you want to wiggle out of this. You asked for published papers with vacuum reconnection and I gave you two.
 
Last edited:
Yes, those are the two equations that demonstrate that plasma isn't optional in terms of magnetic charges and in terms of sources and sinks. The two equations demonstrate that magnetic charges are directly related to CURRENT. Current isn't optional in "reconnection" events, and the only SOURCE of magnetic fields is CURRENT.
Thanks for your response.
OK, I will do the best I can -- using my meager skills -- to attempt to grasp why these two equations provide the proof you claim.

By the way, I made a small mistake with my use of LaTeX in my earlier post. Here are the corrected equations:

Equation 16:
[latex]\mu_0l(z) = 4\pi\alpha^{-1} cos(\alpha|z| +\phi_r)[/latex]
[latex] for z \leq0[/latex]

Equation 17:
[latex]\sigma(z) = -4\pi\alpha^{-1} sin(\alpha|z| + \phi_r) [/latex]
[latex] for z \leq 0[/latex]
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom