I really don't know what you hope to accomplish by continually repeating this sort of thing. Do you think you're convincing the lurkers that you're the rational one here? Is it cathartic? Are you hoping to guilt GeeMack, Tim, Tus, Ben, etc, into agreeing with you?
No, I'm just letting you know WHERE I'm going, and WHY I'm going there. I'd like to discuss solar physics, starting with solar flares, with people who are interested in solar physics. That clearly isn't the case here. I'm tired of the daily onslaught of personal attacks aimed at the individual, rather than the topic. I'm tired of the pure denial-go-round associated with EU hatred here. It's just ridiculous nonsense.
You and T and Tim and Ben *SHOULD* be busting RC's chops and GM's chops over the fact that "Yes, electrical discharges *DO* occur in solar flares". You don't. You all sit back and do absolutely nothing to move us toward any sort of "scientific" conversation, it's just more "bash the individual" nonsense, day after day, after day.
I gave up debating evolutionary theory with "haters". I think it's time I "take a break" from the insanity that passes for rational argument around here.
As I recall, Dungey made only one prediction in the papers presented here and even he acknowledged that it didn't fit well with observations.
The SUBJECTIVITY it takes to latch on to the term "reconnection" from Dungey's work yet UTTERLY REJECT "electrical discharges" from that very same work is way beyond irrational. Haters don't act rationally. That is exactly the type of behavior I expect from them. I've seen creationist and EU haters do it THOUSANDS of times. The topic is irrelevant after awhile. All that remains is "hate" at some point, and no amount of physics or mathematics makes a lick of difference.
Well, they don't attach the importance to them that you do.
Of course not. Why would they attach any importance on the mathematics they claim is so "oh so holy" in their religion? Why would they care about Onel's work? Why would they care about Alfven's double layer paper, or his work on solar flares? Why would they attach any importance to any of it?
Why would they attach any importance to the fact that all seven of the key observations related to solar flares are directly related to "electrical discharges" on Earth and the fact that EVERY physical body in the solar system with a magnetic field and an atmosphere experiences "electrical discharges"? Why would they care about any of it?
Those 7 phenomena were all associated with high temperatures.
Ya, million degree, sometimes SUSTAINED HIGH TEMPERATURES in plasma.
Nothing about them was unique to electrical discharges, so all they do is support the observation that flares are very hot. Nobody here has disputed that. Your 7 phenomena provide exactly 0 support for electric discharge vs. any other energy source. There's nothing there to ignore.
That's just utter BS IMO. There are SEVEN EMPIRICAL reasons to believe "electrical discharges" did it. There's exactly ONE reason to believe "reconnection" did it in terms of pure laboratory physics. You cling to ONE physical experimental piece of evidence, and *PAPERS YOU DON"T EVEN UNDERSTAND*. All that seems to register is the term "reconnection" and nothing else matters.
The "hot" aspect is easily explained by "electrical discharges" and large amounts of SUSTAINED CURRENT in some cases. You simply can't handle the truth.
I have yet to see a paper that demonstrated that plasma was required. The fact that plasma may be present does not mean that it is required.

Wow. That's a first class rationalization. That 'holy math' that you folks love and adore doesn't work *WITHOUT* it.

You can't provide any *PUBLISHED* work to support "reconnection" occurs *WITHOUT* it. All you can provide is some guy's LAME UNPUBLISHED website with PRIMITIVE maths that mean NOTHING. I've seen creationists try to peddle material from a lame website before, but the argument that reconnection is "plasma optional" is NEVER going to see the light of publishing day!
And AFAIK, nobody here is basing their belief in vacuum reconnection on "some guy's website," they just thought the website provided a clear demonstration.
Ya, and I've seen astrology websites show maths related to their beliefs. You never see them published in a physics publication either.
This is beneath you, Michael. It's one thing to dispute the interpretations from Tim, GM, Ben, Sol, Zig, etc, but you know that nobody's disputing whether Alfven or O&M included any math.
Where then is the 'electrical disconnect' between the math presented and the "electrical discharge' Dungey described?
Seriously, how does this sort of thing help you?
BTW, I still owe a long response to your response to my post a few weeks ago. I've been traveling so I haven't had the chance to devote a block of time to it, but hopefully this weekend.
I'll check back from time to time, but my time is pretty limited for the next several months. I can't do this board and another board, so I'm going to go try something new for awhile. If there's really any progress here in terms of providing *PUBLISHED* support for the claim that 'reconnection" is a "plasma optional" process, and "electrical discharges" occur in "conductors", maybe I'll rejoin the conversation. As it stands Thunderbolts at least understands the BASICS of plasma behaviors. It's therefore possible to have a rational scientific conversation there. I see no sign that EU haters care about science, empirical physics, or math at all. It's subjective denial based behavior around here as far as I can tell.