Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
What is the difference between "magnetic flux" in a vacuum and what you're calling "magnetic reconnection" in that same vacuum?

Really, that is a question?

Assuming it is a real questions. If you really don't know what the difference is between magnetic flux and magnetic reconnection you really are a lost cause, and apparently never ever read a book on plasma physics.

Ah well, who is surprised?
 
Really, that is a question?

Assuming it is a real questions. If you really don't know what the difference is between magnetic flux and magnetic reconnection you really are a lost cause, and apparently never ever read a book on plasma physics.

Ah well, who is surprised?

Oh, I know the difference which is why I know that "reconnection" isn't plasma optional. I just don't think YOUR SIDE knows the difference.
 
Let me rephrase that. Two magnets and magnetic *FIELDS* experience magnetic flux when brought together or pulled apart in a vacuum or non-conductive medium.

I'm not even going to bother responding to the rest of the post when it's so wrong right from the start.

Magnetic flux is not something that fields "experience" when they interact. It has nothing to do with changes in the field. Magnetic flux is a measurement of the field density intersecting with an area. It exists for any field, whether it's dynamic or static.
 
Oh, I know the difference which is why I know that "reconnection" isn't plasma optional. I just don't think YOUR SIDE knows the difference.

That's like not knowing the difference between mass and combustion. One is a measured value, the other is a process. I think it's you who doesn't know what he's talking about if you think flux and reconnection could somehow be confused with each other.
 
Let me rephrase that. Two magnets and magnetic *FIELDS* experience magnetic flux when brought together or pulled apart in a vacuum or non-conductive medium.


The mathematical representation of those magnetic fields is what we call magnetic field lines. Maybe it's difficult for some people to understand because it's a math thing.

Both magnets have a full field around them. They can even physically "reconnect" when the physical magnets "reconnect".


The mathematical representation of those magnetic fields is what we call magnetic field lines. The magnets don't have to touch for the field lines to change. When the magnets are moved apart those field lines do not simply get longer and longer and eventually extend onward to infinity. And in particular when one magnet is moved away from another then brought into the proximity of a third magnet, the field lines disconnect and reconnect. It can be done with a couple of refrigerator magnets. The results can be seen in a grade school experiment with some magnets, a piece of paper, and some iron filings. Maybe it's difficult for some people to understand because it's a math thing.
 
Let me rephrase that. Two magnets and magnetic *FIELDS* experience magnetic flux when brought together or pulled apart in a vacuum or non-conductive medium. No current is induced as Sweet states, and no "electrical discharge" could occur as Dungey describes.

Sheesh! magnets and fields are experiencing magnetic flux??????????

Magnetic flux is, to use words, the number of field lines that cross through a unit surface, it is a value, it cannot do anything, whatsoever.

In math, if you can understand it, magnetic flux is:

[latex]
\Phi = \int \int {\bf B} \cdot d{\bf S}
[/latex]

Flux can increase, or decrease, but it is just a number, nothing more nothing less.

If you want to have a real scientific discussion, then get your terms correct.
 
Last edited:
Oh, I know the difference which is why I know that "reconnection" isn't plasma optional. I just don't think YOUR SIDE knows the difference.

The only reply can be [bart simpson mode]I know you are but what am I?[/bart simpson mode]
 
So, I have not recieved a response from Mozina to my questions about Priest's paper. Specifically, I would like to learn how equations 16 and 17 from Priest's paper prove that plasma is required for reconnection. The first step is for me to understand the equations, so looking at equation 16 for starters, I have asked for Mozina to help define the terms in that equation. So far I've had no response. Since these equations are so straightforward in proving the requirement for plasma and Mozina is an expert in this area, it should be quite easy for him to help define the terms. So, again, Mr. Mozina, tell me about [latex] \alpha[/latex] and [latex] \phi_r [/latex] in the following equation 16:

[latex]\mu_0I(z) = 4\pi\alpha^{-1} cos(\alpha|z| +\phi_r)
[/latex]

Either define these two terms or show me where they are defined so we can have a meaningful discussion and you can share your knowledge about this equation.
 
I'm not even going to bother responding to the rest of the post when it's so wrong right from the start.

Magnetic flux is not something that fields "experience" when they interact. It has nothing to do with changes in the field. Magnetic flux is a measurement of the field density intersecting with an area. It exists for any field, whether it's dynamic or static.

Oh for crying out loud. It does have to do with the *changes* in the LOCATIONS of the fields (physically) in relationship to the magnets! OMG.

You folks are SO caught up in legaleeze, you can't see the forest for the trees. You can't go on because your show falls apart if you do. Who do you think you fooling?

Plasma (a conductor) is not OPTIONAL in the "reconnection" process. The magnetic fields change over time. In a CONDUCTOR that change over time int the field location INDUCES current in the conductor.

In a vacuum, *NOTHING* but flux. No induced current in the vacuum, no discharge in the vacuum. You folks cannot handle the truth. You therefore look for ANYTHING I say to TWIST LIKE A PRETZEL to suit yourselves. I'm definitely wasting my breath here.
 
The only reply can be [bart simpson mode]I know you are but what am I?[/bart simpson mode]

When did you intend to come up with a PUBLISHED work that supports your claim that plasma is optional in the reconnection process Bart? Sweet said *NOTHING OF THE SORT*. He actually sank your ship because he noted the exact issue that differentiates Clinger's vacuum from a real plasma, namely the ability for currents to be induced in the plasma. Plasma is not optional. All your *PUBLISHED MATHS* demonstrate this claim because they *ALL* (each and every single one of them) use MHD theory in them. Not a single *PUBLISHED* works supports you. It's definitely like arguing with creationists. Published science and published math really mean nothing to you at all. You do it lip service, nothing more.
 
Last edited:
I wasn't asking because I didn't know, I was asking because I want you to explain it in your own words. It's not a complicated concept, it can be done in a sentence.
 
Magnetic Reconnection Defined and Described II

How are you distinguishing between ordinary magnetic flux and magnetic reconnection?


Any change in the topology of the magnetic flux is magnetic reconnection by definition. See my earlier post Magnetic Reconnection Defined and Described (24 January 2012). The terms "magnetic flux" and "magnetic field" are related to each other as shown by the passages below ...

Even still, "reconnection" requires PHYSICAL THINGS ...


Magnetic fields exist and are physical things with topology. There is no law of physics which prevents the physical thing we call a magnetic field from altering its topology in a vacuum; there are laws of physics which require the topology of he magnetic field to change in a vacuum (Specifically Maxwell's equations in a vacuum). In what sense do you assert that a magnetic field is not a "physical thing"?

Finally, it would surely clear things up a lot if Mozina chose to respond to this ...

I do not reject the math's associated with "reconnection" theory either Tim. I reject the STUPID NAME you folks assigned to the PLASMA PROCESS.


OK. Reference my post Magnetic Reconnection Defined and Described

In the paper Magnetic Reconnection by Yamada, Kulsrud & Ji, we find this statement: "Understanding magnetic reconnection, a topological rearrangement of magnetic field lines, provides a key to these questions. In magnetized astrophysical and laboratory plasmas, magnetic reconnection rearranges the magnetic field-line configurations restructuring macroscopic quantities of plasmas such as flow and thermal energy."

Do you agree with this? Specifically, do you agree that the magnetic field lines reconfigure to change the topology of the magnetic field?

In the book Magnetic Reconnection: MHD Theory and Applications by Priest & Forbes we find this statement: "As we shall discuss in more detail later on, magnetic reconnection is essentially a topological restructuring of a magnetic field caused by a change in the connectivity of its field lines. This change allows the release of stored magnetic energy, which in many situations is the dominant source of free energy in a plasma."

Do you agree with this? Specifically, do you agree that the change in the topology of the magnetic field is caused by changes in the connectivity of the magnetic field lines?

In the paper Review of controlled laboratory experiments on physics of magnetic reconnection by Masaaki Yamada we find this statement: "Magnetic reconnection is the topological breaking and rearrangement of magnetic field lines in a plasma and is the most fundamental process in the interplay between plasma and magnetic field (Parker, 1979; Priest, 1984; Vasyliunas, 1975)."

Do you agree with this? Specifically, do you agree that the magnetic field lines break and then rearrange into a different topology?


The plasma processes associated with magnetic reconnection happen because first the topology of the magnetic field changes to that of a lower energy state and then the energy is transferred to the plasma which reacts accordingly. So why is "magnetic reconnection" a "stupid name", when it is in fact the root cause of the plasma process to begin with? And if in fact you accept the math, as you claim you do, and the math shows field lines reconnecting, then again, why is it a "stupid name"?
 
I wasn't asking because I didn't know, I was asking because I want you to explain it in your own words. It's not a complicated concept, it can be done in a sentence.

You don't want to address the REAL PHYSICS issue. You will not accept the *FUNDAMENTAL PHYSICAL DIFFERENCE* between a "vacuum" and a plasma as the magnetic fields are being changed. If you start rotating those magnets inside of a vacuum, no currents are going to be induced in the vacuum, therefore no DISCHARGES/RECONNECTION processes can occur.

You can't and won't embrace the mathematical evidence, all of which OVERWHELMINGLY (thousands to none) demonstrate that reconnection *REQUIRES* (fundamentally requires) PLASMA. MHD theory is all about PLASMA PHYSICS! Those maths that are related to "reconnection" are all based upon the behaviors of PLASMA and movements of PLASMA! Come on! How much more stuck in denial can you folks be?

You folks just can't handle the math and you can't handle the truth.
 
Last edited:
You don't want to address the REAL PHYSICS issue.

No, I don't think you understand the basic theories that build up the complicated subject you're trying to debate.


ETA:

You folks just can't handle the math and you can't handle the truth.

I've never seen you post any math, just link to other's math that you haven't shown any understanding of.
 
Last edited:
Any change in the topology of the magnetic flux is magnetic reconnection by definition.

So your ENTIRE argument is one giant equivocation fallacy?

The plasma processes associated with magnetic reconnection happen because first the topology of the magnetic field changes to that of a lower energy state and then the energy is transferred to the plasma which reacts accordingly.

It's called "induction".

So why is "magnetic reconnection" a "stupid name", when it is in fact the root cause of the plasma process to begin with?

Because it's NOT the "root cause" Tim. You're fundamentally relabeling an INDUCTION process 'reconnection". A simple coil in a car does the same thing Tim. It changes the field topology over time in the presence of a "conductor". Is that "magnetic reconnection" as well?
 
Last edited:
No, I don't think you understand the basic theories that build up the complicated subject you're trying to debate.

Ditto. With the exception of Tim and T, I don't know if any of you even OWN a book on the topic of plasma physics.

I've never seen you post any math, just link to other's math that you haven't shown any understanding of.

Oh, I understand full well that all your precious reconnection maths *REQUIRE* plasma, and plasma physics because they all use MHD theory. Your maths are now your own worst enemy. ;)
 
FYI, that's also why none of you can produce any published maths to support your claim that plasma is 'optional' in the 'reconnection' process. None of the "published pros" even agrees with you with PUBLISHED WORKS! :(
 
Oh for crying out loud. It does have to do with the *changes* in the LOCATIONS of the fields (physically) in relationship to the magnets! OMG.

You folks are SO caught up in legaleeze, you can't see the forest for the trees. You can't go on because your show falls apart if you do. Who do you think you fooling?


And yet it's not the people pointing out the failure of the against-the-mainstream proponents who are fixated on some archaic and dishonestly cherry-picked meaning for the term "discharge". :rolleyes:

Plasma (a conductor) is not OPTIONAL in the "reconnection" process. The magnetic fields change over time. In a CONDUCTOR that change over time int the field location INDUCES current in the conductor.


Plasma is optional in the magnetic reconnection process, as anyone with the brains and gumption to perform the grade school kid experiment described before wshould understand.

In a vacuum, *NOTHING* but flux. No induced current in the vacuum, no discharge in the vacuum.


In a vacuum? If an astronaut took those grade school kids' magnets out on a space walk, that very same magnetic reconnection experiment would produce virtually the same results. Magnetic reconnection would occur, demonstrably, objectively.

You folks cannot handle the truth. You therefore look for ANYTHING I say to TWIST LIKE A PRETZEL to suit yourselves.


It doesn't take twisting. It's so wrong, not to mention incredibly uninformed and dishonestly assembled, that it starts out twisted.

I'm definitely wasting my breath here.


That seems like a reasonable assessment since the failure has been absolute. The entire argument to support an electric/iron Sun conjecture is based on misunderstanding a couple pictures and cherry-picking a half dozen documents, some over a century old. And each additional breath only results in more failure.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom