Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
I came across it in another thread here at JREF, and this thread immediately came to mind. The inability to pin Michael's arguments down to any real physics makes it impossible to discuss anything. It's like playing Tekken with someone who will only use cards. There's no connection, and no real communication.

A slightly different take, one rather less succinct: to the extent that language, especially vocabulary, reflects worldview, MM's persistent use of what can be established - objectively - as highly idiosyncratic terms is a dead give-away. If nothing else, look at all those words enclosed in double quotes, the use of asterisks, of capitalized words, etc. Then there's the odd, also idiosyncratic, logic of so many of his posts; the non-answer responses to simple, direct questions (several other, long-running threads here have similar examples, by different posters); etc.

It's as if MM is speaking in a language that only he understands*, while everyone else is speaking the subset of English used for discussion of physics. Communication is nigh on impossible, if only because MM has not supplied a bilingual dictionary ...

* it may be an extreme dialect of Thunderdolt, but I suspect that if MM had posted there the way he's posted here, he'd have been banned quite some time ago ...
 
I really don't know what you hope to accomplish by continually repeating this sort of thing. Do you think you're convincing the lurkers that you're the rational one here? Is it cathartic? Are you hoping to guilt GeeMack, Tim, Tus, Ben, etc, into agreeing with you?

No, I'm just letting you know WHERE I'm going, and WHY I'm going there. I'd like to discuss solar physics, starting with solar flares, with people who are interested in solar physics. That clearly isn't the case here. I'm tired of the daily onslaught of personal attacks aimed at the individual, rather than the topic. I'm tired of the pure denial-go-round associated with EU hatred here. It's just ridiculous nonsense.

You and T and Tim and Ben *SHOULD* be busting RC's chops and GM's chops over the fact that "Yes, electrical discharges *DO* occur in solar flares". You don't. You all sit back and do absolutely nothing to move us toward any sort of "scientific" conversation, it's just more "bash the individual" nonsense, day after day, after day.

I gave up debating evolutionary theory with "haters". I think it's time I "take a break" from the insanity that passes for rational argument around here.

As I recall, Dungey made only one prediction in the papers presented here and even he acknowledged that it didn't fit well with observations.

The SUBJECTIVITY it takes to latch on to the term "reconnection" from Dungey's work yet UTTERLY REJECT "electrical discharges" from that very same work is way beyond irrational. Haters don't act rationally. That is exactly the type of behavior I expect from them. I've seen creationist and EU haters do it THOUSANDS of times. The topic is irrelevant after awhile. All that remains is "hate" at some point, and no amount of physics or mathematics makes a lick of difference.


Well, they don't attach the importance to them that you do.

Of course not. Why would they attach any importance on the mathematics they claim is so "oh so holy" in their religion? Why would they care about Onel's work? Why would they care about Alfven's double layer paper, or his work on solar flares? Why would they attach any importance to any of it?

Why would they attach any importance to the fact that all seven of the key observations related to solar flares are directly related to "electrical discharges" on Earth and the fact that EVERY physical body in the solar system with a magnetic field and an atmosphere experiences "electrical discharges"? Why would they care about any of it?

Those 7 phenomena were all associated with high temperatures.

Ya, million degree, sometimes SUSTAINED HIGH TEMPERATURES in plasma.

Nothing about them was unique to electrical discharges, so all they do is support the observation that flares are very hot. Nobody here has disputed that. Your 7 phenomena provide exactly 0 support for electric discharge vs. any other energy source. There's nothing there to ignore.

That's just utter BS IMO. There are SEVEN EMPIRICAL reasons to believe "electrical discharges" did it. There's exactly ONE reason to believe "reconnection" did it in terms of pure laboratory physics. You cling to ONE physical experimental piece of evidence, and *PAPERS YOU DON"T EVEN UNDERSTAND*. All that seems to register is the term "reconnection" and nothing else matters.

The "hot" aspect is easily explained by "electrical discharges" and large amounts of SUSTAINED CURRENT in some cases. You simply can't handle the truth.

I have yet to see a paper that demonstrated that plasma was required. The fact that plasma may be present does not mean that it is required.

:) Wow. That's a first class rationalization. That 'holy math' that you folks love and adore doesn't work *WITHOUT* it. :) You can't provide any *PUBLISHED* work to support "reconnection" occurs *WITHOUT* it. All you can provide is some guy's LAME UNPUBLISHED website with PRIMITIVE maths that mean NOTHING. I've seen creationists try to peddle material from a lame website before, but the argument that reconnection is "plasma optional" is NEVER going to see the light of publishing day!

And AFAIK, nobody here is basing their belief in vacuum reconnection on "some guy's website," they just thought the website provided a clear demonstration.
Ya, and I've seen astrology websites show maths related to their beliefs. You never see them published in a physics publication either.

This is beneath you, Michael. It's one thing to dispute the interpretations from Tim, GM, Ben, Sol, Zig, etc, but you know that nobody's disputing whether Alfven or O&M included any math.

Where then is the 'electrical disconnect' between the math presented and the "electrical discharge' Dungey described?

Seriously, how does this sort of thing help you?

BTW, I still owe a long response to your response to my post a few weeks ago. I've been traveling so I haven't had the chance to devote a block of time to it, but hopefully this weekend.

I'll check back from time to time, but my time is pretty limited for the next several months. I can't do this board and another board, so I'm going to go try something new for awhile. If there's really any progress here in terms of providing *PUBLISHED* support for the claim that 'reconnection" is a "plasma optional" process, and "electrical discharges" occur in "conductors", maybe I'll rejoin the conversation. As it stands Thunderbolts at least understands the BASICS of plasma behaviors. It's therefore possible to have a rational scientific conversation there. I see no sign that EU haters care about science, empirical physics, or math at all. It's subjective denial based behavior around here as far as I can tell.
 
Last edited:
If you folks *REALLY* care about math and science.....demonstrate it.

Help Clinger put together a paper based on the materials on his website. Entitle the paper something like 'The release of energy via "magnetic reconnection" without plasma." You can call it "Magnetic reconnection in a vacuum" too but be sure to INSIST that there are NO electrons and NO protons and NO plasmas at all in your "vacuum" and explain how you released any energy very clearly for all the world to see.

If you folks really cared, then surely you have the combined math and physics skills to help him dress up his stuff and get it published.
 
Okay, to quote Sweet, page 124:

If the medium above PQ were a non-conductor, the two system would suffer a ruther interpenetratin and the value of A at the neutral point would increase to values A3, A4, etc., according to the extend of the displacement, as in Fig. 2. No currents are induced above PQ and the field here is called the equivalent potential field.

Emphasis mine. He's quite clear that the CONDUCTOR is a REQUIRED to get "induced current". No induced current, no "electrical discharge'.

If you would look then to Fig. 2 you would understand how the neutral point moves from field line to field line. Yes, it would maybe ask a little creative thinking on your part, but to anyone else it is clear that there has to be reconnection to let the neutral point move to A3, A4 etc.

No, you READ THAT INTO HIS WORK AND STUFFED THAT INTO HIS MOUTH! He didn't say a WORD around "reconnection". He's talking about FLUX CHANGES that occur in the magnetic fields. PERIOD. The field change topology and some lines become "stronger", some become "weaker" and some flux change occurs. Without a CONDUCTOR, no current is induced, no discharge occurs and no flare happens.

However, you will never understand this most simple case of reconnection of field lines in vacuum.

You've never provided even one published work that makes such a claim in print. You keep reading stuff into other peoples work and claiming things they didn't claim. Sweet does NOT claim reconnection occurs without a plasma. You read that in all on your own based on a couple of "pretty pictures".

Maybe you should join up with MGmirkin with his comments "reconnection is just an exploding circuit," as it that actually explains something.

The release of stored energy occurs many ways, sometimes as a complete disruption of a complete circuit. It also can be broken into "parts" and multiple circuits as the Onel and Mann paper demonstrate. I also appreciate the B orientation for a more granular, "smaller view" orientation of events. That doesn't change the fact that current does the work and current generate the magnetic fields, and flares can be viewed from E orientation of physics. That puts them LIGHT YEARS ahead of haters.
 
Michael Mozina said:
It's time for me to explore Thunderbolts.

Where people are stupid enough to believe a running difference image actually shows an iron surface below the point where the Sun's atmosphere becomes opaque?

Emphasis mine. That's so typical of you to call an entire group of people STUPID for what you THINK they "might" believe or not believe. I've seen ad homs used as a crutch in debate before, but you're in a class by yourself.

It's pointless to discuss high energy solar satellite images here, especially with you, because you don't have the first clue what the light source is. According to you, electrical discharges cannot occur in a conductor. Worse yet, you don't even understand a RAW COMPOSITE image. You seem to think that the color on the horizon of a composite iron ion image is related to a "misalignment" of the RGB images! Holy cow. If you don't understand the light source, or the horizon color of a standard iron ion composite image, there's no hope you'll ever understand anything about high energy solar satellite RD images. Forgetaboutit.

The blatant dishonesty is yours and yours alone for latching on to one word in Dungey's work "reconnection" and DENYING the rest of it, including the term "electrical discharge". The DISHONESTY is the constant PERSONAL ATTACKS that haters engage themselves in, including labeling a whole group of people STUPID for understanding things about plasma that you will NEVER understand, including the fact that electrical discharges occur in conductors. They also already seem to understand that the color of the horizon line a composite image is a direct result of the BLENDING OF THE COLORS assigned to the wavelengths. That puts them LIGHT YEARS ahead of you terms of understanding high energy satellite imagery.
 
Last edited:
I came across it in another thread here at JREF, and this thread immediately came to mind. The inability to pin Michael's arguments down to any real physics makes it impossible to discuss anything.

You have that backwards IMO. Dungey described the physics related to 'electrical discharges' in solar flares. It's your inability to DEAL WITH IT that makes any real physics conversation possible. I've pinned down the fact that "reconnection" is not a 'plasma optional' process. I can site THOUSANDS of papers of holy maths related to PLASMA PHYSICAL process that create "reconnection/discharge" events in plasmas. I can pin down 7 key EMPIRICAL OBSERVATIONS in solar flares that are directly CAUSED BY electrical discharges here on Earth. It's the EU hater's inability to DEAL WITH THE PHYSICS that makes a scientific conversation impossible. I provided Peratt's definition. I provided Dungey's work too. It's not my fault the EU haters are in pure denial of his use of "electrical discharges" in the "reconnection' process. It's their failure, not mine.
 
You and T and Tim and Ben *SHOULD* be busting RC's chops and GM's chops over the fact that "Yes, electrical discharges *DO* occur in solar flares". You don't. You all sit back and do absolutely nothing to move us toward any sort of "scientific" conversation, it's just more "bash the individual" nonsense, day after day, after day.

If you can show me any example of where I have bashed the individual, I will apologize, but I don't think I have. We have gone over the whole "should be busing RC's chops" thing a few times; I felt (and still feel) that it's simply a disagreement about terminology and that the terminology in question may be simply avoided, but you keep steering the conversation back to it for reasons that I've never understood.

The SUBJECTIVITY it takes to latch on to the term "reconnection" from Dungey's work yet UTTERLY REJECT "electrical discharges" from that very same work is way beyond irrational.

Since I have no reason to believe that Dungey had received any divine enlightenment, I don't much care what Dungey was thinking. I do care about how well his model matches with observations, but AFAIK he made only one testable prediction and it failed. So I don't see the point in arguing about what Dungey meant in 1958.

Haters don't act rationally. That is exactly the type of behavior I expect from them. I've seen creationist and EU haters do it THOUSANDS of times. The topic is irrelevant after awhile. All that remains is "hate" at some point, and no amount of physics or mathematics makes a lick of difference.
<sigh>

Of course not. Why would they attach any importance on the mathematics they claim is so "oh so holy" in their religion? Why would they care about Onel's work? Why would they care about Alfven's double layer paper, or his work on solar flares? Why would they attach any importance to any of it?

Actually, they've elaborated on that at length.

Why would they attach any importance to the fact that all seven of the key observations related to solar flares are directly related to "electrical discharges" on Earth and the fact that EVERY physical body in the solar system with a magnetic field and an atmosphere experiences "electrical discharges"?

<sigh> First, Venus has Earth-like lightning but lacks a significant magnetic field, so it would appear that the magnetic field is not a requirement for lightning. Second, as I'm sure you'll agree, the presence of a conductive plasma is of profound significance to electrical phenomena. Thus, I would think that even you should agree that the presence of lightning in non-conductive atmospheres on Jupiter and Earth is not immediately relevant to solar phenomena. So . . . why do *you* attach importance to it?

Ya, million degree, sometimes SUSTAINED HIGH TEMPERATURES in plasma.

That's just utter BS IMO. There are SEVEN EMPIRICAL reasons to believe "electrical discharges" did it.

Are any of those "SEVEN EMPIRICAL REASONS" not simply indicators of high temperature? Do any of them imply one energy source rather than another? As far as I can tell, your argument is that "flares are really hot. Electrical discharges can make things really hot. Therefore flares are electrical discharges." How do the "SEVEN EMPIRICAL REASONS" play into this? Is it simply because we don't normally use magnetic reconnection to create high temperatures in laboratories?

There's exactly ONE reason to believe "reconnection" did it in terms of pure laboratory physics. You cling to ONE physical experimental piece of evidence, and *PAPERS YOU DON"T EVEN UNDERSTAND*. All that seems to register is the term "reconnection" and nothing else matters.

Then you have completely failed to understand my lines of reasoning.

The "hot" aspect is easily explained by "electrical discharges" and large amounts of SUSTAINED CURRENT in some cases.

"hot" can be explained many, many ways. We've covered that earlier. Pretty much any form of energy release (kinetic impact, gravitational collapse, fusion, fission, magnetic, electrical, etc) will make things get hot. The "SEVEN EMPIRICAL REASONS" do not help to distinguish between various heating methods.

You simply can't handle the truth.

<sigh> I suppose that's one possibility.

:) Wow. That's a first class rationalization. That 'holy math' that you folks love and adore doesn't work *WITHOUT* it. :)

Actually, I thought that the math provided repeatedly in this thread covered it pretty well.

You can't provide any *PUBLISHED* work to support "reconnection" occurs *WITHOUT* it. All you can provide is some guy's LAME UNPUBLISHED website with PRIMITIVE maths that mean NOTHING. I've seen creationists try to peddle material from a lame website before, but the argument that reconnection is "plasma optional" is NEVER going to see the light of publishing day!
I'll leave that one to others.

Ya, and I've seen astrology websites show maths related to their beliefs. You never see them published in a physics publication either.

Where then is the 'electrical disconnect' between the math presented and the "electrical discharge' Dungey described?

Not sure of the connection to what I said, but I'll assume these are tangential.

I see no sign that EU haters care about science, empirical physics, or math at all. It's subjective denial based behavior around here as far as I can tell.
I think you already said that.
 
Mozina never responded to my post, and did not respond to Phunk either. He has the habit of ignoring uncomfortable facts. But sometimes he slips up and actually responds, with amazing consequences. For instance, he did himself suggested a set of animations which clearly show magnetic field lines actually in the act of physically breaking, and physically reconnecting ...

I didn't respond because I've ALREADY RESPONDED to this lame argument DOZENS of times. The B field does not form as discrete individualized lines, it forms as a FULL and CONTINUOUS field. It can be "visualized" as discrete lines, and some REGIONS/CHANNELS are stronger than others. You can put iron filings (particles) around them and create "lines" of you like, but the concept of "lines" is a GROSS OVERSIMPLIFICATION from the start.

You folks STILL cannot tell the difference between "magnetic flux" or simple changes in the magnetic field and "reconnection/discharges" in PLASMA. Amazing.

No Tim. All that demonstrates is FIELD FLUX. *IF* and only if we generate such a flux in a CONDUCTOR LIKE A PLASMA, will A) currents be induced, so B) discharges can occur. Magnetic flux isn't anything other than "magnetic flux" and that is all you will ever get from two magnets (or more) in a vacuum without any plasma.
 
Last edited:
Almost 1500 words and not a single substantive comment of any sort.

I don't know know how many words you've posted to this thread, but I can't think of anything substantive from your lips that was actually accurate. I've heard plenty that wasn't accurate, starting with your claim that electrical discharge cannot occur in a conductor as Dungey demonstrated before I was even born.

None of that was any sort of argument. It was an acknowledgement of failure, blaming other people for that failure, and a complaint about achieving failure.

It was simply noting that some folks are lost causes and anyone that claims that electrical discharges do not occur in solar flares after reading Dungey's work and Mann's work and Alfven's work is a lost cause.
 
Since I have no reason to believe that Dungey had received any divine enlightenment, I don't much care what Dungey was thinking.

Lovely. The guy coins the term "reconnection" and that terminology is somehow oh so important, but in the very same papers uses "electrical discharges", and that is now *IMPOSSIBLE* since "electrical discharges" cannot occur in conductors? Wow! Talk about selective and subjective reading skills. You'll latch on to one term and his maths, but throw out the other term and claim it's impossible, even while clinging to the maths that support that term as well as it supports the term "reconnection"! Talk about fascinating rationalizations.

I do care about how well his model matches with observations, but AFAIK he made only one testable prediction and it failed. So I don't see the point in arguing about what Dungey meant in 1958.

Huh? Which "failed" prediction just got you to write off all his life's work? Why didn't you reject "reconnection" theory as a whole then?

Actually, they've elaborated on that at length.

Actually they made absurd claims related to how only ONE orientation is valid (B) while the other is to be ignored (E). They pretty much ignored Onel and Mann's work outright.

First, Venus has Earth-like lightning but lacks a significant magnetic field, so it would appear that the magnetic field is not a requirement for lightning. Second, as I'm sure you'll agree, the presence of a conductive plasma is of profound significance to electrical phenomena. Thus, I would think that even you should agree that the presence of lightning in non-conductive atmospheres on Jupiter and Earth is not immediately relevant to solar phenomena. So . . . why do *you* attach importance to it?

It's important because Birkeland empirically demonstrated that the two electrical processes (aurora/discharges on Earth) and solar flares, are DIRECTLY RELATED and directly related to a "cathode sun".

Are any of those "SEVEN EMPIRICAL REASONS" not simply indicators of high temperature?

Sure. The EASIEST way to explain such temperatures is using large amounts of current.

Do any of them imply one energy source rather than another?

What other energy source scores 7 of 7 in the lab and occurs NATURALLY in the atmosphere of Earth and all those other planets?

As far as I can tell, your argument is that "flares are really hot. Electrical discharges can make things really hot. Therefore flares are electrical discharges." How do the "SEVEN EMPIRICAL REASONS" play into this? Is it simply because we don't normally use magnetic reconnection to create high temperatures in laboratories?

You can't "use magnetic reconnection" in the absence of CURRENT. The connection is OBVIOUS. The foot dragging is equally obvious.

Then you have completely failed to understand my lines of reasoning.

Understanding it and agreeing with it are two entirely different things. I hear you basically trying to sweep under the carpet the fact that electrical discharge theory outperforms MR theory in the lab in terms of generating high energy events associated with flares. I just don't buy it.

MR theory doesn't work without plasma. It requires plasma. Your side hasn't even figured that out yet. How did they intend to HEAT anything from two NULL points of a VACUUM?

"hot" can be explained many, many ways. We've covered that earlier. Pretty much any form of energy release (kinetic impact, gravitational collapse, fusion, fission, magnetic, electrical, etc) will make things get hot. The "SEVEN EMPIRICAL REASONS" do not help to distinguish between various heating methods.
None of those are applicable to the solar atmosphere. We can rule out gravity. We can rule out fission. We can rule out fusion as the primary culprit in the solar atmosphere too. You can't get magnetic energy in plasma without current and electrical energy. Why all the foot dragging when Birkeland already "successfully predicted" that "electrical discharges' occur in solar flares with his cathode sun model?

Actually, I thought that the math provided repeatedly in this thread covered it pretty well.

No, it's "website gossip". That's why it is UNPUBLISHED and unpublishable with no published support of any sort. Be sure to let me know when they help Clinger publish that nonsense.
 
I didn't respond because I've ALREADY RESPONDED to this lame argument DOZENS of times. The B field does not form as discrete individualized lines, it forms as a FULL and CONTINUOUS field. It can be "visualized" as discrete lines, and some REGIONS/CHANNELS are stronger than others. You can put iron filings (particles) around them and create "lines" of you like, but the concept of "lines" is a GROSS OVERSIMPLIFICATION from the start.

We all know that fields are not made of lines, and that lines are a visualization tool.

Now, yes or no, do lines reconnect when two permanent magnets are brought together or pulled apart, with no plasma involved?
 
We all know that fields are not made of lines, and that lines are a visualization tool.

Now, yes or no, do lines reconnect when two permanent magnets are brought together or pulled apart, with no plasma involved?
Cue for non-answer response in 3, 2, 1, ...

If PS, to take just one regular here, were to collect all the MM non-answer responses to his simple, direct questions, they'd surely fill at least a couple of pages. :p
 
We all know that fields are not made of lines, and that lines are a visualization tool.

Now, yes or no, do lines reconnect when two permanent magnets are brought together or pulled apart, with no plasma involved?

No. Two *FIELDS* "flux" when brought together or pulled apart and no current is induced as Sweet states, and no "electrical discharge" could occur as Dungey describes.

When you introduce a CONDUCTOR like a plasma into that magnetic FLUX, you will indeed get an inducement of current and we may indeed observe a rapid release of EM energy in one giant "electrical discharge/current reconnection" event.
 
Cue for non-answer response in 3, 2, 1, ...

If PS, to take just one regular here, were to collect all the MM non-answer responses to his simple, direct questions, they'd surely fill at least a couple of pages. :p

Let's see how you do, shall we?

Do electrical discharges occur in solar flares DRD, yes or no?
 
Bonus questions for DRD:

Is "magnetic reconnection" a plasma optional process?

What is the difference between "magnetic flux" in a vacuum and what you're calling "magnetic reconnection" in that same vacuum?
 
Let's see how you do, shall we?

Do electrical discharges occur in solar flares DRD, yes or no?


In case anyone missed it, here is a substantive explanation of the non-answer response above, a response which was predicted by DeiRenDopa just minutes ago...

Well, Peratt wrote, "An electrical discharge is a sudden release of electric or magnetic stored energy." So although a spring releasing its stored energy may not be an electrical discharge, a piece of paper falling to the floor when I pull a magnet off my refrigerator is.

The entire "electrical discharge" definition thing is a dishonest attempt to force agreement where there is none. It's the same juvenile tactic that DOC and yrreg try in the religion discussions. Get everyone to agree that the Universe is everything, and our imaginations exist in the Universe, and we can imagine gods, therefore gods exist. Get everyone to agree that miracles have no explanation, and everyone has seen something which he/she can't explain, therefore miracles exist. It probably works on stupid people and gullible people and people who already have the faith. But intelligent, objective people applying critical thinking and the scientific method aren't so easily fooled by such dishonest tactics. In great part that's why the electric/iron Sun conjectures have gotten no traction in this discussion, and why the bulk of the arguments allegedly supporting those conjectures have so completely and dismally failed.
 
No. Two *FIELDS* "flux" when brought together or pulled apart and no current is induced as Sweet states, and no "electrical discharge" could occur as Dungey describes.

I've never seen "flux" used as a verb in this context, could use explain what that means? Also, who said anything about electrical discharge? I asked about magnetic fields. Surely you don't expect an electrical discharge if for example a permanent magnet is split in half and pulled apart, right? And since lines can't reconnect, when you pull them apart the original field must grow indefinitely and always surround both halves?
 
I've never seen "flux" used as a verb in this context, could use explain what that means?

Let me rephrase that. Two magnets and magnetic *FIELDS* experience magnetic flux when brought together or pulled apart in a vacuum or non-conductive medium. No current is induced as Sweet states, and no "electrical discharge" could occur as Dungey describes.

Also, who said anything about electrical discharge?

Dungey. We are talking about solar flares, right?

I asked about magnetic fields. Surely you don't expect an electrical discharge if for example a permanent magnet is split in half and pulled apart, right?

No, but you might induce currents if you moved them around inside of a plasma. Theoretically if you moved them FAST ENOUGH, you might induce a LOT of current.

And since lines can't reconnect, when you pull them apart the original field must grow indefinitely and always surround both halves?

Both magnets have a full field around them. They can even physically "reconnect" when the physical magnets "reconnect". Even still, "reconnection" requires PHYSICAL THINGS, like PLASMA in the case of those thousands of published papers and maths related to solar physics, and in this case the physical magnets.

How are you distinguishing between ordinary magnetic flux and magnetic reconnection?
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom