Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Really, so a spring releasing “STORED ENERGY” is an “ELECTRICAL DISCHARGE”? Perhaps there were some other important things to know? Oh and don’t blame Dungey for your own simple inclination to label any “RELEASE OF STORED ENERGY” an “ELECTRICAL DISCHARGE”.


Well, Peratt wrote, "An electrical discharge is a sudden release of electric or magnetic stored energy." So although a spring releasing its stored energy may not be an electrical discharge, a piece of paper falling to the floor when I pull a magnet off my refrigerator is.

The entire "electrical discharge" definition thing is a dishonest attempt to force agreement where there is none. It's the same juvenile tactic that DOC and yrreg try in the religion discussions. Get everyone to agree that the Universe is everything, and our imaginations exist in the Universe, and we can imagine gods, therefore gods exist. Get everyone to agree that miracles have no explanation, and everyone has seen something which he/she can't explain, therefore miracles exist. It probably works on stupid people and gullible people and people who already have the faith. But intelligent, objective people applying critical thinking and the scientific method aren't so easily fooled by such dishonest tactics. In great part that's why the electric/iron Sun conjectures have gotten no traction in this discussion, and why the bulk of the arguments allegedly supporting those conjectures have so completely and dismally failed.
 
On the off chance you do actually want to discuss the maths and/or the physics of the process Priest describes in terms of sources and sinks, it's found here:

http://articles.adsabs.harvard.edu//full/1992A&A...258..535D/0000539.000.html

OK, I have printed that page (from the link above) and have it before me. I'm ready. Which of the equations provides the proof you mentioned?:
No. I claimed that PLASMA and CURRENT are required for "reconnection" and I showed you the exact two equations in Priests 'Source/Sink' paper to prove it.
 
Michael thinks that Equations 16 and 17 of

http://articles.adsabs.harvard.edu//full/1992A&A...258..535D/0000539.000.html

prove that plasma and current are required for reconnection? Is this another game of wacky-definitions, where Michael will reveal some uncited circa-1962 conference abstract where "reconnection" is used to mean the designated-hitter rule? Otherwise: nooooooo, equations 16 and 17 of this paper are descriptions of the (remote) source terms that are needed to match a particular boundary condition. The entire paper is about boundary value methods in magnetostatics, for crying out loud.

And field-line reconnection in a vacuum is utterly trivial, Michael. Despite many challengers over the years, this remains (IMHO) the dumbest and most-pointless of your many physics misunderstandings.

As I've said many times: hold two refrigerator magnets together. Draw the field lines. Note the connectivity. Pull the magnets apart. Draw the new field lines. Note the connectivity. That's called "reconnection". If you can't find the field lines using the Biot-Savart Law, sprinkle some iron filings on a piece of paper and ask an eight-year-old to identify the lines for you.

(It's not like this is an important tenet of your crackpot theory, Michael. You can drop it. Try this instead: "Magnetic reconnection is a hypothesis for solar flares, but I don't think it happens often, nor explosively, nor energetically on the sun. I think that <fill in crackpot theory here> is what's actually happening". Try that. You lose nothing, you can keep posting filament photos, and we can stop rehashing it.
 
Last edited:
I think the only way to stop rehashing it is for us to turn the thread into an echo chamber.

I know, it's maddening. You put Mozina on ignore for a while, and all is well. Then someone quotes him saying something to which you have an apparently-indisputable response---I think it was something about the neutron star in the core of the Sun this time. He ignores that, and before you know it you're reading rants about Alfven, terellas, and circuits again.

You're right, though. Back on ignore he goes. Almo, help me out: if I show up in this thread again in less than 12 months, please call me an idiot and tell me to go away.
 
No, I showed you where the process of "reconnection" absolutely REQUIRES current and plasma.
No, you never showed that magnetic reconnection requires current and plasma.
Magnetic reconnection requires a magnetic field. Examples use current to create that magnetic field.

Plasma is not required. The case of magnetic reconnection in vacuum is so trivial that it is not often mentioned. However we have
and
W.D. Clinger's derivation of magnetic reconnection in a vacuum.
 
Michael Mozina's delusions about the Demoulin & Priest 1992 paper IV

No. I claimed that PLASMA and CURRENT are required for "reconnection" and I showed you the exact two equations in Priests 'Source/Sink' paper to prove it.

No. You have asserted this and are wrong.
You are also repeating a major delusion this paper: Michael Mozina's delusions about the Demoulin & Priest 1992 paper IV
Dèmoulin & Priest, 1992 by Tim Thompson:
  • The paper is not about magnetic reconnection. All references to reconnection are in the introduction and conclusion.
  • ...
  • (emphasis added)
MM repeats his delusions about the Demoulin & Priest 1992 paper!


And adds another: He thinks that a paper about force-free magnetic fields in plasma has a couple of equations that somehow proves that magnetic reconnection requires plasma! Plasma is a given in the paper.

Also Michael Mozina's delusions about the Demoulin & Priest 1992 paper III, etc.

The current is a consequence of the magnteic field in the paper because it is caused by the magnteic field (equation 15). Read section 3 and note that before section 3 no currents are mentioned:
  1. Starts with equation 15
  2. Applies Ampere's theorem to get equation 16 (the current)
  3. Applies Gauss' theorem to get equations 17 and 18 (the magnetic charge densities).
What does Priest actually say about magnetic reconnection in a vacuum? He states that it exists and is a trival process!
Magnetic reconnection on the sun, Priest 1990
Aspects of Three-Dimensional Magnetic Reconnection - (Invited Review); Priest & Schrijver
 
Last edited:
I 'fixated' on them because we were discussing sources and sinks and you all CLAIM to honor mathematics and QUANTIFIED evidence.
The problem is that you cited a paper that was not about MR. The sources and sinks have are teh sources and sinks of a force free linear magnteic field.
Michael Mozina's delusions about the Demoulin & Priest 1992 paper IV

Clinger "went wrong" when he claimed "reconnection" was "plasma optional". Equations 16 and 17 demonstrate that fact.
W.D. Clinger's derivation of magnetic reconnection in a vacuum explicitly shows that you are wrong.

You are lying about Equations 16 and 17. They are merely the application of Ampere's theorem (to get a current from the magnetic field) and Gauss' theorem (to get the magnetic charge density) for the particluar case of l = 0.
 
Math is *IRRELEVANT* to this crew. You use it ONLY WHEN IT SUITS YOU, and you IGNORE the maths you don't like.

But that's the problem Clinger, it's DIRECTLY RELATED to the source and sink of the process in question. The process in question is a PLASMA PHYSICS process that *REQUIRES* the flow of CURRENT. Plasma and current are not OPTIONAL!

Math's don't ACTUALLY matter to any of you.
Michael Mozina's raving is surreal.

If I didn't care about math, I wouldn't have earned a doctoral degree in that subject, and I certainly wouldn't have completed that degree through the pure math program at one of the world's most selective departments.

If I didn't care about math, I wouldn't have bothered to write up a fairly detailed proof that magnetic reconnection, in a vacuum, without plasma, is a simple consequence of Maxwell's equations. If I didn't care about math, I wouldn't have taken the trouble to illustrate that proof with accurate graphs and animations.

If I didn't care about math, I wouldn't have replicated the main result of Dungey's 1958 paper.

If Michael Mozina cared about math, he'd have learned some.
 
True.

What's important to note, I think, is *why* it's a non-discussion.

Take a somewhat hypothetical, concerning "flares" on the Sun.

Observationally, a solar flare is pretty easy to describe, and every now and then there are 'white light flares' (i.e. flares so bright they are visible, to the (suitably shielded) eye, across the visible spectrum.

But what a solar flare is, beyond what you can (in principle) see with your eyes, requires physics. For example, flares are obvious, and often quite spectacular, when the Sun is observed by an x-ray observatory. But such an x-ray observation can be understood *only* if you accept that x-rays are a form of electromagnetic radiation, that the instruments aboard the spacecraft function in a certain way, that the spacecraft is observing the Sun, ... all of which require an acceptance of much of textbook physics1.

Note that one of MM's claims is that at least some of Birkeland's experiments are relevant to understanding solar flares because a photograph or two from those experiments resembles ('looks like') some soft x-ray images of the Sun, from an orbiting x-ray observatory.

To go one step further, and consider possible explanations of the observations of solar flares - whether built on/incorporating Electric Sun, Sun-has-a-rigid-iron-surface, the Sun is powered by an inner neutron star, or anything else - requires an understanding of those ideas. And any such explanation *must* get quantitative! :D

For example, a white light flare is one in which the total energy in the visible (a part of the electromagnetic spectrum) is some considerable fraction of the total energy output of (that part of) the 'quiet' Sun; so unless the proposed explanation can be shown - objectively and in an independently verifiable way - to give an energy output in that ballpark, it is a non-starter. Ditto for the observed x-ray output, etc ... all the way up to the full SED (spectral energy distribution). Oh, and how the SED changes with time too ...

Now AFAIK, not once has MM ever even hinted that his proposed explanation(s) could do any of this, much less outlined how! :jaw-dropp :eek:

What's particularly sad (if that's the right word), is that MM doesn't seem to even understand *why* this is necessary, in order to have a meaningful discussion2.

1 try to accurately describe such an x-ray observation without - implicitly or explicitly - relying upon textbook physics! No, really, see if you can do it
2 BTW, this is also (one of the things) which makes the discussions on Thunderdolts so hypocritical; they claim 'scientific', but do not actually do any science (physics), because they do not do any math (or anything quantitative).
At the time I wrote that, I hadn't gone back and checked, to see - in cold, hard detail - how MM had not provided the quantitative links ...

Well, here are three recent posts, by me, which illustrate my point rather well, I think:

The first (extract):
DeiRenDopa said:
Here's the MM comment which started this: "The solar model on my website is an updated (with satellite imagery) presentation of THEIR SOLAR MODEL, not mine."

Now, as usual, we have to do a fair amount of creative interpretation to understand what MM means. In particular, what is "THEIR SOLAR MODEL"?

Well, the context is this: "Kristian Birkeland and his team were the very first members of the EU community in terms of LAB TESTED EMPIRICAL PHYSICS with electric suns, in this case "cathode" suns. The solar model on my website is an updated (with satellite imagery) presentation of THEIR SOLAR MODEL, not mine. Another noteworthy member of the EU community would be Hannes Alfven. His model is a HYDROGEN PLASMA FUSION model."

An updated presentation (not version, or interpretation), of Kristian Birkeland and his team's model of "electric suns, in this case "cathode" suns". Not, of course, of Hannes Alfven's "HYDROGEN PLASMA FUSION model".

Does MM channel Kristian Birkeland and his team? If he doesn't - and he doesn't, this being the Science, Mathematics, Medicine, and Technology part of JREF - what is the basis of MM's (astonishing) claim?

Why it's images!

Does MM's website present quantitative analyses of the "satellite imagery"?

No.

Does that website present quantitative re-analysis of Kristian Birkeland and his team's published work, to show their relevance to parts of the electromagnetic spectrum that team did not do imaging (photography, at the time) in?

No.

Does MM's website present simulations, or theoretical analyses of the physical regimes now known to exist in the relevant parts of the Sun, with the purpose of showing correspondence between Kristian Birkeland and his team's published conclusions and results and the satellite imagery?

No.

Does ... (you get the idea).

The second (extracts):

DeiRenDopa said:
Michael Mozina said:
158 papers written by me personally wouldn't convince an EU hater of anything.
Unless and until you actually do write such papers, there's no way to tell, is there?

I mean, I'm just using your logic re fission as the predominant source of the Sun's energy ...
Alfven wrote HUNDREDS of papers on circuit theory as applied to events in space, including coronal loops.
Perhaps he did.

However, a) you are not Alfvén, and b) you have not written a single paper "on circuit theory as applied to events in space, including coronal loops". Further, c) your published electric Sun ideas contain nothing - quantitative - that links those ideas to Alfvén's "HUNDREDS of papers on circuit theory as applied to events in space, including coronal loops".
This crew doesn't care one iota about the maths in the final analysis. Did the paper by Mann and Onel convince anyone here of the scientific/mathematical legitimacy of circuit theory as applied to coronal loop activity?
Maybe it did, maybe it didn't.

However, that's hardly relevant, is it?

After all, a) you are not Mann or Onel, and b) you have not written a single paper on "the scientific/mathematical legitimacy of circuit theory as applied to coronal loop activity". Further, c) your published electric Sun ideas contain nothing - quantitative - that links those ideas to anything Mann and Onel wrote on "the scientific/mathematical legitimacy of circuit theory as applied to coronal loop activity".
[...]
However, in terms of the amount of math that would be convincing to me, well, I've already provided an extensive list of exactly what I would regard as a good start, in several posts this month alone.

As far as I know, you did not respond to any of those questions/suggestions in any way that could be called positive; specifically, you did not provide anything quantitative that links your published electric Sun idea - as it relates to coronal activity (the subject of this thread) - with any published experimental results, observational results, simulations, theory, ...

I'd be delighted to be proven wrong.

The third (extract):
DeiRenDopa said:
Michael Mozina said:
DeiRenDopa said:
Unless and until you actually do write such papers, there's no way to tell, is there?
Sure there is. All I have to do is use this thread to see that Lee's empirical lab work doesn't matter to you.
Let's see now, this thread is - per your own post, IIRC - about the Sun's corona (well, photosphere to corona, or something like that).

And it's about the electric Sun idea that you, MM, have proposed.

That idea is presented, published one might almost say, on your website, as you have also reminded us, quite a few times, recently.

So the obvious question to ask would be this: does your website contain material which - quantitatively - links "Lee's empirical lab work" to your electric Sun ideas?

Hmm, well, I looked, but could not find any such material. Maybe I missed it; can you point us all to it please?
 
Originally Posted by Michael Mozina
On the off chance you do actually want to discuss the maths and/or the physics of the process Priest describes in terms of sources and sinks, it's found here:

http://articles.adsabs.harvard.edu//...00539.000.html

me:
OK, I have printed that page (from the link above) and have it before me. I'm ready. Which of the equations provides the proof you mentioned?:
Mozina:
No. I claimed that PLASMA and CURRENT are required for "reconnection" and I showed you the exact two equations in Priests 'Source/Sink' paper to prove it.
OK, as others have suggested. is it equations 16 and 17 that provide the proof you indicate above?
 
Well, Peratt wrote, "An electrical discharge is a sudden release of electric or magnetic stored energy." So although a spring releasing its stored energy may not be an electrical discharge, a piece of paper falling to the floor when I pull a magnet off my refrigerator is.

Ah, but take a couple of magnets. One fixed and the other free to rotate. Rotate that one and you can store some of the mechanical energy you impart only in the magnetic fields. Quite analogues to a spring, as we have discussed before. Release such a mechanical constraint and you have a sudden release of magnetic stored energy. "An electrical discharge" by such a definition.

The entire "electrical discharge" definition thing is a dishonest attempt to force agreement where there is none. It's the same juvenile tactic that DOC and yrreg try in the religion discussions. Get everyone to agree that the Universe is everything, and our imaginations exist in the Universe, and we can imagine gods, therefore gods exist. Get everyone to agree that miracles have no explanation, and everyone has seen something which he/she can't explain, therefore miracles exist. It probably works on stupid people and gullible people and people who already have the faith. But intelligent, objective people applying critical thinking and the scientific method aren't so easily fooled by such dishonest tactics. In great part that's why the electric/iron Sun conjectures have gotten no traction in this discussion, and why the bulk of the arguments allegedly supporting those conjectures have so completely and dismally failed.

And that's it GeeMack, semantics. Just get "electrical" in there somehow, any way, in just the wording or nomenclature and now you've got your foot in the door. Everything becomes "electrical" not just to some degree or another but as a dominant factor. One clearly disputed by at least 3 other physical forces. Two being combined into electro-weak and the other (the strong) having an at least somewhat analogues gauge boson mediator. Once we get gravity in the mix, then just "electro" becomes even more of a side show of a sideshow than it already is.
 
I 'fixated' on them because we were discussing sources and sinks and you all CLAIM to honor mathematics and QUANTIFIED evidence. Don't LIE about my motives.

Again as already asserted multiple times, the fixation on "sources and sinks" for magnetic reconnection is entirely yours. Your above assertion confirms that I haven't been lying about your motives. Why do you continue to do so when it is so blatantly obvious?


No. *CLINGER* would require magnetic monopoles to get *HIS* contraption to work. Priest's "source" simply requires CURRENT!

Well you got's your two equations. Again please show mathematically exactly where W.D.Clinger's calculations " would require magnetic monopoles" using those or any other equations? Again the purported requirement is simply yours. Heck, I wish you could show it mathematically, it would then be a confirmation of magnetic monopoles and a major advancement of physics. Oops sorry, that's right you don't just 'bark math' but do just bark whine.


Clinger "went wrong" when he claimed "reconnection" was "plasma optional". Equations 16 and 17 demonstrate that fact.

Nope, you can demonstrate magnetic reconnection, sans plasma, with any of the simple experiments you can perform in your own home already recommend to you. If you just don't like math, try them and report your results.

Hint: you can use some paper and iron fillings to visualize the magnetic field lines if you can't calculate them.
 
Last edited:
Well, Peratt wrote, "An electrical discharge is a sudden release of electric or magnetic stored energy." So although a spring releasing its stored energy may not be an electrical discharge, a piece of paper falling to the floor when I pull a magnet off my refrigerator is.

The entire "electrical discharge" definition thing is a dishonest attempt to force agreement where there is none.

No, the "dishonesty" is the BLATANT BIGOTRY of EU haters. You for instance take Dungey's work, and you SUBJECTIVELY cling to some terms like "reconnection", yet REFUSE to agree on other terms that Dungey also used like "electrical discharge" entirely! Such actions are DISHONEST!

This conversation is *EXACTLY* like arguing with any type of HATER on any type of topic. The topics change, but the behaviors of IDENTICAL. This is exactly like a creationist REFUSING to accept scientific terms like "macroevolution" and 'microevolution" so the conversation CANNOT more forward at the level of science.

EU haters CLAIM to honor mathematics, but just like with Dungey's work, they are entirely and purely SUBJECTIVE in terms of WHICH MATHS and terms they accept from such maths. Anything with the term "reconnection' in it they accept, but ones the don't like, such as Dungey's use of the term DISCHARGES in his maths they simply reject. The maths are irrelevant too. They ignore Alfven's maths related to circuit theory and double layers, and those maths by Mann and Onel. EU Haters simply *IGNORE* the maths related to the E orientation that they don't like just as SUBJECTIVELY an creationist ignores maths they don't like. It's just one giant denial-go-round.

There's no logic to EU hater behaviors, or any HATER behaviors on any topic. Haters are all about ATTACKING INDIVIDUALS with DISHONEST debate tactics that are based upon pure denial and LOADED with ad homs galore.
 
OK, I have printed that page (from the link above) and have it before me. I'm ready. Which of the equations provides the proof you mentioned?:

BOTH! OMG!

Tell me what they mean PS. If you want to talk math, explain them. They demonstrate CONCLUSIVELY that the magnetic CHARGES are directly and mathematically linked to CURRENT up the Z axis, and that requires PLASMA.
 
Life will not be the same without MM here.
Not sure if he will have a long life at thunderdolts though.

ETA
OOPS He's baaaahaaaaack!
 
Michael thinks that Equations 16 and 17 of

http://articles.adsabs.harvard.edu//full/1992A&A...258..535D/0000539.000.html

prove that plasma and current are required for reconnection? Is this another game of wacky-definitions, where Michael will reveal some uncited circa-1962 conference abstract where "reconnection" is used to mean the designated-hitter rule? Otherwise: nooooooo, equations 16 and 17 of this paper are descriptions of the (remote) source terms that are needed to match a particular boundary condition. The entire paper is about boundary value methods in magnetostatics, for crying out loud.

It's about the PROCESSES involved! OMG. The denial quotient around here is simply off scale. You don't like the fact that your magnetic source, and those magnetic charges are ENTIRELY DEPENDENT UPON THE FLOW OF CURRENT (ampere's law), so you simply deny it's even relevant to the conversation!

And field-line reconnection in a vacuum is utterly trivial, Michael.

BS. If it was *TRIVIAL* you'd have published works to support it, not some lame and ridiculous website that will never see the light of publishing day. Every other paper on "reconnection" uses *MHD* theory, leaving Clinger up a magnetic source creek without a plasma paddle.

Despite many challengers over the years, this remains (IMHO) the dumbest and most-pointless of your many physics misunderstandings.

Um, DUMBEST claim your side has ever made is the claim that solid magnet reconnection = magnetic reconnection: :) Talk about equivocation fallacies.

As I've said many times: hold two refrigerator magnets together. Draw the field lines. Note the connectivity. Pull the magnets apart. Draw the new field lines. Note the connectivity. That's called "reconnection".

No, that called "magnetic flux".

Haters can't even tell the difference between an electrical discharge in plasma and simple magnetic flux change. Wow!
 
Last edited:
No, the "dishonesty" is the BLATANT BIGOTRY of EU haters. You for instance take Dungey's work, and you SUBJECTIVELY cling to some terms like "reconnection", yet REFUSE to agree on other terms that Dungey also used like "electrical discharge" entirely! Such actions are DISHONEST!

This conversation is *EXACTLY* like arguing with any type of HATER on any type of topic. The topics change, but the behaviors of IDENTICAL. This is exactly like a creationist REFUSING to accept scientific terms like "macroevolution" and 'microevolution" so the conversation CANNOT more forward at the level of science.

EU haters CLAIM to honor mathematics, but just like with Dungey's work, they are entirely and purely SUBJECTIVE in terms of WHICH MATHS and terms they accept from such maths. Anything with the term "reconnection' in it they accept, but ones the don't like, such as Dungey's use of the term DISCHARGES in his maths they simply reject. The maths are irrelevant too. They ignore Alfven's maths related to circuit theory and double layers, and those maths by Mann and Onel. EU Haters simply *IGNORE* the maths related to the E orientation that they don't like just as SUBJECTIVELY an creationist ignores maths they don't like. It's just one giant denial-go-round.

There's no logic to EU hater behaviors, or any HATER behaviors on any topic. Haters are all about ATTACKING INDIVIDUALS with DISHONEST debate tactics that are based upon pure denial and LOADED with ad homs galore.


That is not a reasoned quantitative objective argument to support an electric/iron Sun conjecture. In fact it is not an argument at all. It is a complaint about failing. Yes, failing. The continued uncivil complaints about failing are not going to result in success. Really. Well, unless the whole purpose is whining about failing, and success is measured by the amount of complaining. :p
 
Last edited:
Ah, but take a couple of magnets. One fixed and the other free to rotate. Rotate that one and you can store some of the mechanical energy you impart only in the magnetic fields. Quite analogues to a spring, as we have discussed before. Release such a mechanical constraint and you have a sudden release of magnetic stored energy. "An electrical discharge" by such a definition.

Well, sort of. In the sense you're releasing stored EM energy, yes, that is in fact an "electrical discharge". It's not actually an "electrical discharge in plasma' however. I suppose you could suspend the magnets *IN* a plasma and release them. The FLUX CHANGES that occur will likely induce currents. Assuming you could store and release enough magnetic field energy, I suppose it COULD result in an ELECTRICAL DISCHARGE that might result in highly ionized iron, x-rays, gamma rays, etc.
 
BS. If it was *TRIVIAL* you'd have published works to support it, not some lame and ridiculous website that will never see the light of publishing day. Every other paper on "reconnection" uses *MHD* theory, leaving Clinger up a magnetic source creek without a plasma paddle.

Apparently you missed my message where Yamada says that vacuum reconnection was presented by Sweet in 1958 in a peer reviewed published paper and I even gave the link to the paper (and the Yamada paper is available from me).

Very convenient Mikey to always not notice those messages that exactly give you what you are asking for.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom